8 ms·
AI is predominantly replacing outsourced, offshore workers
Paper:
https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf
https://web.archive.org/web/20250818145714/https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf
- toomuchtodo 1y agohttps://archive.today/dcz9V https://archive.today/dcz9V Original title "AI is already displacing these jobs" tweaked using context from first paragraph to be less clickbaity.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- toenail 1y agoMakes sense, current llms seem to be at a similar level considering quality and supervision.
- pydry 1y agoIm skeptical it's even replacing those.
- jsnell 1y agoThe actual report (which this article doesn't link to; bad Axios): https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- modernerd 1y agoArchived at https://web.archive.org/web/20250818145714/https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20250818145714/https://nanda.med...
- fuzztester 1y agoNot Found The requested URL was not found on this server. Apache/2.4.62 (Debian) Server at nanda.media.mit.edu Port 443
- bux93 1y agoAnd that report has this to say: "Our analysis reveals that GenAI-driven workforce reductions concentrate in functions historically treated as non-core business activities: customer support operations, administrative processing, and standardized development tasks. These roles exhibited vulnerability prior to AI implementation due to their outsourced status and process standardization. Executives were hesitant to reveal the scope of layoffs due to AI but it was between 5-20% of customer support operations and administrative processing work in these companies." They interviewed 52 people, and some of them said yes to "Have you reduced headcount due to GenAI?" - which may indicate that those people believe this to be true.
- hunglee2 1y agoIn hindsight, remote working is an obvious stepping stone to offshoring, which itself is an inevitable milestone toward full automation. It is the work we do in in-person collaboration which will keep the moat high against AI disintermediation.
- lan321 1y agoDoubt. The meaningful work in person is organisational, and it's only marginally better onsite due to whiteboard > Excalidraw. Who does what, how it'll all interact, architecture, etc. If an LLM can code the difficult bits and doesn't fall apart once the project isn't a brand new proof of concept, it'll surely be able to pick the correct pattern and tooling and/or power through the mediocre/bad decision.
- deadbabe 1y agoHave you used a whiteboard recently? It sucks. Writing anything significant takes forever, there’s no undo or redo, difficult to save and version. There’s just no way it’s better.
- lan321 1y agoIt takes forever to make a beautiful diagram, but the usual flow is that you have your presentation for the base idea, and then when the questions come, you can all grab a marker and start making a mess on the boards around the room. We also have one in the dev room, which is nice for smaller topics. It's not meant to be the actual documentation, and it makes sense to me since you don't want to write the actual documentation during the discussion with multiple highly paid devs and managers. Just take a photo at the end, and it's saved for when you make the documentation.
- deadbabe 1y agoThat just sounds like office theatre.
- DonnyV 1y agoH1Bs are replacing workers.
- GuinansEyebrows 1y agoH1B is a type of visa, the holders of which are workers.
- DonnyV 1y agoIt was implied that is was American workers being replaced.
- peterldowns 1y ago“AI reshoring” is what I call it. Makes perfect sense.
- candiddevmike 1y ago> Despite $30–40 billion in enterprise investment into GenAI, this report uncovers a surprising result in that 95% of organizations are getting zero return. Oof
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- close04 1y agoI'm wondering, if the return is that the employees get 20 minutes extra free time per day, is that a good, quantifiable return? Would anyone consider as a "return" anything that you can't put on your balance sheet?
- DoctorOetker 1y agoFor companies competing in the same niche, the same low hanging fruits will be automated first if they invest in ML. So within the niche there is no comparative advantage. It's pay big tech or fall behind.
- grues-dinner 1y agoThese are probably the same people who are "surprised" when 100 offshore agency dredgings don't magically do the app 10x faster than 10 expensive onshore workers. To be fair, the PowerPoint they were shown at that AI Synergies retreat probably was very slick.
- ToucanLoucan 1y agoIt's almost like the people in charge of these businesses have no goddamn clue what they're actually selling, how it works or why it's good (or isn't). It's almost like, and stay with me here, but it's almost like the vast majority of tech companies are now run by business graduates who do not understand tech AT ALL, have never written a single line of code in their lives, and only know how to optimize businesses by cutting costs and making the products worse until users revolt.
