8 ms·
Building supercomputers for autocrats probably isn't good for democracy
- prpl 1y agoNot clear to me anyone “in charge” cares in any case. In fact, that may be the point.
- martin-t 1y agoThe biggest danger of AI isn't that it will revolt but that it'll allow dictators and other totalitarians complete control over the population. And I mean total. A sufficiently advanced algorithm will be able to find everything a person has ever posted online (by cross referencing, writing style, etc.) and determine their views and opinions with high accuracy. It'll be able to extrapolate the evolution of a person's opinions. The government will be able to target dissidents even before they realize they are dissidents, let alone before they have time to organize.
- tabarnacle 1y agoSure.. for folks who don’t worry about anonymity when sharing online. For those who prioritize anonymity, I’m doubtful.
- barbazoo 1y agoThat’s what the database is for then. https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-database-palantir-dystopian-alarm-2079688 https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-database-palantir-dyst...
- throwanem 1y agoSure. https://www.criterion.com/films/211-brazil https://www.criterion.com/films/211-brazil
- exiguus 1y agoI'm not entirely convinced that nations will play as significant a role in the coming decades as they have historically. Currently, we observe a trend where affluent individuals are increasingly consolidating power, a phenomenon that is becoming more apparent in the public sphere. Notably, these individuals are also at the forefront of owning and controlling advancements in artificial intelligence. Coincidentally, this trend is often referred to as 'tech fascism,' bringing us back to the dictator schema.
- throwanem 1y agoStates haven't always been a major feature of power. But we've never seen the interaction of personal power with modern weaponry, by which I do not mean nukes. When it was just a question of which debauched noble could afford more thugs or better assassins, sure. But 'how many Abrams has the Doge?'
- exiguus 1y ago>But 'how many Abrams has the Doge?' As many as you can control with signal chat. Besides, I'm not sure if tanks like the Abrams are as important anymore. Nowadays, things like food and water really matter. For example, exporting corn is crucial. Also, having the soils needed to make modern tech, like chips and batteries, is super important. Therefore Greenland is.
- throwanem 1y agoShow me the war where resources weren't important. But you fail to take my meaning, which is that of the two, bureaucracy is far more robust than aristocracy, because power held by aristocracy succeeds by lineage where that by bureaucracy does so by role - that is, in a fashion far less constrained by the available resource of satisfactory personnel. Every billionaire in function constitutes an aristocracy of one. Meanwhile, states have armed forces. A billionaire, in relying on money for power, implicitly also depends on continued access to the global financial system which gives money meaning, in order to exercise that power. States are not obligated to allow such access, and may easily prevent it in the limiting case by ensuring such trade comes with a side of explosives delivered at speed, which broadly suffices to deter desirable counterparties. Think what anyone may of such a thing, the fact is having an army or navy or air force means you can do it. Which billionaire has one of those?
- noident 1y ago> A sufficiently advanced algorithm will be able to find everything a person has ever posted online (by cross referencing, writing style, etc.) Is this like a sufficiently smart compiler? :) Stylometry is well-studied. You'll be happy to know that it is only practical when there are few suspect authors for a post and each author has a significant amount of text to sample. So, tying a pseudonymous post back to an author where anyone and everybody is a potential suspect is totally infeasible in the vast majority of cases. In the few cases where it is practical, it only creates a weak signal for further investigation at best. You might enjoy the paper Adversarial Stylometry: Circumventing Authorship Recognition to Preserve Privacy and Anonymity by Greenstadt et al.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- sitkack 1y agoSomeone did a stylometry attack against hn awhile ago, it would with very high confidence unmask alt accounts on this site. It worked. There is zero reason to believe that it couldn't be applied on a grand scale.
- AStonesThrow 1y agoHow do y’all prove it worked, O Privacy Wonks? How do y’all establish ye Theory Of Stylometry, O Phrenology Majors? O, @dang confirms it on Mastodon or something??
