8 ms·
Cursor hits $9B valuation
- brianbreslin 2y agoDoes this fundraising only make sense if cursor is planning to jump into the infrastructure side too? To do application hosting layer like Replit.
- karel-3d 2y agoit's vscode with chatgpt
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/yQlLu https://archive.ph/yQlLu
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kurtis_reed 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hhghkj 2y agoQuite a valuation for a VSCode fork. They have no moat.
- raffraffraff 2y agoIt's a rented castle, too.
- enlightens 2y agoIndeed. "DID YOU JUST BAN CURSOR?" https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-dotnettools/issues/1909 https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-dotnettools/issues/1909 > The error seems very clear to me. Dev Kit is licensed only for use with VS Code, Cursor is not VS Code, ergo it is not licensed to use it. > > Not to mention that only VS Code can use the official plugin registry in the first place. Everything working as intended.
- Keyframe 2y agoAh, good old Microsoft.
- rvz 2y agoExactly. From: [0] >> I know it works as intended. Just curios why Microsoft decided to enforce this all of a sudden. Because they can. Also... >> Did GitHub Copilot just give up on playing fair with Cursor, admitting it's winning? The game wasn't 'fair' to begin with and it was rigged for Microsoft to win anyway. (Cursor being based on VS Code). If you're competing against Microsoft, expect them to race you to zero for years (extinguish) at close to no cost for them. It is all for Cursor to lose if they continue as they are and competitors like Microsoft catch up (and they will do so very quickly whilst lowering prices). [0] https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-dotnettools/issues/1909#issuecomment-2784776197 https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-dotnettools/issues/1909#...
- UncleOxidant 2y agoMore like a squatted castle.
- wordpad 2y agoTheir user base is the moat. Same as any network effect business. If all your peers are using a thing, it's really hard to convince entire industry to switch even if something better is available.
- PUSH_AX 2y agoThat’s not a moat when it comes to tooling like this, I can and will cancel my sub when I try something objectively better, there is zero lock in, even if I make a poor choice I can come back. This is not a moat, the fact there are a bunch of companies hot on their heels proves this too.
- madeofpalk 2y agoI don't think user base is a moat, at least not for tooling like this. Switching costs is practically zero, as evidence by how quickly Cursor came up and ate Copilot's lunch. Presumably all of Cursor's users switched away from VS Code or another editor. How did that moat go for them?
- Lalabadie 2y agoEarly adopters are the most fickle version of a user moat I can imagine.
- notfromhere 2y agoWe're talking about an IDE, switching is pretty frictionless.
- solarkraft 2y agoWell, switching IDEs can actually be hard due to all the integrations. But this is VScode to VSCode …
- wrs 2y agoNetwork effect? What network?
- notnullorvoid 2y ago
- kcatskcolbdi 2y agoI want to agree, but whatever they are doing is working incredibly well so far. The results I get from cursor outweigh what I can get from Copilot by orders of magnitude. Maybe long term there's no moat, but you'd think if there were no moat now the folks at Microsoft would be able to compete.
- 0x500x79 2y agoThis is something that I think Copilot is working on fixing actively. I think that they were focused on Agent mode previously, so put less effort into the autocomplete functionality but they are hearing more and more that this is somewhere they need to focus.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- owendarko 2y agoThere are already VS Code extensions (Cline, Roo Code and Kilo Code) that do the same + are much better IMO. Disclaimer: I'm one of the maintainers of Kilo.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CyberMacGyver 2y agoDidn’t they reject $20B from OpenAI? This seems like a 50% haircut.
- Zealotux 2y agoI use both and I'm amazed at how poor the VSCode proposal is compared to Cursor.
- moduspol 2y agoI mean... it's a little disingenuous to call it a "vibe coding" app.
- be_erik 2y agoIt’s how a lot of code is being generated by owners of small startups with minimal engineering engagement. PMs are producing full walking skeletons of designs that used to take a week to polish to that fidelity.
- moduspol 2y agoSure--but it's also the most widely used IDE for integrated AI assistance to normal software engineers. It's a "vibe coding" app in the same way that a washing machine is a "sock cleaning machine." I mean, yes, it does that, but that's a small part of its designed and in-practice usage.
- fkyoureadthedoc 2y ago> but it's also the most widely used IDE for integrated AI assistance to normal software engineers. Is it? I'd be surprised if GitHub Copilot didn't have more paid users.
