12 ms·
Open guide to equity compensation
- no_wizard 2y agoThis seems mostly geared toward private companies that grant equity. As it’s part of the Galloway series that targets this audience that makes sense. I do wonder how much of this applies to RSUs granted by public corps
- neilv 2y agoWould they be referring to that here? https://github.com/jlevy/og-equity-compensation/blob/master/README.md?plain=1#L91-L95 https://github.com/jlevy/og-equity-compensation/blob/master/... > Topics **not yet covered**: > - Equity compensation programs, such as [ESPPs](https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/espp.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/espp.asp) in public companies. (We’d like to [see this improve](#please-help) in the future.)
- GeneralMayhem 2y agoBasically none of it. RSUs at public companies are as good as cash that just happens to be pre-invested. The tax implications are very simple (they're just regular income like getting paid in cash), and so are your legal rights (you're not much different from anyone who bought a share on the stock exchange). You should risk-adjust their value like any investment, but there's are very few if any sneaky things that can happen to pull the rug entirely.
- PopAlongKid 2y agoAnother resource I've found very useful (disclaimer - no affiliation on my part) is https://fairmark.com/compensation-stock-options/ https://fairmark.com/compensation-stock-options/ There are several books also available, including a 2014 book aimed at financial planners and tax advisors that I have on my shelf and find myself consulting several times a year, as it is still pretty relevant under today's tax law.
- cj 2y agoAs our 30 person startup has grown, I made a conscious decision to stop pitching stock options as a primary component of compensation. Which means the job offer still includes stock options, but during the job offer call we don’t talk up the future value of the stock options. We don’t create any expectation that the options will be worth anything. Upside from a founder perspective is we end up giving away less equity than we otherwise might. Downside from a founder perspective is you need up increase cash compensation to close the gap in some cases, where you might otherwise talk up the value of options. Main upside for the employee is they don’t need to worry too much about stock options intricacies because they don’t view them as a primary aspect of their compensation. In my experience, almost everyone prefers cash over startup stock options. And from an employee perspective, it’s almost always the right decision to place very little value ($0) on the stock option component of your offer. The vast majority of cases stock options end up worthless.
- Swizec 2y ago> The vast majority of cases stock options end up worthless My fav manager had a great way of phrasing this: "There are more ways for your options to be worthless than to make you rich" But I also personally know plenty of people who made off great with their startup equity. They're def not worthless. Ultimately I think you should never take an uncomfortable pay-cut to join a company and you should maximize your stock compensation on top of that. Don't forget other types of equity – brand, exposure to good problems, network.
- awesome_dude 2y ago> But I also personally know plenty of people who made off great with their startup equity. They're def not worthless. I personally view Stock Options in the same way as lottery tickets - sure they might pay out big sometimes, and people do win lotteries, but, for the most part, they're going to be losers. There might be argument about the difference in how often stock options lose compared to lottery tickets, but that's missing the point.
- fragmede 2y ago
- wyldfire 2y agoOn this April 13 in these United States, I can't help but think of the incredible inconvenience of how RSUs and shares sold seem to be calculated for the sake of income taxes. Please just add it up and send me the bill. I don't want to pay more than what's due. And I don't want to cheat. For whatever reason, the typical tax interview software guesses wrong or has insufficient inputs when I feed it info from employer + brokerage. So what remains feels like guesswork with liability on both ends.
- toast0 2y agoRSUs aren't really that bad, unless your employer does sell to cover in annoying ways. Net share withholding works out super simple, the shares that weren't withheld are at the brokerage with the correct basis, and the income and withholding are reported accurately on your w-2. Options do get pretty nasty if you exercise and hold, when the fair market value is higher than the fair market value; because then you have to have an AMT return and a regular return and reconcile them. ESPP with a discount was pretty bad the last time I had it; the brokerage said they were specifically required by IRS rules to report the wrong cost basis, and you had to adjust it when you sold, or you'd have the discount reported on your w-2 and again as a capital gain. Maybe that changed, capital gains reporting has changed over time.