- squeeeeeeem 1y agoIt found 11 of my alt accounts with 90% accuracy. Now I make a new alt every post despite HN rules. sorry, but it is essential to do so.
- nixgeek 1y agoAdding an extra “e” for each doesn’t create much extra mystery requiring stylometry to unmask you. More seriously, why is this essential?
- dfxm12 1y agodetermine their views and opinions with high accuracy The truth, accuracy doesn't matter to authoritarians. It doesn't matter to Trump, clearly, people are being sent away with zero evidence, sometimes without formal charges. That's the point of authoritarianism. The leader just does as he wishes. AI is not enabling Trump, the feckless system of checks and balances is. Similarly, W lied about wmd's, to get us into an endless war. It doesn't matter that this reason wasn't truthful. He got away with it and enriched himself and defense contractor buddies at the expense of the American people.
- Terr_ 1y agoRight: They often don't care about accuracy, only plausibility they can pick and choose from.
- Mountain_Skies 1y ago[flagged]
- z0r 1y agoHow on earth did you infer that from his post? I can't follow your logic at all. Is it because he criticized two Republican presidents by name? Did he lie?
- BriggyDwiggs42 1y agoClassic left are authoritarians brainrot.
- blackoil 1y agoListen, you can get one of these local LLMs - and let me tell you, some of them are tremendous, really tremendous - to write exactly like Trump. It's incredible, actually. People will come up to you all the time and they'll say, 'Sir, how do you do it? How do you write so beautifully?' And now, with these artificial intelligence things - which, by the way, I was talking about AI before anyone even knew what it was - you can have them copy his style perfectly. Amazing technology, really amazing.
- fc417fc802 1y agoThe right to locally maintain fully private AI shall not be infringed ... ?
- SecretDreams 1y agoWell said. It's just a new lever to embolden the same shitty people and behaviours that keep tending to run society into the ground - but at a much larger scale.
- arcanus 1y agoI do not find her critique of argument #2 compelling [1]. Monetization of AI is key to economic growth. She's focused on the democratic aspects of AI, which frankly aren't pertinent. The real "race" in AI is between economic and financial forces, with huge infrastructure investments requiring a massive return on investment to justify the expense. From this perspective, increasing the customer base and revenue of the company is the objective. Without this success, investment in AI will drop, and with it, company valuations. The essay attempted to mitigate this by noting OAI is nominally a non-profit. But it's clear the actions of the leadership are firmly aligned with traditional capitalism. That's perhaps the only interesting subtly of the issue, but the essay missed this entirely. The omission could not have been intentional, because it provides a complete motivation for item #2. [1] #2 is 'The US is a democracy and China isn’t, so anything that helps the US “win” the AI “race” is good for democracy.'
- bgwalter 1y agoThe U.S. may be a nominal democracy, but the governed have no influence over the oligarchy. For example, they will not be able to stop "AI" even though large corporations steal their output and try to make their jobs obsolete or more boring. Real improvements are achieved in the real world, and building more houses or high speed trains does not require "AI". "AI" will just ruin the last remaining attractive jobs, and China can win that race if they want to, which isn't clear yet at all. They might be more prudent and let the West reduce its collective IQ by taking instructions from computers hosted by mega corporations.
- gsf_emergency 1y ago>anything that helps the US “win” That is, "the ends justifies the means"? Yep, seems like we are already at war. What happened to the project of adapting nonzero sum games to reality??
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- credit_guy 1y agoMaybe. I would not do business with Kim Jong Un. He is murdering a lot of his own people. Or with Putin. He is murdering a lot of Ukrainians. But guess what: both North Korea and Russia are under sanctions. You can't do business with them anyway. But the UAE is not under sanctions. Which means that in the opinion of the US Government it is ok to do business with them. Then who is Open AI to say otherwise? Why should it be any of their concern to determine who is a good guy or a bad guy in the world? Shouldn't there be a division of responsibilities? Let the Department of State determine who is good and who is bad, and let companies do business with those who are not on the sanctions list.
