10 ms·
Backlash to artificial dye grows as Kraft ditches coloring for Kool-Aid, Jell-O
- bookofjoe 1y agohttps://archive.ph/Wq46t https://archive.ph/Wq46t
- superkuh 1y ago[flagged]
- FuriouslyAdrift 1y agoMmmm... they'll probably use more Cochineal extract (bug derived) for red dye. Wonder if we will see an uptick in allergic reactions. https://news.umich.edu/food-dye-can-cause-severe-allergic-reactions/ https://news.umich.edu/food-dye-can-cause-severe-allergic-re...
- badc0ffee 1y agoI think beetroot is more likely.
- SoftTalker 1y agoScience (FDA) is what has allowed all the hyper-processed foods and food additives that are so often criticized here. Seems a bit disingenuous to suddenly recast those concerns as the "whims" of an ignorant person just because of his political affiliation. Take wins where you can get them. That said Kraft is just positioning itself to provide what it thinks the market will want. They haven't suddenly found some ethics and decided they are going to produce good healthy food for its own sake.
- mathw 1y agoAnd it should be fairly easy for them because they're already doing it for most of the rest of the world.
- Eisenstein 1y agoThe FDA 'allowing' hyper processed foods is a just what you get when you don't ban things pre-emptively or because you don't think people should be eating them. People blame science when a company does something they don't like and then credit the free market when it does something they do, forgetting that a huge public company doesn't do anything because it is the right thing, they do it because they think they will make money by doing it. We can either change the incentives that exist to sell people hyper processed food, or we can regulate everything to death, or we can figure out how to make people not want to eat it. I'm not sure which answer is the best one, but I think that making scientists the boogeymen for a human incentive problem is the wrong way to find it.
- xnx 1y agoWe're talking about Kool aid. Changing the food coloring isn't going to make six cups of refined sugar healthy.
- superkuh 1y agoThe only institution cited in this article is from the "California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment" study. Otherwise it was consumer advocate groups. No FDA studies are cited and these are direct quotes from the article we both read, >Kraft is the latest company, including Tyson Foods and PepsiCo, to transition from artificial colors for popular products under pressure from government officials. “The FDA has failed for so many decades that state legislators had no choice but to step in to protect our kids.” The FDA science isn't and hasn't been behind it but at state government scales dietary memes and their profitable consumer groups are influential enough. And now the feds have been coopted and the FDA is being forced into this by Kennedy. They're trying to migitate the damage as much as possible on the way down. Lets hope the replacements are so well and throughly vetted by science and time as the ones being banned for no reason but 'natural = good' memes.
- danaris 1y agoThis is basically a stopped clock happening to be right. AIUI, there's ample evidence that (certain) artificial food dyes can cause various problems. I know that I have anecdotal evidence that they can—even in "blind" situations, where we didn't realize they were in the food until after having problems—cause things like headaches, lightheadedness, and other vague but unpleasant reactions. I find it frustrating that, as another commenter said, it took an absolute nutter like RFK Jr to make this happen, and also that I have to give him credit for anything positive—but it's pretty clear that this specific thing is, indeed, positive.
- xnx 1y agoI agree, but it looks like the article title is now "Backlash to artificial dye grows as Kraft ditches coloring for Kool-Aid, Jell-O". Seems like that's what their clickbait testing algorithm landed on.
- N_A_T_E 1y agoI don’t think this is a science or safety issue, it’s an issue with bad ingredient labeling. They should name these numbered dyes something more understandable. “Red dye 4” sounds pretty sketchy when they could say “Cochineal extract for coloring”. People can reject the product because the ingredients include a bug derived coloring rather than fear of the unknown “red dye” invented by their imagined evil food scientists.
- FuriouslyAdrift 1y agoSince cochineal casues so many allergic reactions, there's already a law that they have to put it on the label.
