10 ms·
Doge staffer's YouTube nickname accidentally revealed his teen hacking activity
- decremental 2y ago[dead]
- mschuster91 2y agoFor all I love to dunk on Musk and the 47th... there is a lot of truth in the words that most talented nerds start out as hackers in the negative interpretation of the word or get other kinds of run-ins with the law. Hell, many years ago one of the three letter agencies complained that they have to reject too many people for weed convictions. At the core of it, companies (and the three-letter agencies) want highly experienced people, and the most experience, creativity and wisdom can be had by, well, breaking rules. When you're up against other nation states, you need people with the mindset to question things.
- ludston 2y agoA lot of people like to tell themselves that breaking into other people's computers is about curiosity or activism or some other such virtue. I don't see it. What I see is post-hoc rationalisation to justify lust for a feeling of power and control over others. Practically any virtue you ascribe to "hackers" you can give to those kids that break into people's cars and take them on joyrides.
- calgoo 2y agoTo me its more about the intent and actions. If you figured out how to hack something, and possibly leave a note for the admin to fix their systems, thats one thing. If you figure out how to hack something, and your first thought is to trash / destroy the system, thats the crime. So personally: > "where Stanley, at 15, bragged about fucking up servers" is more damning to me then the actual hacking part.
- mschuster91 2y ago> I don't see it. What I see is post-hoc rationalisation to justify lust for a feeling of power and control over others. There's always two sides to a medal. I think that the executive branches of government - across the Western world - suffer from lethargy caused because barely anyone in public service is willing to question, much less stretch or even bend, the rules in power. A government obviously cannot be purely made out of rulebreakers and, frankly, toddlers and imbeciles. We see this in the current US administration. But it cannot be made out of "we always did it this way" people either, because that's how you end up with systems and processes that are so hopelessly fossilized that no one even understands why these systems are the way they are.
- ludston 2y agoI'm talking about the virtues that you've just tried to paint on people that practice breaking into other peoples computers for fun. It seems like what you are looking for is a discussion about whether or not it it is ethical for bureaucrats and elected officials ought to circumvent or ignore their countries democratic processes and laws. I'm sure there are some ethical justifications for doing this in some hypothetical situations, but really I'm not sure it's as useful to be discussing hypotheticals rather than specifics in this space.
- mschuster91 2y ago> It seems like what you are looking for is a discussion about whether or not it it is ethical for bureaucrats and elected officials ought to circumvent or ignore their countries democratic processes and laws. What was the saying, three felonies a day? Society doesn't work out when people behave like role models all day long, the economy would grind to a standstill. That's why you get stuff like "shadow IT" and whatnot. Processes tend to grow ("scope creep") and no one is interested in cutting the crap.
- stavros 2y agoI disagree. I definitely have the curiosity to break into things all the time. There's a difference between unlocking a car, leaving a note saying "I unlocked your car" and locking it again, and unlocking it to crash it.
- kelnos 2y agoI think both of those things do give people that rush of power and control over others. Certainly one is harmless and the other... not so much.
- stavros 2y agoIt doesn't give me a rush of power or control, I just like solving puzzles, and locks are puzzles.
- ludston 2y agoI don't know how to explain that the feeling of solving a puzzle is a "rush of power". If it weren't, you'd be equally happy fiddling with a pile of puzzle pieces and making no attempt to solve it as you were to searching for a solution. There isn't anything inherently unethical about enjoying power, but neither is it in any way virtuous.
- stavros 2y agoI still disagree. You're making a false dichotomy that there can be either "rush of power" or "nothing". Instead, I feel a sense of achievement at a job well done. To say that that's "power" requires stretching some definitions.
- ludston 2y agoYou can take the position of "achievement isn't a feeling of power" if you'd really like to, in which case I simply say find and replace all prior uses of "feelings of power" with "feelings of achievement" and the argument still stands. I'm happy to use whatever definitions you want. Taking joy from your success in doing things (whether you refer to it as achievement or power) is simply not an valid ethical justification when it is at the expense of violating other peoples right to control of their possessions.