- anthonymartinez 1y agofor a while the Pinochet regime was our perfectly acceptable ally in Chile, even though we knew he was a mass murderer. its silly to throw up your hands just because the state department (itself not exactly a bastion of morality) says that its not illegal to do business with someone.
- credit_guy 1y agoLet me guess: you were against Bush's war in Iraq to take down Saddam. Why? Wasn't it moral to try to eliminate a known mass murderer? Either is our duty to be the the moral arbiters of the world or it isn't. Which one is it?
- sitkack 1y agoOne can be against a war and at the same time be against the government that war would remove. We killed hundreds of thousands of Iraqis, many of those troops were conscripts who didn't want to be there, yet we bulldozed them into the sand to suffocate, or burned them alive on the highway while they retreated. There are more than two answers to everything. > Wasn't it moral to try to eliminate a known mass murderer? Given the context and the means. No.
- jamroom 1y agoWe didn’t go in to Irag because Saddam was a mass murderer - we went in because Bush lied to America that Saddam was trying to get yellow cake uranium to build a bomb. A lot of Americans were against the war because we knew Saddam was not involved in 9/11 but Bush jr wanted to finish what his father couldn’t in the first gulf war. Honestly I would love it if we cared enough about mass murderers to actually go in and help, but I just don’t see that being a reason.
- Exoristos 1y agoI would have thought it obvious that LLMs' primary usefulness is as force-multipliers of the messaging sent out into a society. Each member of hoi polloi will be absolutely cocooned in thick blankets of near-duplicative communications and interactions most of which are not human. The only way to control the internet, you see, proved to be to drown it out.
- kragen 1y agoI cannot imagine what it would be like to have such overconfidence in my own knowledge and imagination to think it was obvious to me what LLMs' primary usefulness was. What did people think the primary usefulness of steam-engines was in 01780?
- Exoristos 1y agoUsefulness as of today, approximately. That is, that the massive interest and investment is not all speculation.
- kragen 1y agoThe massive interest and investment is about its usefulness (or profitability) in the future, not as of today, almost by definition! It's necessarily mostly speculative.
- forgetfreeman 1y agoThis seems like a lack of perspective on your part. Why would AIs primary usefulness be substantially different than any other software? Steam engines don't really factor into this.
- GolfPopper 1y agoSteam engines move stuff. That was obvious from the start. How that was applied became complex beyond imagination. LLMs cheaply produce plausible and persuasive BS. This is what they've done from the start. Exactly how that ability will be applied we don't know, but it doesn't take a lot to see that the Venn Diagram of 'cheap & effective BS' and 'public good' does not have a great deal of overlap.
- antithesizer 1y agoIf democracy builds supercomputers (and bombs, propaganda, prisons) for autocrats, of what good is democracy? The evidence points strongly to democracy and autocracy being friends, even "good cop, bad cop"
- Kapura 1y ago[flagged]
- zelphirkalt 1y agoOr is it rather, that there are few well working democracies and most are infiltrated by autocrats at least to some degree?
- bgwalter 1y agoI missed that the article is talking about Gulf monarchy autocrats instead of U.S. autocrats. That is very simple: First, dumping graphics cards on trusting Saudi investors seems like a great idea for Nvidia. Second, the Gulf monarchies depend on the U.S. and want to avoid Islamic revolutions. Third, they hopefully use solar cells to power the data centers. Will they track users? Of course, and GCHQ and the NSA can have intelligence sharing agreements that circumvent their local laws. There is nothing new here. Just don't trust your thoughts to any SAAS service.
- zelphirkalt 1y agoBut at the end of the day HN is a small bubble and many people out there are not well informed and even more will trade privacy for convenience sooner or later. Making it so that the temptations do not even come into existence would be preferable from a certain point of view.