- hinkley 1y agoWhen I was a kid I ate lunch with a girl who couldn’t have M&Ms because she was allergic to the red die. I was appalled by this. And the strangest thing about that story is that she was maybe 4 years old when Mars pulled the red M&Ms due to a cancer scare with a different red food coloring. Though my recollection was that it was a few years more recent than that, given how shelf life and supply chains work, I may have been getting back stock. I think I eventually proved to her that there were no red M&Ms anymore. I guess her parents hadn’t bothered to check for years. Not the first injustice I had tried to right but the easiest one. Five years later they added Red back and I would think of her every time I ate M&Ms for a long time after.
- toast0 1y agoWikipedia reports red M&Ms were eliminated in 1976, and added back in 1987. I'm sure it took several months for these changes to make it to the marketplace, but probably not years; M&Ms have a reasonable shelf life, but they do degrade, so year old stock isn't great. My Mom was pretty salty about the red M&Ms going missing, and refused to eat blue M&Ms for quite some time.
- hinkley 1y ago
- neuroelectron 1y agoI hope they remove them from animal food as well. Ol' Roy dog food uses tones of the stuff. Why?? So unnecessary.
- Molitor5901 1y agoPet food is some of the most unsanitary "food" on earth. A lot of it is mass produced overseas with little to no regard as to the safety of the ingredients, and I would venture to say at least half of it is adulterated. We only find out about it when large numbers of pets start dying. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_pet_food_recalls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_pet_food_recalls
- hinkley 1y agoWhen I was a kid Ralston Purina owned a bunch of human food enterprises as well and that always disturbed me.
- vel0city 1y agoI mean the company that makes M&Ms and Kind Bars also makes Whiskias and Royal Canin. In the end I don't get why it matters. Do we not expect there to be good standards for both?
- Gracana 1y agoIn Smithfield Virginia there's a big Smithfield Foods pork plant, and right next door is Premium Pet Health, which is a Smithfield-owned pet food plant. I've only ever been in the Smithfield plant, and it seems fine. Very industrial, but similar to other meat plants.
- hinkley 1y agoWhen I was a kid it was still considered normal for your dog to sleep outside. Most people drew the line at chaining your dog instead of having a fence, but that was about it. My dad built an insulated doghouse for our dog rather than let her stay inside. I thought that was weird, but I was the “weird kid” so who cares what I thought. The number of things I thought should be true at that age that finally are is baffling. Even accounting for recent regressions.
- egypturnash 1y ago[flagged]
- newsclues 1y agoThis and the Pharma advertising changes could be great. I think it's important to judges individual policy, not just judge an individual.
- Workaccount2 1y agoGetting rid of pharma ads is going to be a first amendment issue, and should be struck down, as it likely will. Creating an environment where the goverment can single out who the first amendment does and doesn't apply to is far far worse than pharma advertising.
- SV_BubbleTime 1y agoIf the Pharma industry as it exists, today could exist without federal government regulation, then I think you might have a point. The government is so intertwined in the Pharma industry, that no I don’t really see a 1A problem here. Sparing misused, and completely incorrect fire in a theater, tropes, there is a good point we made that freedom of speech does not extend to unnecessarily dangerous things. Remind me which company has received the largest criminal fine in history (Pfizer). I just don’t think you’re gonna have a lot of sympathy for oh poor Pharma companies and their lack of free speech.
- strictnein 1y ago> I just don’t think you’re gonna have a lot of sympathy for oh poor Pharma companies and their lack of free speech This is perhaps the worst argument possible for restricting the rights of a certain group.
- SV_BubbleTime 1y agoBecause they are government subsidized to the point of being an arm and they’re naughty? Ok, but it works for me.
- jasonthorsness 1y agoEven in the 90s artificial dyes already had a bad reputation. The manufacturers must have considered removal and it's shocking to me that their analysis must have guided them to keep them in despite nobody really asking for them. I guess people love bright colors.
- bunderbunder 1y agoJust guessing, they did research and found that products with dyes sell better. People say all sorts of things about what they do and do not want to buy, but actions speak louder than words.