- Thorrez 2y agoI agree options are worse than RSUs. But RSUs are very bad. 3 reasons: 1. My RSUs vest monthly. I've been selling immediately. For the last ~2 years, I guess I've been unlucky, and the sales have generally been small losses. Each of those sales gets washed by a vest that occurred either a month before or a month after. I used to track these by hand in a spreadsheet. It become essentially impossible due to increasing complexity every year caused by the long chains of vest+sale. Now I wrote a 1000+ line Python program to calculate my wash sales. It probably took 20+ hours to write. It takes about 30s to run, that's how large the vest+sale graph is (and the program isn't optimized for runtime). A single sale is now being washed by chains of vest+sale that are extremely long. And due to each vest involving different amounts of fractional shares due to changing compensation and changing tax rates, the washes are constantly doing partial washes, that split lots into sublots. So a single sale might involve many many sublots. The holding period is also propagated to the new lot. The chains are starting to get so long, that if this were to continue a few more years, I would have some sales that are partially long term (>= 1 year) and partially short term, which I can't find any information online about how to file. It takes me hours to format my data from my 1099B and statements into a CSV to put into the program, and hours more to take the output CSV and put it into Turbotax. Quarterly vests would partially solve this problem (you would still get washes caused by multiple vests happening on the say day sold for a loss washing each other, but at least it wouldn't propagate to future or past vests). I have now resolved to never sell for a loss (where loss is defined as for any sublot within the lot, the sale price is lower than the original basis + the basis added by all the previous sells washed by this sublot's vest), to avoid this problem. This may mean I have to hold on to stocks that I want to sell, potentially until I die. 2a. I live in CA, but worked from MI a few days a few years back. That means I now have to pay MI tax for 4 years. I receive ~48 vests per year (monthly vests of 4 different grants (from the 4 prior years)). For each of those ~48 vests, I need to calculate what percent of the days between grant and vest I worked in MI, and pay that amount of MI tax on that vest. Turbotax has some bugs related to MI taxes and 401ks and IRAs. Even though my 401ks and IRAs have nothing to do with MI, I now have to deal with these Turbotax bugs every year because I have to file MI taxes. 2b. If you need to file NY taxes as a non-resident (like I have to do for MI), it's even worse, because not only do you need to do that calculation for each vest (~48/year in my case), but you also need to file a new IT-203-F form for each vest. That's 48 IT-203-Fs to file each year. And each one is a complex form involving workdays, weekdays, holiday days, sick days, vacation days, etc. 3. If you move between states with different tax rates, your vests are taxed completely at the new state's tax rate. They're also taxed proportionally (based on time between grant and vest) at your old state's tax rate. So they're double taxed. You do end up with a tax credit that undoes the smaller of the taxes. But this means that when you move, for 4 years you're taxed at the maximum tax rate of the 2 states (on at least some portion of the vests). This makes WA->CA movers mad, because all they have to pay CA tax on 100% of their vests immediately. It also makes CA->WA movers mad, because they have to pay CA tax for 4 years on some portion of their vests. I dearly wish to be paid in cash.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jan3024-2r 2y agoJust remember this is the forum run by the dudes that set up Sillion CON Vallee bank.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> this is the forum run by the dudes that set up Sillion CON Vallee bank No. Y Combinator didn’t found SVB.
- j45 2y agoStatistically, stock options are often lottery tickets that the holder may have a tiny say in.
- phendrenad2 2y agoIt's hilarious that people still take them seriously.
- jlundberg 2y agoAny suggestions on the topic relevant for other countries than the US?