- zknowledge 2y agoWow, AI 'vibe coding' app? What a reductive statement on what Cursor is.
- bluefirebrand 2y agoSeems about right to me Are you sure you don't have a very inflated idea about what Cursor is?
- PUSH_AX 2y agoThis is like saying cars are for doing skids and speeding illegally, then telling the person who drives for a living if they “don’t have a very inflated idea about what a car is”. Vibe coding is letting the AI take the wheel for every decision, not verifying output, progress above all. Of course it’s possible to use it in a more subtle collaborative capacity with heavy oversight.
- zknowledge 2y agoI doubt it. Cursor is an IDE with an ai co-pilot deeply integrated into it. They've literally changed the paradigm of software development by making ai-assisted coding feasible. The vibe-coding mention is reductive imo. Another way of looking at it: Maker of "pricey electronic typewriter", Apple hits $9B valuation (FT 1984) pretty reductive
- lostmsu 2y agoAre they different from Copilot though? I mean I tried C# integration and Cursor does not even fix all compilation errors before reporting it has "completed the task". Feels like that's the most basic integration you can have beyond reviewing diffs.
- zknowledge 2y agoThat's a fair question and point. I'm not die-hard Cursor fan. Use what works best for you, but I'm just more so commenting that the vibe-coding part totally minimizes what the offering is.
- bethekidyouwant 2y ago9B, no moat, it’s bubble time!
- url00 2y agoOn the off chance there was any doubt still... Alas, seeing a bubble provides almost no good information except that you know something bad will happen sometime.
- spacemadness 2y agoThat sometime will be when reality sinks in regarding revenue, but by then some of the original investors have made their money and split.
- riku_iki 2y agothey have userbase, revenue, super-fast growth, leading market position and capable team.
- disgruntledphd2 2y agoYup, but good unit economics are what matters in the long run.
- rvz 2y agoExcept that there is one problem and that is Microsoft GitHub who has a much more massive platform (220m+ users), distribution and ecosystem lock-in which Cursor does not have. Things can change very quickly in 6 - 12 months.
- riku_iki 2y agothere is no lock in on github, since communication happens through git protocol, so no external tool/client can be locked out.
- 2y ago
- danenania 2y agoIf you're using Cursor (as I do), but find it tends to struggle once your project reaches a certain size, and you're ok with something CLI-based, you might find the open source CLI coding agent I've built interesting: https://github.com/plandex-ai/plandex https://github.com/plandex-ai/plandex - It can handle up to 2M tokens of context directly, and can index/work with/chat with projects up to 20M tokens (1M+ lines). Here's an example of chatting with with SQLite codebase to learn about how transactions are implemented: https://plandex.ai/_next/static/media/plandex-sqlite.0ee6cb28.gif https://plandex.ai/_next/static/media/plandex-sqlite.0ee6cb2... - All changes are committed to a version-controlled sandbox by default, preventing the problem of stray changes that you don't notice being left behind in the project. - Being terminal-based allows for more seamless and powerful execution control and automated debugging. Here's an example of automatically debugging a browser app (via redirection of console logs/errors to the terminal): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-_76U_nK0Y&embeds_referring_euri=https%3A%2F%2Fplandex.ai%2F https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-_76U_nK0Y&embeds_referring...
- colesantiago 2y agoI see too much self promotion over this tool all over HN and it is not anywhere near the same as Cursor? I don't see any similarities other than it uses AI and that is about it.
- danenania 2y agoIf you don't see any similarities, I'm not really sure what to say. I built it specifically to improve the workflow of what has come to be labelled 'vibe coding', and I believe it's more effective for this purpose than Cursor... though I find that Cursor is excellent for IDE auto-completion. It's MIT-licensed and can be used for free, so yes I do mention it when relevant conversations come up, because I think can be useful to people, and I think that is well within the spirit of HN, which is supposed to be a maker community. Since I'm an HN addict, I read/post a lot, and so I notice when these topics come up.
- kristopolous 2y agoI've used it. Honestly it's the same place as goose and aider ... it tries to DIY its own solutions too often as opposed to using existing robust libraries, writes inflexible code where simple piped commands would do, and basically Katamari Damacies the problem into a complicated sprawl that doesn't work.
