13 ms·
Cheap blood test detects pancreatic cancer before it spreads
- aszantu 2y ago[flagged]
- infecto 2y agoThats for the summary. This is huge if proven true. The problem with many of the cancer tests historically is their high false positive rate.
- allturtles 2y agoIsn't this still too high of a false positive rate to be useful? IIUC, if you give this to 100,000 people, it will give you 2,000 false positive results. But only 13.5 new pancreatic cancer cases occur per 100,000 adults in the U.S. each year [0]. So if you took this test annually, a positive result still means a less than 1% chance you have cancer? [0]: https://seer.cancer.gov/statfacts/html/pancreas.html https://seer.cancer.gov/statfacts/html/pancreas.html edit: although that NCI data doesn't make sense to me. If only 13.5 new cases appear per 100K, how can that accumulate to lifetime diagnosis rate of 1.7%? 100000 * 0.017 = 1700; 1700 / 13.5 = ~126 years to accumulate a 1.7% chance of diagnosis.
- duxup 2y agoI wonder what the follow up test is like / cost. If it is highly accurate, but you end up doing expensive follow up tests for 2,000 people ... that has to factor into the overall "cost" of such screening right?
- lr4444lr 2y agoYou wouldn't just screen the entire population with this test. You'd give it to the high risk factor subpopulations where the rate is way higher than 13.5 / 100K: older people, tobacco users, etc.
- allturtles 2y agoMakes sense, thanks.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mbreese 2y agoHere is the link to the actual paper. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/scitranslmed.adq3110 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/scitranslmed.adq3110
- duxup 2y agoSo for a test like this, do you just give it to everyone without symptoms? For a very high mortality cancer is it even useful to test after you have reason to test? I read about these tests and breakthroughs that involve general predictions and test, but I'm pretty sure when I go into the doctor I'm not screened proactively for all that much.
- allturtles 2y agoAFAIU, with pancreatic cancer usually by the time you have symptoms you are already stage 4 and uncurable. So I'm assuming the intent is to test non-symptomatic people.
- duxup 2y agoThat's what I was assuming as well. But then that leads to my other question, do we really regularly screen people this proactively for much at all?
- The_Colonel 2y agoMeasuring your blood pressure is an example of proactive screening. I assume we will start screening for things like cancer when the test will be as simple / cheap as measuring your blood pressure.
- mwigdahl 2y agoIn the US, asymptomatic people 50+ are routinely screened for colon cancer with a much more expensive and invasive process. A cheap blood test for another major killer seems pretty reasonable to add in.
- alistairSH 2y agoAre we still doing colonoscopies on "everybody", or are we pivoting to the mail-in stool sample tests? FWIW, my health plan sent my wife and I the mail-in kits last year.
- pfdietz 2y ago> The nanosensor correctly identified healthy individuals 98% of the time, Since pancreatic cancer would have to be detected before any symptoms occur for this to be useful, the test would have to be applied to everyone. The incidence of PC is 1 per 10,000 per year. If the test is applied once per year, then for every true positive result there would be 200 false positives (actually worse, since it only detects PC 3/4 of the time.)
- newsclues 2y agoIf you can cheaply test everyone, and narrow down the number of people requiring more expensive testing, you can potentially, at scale, detect and limit negative health outcomes. There is both an economic and societal benefit to testing and treating people.
- pfdietz 2y agoIf the more expensive testing is at all invasive (for example, biopsies) or still has false positives (benign tumors, say) then it could end up being a net negative. This effect has bedeviled screening for other cancers, like breast and prostate cancers.
- steveBK123 2y agoSure but the current state of affairs is clearly not optimal from an individual patients perspective. You notice this as you hit 40, 50 years old. I know multiple "woops we don't screen often/early/proactively for that" cancer deaths in mid 30s to mid 50s. I even know a few "wow good thing you had that CT scan for xyz, we just found some unrelated Stage 2 cancer elsewhere" people. I know ZERO "oops false positive, we killed you with an invasive procedure" deaths. I know they happen, just clear to me its less often than the above.
- jf22 2y agoFrom now on we should probably make all medical decisions treatment decisions based upon your steveBK's personal experiences.
- bloomingkales 2y agoElizabeth Holmes: I was too early! Speaking of the banality of evil in another thread, Elizabeth Holmes really just made a poorly timed stock pick. Lying and stuff, that’s a constant amongst that type, so let’s factor that out. She might have been right all along though, weird.
