9 ms·
AI not affecting job market much so far, New York Fed says
https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2025/09/are-businesses-scaling-back-hiring-due-to-ai/ https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2025/09/are-bu...
- insane_dreamer 1y agotitle is misleading the NY Fed actually said "very few firms reported AI-induced layoffs" this is quite different than "not affecting job market" We don't expect mass layoffs from AI (yet), but we do see companies not hiring, especially entry level workers, because of the promises of AI (real or imagined)
- evolve2k 1y agoDoesn’t seem to square with this article which (at time of writing) is a few posts down from this one. The Evidence That AI Is Destroying Jobs For Young People Just Got Stronger https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342
- g42gregory 1y agoSame people who say inflation is under control?
- chad_strategic 1y agoThe same people who didn't see the financial crisis of 2008.
- daveguy 1y agoThey very specifically say inflation is not "under control" which is why they have not lowered interest rates recently. It was almost under control until Trumpty Dumpty started his corrupt monkey wrenching with tariffs.
- g42gregory 1y agoAs I recall, they were saying the inflation was under control 2019-2024, during which real inflation was around 40% (not annual but aggregate for 4 years).
- daveguy 1y agoNot sure if you don't know the difference between say and said or that inflation is measured as a yearly rate and not aggregate. Maybe a language barrier issue. 2019 and 2020 inflation was under 2% (target) each year. I agree with Elizabeth Warren and most other observers that they were late to raise interest rates. But they did start raising interest rates in early 2022 (but later and slower than they should have -- peaked early 2023). Regardless, have a great day!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- recursive 1y ago2019 to 2024 is five years, not four. Not sure if the 40% is real, but if so, it annualizes to 6.96% across five years. I don't know if that's considered high or not.
- dgfitz 1y agoIf we’re being pedantic, it’s actually somewhere between 4 years and 2 days, to 5 years and 364 days, 2024 was a leap year. I sure don’t feel like I added anything to the discussion. Do you?
- recursive 1y agoI was curious about the annualized rate when I read the original comment, so if nothing else, I think that was a constructive addition.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- muldvarp 1y agoIf AI with the current capabilities and within this short timeframe would have already had a big impact on the labor market, we'd be in big trouble.
- MarkusQ 1y agoThere are two levels here. It isn't affecting the actual job market (what the Fed's talking about), but it's having a huge impact on the narratives surrounding it and the pipelines feeding into it (e.g. resume spamming and slush pipe filtering).
- itqwertz 1y agoThe AI hype seems to be a smokescreen for mass layoffs from the CoVid era. The increased attention on the H-1B visa’s hiring process and labor market impact reveals a far more underreported and significant contributor to job shortages. Also, a lot of these companies have existed way longer than they should have. Be happy you’re not employed in tech course content creation or something that is directly replaceable TODAY, like language translation or low-level graphic design.
- utyop22 1y agoThere is very clearly tacit collusion by managers of firms in the software production segment of economy. And why not? It benefits them. I get it. But lets be real about it.
- notahacker 1y ago> The AI hype seems to be a smokescreen for mass layoffs from the CoVid era This. Better to tell markets "we can now downsize our workforce due to incredible efficiencies achieved by our AI initiative" than "we hired too many people, grew slower than expected and now we're making cuts"
- underlipton 1y agoA little tinfoil birdie told me that even the Covid era itself (and the resultant mass layoffs during, mass hiring following, and mass layoffs following that) were a smokescreen for (bond?) market instability. I personally tend to think that both were more of a, "Don't let a good crisis go to waste," situation. Market hiccups? Use a pandemic panic to justify printing a ton of money. Printed too much money? Distribute it to the "right" people through a hiring frenzy, personnel you totally need in order to build a metaverse or whatever. Money ran out + overleveraging during the boom + market changes caused by the rapid socioeconomic shifts (e.g., commercial real estate tanking)? You can cover the bottom line for now with a lot of firing and consolidation, say it's AI's fault.
- zahlman 1y ago> A little tinfoil birdie told me I appreciate your willingness to consider possibilities like this, but I think it really is tinfoil in this case. > Market hiccups? Use a pandemic panic to justify printing a ton of money. This gets cause and effect wrong. Wikipedia reminds: > The World Health Organization declared the COVID-19 outbreak a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC) on 30 January 2020, and first referred to it as a pandemic on 11 March 2020.[3][4] Markets were doing well in Jan 2020 until people started noticing the case numbers and speculating about the WHO's judgement. They were on a bull run before that — up almost 29% in the 2019 calendar year — which was largely a recovery from problems at the end of 2018. So the market was only hiccuping because of existing panic over the pandemic (including people reasonably pricing in risk that pandemic would be officially declared; the "social distancing" policies and business closures were quite telegraphed). > Printed too much money? Distribute it to the "right" people through a hiring frenzy This is just naturally what would happen. > Money ran out It's more that people started devaluing money because of how much was printed, so interest rates were controlled to avoid a hyperinflationary spiral. It could have gone much worse (see: early 70s until early 80s). Powell did an impressive job to engineer the desired "soft landing", but I personally was surprised and displeased that they waited that long to reach for the brakes. (It came across that there was a reluctance to trust early vague inflation signals, despite what should have been a high prior on their correctness given recent policy.)