- tomjuggler 2y agoCursor may be $9B but Aider is priceless
- BeetleB 2y agoYeah, this is what I don't get. How is Cursor that much better than Aider? When you have a great, free, open source tool, why would an investor pump money into Cursor?
- moltar 2y agoEE monies?
- n_ary 2y agoCursor is gated, Aider is too open and unlocked. Also, Cursor starts with a subscription for basic tier which equates to proven revenue and revenue is proof of demand. Aider is… a product of love and is not valuable to investors. Locking down Aider will result in backlash and driving all potential users to cursor/windsurf.
- BeetleB 2y agoWow. Not sure if this was humor or someone being too literal. Because Aider is open its capabilities will develop faster than Cursor's and thus as soon as people start charging for Cursor everyone will switch to Aider. Cursor has no moat.
- iamsaitam 2y agoWhy would I use Aider instead of Cursor? One offers me an IDE that I already used with AI capabilities, the other one is in the terminal (according to the homepage)
- BeetleB 2y agoAider works with any IDE. As in you don't need to type your prompts in a terminal. https://aider.chat/docs/usage/watch.html https://aider.chat/docs/usage/watch.html Furthermore many IDEs have a plug-in for Aider. Is Cursor open source? If not, I expect it to be buggier in the long run. And less featureful. It seriously has no moat.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Frieren 2y agoIt may come back to be relevant "Here Comes Another Bubble v1.1 - The Richter Scales" but some lingo needs update (but other parts are still spot on). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I6IQ_FOCE6I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I6IQ_FOCE6I
- golergka 2y agoI've been on HN since around 2010 (I think) and I have heard "we're in a bubble and it's going to pop" this whole time.
- tmpz22 2y agoCalifornia just became the 4th largest economy largely due to tech, and currently ranks 42nd among states in terms of job growth in Q1 2025. The Pop won't be a collapse of capital it'll be in continued decline for the 95% as tech oligarchs continue to facilitate the transfer of wealth to the very top. [1]: https://www.mercurynews.com/2025/05/03/economy-jobs-layoff-work-california-bay-area-san-jose-oakland-tech/?share=feowe2lnaljfoimyoo2w https://www.mercurynews.com/2025/05/03/economy-jobs-layoff-w...
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoBut it (at least one of the bubbles) did pop. Tons of companies who got gargantuan raises and valuations in 2020/2021 are essentially in the position where they won't hit those valuations again for years, if ever.
- golergka 2y agoThat must be tough for them. But everybody talking about it was referring to "pop" of 2001, when most of the companies didn't just hit lower valuations, they went out of business.
- rchaud 2y agoZero-interest rate policy began in 2008 and ended in 2022. Bubbles can last a long time when borrowing money has been free for the VC class to throw into AI, alongside food delivery, crypto, office rentals and taxicabs under the guise of 'technology'.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- owendarko 2y agoWhy do we need a new IDE for "AI/vibe coding"? The entire workflow for "AI coding agents" boils down to: 1. You write a prompt 2. The agent wraps it in a system prompt and sends it to the LLM 3. The LLM sends back a response 4. The agent performs specific actions based on that response (editing files, creating new ones, etc.) I don't see why anyone would ditch their current (non-AI) IDE for Cursor just to get this functionality (especially if you're getting hit with a monthly subscription fee on top of it.) P.S. I maintain a VS Code extension that does the 4 steps above as a baseline[1] [1] https://github.com/Kilo-Org/kilocode https://github.com/Kilo-Org/kilocode
- Maxamillion96 2y agoIt’s vibes investing to match the vibes coding
- sircastor 2y agoI think there are 2 or 3 reasons: 1) Popularity. While there are plenty of die-on-a-hill users for ____ app, there are just as many people who will step away to try something and find they like it. Lots of devs use VScode, but its only been around for 10 years. Some people still swear by Notepad++ 2) Demand from on-high: When the non-tech boss shows up and says "Everyone use this now". I don't know how much this happens, but it does happen. Technical dictates from someone who shouldn't be making the decision, probably for a non-technical reason. 3) I hesitate to bring this one up, but here we go: People don't know any better. There is a new generation of developers coming up who are leaning hard into vibe coding. And just when I was young, there are plenty of seasoned developers crying out about it's validity. The new generation will pick their own tools - in part to distance themselves from the current generation.
