24 ms·
How the U.K. broke its own economy
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- bell-cot 2y agoBritish economic dysfunction is an old, old story. My favorite quip: "This island is made mainly of coal and surrounded by fish. Only an organizing genius could produce a shortage of coal and fish at the same time." - Aneurin Bevan, British Labour politician, in a speech at Blackpool, 24 May 1945
- potato3732842 2y ago>British economic dysfunction is an old, old story. My favorite quip: That doesn't mean it's not an existential problem. You can have a growth forever before the cancer gets bad enough to notice.
- pelagicAustral 2y agoI never heard this one before, and made my day... haha Thank you.
- WalterBright 2y agoRelated: If the Soviet Union took over the Sahara, nothing would happen for a few years, and then there would be a shortage of sand.
- devnullbrain 2y agoWe have a broken mentality. In the US, they're temporarily embarrassed millionaires. Here, we're temporarily embarrassed landlords. The only ambition that's socially acceptable is a mortgage.
- reverendsteveii 2y agoEveryone who bought into neoliberalism in the 80s is now experiencing economies that are mysteriously failing to thrive. Correlation isn't cause, except when it is.
- pipes 2y agoSo what was the alternative? Continue with the disaster of central planning. Which is the actual thing that destroyed British industry.
- sjducb 2y agoGo back to what the western world was doing in the 50’s. High tax and high public spending. In 1950 the US had a top marginal tax rate of 91%. The 50s were great, let’s do that again. https://www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2021/04/26/taxing-the-rich-the-evolution-of-americas-marginal-income-tax-rate-infographic/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2021/04/26/taxing...
- twoodfin 2y agoFederal receipts as a % of GDP has gone up and down by a few % but is basically unchanged from the 1950’s: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=ockN https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=ockN Meanwhile the income tax burden, specifically, has gotten considerably more progressive: https://www.ntu.org/foundation/tax-page/who-pays-income-taxes https://www.ntu.org/foundation/tax-page/who-pays-income-taxe...
- raoulj 2y agoIs figure 4's legend correct from the NTU link? It would seem that the grey is the top 1%, not bottom 50%.
- yndoendo 2y agoThe NTU only goes back to the 1980s and does not actually include any analysis of the 1950s. Looks like NTU also is positing their stance on the ideology that the 1% are the only ones that create jobs but they are the ones to most likely invest in large corporations. There seems no prospect to help the mom and pop shops or small companies that have stronger solutions beyond what large corporate tunnel vision provides. My personal taxes keep going up with these "Tax Cuts". I don't expect them to come down with the push for tax cuts for the wealthy. Nor has my income gone up. Wouldn't buying more local would reduce energy used for transportation of goods and services? I see less Amazon purchases and deliveries as a net benefit for the majority and a net deficit for the wealthy investors. Wealth that stays more in the community versus being shipped to Wall Street.
- aftbit 2y agoAren't higher energy prices exactly what we need to combat climate change though?
- _aavaa_ 2y agoNot really. We need polluting energy sources to be charged for their pollution, ie stop using the atmosphere and land as a free sewer, which in turn will put renewables on an equal footing. Though even without that, solar, wind, and batteries are already cheaper.
- robertlagrant 2y agoIsn't that the same? You want to raise the price of energy to make wind etc competitive?
- rawgabbit 2y agoSound bites drives political discussion. When a polluting industry poisons the air and the water and people go to the hospital because they are coughing or they have dysentery, who will pay to cleanup the mess? If you frame the discussion as about “price” it is a non-starter. I would argue it is better to talk about workers and their families. As in let us not shit in the river so our children don’t get sick and can go to school. Let us not poison the air so workers can do their jobs and not go to hospital.
- robertlagrant 2y agoThis seems disingenuous twice: 1. You're welcome to argue that, but you haven't here. You've just stated it. 2. You shouldn't supplant one topic with another. High energy prices kill people, because energy drives the cost of everything, and people can direct less value into things that keep them healthy if they're spending a greater proportion of their income on survival. You can say "also air should be clean", fine, but not "Don't think about prices! Look over here instead!"
- mitchbob 2y agohttps://archive.ph/2025.03.03-161011/https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/03/uk-needs-abundance/681877/ https://archive.ph/2025.03.03-161011/https://www.theatlantic...
- tester89 2y agoVery derivative of https://ukfoundations.co/ https://ukfoundations.co/ , which is mentioned.
- lsllc 2y agoI have some friends over there and they (or their employers) are cutting back on their business expenditures, staffing and overall outlook. The new payroll taxes (unemployment insurance?) are going to bite both employers and employees alike. Taxes are too high, there's too much red tape for businesses and successive governments have failed to invest in anything outside of the "south" (e.g. Greater London). I was (half) joking with them that the "north" would be far better off if it seceded and joined Scotland!
- walthamstow 2y agoI don't know why you think the north and Scotland would be better off together. The south east would only get richer under such a scenario. Taxes-too-high is a common refrain but income tax + national insurance takes 26% of my 95th-percentile income. Is that so bad?
