6 ms·
The US Department of Agriculture Bans Support for Renewables
- ujkhsjkdhf234 1y agoI don't think ban is the right word for this? The federal government will no longer be funding renewables on farmland which is stupid but not a ban.
- fknorangesite 1y ago> bans support
- bananalychee 1y agoDo we really need to play this game? It's obviously sensationalistic and "ends funding" is more accurate.
- downrightmike 1y agoCrops are already not doing well with the drought. This will increase carbon in the atmosphere and create worse droughts. If we want power, we're going to need to get it from sources that don't rely on steam to turn a turbine. That rules out coal, Natural Gas, biomass and Nuclear.
- watwut 1y agoThey have overproduction of corn this year. What are on about in here.
- programmertote 1y agoShort-sighted actions. Sad to see that the US is taking all these backward approaches while China is charging heads down toward renewal future....
- reactordev 1y agoIdiocracy. It’s all just a move to protect vested interests in fossil fuels. Tesla has the right idea with solar roofs but we need better options than shingles or giant panels mounted. Wind gen is amazingly good if you have a consistent supply. When I was sailing, the sun and wind would recharge my batteries during the day. At night, wind would keep the batteries charging so I could run lights, laptops, VHF, and NMea2000 equipment. The future isn’t this. Banning renewable energy is like banning breathing. EDIT Coming back after a walk, I can't stop thinking about this. When I worked at an energy tech company, me and a couple data scientists actually worked out that if, theoretically you had solar panels capable of capturing sun energy with 99% efficiency - you could power all of humanity on 1 day's worth of sunlight. (granted you had the storage capacity, we did fun things like "You saved 254,143 trees by reducing your water use" kind of stuff). The wind farms off the coasts in the EU countries are producing massive amounts of energy at fractions of the cost. Yes, the engineering is hard. Yes, the big tall windmills are ugly (paint them, put LED lights on them, who cares). You don't need the giant big ones, a field of smaller ones works too at the same altitude (key part... wind is faster at altitude). Make a wind mill kite and send it up. There's so much energy around us. We just need to find a way to trap those electrons.
- softwaredoug 1y agoIt's not really good for those vested interests. If the rest of the world moves away from fossil fuels, they'll be stuck, in a market with shrinking growth. Instead they could invest in a different, growth market. If they get mixed signals from the US govt, they risk making poor strategic decisions It may be short term good for them but long term fairly idiotic (for them and the US).
- Jtsummers 1y agoLong term isn't even that far away. Much of the developing world will be happy to adopt renewables and battery storage, just as they've been happy to adopt mobile networks over fixed lines. It's a leapfrog moment and the US is not supplying the materials nor participating in the improvements gained from it.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoI can't read it. Is it going to cut subsidies or put new restrictions on what farmers can do with their own land?
- maleldil 1y ago> At the state fairgrounds in Lebanon, Tennessee, Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins said Monday that the agency will no longer allow “businesses to use your taxpayer dollars to fund solar projects on prime American farmland, and we will no longer allow solar panels manufactured by foreign adversaries to be used in our USDA-funded projects.”
- layer8 1y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20250822182457/https://insideclimatenews.org/news/19082025/usda-bans-farm-renewables-support/ https://web.archive.org/web/20250822182457/https://insidecli...
- mikeyouse 1y agoIt’s going to cut a specific kind of subsidy in favor of other subsidies (biofuel, biomass, nat-gas hydrogen).
- blitzar 1y ago[flagged]
- softwaredoug 1y agoIn the US we’re fond of pigs
- skhameneh 1y ago> Brooke Rollins said Monday that the agency will no longer allow “businesses to use your taxpayer dollars to fund solar projects on prime American farmland, and we will no longer allow solar panels manufactured by foreign adversaries to be used in our USDA-funded projects.”. Could be reasonable, we need more renewable independence. > ...while boosting support for biofuels... And there it is, going backwards. So tired of this.
- skhameneh 1y agoMy biggest concern is this could bring hybrid solutions to a halt. Solar panels make for perfect shading in some use cases, for multi-use land. There has been many approaches to selectively place solar panels to increase farming efficiency while providing energy, a win-win-win scenario.