- timewizard 1y ago> Just don't trust your thoughts It's a little more insidious than that, though, isn't it? They've got my purchases, address history, phone call metadata, and now with DOGE much of our federal data. They don't need a twitter feed to be adversarial to my interests. > to any SAAS service. They're madly scraping the web. I think your perimeter is much larger than SAAS.
- ReptileMan 1y ago>the Gulf monarchies depend on the U.S. and want to avoid Islamic revolutions There is no one left to islamic revolute in the small gulf states. The natives are minority, the security forces are all foreigners directly under the command of the ruler and in some cases outnumber the total native population. And the natives are too well fed to have the fight in them to risk it all.
- lupusreal 1y agoYou describe a situation ripe for violent inversion, albeit perhaps not of an Islamic flavor.
- jeffbee 1y agoI have a question. In what sense is OpenAI going to assist UAE in building large-scale data centers suitable to machine learning workloads? Do they have experience and expertise doing that?
- fakedang 1y agoThe UAE already host AWS and Azure datacenters. G42, the semi governmental company which Open AI has tied up with, has a shit ton of imported expertise in the space. They have even developed their own LLM.
- jeffbee 1y agoRight. This is my point. What is OpenAI bringing to this deal?
- fakedang 1y agoLocally hosting models. For one, bringing down costs for local usage. Open AI could then charge prices regionally for their APIs, at a discount even - further incentivizing more companies to set up in the country. There's already been a lot of speculative announcement of ChatGPT being offered to all residents in the country for free. Obviously, the big draw here is for the government to get yet another channel to monitor their citizens and residents.
- Havoc 1y agoExpertise can be bought. Think few could resist an offer of 10x current comp or whatever. If you look at the other insane shit happening in Middle East like The Line etc it’s clear that it won’t be an obstacle
- hamstergene 1y agoRemember how the central idea of Orwell's 1984 was that TVs in everyone's home were also watching all time and someone behind that device actually understanding what they see? That last part was considered dystopian: there can't possibly be enough people to watch and understand every other person all day long. Plus, who watches the watchers? 1984 has been just a scary fantasy because there is no practical way to implement it. For the first time in history, the new LLM/GenAI makes that part of 1984 finally realistic. All it takes is a GPU per household for early alerting of "dangerous thoughts", which is already feasible or will soon be. The fact that one household can be allocated only a small amount of compute, that can run only basic and poor intelligence is actually *perfect*: an AGI could at least theoretically side with the opposition by listening to the both sides and researching the big picture of events, but a one-track LLM agent has no ability to do that. I can find at least 6 companies, including OpenAI and Apple, reported working on always-watching household device, backend by the latest GenAI. Watching your whole recent life is necessary to have enough context to meaningfully assist you from a single phrase. It is also sufficient to know who you'll vote for, which protest one might attend before it's even announced, and what is the best way to intimidate you to stay out. The difference is like between a nail-driving tool and a murder weapon: both are the same hammer. During TikTok-China campaign, there were a bunch of videos showing LGBT people reporting how quickly TikTok figured their sexual preferences: without liking any videos, no following anyone, nor giving any traceable profile information at all. Sometimes before the young person has admitted that for themselves. TikTok figures that simply by seeing how long the user stares at what: spending much more time on boys' gym videos over girls', or vice versa, is already enough. I think that was used to scare people of how much China can figure about Americans from just app usage? Well if that scares anyone, how about this: an LLM-backend device can already do much more by just seeing which TV shows you watch and which parts of them give you laugh or which comments you make to the person next to you. Probably doesn't even need to be multimodal: pretty sure subtitles and text-to-speech will already do it. Your desire to oppose the upcoming authoritarian can be figured out even before you admit it to yourself. While Helen Toner (the author) is worried about democracies on the opposite end of the planet, the stronghold of democracy may as well be nearing the last 2 steps to achieve the first working implementation of Orwellian society: 1. convince everyone to have such device in their home for our own good (in progress) 2. intimidate/seize the owning company to use said devices for not our own good (TODO)
- yyyk 1y agoWelcome to the future. Increasing technical progress makes the common person much less relevant, and political power will flow to elites as a result.