- mistrial9 2y agoif you are an employee and that is direct compensation (not deferred capital gains) then your taxes are lower than California
- lotsofpulp 2y agoIs this including the use of tax advantaged accounts like HSAs/401Ks/IRAs/etc? In the US, it should be possible to get a 95th percentile household income ($300k, married filing joint) effective federal income tax rate down to 10% to 15%. Including total health insurance costs (employer + employee) plus some amount of deductible/out of pocket maximum for a family of 4 would bump it up to 20% to 25%. And then on top of that would be state + local tax liabilities like property and sales tax. All in, I bet total proportion spent on taxes is less than 40%, even in California, at 95th percentile income, and 30% in a state without income tax. Edit: I’m probably understating my numbers by 5% due to forgetting about social security and Medicare taxes.
- dmoy 2y ago
- PaulRobinson 2y agoThe core argument - that the state is getting in the way of the private sector fixing everything - is clearly false, at least in the case of the UK. If that were the case, public transport (which underwent radical privatisation and deregulation across the UK some 40+ years ago), would be the cheapest and most effective in Europe. In fact, it's the most expensive in Europe. It is all currently being wrestled back into public hands through bus and rail fixed franchises, because Stagecoach (they own Greyhound in the US, you might be familiar with their work), have driven public transport into the ground in the name of profits for themselves. On housing, the Thatcher government in the 1980s gave social housing tenants the right to buy homes, and created laws that prevented local authorities from building new public sector housing projects: the market, after all, would be more effective. That's led to a situation where private developers own land they won't build on until prices rise - they're artificially shortening supply. The houses they do build are small and expensive, and most people actively look for non-new build homes, to the extent that the government had to introduce tax breaks (Lifetime ISA), and incentives (help to buy), for people to buy new builds they didn't really want. This isn't breaking news. People have been pointing out the problems and obvious drawbacks to the libertarian "private corporations can fix it all" nonsense that drove Thatcherism from the first moments it was conceived in the 1980s, and were hand-waved away as relics of the past by the centre right who took control of the country and destroyed it. Yes, the public sector has problems too. Nobody is arguing that the right solution is to nationalise everything (except in the case of monopoly markets like public transport and utilities, where the UK is markedly behind the rest of Europe in the sectors which it has left to private sector utilisation). It's about balance. It always was, for many years, and for many years it was successful, as it has continued to be across Europe. TFA suggests that the real problem is that the private sector has been leashed by red tape, but that's just not true. The government has given the private sector ample opportunity: to build houses, and they've refused to do so; to build nuclear power, and they keep coming back and asking for more money to fix problems of their own making; to run utilities as they wish, and they pollute rivers and raise bill prices. In most of Europe (with almost identical regulations and rules, thanks to the power of EU frameworks the UK was entirely aligned to until very recently), the public sector has been able to retain a larger part of these critical economic components, and these problems have not arisen to the same extent. As an aside, it's not lost on most that it is ironic that the French public sector is allowed to invest in UK transport and energy sector companies, but the UK public sector is not, due to EU law that we're still trying to get rid of. TFA is therefore philosophically, intellectually and factually flawed at every level based on the actual data and lived experiences of the people suffering this - and yes, I am one of those people. I'm sick of this utterly absurd libertarian agenda being pushed like this, claiming that the private sector is somehow a victim. I believe so are most UK citizens who see it for the propaganda it is. There is an increasing, and deepening sense of unease at private capital in the UK, much of it unfounded. Right-wing libertarian agitprop nonsense like this article doesn't help: it's toxic, and harms the private sector in those areas where it can make a real difference.
- piker 2y agoMy own [local government] is so stupid its own massive 7-figure park project got blocked by [local government] planning halfway through. For about a year instead of a park we’ve had two massive holes surrounded by fences. Too many taxes, too much nimbyism. This one really is that simple.
- xyzzy123 2y agoThis happens everywhere in enterprise and government because policies and processes are designed to avoid mistakes or embarassment at any cost (because those risks are internalised by the bureacracy and therefore "real") but do not account for the cost of not being able to get anything done, because those are externalised and everyone involved in the various committees and review processes gets paid regardless. I wish there were better ways to align incentives here.
- yunesj 2y ago> I wish there were better ways to align incentives here. I have a crazy idea that might work to hold organizations accountable if they never get anything done.
- alwa 2y agoOo! Oo! Is it a free and fair public election?
- florbnit 2y agoThat mentality is exactly what leads to the problem. You want to hold everyone organization accountable for every perceived failing which leads them to optimize towards a state where they can justify existence but do as little as possible to minimize the potential for any perceived failing.
- yunesj 2y agoI was talking about market accountability. Companies that don’t get anything done fail.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoThe last government intentionally banned the cheapest source of energy, onshore wind, from being built in England, by making it so that a single complaint could stop a project. I cannot believe this article talks about planning constraints and energy prices and doesn't mention that.
- giantg2 2y agoI hate the large scale turbines. I'm sure small scale or other designs are OK. But screw the large turbines. Where I grew up they outsourced the jobs and then we were left with ugly giants ruining the once beautiful mountains. It's on par with strip mining (aesthetically).
- cr__ 2y agoI like em.
- giantg2 2y ago[flagged]
- thinkingtoilet 2y agoWhere do you think coal and oil comes from? It's ok as long as other people's environment is destroyed for non-renewable energy but not your environment for renewable energy?
- giantg2 2y agoLol, they used to mine coal under that very mountain (until it was outsourced). It's not like we have some insular life. The region is economically depressed. People would rather have jobs while destroying the environment than not have jobs while destroying the environment and recreational value simultaneously.
