12 ms·
Tour de France confronts a new threat: Are cyclists using tiny motors?
- bookofjoe 1y agohttps://archive.ph/jwd4K https://archive.ph/jwd4K
- treetalker 1y agoNot as far as they can tell!
- lillecarl 1y agoAt that level of competition, just keep xraying bikes so it can't become an issue? Drug testing is privacy invasive, having your bike xrayed isn't if you're not cheating.
- jerlam 1y agoAt the top levels, there isn't much privacy already. In 2007, the GC leader of the Tour was removed from the race because they had lied about their location a month prior. Racers are required to tell UCI, the cycling governing body, their locations in order for doping controls. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Rasmussen_(cyclist)#Unavailability_for_doping_controls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Rasmussen_(cyclist)#Un...
- djhn 1y agoNot just at the elite level either. The whereabouts system has expanded to apply to tens of millions of people, completely outside of any serious national or international legal frameworl.
- thaumasiotes 1y ago> The whereabouts system has expanded to apply to tens of millions of people, completely outside of any serious national or international legal framewor[k]. What? Why? Who cares whether the 500,000th-fastest bicycle racer in the world is cheating?
- mousethatroared 1y ago1. Scholarships 2. The top 10 were once top 10 000
- LeifCarrotson 1y agoThe 500,001st cares quite a lot!
- thaumasiotes 1y agoThat's unlikely; there is no ranking that includes so many people, and those two particular people will never have heard of each other.
- mailund 1y agonot necessarily saying it's a good system, but I remember working with someone who had previously tried making it pro in a sport who was really frustrated with a lot of doping at the low levels. In order to advance upwards, it was necessary to do well in the lower levels, but due to the lax testing he was competing against other athletes with an unfair advantage.
- eCa 1y agoThe whereabouts of system is used in all serious sports, ie those that follow wada rules.
- bcraven 1y agoI understand that thermal imaging cameras can pick up anomalies in the frame where the motors are housed during the race.
- AstralStorm 1y agoNot really for a small motor cooled by the frame. The bikes are IR reflective too.
- fizx 1y agoYou can swap bikes in the middle of the race if you have a mechanical issue. There was one famous time where someone climbed impossibly fast, had a mechanical at the top of the mountain, then finished the race on a different bike, leading us to forever wonder.
- tharkun__ 1y agoThat seems like an issue with checking though. If you know people can switch bikes mid race, meaning it's allowed by rules then it is simply stupid to only "double check" the winning bikes that made it to the finish line. Obviously you would need to check every single bike someone used during the race. That's different from someone illegally changing bikes.
- chrisfosterelli 1y agoThis is what they do, for what its worth. Every team bike is subject to random or suspicion based inspection both pre-stage and post-stage. There's also in-stage monitoring that flags riders or their equipment for additional investigation.
- vorgol 1y agoThe first athlete to be sanctioned for mechanical doping did exactly that. Inspectors found a bicycle in her pit with a hidden motor. Her excuse was "the bicycle was owned by a friend and was taken to the pit in error". The bike looked exactly the same as the bike she was riding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femke_Van_den_Driessche#Allegations_of_mechanical_doping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femke_Van_den_Driessche#Allega...
- sumo89 1y agoExcept in cyclocross you swap bikes constantly during the race so the current one can be cleaned of mud before it blocks the wheels from spinning.
- thyristan 1y agoXRay is also somewhat privacy invasive to bike athletes, but not to "normal" people. The reason is that there is a huge competition on making bikes lighter while still being able to withstand the exact stress put on in in that one leg of the race. So they file off a little metal here, a little there, shorten some screws, etc. The secret is in how much you can take away in which places. This can lead to bikes that are usable only for that one leg on that one day, after which you have to change the slightly deformed parts, because e.g. the braking downhill would kill your lighter, thinner, filed-down uphill tires.
- Gigachad 1y agoThey have minimum bike weights to counter this. Commercially available well built carbon fibre bikes are sometimes bellow the minimum weight right out of the factory so they have to add weights to them.
- swores 1y agoThat's what the article says they are doing.
- aaronrobinson 1y agoMotor doping has been around for ages. Nothing new.
