7 ms·
Meta: Shut down your invasive AI Discover feed
- iambateman 1y agoThis sounds like a big deal but could we get more details from Mozilla? An example? A screenshot? I don’t understand, after reading, when this is happening or how.
- JimDabell 1y agoIt does a terrible job of explaining (in fact it doesn’t even attempt to!), but I think it’s related to Meta’s new “AI social media app”: https://about.fb.com/news/2025/04/introducing-meta-ai-app-new-way-access-ai-assistant/ https://about.fb.com/news/2025/04/introducing-meta-ai-app-ne... I heard that some people are using the AI in it without realising that they are sharing their prompts publicly.
- charcircuit 1y ago>And as always, you’re in control: nothing is shared to your feed unless you choose to post it. You have to explicitly hit a share and post button in order to post to your feed.
- JoBrad 1y agoTo be fair, Meta has a history of pushing people towards sharing when they wouldn’t otherwise do so. Doesn’t explain the petition’s wording, which suggests interactions are public by default.
- marcellus23 1y agoIt's still a problem they should fix (clearly they're not making it obvious enough that you're making your chat public), but that hardly fits Mozilla's accusation of "quietly turning private AI chats into public content." Disclaimer that I have not seen the UI, maybe it's much more misleading than it sounds.
- jonny_eh 1y agoBut Mozilla isn't showing the supposedly problematic flow. Where, exactly, are things going wrong? Show an example?
- vini 1y agoSame, here's some context: "Meta’s rollout of social features in its stand-alone AI app, released last week. Those quiet queries — “What’s this embarrassing rash?” or “How can I tell my wife I don’t love her anymore?” — could soon be visible to anyone scrolling through the app’s Discover tab." https://www.fastcompany.com/91327812/metas-ai-social-feed-is-a-privacy-disaster-waiting-to-happen https://www.fastcompany.com/91327812/metas-ai-social-feed-is...
- ot 1y ago> While the company insists that “nothing is shared unless you choose to post it,” the app nonetheless nudges people to share—and overshare—whether they fully realize it or not.
- AlienRobot 1y ago[flagged]
- Sanzig 1y agoWhile I am happy Mozilla is still going after privacy disasters like Meta, it does ring a little hollow after the Firefox terms of use change and subsequent back pedaling [1]. [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2025/02/firefox-deletes-promise-to-never-sell-personal-data-asks-users-not-to-panic/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2025/02/firefox-deletes-...
- DeepYogurt 1y agoReally just get off meta platforms
- kennywinker 1y agoNetwork effects have most people stuck on at least one of them. If all your friends use instagram/fb/whatsapp to keep in touch / make plans, leaving the platform is akin to cutting ties with your community. Which is why there is a role for gov in regulating privacy and mandating interop between platforms. Asking people to “just stop using them” isn’t a realistic ask.
- 8fingerlouie 1y agoBesides that, pretty much everything “after school” is being arranged over Facebook, as well as community “blogs”, newsletters etc. Facebook solves this problem extremely well. I still remember the “good old days” of poorly managed Wordpress sites, shared Google calendars, mailing lists, and texts, and I’m not particularly keen on going back to that. The sad truth is that there is nothing on the market today that solves this problem in a combined package, and you can add discoverability to the mix. If you’re interested in X you can search for it on Facebook and 9/10 times you’ll find what you’re looking for, from menus for restaurants to opening hours. Yes, Google does this as well but somehow people (here) are more aware of the feature on Facebook.
- rel_ic 1y agoYeah, it's a tradeoff. I don't mean to be glib, but on one side we have a loneliness epidemic, mass misinformation campaigns, and centralized control, and on the other side we have better information about restaurants, easier after-school arrangements, and community blogs. I really don't mean to say that the benefits are not real benefits - they are! I just think their price is way too high.
- a57721 1y agoI would rather prefer the good old days with wonky WordPress sites and mailing lists. It is true that most business owners moved to Facebook at some point, but the price to pay is having all content undiscoverable and inaccessible, unless your user has a Facebook account.