- 2y ago
- patrickdavey 2y agoFascinatng that `brexit` isn't mentioned once in that article. Making trading harder with your closest neighbour can't be a great move for the economy.
- kmeisthax 2y agoBrexit is a symptom, not the cause. The people who were most screwed by Britain's prior mistakes voted for it in a vain attempt at fixing the problem by throwing misguided nostalgia at it.
- nikkwong 2y agoThe British economy was doing quite well before Brexit. Now it's absolutely crippled.
- BuyMyBitcoins 2y agoI wonder how Napoleon would react to finding out that British voted to impose the continental system on themselves.
- curo 2y agoReal GDP per capita growth for US vs UK was almost identical until 2008. The last 3 years have been terrible for the UK, but if you're looking for the start of UK's stagnation you have to go much farther back than Brexit.
- hadlock 2y agoThe problem I see is that although the trend may have started before, Brexit caused the local financial services sector to effectively collapse and move to the Netherlands and Germany. London will never be able to recover that loss in ten generations. Had brexiters not ejected your finance industry, there was probably an opportunity to recover.
- 2y ago
- rahimnathwani 2y agoA new report, titled “Foundations,” captures the country’s economic malaise in detail. That 'new' report was discussed here 5 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41600388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41600388
- shruggedatlas 2y agoThe source report is a much better read. The article barely adds anything of value to it, outside of quoting it a dozen times.
- regularfry 2y agoIt is, but also read the discussion. The initial report keeps cropping up in places where folks hope nobody notices how slanted it was.
- throwaway2037 2y agoWow, this report is savage. Thank you to share. I was no aware of the original report.
- genmon 2y agoFor Brits, Foundations is a must-read report. Any policy suggestions need to show how they'll urgently remedy the serious issues with energy, housing, and infrastructure detailed in the report -- or make the case that this issues don't matter. Here's the direct link: https://ukfoundations.co https://ukfoundations.co
- monkeycantype 2y agoI want to see more discussion from the perspective that the economy and government is not just a process, an institution, but a contest, an arena. Outcomes which are presented as a failure, are not merely a failure, but like a punch in a boxing match that misses its mark, occurs in a wider context, and against deliberate opposition. A failed project might be a failure for most, but for opponents it may be a victory, or even just collateral damage in a wider fight.
- Sabinus 2y agoAre you referring to the libertarians who like to see government fail so they have a reason to dismantle it?
- xyzzy123 2y agoNot the OP but look at the difference between what governments can do when there is a sense of urgency (i.e it is wartime or one is in recent memory) vs what they do when it's not. My lizard brain interprets this in the following way: Elites in response to external competition or in the presence of existential threat experience strong incentives to make "real" progress. When there's little external competition, leadership are more concerned with maintaining or slightly enhancing their relative status within existing power structures and this leads to stasis as their interest is mainly blocking or slowing any disruption which could change the balance of power. Projects often fail because the forces of "keep things the same" beat the team that wanted the change to happen.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoYeah I argue that's human nature. When you're in danger (or perceived danger) you will make drastic moves to survive. When you're in a good spot, you are less incensed to rush things. And generally, status quo in not-bad times is the majority. So on a macro level a progressive or simply sympathetic minority has to fight a conservative majority in order to keep pushing for change. The only solace here is that the you rarely need a majority to enact change. Apparently movements need a critical capacity of 3.5% in order to start this network effect of people joining in due to popularity bias.
- thrance 2y ago60 years of tories and tory-lites slowly but surely cutting "waste", privatizing, deregulating, pushing for austerity... Let that be a lesson to the US, seeking government efficiency is a non-goal. Good, well-funded public services make productive citizens and a strong economy. Austerity leads to a dead country.
- ryan93 2y agoLike 44% of your economy is government spending. lol
- bruce511 2y agoThis is not as crazy as it sounds at first glance. The % is less important than where they are spending that money. An "economy" is just a measure of the overall movement of money. If the bulk of that spending is internal, then that is contributing to the economy. Govt workers are consumers, local companies are providing goods to govt etc. USaid for example spent a lot of money on food. And a lot of that was purchased from US farmers. Killing USaid "saves a lot of money" but also costs a lot of producers their income. As long as the bulk of spending is local, govt spending is an excellent way of keeping money moving.
- ryan93 2y agoYeah but you can see how the endless British bleating about “austerity” is a little overwrought?
- gottorf 2y ago> Good, well-funded public services make productive citizens and a strong economy. Austerity leads to a dead country. Most Western European nations have a government expenditure as a percentage of GDP of roughly 50%; half the economy is government. Singapore, a famously productive country, is around 15%.
- thrance 2y ago
- coloneltcb 2y agofunny to read this on the day that Trump announces tariffs for... (reasons?)
- olddustytrail 2y agoThere was plenty of housing before the Thatcherite "right to buy". Pretending it was socialist politics that broke it is moronic.
- danny_codes 2y agoExactly. Housing is the big cost of living increase. A perfectly unregulated economy with finite land will drive land prices up to the margin of cultivation (the margin at which one would move to a less desirable piece of land). As population and productivity grows this results in ever higher land rents. In the limit rents will be exactly the edge of what people can pay.