- croes 2y agoAnd what qualifies a nerd and hacker to audit systems whose full impact they don’t know and whose programming language they aren’t experienced in? Would you ask a rocket scientist to do a brain surgery?
- blatantly 2y agoThey'd get training presumably. I wasn't qualified for my current job. Luckily they have training! And people to help.
- croes 2y agoThey got trained in all the department activities and laws they now work in? How many years of training were that?
- pc86 2y agoYou seem to think that every government agency does highly specialized incredibly specific work that you couldn't possibly have any idea how to manage. That's absolutely not the case. Sure there are absolutely certain jobs etc. where that may be the case - certain engineering departments in perhaps DOE come to mind, that sort of thing. 99% of the government is not that. It's paperwork, databases, forms. Not saying it's not important work, I'm saying it doesn't take a genius to look at the workflow for the vast majority of the government and understand it, and see opportunities for better efficiency.
- rbanffy 2y ago> It's paperwork Paperwork, with a mind-numbing set of rules you need to pay attention to, that can affect people's lives in very serious ways. Just a couple days back a guy with protected status was deported to a gulag in El Salvador by a "clerical error".
- pc86 2y agoCan you explain how DOGE and deportations are related?
- blatantly 2y agoHire a burglar to give home security advice.
- pc86 2y agoThis absolutely happens a lot, not at the individual level but security companies absolutely hire former criminals without violent convictions who know what they're talking about and have turned their life around.
- axegon_ 2y agoYou basically just described rebellious youth, which we have all been at some point in our lives. And this statement is complete and utter bs. The problem is that comrade muskov is not a technical person, he is just a "marketing strategist" (quotation marks since I don't want to offend people who actually know what they are doing). Here's the painful truth: most governments have appalling security practices and it's a miracle that the world still exists. Finding vulnerabilities or leaks is not a hard task and it only requires patience - there are dozens of such examples in my own country alone and the only reason no one has sounded the alarm is because two things are going to happen: media scandal for 2 days, then everyone will forget about it and the second thing that will happen is that whoever rings the alarm will be dragged in by security agencies for years to get questioned about what they were looking for and they will not accept "I know you are morons and I don't trust you with handling my data in a service that is completely open to the general public". "Run-ins with the law" has nothing to do with talent and if anything, it's the absence of a talent if that resulted in "run-ins with the law". That is a clear indication that the people involved have no idea what they are doing and just managed to connect two simple dots after a "complete 2 hour hacking crash course - FREE, pls subscribe for more". The simple fact is that musk has no goddamn clue about what he is doing or talking about: "the government does not run relational databases". Right comrade, cause precisely the usa spending service which you are referring to is not a django app using psql: https://github.com/fedspendingtransparency/usaspending-api/blob/master/usaspending_api/settings.py#L308 https://github.com/fedspendingtransparency/usaspending-api/b...
- INTPenis 2y agoI was a menace online until around 2008. I'm so glad most of my history is erased, and nobody knows my old aliases. Now in my 40s working for big enterprise.
- thoroughburro 2y agoDismantle many democracies in your time? Then not that similar.
- ta1243 2y agoLooks like he was a script-kiddie, at most he dismantled some game-cheating sites. Maybe he used back-orifice to open someone's cd drive for the lolz. (This assumes he wasn't just making it up) Sounds a very familiar background. His support of a horrendous reigime today is unrelated to his actions in his youth.
- moomin 2y agoI dunno, DOGE's activities feel very much like a public policy version of being a script kiddie.
- red-iron-pine 2y agothe implication of 'script kiddie' is also low hanging fruit and things like website vandalism. DOGE is dismantling the western global order and destroying generations of government institutions. these are far, far more damaging than anything a script kiddie could ever do, and will impact generations of Americans + many other countries.