- jeffbee 1y agoYeah, it's so common that literally nobody in high-level road cycling has ever been found doing it. "Motor doping" is the chupacabra: universally feared, never seen. The math doesn't even begin to pass the smell test, with regards to how much energy you'd get out of some tiny battery vs. the amount you'd spend dragging the dead battery around France all day.
- red369 1y agoPerhaps the math would make more sense if you swap the bike once the battery is depleted? I'm still not sure that the tiny battery would give enough of an advantage to be worth the risk - I don't know take enough interest in road racing to know. Oh - unless the peloton forget about the breakaway, then I take great interest! Love watching that race: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2021/jul/25/anna-kiesenhofer-claims-shock-road-race-glory-as-van-vleuten-mistakes-silver-for-gold-olympics https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2021/jul/25/anna-kiesenhof...
- tln 1y agoI agree it is rare - the UCI measures seem very effective. I'm not so sure about the math though, it is trivial for a motor+battery to exceed the 6-7 W/Kg sustained that a human can achieve, thus raising the total system W/Kg. Also consider that the lightest bikes are 5.5kg or so, and UCI has a minimum weight of 6.8 kg which gives "free weight" for these theoretical cheaters to use...
- luqtas 1y agohow about 0.5% performance increase on climbs? downhill, the more weight you have the better i guess.
- 0_____0 1y agoShall we do the math on this? Pogi's Zone 2 power is apparently around 320W. That puts his FTP around 500. Assume he's doing a climb at tempo, say 6W/kg based on system weight. The power density to beat for your mechanical doping device is 166g/W. But keep in mind, that's the power it has to do in order to just break even and not slow him down. Also the gains from your device are probably erased if Pogi forgets to poop before starting the stage.
- jfghi 1y agoThey could examine random bicycles plus those that did extraordinarily well and issue lifetime bans for offending parties.
- aeternum 1y agoIt's too obvious to put the motor in the bike. What they should do is embed electromagnets under the road surface to help accelerate certain bikes and decelerate others.
- throwaway81523 1y agoThis is not new and they routinely examine bikes for it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_doping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_doping Article created in 2016.
- cactusplant7374 1y agoYeah, I think I remember reading about this a long time ago. Either here or on Wired.
- ajsnigrutin 1y agoeven before that, eg. WP article from 2015: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2015/07/23/forget-doping-greg-lemond-thinks-tour-de-france-riders-could-be-cheating-with-tiny-motors/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2015/07/23...
- 4ndrewl 1y agoEven before that. 2010 or so they were saying - without evidence - Cancellara used motors in the spring classics. It's just clickbait to co-incide with the end of the TdF.
- blakesterz 1y agoThere's a famously old accusation against Lance Armstrong https://telegrafi.com/en/keshtu-funksionon-motori-vogel-per-te-cilin-lance-armstrong-u-akuzua-se-kishte-mashtruar-per-vite-radhe/ https://telegrafi.com/en/keshtu-funksionon-motori-vogel-per-... The video of him reaching behind his seat is interesting I guess.
- mobiuscog 1y agoBut "It's not about the bike" ...
- fellowniusmonk 1y agoI mean if I was blood doping and had tons of scrutiny leveled at me I would definitely try some easy misdirection. Get accused of mechanical doping, have them waste all this time going after it, you look clean and your accusers lose credibility.
- gwelson 1y agoI am definitely a layperson when it comes to organized sports, but from my POV it seems like competitive cycling attracts WAY more fraud/cheating/doping/etc. than many other kinds of sports. At least I have heard about it a lot more. I wonder why that is.
- 50208 1y agoIt's not unique. Different sports police themselves more & less, punish more & less, coverup wrong doing more & less. As you said, you've just heard about it more.
- kube-system 1y agoYeah, in some sports cheating is so common that the cheating itself has become part of the competition... e.g. finding 'loopholes' or difficult to detect cheats in motorsports, doctoring the ball in baseball, flopping in soccer, etc.