- gottorf 2y agoInsofar as "socialist politics" make it harder for the supply of housing to rise to match demand, it is not moronic at all. Places in the UK where housing stock grows with population don't have it as bad as places that don't[0], i.e. London. Thatcher left office in 1990. The population of Greater London has grown by 44% since then. I don't think there has been a single decade since where the growth of housing stock kept up with the growth of people. Why blame Thatcher for this? [0]: https://ifs.org.uk/articles/england-has-poor-record-building-homes-where-they-are-needed https://ifs.org.uk/articles/england-has-poor-record-building...
- seabass-labrax 2y agoAlongside Thatcher's 'Right to Buy' policy that reduced the stock of social housing, there were also restrictions on how much new housing could be bought or built by local councils to replenish the availability of social housing. These restrictions had more or less remained the same until very recently. It was only during the Johnson government that the restrictions started to be lifted. Of course, the current Labour government are attempting to once again build new social housing, but it is easy to see why people look back and see Thatcher as being the cause of those three decades of social housing shortages.
- 486sx33 2y ago[flagged]
- nemo44x 2y agoAt least the weather is great so they got that going for them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- owenversteeg 2y ago>Per capita electricity generation in the U.K. is now roughly one-third that of the United States, and energy use per unit of GDP is the lowest in the G7. By these measures, at least, Britain may be the most energy-starved nation in the developed world. Yikes. Housing is the big issue that gets everyone’s attention, but this is huge. Cheap energy drives economic growth at all levels. It’s incredible that the various British governments have let it get to this level. Maybe it’s time to import a few Chinese or Soviet technocrats?
- riffraff 2y agoI think those are intentionally misleading numbers. The UK is a finance power house, not a manufacturing one, so of course it derives a larger share of GDP from less energy. Italy has a higher % of GDP from manufacturing but way more expensive energy.
- hadlock 2y agoGermany and the Netherlands bled off more than half of London's finance industry since Brexit if you look at recent numbers. They still have a finance industry but powerhouse might be a stretch these days.
- rossriley 2y agoUK has 10% of the entire world's digital exports: https://www.voronoiapp.com/technology/The-Worlds-Largest-Digital-Exporters--3179 https://www.voronoiapp.com/technology/The-Worlds-Largest-Dig...
- riffraff 2y agoPerhaps, but e.g. LSEG had 8B in revenue last year and Euronext had less than 2B. I'd be interested to know about specific numbers you're thinking of, if you can share a link or two.
- whenc 2y agoI suspect they are confusing "total market capitalization of companies on stock exchange" with "financial industry".
- gkanai 2y agohttps://archive.md/DTkz1 https://archive.md/DTkz1
- Tiktaalik 2y agoThis article is severely tilted nonsense with a weird ideological bent. The author sneers against regulatory rules to limit suburban sprawl but really none of that has anything to do with a housing shortage. It is entirely possible to denser and taller buildings, having both compact communities, green space, farms and forest and also addressing housing needs. UK hinders its economy by declining to do so (as do so many other places with housing shortages).
- ascorbic 2y agoThe UK needs to do both. It needs to allow denser development, but that isn't enough. It is also possible to expand the green belt without causing suburban sprawl.
- devnullbrain 2y agoThere's not one green belt. There are a number of green belts, typically constricting our biggest economic centres, but the spaces between allow development. This leads to situations like Oxford where people working in the university that gave the city its current fame can't afford to live in it. Instead they live in suburban towns outside of Oxford's green belt and commute in - through it. Ironically, there is now an incentive for the same number of people to sprawl over a larger area, requiring more railways, roads and parking. Many locals in Oxford's new sprawl expect a non-existent greenbelt to protect their areas and are left disappointed. The real rub is that England lacks Scotland's right to roam. So protecting all this green land doesn't even give us the right to walk in it. Only to gaze from a passing window.
- automatic6131 2y ago>It is entirely possible to denser and taller buildings Yes, but you're not allowed those either.
- dmje 2y agoNastily anti-state bias that’ll get a heap of upvotes here no doubt. What the uk actually needs is less private companies leeching off the masses and more investment in state support.
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoDon't get me started on the water companies
- sublimefire 2y agoTo fund state support you need a healthy and prosperous environment for the business to collect taxes. Foreign investment is important, the ability to borrow is essential. Unfortunately there is still ample of red tape, e.g. try building a house for yourself, try opening a business and risk litigation from the customers.
- urban_winter 2y ago"...energy use per unit of GDP is the lowest in the G7" The article characterises that fact as "energy starvation". Wouldn't "efficiency" be a better analysis? Low energy use per GDP or per capita is surely a thoroughly good thing.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Postwar Britain had been swept up by the theory that nationalization created economies of scale that gave citizens better outcomes than pure capitalism. “There was an idea that if we could rationalize the planning system … then we could build things in the right way—considered, and planned, and environmentally friendly,” ... But the costs of nationalization became clear within a few decades. Central economic planning - the eternal hope that never works.
- smcl 2y agoSeems to be working extremely well in China, to be honest.
- WalterBright 2y agoThey've built entire cities that are completely vacant.