- freedomben 1y agoA couple of things. I'm not disputing the findings here, but I do think there are some caveats to be aware of. Firstly, this doesn't seem to differentiate between fields/industries. It's entirely possible for AI to devastate a particular segment (like graphic design or software dev, etc) while still appearing low-impact on the overall. Secondly, > "Businesses reported a notable increase in AI use over the past year, yet very few firms reported AI-induced layoffs," New York Fed economists wrote in the blog. Is this only relying on self-reporting? What company wants to be the lightning rod who comes out and says, "we laid off a bunch of people and replaced with AI"? Maybe for huge public companies that can't fudge it this would be ok, but relying on self-reports comes with an inherent risk of bias
- crowbahr 1y agoThe overwhelming majority of AI pilot projects at companies fail. They're trying to replace people but overwhelmingly can't.
- arthurcolle 1y agoMarc Benioff at Salesforce is saying exactly this And Brian Armstrong at Coinbase
- kevsim 1y agoExactly. If they just lay people off, that's just cost cutting, and potentially seen as a bad sign. If they're saying they're laying people off because they're replacing them with AI, then they're innovative!
- throwaway29812 1y ago[dead]
- hobs 1y agoThe question is how does the product outlook appear? Most large companies do layoffs constantly to appease investors and nobody blinks twice, why would they care if you made the P&L even better if it doesn't degrade the product in their eyes?
- esafak 1y agoSource: https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2025/09/are-businesses-scaling-back-hiring-due-to-ai/ https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2025/09/are-bu...
- dang 1y agoWe'll put that link in the top text too. Thanks!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- stuckinhell 1y agohttps://fortune.com/2025/09/02/salesforce-ceo-billionaire-marc-benioff-ai-agents-jobs-layoffs-customer-service-sales/ https://fortune.com/2025/09/02/salesforce-ceo-billionaire-ma... Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff says his company has cut 4,000 customer service jobs as AI steps in: ‘I need less heads’ seems not true ?
- toomuchtodo 1y agoSalesforce's weak quarterly revenue forecast signals lagging AI monetization - https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/sustainable-finance-reporting/salesforces-weak-quarterly-revenue-forecast-signals-lagging-ai-monetization-2025-09-03/ https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/sustainable-finance-r... - September 3rd, 2025 > Salesforce forecast third-quarter revenue below Wall Street estimates on Wednesday, signaling lagging monetization for its highly-touted artificial intelligence agent platform as clients dial back spending due to macroeconomic uncertainty. > The cloud software provider also announced a $20 billion increase to its existing share buyback program, but that was unable to allay investors' concerns, sending Salesforce's shares down over 5% in extended trading.
- throwaway29812 1y agoI seem to recall a vague statement about AI doing half of his company's work, which was never really defined either.
- toomuchtodo 1y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42639417 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42639417 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43208081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43208081
- josho 1y ago4k jobs across the economy is far less than random variation in the stats. Salesforce reduced their headcount in 2023 by 8-10%. Another reduction by 5% attributed solely to AI could be a half truth and the reality could simply be Salesforce driving an efficiency agenda. Personally, I believe it will take a few more years for systems to be built. Once those systems are in place, then headcount reductions are going to come fast and wide. Or putting it simply think of it as exponential growth. Currently AI job displacements are small, but it's growing, and will continue accelerating in its growth.
- disillusionist 1y agoi can only speak to my personal experiences and not the entire "Job Market" but i have seen qualified, competent team members let go during "positive transformations" and expectations that their workload will be covered by others while corporate crows about how using AI will be such a force multiplier for those who remain.
- Guid_NewGuid 1y agoBest as I can tell, and I'm just some guy, is there is a real problem with the job market, not just in the US. AI is mainly interesting for the media to report on and hype for CEOs and the kind of MBA airheads no one with any self respect should pay attention to. It's a fairly cool search, synthesis and retrieval tool with real value but it's not as impactful as 'thoughtleaders' want us to believe. In the US as elsewhere it's a combination of factors, COVID overhiring and inflation, interest rates going up, market concentration and, US specific, the since Trump-reversed Trump-imposed tax changes. While this reversal probably helps the job market some in the immediate term the indicators of the fundamentals are flashing red everywhere and outside of the US it all just continues to be part of the same Omnirecession since 2008.
- atleastoptimal 1y agoThere seems to be wishful thinking on HN where people seem very biased in general against any article that claims AI is taking jobs, and supportive by default of any article that claims it isn't. For some reason many people just refuse to accept that AI could even just be one of many reasons leading to job loss.