- 1y ago
- jcfrei 1y agoIMHO this is going to be part of a broader trend where advancements in AI and robotics nullify any comparative advantages low wage countries had.
- ckorhonen 1y agoI don’t fully agree. Yes, AI can be seen as a cheaper outsourcing option, but there’s also a plausible future where companies lean more on outsourced engineers who are good at wielding AI effectively, to replace domestic mid-level roles. In other words, instead of nullifying outsourcing, AI might actually amplify it by raising the leverage of offshore talent.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- PhantomHour 1y agoConsider the kinds of jobs that are popular with outsourcing right now. Jobs like customer/tech support aren't uniquely suited to outsourcing. (Quite the opposite; People rightfully complain about outsourced support being awful. Training outsourced workers on the fine details of your products/services & your own organisation, nevermind empowering them to do things is much harder) They're jobs that companies can neglect. Terrible customer support will hurt your business, but it's not business-critical in the way that outsourced development breaking your ability to put out new features and fixes is. AI is a perfect substitute for terrible outsourced support. LLMs aren't capable of handling genuinely complex problems that need to be handled with precision, nor can they be empowered to make configuration changes. (Consider: Prompt-injection leading to SIM hijacking and other such messes.) But the LLM can tell meemaw to reset her dang router. If that's all you consider support to be (which is almost certainly the case if you outsource it), then you stand nothing to lose from using AI.
- thewebguyd 1y ago> But the LLM can tell meemaw to reset her dang router. If that's all you consider support to be (which is almost certainly the case if you outsource it), then you stand nothing to lose from using AI. I worked in a call center before getting into tech when I was young. I don't have any hard statistics, but by far the majority of calls to support were basic questions or situations (like Meemaw's router) that could easily be solved with a chatbot. If not that, the requests that did require action on accounts could be handled by an LLM with some guardrails, if we can secure against prompt injection. Companies can most likely eliminate a large chunk of customer service employees with an LLM and the customers would barely notice a difference.
- mickeyp 1y agoThat has long been my personal theory as well, though I never had a way of firmly backing it up with evidence, though this article hardly does that either. But it does make sense on a superficial level at least: why pay a six-pack of nobodies half-way 'round the world to.. use AI tools on your behalf? Just hire a mid/senior developer locally and have them do it.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- throwaway106382 1y agoGood riddance.
- avrionov 1y agoFor now!
- api 1y agoThis makes a ton of sense. The interaction is similar: write specs, give orders, wait, review and fix results.
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoSource: https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44941374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44941374) Or err, since that's been taken down: https://web.archive.org/web/20250818145714/https://nanda.media.mit.edu/ai_report_2025.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20250818145714/https://nanda.med...
- notyourwork 1y agoI can see this. We employ a lot of off shore for what we call support engineering. Things like jdk upgrades or cert updates. It’s grunt work that lets higher paid engineers utilize their time on business value work. As AI continues to grow in scope, it will surely commandeer much of this. Employing a human is more expensive when compared to compute for these tasks at a certain scale.
- simianwords 1y agoCan I ask how the offshore team manages to deploy these changes? What skills are required for such a role in support engineering?
- notyourwork 1y agoThrough the CI/CD deployment pipeline that all code changes get deployed through. Primary engineering team reviews code and ensures things are tested appropriately. If it requires a managed change, engineering team helps them draft the execution and schedule. Skills would be similar to IT or dev ops but with expectation that they can code.
- simianwords 1y agoWith a ci/cd in place and a reviewer from the devs it’s probably very less value that the offshore employees are providing. Moreover these kind of upgrades sometimes involve unforeseen regressions which again can’t be solved by these employees.
- notyourwork 1y agoThe value is their salary being dramatically less.