- keybored 2y agoLike building transport infrastructure to nowhere, hmm? And then they build all the other infrastructure around it.[1] Because with such central planning you don’t need to build around and on top of existing infrastructure—you can build like in Sim City. That vacant “Paris” also turned out to become populated later. Ha ha they centrally planned a city and didn’t move people into it before it was done... like what you do when building a house. That’s effectively what you are alluding to as absurd. [1] But by that time the Western journalists might not care anymore whistles
- WalterBright 2y agogoogle "vacant cities in china"
- smcl 2y agoOh yeah that's a boomer favourite! There are a bunch of articles from the early 2010s of Americans laughing at China for exactly this ... and a handful of more recent ones from the latter part of that decade conceding that actually those "ghost cities" are rapidly filling up. They don't do articles on them any more, it's too embarrassing because they're filling up and just turning out to be normal cities. You can get a nice overview of each on the wikipedia page if you like: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Underoccupied_developments_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Underoccupied_developments_in_... They've also built thousands of miles of high-speed rail, many dozens of subway lines and elevated hundreds of millions into the middle class. I don't particularly like the CCP for a variety of reasons, however to downplay their incredible strategic planning starting in the early 1980s in terms of industry and infrastructure is to be frighteningly ignorant of the world outside your borders. If you're an older American, you can probably afford to live out the rest of your days in this blissful ignorance. The rest of us however will have to figure out how the rapid decline of the USA and ascendency of China will affect our lives and plan accordingly.
- cm2187 2y agoIt is also pleagued with high taxes, something the tory party did nothing to address. And labour seems to think the solution is more taxes, and oh surprise, this hurts the economy further.
- eitau_1 2y ago> something the tory party did nothing to address When PM Liz Truss tried, it ended with disaster.
- fransje26 2y ago> When PM Liz Truss tried, it ended with disaster. The plan Liz Truss proposed was to scrap the top rate of income tax, i.e. giving a tax break to the rich. And the markets, understanding that it was exactly what the economy needed, reacted accordingly. By crashing.
- eitau_1 2y agoYou have a point, I guess. I'm wildly interested what's your (and hn community's in general) proposed macro policy mix. When accounted for workforce changes (demography+participation), there was absolutely no economic growth in all developed EU economies (+UK) since the GFC. Zero productivity growth. That's stark difference compared to US. Did Europe over-auster when US massively increased it's debt? But , as above-mentioned example shows, fiscal expansion can be challenging…
- Rovanion 2y agoThis article is plain wrong. It ignores that the largest amount of housing ever built in Britain was council housing post war through to Thatcher.
- quantum_panda 2y agoBut the quality of what was built was worse than what the commies built in the Eastern Europe. That's quite an achievement!
- stringsandchars 2y ago> But the quality of what was built was worse than what the commies built in the Eastern Europe. The rural council housing built in post-war UK was of really high quality: these houses were built for durability and community. They were solid brick or stone construction, and had large gardens to promote self-sufficiency. I grew up in one of these houses, and my parents grew enough vegetables in the enormous garden that we only needed meat and dairy from the store. The article is an awful jumble of free-market junk, and as others have mentioned, doesn't mention Brexit or privatization as two of the main causes of economic stagnation.
- have_faith 2y agoI grew up in council housing built during this period. It's not exactly premium but it was built fairly well and they sold well when many of them eventually made it onto the private market many decades later. Good sized gardens and I remember the council doing necessary repairs and upgrades throughout my time there. I'm not exactly familiar with buildings from ex-soviet eastern Europe but I'd be surprised if it was a much higher build quality.
- quantum_panda 2y agoThis doesn't describe council houses I've seen in London and surroundings (e.g. Milton Keynes/Bletchley). What I remember: - small rooms - mould - no insulation - in larger buildings gardens, if any, would be only for ground floor flats - in smaller buildings flats would be split over 3 levels, with each level being rather small - often wired entrance to the flats from outdoor gallery/balcony (in larger buildings) - low ceilings (for my liking)
- matthewmorgan 2y agoWhy break your back when the prospect of owning your own home is so remote? Better to drop out.
- ludston 2y ago> In February, the Bank of England reported an ongoing productivity slump so mysterious that its own economists “cannot account fully” for it. And then goes on to immediately point out what I would expect to be the most obvious cause. > Real wages have barely grown for 16 years. Why would the general populous care to be more productive when they aren't going to see the profits?
- Peteragain 2y agoThis is a conservative (note small c) bit of agi-prop. "Things were better in the old days" before politicians stuffed up. Sows discontent with no discussion of future action. The comments here are far more interesting and important. Bloody MSM!!
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoI thought that the article would be investigating how Thatcher's policies caused disastrous results. Her right-to-buy policy led to councils not having an incentive to build housing and encouraged landlords to buy up housing and thus contributed to the over-priced housing we see today https://www.ft.com/content/8d5f2952-3c17-11e8-bcc8-cebcb81f1f90 https://www.ft.com/content/8d5f2952-3c17-11e8-bcc8-cebcb81f1... https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-housing-act-from-1988-that-shaped-the-sector-today-89675 https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-housing-act-from... Fun fact: there's a popular pub question to ask tories - "name one successful Thatcher policy" which on the face of it doesn't have an answer. However her "Enterprise Allowance Scheme" was ironically a big success https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2023/jul/26/thatcher-enterprise-allowance-scheme-artists-rachel-whiteread-jarvis-cocker-britpop-ybas https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2023/jul/26/thatcher-ent...