- hakfoo 2y agoAs someone who has basically been told by the boss "I'm the one pushing for AI, so we all have to make it a success" I can see 2 being a thing because it lets them point at the desks and say "see, they're all using the tools." We're a JetBrains shop, so they showed us Cursor and how to set up Claude in a terminal window, and I think most of our team has been using Claude because we don't want to give up the experience we're used to for the non-AI parts of the day.
- rvz 2y agoThis is similar to the sort of hype which happened with Clubhouse app ($4B valuation, then the users stopped signing up.), Hopin ($9BN until the pandemic ended) and finally Inflection AI ($4B and almost no-one uses it after the initial AI hype). One of biggest risks is Microsoft who can further lower prices with Copilot (and they can afford to do that for years) for longer and rapidly copy Cursor just like they destroyed Slack with Teams. There really is no lock-in case for Cursor (unless they acquire something else) as users can easily cancel and switch back to VS Code and Cursor can lose that ARR very quickly and the cost is the entire company. For Microsoft? Costs them nothing. This $9B valuation is peak euphoria and this is the best time for Cursor to sell as they are getting very greedy after rejecting a buyout from OpenAI (twice).
- johanyc 2y agoWell said. There are so many AI assist tools (windsurf, cline/roocode, trae, etc) and it’s so easy to switch between them.
- Jubijub 2y ago+1, they have no most, and we clearly see that big actors are willing to run at loss to get market shares. At this point I guess people are looking for an exit, and the last investors will own an empty shell
- evelant 2y agoCursor isn’t very good. It aggressively limits context I assume to save money. Augment runs circles around it.
- seunosewa 2y agoWhich models are available on Augment right now? Which do you use?
- evelant 2y agohttps://www.augmentcode.com/blog/ai-model-pickers-are-a-design-failure-not-a-feature https://www.augmentcode.com/blog/ai-model-pickers-are-a-desi... Augment does not have a model picker. It uses Claude 3.7 right now. The context engine is the magic sauce. It’s miles ahead of all the other tools, almost always gets it right where others fail.
- gaeb69 2y agoI haven't fully stress tested it, but from brief use their proprietary context engine just feels like a gimmick to draw in VC investments. You can't convince me you get better end performance using an older model. Especially as most AI coding tools draw closer to enshitification with opaque context compression to save on costs
- evelant 2y agoYMMV, but I've found it really does work and isn't a gimmick. It gets problems right that Cursor, Roo, Windsurf, etc trip up on because somehow it finds exactly the relevant stuff for context at a granularity you can't really achieve by @mentioning whole files/directories in other tools. I'm going to enjoy it at least until something better comes along. I think the "relevant accurate context is better than just adding more context" approach is the way to go. I find the autocomplete model a lot better than cursor/copilot as well. IMO it does a much better job of understanding the intention of your changes and generating relevant changes across files. I think that's also due to the context engine, it checks for relevant changes to the task at hand across files rather than being mostly "local".
- akmarinov 2y agoBetter sell fast, then enjoy life.
- heymax054 2y agoNo need to change your IDE to AI/vibe code. There are already a few good VS Code extensions like Cline and Kilo Code which do 80/20 of the job.
- addandsubtract 2y agoEven Copilot has caught up with its chat and agent editing features.
- ForOldHack 2y agoI have a paint-rapido pointed at a keywords list with JDVance in a dumpster at the center. Kilo is not "Vibe" coding, nor does it need to steal "Intellectual" "property" at the end of it's 5 hours shift. I am about done with VSCode and it's claims of usefulness. I started long before the internet and PCs.
- kristopolous 2y agothe proper timeline is cline -> roo -> kilo There's also things like goose, plandex, and aider. The real problem is what to with all those bugs written by the AI, however you choose to vibe them. That's what my latest effort, https://github.com/kristopolous/llmehelp https://github.com/kristopolous/llmehelp is trying to address.
- seattle_spring 2y agoWhy are so many people conflating Cursor's main value proposition with "vibe coding"? AI assisted development is not "vibe coding", which is just a silly gimmick to churn out half-assed insecure garbage quickly. Edit: oh, it's because the article erroneously claims it's a "vibe coding app." Yikes.
- crote 2y agoConsidering how hostile Microsoft is being to forks - even benign ones like VS Codium - it's probably worth it to explore switching to another IDE anyways.
- odie5533 2y agoUsing Cursor is a lot easier than Roo Code or Cline. It has a much better UI and it's faster for streaming tool uses, and I believe it's cheaper.