- spongebobstoes 1y agocan you share some of the evidence showing that AI has caused job loss? I haven't seen any
- cyanydeez 1y agoespecially when theres reports that suggest only 5% of businesses have leveraged AI for value. The "AI revolution" seems as a cover story for covid related job cuts and likely includes losses stemming from over investing in AI supplements. But regardless, real business data is nigh impossible to penetrate because private business is now a first class citizens and the rest of us are at it's mercies.
- ivewonyoung 1y agoThe best indication I've seen so far is the the study and discussion in the linked article in this HN post[1]. I agree with you in a general sense though. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342
- tkiolp4 1y agoAt least in western Europe it doesn’t look like ai is taking over anything. Maybe in the US it is different
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoEU doesn't have the fixed number cap that H1Bs have in the US, so they can hire unlimited people from abroad to suppress wages, no need for AI.
- deadbabe 1y agoAI hasn’t don’t anything. It hasn’t eliminated jobs. It hasn’t increased revenues. It’s just another shiny toy for people to play with and buy some mental laziness. It’s a nothing technology, empty calories.
- utyop22 1y agoIt has done something - caused a tremendous amount of expenditures with negative returns for claimholders of firms pursuing AI (so far) :)
- j45 1y agoMaybe not that they can see? Technology of any kind evolves all societies.
- oceanplexian 1y agoExpecting the Fed to know anything about AI would be like asking your pet dog to express his opinions on astrophysics.
- Molitor5901 1y agoI've seen it affecting in a few ways: Less customer service employees at call centers, replaced by lengthy, egregiously pedantic AI systems. Some fast food places are replacing employees with an AI drive through. I've also seen AI health coaching services that removes the dietitian/nutritionist/health coach from the equation. Not quite AI, but getting there, are the self checkouts slowly replacing front line cashiers, etc. So I think it is affecting the job market, but not in the white collar, higher paying jobs that people tend to notice.
- echelon 1y agoI work in the media space. AI is absolutely ripping through film, TV, and advertising. Several medium sized studios I've talked with are bidding $50k for projects (eg. Netflix, HBO, Proctor & Gamble are typical clients) they used to bid $400k on, and they're winning more contracts. They don't need to shoot in person in Venice for pharma ads or animate elaborate TV show intros anymore. This is having a huge impact to the fundamentals of how they do business. They haven't laid anyone off yet, but they're talking about the ramifications if this gets cheaper.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bob1029 1y agoHave these studios actually shipped any of their projects to their customers yet? Do we have feedback from a quality perspective? It's quite easy to promise dirt cheap services and get paperwork signed.
- zahlman 1y ago> Do we have feedback from a quality perspective? ... Have you watched YouTube (without attempting first-party ad blocking) recently? The ads created with AI are pretty obvious, and pretty bad.
- 1y ago
- oarla 1y agoThere was a discussion last week about AI taking away entry level jobs: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45052423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45052423 Maybe it hasn’t come for jobs that are not entry level yet.
- dang 1y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Evidence that AI is destroying jobs for young people - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342 - Sept 2025 (313 comments) AI adoption linked to 13% decline in jobs for young U.S. workers: study - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45052423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45052423 - Aug 2025 (629 comments)
- johnnyanmac 1y ago>Maybe it hasn’t come for jobs that are not entry level yet. You don't layoff what you don't hire, so ou can argue it "hasn't affected the job market" if hiring freezes are just that. Not growing, but not really declining either.
- sheepscreek 1y agoAI may not affect tech jobs in NYC and other marquee locations and big city hubs in the near future. We could see a trend of smaller office locations get shuttered, and more people asked to relocate to major hubs/HQs. So I can understand the picture in NYC. But if they’re talking about New York state as a whole, then I’d question their data/or inference. Companies in the area haven’t hired much in the last couple of years. Now we’ve got more layoff pressure on top of the non-existent hiring. The other day, Mark Benioff (Salesforce CEO) very clearly said on TV that his main problem is that he “need(s) fewer heads”. Edit: Lightly updated my outlook to sound less decisive because I don’t really know anymore. So much is up in the air. Policy decisions at the government level could alter how it all plays out.
- johnnyanmac 1y ago>"Indeed, for those already employed, our results indicate AI is more likely to result in retraining than job loss, similar to our findings from last year I guess that angle it doesn't contradict this other posting earlier today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45121342 Can't be laid off if you were never hired. >The New York Fed blog noted that the modest impact on jobs so far may not hold in the future. "Looking ahead, firms anticipate more significant layoffs and scaled-back hiring as they continue to integrate AI into their operations," New York Fed researchers wrote. Oh okay, so the title should be "AI not affecting the [financial] Job Market... yet"
- emsign 1y agopssst… don't tell anybody but I think it's because it doesn't work as good as the hype says it does.