- asdfasvea 1y agoFirst, what is there to wonder about? Stakes. There are things to be gained from winning (and purposely losing). Second, no one sport has more cheating than any other with similar stakes. Third, "cheating" is more of a spectrum than binary. Travelling with the basketball is cheating and sometimes penalized. Having your husband kneecap your Olympic skating rival is cheating as well. Fourth, "cheating" is relative and always in flux. You could head slap an NFL receiver in the 1970's, but no longer. Forward passes in the NHL were illegal in olden times, but fine today.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoDoping happens in all sports. It's pretty safe to assume that most/all top athletes are on something.
- ahi 1y agoI replied directly to OP, but applies here as well. Cycling is far more specialized than other sports so the pay off for doping is greater.
- smitty1e 1y agoDon Ho is all: "Tiny motors In my wheels Giving Gauls Goofy feels"
- Simulacra 1y agoThere was a lot of suspicion about Cancellara that was never really investigated. A couple of people have been caught... They brought out x-ray machines, and x-rayed bikes, but that's sort of fell by the wayside over the pandemic. I think the truth is, professional cycling, doesn't want to confront another scandal. So they just sort of turn a blind eye into it.
- driggs 1y agoThis article is about professional cycling NOT turning a blind eye to it.
- gghffguhvc 1y agohttps://youtu.be/Wv5F5N6mFf0?si=uE9fqMC_LdViYJWu https://youtu.be/Wv5F5N6mFf0?si=uE9fqMC_LdViYJWu. Nice review of how they work and what they feel like.
- floodfx 1y agoBikers and their teams are known for removing as much weight as possible from their bikes. Would love to see the math for weight/power/time ratio for a motor like this. Would it be worth it considering you'd have to expend additional watts lugging it around all stage? My guess is probably not. Especially on a mountain stage which is where the tour is really won or lost.
- ahi 1y agoTheoretically, the motor would be most useful on the climbs of the mountain stages. On the flats a couple of hundred grams don't matter, especially when most of the leaders are hanging back in the group anyway. That said, bikes can already be made under UCI weight minimums of 6.8kg. Yet from what I've seen, most tour bikes are in the 7-7.5kg range.
- LeifCarrotson 1y agoThe difference between the top 0.0000001% of humanity and second place is very, very small. Fractions of a watt. Adding just 10W would be game changing, and modern lipos and brushless motors add far, far more power than their weight penalty subtracts.
- floodfx 1y ago10W for a sustained time perhaps but these are looong climbs. Col de la Loze is 26.4km with an average gradient of 6.5%.
- dgacmu 1y agoA 60Wh battery weighs about 300g. That stage is about 5 hours. 300g seems a pretty small price to pay for a 10W boost, especially if you achieve it by making the bike be under the limit and then adding motor+battery (switchable with a dummy weight, of course) to bring it to spec. (The motor, of course, would probably weigh more - but it remains the case that you can build a bike that weighs under the minimum.)
- deleted 1y ago
- teeray 1y agoI wonder if you could surreptitiously detect motors from their RF emissions.
- andreareina 1y agoGood article, crap clickbait headline. S as usual Betteridge's law of headlines applies.
- jahewson 1y agoAt this point I’d prefer to see a Looney Tunes style race with no rules at all.
- manarth 1y agoThe Enhanced Games: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/68672104 https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/68672104
- neutrinobro 1y agoJust drill a small ~1mm hole in the seat/down tube of all bikes before each race. That shouldn't meaningfully affect the frame's structural integrity, but would easily disable any small motor attached to the crank.
- atemerev 1y agoYou could probably just eject the motor close to the finish line, or, if there's weighing involved, replace it by some neutral part.
- 0xAFFFF 1y agoThere is no realistic way to do anything like that "close to the finish line" on a Tour race, especially during a mountain stage, there are people and cameras everywhere.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- arduanika 1y agoHow tiny? At a certain scale, mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell...
- jonplackett 1y agoSeems like the answer to the question posed is… no
- begueradj 1y agoI am familiar with the UFC as a follower: there are many current and former competitors confessed every training camp out there hires experts who know to administer performance enhancing drugs into their athletes in a way they can not be caught when tested. There is always a way to cheat.
- jonplackett 1y agoI am in no doubt they’re still using drugs! But this headline is clickbait.