- sprocklebud 2y agoI got hit with a new equity compensation fugazi with RSUs at a small public company recently. My offer letter pledged something like $100,000 of stock, vesting over four years. I was told that I would receive the grant within the first three months of my employment, once it was approved by the board. Once I finally received the grant, it was 1/5 of what it should have been. “What gives?”, I inquired. Apparently the stock incentive plan has a “price floor” for grants at $5 / share, and the stock had plunged to approximately $1 / share at my time of hire. So my offer letter says my grant is for $100k, but in reality it’s $20k. I learned this was because there was a limited pool of stock available for employee award grants, and a recent rout in the stock price meant there was an insufficient amount of stock available for grants. Apparently going forward, offer letters specify the number of RSUs rather than a $ amount. So I guess a charitable interpretation is that it may not have been so much an intentional deception as a set of unfortunate circumstances coming together with some poor oversight on the details of my offer letter. Still, I am incensed. I referred to a previous employer’s offer letter and RSU grant for comparison. The offer letter also specified a $ amount, and did not specify how it would determine the price of the stock to calculate the awards by. In that case, it seemed to be the average closing price of the stock in the month the award was granted. Which I’m content with, but these details also were not specified in the offer letter. tldr if you get an offer letter for a $ amount of RSUs, make sure to clarify (in writing) how the valuation of the stock is determined for the calculation of the number of units awarded.
- pyfon 2y agoOh that is bad! It is a 20k/y pay cut you weren't expecting. If they were keen to make amends they should just bump your pay that much. Unless they are struggling. By the way I have a similar RSU amount and schedule. So gar so good but cognizant that in the contract they can stop it at any time. I took the risk as I can also quit at any time!
- marcusb 2y agoAll of the RSU offers I ever got stipulated the grant was "subject to the approval of the board", i.e., not guaranteed. That said, I'd be absolutely livid if something like this happened, and would be expecting my manager to either make it right, or I'd look for a new job at the first available opportunity. You can't do good business with bad people.
- retiredpapaya 2y agoThe Netflix approach to this [1], where Netflix allows employees to choose how much of their compensation is cash vs options seems like the best approach - you can tune based on your risk tolerance. > Each employee chooses each year how much of their compensation they want in salary versus stock options. You can choose all cash, all options, or whatever combination suits you. You choose how much risk and upside (down) you want. These 10-year stock options are fully-vested and you keep them even if you leave Netflix. [1]: https://jobs.netflix.com/work-life-philosophy https://jobs.netflix.com/work-life-philosophy
- lbotos 2y agoI know a few years ago spotify had a similar selector: - cash bonus - RSUs - More OTE Options You got to pick two and your ratio. IIRC, 80/20, 60/40, 50/50.
- jjeaff 2y agoIs there some bonus given if you choose stock options? Otherwise, what would be the incentive of taking options over cash in any amount?
- dandandan 2y agoIf you think NFLX is going to increase x%, then your total comp goes up accordingly. If you took straight cash, you'd only recognize those same gains if you had purchased NFLX with it.
- fastball 2y agoIt's actually more than that, because the option costs less than the price of a full share. i.e. if your comp is $400k and you choose 100% stock options as your comp, that value allocation will almost certainly control more shares than if you took 400k in cash and used that to buy all NFLX shares. If that wasn't the case then yes, there would be no reason to take options as comp because obviously (as you say) you can just buy NFLX on the stock market directly with some or all of your cash.
- blindriver 2y agoThose equity percentages in this document are EXTREMELY FOUNDER FRIENDLY and I believe this entire document was written to anchor new employees with lowered expectations on equity. I think this entire document is a disingenuous scam to make new startup employees think that those percentages are okay. I’ve been in Silicon Valley a long time, since the dotcom boom. My first company, the executive assistant got so rich from the pre-dotcom IPO she quit and bought a vineyard. That’s how things used to be. And we aren’t talking about some crazy ipo, it was before those times. Fast forward to these days, the startup I worked for got acquired. I was engineer < 15. The founders got low 9 figures, I got 5 figures. Almost everyone got fucked for years of loyalty. But that’s what YC and other accelerators teach founders. Be cheap with equity. And this document just perpetuates that. Founders can easily make life changing money but the people that do the actual work get fucked unless it becomes a >100B company like a Facebook. That’s not realistic and they know that. Employees need a bigger piece of the pie when things go great for the company and not just when it becomes a Facebook, Uber, etc. If you want to know how to evaluate equity, pick a total valuation of the company at exit and then multiply by your stake. If the company needs to exit at > 10B for you to make a life changing amount of money, then ask for much much more equity or don’t take the offer.