- jghn 2y agoThere is an enormous gulf between what Theranos was doing and these sorts of tests. For starters, one was just making crap up. The other actually has some potential merit.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoHer notion of frequent and cheap diagnostics was correct. But the main difference with their solution was being able to just do a finger prick, which was maybe a nice idea but definitely did not work. And their claims, knowing it didn’t work, were fraudulent and harmed thousands of people who got bad test results.
- proee 2y agoThere seems to be a ton of benefits to doing all kinds of blood work - from vitamin deficiencies, hormonal changes, cancer signs, etc. Our system is very reactionary in that we order all these tests AFTER we get sick. Why is there not a more proactive approach to getting bloodwork done with as many tests as possible? We should see this type of service like going to the dentist. Seems like a good industry to disrupt.
- NotYourLawyer 2y agoI mean, you’re supposed to get a yearly checkup. They do blood work.
- plasticsoprano 2y agoYes but that blood work checks things like cholesterol and vitamin deficiencies. They aren't checking for these types of markers that point toward cancers. They may notice something is out of whack that may lead to more specific testing but I think the overall question is why aren't we just checking for everything more frequently with these blood draws?
- 6LLvveMx2koXfwn 2y agoI had to explicitly ask for Vit D and Iron/Ferritin to be added to the default bunch of tests on my decennial check-up as I was constantly tired. They eventually found out I had iron-deficient anaemia caused by undiagnosed Coeliac disease.
- OptionOfT 2y agoIt's very important to advocate for yourself at the doctor. My wife went to the doctor many times complaining about fatigue. Response: "Oh, you're unemployed, you must be just bored...". We moved, new doctor, new yearly checkup, and one attentive doctor noticed something on her. 6 months and a whole battery of tests later she got a diagnosis of EDS. A genetic disease that causes issues with connective tissue. She was always tired because her muscles were compensating in places where people who have normal connective tissue can rely on this tissue as a stabilizer. I'm very glad that you were able to get your diagnosis.
- StevenNunez 2y agoIs this the test offered by https://www.functionhealth.com/ https://www.functionhealth.com/? I know they have an early cancer blood screening as a part of their tests.
- fosterfriends 2y agoHas anyone tried function? I'm curious how legit it is.
- devin 2y agoI have wondered about it as well. I worry that I'll get a few results that are slightly outside of normal range and then sit around wondering if I'm dying, which seems like more stress than it's worth.
- Symmetry 2y agoMy parents got it for me. A lot of dark pattern upselling on the website you can't correct there but relatively painless to correct that on the phone. All the labwork seems to be done via CLIA labs in the standard way, they grab as many vials of blood as you'd expect and the numbers for one test were close to the ones from a test my doctor ran. Lots of hogwash interpretation in addition. So: they're predatory but play by the rules.
- kylesnc 2y agoi have, feel it's reasonably priced, and i've been pleased with what i've gotten for the money. i wanted it for exactly the reason of "don't wait until after you've got a serious problem".
- pharaohgeek 2y agoAspiring pancreatic cancer survivor here. This is excellent news. Part of the reason this is such a deadly form of cancer is that there are often no symptoms until it's far too late. I know that there is a blood marker - CA19 - can indicate issues with the pancreas. I don't know if this blood test is related to that or anything, but any advancements on this disease are great and sorely needed.
- hammock 2y agoThis is different and the study says it performs better than CA19
- e40 2y agoI've known > 10 people who have died from this cancer. It is my #1 fear (cancer wise). My best friend died 3 months to the day after being diagnosed. It is both a blessing and a curse how quickly this kills you. The day before he found out we went on a long walk. Within a couple of weeks we'd walk around the block, then just sit in his living room and talk for hours. The bad times lasted about 1 week and the last 2-3 days he was not really there. I really hope this test becomes a reality and is OTC and not too expensive.
- croissants 2y agoI was going to ask about this number, because it seems high enough to be statistically improbable, but back-of-the-envelope arithmetic says otherwise: there are about 10 cases of pancreatic cancer per 100,000 people per year [1], so let's say each person has a 1 in 10,000 chance of a diagnosis each year. If you know somebody for 50 years, there's a 1 in 200 chance they receive a diagnosis in that time, so you'd expect to need to know 2000 people to eventually know 10 diagnosed people. 2000 is a lot, but "knowing" a person is a pretty loose term, and pancreatic cancer has a miserably high death rate within 5 years, so it's unfortunately plausible. [1] https://seer.cancer.gov/statfacts/html/pancreas.html https://seer.cancer.gov/statfacts/html/pancreas.html
- steveBK123 2y agoThe number of people you know who have or die of cancer grows exponentially with age once you are an adult. In 20s-early 30s, maybe 0 if your parents/uncles/aunts are lucky. You can be completely oblivious to it if your older relatives manage to escape it. By 40 you start hearing about friends having it pretty routinely. We seem to have hit a one close friend per year pace at the moment. Every time I talk to my 70+ parents, they are telling me about a funeral they've been to recently, often caused by either cancer or heart disease.