- Syzygies 2y agoI just ended my Cursor subscription today, and upgraded from Claude's Pro to Max plan to reduce my Claude Code costs. They now include a healthy Claude Code allowance in the Max plans. If one has already set up Claude Code with metered API use, one toggles between plans using the /login command. Once to start using Max, then whenever one hits a five hour rate limit and wants to keep working. I've tried many platforms. I kept Cursor long after Windsurf, but Claude Code is a clear winner, as most people report who don't bristle at the cost. When Cursor or Windsurf forks VS Code, they have a reason. Their chat panes always felt like periscopes; one has better control over Claude Code in a terminal, and this frees up one's choice of editor. I now use Sublime Text, fast and lean.
- disqard 2y agoSignal-boosting this -- I use Claude Code too, and it's beautiful: all the benefits of typing long-form thoughts, ideas, strategy, combined with direct access (for the llm api) to the codebase (no uploading/downloading), and Anthropic's promise of not training on your inputs or outputs.
- yoyohello13 2y agoClaude code is actually great. I get to use any tools/editor I want, and get the AI agent workflow.
- disqard 2y agoRight, it decouples your IDE choice from the "Code Assistant" choice, giving you massive flexibility.
- Scene_Cast2 2y agoHow does this compare with using openrouter + OSS? I'm currently averaging $20/month with copious usage (and no limits, obviously).
- ode 2y agoOSS?
- 0x500x79 2y agoI'm not sure that Andrej envisioned this when he tweeted out his Vibe Coding take what seems like forever ago now. I applaud anybody who jumps into Cursor (or other AI Assisted Coding Tools) to build a new product. I think that a way to express ideas is awesome, and allowing for these ideas to materialize is valuable for society and users will determine what is valuable/usable. However, it's well documented that the expression of these tools is limited. I think that the bet here is that LLMs will continue to get better and better, paving the way for these tools to become more valuable: which I haven't been convinced with yet. At it's core you can list out the primary functionality of an AI Assisted Coding platform and how these components interact. Their prompts have been dumped, and the tools have been replicated, plus the big LLM providers are in this space as well and understand more nuances around the models and how they interact with the different components. $9B seems bonkers, but time will tell. There are a few outcomes here: pop, life changes incredibly, or this is the stagnation period that seems to happen with AI/ML. LLMs have changed the way I work already, the question is "what is next". I am hoping that I am ahead of others on the Hype cycle, but only time will tell (from heavy use of AI tools).
- madeofpalk 2y ago> I think that the bet here is that LLMs will continue to get better and better I don't think so. I think the way we use the same LLMs will continue to get better. Cursor is built on essentially the exact same LLM models as VSCode/Github Copilot, yet Cursor managed to wring a lot more usefulness out of them. I think it's still early days in understanding how to use LLMs as a foundational technology to build out other products, and improving the models isn't all that necessary. In my view.
- sumoboy 2y agoI think it's a combination of both, the LLM's today for coding are just average containing a lot of pre-2024 knowledge. The vibe tools are getting around some of the shortcomings and increased token limits which is great, but up to date current knowledge can't rely on llm.txt doc updates as context and expect reasonable code generation. Give me some monthly updated topic related LLM's to use (coding, content writing, history), I don't need the entire world all the time.
- outside1234 2y agoThis is crack smoking. This company is going to get wiped out by GitHub Copilot in short order.
- jryan49 2y agoCurrently, GH co-pilot sucks. At least the plan we have at work...
- UncleOxidant 2y agoAnd/or wiped out by VS Code plugins like Cline and Kilo which are free.
- boleary-gl 2y agoKilo Code maintainer here Just wanted to add "and open source!"
- mdaniel 2y agoI learned about your project from your comment on the Windsurf post but wanted to suggest that you plug your URL anytime you plug the project since it can make the difference between someone "adding it to their eventual list" versus "open in new tab, read, enjoy, engage" https://github.com/Kilo-Org/kilocode#-kilo-code https://github.com/Kilo-Org/kilocode#-kilo-code (Apache 2)
- UncleOxidant 2y agomaybe you could answer a question about kilo usage: If I choose Google Gemini as the API provider and give it my Gemini API key, why does it say that I'm low on credits (and I get API request failures)? As far as I understand gemini 2.5 pro is free to use.