- thih9 1y agoContext: - “Meta has a new stand-alone AI app. It lets you see what other people are asking.” https://www.businessinsider.com/meta-ai-app-public-feed-warning-how-2025-05?IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/meta-ai-app-public-feed-warn... (may 2025) - “People are seemingly accidentally publishing their AI chat histories with Meta’s new AI app” https://www.crikey.com.au/2025/05/05/meta-ai-chatbot-discover-feed-public-accident-publish/ https://www.crikey.com.au/2025/05/05/meta-ai-chatbot-discove... (may 2025) Note that the first link states that conversations are private by default and that user error is likely involved[1]. Mozilla’s use of text emphasis almost implies otherwise[2]. [1]: “To be clear, your AI chats are not public by default — you have to choose to share them individually by tapping a share button. Even so, I get the sense that some people don't really understand what they're sharing, or what's going on.” [2]: At least that’s how I understood “_Make all AI interactions private by default_ with no public sharing option unless explicitly enabled through informed consent.” at first glance.
- plasma_beam 1y agoIt blows my mind how many people still publicly post venmo payments, so this doesn’t surprise me actually.
- laweijfmvo 1y agowhy venmo even has a "feed" is unknown to me. are people actually doom scrolling that?
- triceratops 1y agoIf it's there people will use it like social media. "Ooh looks like Adrian went to La Bamba with Chilliwack, he paid them $50 for drinks there"
- 0xEF 1y agoEngagement. It's part of a dark pattern that triggers that little neuron tie our tendency to compare ourselves to others, a sort of "keeping up with the Joneses" type thing. It is also billed as a free advertising for businesses (e.g. hey, look where your friends shop!) which encourages more businesses to accept Venmo as a payment method. Anything for the sake of growth or perceived growth, up to and including privacy violations.
- joshstrange 1y agoMozilla, come on. WTH is the "AI Discover Feed"? Can you link to something? Show a video? Post an image? This entire page assumed you know everything about it, assumes you know about some kind of issue involving private chats leaking, and assumes it's been proven they training on private chats. I'm not interested in trusting Meta at all and I can completely believe they are doing something horrible but this page doesn't give even 1/10th of the information needed.
- bluSCALE4 1y ago[flagged]
- zoklet-enjoyer 1y agoSo like do if I buy the Meta Ray-Bans will my pictures and stuff be posted for everyone to see or is this an opt-in type thing?
- georgeecollins 1y agoThe sad thing is if they told you they wouldn't I am not sure I would trust it. People think this is about giving away embarrassing information. Think if you are using AI to explain a contract, explore a business deal, etc. The sensitive information could be very valuable.
- mgraczyk 1y agoMeta has never accidentally shared private photos. I don't see any reason to believe this would happen
- animanoir 1y ago[dead]
- bluSCALE4 1y agoWho in their right mind would trust fb with AI questions?
- SoftTalker 1y agoJust assume that every interaction you have with Meta will be public. Because it will be, either accidentally or if they think they can make an extra dollar by selling it. And behave accordingly.
- School-Cotton 1y agoAfter 10+ years of using Messenger daily, my chats still have not become public. I agree there are huge privacy concerns with meta, but hyperbole that anyone can immediately see is false isn’t the right way to convince people.
- kyle-rb 1y agoMessenger is also the only one of Meta's apps that I still use regularly and I was pleasantly surprised with their decision to roll out E2E encryption by default. https://about.fb.com/news/2023/12/default-end-to-end-encryption-on-messenger/ https://about.fb.com/news/2023/12/default-end-to-end-encrypt...
- lcfcjs6 1y ago[dead]
- pests 1y agoIt’s probably beyond your 10 year cutoff, but back when Messenger was still just an email inbox on Facebook and the Timeline was all the rage, I do remember a message leak. For some period of time, if you scrolled back far enough in someone’s Timeline you would begin to see their messages as posts in the feed.
- barbazoo 1y agoDo you know though that they haven't been accessed/used/sold? Chances I would say are much higher compared to Signal, Telegram, etc.
- School-Cotton 1y ago
- dmos62 1y agoThe punctuation in "Meta: shut down [...]" implies that meta is saying "shut down". It should be a comma, as in "Meta, shut down your [...]".
- fastball 1y agoShould probably be: "Dear Meta: ..."
- Izkata 1y agoColon was how you'd get someone's attention in old chat apps. For example IRC clients that tab-complete nicknames would automatically add it if the input started with the nickname.
- dmos62 1y agoInteresting point. Then today it could be "@Meta shut [...]".