- nickff 1y agoWhat you're describing makes complete sense to me, but what I don't understand is why the USDA should be endorsing specific practices like this or that. To be clear, I also think the Farm Bill is a ridiculous and unnecessary giveaway.
- rapsacnz 1y agoDoesn't matter. At this point renewables are going to win, it's just an economic fact. This will only serve to delay this by a small amount.
- Robotbeat 1y agoYou underestimate how making something illegal can stop the thing in that country. Look at a place like Germany, blocking fracking and nuclear power and now reliant on Russian gas.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoGermany has historical low usage of gas for generation and is adding 14-17GW of solar per year. Germany will need ~57 GWh of batteries by 2030 to sunset coal generation, scaling to 271 GWh by 2050. Current storage is just ~19 GWh (mostly in homes). https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE/12mo/monthly https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE/12mo/monthly https://ember-energy.org/countries-and-regions/germany/ https://ember-energy.org/countries-and-regions/germany/ https://ember-energy.org/latest-insights/eu-battery-storage-is-ready-for-its-moment-in-the-sun/ https://ember-energy.org/latest-insights/eu-battery-storage-... https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/01/03/germany-hits-62-7-renewables-in-2024-energy-mix-with-solar-contributing-14/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/01/03/germany-hits-62-7-ren... https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/commodities/negative-power-prices-germany-renewables-solar-wind-energy-europe-2025-1 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/commodities/negativ... https://www.heise.de/en/news/Power-generation-from-renewables-continues-to-rise-sharply-10190815.html https://www.heise.de/en/news/Power-generation-from-renewable... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-08-27/how-germany-sped-up-its-deployment-of-solar-and-wind https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-08-27/how-germa... | https://archive.today/4Vk52 https://archive.today/4Vk52
- cyberax 1y agoGermany needs north of 10TWh of batteries to sunset _gas_ generation. If you're looking for a renewables success story, Germany ain't it.
- realo 1y agoIf I were an adversarial state to the US I would certainly applaud all those initiatives and Big Beautiful Bills from the current US administration. In time, it seems to me that those will drive the US economy right into a solid brick wall.
- BlackjackCF 1y agoThis administration might not be full of adversarial agents, but they sure are behaving like they are.
- dpkirchner 1y agoIt only takes a few well placed hostile (or fools) to take down an organization, especially when there are no ramifications.
- alangibson 1y agoSo they're worried about (easily removable) solar eating up farm land, but not (impossible to remove) suburbs. OK.
- UncleMeat 1y agoThey are not actually worried about that. They just think that solar and wind is woke shit that liberals like and since they hate liberals they need to hate solar and wind.
- thomascountz 1y agoIt's not that either. It's money.
- UncleMeat 1y agoWe'd see different behavior if they were motivated by money.
- Supermancho 1y agoThey are motivated by people with money today, who plan on continuing to make money tomorrow, without competing with new technologies. Money is the motivation for everyone in the chain that is alive today, not worrying about those that live in a far tomorrow.
- anigbrowl 1y agoAgreed. There are a lot of people who would rather be a big fish in a small polluted pond than a small or middle-sized fish in a more competitive one. A lot of the objection 'globalism', 'green new scam', 'woke mind virus' is just atavistic dislike of outsiders manifesting as a desire for autarchy.