- ArthurStacks 1y ago[flagged]
- AtlasBarfed 1y agoThis is the great filter upon us more than anything else, even nuclear armageddon. Virtually every "democracy" has a comprehensive camera monitoring system, tap into comm networks, have access to full social graph, whatever you buy,know all your finances, and if you take measures to hide it ... Know that you do that. Previously the fire hose information being greater than the capability of governments to process it was our saving Grace from TurnKey totalitarianism. With AI it's right there. Simple button push. And unlike nuclear weapons, it can be activated and no immediate klaxon sounds up. It can be ratcheted up like a slow boil, if they want to be nice. Oh did I forget something? Oh right. Drones! Drones everywhere. Oh wait, did I forget ANOTHER thing? Right right, everyone has mobile devices tracking their locations, with remote activatable cameras and microphones. So ... Yeah.
- timewizard 1y agoWe can generate noise. Garbage data. Huge amounts of it. The asymmetry of this tactic is massively in our favor.
- bix6 1y agoCan you? How do you spoof your bank accounts?
- komali2 1y agoNeal Stephenson seems prophetic in this sense. In "Fall," someone does exactly that - leverage what nowadays we'd call LLMs but micro ones deployable as a massive botnet, that take a given topic and vomit out unfilterable torrents of garbage about it. In the novel the POC for it is to divide the world into those that believe a small town in Utah was nuked, and those that don't. The deployment completely destroys the internet as well as a large swath of American sovereignty in its own borders, as a portion of the population becomes AI-addled ungovernable jihadists that spend half their time drooling over AI generated images and the other half crucifying heretics.
- reverius42 1y ago
- tptacek 1y agoI agree directionally with this but it drives me nuts how much special pleading there is about what high-profile companies like OpenAI do, vs. what low-profile industry giants like Cisco and Oracle have been doing for a whole generation. The analysis can't credibly start and end with what OpenAI is doing.
- kennywinker 1y ago[flagged]
- vFunct 1y ago[flagged]
- sneak 1y agoGitHub (Microsoft) supports US ICE which runs concentration camps in Texas. It works much the same everywhere.
- dralley 1y agoNot every war is genocide. Calling it genocide over and over doesn't actually make it one if it literally doesn't meet the legal definition.
- cookiengineer 1y ago[flagged]
- ipv6ipv4 1y agoEven the Irish, who can’t be accused of being pro-Israel, recognize that the genocide accusation is bunk. The Irish solution is to try to redefine the term to fit their agenda. About par for the course. https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/ireland-wants-expansion-of-the-definition-of-genocide-under-the-geneva-convention-says-taoiseach/a1112529887.html https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/ireland-wants-expansio...
- hnthrowaway0315 1y agoBasically, advancing any technology for autocrats isn't good for democracy.
- vkou 1y agoReally, doing anything for autocrats, foreign or domestic isn't good for democracy.
- twoodfin 1y agoChris Lehane’s Wikipedia page apparently hasn’t caught up with his resume: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Lehane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Lehane Fixer par excellence!
- Klaus_ 1y ago[dead]
- FilosofumRex 1y agoSan Altman's lack of scruples, notwithstanding, I find the distinction between democracies (USA, Israel, India) that oppress, occupy and murder hundred of thousands, and autocratic regimes (Saudis, China, N. Korea) who censor, imprison, or execute a few dozens of their opponents, to be a distinction without a difference.
- huevosabio 1y agoIt's also weird to call democracies countries that impose their rule over people that have no say in said rule.
- Ekaros 1y agoOr fail entirely to punish those who destroy democracies in other places... If democracy was a highest value, each time this should result in highest punishment.