- Neil44 1y agoBetteridge's law of headlines
- jibal 1y ago"What if the reason cyclists were able to glide up the Pyrenees mountains was because they weren’t pedaling unassisted?" Ugh ... journalism. We know that's not why. At most some cyclists are "gliding" faster than others due to assistance. "As electronic bikes — with motors that provide up to 1,000 watts of power — have become available for recreational cyclists, hobbyists began building lighter road bikes with more discrete motors." Surely they mean "discreet".
- jmcdowell 1y agoIf anyone is a fan of podcasts and this subject, there is a really good podcast series called 'Ghost in the Machine' which does a deep dive into motor doping, how it could be occurring, the current state of technology to enable it and also looking into Femke van den Driessche's case which is mentioned in the article.
- jnsaff2 1y agoRecommended watching: Tour de Pharmacy[0]. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tour_de_Pharmacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tour_de_Pharmacy
- stdclass 1y agothere are multiple documented cases of motor doping - here you can see wout van aert using motors multiple times in belgian cyclocross races in 2016: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUGNKwcbbDw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUGNKwcbbDw
- veltas 1y agoThat video isn't conclusive and there's a lot of debate in the comments. Personally I agree with the people saying it's explainable.
- stdclass 1y agoin 2 of the instances you can see (if you go in 0.25x) that the wheels start spinning before torque is applied by the pedals - physically impossible. also when wout is running with the bike, it starts spinning after losing traction on the ground
- jamesblonde 1y agoFabian Cancellera was widely suspected of mechanical doping in Paris Roubaix in 2010 (possibly also the tour of Flanders that year). Since then, however, they x-ray bikes for motors. More importantly, riders aren't switching bikes they way they used to. Greg LeMond claimed Chris Froome used on in the TDF. References: https://www.bennionkearny.com/the-hidden-motor-mechanical-doping-paris-roubaix-fabian-cancellara/ https://www.bennionkearny.com/the-hidden-motor-mechanical-do... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgbvuJCvfxg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgbvuJCvfxg
- ekianjo 1y agoso did they find anyone using tiny motors when doing inspections?
- fnands 1y agoI don't think they've found anyone on the big tours, but iirc this was the first case of someone getting caught: https://www.bbc.com/sport/cycling/36142963 https://www.bbc.com/sport/cycling/36142963
- tdeck 1y agoThe excuse of the cyclist in this article is hilarious. "My friend just so happened to have an identical looking bike with an extremely rare stealth motor setup and it got swapped for mine, and I as a professional cyclist didn't notice that."
- tokai 1y agoGreg LeMond has been on a whole motodoping tour online recently to stay relevant. He clearly does not understand modern cycling and he has a ton of people he wants to put down for the sake of his own reputation. There is not reason to believe him more than a crazy uncle.
- IncreasePosts 1y agoYes, that's what people said about him when he was speaking against doping in the late 90s/early 2000s too. Remember when he was forced to issue an apology to Lance Armstrong for calling out his relationship with Dr. Ferrari(doping connoisseur)?
- navaed01 1y agoMy old boss was a tour rider in the early 90’s - he told me in 2012 that tiny motors were being used. I believe him.
- ur-whale 1y agohttps://archive.is/CpCeX https://archive.is/CpCeX
- jl6 1y agoThe lengths people will go to to cheat in sports is super interesting - sometimes more interesting than the sport itself! There should be a global all-sport annual prize for red-teaming (against the cheaters).
- create-username 1y agoAnd the black maillot for the most powerful doping chemicals goes to…
- mjklin 1y agoSNL had that idea: the “all drug Olympics” https://youtu.be/jAdG-iTilWU?si=25YzT63fNu_dCIq4 https://youtu.be/jAdG-iTilWU?si=25YzT63fNu_dCIq4
- Der_Einzige 1y agoYet no one seriously accepts the idea that Anal Beads might have been used for cheating in chess and that was after the literal top chess grandmaster in the world accused someone of doing it.
- tokai 1y agoMotordoping does not exist. There has not been a single case at top professional level even though they have looked for the motors for over a decade. But journalists, bloggers, and youtubers love to bring it up as a exciting story they don't need to do any work to write. Also old men like Greg LeMond uses it to stay relevant even though he knows nothing about motors nor modern cycling.