- nico 1y agoIt was pretty shocking to me, learning that the White House had solar panels in the 70s!, and Reagan removed them when he came into office
- IT4MD 1y ago[flagged]
- UncleMeat 1y agoPlanned malice. They simply hate "lib shit" and want liberals to suffer. The left likes solar and wind so actively placing barriers in the way of solar and wind is a way of saying "fuck you, libs" and kicking sand in their faces. My aunt is a conservative lobbyist. She is also a drunk. This means that she gets drunk and texts my family her real feelings all the time. She is absolutely 100% motivated by hate. That's it. She has told her sister to kill herself because she's on government benefits. She has told my mom that she should be thrown in prison for going to an anti-Trump protest. She has told her own daughter that she'd be better off dead than bisexual. Her daughter has attempted suicide twice. She is not motivated by some actual policy outcome. She is not motivated by trying to help people just through some different mechanism than the left would use. She is not motivated by libertarian ideals. She is motivated by hate.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoThis is true, but the funny part is, it's only going to impact red states. PNW/California already get most of their power from low carbon sources. Illinois has the largest fleet of commercial nuclear generators, and subsidizes it. NYISO gets a bunch of clean hydro power from Canada and some fossil gas. Is industry going to build where power costs are higher out of stupidity? Unlikely. "Stop hitting yourself." As another comment mentioned, this is immaterial at the rate at which solar PV and batteries are being manufactured, it just makes electricity more costly (an additional tax) until we get to the future. https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/72h/hourly https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/72h/hourly (center on US)
- UncleMeat 1y agoIt doesn't matter. Outright banning solar and wind in red states and then watching as power generation companies flee to blue states as these energy sources outcompete fossil fuels in the marketplace doesn't matter. They still got to say "fuck you, libs." That's all that matters. Pointing out how this hurts their own voters won't change anything because the thing they want is not actually human flourishing. The thing they want is "fuck you, libs" and they got that already.
- megaman821 1y agoSerious question. Why do farmers need the USDA's help on this? Is it a financial issue, banks don't believe there is a positive ROI on farmland solar so the wont lend? Is it health related, the USDA needs to approve solar panel usage in close proximity to crops? Is it infrastructure related, someone has to approve and build transmission lines to the farm?
- xnx 1y agoCame here looking for information on the same. I would be upset if restrictions were put on installation of renewables, but this looks like its ending giveaways to farmers.
- troyvit 1y agoMy partner works directly with farmers and USDA folks. Farmers have long, established relationships with USDA people and field offices. It's not always perfect and the relationships aren't always great but it's people they know and farmers being out in the middle of nowhere and very busy people those relationships are rare and valuable. That's how I understand it anyway.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jackschultz 1y agoGo to usda.gov and two recent press releases are 1 - Secretary Rollins Blocks Taxpayer Dollars for Solar Panels on Prime Farmland 2- Secretary Rollins Prioritizes American Energy on National Forest Land Both have quotes about putting "America first" to confuse people to make them think this is better for all. We think the USDA is about getting healthy food to people, but really they're about maximizing the money for farmers and people who own the land. Terrible. [1] - https://www.usda.gov/about-usda/news/press-releases/2025/08/19/secretary-rollins-blocks-taxpayer-dollars-solar-panels-prime-farmland https://www.usda.gov/about-usda/news/press-releases/2025/08/... [2] - https://www.usda.gov/about-usda/news/press-releases/2025/08/21/secretary-rollins-prioritizes-american-energy-national-forest-lands https://www.usda.gov/about-usda/news/press-releases/2025/08/...
- Loughla 1y agoFarmers also want solar panels is the thing. It brings their costs down.
- wnevets 1y ago> Farmers also want solar panels is the thing. It brings their costs down. I am a little curious to know what percentage voted for this.
- some-guy 1y agoMost polls hover around 75% [1] [1]: https://www.npr.org/2025/03/07/g-s1-52362/tariffs-farmers-trade-china-mexico-canada https://www.npr.org/2025/03/07/g-s1-52362/tariffs-farmers-tr...
- Jtsummers 1y agoDepending on the state, not enough to matter. Farmers are not a major voting block in most of the US anymore. Farmers are a bit over 1% of the US population. I'm trying to find better sources than listicle type things, but the best I can find is that in the states with the highest percentage of farmers, it's still only 5-6% of their state population. That can be enough to swing things, but it's not enough to be the deciding block that many think they are. A century ago things were much different.
- zywoo 1y agoChina is working on it: whether hydropower, solar, onshore wind, or offshore wind, it ranks first in the world — and the cost of generation has already fallen below coal. If the world’s fastest-growing industrial nation can rely on renewable electricity, I can’t see any reason why other countries wouldn’t.
- dabinat 1y agoThis is the part I don’t understand. Trump goes on and on about the threat of China but doesn’t appear to be positioning the US to actually compete with them. An energy revolution is coming and China looks poised to take most of the spoils while the US buries its head in the sand and clings to the past.