- 1234letshaveatw 2y agoDemocracy = spending tax dollars
- galactus 2y agoHe is probably more of a menace now than before tho
- soulofmischief 2y ago> hacking > distributing pirated e-books, bootleg software, and game cheats. I guess words can mean anything you want them to in 2025.
- rco8786 2y agoThe article describes actual hacking related activity, you just have to read more than 2 sentences to get to it. I still don't think it's particularly damning given how many of us were tinkering with hacks and exploits at 15, but you're not being accurate here.
- soulofmischief 2y agoI see that now, but I think I was well-justified in not reading the rest of the article after the opener. That first sentence set the tone and intent of the rest of the article, and it's a failure of the article to start with what I quoted instead of making it clear what really occurred.
- elicash 2y agoYou are quoting only a few words out of the article to create a false impression. Here's another short excerpt, an alleged quote: > I no longer hack into Paypals, gain root access into other peoples computer (sic), or exploit online websites
- soulofmischief 2y agoI see, thank you for pointing that out. The article should have led with that instead, then. I immediately exited after the ridiculous opener that I quoted. Shoddy writing is shoddy writing. But let's be clear: I was not out to create a false impression, and I resent your accusation without giving benefit of the doubt.
- elicash 2y agoIrony that the person who assumed the worst of the article author is offended by bad faith accusations. But I do believe you that you just didn't read it.
- whywhywhywhy 2y ago> Stanley, at 15, bragged about "fucking up servers," a now-deleted Internet Archive screenshot reportedly showed. Another, reneg4d3.com, was launched when he was 16. There, Stanley branded a competing messaging board "stupid noobs" after supposedly gaining admin access through an "easy exploit," I'd expect a large percentage of high talent adult developers to have done exactly this at 15 years old if not more. Pathetic of journalists to be reporting on essentially totally normal 15 year old nerd and neurodivergent things from 20 years ago.
- netdevphoenix 2y agoDoing a crime when underage doesn't stop it from being a crime even if tons of people have done it in the past. Bragging about committing a federal crime is not something we should normalise regardless of the neurodivergence (or lack thereof) of the individual. It does seem to me that some people in this thread are condoning unauthorized computer access (which is a federal crime).
- mc32 2y agoPeople will defend or denounce hackers not on the actual activity but will base it on politics. Ic someone aligns with the hacker hacktivist then that person is good. (All the Anonymous activity a decade back), if they don’t like their politics then they want to bring the weight of federal regulation down on them. People are hypocrites. For example, Manning, Schwartz. they are typically seen in good light. Then there is the scourge of those who hack for money (ransomware) that just about everyone hates.
- adzm 2y agoYour examples are not about politics per se, but motivation.
- kelnos 2y agoSwartz was acting to make locked-up information (information derived from research largely paid for with tax dollars) free, because he believed it was an injustice to charge people for it. Stanley was hacking Paypal and defacing other people's forums and websites, for the lulz. While I think it's safe to say both committed crimes, I'm a lot more sympathetic to Swartz than to Stanley. Anonymous is a bit more grey: they perhaps exposed things that needed to be exposed, but they were often indiscriminate and hurt people in the process. This isn't politics or hypocrisy; it's thinking critically about different circumstances and applying common-sense ethics and morality.
- b3lvedere 2y ago""Politics are polarizing because humans tend to label people and put them into buckets," Stanley said. "Once labeled, individuals are often treated according to the bucket they are placed in, rather than considering each topic. This oversimplifies complex issues and contributes to division." Which is exactly what most politicians do to non-policitians.... "We're sorry" (c) Southpark
- huxley 2y agoHardly just politicians Seamus was coming out of the pub with his son when he stopped and put an arm around the youngster. He nodded towards the village in front of them and said, “You know, I built half the homes in this village but nobody calls me Seamus the homebuilder.” Then with a wave of his arm, he said, “And I worked on half the roads in this village but nobody calls me Seamus the roadbuilder.” Seamus sighed, put his two hands on his son’s shoulders and, looking him hard in the eye, said, “But you f**k one sheep …”
- StefanBatory 2y agoAccording to the previous party that ruled the country, my entire existence was "ideological" and I was a "rainbow disease". And then those same politicals complain, why everything is so tribal :P
- megadata 2y agoThings are also being labelled left/right, where they really should be labelled humane/inhumane or normal/sociopathy, criminal/not.