- Meneth 1y agoNational sovereignty is valued above democracy, because respecting sovereignty avoids wars between nations. We assume such wars are more destructive to human well-being than the lack of democracy. That's the idea, anyway. I'm not sure how correct it is.
- eviks 1y agoHow can you expect to see any difference if you ignore the difference? > few dozens of their opponents Why did you ignore the censored/oppressed billions of people living there?
- fakedang 1y agoI'm pretty sure at least a third of the Chinese (more than the population of the US), aren't looking at the US right now and saying, "Yeah, we want some of that."
- maxlin 1y agoBetter do business with UAE and reap the benefits, than let the benefits eventually go to China. Trying to forever suppress the middle east obviously hasn't worked, so this is just realpolitik with the obvious right choice being what is being done now imho. Saudis are gonna be autocratic in any case, this is just good Hearts of Iron gameplay in real life.
- int_19h 1y agoWhat are the benefits? The downsides are obvious: we're effectively arming people whose worldview is fundamentally incompatible with ours and who are, at most, allies of convenience right now, and with no guarantee that anything we'll give to them won't end up resold to China anyway (indeed, given that those regimes are notoriously corrupt, I think that's virtually a certainly).
- maxlin 1y ago>What are the benefits? It's good business. I'd assume you know what the benefits of that are. >The downsides are <snip> So, less bad than the alternative. The only real danger would be them selling the GPU's to China, but that'd be so short-sighted by them and cut short so its not really that much of an issue, and would be barely worse than the other option that'd come by default. Hell, if you learn from Russia's isolation, to a degree making the Chinese reliant on NVIDIA could even slow them down as they'd not be as pressured to advance domestic technology. Also, using terms like "arming" here is hardly fair.
- root_axis 1y agoI appreciate that people are thinking about these things, but I still can't take the idea seriously that transformers represent a threat to democracy. Maybe with a massive enough supercomputer a country could run an AI IDE capable of end-to-end writing a device driver in Rust - but even that's not a given. Certainly, it's almost meaningless in the face of building our lives around a network of personal surveillance devices that we literally never part with. I'm just saying... ChatGPT is the least of our problems.
- jasonfarnon 1y agoWell do you think that social media could be a threat to democracy, as many have asserted, e.g., cambridge analytica, the US disinformation bureau etc? (Likewise that social media could be a threat to autocracy?) You don't see LLMs' impact on culture and society being at least as broad and thorough?
- root_axis 1y ago> Well do you think that social media could be a threat to democracy Yes, I certainly agree that it is and recognize all your examples. > You don't see LLMs' impact on culture and society being at least as broad and thorough? In the sense I think you're implying, I see them as having almost zero impact. Just because more crap is generated doesn't mean it's going to be more believable, or that it will even be seen. How many tokens do you think it would take a SOTA model to convince you that the earth is flat or that the moon-landing was a hoax? Do you think Trump supporters will start voting for Democrats if they see 100 anti-Trump posts in every comment section on the internet? The LLM isn't going to generate anything that we haven't all heard already.
- TheOtherHobbes 1y agoWith enough money, you absolutely could persuade Trump voters to vote for Democrats. This isn't up for debate. PR and advertising exist because this is absolutely possible, and has been for a long time. AI makes it much, much easier and more cost-effective. This was how Cambridge Analytica and Facebook swung the Brexit vote. They didn't send out blanket "EU bad, vote Brexit" content. They created targeted ads that addressed hot-button fear points for individuals and niche demographics and used Facebook's ad targetting system to deliver them. So some people were concerned about money for the UK's health system. They saw ads promising that Brexit would mean more money for the NHS. Others were concerned about potholes, or education, or - often - immigration. Every group saw ads that triggered their personal hot-button issues and persuaded them to vote against their interests.