- baby_souffle 1y agoIt's a talking point. His base can't think beyond "China bad" and "Trump is us". If he says $action is good for the US, and bad for China then the only question they'll have is how many of those pesky elites will be sad because of this. If you stop thinking so critically and logically, it'll all start to make a lot more sense.
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoTrump doesn't understand that it's a new fight. He's trying to win the old fight again. In the exact same way that "back in my day" stories don't matter to the lives of the grandchildren being told.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 1y agoTrump wants to be king of America and make Washington DC and the White House in particular look like his vision of how America should have been. He is not that interested in the outside world or how people live, which is why he puts a non-negligible share of his mental energy into things like remodeling the Rose Garden to look more like a hotel patio, eg https://x.com/MargoMartin47/status/1958969428948980139 https://x.com/MargoMartin47/status/1958969428948980139
- jmclnx 1y agoLets hope the children/grandchildren of these people, as they are struggling to avoiding heat stroke and watching their homes float/fly away, realize how stupid there ancestors where. That is were we are headed, if you live below the Mason/Dixon line, a good chance your descendants will be one of those migrants many people seem to hate these days.
- cladopa 1y agoI have solar panels on my land. Do you realize how much heat those things absorb from the sun? My fields are way hotter(several celsius) because of the panels that what they were before without them. Solar panels are manufactured using energy that comes mostly from coal. I certainly do not believe that solar panels are the universal solution for climate change, like a lot of zealots with no contact with reality believe.
- lovich 1y agoWhat claim are you trying to make here? It sounds like you’re implying that solar panels are a net negative in regards to reducing heat and/or carbon but you never actually made a firm declaration.
- MaxPock 1y agoIf Sputnik had happened today,MAGA would would have dismissed it as commie wastefulness.
- nickff 1y agoAs much of a fan of human spaceflight as I am, the Apollo program which made up the most notable part of the reaction to Sputnik was immensely wasteful and unnecessary.
- lovich 1y agoYou don’t even need to have a theoretical, they are doing that today with the race for a moon base with China. The Artemis program was our plan to get to one, most likely going to be located in a crater on the pole if they could find one with ice in it. They are currently cutting funding and trying to cut what’s left after that too
- hereme888 1y agoThe bill prioritizes use of agricultural land for food over renewables (using just 0.05% of acres vs. biofuels' 30-40% of corn/soy), curbs land cost inflation, and favors U.S. energy. It also bans Chinese solar panels, ends wind/solar tax credits post-2027, and extends biofuel credits to 2029. This is common-sense stuff to me. America chooses America and food-supply security. The article is horribly biased.
- rwyinuse 1y agoIf "choosing America" means significantly higher Co2 emissions, then that's not a good strategy for maintaining food supply security. Extreme and more unpredictable weather makes farming difficult, especially without irrigation. Any country that still sees fossil fuels as primary form of power generation is basically risking its (and everyone else's) food supply in the future.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- hereme888 1y agoAs I understand, CO2 emissions by the US have been decreasing since the year 2000. The US has decreased its emissions by 1.2% in the past year, while China has increased it by 1.9%. This bill is not increasing CO2 emissions, just creating a more sensible change, and also protecting the American economy.
- chriskanan 1y agoThis is so shortsighted. The US needs a huge increase in its electricity generation capabilities, and nowadays, rewnewables, especially solar, are the cheapest option. This video from a few days ago analyzes the issue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tNp2vsxEzk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tNp2vsxEzk Regardless of climate change issues, the anti-renewable policy doesn't seem to make any sense from an economic, growth, or national security standpoint. It even is contrary to the anti-regulation and pro-capitalism _stated_ stance of the administration.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- julienchastang 1y ago> while boosting support for biofuels, which consume the majority of the country’s cropland. Wow. I knew it was a lot but did not know it was the majority.
- bluGill 1y agoyou can run numbers in many ways. a part of most crops goito renewable but there is other parts on the same crop used for food
- ethan_smith 1y agoThe article's claim is misleading - biofuels don't consume the majority of US cropland. Corn for ethanol uses ~38% of US corn production, but only about 7% of total US cropland is devoted to all biofuel crops combined according to USDA data.