- sitzkrieg 1y agoi worked for a company that did this. then they opened an office in india and put us employees on call for india to squeeze em out haha
- jmyeet 1y agoAI is going to force the issue of having to deal with the inequity in our economic system. And my belief is that this confrontation will be violent and many people are going to die. The fundamental issue is wealth inequality. The ultimate forms of wealth redistribution are war and revolution. I personally believe we are already beyond the point where electoral politics can solve this issue and a violent resolution is inevitable. The issue is that there are a handful of people who are incredibly wealthy and are only getting wealthier. The majority of the population is struggling to survive and only getting poorer. AI and automation will be used to further displace working people to eke out a tiny percentage increase in profits, which will furhter this inequality as people can no longer afford to live. Plus those still working will have their wages suppressed. Offshored work originally dsiplaced local workers and created a bunch of problems. AI and automation is a rising tide at this point. Many in tech considered themselves immune to such trends, being highly technical and educated professionals. Those people are in for a very rude shock and it'll happen sooner than they think. Our politics is divided by those who want to blame marginalized groups (eg immigrants, trans people, "woke" liberals) for declining material conditions (and thus we get Brownshirts and concentration camps) and the other side who wants to defend the neoliberal status quo in the name of institutional norms. It's about economics, material conditions and, dare I say it, the workers relationship to the means of production.
- igleria 1y ago> personally believe we are already beyond the point where electoral politics can solve this issue and a violent resolution is inevitable. I do think more or less this too, but it could be 4 years or 40 before people get mad enough. And to be honest the tech gap between civilian violence and state sponsored violence has never been wider. OR in other words, civilians don't have reaper drones etc etc.
- jmyeet 1y agoI agree on time frames. This system can limp on for decades yet. Or fall apart in 5 years (though probably not). As for the tech gap, I disagree. The history of post-WW2 warfare is that asymmetric warfare has been profoundly successful, to the poin twhere the US hasn't won a single war (except, arguably, Grenada, if that counts, which it does not) since 1945. And that's a country that spends more on defence that something like the next 23 countries combined (IIRC). Obviously war isn't exact the same thing but it's honestly not that different to suppressing violent dissent. The difficulty (since 1945) hasn't been defeating an opposing military on the battlefield. The true cost is occupying territory after the fact. And that is basically the same thing. Ordinary people may not have reeaper drones and as we've seen in Ukraine, consumer drops are still capable of dropping a hand grenade. Suppressing an insurrection or revolt is unbelievably expensive in terms of manpower, equipment and political will. It is absolutely untenable in the long term.
- alephnerd 1y agoYep! The low value outsourcing firms like Indian WITCH companies have been heavily leveraging LLMs and laying off employees as a result. High value product work remains safe from AI automation for now, but it was also safe from offshoring so long as domestic capacity existed.
- musesum 1y agoSo, aside from trust the biggest barrier is lack of adaptability?
- donperignon 1y agoYes, I agree. And it is not that AI is any good, but those outsourcing shops are most of the time not adding any value, all the contrary takes time to babysit them. Some of this even look like an elaborate scam, someone in the organization launder money through this companies somehow, otherwise I don’t understand how they are useful. Obviously there some good ones, but in my experience is not the norm.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- segfaultex 1y agoYeah I think this will be a noticeable trend moving forward. We've frozen backfills in our offshore subsidiaries for the same reason; the quality is nonexistent and onshore resources spend hours every day fixing what the offshore people break.
- zero_shift 1y agoYou are not wrong. Sometimes I have seen outsourcing relationships that I am sure are suspect in some way. It may just be incompetence in large organisations though. Things get outsourced because nobody wants to manage them.
- commandlinefan 1y ago> launder money through this companies That would explain a lot, actually. If so, it'll be interesting to see what happens to the overall software economy when that revenue stream dries up. My wife grew up in Mexico on a border town and told me that the nightclubs in her town were amazing; when she moved to the US, she was disappointed by how drab the nightclubs here were. Later she found out that the border town nightclubs were so extravagant because they were laundering drug money. When they cracked down on the money laundering, the nightclubs reverted back to their natural "drab" state of relying on actual customers to pay the bills.
- keybored 1y agoPretend for a moment that capital investors do any work. Can AI replace that work?
- walterbell 1y agoI'm sorry Dave. I can't answer that.