- anon7000 2y agoProbably not — I know of companies dropping GH Copilot because of low internal usage compared to cursor.
- 2y ago
- twodave 2y agoAre different coding agents better at different languages? Like if I’m trying to write in python vs Golang vs PHP vs C#, am I going to want a different agent for each? Or is one agent going to be more or less consistent among all languages?
- kristopolous 2y agoreally, prompting and workflow style is 80%. AI is like any other program, good output can't come from bad input.
- jmacd 2y agoAny IDE based editor feels like a stopgap to me. We may not be there yet, but I feel that in the future a "vibe coder" isn't even going to look at much code at all. Much of what developers who are relying on Cursor, Windmill, Replit, etc etc are doing is performative as it relates to code. There is just a lot of copy/pasting of console errors and asking for things one way or another. Casual or "vibe" coding is all about the output. Doesn't work? Roll back. Works well? Keep going. Feeling gutsy? Single shot.
- seattle_spring 2y agoVibe coding is just a prototyping tool / "dev influencer" gimmick. No one serious is using Cursor for vibe coding, nor will anyone serious ever vibe code. It's for AI assisted development-- in other words, a more powerful intellisense.
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoThe people who outsource their jobs to mechanical Turks will be using it until their employer(s) find out.
- odie5533 2y agoHave you tried Bolt.new? You can vibe code with it.
- jmacd 2y agoI felt the same way for a while, but I am really not so sure now. Cursor is definitely drawing on the influencer/growth well to drive some portion of these #s. It's a lot easier and more scaleable to get 1000 people "vibe coding" than it is to get 10 experienced engineers using you for autocomplete.
- furyofantares 2y agoI vibed this puzzle game into existence with two breaks* from vibe coding midway through to get it out of a rut: https://love-15.com/ https://love-15.com/ It builds for PC, web, iOS and Android. It's a simple sliding block puzzle game with a handful of additional game mechanics which you can see if you go into settings to unlock all levels, saved progress and best times/move counts, a level editor, daily puzzles with share results, and theme selection. I think I found the current limits of vibe coding. There's one bug that I know of which I don't think can be fixed with vibe coding, and so I haven't fixed it as this was largely an experiment to see how far you could get with vibe coding. I've since inspected the code and I believe the code is just too bad for the LLM to get anywhere at this point. Looking at the git history - I had it commit every time a feature was complete and verified working by me - the code started OK but really went downhill as it got bigger, and it got worse faster over time. (When I first broke from vibe coding it was hitting a brick wall on progress earlier than expected and I needed to guide it to break the project up into more files, which it is terrible at by the way; I think the one giant file was hitting context length limits, which were smaller at the time than they are now. The second break was at the end to get it over the finish line when it just could not fix some save bugs without introducing new ones, and I did just barely enough technical guidance to help it finish. In neither case did I write code, but I did read code in both cases.)
- ndr 2y agoWARNING for Cursor users: Cursor is currently stuck using an outdated snapshot of the VSCode Marketplace, meaning several extensions within Cursor remain affected by high-severity CVEs that have already been patched upstream in VSCode. As a result, Cursor users unknowingly remain vulnerable to known security issues. This issue has been acknowledged but remains unresolved: https://github.com/getcursor/cursor/issues/1602#issuecomment https://github.com/getcursor/cursor/issues/1602#issuecomment... Given Cursor's rising popularity, users should be aware of this gap in security updates. Until the Cursor team resolves the marketplace sync issue, caution is advised when using certain extensions. I've flagged it here, apologies for the repost: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43609572 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43609572
- bix6 2y agoIs there a list of extensions to avoid?
- nicce 2y ago> Until the Cursor team resolves the marketplace sync issue, caution is advised when using certain extensions. Isn’t the issue with Microsoft’s legal barriers? This may take years. https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1jrl2zw/microsoft_has_released_their_own_agent_mode_so/ https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1jrl2zw/micros...
- TiredOfLife 2y agoNo it's an issue with Cursor using another companies infrastructure without permission. Think reselling access to somebody's Netflix account you just happened to guess password.
- ndr 2y agoEither way it sounds pretty bad for those of us who really love using Cursor.
- 2y ago
- drbojingle 2y agoGood for them. IMO they should ditch the editor though. I see no reason that they should tie themselves to one editor. It seems like a waste of time. If Claude code let me use me subscription I'd be off cursor pretty quick.