- quantum_panda 2y agoAn unpopular opinion, but outsourcing abroad the industry, which wasn't working due to permanent strikes anyway, was probably net positive overall. Of course keeping the industry and fixing somehow the issue would have been better, but it's a bit though in a democratic country where unions exist - just take a look at train drivers now - they keep the whole country hostage, and even though they earn comparatively more than in other countries they demand relatively big pay rises every year. Every British person would probably kill me for saying this.
- relistan 2y agoIreland followed Britain down this disastrous planning hole and now has a matching housing crisis. For most of the last sixty years, a good idea about how to run an economy should have involved closely scrutinizing what the British were doing. And then not doing that.
- tempfile 2y ago> The housing shortage traces back to the postwar period, when a frenzy of nationalization swept the country. ... Rates of private-home building never returned to their typical prewar levels. This is obfuscation to the point of dishonesty. The postwar public home-building project was the largest in history, and provided a previously-unbelievable increase in the quantity of cheap, good-quality housing. > With some spikes and troughs, new homes built as a share of the total housing stock have generally declined over the past 60 years. Again, very disingenuous wording. It is equivalent to saying "the housing stock grew less than exponentially over the past 60 years". For instance, a constant rate of house building would result in "new homes built as a share of the total housing stock" declining. Note also that 60 years takes us back to 1965, leaving an unmentioned 20-year postwar period. Incidentally, wtf does planning permission have to do with nationalisation? The US has zoning laws, am I supposed to think they've nationalised their housing market? Does the author think we still have nationalised housing?
- toyg 2y ago> the U.K. has passed several measures to reduce shale-gas extraction, citing earthquake risks It's not a risk - we actually saw earthquakes in the areas where shale gas extraction had started: https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn21120-how-fracking-caused-earthquakes-in-the-uk/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn21120-how-fracking-ca... I honestly cannot take this seriously after such a lie. This article is very thinly-veiled industrialist propaganda, covering a "report" by right-wing think-tankers lobbying the government to relax rules around real estate speculation. It does not deserve the upvotes it got.
- sgt101 2y ago“To do so, it need simply remove the barriers that stop the private sector from doing what it already wants to do.” Which is fine if resources were infinite or distribution was equal, but neither are true and the private sector will not safe guard the public sphere of the environment. In any case, plain as day, the big problem with the UK economy was and is the 2008 financial crisis that chopped 5% of GDP off the economy. Since then every government has been faced with either doing what would be needed to make things right, or doing what is needed to get reelected. They have all picked the second option apart from Boris Johnson's administration through to Truss, who picked electoral destruction through magical thinking (on Northern Ireland and then by raising spending without raising tax to pay for it, precipitating first a crisis of politics and second a crisis of finance).
- rickdeckard 2y ago> Which is fine if resources were infinite or distribution was equal, but neither are true and the private sector will not safe guard the public sphere of the environment. On top of that there is a part of the private sector which currently benefits tremendously from the imbalance of supply and demand. Approximately one in five Members of UK Parliament are landlords or have investments in the property market. So a part of the private sector is ALREADY "doing what it wants to do", and surely supports the political direction in its favor.
- TheSpiceIsLife 2y ago> private sector will not safe guard the public sphere of the environment. In what sense are homes for people to live in not the public sphere of the environment? What do you expect people to do? Go back to freezing in the dark?
- sgt101 2y agoI don't expect the private sector to fix it spontaneously if left to it's own devices. This is (as you flag) a specifically political problem - not a commercial one. There are political fixes which are available, but have not been taken. There are planning reforms, and fiscal reforms, that could change the housing market very significantly - without enabling a free for all that would simply result in the creation of thousands of five bedroom des res's all over the home counties. This would not salve the real social ills that bad and limited housing have created, but it would destroy what's left of the countryside. England is as densely populated as India, and we need to manage what happens to land in our country in a way that Australia and the USA doesn't.
- Slava_Propanei 2y ago[dead]
- piqufoh 2y agoThere are too many glaring holes in this article for it to be taken seriously. It's simply not a complete argument if you discuss the UK's current economy and don't mention 1) Brexit 2) Green energy policies
- pjc50 2y agoNot so much green energy policies per se as the incoherency of banning onshore wind, due to .. NIMBY planning objections. And objections to the construction of pylons. And objections to the construction of new nuclear. And objections to the construction of batteries. And offshore electricity links. The UK's energy crisis and its BANANA (build absolutely nothing anywhere near anyone) planning system are very linked. (credit to the Economist some years ago for that acronym)
- matt-p 2y agoI didn't vote for Brexit, but the thing is it's not really helpful to re-rake the coals on that one - it knocked our GDP, some kind of common market with the EU would clearly be good for trade.. but to what end, we can't change this.. surely better to discuss things we can actually change?
- rickdeckard 2y ago"These problems are obvious to many British politicians. Leaders in the Conservative and Labour Parties often comment on expensive energy and scarce housing. But their goals haven’t been translated into priorities and policies that lead to growth." I can't find this mentioned anywhere in the article, but the current imbalance of supply and demand and the resulting high prices is quite beneficial for parts of the real estate lobby which don't focus on building houses but on maximizing value from existing properties. Approximately one in five Members of UK Parliament are landlords or have investments in the property market. So while the article is advocating for the removal of "barriers that stop the private sector from doing what it already wants to do", it seems to be blissfully unaware of the powerful forces outside and likely WITHIN the political parties that rather prefer to maintain this imbalance...