- Teever 2y agoKeep in mind that there could be clusters of cases related to environmental contamination so it's very possible that some people know more people who get a particular form of cancer.
- csours 2y ago> The nanosensor correctly identified healthy individuals 98% of the time, and identified people with pancreatic cancer with 73% accuracy. ctrl+f specificity
- ForOldHack 2y agoSteven P. Jobs.
- daft_pink 2y agoHow come we’re always talking about new and amazing tests, but I never am able to actually get these test at the doctor?
- croes 2y agoCheap for whom? And it the part I can read without subscription it says simple test not cheap. Did they mention they price further down.
- ugh123 2y agoCue the doctors and industry saying "too many tests are bad for you"
- doctoring 2y agoPublic service announcement: There are already blood tests for detecting pancreatic cancer and other cancers on the market, and more coming, depending on where you live. So get tested, if this is something you are worried about. I believe the only commercially available one in the US is Grail's Galleri (https://www.galleri.com https://www.galleri.com). More info on this category of tests: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/screening/multi-cancer-early-detection-tests.html https://www.cancer.org/cancer/screening/multi-cancer-early-d... There are many tests in the pipeline -- although the technology is there, the regulatory and evidence process is slow. (Data relating to detecting cancer early, by its nature, takes a long time and a lot of people to prove out.)
- e40 2y agoThe Galleri website says: >Assumes screening is available for all prostate, breast, cervical, and colorectal cancer cases and 43% of lung cancer cases (based on the estimated proportion of lung cancers that occur in screen-eligible individuals older than 40 years). Doesn't list pancreatic. EDIT: never mind, I found a more complete list. https://www.galleri.com/what-is-galleri/types-of-cancer-detected#block-glossary-45819 https://www.galleri.com/what-is-galleri/types-of-cancer-dete...
- Someone1234 2y agoIf Grail's Galleri is that great, why isn't it part of an annual checkup?
- raffraffraff 2y agoAnnual might not be any good. I knew a guy who had a history of colon cancer in his family. He got checked annually from his mid 30s on. At 46, a few months after a clear checkup, he visited his doctor who sent him for another check, and bam: he had cancer.
- nradov 2y agoIt's expensive, accuracy isn't very high, and no one has done the studies to demonstrate that it actually improves subject outcomes. By its very nature that type of research takes a long time because the investigators have to wait years to detect a difference in subject survival rates or other significant endpoints. There's a huge amount of funding going into the liquid biopsy space so things will improve. But don't expect rapid changes in clinical practice.
- caycep 2y agohttps://europepmc.org/article/MED/39937880 https://europepmc.org/article/MED/39937880 Sadly, the group lists funding sources as: National Cancer Institute: P30CA069533 National Cancer Institute: P30CA069533 So the group's activities likely on pause, and with a good likelihood of closure due to the lack of NIH indirects from the current administration.
- daedrdev 2y ago[flagged]
- phony-account 2y agoAw come on - the money is obviously much better spent on some armored Cybertrucks.
- pstuart 2y agoIt's a pity that even discussing policy/objectives/outcomes is fraught with danger here. Partisan sniping obviously doesn't belong, but we now live in a world where vaccines, energy production and efficiency of use, climate science et al, are all "politicized". For those wielding power, that's a feature, not a bug.
- sho_hn 2y ago> we now live in a world where vaccines, energy production and efficiency of use, climate science et al, are all "politicized". Oh, you speak from my heart. I wish these were not partisan and weren't coded for allegiances. Some things we should just be able to agree on, much like water being wet. Every time the Culture War escalates to cover another important topic I groan.
- boplicity 2y agoPlease remember this next time there's an election.
- pstuart 2y ago
- anonymous_ch 2y agothere's a number of new testing companies popping up (like superpower.com) that I recently used which make it easy to get these tests. doctors don't like ordering them because then they become medically responsible for the results.
- egberts1 2y agoApparently, the current US administration has learned from the antiquated Bell Lab, its many large companies' research division, and inability for small biz to do independent research. They're going back to DARPA model of smaller and much numerous grants approach which tends to be more responsive to real world needs. Theorectical realm, like Livermore Lab or Idaho DoE, might take a backseat or they could just do many more smaller grants but with very specific real-world needs. So, your first grant had better be (at least a micro-)success or it will be a long time before another grant comes along.