- thelastgallon 1y agoNext up: Ban all electric cars. Then ban all electricity. Standard Oil became the biggest company selling kerosene for lamps. We need to restore status quo!
- 3eb7988a1663 1y agoWhale oil does not seem out of the question.
- lukeschlather 1y agoThe Trump administration has already sold many brand-new electric vehicles at a loss with the same sort of logic.
- wagwang 1y agoWhat is being banned
- Waterluvian 1y agoIf you made a graph of the amount of land area being used for wind and solar, you’d have a hard time finding a way to actually visualize how little land that is…
- bluGill 1y agoThat graph would be misleading - wind may only have a tiny footprint, they cover a lot more area. In some parts of iowa there are wind turbines in all directionsas far as the eye can see. That is how my iowa utility can claim I'm 103% wind - they generated more wind power than all customers used. (But there are other utilities in iowa so state wide and official numbers are not as good - though iowa is number 2 in the us for windpower)
- avianlyric 1y agoWhen people talk about land usage for wind, they normally include the entire clear area of land around each turbine. Nobody is claiming a huge wind farm technically has a tiny footprint because only the base of each tower touches the ground. The US if fucking huge, seeing “as far as the eye can see” is only about 28 sq miles, even if we assume we’re looking for wind turbines only (so can see 100m tall turbines with their bases over the horizon), you’re looking at 1500 sq miles. The U.S. is 3.5 million square miles. That’s three orders of magnitude greater than the area with wind turbines are far as the eye can see in every direction covers. Or put another way, if you stood in the middle of a wind farm filled with the worlds largest onshore wind turbine stretching in every direction as far as the eye can see, that would be a land area about equivalent to 0.042% of the U.S. I don’t think there are wind farms even remotely close to that size. Another way of looking at that number, is wind turbines evenly distributed across the US, so that a turbine as always just visible over the horizon from anywhere, would only consume 0.042% of the U.S. So yeah, it would be very hard to visualise show just how little land the U.S. wind turbines currently cover.
- Waterluvian 1y agoYeah. And I’m not sure how America does it but all the wind turbines I’ve seen in Ontario are just sitting in farmers’ fields. No fences. Spread out. The footprint is really quite small. I could see it being larger if one stuffed them so close together that the incorporated land really couldn’t be utilized well, but even then, it’s such a tiny amount of land. Especially compared to basically every other land use.
- neonate 1y agohttps://archive.md/Qsxhj https://archive.md/Qsxhj
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deathanatos 1y ago> Subsidized solar farms have made it more difficult for farmers to access farmland by making it more expensive and less available. Within the last 30 years, Tennessee alone has lost over 1.2 million acres of farmland and is expected to lose 2 million acres by 2027. A quick Google says that solar generates ~20 W/sq ft., so the amount of farmland lost here, by implication, to solar generation, is enough to power the entire United State with solar power alone, twice over. Obviously, not all 1.2 million acres of land here is lost to solar generation as the government is implying. They don't cite their source, but AFAICT, this is all land that is no longer farmland for any reason at all.
- Gibbon1 1y agoA solar farm produces 30 to 100 times more energy per acre than corn.
- adabyron 1y agoMany things can be true at once: * Most crops have shifted to corn which 1/3-1/2 of what the US produces is for energy * China is all in on solar and renewables because the amount of energy & how they import is a weakness the US threatens. It also makes a great export & influence for them over other countries. * Many Republican donors, voters and politicians have invested a lot in corn, oil, coal and ethanol infrastructure which solar/wind threaten if they grow to fast. Some of their towns may depend on that as the main reason anyone lives there. * Corn is really easy to grow for most farmers in the midwest, easy to store for long periods & farmers have invested a lot in machinery (which creates lobbyists from John Deere & others) * Corn farms are an incredible waste of land by almost all measures compared to other crops or solar & wind, especially when you do a mixed land of solar/wind with small animals, bees & battery storage. * The US has a lot of land available * Most people care little about what's good for everyone or what's good for the planet, even if they claim to. This one is just my opinion based on how people actually behave.
- burnt-resistor 1y ago5% of all land in America is dedicated just to growing inedible field corn.