- ryandrake 2y agoIt's crazy how "founder friendly" and "investor friendly" (read: "employee unfriendly") the norm has gotten. I would never work for someone else's startup these days. No way, no how. Four orders of magnitude difference between the founders' exit and the early employees' exit is totally unacceptable.
- neilv 2y agoYeah, I've been burnt badly by that before. Which is part of why my founder co-matching profiles mention that I'm looking to spread the equity wealth around among early hires, more than is usual. If a prospective co-founder is turned off by that, without a really compelling reason, then we'd probably clash on other values as well. And I'd also think there's a good chance they'll backstab me when they think they can.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThe sin in Silicon Valley’s equity model is the lack of voting rights attached to employee shares. Once an ESOP plan has more than 1,000 members (or an employer more than 1,000 employees), the ESOP should—as a class—get a Board seat.
- Sytten 2y agoThere is a mistake on NSO in this guide, there is not tax on grant even if the strike price is lower than FMV.
- jagged-chisel 2y agoCan you provide a reference for this?
- OptionOfT 2y agoI got offered .3% as a first developer at a company. That's just insane. No benefits, $45k pay cut, and even when everything goes well I might break even.
- marssaxman 2y agoWere they people you'd like to work with on a project you'd like to help build? Maybe it's worth it. Life is for living, after all, and we do a lot of our living at our jobs; there's more to consider than just what you get paid.
- jjk7 2y agoUntil they get rich off your labor and you get bitter about it.
- callc 2y agoI would not want to work so closely with someone trying their hardest to minimize the benefit to me. Since life is for living, we should work on teams where there is genuine respect for all members, not animosity and greed. The sad fact is that being able to work just for personal satisfaction and not just for money is an extremely privileged position.
- paulcole 2y agoIsn't it just insane from your point of view. For somebody else couldn't the same offer be appealing?
- kccqzy 2y agoMy personal preference only: I'm glad my current employer has no equity compensation altogether; just base salary and bonus. My former employer did have RSUs, but they have an auto-sell program that I utilized every year. In college the computer science department had an extracurricular talk about finances for a software engineer; the invited speaker was very adamant that holding most of your net worth in a company that employs you was an unacceptable concentration risk. I remembered that to this day.
- doktorhladnjak 2y agoA lot of employers who only pay cash have salaries similar to companies that pay cash salary plus equity. Perhaps the equity won't be worth anything, but often times it's extra on top of what's being offered. Those accepting cash only are often leaving potential expected value on the table.
- kccqzy 2y agoNot true at all in my experience. Employers who do not give equities tend to pay much more generous bonuses.
- darod 2y agoOne thing not pointed out in the article, but I would like to hear others perspective on, is what happens at the 4 year mark when all options are fully vested and exercisable. This is a scenario for employees that have been there long-term. Should requests be made for further option grants? Should employers think about further option grants to retain employees? What are people’s thoughts and experiences?
- paxys 2y agoYou should be getting refreshers every year. If you don't then you are either not negotiating hard enough or the company just doesn't want you around for the long term.