- snvzz 2y agoWhy do so many journos keep making these politically motivated articles. They're going full mask off, even. >report says... >experts see... I am disappointed arstechnica is among them, too.
- abcd_f 2y ago"Hackers" in the Hollywood sense of the term, which applies here, are a red flag in many real-world scenarios.
- rbanffy 2y agoAnd they lack the excellent soundtrack of the movie. Also, rarely are good looking like the ones depicted.
- huxley 2y agoIt would be politically motivated to ignore it.
- andybak 2y agoThis article doesn't seem especially pernicious. The subject matter is newsworthy. The article has a position which you may or may not agree with but it's not unusual in that regard. It's probably slightly better in that regard than most pieces of writing that have a bearing on politics. > They're going full mask off, even. What does this mean?
- snvzz 2y ago>What does this mean? "to go mask off" means to drop a façade, and show the true nature. Here, it means they are not even trying to hide what they are doing anymore: Digging into every DOGE employee they can identify, and slandering them for political gain. Why else would they care what a random administration employee did in this free time when he was 15 years old? It is disgusting articles like this are what passes as "journalism" these days.
- 2y ago
- KillenBoek 2y agoI’m happy in spend my youth during the 90s so none of the stupid things I did is on the internet or on digital photography. All those happy silly things are tucked away on analog print somewhere only I can access it. Being a Xennial is truely a blessing and I regret for kids not to have that anymore.
- kelnos 2y agoXennial here, too, and I muse about this often. I don't think I'd ever framed it quite like you have, that I'm a part of the last group of people who don't have our youthful misdeeds immortalized on the internet. That's a big one, to be sure. But I do think of other aspects. People born from the late '90s onward don't really know a world without the WWW, and don't (or barely) remember a world without smartphones and tablets. They don't remember a time before texting. A time when you had to plan ahead if you wanted to meet your friends somewhere, and if something went wrong, it was difficult to communicate to figure out what was going on. They don't remember when getting computers to do things was hard. When it was common to build your own machine from parts, and when you'd almost always upgrade parts in your existing computer instead of buying a new one. They don't remember when laptops were a luxury, and when people instead brought pencil and paper to class so they could take notes. They don't remember floppy disks, and many don't remember CD-ROM or DVD-ROM, or their burnable counterparts. They don't remember printing out directions, and not having GPS navigation in their pockets. They don't remember having to use paper maps, and actually plan out routes ahead of time for any non-trivial car trip. They don't remember CRT TVs in classrooms, or "portable" film projectors. They don't remember slides or overhead projectors or microfilm. They don't remember bulky camcorders that recorded to VHS tapes. Everything is high definition for them. Many younger folks have never seen a music CD or cassette tape; ironically many have seen vinyl since it's become retro-popular again. Certainly there are things that we don't (or barely) remember, like "party line" phones and black-and-white-only TVs. But man, it seems like there was an unusually huge burst of technological progress while we were growing up.
- nkrisc 2y agoBorn in 1989 and I feel like I was one of the last kids to grow up with and without l those things, I can remember almost all them disappearing. I remember driving back to college both with printed directions and then with navigation on an iPhone.
- SenorKimchi 2y ago> Reuters noted that the Deputy Attorney General’s office is in charge of investigations into various crimes, "including hacking and other malicious cyber activity." Assuming this is true, wouldn't a history of hacking activity actually be an upside? I don't like Musk but I'm not a fan of the negative spin. Hell, when I was 15 I'm sure some things I did could now be charged as "hacking" or "cyberterrorism" or something much harsher than the actual reality under today's laws. edit after reading further along: > Among them was Jonathan Rusch, a 25-year DOJ veteran prosecutor now in academia, who told Reuters that Stanley's apparent history of disclosing illegally acquired data should have prompted "serious concerns." Is this guy a veteran who prosecutes, a guy who prosecutes veterans, or something else? It feels even weirder to spin the Doge employees as inexperienced kids (which they may be) but then to call a 25 year old critic a veteran prosecutor.