- mft_ 1y ago> Motordoping does not exist. It does exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femke_Van_den_Driessche https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femke_Van_den_Driessche Aside from allegations about Cancellara (basically that his seated attack was too strong, plus he 'moved his hand suspiciously' just before) I always struggled to find an alternate explanantion for this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ideiS-6gBAc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ideiS-6gBAc > There has not been a single case at top professional level even though they have looked for the motors for over a decade. Or, no-one has been caught as they stopped before the checks were brought in, as it's impossible to hide without a much broader conspiracy? > But journalists, bloggers, and youtubers love to bring it up as a exciting story they don't need to do any work to write. Agreed. WaPo is about a decade too late on this one.
- tokai 1y agoThis is the thing that's always brought up. That female junior cyclocross racer (its a different sport bub) and one attack that fans didn't like. People like you keep going with these two, even though they mean nothing. And then the conspiracy shit. The motodoping topic is closer related to pizzagate than it is road racing.
- blueflow 1y agoWhat does Istvan Varjas do for a living?
- throwaway3b03 1y agoNow that I found out about him, and saw an [interview](https://index.hu/video/2018/07/23/rejtett_motoros_kerekpar_bicikli_varjas_istvan_mechanikai_dopping/ https://index.hu/video/2018/07/23/rejtett_motoros_kerekpar_b...) he gave years ago, an old thought of mine came up. I was always thinking this was a really underserved market. Ebikes have been really in demand for a long while, but most of the offer was based on very heavy city bikes. I was always thinking that a much sportier, more efficient race ebikes would be a huge hit. I saw some prototypes on kickstarter but nothing that sticked. I wonder why. If I had the energy and resources I think I would try going into that product space. Seems like ripe for disruption. I ride ebikes a lot, and I used to ride race bikes a lot as well, years ago. For a long time I thought that a heavy city ebike is similar to a very efficient race bike that in terms of effort required. After I started to ride them simultaneously (more or less), maybe an ebike is in fact more helpful over longer periods, but a light race bike isn't far away. So a product that captures best of both worlds would do great IMO. LE. Apparently I'm late by around 5 years. When I last had this thought there was literally just a kickstarter project. Now I see most big brands have electric road bike offerings. Still, at 4-5k EUR price points, there's still a lot of value to capture.
- this_user 1y agoBetteridge's law. There have been suspicions about this for about 15 years. Yet, in that entire time, not a single road cyclist in a UCI competition has ever been found to be doing this. Even just from a practical POV, it makes little sense. Stock road frames do not have room to even mount such a motor. You would also need a sufficiently large battery somewhere on the bike that can deliver enough power to make an impact. Examples that people have built are usually replacing one of the bottles on the frame with a battery, but that would obviously be noticed immediately upon closer inspection of the bike. Even if you can remove the battery bottle, there would still need to be some kind of cable to connect it that you cannot remove on the fly without anyone noticing while in a highly public space. They have also been scanning bikes for years for potential signs of motors. Nothing has ever been found. So, if it does exist, someone has found a way to build incredibly tiny motors and batteries that don't show up during checks, but are still powerful enough to make a difference for a cyclist who is already pushing 400-500w or more. The much simpler explanation is that it's a complete myth that some people keep pushing for whatever reason.
- KingOfCoders 1y agoNot saying anyone does this, but my bottle holder has two screws that could easily act as contacts - no wires needed.
- randomcarbloke 1y agothere is room, bear in mind such a device need only provide minute advantage for it to be significant.
- RankingMember 1y ago> it's a complete myth that some people keep pushing for whatever reason. I think it's simply because the top cyclists are now blowing the performance of doped cyclists of decades past out of the water and people get suspicious. I personally think huge advances in nutrition + altitude training are making the difference, but I understand people being suspicious especially in this sport. I agree with you, btw- I've yet to see anything proving conclusively that this form of doping even exists.
- sidibe 1y agoMotordoping has been talked for decade+. The new rage is training with carbon monoxide
- Bluescreenbuddy 1y agoWaPo must be running out of stories. This is old news
- littlestymaar 1y agoNew? The suspicions of motor use have peaked almost a decade ago. Now bike inspections are routine and there hasn't been a single high profile case involving electric motors.
- Steve16384 1y agoAny headline with a question mark at the end is usually answered with "no".