- temp250417 2y agoAfter seeing several option grant story arcs from start to finish (including one I’ve experienced personally), I find this type of compensation utterly worthless and frankly insulting to the workforce. What happens in the average case scenario when your options vest, is that you are essentially allowed to make an equity investment in the company with really unfavorable terms (ie ur not even getting preferred stock or any voting rights unlike your average investor). Let’s run the math here really quickly. You leave your high paying, hard, cold cash job at megacorp XYZ (let’s call it $300k), to join hot startup ABC that just raised a series A at a $50MM post. The startup offers you $150k in cash because … everyone is in it for “the mission”, and if they’re generous another $250k in options compensation to basically be on par with the XYZ salary that you’re leaving. Now, that $250k options grant is based on where the founders want the company to be by the time that your vesting schedule starts kicking in. So really, what you’re getting is more like 0.25 of the company if the company hits $100m valuation. We’re not going to even bother discussing pref, dilution and all the other factors that are constantly fighting to reduce that equity value. ANYWAY… once you vest you’re presented with the right to exercise, which costs money and is going to result in a tax bill which…costs money. Now you’re a wise financial planner and know that the sooner you exercise, the less tax you have to pay in the case of a liquidation event…so you fork up the cash. Now what’s it going to cost? Probably not 0, because strike prices are determined based on the valuation of the company when the options are issued…so you’re probably more in line to spend maybe $50k if you’re lucky but mostly closer to $100k. If there hasn’t been a 409A adjustment, you don’t have to pay tax on that. Now if you’re closer to a series B and let’s say the founders got where they wanted to be and valuation doubled, the 409a was filed and now you get to pay regular income tax, so you find yourself being taxed as if you just made that coveted $250k…but you didn’t. You are making an investment … just like any other investor, albeit with a lot less favorable terms. The best part is..guess what? If your circumstances change and you want to move on to a different job, you are now getting to choose between staying with the company until it has a liquidation event..or you have to effectively invest in it. Pretty shitty deal! Now, this obviously assumes that you exercise your options and that you’re trying to optimize your tax bill. You could just as well be vesting and staying with the company for a long period of time, not having to really exercise your options and effectively you can make a ton of money without putting anything up for equity besides your sweat. Or you could have stayed at megacorp and taken that half of your salary that you gave up to invest in this ABC startup OR maybe a big bundle of the same kinds of startups with a much better risk profile because of diversification (and less reward). Now let’s actually talk about a happy case. You joined early, you’re now an exec, you earned your stock, you vested, the company was gracious enough to give you a low interest loan to exercise your options…you’re golden. Company is getting acquired by a legacy big pocketed company or PE firm, you’re about to make bank and retire early. BUT…there is a caveat. During the sale proceedings it has been decided that half the purchase price is going to be stock and half is going to be cash. Moreover, all the execs should roll half of their equity into the new venture and you’re locked in for another 3 years, but now…you’re holding equity in a totally different beast of a company and you have 0 say or idea as to how that company works or trades. In any case, as one of the comments here said…there are a lot more ways for your options to be worth nothing than there are for you to become rich from them. There are just too many variables to consider. It is not a good way to become rich. In order for it to be worth it, you have to be at a company that succeeds in making your equity worthwhile despite all of these caveats.
- pm90 2y agoMy personal preference has been for post series B companies that have some kind of name recognition and legitimate business model. You get less equity but the chances of the equity being worth something is higher. Plus its a smaller team: just a personal preference, I like smaller teams.
- elephanlemon 2y agoConspicuously missing from this is any discussion of clawbacks or repurchase rights, which can be a big deal. Sadly most people do not seem to be too familiar with these, but they should as they are quite common and very dangerous to employees. https://www.stockoptioncounsel.com/blog/standards-ownership-canthecomanytakebackmyvestedshares https://www.stockoptioncounsel.com/blog/standards-ownership-...
- Terretta 2y agoAlso missing, any discussion of equity-like or profit-participatory structures from LPs (limited partnerships). Technologists joining one of these should know the "business domain" "partners" are either buying into or awarded partnership interests, but structures can be available for non-business domain roles (in firms that think technology isn't in their business domain cough), such as "profits interests", "synthetic equity", "phantom equity", or etc.* If the firm has a product and you're helping build it, look for equity-like that let you not only share in profits (if any, most starting things don't have profits) but have a stake in capital events (from asset sale to IPO). Think of these two forms as something like dividends and something like a combination of options and RSUs. If the profit component is intended as part of annual comp, it should pay at 100% from the start even if you don't "own" it until you vest. Meanwhile if it's a future reward, then both it and the capital-like would have a "tail" that remains in effect if profits or a capital event happens after you leave. These are very complicated and very bespoke per firm since they are 'made out of' the partnership interests of the LP where ownership is handled as "capital accounts" and may have no accounting method for "goodwill" value separate from partner capital accounts. In such cases, generally partners have shaved off some portion of their rights and allocated those rights to employees, and the mechanisms of this "waterfall" amount to where you stand in that line if at all. Ideally (a) seek advice from someone experienced with these that (b) you don't have to spend $1200 an hour on. * Partnerships that understand their business domain is in the technology business — since technology is just another word for tools, and business humans should be tool crafters too — will be using this and have told you about it during interview, and it will all go more smoothly.
