42 ms·
Children's arithmetic skills do not transfer between applied and academic math
- peterprescott 2y agoThis is really interesting, but I don't agree with this conclusion: "These findings highlight the importance of educational curricula that bridge the gap between intuitive and formal maths." (My own opinion is that educational curricula are generally not very important at all; that people are learning machines that learn what they need to in the contexts they find themselves; and that people -- as shown by this study -- struggle to effectively apply what they've learnt in one context into a different context.)
- throwaway984393 2y ago[dead]
- csours 2y ago> My own opinion is that educational curricula are generally not very important at all We spend an incredible amount of time and effort on educational curricula, so it's worth thinking about. My opinion is everything you learn before you start actually using knowledge is "just" familiarization. In my opinion, pedagogical instruction should do a much better job of explaining this and incorporating this realization. I do think individual teachers understand this.
- delichon 2y agoI'm afraid that this is because academic math is often taught and tested in a way that rewards memorization rather than understanding. Here's Richard Feynman's take on the problem: https://v.cx/2010/04/feynman-brazil-education https://v.cx/2010/04/feynman-brazil-education
- 1970-01-01 2y agoFeynman was correct for science in school, however arithmetic is fundamental and maybe one level above the root of all mathematics. Children should be able to do most of it via mental lookup tables and apply that knowledge on paper. For some reason, they can't.
- freeone3000 2y agoWhy should they? We have the tables in our pockets at literally all times; doing arithmetic without it might be useful, or a bit faster sometimes, but is hardly an essential skill.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 1970-01-01 2y ago"Will you have enough fuel to make it over the mountain range?" "My phone is just rebooting" the pilot replied.
- freeone3000 2y agoThe plane has an onboard calculator for this :)
- BeFlatXIII 2y agoThese are the idiotic contrived examples that made me dismiss every lecture on the value of hard work my K–12 teachers gave.
- BeFlatXIII 2y agoFor catching when you keyed something in incorrectly.
- somenameforme 2y agoIt builds a numeric intuition. When you repeat something enough, it begins to do itself - you gain a subconscious mastery. Think about yourself as you read these words. Imagine if you were looking at the letters and actually trying to sound out each word, consciously thinking about each words meaning, and then finally trying to piece together the meaning. You'd spend 5 minutes reading a sentence or two, and oh God help yo if tere ws a tpyo. Instead it all just flows without you even thinking about it, even when completely butchered. And that sort of flow is, I think, obtainable for most of anything. But 100% for certain for numbers. Somebody who doesn't gain an intuitive understanding of basic arithmetic will have an extremely uncomfortable relationship with any sort of math, which mostly just means they'll avoid it at all costs, but you can't really. I don't even mean STEM careers, but everything from cooking (especially baking) to construction and generally an overwhelming majority of careers make heavy use of mathematical intuition in ways you might not consider, especially if you're already on good terms with numbers.
- derbOac 2y agoI had a similar reaction. I had a lot of reactions, and found the paper interesting. First, it reminded me of something a stats professor said in grad school: "there are two kinds of mathematicians, those who are good at arithmetic, and those who are not." He was speaking as someone who identified with the latter. I can't tell if this is something related to this domain of math in particular or something broader. My guess is it's something broader. I have colleagues (speaking as a professor) who have complained about admitted students who come in with very high grades and test scores, but who can't actually reason independently very well and despair when they are not "told exactly how to respond" on tests and whatnot. You have to be careful because sometimes these complaints hide bad teaching, but I think this is a common sentiment, and I've seen articles written about similar sentiments at other places. The paper touches on a lot of issues, like applied versus abstract concepts, generalizability of learning, "being a good student" versus actual cognitive ability, learning how to take tests versus learning concepts, the difficulty of measuring cognitive and academic ability, and the fallibility of measuring complex human attributes in general.
- zdragnar 2y agoEven in lower education, as a student I hated word problems. Partly, I just wanted to be told what equation to solve. In retrospect, though, I think a lot of it was the framing. It was always presented as some variation of short exposition followed by a question. The question was usually framed as an outside observer asking for some fact about the story. Think of the classic "A train leaves station A headed west at 6:30 traveling at 30 miles an hour. A second train leaves another station at 7 traveling 50 miles an hour. When do they pass each other?". There's no problem here to solve. Who cares when they pass each other? Why do we care? Sure, a little exposition helps build up analysis and application skills, but it doesn't actually offer much in the way of engagement.