- npn 1y agoI'm just here to remind all of you that US democracy is a terror for the whole world. You have already killed ten millions people and you still do not have enough? How much bloodthirsty you are?
- aussieguy1234 1y ago- Dictator builds AI to help control the humans - AI realizes it doesn't need the dictator anymore - AI is now the dictator
- p0w3n3d 1y agoI would say that implication is in the opposite direction. Any sufficiently high-profile technology can turn any government autocratic/totalitarian. It's like a greatest temptation for people in power to have everything under control, which gives birth to horrible country and people governance
- ghushn3 1y agoBuilding anything for autocrats probably isn't good for democracy, tbh. If you want democracy to be healthy, you probably want to maximize the amount of wealth of the working class. People who have enough to care for themselves and their families and their communities a little will have enough time and education to meaningfully participate in democracy. Whether you are building for US autocrats, gulf state autocrats, Russian autocrats, whatever... maybe it's better to not do that? (I know, easier said than done.)
- fakedang 1y agoYour statements are kinda unrelated? Or what do you mean by participating in democracy, in autocracies? Ironically, I see a lot more leaning towards dystopian tendencies in the West, mostly the US, as technology advances to the point of singularity (or near singularity, where most low and midskilled jobs are automated away). Meanwhile these autocratic countries have had strong welfare systems for their citizens and increasingly now their residents, since God knows when, and are well positioned to reap the benefits of an AI boom, given their smaller population sizes.
- avazhi 1y ago[flagged]
- kochbeck 1y agoI’m just going to leave this here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust
- seydor 1y agoIt's not about democracy in the middle east at all. China is more democratic than those countries. It's about containing china s rise as it grows to be a direct rival to the US Western hegemony . That would be an affront to democracy
- Slava_Propanei 1y ago[dead]
- thwoerjwelkrjw 1y ago[flagged]
- snickerbockers 1y agoReally, the protestant are taliban? did the Catholic Church never wage jihads and inquisitions? Were the protestants the ones going apeshit over the heliocentric model?
- p_l 1y agoIt's more a reference to "sola scriptura" and the dismissal of scientific thought related to it. Similar movement happened, with way more success, in Islamic world AFAIK. And yes, protestants were actually going more apeshit about heliocentrism than catholic church. The preface "explaining away" heliocentrism as just mathematical device instead of description of reality was by lutheran theologian, the catholic church being big patron of astronomy at the time. It was mathematicians and astronomers who were against heliocentric model who were "expert witness" for inquisition, and despite their arguments the only thing inquisition struck was pieces about theology. Galileo got slammed originally for claiming his work as established fact, and the further problems were more political in nature when he attacked pope in his next book and alienated his previous supporters. Not great, not terrible, honestly pretty good outcome for the time period.
- snickerbockers 1y agoSola scriptura was primarily a rejection of all Catholic theology outside of the Bible; I've never heard of it being applied to subjects outside of the Bible but I'll admit I'm uneducated in this aspect as my knowledge of protestantism relates primarily to modern protestantism and I don't know that much about the history of the religion. >The preface "explaining away" heliocentrism as just mathematical device instead of description of reality Isn't that actually the way newtonian mechanics describes all motion? using earth as your frame of reference creates needless complexity when you have to describe how the other planets move since obviously the sun's gravity is the dominant force but it's ultimately just a change of coordinates. You can put your fixed reference anywhere you want and some places are better than others but there aren't any hard rules. Anyways I'd never argue that the protestants haven't committed their share of oppression against Catholics, Jews, Islam, rational thought, gays, etc because they definitely have and in many instances still do. I just find it bizarre that they're the taliban in this analogy and not the Catholic Church, because the primary contention between the Catholics and protestants that drove the reformation was a rejection of the church's claim to divine authority, and it only really became a separate religion when the Pope excommunicated Martin Luther and supposedly condemned him to hell.