- f6v 2y ago> Approximately one in five Members of UK Parliament are landlords or have investments in the property market. Ah, the class-based society.
- thepaulmcbride 2y agoEverybody wants affordable housing until it’s their housing becoming affordable.
- rickdeckard 2y agoIf only those people outside of my window would just "vote with their wallets" and stop demanding a roof to live under, demand would die down and prices would stabilize again. It's simple free market economics! /s
- robertlagrant 2y agoIt is indeed simple free market economics: far more demand for housing than there is supply.
- 2y ago
- InDubioProRubio 2y agoBrought to you by endless privatization: https://www.sewagemap.co.uk/ https://www.sewagemap.co.uk/
- DonHopkins 2y ago[flagged]
- 2-3-7-43-1807 2y agoas a german i do not believe that brexit is actually a root of their problems. it is more that despite advantages thanks to brexit they still fucked it up because their government is a bunch of greedy grifters. eu membership at best takes away some of their power and averages the incompetence and ignorance over several countries (as every member exerts indirectly power over all the other members to some extent). also leaving eu is a long-term project. it's ridiculous to argue that it's a bad thing to do just because the immediate effects are negative. that's always the case if something fundamentally is changed. the eu is a huge bureaucratic self-service shop for the politicians and their minions.
- amriksohata 2y agoIt was lib Dems and labour that blocked going nuclear in 2013, France did it and are doing much better for energy
- johmue 2y agowealth inequality
- amai 2y ago"More than a decade ago, Germany began to phase out nuclear power while failing to ramp up other energy production. The result has been catastrophic for citizens and for the ruling government. In the first half of 2024, Germans paid the highest electricity prices in the European Union." Catastrophic? If I have to pay 33% more for electricity now than in 2010? And if corrected for inflation the electricity costs in Germany are actually going down. There is some obvious spin in this article which is distracting from the real issue: It's the housing, stupid! What is really catastrophic also in Germany is the increase of rents and housing prices.
- 127 2y agoSure, if you don't care about climate change at all you can just activate and build coal power plants.
- amai 2y ago"Germany's carbon dioxide emissions fell to their lowest in 70 years in 2023, touching levels last seen in the 1950s" https://etn.news/buzz/germany-emissions-fall-re-dominates-energy-mix https://etn.news/buzz/germany-emissions-fall-re-dominates-en...
- wtcactus 2y agoThe reason is simple, straightforward, and the usual answer in these situations: state intervention.
- maxehmookau 2y agoBrexit. It was Brexit.
- cbeach 2y ago> In February, the Bank of England reported an ongoing productivity slump so mysterious that its own economists “cannot account fully” for it. The UK has seen unprecedented mass immigration from outside the developed world over the last 25 years. 250,000/yr non-EU migrants in the 2000s, rising to 500,000/yr non-EU migrants by 2022. In 2023, the UK had 1.2M arrivals, comprising 968,000 non-EU nationals. Illegal immigration (mostly by small boats over the English Channel) is running into the tens of thousands (and those are the ones we know about). https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/internationalmigration/bulletins/longterminternationalmigrationprovisional/yearendingjune2023 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populati... Some of the main source countries have low literacy rates (Pakistan 60%, Nigeria 62%, India 77%, Bangladesh 74%) so it is no surprise that economic productivity has taken a hit due to wage suppression and a growth in the labour supply at the entry level. Obviously, Bank of England economists suffer from institutional cowardice preventing them from joining the dots, for fear of being branded xenophobic. But the numbers don't lie.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoIndeed. GDP per capita has been decreasing for some years (effective recession) but this is hidden because the overall GDP is stagnant to minimally increasing via mass immigration. Obviously it means that on everage immigrants earn less than average (thus bringing productivity down), which is not that surprising with the number you've quoted.
- mattmanser 2y agoThis is such a bizarre story, so obviously just an attack on social democracy. Blames privatisation and yet in no way explains why that affected house buildings which was not privatised, talking about an entirely different law. And then it doesn't mention Brexit once. This is such an obviously ultra-right wing biased and trash article, I have no idea why it's being upvoted so much.
- pjbster 2y agoThe UK is drowning in debt. The Office for National Statistics publishes several datasets charting the sorry story. Here's a good one: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/governmentpublicsectorandtaxes/publicsectorfinance/timeseries/hf6x/pusf https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/governmentpublicsectorandtaxe... You can see two upticks in debt: first was the steady rise after the 2008 crisis (which austerity clearly failed to stem) and the second around 2020 which may be pure Covid or may be also due to a bit of Brexit. When the UK government talks about "growth", it really means "growth in tax revenues". This means they want you and me to spend more because transactions are the drivers of revenue. Inflation is generally painful for the public but very useful for a government up to its ears in debt because debt payments do not rise with inflation but revenues do. And public services are highly toxic to an economy which requires 4-5% growth just to meet its debt payments. Why provide services for free when you can collect VAT receipts for basic essentials like clean water, energy, and medication? Why spend millions on regulatory oversight when the inevitable health issues downstream will result in more private spending and GDP growth?