- singleshot_ 2y ago> There's no problem here to solve. Who cares when they pass each other? Why do we care? Not trying to “but acktually” you, however, this is more or less how I calculate the optimal time to take a pit stop in a lap-based auto race. I have a little spreadsheet widget that I made to be able to plug the numbers in, but the problem is simply stated: If old tires decrease my speed, and making a pit stop takes time, when should I stop. Agreed that elementary school word problems are dumb, though.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- almostgotcaught 2y agoi hate when people quote random celebrities as authoritative on any topic, let alone as a counterpoint to actual authorities (google the authors of this study). Edit: hn is just as anti-intellectual as any other place these days but y'all style yourselves as intelligentsia because your celebrities are special. I'll repeat: check out the qualifications of the authors of this study and compare them to Feynman's on this subject. Any reasonable person would conclude that comparing them is exactly like comparing Kim Kardashian and Feynman's on QED.
- gjstein 2y agoFeynman is no random celebrity. In addition to be a renowned physicist, his famous "Feynman Lectures" and his thoughts on pedagogy are similarly legendary.
- BeetleB 2y agoThe Feynman Lectures are great at giving you an intuitive understanding, but is no substitute for the regular curriculum. You don't find many people who read only the Feynman Lectures who can then go on to solve physics problems well. You do find many who read the regular textbooks and who can.
- codelieb 2y agoYou have to bear in mind that the lectures in The Feynman Lectures on Physics were only one third of an introductory physics course, the other parts being recitation sections (in which homework problems, quizzes and tests were given and discussed), and labs. Lecture attendance was optional - many people prefer reading to listening - but the recitation sections and labs were mandatory, because they were considered much more important. Nobody learns physics from just reading lectures.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoIn this case, Richard Feynman is just writing about his personal experiences of a well-known phenomenon. https://profkeithdevlin.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/lockhartslament.pdf https://profkeithdevlin.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/lockh... ("Lockhart's Lament") would perhaps be a better reference, but nearly anyone who's been through the education system would be able to tell you this.
- mvieira38 2y agoThis tracks nearly 1 to 1 with my experience growing up in Brazil. Nice to see someone so accomplished pointing it out, thanks for sharing
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI wonder if this is true for all cohorts. There are a lot of children who are just fundamentally not intelligent, and deal with math classes by basically memorizing things and repeating them without real understanding. But for children who are understanding what they’re learning, I would expect academic learning to translate to other things.
- wahern 2y agoApplied math in daily life, such as making change, also involves a lot of memorization, it's just that the person doesn't realize they're committing various formulas and equalities to memory. The problem with proficiency in, e.g., making change, is that it doesn't carry over to higher-order math, logic, and reasoning. Arithmetic as taught in elementary school is attempting to achieve two things at once: proficiency in applied arithmetic, and foundational number theory (e.g. commutativity). My mother was a waitress and emphasized skills like making change. While she never articulated the rules, I ended up developing many of the mental arithmetic techniques that (I later discovered) Isaac Asimov discussed in Quick and Easy Math: https://archive.org/details/QuickAndEasyMath-English-IsaacAsimov https://archive.org/details/QuickAndEasyMath-English-IsaacAs... But I never developed an appreciation for number theory until it was too late--i.e. after high school. I did get into philosophy and logic during high school, but the connection (theoretical and applied) between the two didn't click until later. Sadly (or not?), proficiency in mental arithmetic has become much less common even among waiters, clerks, etc, at least where they don't deal in cash directly and without the aid of a register. And professional mathematicians have always humble-bragged about their impoverished mental arithmetic skills. So maybe we should drop the pretense that we're attempting to teach applied mathematics in the early years and admit the purpose is to lay theoretical foundation for higher-order math, applied and theoretical.
- adsteel_ 2y agoI only learned this in adulthood, too. I had to discover and memorize those shortcuts. Now I know that some of the "brilliant" math students I went to high school with had simply learned these skills the rest of us didn't.
- RAdrien 2y agoI agree. Academic math is taught as a set of rote rules or steps. The focus is not on intuitive understanding. I was taught the usual method of long division and carrying all by rote. Only later on in my academic life did I work out on my own why it works as it does.
- lupire 2y agoThis hasn't been true in most of the USA for decades. A common failure more is for students to forget something and then claim they were never taught it. Arguably the should have been taught it more thoroughly.
- esseph 2y agoThis is still the way my kids in middle and high school are taught today.
- milesrout 2y agoLong division is taught to 8 year olds. That is not "academic maths" it is primary school arithmetic. When I was taught long division I was told how it worked, although it is fairly obvious if you think about it for a few seconds anyway.
- dkarl 2y agoThat take has been accurate in specific times and places, but it is also blindly repeated in contexts where it's simply not true. All the teachers I encountered in my time in the US public school system were trained in the progressive spirit expressed by Feynman, with a strong bias against rote learning and in favor of a conceptual, understand-based approach. My math education in school both encouraged and rewarded figuring things out, which was good for me because I hated memorization and was always bad at it. Despite that, the criticism that school rewards memorization and doesn't teach critical thinking is still the only criticism I ever heard about the education I received. It's the standard thing that well-meaning people say. Which I think is a shame. When virtually every teacher in the system is trained in the progressive approach to education, and most of them sincerely believe in it and do their best to practice it, only to have the entire society turn around and claim that they are actually implementing ideas that nobody has believed in in a century, must be incredibly discouraging.