- ngriffiths 1y agoBetteridge's Law strikes again
- consumer451 1y agoAccording to the Wikipedia entry, the "law" does not reflect reality upon inspection: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines#Studies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- ngriffiths 1y agoCool! Seems to be citing this nice post here: http://calmerthanyouare.org/2015/03/19/betteridges-law.html http://calmerthanyouare.org/2015/03/19/betteridges-law.html I didn't realize the biggest reason against it is that the majority of headline questions aren't yes/no. Oh well, it's still funny to silently answer any (yes/no) headline question with "no!" before reading.
- thenoblesunfish 1y agoTrue, but in this case the story is about the suspicions of cheating themselves, and the new checks, so fair enough.
- timost 1y agoThere is this french website[0] which (among other things) analyses TdF performances over the years. They compute power metrics based on climbing times in the mountain stages. The trend these last few years is quite worrying, reaching and going above peak doping-era performances [1]. The website is maintained by a former pro-level coach of the festina era. [0] https://www.cyclisme-dopage.com/ https://www.cyclisme-dopage.com/ [1] https://www.cyclisme-dopage.com/actualite/2025-07-26-cyclisme-dopage-com.htm https://www.cyclisme-dopage.com/actualite/2025-07-26-cyclism...
- alistairSH 1y agoI don't read French, so can't directly comment on the content. However, these year-by-year comparisons often miss a few key points... - Technology advances. Looks at the jerseys worn during the peak doping era (Lance, etc) vs today - they look downright baggy in the 90s vs now. The bikes are more aerodynamic as well. The tire roll faster. - Nutrition has changed MASSIVELY in the last ~5 years. Gone are bananas and pastries (even from the Italian and French teams). The "bonk" is almost completely a thing of the past at this level - cyclists are consuming carbs at rates that would have put most people on the toilet a few years ago. Part of this is better mixes; part of it is humans can simply consume more carbs than we thought possible (with appropriate gut training). - Training itself has changed. It's year-round, it's far more structured. Everybody has a power meter, glucose monitor, etc. Kids are starting this structure training at younger ages. Anyway, do I think pro cycling is 100% clean? No, of course not, there's massive incentive to cheat. Do I believe the top cyclists (Pogi, Vingegaard, etc) are clean (per current rules)? Yes. They're testing far too often to not be. Are they possible pushing the limits of what's legal? Probably (see also: CO training last year, which is now banned).
- timost 1y agoThank you for your answer ! I'm trying not to pick sides but here are a few arguments they oppose to these key points : - Technological advancement : Although it does play a role, they measure power in long climbs to limit that bias. Speeds are lower so aero plays less of a role. Bikes were already as light or even lighter in the 2000s. They also calibrate their power predictions against riders of the peloton who publish their power on strava. - Nutrition has indeed changed, it helps producing near max power efforts at the end of long stages (aka durability) but doesn't play a direct role on pure max power (VO2 max related) which is what they are worried about. - Regarding training, I'm not really sure, I think the pro peloton already had access to power meters in the 2000s. - Regarding testing, it's indeed quite frequent but it's not bullet proof. - I think the history of the sport is so bad it's hard to see the half full glass.
- ngriffiths 1y agoThese cheating methods always seem far-fetched until I remember that getting that good at cycling is pretty far-fetched, and it's all relative to that
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Aperocky 1y agoOccams Razor says no. A proper ebike won't stand a chance against the modern queen stage of the tour de france, even if ridden by a professional with appropriate gears otherwise, because the battery would run out half way on the first HC and it would just be a very heavy bike for the rest of the stage. Same with a tiny motor - you gain tiny amount of force but you'll have to carry a full bidon with you on all the climbs, not to mention that the delicate mechanism can break easily. I'd rather believe they're doping.
- ortusdux 1y agoHow much breaking is done during a race? Would a KERS style motor w/ capacitor be beneficial?
- gambiting 1y agoThere is no way to do this unless the motor is inside the wheel hub and that would be instantly obvious - regular hubs are super thin and wouldn't fit a motor + capacitor inside them. And you'd need to tell it you want to brake somehow.