- gs17 1y agoOf course, but then it reads like Meta shut down my invasive AI Discover Feed if I didn't realize what the @ meant. Really, the best solution is a comma after Meta instead of a colon, so it's clearly a command at Meta, like you said.
- woah 1y agoMeta: Shut down. You're invasive. (AI Discover feed)
- Drew_ 1y agoMozilla should be more focused on figuring out how to actually make money and not this sensationalist stuff. Depending on how the Google case lands, they're finished.
- __loam 1y agoMeta should be more focused on not being massive ass holes and not this invasive shit. Depending on how their own anti-trust suit lands, public society might decide to break them up out of spite.
- zer0zzz 1y agoYeah that’s not going to happen. They’re going to be building weaponry for the government soon.
- __loam 1y agoIs that why there's an ongoing anti-trust case against them?
- platevoltage 1y agoThere is one reason and one reason alone that this case is still ongoing. Mark's financial contributions, character change, and makeover weren't enough to make nice nice with the man in charge.
- Xunjin 1y agoGoing to be fair, when Mozilla focuses on new products to try to make money, people complain and tell them to focus on the browser because it's bad (it's not).
- serf 1y agono, people tell them to focus on the browser because the majority of features added in the past 15 years are either incredibly flavored (here's your new AI tab!) , or they're profit-seeking motivated (we're proud to present our new collaboration with Pocket (tm) (c), P.S. welcome to your new hompeage with cookies and sponsored assets. ) The major reason Firefox has a large market share is simply because Google is that much more abusive to users -- and that's not a great reason.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- drillsteps5 1y agoI mean... People are willingly sending their data to another computer operated and fully owned by another entity, and then take offense when that other entity does what it wants with that data (which I'm pretty sure is allowed according to their incredibly/intentionally vague T&Cs). What exactly are they complaining about?..
- thuanao 1y agoMozilla: Stop lying. Now.
- lcfcjs6 1y ago[dead]
- platevoltage 1y agoabout what?
- thuanao 1y agoThey don't share chats with others unless you click the "Share" button to share the chats. They are private by default. It's basically the same as every other AI chat app.
- djaychela 1y agoDear mozilla (actually loads of Web debs) Make your website strip trailing spaces off autofillled emails instead of saying they are invalid. It's really not hard, I can manage it.
- throwaway314155 1y agoSeriously? That's your complaint? You pasted in an email with a space in it (somehow on purpose?) and rather than just hitting backspace once you had too make a mostly irrelevant comment about it?
- clarkmoreno 1y agolmao
- haolez 1y agoI wonder what chain of events led to this design in the PM's mind.
- mgraczyk 1y agoAfter trying the app, it's hard for me to interpret this article as anything other than Mozilla lying. Sharing in this app is the same as any other social media app. In the app there is a "Share" button at the top right. After clicking you see an interstitial with a big "Post" button at the bottom. When you click that button, the chat is shared. Am I seeing something different than anybody else? Why would Mozilla lie like this? Most of the "demands" are already satisfied. > Shut down the Discover feed until real privacy protections are in place. Everything is already private by default and you can see what is public. > Make all AI interactions private by default with no public sharing option unless explicitly enabled through informed consent. This is true already > Provide full transparency about how many users have unknowingly shared private information. Meta shouldn't have to do this > Create a universal, easy-to-use opt-out system for all Meta platforms that prevents user data from being used for AI training. This already exists (EDIT, looks like only for EU users. Personally I don't believe this is related to the public sharing claims) > Notify all users whose conversations may have been made public, and allow them to delete their content permanently. This already exists
- JoshTriplett 1y agoThis is a dark-pattern problem. A large number of people are accidentally sharing things to the general public when they intended to share them to specific people. That is one issue being flagged here. To many people, "share" means "give me a way to share to specific people", not "mark this for indexing/searching for the general public".
- hanspeter 1y agoI don't think this is a dark-pattern problem in the sense that I don't think it is _intentionally_ deceiving. I think Meta fully expected this feature to be used by people who are excited about their conversation with the AI and wants to share it publicly. Just like we see with OpenAI Sora. There's not much to win for Meta if users instead are unknowingly sharing deeply personal conversations.