- cantSpellSober 2y agoeasier sell/setup
- BeetleB 2y ago> Makes it an easier sell to devs, "you don't have to 'change' editors" and it makes setup easier if you happen to be using VSC But tying it to an editor (including VSCode) means "you have to change editors". I don't use VSCode, so any solution requiring it is a no-go. When we have aider[1], which works with any editor/IDE, I just don't see the value in trying Cursor, et al. [1] https://aider.chat/ https://aider.chat/
- sanswork 2y agoThe value for me in cursor is the tab feature not the chat. I use the chat to generate code maybe once per week but the tab autocompleting saves me probably 30 minutes per day.
- drbojingle 2y agoI'm the opposite. I care little for any feature that isn't the agent.
- drbojingle 2y agoI would argue that Claude code is easier to set up. Not sure about selling though.
- nyrulez 2y agoAsking a programmer to ditch their editor is just wild. A lot of this thread seems to be full of non-programmers trying to figure out why Cursor exists lmao
- bix6 2y ago$200M ARR so that’s a 45x multiple. Wow. Why not go public?
- givemeethekeys 2y agoBecause there's plenty of private equity lined up and dumb enough to buy at a 45x multiple.
- nyrulez 2y agoCalling Cursor a vibe coding app is just wild. The journalists and influencers are so out of touch with the software engineering world.
- indigodaddy 2y agoThere's plenty of people using Cursor this way though: https://youtu.be/opB25teOxYQ https://youtu.be/opB25teOxYQ Just because (perhaps) a majority of SWEs are using it responsibly as a tool, doesn't mean that a likely fairly wide swath of newcomers aren't jumping on the vibe coding wave.
- kennu 2y agoCursor is not about vibe coding. Vibe coding means you don't care about the AI's code output as long as it works. Cursor is all about efficiently reviewing the AI-proposed changes and hitting Tab only when you approve them. Much of the editing process is hitting Esc because the proposed change is not good.
- guywithahat 2y agoI know this is a meta point but I'm pretty sure vibe coding is just an X meme that means whatever the poster intends. I'm not sure you can say vibe coding does or doesn't care about relative quality
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoYeah, I'm afraid "vibe coding" is a term that quickly lost its meaning because everyone was using it to mean different things. Some people use it to mean using AI for writing code in general. I've preferred for it to mean when someone who doesn't know how to code uses AI to write code and doesn't understand the output.
- falcor84 2y agoAlmost, but not quite. As per Karpathy's definition [0], it's not about not knowing to code (he obviously does), but rather not caring - "fully give in to the vibes" and "forget that the code even exists". So the closest implementation to this ideal would probably be something like lovable.dev, that fully hides the code from you, because if you can't resist the need to look at the code, you're not fully "vibing". [0] https://x.com/karpathy/status/1886192184808149383 https://x.com/karpathy/status/1886192184808149383
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoSomehow, to me that's even worse.
- stavros 2y ago
- jgalt212 2y agoIt's pretty clear given the post Liberation Day recovery in stonks that there's way too much cash floating about for any general retreat in asset prices regardless of news and fundmentals. Just give M2 a gander. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WM2NS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WM2NS
- dyl000 2y agoI don't understand... it's a vscode fork where they're earning $20/mo for customers that are regularly costing much more. They have no moat. I've used all 500 of my fast requests this month with cursor, I've 100% cost them more money than they've made from me every month I've had it. Whats the path to profitability with this? they're expecting models to cost almost nothing and users not to just jump to the next coding agent?
- sunaookami 2y agoThe "path to profitability" for every startup is "getting enough users and then getting bought by some big company". See Windsurf which OpenAI just bought.
- dham 2y agoThe moat is Cursor Tab, which is even better than SuperMaven.
- th2o34i24234 2y agoMight be a bad place to ask: but what do you guys use on Emacs ? I've tried GPTEL, but it's obviously not a straight-forward solution.
- metalrain 2y agoWhy? They need tens of millions of users for that valuation.
- gaeb69 2y agoAdding to the conversation, Cursor is really genuinely good. Their agentic system has solid system prompts, better than Roo imo. Their UX is absolutely the best as well. Excluding maybe Claude Code (completely different tho). You can argue what's better, what deserves to stand as a standalone product, but Cursor is easily the most mature 'vibe coding' tool imo.