- jalk 2y agoAnd if the current laws prevent you from getting a security clearance, then that is what it is. Sure the laws can be changed, but in this context it’s probably better to exclude some “reformed” people than letting “criminals” through.
- batch12 2y agoI don't think the article is saying that the prosecutor is 25 years old. It's saying that he has 25 years of experience as a prosecutor.
- SenorKimchi 2y agoHaha thank god. I really confused myself reading that. I am truly an idiot today.
- account-5 2y agoWhat a non-story. TL;DR Approx 20 years ago, whilst still a child, a staffer in a contempory politically unpopular US gov dept, bragged on the internet. Just to note: I'm no trump administration supporter and wouldn't be even if I was American.
- kelnos 2y agoYeah, I am disgusted by what this guy and his fellow DOGErs are doing today, but I really hope I -- currently in my mid-40s -- wouldn't be judged by how I acted in high school. Though the kind of hacking he did sounds like it was worse than anything I did online in the 90s with my 28.8 modem. I mean, he committed actual computer crimes, and not for any sort of noble purpose.
- yahoozoo 2y agoI feel like this was a lot of people that grew up on the computers and the Internet in the 90s/early 2000s before social media took off. If anything this gives him credibility. Beats being a boot camp graduate normie.
- swaits 2y agoAgree. I grew up in the era of phreaking and when I see something like this it makes me happy. We want the tinkerers, the curious, the people always pushing on the margins.
- watwut 2y agoIt is not necessary to be an asshole with no regard to others to be curious. Maybe we should stop glamorizing these.
- mirekrusin 2y agoSounds like genuinely good coder in his teens. I'd definitely hire a decade or two later. Author seems clueless.
- bitbasher 2y agoIf people knew the kinds of things I did and said online in my youth I'd be cancelled too. Kids do and say stupid things. Kids get into trouble. This is especially true if you grew up with a keen interest in computers, programming and for some reason, gaming.
- watwut 2y agoI had interest in programming and never tried to exploit someone elses systems. What stopped me was knowing that it would "wrong thing to do", that it would be unethical. People here will pontificate for hours over kids reading less or whatever and then turn around and treat activities like this as a proof of something positive. There are plenty of kids who are not acting like, well, entitled assholes. They have interest in programing, gaming, computers and enough impulse control to not do these. It is not something positive - even if you grow out of it.
- bitbasher 2y agoYes, not everyone with interest in games and programming was a degenerate like me. With that being said, there sure were a lot of us.
- archagon 2y agoGetting cancelled is one thing, gaining security clearance and unconstrained access to everyone's health/tax/social security/etc. data is another.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoWorking for DOGE is a much greater stain on his character (and/or intelligence if he's a true believer). Imagine writing on your resume that you did a cost efficiency project that added hundreds of billions in costs and killed millions of people. A script kiddie youth hardly compares.
- anonym29 2y agoWhat DOGE activities are you referring to that added hundreds of billions in costs and killed millions of people?
- woodruffw 2y agoThey’re presumably talking about things like USAID and PEPFAR. (We haven’t seen the costs of slashing these materialize yet, but with PEPFAR in particular there’s a very good chance millions will die without access to the drugs provided under the program.)
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoIncluding more than half a million children born with HIV!
- anonym29 2y agoUnder this logic, aren't all preventable deaths (no matter how much it costs to prevent that death) the same as murder? Doesn't that technically make all of us guilty of murder if we are not all spending our entire paychecks preventing the deaths of others?
- mexicocitinluez 2y agoThis is a false equivalency. No one is saying you need to donate your entire paycheck.