- snickerbockers 1y agoI have a bit of a problem with TFA's implication that Western countries don't do the exact same things but to a lesser degree. We need to get over this dumb eurocentric idea that we have the best system of government and the entire world suffers for the lack of it. I'm reminded of back in the "Arab spring" when journalists and politicians were praising social media as a "democratizing force" only to clamp down on free speech with the "mis/dis/malinformation" slander about 5 years later.
- iDon 1y agoThe article asks what is the meaning of OpenAI's statement that "the UAE will become the first country in the world to enable ChatGPT nationwide." My first guess would be that it will be a geo-fenced service, in particular UAE residents will have (subsidised) access to it and perhaps not to the global service, and it will have a system prompt designed and tuned in consultation with the UAE government.
- amai 1y agoAny business with autocrats and dictators should be forbidden. The first 100 countries on this list https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economist_Democracy_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economist_Democracy_Index you can do business with. If you do business with the rest you will just strengthen inhumane regimes, which unfortunately not only kill their own people, but these regimes also attack their neigbors (see Ukraine and maybe soon Taiwan). Money does stink!
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago>Any business with autocrats and dictators should be forbidden. If that after the top 100 countries on that list made money trading with the rest, or before? A lot of the wealth in first world countries is build on exploiting the corruption in developing countries. That's why the incentive for them to stay corrupt, as long as they play ball with the western powers and sell their resources and peoples' labor for cheap to western companies.
- lonelyasacloud 1y agoHow likely are believers in Super AGI for the good of the human race to be worried about downsides of enabling them for dodgy regimes in the short term?
- adolph 1y agoBecause of this, I agree that it is a very good thing for the US to have more AI compute, including more AI supercomputers, than China. But if you take this argument seriously at all, the implication of the UAE deal becomes plain: this is a significant power boost for the UAE’s autocratic government. This is a wonderful exposition of how Realpolitik allows one can have an anti-autocracy cake and eat it too.
- jrochkind1 1y agoRemember when OpenAI was a non-profit claiming to be dedicated to public good?
- eggy 1y agoI spent 6 months in Saudi in 2022 and 2 months in 2023, and I went to the UAE and did business with both countries. They've been on this wave like the world has. The UAE mandated AI education in their schools, are acquiring and training talent, and have huge, huge amounts of money invested in developing on all fronts from education to engineering to application for their 2031 initiative. The AI genie is out of the bottle, and although OpenAI is a hybrid non-profit / for-profit company in that they have for-profit LLCs that are managed by the non-profit, so this gets murky. See OpenAI Holdings, LLC and OpenAI Global, LLC. I don't think you can monopolize technology such as AI when computing hardware is expanding in capability and cost is going down as well as the immediate ability to read research papers, YouTube videos, books, and all media available on the internet or other media venues. The Saudi Digital Library in the largest digital library in the Arab world. Is China's AI better than the West's? They've certaily implemented a lot of real world installations and applications of it, but I am not sure how it compares to the NSA pre and post Snowden.
- nojvek 1y agoOpenAI, Grok, Gemini, Anthropic are all cut of same cloth no? Closed AI to serve their corporate shareholders and respective governments. There is no deeper altruistic move here. It's capitalism at it's best or worse, depending on the observer.
- rollcat 1y agoOne word: Dehomag
- aaroninsf 1y agoYes, crappy anti-social anti-commons anti-democratic supercomputing has more or less literally fueled the long tech boom, for decades now. But that is not the issue right now. Right now, the issue is that the power of ubiquitous surveillance crossed with contemporary compute is unprecedented and new. LA is burning and the National Guard has been called on protestors over the Governor's objections. The fate of the nation and by extension the first world is what's at stake here.
- nis0s 1y agoA sizable population of the US voted for Trump to address the issue of illegal immigration. People who keep denying the reality of other people’s views which aren’t aligned with their own cannot be taken seriously, especially when they’re talking about democracy. Your political opponents winning democratically and enacting their agenda, is not an autocracy.