- Workaccount2 1y agoSilly Rabbit! Original Trix With Artificial Colors Is Back After Customers Revolt https://archive.ph/GFMs0 https://archive.ph/GFMs0
- sudobash1 1y agoIt's not just the bright colors. The color of food greatly influences our perception of it. My grandmother was a caterer for many years, and she would tell me that the main difference between a chocolate cake and a vanilla one, is that one is brown. If you colored a cake brown, people would start to perceive it a chocolate.
- b112 1y agoI can believe this for the cake itself, not the icing, which is probably what she/you mean. Interesting.
- compiler-guy 1y agoChefs have a famous saying that "You eat with your eyes first." The color of one's food is a huge part of that first sample.
- cma 1y agoI can report that Crystal Pepsi tasted like Pesi and not Sprite at least, so there must be some limitations.
- msgodel 1y agoThe red dye they use in a lot of stuff is absolutely psychoactive. I used to intentionally consume things with it on long drives because it zaps my short term memory so I don't get bored and fall asleep. I noticed this effect after eating some red candy while trying to do math homework in college. The downside of course is that once you get where you're going you're practically retarded for the next 12 hours or so and can't get any work done.
- Night_Thastus 1y agoSource on red dye being psychoactive?
- msgodel 1y agoYou'll have to look for it yourself I guess? I don't know if anyone has even tried studying it, the effect is pretty subtle if you don't know to look for it. I'm just posting my experiences with it.
- Night_Thastus 1y agoYou can't just make a massive claim like that about such a common ingredient without backing it up. I'm not saying it's not true, it could be, but it's just inappropriate to state something is true like that with 0 evidence aside from personal experience.
- msgodel 1y agoIf that were the case posting on forums like this would be either entirely inappropriate or a complete waste of time.
- account42 1y agoNot at all. You can a) Make claims that are not as extraordinary. b) Back your claims up with evidence. Making absolutely wild claims without evidence just makes you sound like a quack.
- Molitor5901 1y agoWhat bugs me the most about companies like Kraft is that they could have replaced artificial dyes and ingredients any time they wanted to, but didn't. Clearly these companies are in it to make money, and they will sell the public whatever the public will eat, synthetic ingredients be damned, but maybe.. just maybe the government should be much, much more restrictive on the ingredients that goes into our foods...
- toomuchtodo 1y agoThey don't care until there is some combination of public and government pressure, so you just have to keep pressuring, forever. Corporations are fundamentally unaccountability laundering profit machines (limited liability, nebulous shareholder ownership), and must be treated accordingly.
- Molitor5901 1y agoWhich is the worst part about all of this: It took government pressure and calling them out to force a change. My anger at government is why they didn't do this SOONER? Why did it take someone like RJF jr. to move this needle? After all the people we've had at Sec. of Agriculture, HHS, and FDA Commissioners.. I don't think this was because people were putting pressure, otherwise the sheer numbers of those communities would have done something by now. It only required one person in power to say enough, fix this.
- add-sub-mul-div 1y agoAre you asking why people are more susceptible to demagoguery than science education? History tells us what we need to know about that.
- thatguy0900 1y ago[flagged]
- carefulfungi 1y agoBut, as mentioned elsewhere in this thread, others have done this before RJF's appointment. During the Obama administration, cherry picking some example: * Food safety regulatory improvement bill: https://www.fda.gov/food/guidance-regulation-food-and-dietary-supplements/food-safety-modernization-act-fsma https://www.fda.gov/food/guidance-regulation-food-and-dietar... * Improved labelling rules: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/21/health/fda-nutrition-labels.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/21/health/fda-nutrition-labe... * EPA water safety rules made stricter, then rolled back by Trump: https://www.sgrlaw.com/epa-announces-plans-to-revoke-obama-waters-of-the-united-states-rule/ https://www.sgrlaw.com/epa-announces-plans-to-revoke-obama-w.... It isn't correct to see these changes a singular improvement. These rules are constantly being fought over, sometimes becoming stricter, sometimes looser. Another example, NYC has fought to reduce sugary drink serving sizes and to require labels on high sugar foods. (https://www.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/cdp/added-sugars-warning-rule.pdf https://www.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/cdp/added-sugar...)