- westurner 2y agoThis video explains who paid for Brexit and Trump: "Canadian company tied to Brexit and Trump backers" (2019) https://youtube.com/watch?v=alNjJVpO8L4& https://youtube.com/watch?v=alNjJVpO8L4& Cambridge Analytica > United Kingdom: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambridge_Analytica#Channel_4_News_investigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambridge_Analytica#Channel_4_... "New Evidence Emerges of Steve Bannon and Cambridge Analytica’s Role in Brexit" (2018) https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/new-evidence-emerges-of-steve-bannon-and-cambridge-analyticas-role-in-brexit https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/new-evidence-emerge... "‘I made Steve Bannon’s psychological warfare tool’: meet the data war whistleblower" (2018) https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/mar/17/data-war-whistleblower-christopher-wylie-faceook-nix-bannon-trump https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/mar/17/data-war-whistl... Facebook–Cambridge Analytica data scandal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Ana... ($4b FTC fine)
- westurner 2y agoFurthermore, "3.5M Voters Were Purged During 2024 Presidential Election [video]" (2025) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43047349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43047349 They only "won" by like 1.5m votes. Who's illegitimate? https://www.google.com/search?q=Trump+birthrarism https://www.google.com/search?q=Trump+birthrarism
- keybored 2y agoI have never heard of these right-wing explanations leading to solving the problems that the poorer segments of the population face.
- magwa101 2y ago[dead]
- ReptileMan 2y ago>. Postwar Britain had been swept up by the theory that nationalization created economies of scale that gave citizens better outcomes than pure capitalism. Did the tankies were in charge back then?
- sevensor 2y agoFrom the US (where we have problems of our own, believe me), the UK, and especially England, look like a powerful case for federalism. As far as I can tell, the entire country is run by and for rich Londoners, with no countervailing local power having the opportunity to make sane government decisions.
- matt-p 2y agoWe do have devolved powers, so Scotland and Wales* have functioning Regional Governments, with devolved funding from a formula that gives them substantially more money than they collect in tax. So they should be doing great right? Wrong. They massively struggle and yet live in a "best of both worlds" scenario, they can run the health service, transport, taxation policy and all things that affect regular people without having to worry about the annoying stuff like defence and foreign policy. So why do they still have very poor outcomes? Look at the welsh NHS, it's horrific. Essentially most of our productivity comes from London and the SE. That means by the way if you're smart and educated but grew up in the welsh valleys, the first thing you do is move to London/SE where all the jobs are. Can Wales attract a google office to Cardiff when all the talent is in London? *NI is a long story.
- grumpy_coder 2y agoThen when you need to buy a house you have to leave. Net migration to London from the rest of England and Wales is only positive for those aged 20 to 27 There's plenty of great experienced people outside London, but all the rich (business owners) are openly prejudice to everywhere else. https://www.bbc.com/news/videos/cwy57v07gn2o https://www.bbc.com/news/videos/cwy57v07gn2o
- matt-p 2y agoThe issue is actually that there aren't, let's say I go to derby, how many ML engineers will I find, or infrastructure coders, Biomed researchers or industrial chemists. Not that many.
- stronglikedan 2y ago[flagged]
- guardian5x 2y ago"More than a decade ago, Germany began to phase out nuclear power while failing to ramp up other energy production. The result has been catastrophic for citizens and for the ruling government. In the first half of 2024, Germans paid the highest electricity prices in the European Union." That completely ignores that Germany made itself dependent on cheap Russian gas which is not delivered anymore. It's not like nuclear was ever very cheap.
- timerol 2y agoAlready-built nuclear is cheap to keep running. Constructing new nuclear is what's expensive. Phasing out nuclear means that you already paid the big cost, but don't want to get the benefits
- matthewconnell 2y ago[dead]
- michh 2y agoI can't help but read a strong implication in the article of the problem being with Labour policies. But up until recently, the Conservatives have been in power, for 14 years straight. We can pretend the problem is all nanny state and neglected shitty council housing - which I agree it partly is - but it's also the creation of a vast class of landlords and property developers milking the population for rent with shoddily built super-expensive apartments. Classical free market thinking would have you believe they'd build enough housing to satisfy demand but they seem more than satisfied with maintaining the status quo so they can continue to charge exorbitant rents for little shitboxes with paper-thin walls, made to look fancy from a distance. These landlords have had a tremendous influence on Tory politicians and on policy. And with everybody stuck in those high-rent dividend-machines, people under 40 can't afford to outright buy a house or even an apartment. And if you own a house, by means of its value gradually increasing, your mortgage reducing, and your salary hopefully increasing somewhat, you can eventually move on to a bigger/better house making room for the next young family to buy the house you're leaving behind. Not to mention the absolute scam that is selling people leaseholds on apartments designed to make it prohibitively expensive to buy off the lease. An uniquely devious instrument dreamt up by the rentseeking class to screw over the average middle-class Brit. The free market, cutting red tape, etc, isn't the answer. The government and the councils could and in my opinion should pick up the slack from the property developers. Build affordable houses, sell them at a reasonable rate with a provision mandating the buyer actually occupies the property for the coming 5 years or so (outside of exigent circumstances like divorce - we can work out the details). Sell them to people who are actually going to live in the house rather than use it as a financial instrument to speculate with or to rent out. Is that unfair competition to the rentseekers? Yes, it is. Tough luck. You can't demand the government play by free market rules if you've successfully been undermining the free market functioning for at least two decades. Sadly, with the current Labour government being very 'Tory but change the typeface and make it red,' this isn't going to happen. Cause they're friends with the real estate class too.