- sneilan1 1y agoThey do a lot of work but a lot of market research can be automated too.
- beastman82 1y agoThe investment bankers I know worked harder than any software developer to get where they are.
- throwawayoldie 1y agoAnd yet have produced nothing of value for society.
- mythrwy 1y agoIn theory they efficiently allocate capital and resources to drive increased standards of living. In theory.
- throwawayoldie 1y agoIn theory.
- keybored 1y agoCapitalists serve a useful function according to capitalist theory.
- 1y ago
- bilater 1y agoThe Indian IT sector is almost certainly going to be decimated (at least in its current form), and we haven’t really wrapped our heads around what that means for the world’s fourth-largest economy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CK-gnW3f-q0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CK-gnW3f-q0
- dvrj101 1y agoIndian IT sector in nutshell : https://youtu.be/LWfFD4DiUiA?si=VCpWVx_cKKCqCBxH&t=496 https://youtu.be/LWfFD4DiUiA?si=VCpWVx_cKKCqCBxH&t=496 what this person has started is being done by WITCH companies at largest scale and most fraudulent way possible
- hereme888 1y agoAI is already so much better than 99% of customer support employees. It also improves brand reputation by actually paying attention to what customers are saying and responding in a timely manner, with expert-level knowledge, unlike typical customer service reps. I've used LLMs to help me fix Windows issues using pretty advanced methods, that MS employees would have just told me to either re-install Windows or send them the laptop and pay $hundreds.
- pluc 1y agoExcept AI support agents are only using content that is already available in support knowledge bases, making the entire exercise futile and redundant. But sure, they're eloquent while wasting your time.
- scarface_74 1y agoIt’s even worse than you think. I work with Amazon Connect. Now the human agent doesn’t have to search the Knowledge Base manually, likely answers will automatically be shown to the agent based on the conversation that you are having. They are just regurgitating what you can find for yourself. But I can’t imagine ever calling tech support for help unless it is more than troubleshooting and I need them to actually do something in their system or it’s a hardware problem where I need a replacement.
- klodolph 1y agoMost of my questions are answerable from the support knowledge base.
- SpaceManNabs 1y agoIf i am calling support, it is probably because I already scoured the resources. Over the past 3 years of calling support any service or infrastructure (bank, health insurance, doctor, wtv), over like 90% of my requests were things only solvable via customer support or escalation. I only keep track because I document when I didn't need support into a list of "phone hacks" (like press this sequence of buttons when calling this provider). Most recently, I went to an urgent care facility a few weekends ago, and they keep submitting claims to the arm, of my insurance, that is officed in a different state instead of my proper state.
- -peregrine- 1y ago[dead]
- torginus 1y agoI wonder if AI automation will even lead to a recession in total software engineering revenue. At my job, thanks to AI, we managed to rewrite one of our boxed vendor tools we were dissatisfied with, to an in-house solution. I'm sure the company we were ordering from misses the revenue. The SaaS industry is full of products whose value proposition is 'it's cheaper to buy the product from us than hire a guy who handles it in house'
- ido 1y agoHistorically imporvments in programmer productivity (e.g. via better languages, tooling and hardware) didn't correlate to a decrease in demand for programemrs, but quite the opposite.