- woodruffw 2y agoNo, I’m talking very specifically about things that were previously funded but are not, for what are nakedly callous reasons. (There’s no need for logical extremes here: PEPFAR wasn’t a very expensive program.)
- moktonar 2y agoI’ve heard about a guy nicknamed Condor who had similar issues but turned out to be one of the best of all times.. What I want to say is that you can’t always judge a person by his past
- rob 2y agoAll this was pretty common back in the AOL days. Kelly Hallissey would call your parents, you'd get 2 char screen names just by editing the HTML source code before submitting, end users would run Sub7 and let you control their computers, DosFX and PatOrJK were thriving sites, Dolan would get pounds of dog food delivered to his house by anons for pissing them off.
- firefax 2y agoI'm glad that even if you found my teenage hacking handle, the forum it was used on is long defunct and not indexed by the wayback machine. I drifted away from security research in my early 20s partly because of the fear instilled reading about Kevin's trials and tribulations[1]... I think teens today think they're elite when they forget that bitcoin and even pre-paid cards, nor ubiquitous wifi were present in those times. It's a lot easier to be anonymous nowadays -- gone are the days of scanning for poorly secured SSH boxes to use as jump boxes, now someone can go off to Starbucks and spin up a whole ass botnet or just get a burner sim to use for a month as a hotspot. They conflate that ability to hide in the noise as a mark of skill, and then they make mistakes. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20050619225554/https://www.linuxjournal.com/article/5052 https://web.archive.org/web/20050619225554/https://www.linux...
- jmyeet 2y agoMany here are approaching this as "kids do dumb stuff", which is true, but I don't think that's the point. The issue is DOGE's almost complete lack of transparency and the fact that they're given unprecedented access to systems that handle trillions of dollars where they come up with nonsencial data like they claim there are 350 year olds collecting Social Security [1]. Normally, leadership positions in government agencies are political appointees, who go through a vetting process and confirmation hearings in the Senate, or they're long-term civil servants. DOGE is exploiting a grey area to designate its staffers as "special government employees", which means neither of these vetting processes apply. So do I care about this particular employees teenage antics? Not really. But why were they selected for their position at DOJ? And at DOGE? What do they do, exactly? What makes them qualified for that? These are things we should know. Let me give you a recent example of just insane and seemingly kleptocratic this administration is. DOE just awarded a $1.4 billion contract to manage the SPR [2]. This is something DOE has done until now. Why are they appointing a private company to do it? Who knows? And who are they awarding it to? Well, that's where it gets interesting [3]. We seem to have handed a $1.4 billion to a company that invested in self-storage units to manage the SPR and that company may be linked personally to the Secretary of Energy. We are witnessing the destruction of the executive branch at the hands of unappointed, unaccountable individuals and I guarantee you the next step will be to privatize these government functions that have been made to fail by gutting them for the sole purpose of transferring wealth from the government to the wealthiest. [1]: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/social-security-doge-100-150-year-olds-cobol-elon-musk/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/social-security-doge-100-150-ye... [2]: https://www.energy.gov/articles/department-energy-awards-management-and-operating-mo-contract-strategic-petroleum-reserve https://www.energy.gov/articles/department-energy-awards-man... [3]: https://www.tiktok.com/@mrglobaltoo/video/7489245893070294315 https://www.tiktok.com/@mrglobaltoo/video/748924589307029431...
- 1234letshaveatw 2y agoExactly right- why are people talking about Christopher Stanley's teenage antics in regards to an article about Christopher Stanley? Shouldn't everyone be parroting your political views instead? And good point on Christopher Stanley being unappointed- why isn't every employee of the executive branch appointed? It's all so confusing
- DeathArrow 2y agoI did my fair share of hacking when I was 20. Most of it was out of curiosity and stupidity and I tried to never produce any damage. Have I compromised a big website or government server I never leaked credentials or defaced anything. In fact I never bragged publicly and I tried to be quiet, unseen and tried to erase my traces.
- NatalieKrylova 2y ago[dead]
- aricboyer 2y ago[dead]