- daemonologist 1y agoIt would be extremely beneficial, but nearly impossible to integrate. Motors used for cheating in cycling are usually in the seat tube or down tube, where they can invisibly interface with the bottom bracket (between the pedals) and connect to batteries elsewhere in the frame. Because bicycles have a freewheel in the rear hub (chain doesn't move while coasting/braking)*, a KERS would have to be located in the tiny rear wheel hub. *You can of course get a non-race bike with a fixed chain, but UCI rules require use of a freewheel.
- ortusdux 1y agoNow I kind of want to see a separate Formula E style league that allows KERS
- jakewins 1y ago
- msarrel 1y agoThey've suspected this for 10 years.
- ck2 1y agoI'm not saying it's not possible to be motors But something I've noticed across several sports is amateurs really can't grasp how elite some human beings can be biologically due to accidents in evolution So any significantly elite performance is indistinguishable from tech/drug doping It's all in the mitochondria and someday they might be able to test at birth (or even before) And now they are developing mitochondria transplants so just imagine TdF or the Olympics in a few decades
- phtrivier 1y agoBest summary ever for the TdF: [1] Kidding aside, this is one of those fields where I don't know how to use Occam's Razor. Given the fact: "in a sport that is mostly about physical capacity, some racers now routinely achieve better performances than racers that where dopped, but excaped controls, 20 years ago". What is the explanation that requires the less priors: * some teams have perfected training regimen, equipment quality, etc... in order to make the same performance today, but without doping (something that never happened) * some teams have found another way to escape controls (something that happened in the past) So of course, "Past does not predict the future", it's unfair to accuse without proofs, etc... And maybe the performances have improved dramatically in other sports (surely the number of goals scored in football is increasing exponentially, etc... ?) I have to give Pogacar credit for one thing: he knew that things were getting really suspicious, and he had the sportmanship to let other people win a couple of stages. I really wonder how long it will take for the case to be settled ! [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVB7OX0Oa-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVB7OX0Oa-Q
- crashbunny 1y agoI don't know if this is a big factor, but, kids for the last 10 years have had access to really good training techniques for free via youtube. Every kid has the opportunity to use the same training techniques as the professionals. By the time they get serious and have access to professional coaches, they've had maybe 5 years of good quality training. As well as bikes have improved a lot. Clothes have improved a bit. But the biggest factor of all are the drugs. I mean I don't know. I'm just cynical. I think it's a level playing field, though. I think it was a level playing field during the armstrong era. Maybe armstrong had better drugs, better doctors, but it's not like the other riders were clean.
- jnpnj 1y ago> [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVB7OX0Oa-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVB7OX0Oa-Q this is something I never expected to see on HN.
- phtrivier 1y ago"No one expects the comedy show from 25 years ago"
- jandrese 1y agoI would like to see the opposite race. One where contestants are all given a specific battery at the start of the day and have to optimize its use on their e-bike to make the fastest time on the circuit.
- lifestyleguru 1y agoThere are nine million bicycles with tiny motors and everyone riding them are on drugs.
- scoreandmore 1y agoWhere do they fit a motor, battery, controls, and transmission on a 4kg bike? I can’t find any online to buy and I would expect it’s a poorly kept secret.
- kazinator 1y agoThis is not new, by any stretch of the inner tube.
- farceSpherule 1y agoWTF.. Sick and tired of the incessant cheating by these cyclists. It never ends. They cheat, then win, then walk around like they are some big sh*ts. I mean, I am sick and tired of cyclists in general because of the way they act where I live. They obey no traffic laws, run red lights, never signal, blaze through intersections, and generally act like they own the road. It's amazing how many of them forget that they are like cars and must abide by the same laws.
- farceSpherule 1y agoThe only way to solve this is to allow them all to dope. It will level the playing field somewhat, however, will then become an exercise in economic warfare: those with the money will be able to afford the better dope and will win.
- farceSpherule 1y agoThe governing bodies do not want to do anything about this because of the money generated by the races. It's a cash cow.
- egberts1 1y agoTime to go back to 1/2" tubes, and spoked wheels.
- rurban 1y agoNowadays they use ACAIR (and it's legal variants) and of course blood-doping. They still have their blood-doping experts in their teams. See the ARD doc about that. All olympic athletes do that, according to statistics. Motors are so 2000's