- decide1000 1y agoWhy does it take so long? Existing EU recipes are already compliant Kraft’s European products have for years used natural colours such as turmeric, paprika, beet juice or no colouring at all. That is why the 2025 U.S. pledge to go dye free by 2027 is largely irrelevant on this side of the Atlantic. So 2027? That does not make sense at all.. it's a n economic perspective, not a healthy one.
- dehrmann 1y agoGuessing it's to ramp-up suppliers, change equipment over, and stockpile enough for the transition.
- giarc 1y agoI understand the need to phase out/in ingredients in this situation, however I've never understood when there is a simple ban on an unnecessary ingredient why it takes long. I'm specifically talking about those "microbeads" in bodywash that were banned a few years ago. The companies got years to phase them out. They served no real purpose and were not replaced with anything. Companies just had to stop adding them to the bodywash - why give them years to do so? I get that labelling would be inaccurate so give them a few months to change that.
- mslansn 1y agoOf course the beads served a purpose: they were abrasive and exfoliating. And they were given time because they have to sell their existing inventory and use all the beads they already have purchased to put in their products.
- spondylosaurus 1y agoNot sure why you're greyed out, because you're correct that those were literally exfoliant face washes. (No real loss in phasing them out because there are much better ways to exfoliate than rubbing your face with little pellets, but it wasn't some meaningless design choice.)
- curtisszmania 1y ago[dead]
- klik99 1y agoWhy did it take an insane person to actually get sensible regulation for food dyes in? Rhetorical question because I think people like RFKJr got into power because previous administrations didn't take care of the obvious things that need regulation, and if you ignore the basics for too long people flip over to someone who packages a couple of reasonable stances with a lot of damaging ideas. I agree with RFK for pushing for change in this industry but I give him no credit, instead I blame previous administrations on both sides for not taking a better stance on regulating food like every other developed country in the world.
- adestefan 1y ago[flagged]
- refurb 1y ago[flagged]
- magicalist 1y agoThe FDA has nothing to do with this action either though?
- adestefan 1y agoThey did it. The Republicans rolled it all back.
- refurb 1y agoRolled back a banning of artificial dyes? Gonna need a source for that.
- boston_clone 1y agoEven the whole notion of abolishing the food pyramid to advocate for more fibrous whole foods (e.g., vegetables, fruits) and stylizing it as a plate was her idea, later coopted by RFK Jr. https://apnews.com/article/health-healthy-eating-a9f5cd19e17f4c2794e7355325c76d07 https://apnews.com/article/health-healthy-eating-a9f5cd19e17...
- Flatcircle 1y agohow did it take this long?
- stevenwoo 1y agoIt would cost companies money to change their formula for food products and most additives are made by petrochemical companies so two industries with very strong lobbies to fight to keep them in use.
- pplm8 1y ago[dead]
- fabian2k 1y agoLumping all artificial dyes together is a sign the regulations RFK Jr. is proposing or implementing are unscientific. These are different chemicals, and actual scientific or medical arguments would treat them as such. There's plenty of good discussion possible about which additives in food should be regulated more. But making this kind of unscientific push is harmful in the end.
- ipsum2 1y agoFrom the article: "Some consumer advocacy groups argue the dyes aren’t worth the potential risk because they lack nutritional value." It's the precautionary principle in action. Is it scientific? Not really. But does it make rational sense? Possibly.
- avidiax 1y agoI somewhat support being unscientific in this case. It's not as though food dyes are being used to make healthy foods more palatable. It's quite the opposite, that food colorings are used to make processed foods more stimulating, which in turn makes non-processed foods less attractive. I support this in the same way that I'd support an outright ban on processed food advertising (especially to children). There is a health crisis in the US (and much of the western world), with one factor being the prevalence and poor nutrition provided by processed foods.
- someonehere 1y agoIt’s bizarre, reading people here defending the artificial food dyes. Most of these are derived from petroleum. The stuff that comes out of the ground and powers your car and lubricates gears. It’s in your food and you’re OK with that?