- jiveturkey 2y agoclawbacks are not common, and no one should ever accept such a package. (maybe executives, since they may have other golden parachute provisions.) repurchase rights are exceedingly common.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- shelled 2y agoIs there a way to find out current average/going price of shares (I have ESOPs; I have not yet exercised and was laid of sometimes ago) of an unlisted US company? I would also not like the company to find out (if possible). Can I even sell in secondary market? I do not live in USA. Can the company stop me from selling and also refuse to buy it back themselves?
- maxehmookau 2y agoA guide for non-US employees at US companies that offer equity would be super helpful. It's an absolute minefield, especially in Britain. I'd love to contribute that information to your guide if contributions would be considered?
- mppm 2y agoEquity compensation is an essential part of modern corporate incentive structure. In particular, it incentivizes prospective employees to accept lower compensation, by making it appear larger on paper.
- lizknope 2y agoWhy didn't I get any money from my startup? - A guide to Liquidation Preferences and Cap Tables https://www.reddit.com/r/startups/comments/a8f6xz/why_didnt_i_get_any_money_from_my_startup_a_guide/ https://www.reddit.com/r/startups/comments/a8f6xz/why_didnt_... I've posted this before but it's a great read. Even if you have millions of shares, the dilution and later investors could still leave you with nothing. I worked for 2 startups, both failed, but I never got to see the cap table.
- jmuguy 2y agoThis is excellent and illustrates that unless you have access to the cap table, you have no idea what your options are worth. Sometimes you can at least get a founder to tell you what the preference stack looks like, and what multiples were given to investors, and that might be enough to kind of sort of work out what an exit looks like.
- justinbaker84 2y agoI worked at a startup where I joined as the second employee before they raised any money and I basically got 0.5% of the company. They went on to raise over $100 million in VC. I got $0 for my equity. Start ups have SO many ways to screw employees out of their equity. The most basic is that you have options that you are not allowed to sell during equity rounds. If you accept them then you need to pay the strike price and they count as taxable income even though you got shares instead of money so you just lose a lot of money. Say what you will about Elon, but at Space X employees are allowed to sell their shares for actual money at regular intervals. Very few start ups that succeed allow their employees to do that. 90% of startups that succeed just want to grind down their employees rather than pay them the equity they earned.
- lizknope 2y agoAt both startups we bought our shares early using Section 83(b) of the IRS tax code. That first year when we bought the shares I had to file extra paperwork but it shifts the tax rate to long term capital gains. https://www.cooleygo.com/what-is-a-section-83b-election/ https://www.cooleygo.com/what-is-a-section-83b-election/ So I ended up writing checks of $60 and $100 to buy thousands of shares at $0.0001 a share. I left both startups before they went under but everyone lost that small amount. When people ask me how much money I made at the startup I joke that I lose $60.
- neallindsay 2y agoThis doesn't even mention ESOPs[1], which have very favorable tax benefits in the US. I don't think that ESOPs are very compatible with high-risk/high-reward startups, but for businesses that turn a profit and grow at a sustainable rate, they are excellent. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employee_Stock_Ownership_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employee_Stock_Ownership_Plan
- ldjkfkdsjnv 2y agoJust a few weeks ago, I met a CTO that got the company to a series A level of revenue by building the whole product over two years. Was fired by the CEO, who brought on new investors, recapped the equity table, and drove his option value to almost nothing. The guy is now a senior engineer at a decent company, but effectively had 10+ million of value he created lifted from his hands. These stories are extremely common
- Fruitmaniac 2y agoI've earned stock options from three startups and none of them ever went public. The only company that ever actually paid me equity was Amazon and it was a pretty big payout. You will earn a lot more with RSUs than options.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- camilla41511 2y agoi don't like recommending a service , but this hacker really saved me and i think i owe that to them . Are you curious? and you want to penetrate into your spouse, child or any device/ worry no more .contact TECHSPYMAX @ gm ail com they can penetrate any device , social media account, delete content from the internet and so more remotely without any trace. i'm so grateful to them , they help save me from a toxic relationship