- HelloMcFly 1y ago
- udev4096 1y ago> I’m okay with Mozilla handling my info as explained in this Privacy Notice. The irony by making that checkbox mandatory for submitting a privacy protest form
- paxys 1y agoA social media company made an AI app that lets users share its results to social media. Shocker! But sure lets write an article with zero details and just the right amount of buzzwords and engagement bait that it’ll make it to the top of HN and sustain today’s outrage cycle. We’ll go back to “Google is bad” tomorrow.
- gojomo 1y agoLacks context & examples to know what they're concerned about. Has a righteous, bossy tone that doesn't seem earned by case particulars or its (anonymous) author. "Mozilla: Improve your messaging. Now."
- brap 1y ago>"Mozilla: Improve your messaging. Now." That was the first thing I saw. It was so bad I wanted to leave immediately. Dead givaway. My bullshit senses were tingling, but it got so many points on HN so I had to read the rest. I wasn’t wrong.
- hedayet 1y agoDon't touch anything that comes out of Facebook. There, it's that simple. Facebook and its people can't be trusted <period>
- RadiozRadioz 1y agoWhy does this website not work correctly on FireFox Mobile? Good lord Mozilla, sort yourself out. (The viewport only covers 1/4 of my phone screen and I can scroll it around in the black abyss)
- pluc 1y agoStop asking and expecting a private for-profit corporation to do what you want or what you think is right. They are not there to serve you, they exist to profit off of you. Delete your account if you're unhappy with the service or the ethics.
- boroboro4 1y agoMozilla post is quite bad at explaining what's wrong so I went to Meta AI app to try it myself: - When you have a chat it has "Share" button - When you click on the button it shows you a draft of the chat with "Post" button - Clicking on the "Post" publishes the chat to public and sends you to "Discover" tab - From published chat you can click on "send" icon to send link to the chat to someone else IMO it is in fact dark pattern and goes against of how people perceive "Share" action. The fact you can't share without making chat public is also not cool. For example top discover post I see right now is stylized picture of a baby, with original photo available if you open the post. I'm pretty sure the person who posted it was trying to share the picture with their relatives/friends. Overall: Meta at its "best", better to say sorry rather than ask for permission...
- lo0dot0 1y agoIf you are unsure what you are doing, do not do it. For example, I just posted to hackernews. The button in my app says "submit", but doesn't warn me about posting to the internet. Is there any problem with that? No, because I know what I'm doing and anyone using the Internet should too.
- alanbernstein 1y agoThe nature of "being unsure" often inherently precludes being aware of that unsureness. Some companies are well known to exploit this basic fact of existence.
- soulofmischief 1y agoLet's not pretend that context doesn't matter, including the average technical proficiency of the intended audience, or the fact that HN's conventions are recognizable to people who have grown up with Usenet, BBS, forums, aggregators, etc. That is not the case here.
- lo0dot0 1y agoYou don't need context there is terms and services that no one reads
- HenryBemis 1y agoIn all seriousness, who expects and decency, privacy, respect (of human rights) from the makers of Myanmar flame-fanning, the scum who allowed/facilitates Cambridge Analytica (and the likes), to name but a few? Perhaps Zuck wants to look like a good tech-bro by smiling at Joe Rogan and advertise "I am one of you guys, I too do BJJ", but in his soul he is a filthy snake who lies all the time ("FBI forced me and I railroaded you but 3 years later I come clean").. "...it's my nature, said the scorpion."
- hsuduebc2 1y agoYes please. It's invasive garbage. When I click "uninterested" on ukraine war news I immediately got russian propaganda. When I do it again I get back Ukrainian news. I just dont want to see it. Same with politics. It's just switching sides which it shows when I click hide but I cant hide the theme as a whole. I recommend this extension. It blocks this ridiculous bullshit. https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/undistracted-hide-faceboo/pjjgklgkfeoeiebjogplpnibpfnffkng?hl=en https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/undistracted-hide-f...
- guluarte 1y agoyep https://www.meta.ai/@halcon5555/prompt/jg3cmKxENMh https://www.meta.ai/@halcon5555/prompt/jg3cmKxENMh
- dmix 1y agoWhy doesn't Mozilla provide any specific context?