- scarface_74 1y agoThis is completely different - said as someone who has been in the industry professionally for 30 years and as a hobbyist before then for a decade. There are projects I lead now that I would have at least needed one or maybe two junior devs to do the grunt work after I have very carefully specified requirements (which I would have to do anyway) and diagrams and now ChatGPT can do the work for me. That’s never been the case before and I’ve personally gone from programming in assembly, to C, to higher level languages and on the hardware side, personally managing the build out of a data center that had an entire room dedicated to a SAN with a whopping 3TB of storage to being able to do the same with a yaml/HCL file.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- torginus 1y agoImo historically there was no connection between the two - demand for programmers increased, while at the same time, better tools came along. I remember Bill Gates once said (sometime in the 2000s) that his biggest gripe, is during his decades in the software industry, despite dramatic improvements in computing power and software tools, there has only been a modest increase in productivity. I started out programming in C for DOS, and once you got used to how things were done, you were just as productive. The stuff frameworks and other stuff help with, is 50% of the job at max, which means due to Amdahls law, productivity can at most double. In fact, I'd argue productivity actually got reduced (comparing my output now, vs back then). I blame this on 2 factors: - Distractions, it's so easy to d*ck around the internet, instead of doing what you need to do. I have a ton of my old SVN/CVS repos, and the amount of progress I made was quite respectable, even though I recall being quite lazy. - Tooling actually got worse in many ways. I used to write programs that ran on the PC, you could debug those with breakpoints, look into the logs as txt, deployment consisted of zipping up the exe/uploading the firmware to the uC. Nowadays, you work with CI/CD, cloud, all sorts of infra stuff, debugging consists of logging and reading logs etc. I'm sure I'm not really more productive.
- abullinan 1y agoI have hired “outsourced, offshore workers”. Anyone who has similar experience knows the challenges of finding quality talent. Generally, you don’t know what you’re going to get until you’ve already written the first check. Sometimes it is good quality, but lots of the time it is “acceptable” quality or poor quality that needs cleaning (or re-hiring), and 5% of the time it is absolute garbage. Since the costs are typically 1/10th to 1/20th that of US engineer, you can afford to make a few mistakes. However, I can see a future where I can hire local (US) and outsource to AI with oversight within the same budget.
- anelson 1y agoThe move that I’m fighting in my company now is hiring bargain basement Indian outsourced heads who are very obviously vibe coding slop. It’s a raw deal for us since we’re paying extra for a meat wrapper around an LLM coding agent, but I’m sure it’s a boon for the outsourcing company who can easily put one vibe-coding head on three or four engagements in parallel. It’s hard to imagine LLM coding technologies not being enthusiastically adopted by all of the outsourcers given the economic incentives to do so. Whether or not they end up losing business long term, it seems like a nice grift for as long as they can pull it off.
- keeda 1y agoOne thing I recently realized is that the evolution and discussions of AI very closely mirrors those of offshoring, when offshoring first started off. Back then too discussions were about: 1) The quality of work produced being sub-par, with many instances of expensive, failed projects, leading to predictions of the death of offshoring. 2) Unwillingness of offshore teams to clarify or push back on requirements. 3) Local job displacement. What people figured out soon enough was that offshoring was not as easy as "throwing some high-level requirements over the wall and getting back a fully functional project." Instead the industry realized that there needed to be technically-competent, business domain-savvy counterparts in the client company that would work closely with the offshore team, setting concrete and well-scoped milestones, establishing best practices, continously monitoring progress, providing guidance, removing blockers, and encouraging pushback on requirements, even revisiting them if needed. Offshore teams on their part became culturally more comfortable with questioning requirements and engaging in 2-way discssions. Eventually offshore companies built up the business domain knowledge such that client companies could outsource higher- and higher-level work. All successful outsourcing projects followed this model, and it spread quickly across the industry, which was why the predictions of the death of offshoring never materialized. In fact the practice has only continued to grow. It's very interesting how much the same strategies apply to working with AI. A lot of the "how to code effectively with AI" articles basically offer the exact same advice. On the job displacement side, however, the story may be very different. With outsourcing, job displacement didn't turn out to be much of a concern because a) by delegating lower-level grunt work to offshore teams, local employees were then freed up to do higher-level, more innovative work; and b) until software has "eaten the whole world" the amount of new work is essentially unbounded. With AI though, the job displacement could be much more real and long-lasting. The pace at which AI has improved is mind-boggling. Now the technically-competent, business-domain savvy expert could potentially get all the outsourced work done by themselves through an army of agents with very little human support, either local or offshore. Until the rest of the workforce can upskill themselves to the level of "technically-competent, business domain-savvy expert" their job is at risk. "How many such roles does the world need?", and "How can junior employees get to that level without on-the-job experience?", are very open questions.
- yc-kraln 1y agoI work with Claude more-or-less how I worked with our Indian colleagues; the difference is Claude is improving over time.