- LoganDark 1y agoI so don't understand why everyone's been taking the bait and calling this company Meta. I guess because the restructuring was intentional by Facebook for manipulation purposes (everyone mistrusted Facebook at that point and they needed a new identity in order to try to gain people's trust again), while Google doesn't really use Alphabet as a front because they seemingly don't care if people know them as evil. I very commonly see things like Google acquires this, Google acquires that, even in cases where the acquirer is actually Alphabet, but I almost never see anything about Facebook, because everyone's now calling them Meta. Maybe I'm fighting a losing battle at this point, but I will never forget their past actions nor malicious intentions just because they tried to change their name. I know the brand "Facebook" still exists for the social network, but Meta is still Facebook at its core. Same people, same values, same data harvesting. They're just using other methods to get at your data, abusing trust that maybe people wouldn't have given to Facebook if the name change hadn't occurred. I think I must feel a little bit like Louis Rossmann must've felt when Time Warner Cable changed their name to Comcast. He still holds all of their former misdeeds against them and I think it's a real shame that more people don't do that for Facebook. Sure in plenty of people's minds Meta is still its own entire dystopia and a half, but it still feels to me like they've all forgotten the precedent that Facebook set all the way back when that name was the one they put on their dystopia.
- axus 1y agoTo me, Facebook is the service I use as login credentials on McDonalds app and other companies, separate from my offline and online identities. Also it is a social network I don't engage with. Owned by Meta. WhatsApp is a chat program I use almost every day. Owned by Meta. Oculus was a brand of VR goggles, but now the brand name is Meta. Owned by Meta.
- LoganDark 1y agoTo me, Facebook is something I deleted around 2013. Never saw any real reason to create another account, honestly saw so many reasons not to. WhatsApp is something I only use in a strict sandbox to communicate with certain Chinese sellers, as well as one friend who sometimes can't use Discord/Telegram. Oculus used to be usable offline, wired and without an account, but now requires to be logged into an account ever since Facebook acquired it (as Meta). So my first headset was an HP Reverb G2. Also, since 'VR goggles' are starting to genuinely be a thing (see Bigscreen Beyond, or probably more the Ray-Ban stuff and the other stuff starting to pop up in that category), the more general term that the Oculus Rift counts as would be HMD (head-mounted display).
- Aeolun 1y agoKinda funny how they get upset at this, but not at the recent court order to preserve all chat history with ChatGPT.
- CGamesPlay 1y agoTo be fair, in this one Meta is intentionally publishing these on their front page, while OpenAI is subject to a legally mandated retention policy pursuant to an ongoing lawsuit. While I think both are problematic, the Meta one seems much more underhanded.
- spopejoy 1y agoI don't understand the outrage about the court order and chatgpt. Is user data retained by a tech co somehow exempt from discovery? Say you're suing a company over mishandling user data, wouldn't that data become material to the case?
- alex1138 1y agoOk so this comment section is 'appropriately' (really, guys? Listen to Mozilla) derisive Bear in mind Meta/Facebook/Zuckerbook is the same company that's always employed dark patterns to get you to unwittingly share more
- tacker2000 1y agoWhy are they getting worked up about THIS issue in particular? Meta is doing tons of other really shady stuff along with Google, MS, etc. Are Mozilla they now the privacy guardians? This seems so weird. Who is even using the Meta AI app? They should be doing a petition about the Meta AI stuff thats happening in Whatsapp now.
- CafeRacer 1y agoI mean if you're using meta, x or whatever 'free' apps, you're the product. I am not sure why anyone would he surprised at this point. The article really reads like as if Mozilla just wants attention.
- isaacremuant 1y agoSays the company that recently changed "we don't sell your data" in the terms. How about you make a good browser (it's great) and you leave the political righteousness out? I remember when you ousted Brendan Eich unjustly. I remember when you came in favor of censorship for "safety". I love the browser for its customization but the people at the company who write these things tend to be quite delusional and damaging to the brand and product.
- rob_c 1y agoComing from the company that "owns" everything you type into the browser, except maybe you the user miss read that... Go away Mozilla, so trying to wade into a new sector and virtue signal.
- g0db1t 1y ago[dead]
- cykros 1y agoGood luck with the protests; we protested when they brought the newsfeed in in the first place, and it was quite an uproar. You can see how well that panned out. Deleting my Facebook as a gift to myself in 2013 was one of the better Christmas presents I ever got.
- stephenlindauer 1y agoAt this point, if you're using any Meta product, that's on you.