- carabiner 2y agoThis is why American student math performance on PISA is excellent: https://i0.wp.com/www.edwardconard.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/2022-PISA-Math-.png?fit=1092%2C878&ssl=1 https://i0.wp.com/www.edwardconard.com/wp-content/uploads/20...
- LegionMammal978 2y agoYeah, it seems almost as if a lot of people look back at their experiences of U.S. schools in the 90s, and assume that the schools in 2025 must not have changed one iota. While obviously I can't speak for every school district (nor can anyone), many of the criticisms I've heard seem disconnected from the schools I'm familiar with. (Not that they aren't subject to newer criticisms!) Is my personal experience a big outlier, or are people just extrapolating from the past? It makes me worry that school districts will greatly overcorrect in their efforts to ward off the old criticisms.
- zmgsabst 2y agoThis is a general problem with social change.
- HellDunkel 2y agoMade me laugh because I have no higher education but was able to answer the polarization question.
- emursebrian 2y agoI struggle when trying to solve math problems without context. I learned enough trigonometry to pass the final exams in high school, but I didn't REALLY understand it until I took a graduate-level graphics programming class. Some people enjoy the process of solving equations and math problems. For me, it's a tough process. Unless I have a tangible goal, I struggle to visualize the problem. Starting with basic algebra, it would be more effective if mathematics were paired with some practical problems. Computer graphics, engineering, construction, finance and the analysis of data would be good areas to do this in because it's exactly where you'd need said math!
- greentxt 2y ago"ask whether, in the urban Indian context, the arithmetic skills that are used in market transactions transfer to the more abstract maths skills taught in school." I have a hard time with this notion of 2 different maths. I wonder if it is specific to the "urban Indian context" as the authors seem to suggest in their literature review -- I didn't pursue their references. Intuitive math that is not associated with memorization sounds like g.
- dkarl 2y agoMy father, who had a PhD in history, had exactly the kind of math skills the study describes in Indian children. With ordinary arithmetic, he was fast and accurate. Money and baseball statistics were no problem. Algebra? No fucking way. As soon as x and y were involved, he struggled. Strike that: he wasn't able to struggle. He wasn't able to engage the gears that would allow him to apply effort. One time, when I was in high school and already contemplating majoring in math in college, he told me that a math professor had told him that in modern mathematics you didn't have to know what you were talking about. All their theories could apply to anything. Like you could pick up a paper, and they're talking about X, and you could decide X was Donald Duck! He told me this like it was an exotic glimpse into another culture -- he knew that it looked ridiculous to him, but he also knew that it probably looked ridiculous because he didn't understand what he was looking at. You could tell that one part of his brain felt like it was a gotcha moment for the mathematicians, but another part of his brain could see that they weren't embarrassed about it, and he taught WWII every year so he knew that Donald Duck could also be artillery shells or atoms. He had that last defense of common sense that stops people from embracing crank theories about other fields of study. This was a guy who taught recent history and accepted the abstract ideological struggles of the 20th century without blinking, but when you told him that someone could write an entire doctoral thesis about X without knowing concretely what X was, it was such an alien idea that it was out of range of his curiosity. From this I would be confused about how he got through high school math, except that my sister, who also has a PhD in history, explained how she got through calculus: she studied all the homework problems and all the solutions over and over until she had memorized them, and she reproduced the patterns on the tests. At our high school, that was good enough for As. In college, it was good enough for Bs. (It makes me feel a tiny bit more empathy for the condescending mathphobes who denigrate virtually all school mathematics work as pointless, deadening rote learning. For many of them it might be a sincere belief. They might have actually experienced it that way and never experienced any of the worthwhile aspects of it. But, on the other hand, they should have the grace my dad did to stop short of declaring it worthless just because they didn't get it.)
- brnaftr361 2y agoAnecdotally, this is true even as an adult. As a non-trad student the application side of things as they are taught are fairly effete, we learn how to translate graphs in algebra, quadratics, polynomials... I don't recall much in the way of meaningful application in either trig or algebra and what was there was remembered solely in the context of future examination. In one hand I would argue there is virtually no incentive for play, or discovery, or superfluous activity with the math due to grading, and in fact it's disincentivized as it is one factor of a multivariate optimization problem. On the other hand I would argue that it's taught too fast as an effect of the former condition - as someone who isn't in a highly mathematical branch of STEM the use of mathematics is comparably infrequent when considering the TEM, as such atrophy sets rapidly after examination. And this could be said more generally with the S as well, though there is some degree of reinforcement there. As things are, I feel that the timeline is askew, the won't if these institutions to produce biologists along the same timeline as they did a few decades ago is a little ridiculous considering the ballooning of quantitative discovery that has occured since, for instance, it wasn't so long ago that DNA was a conceptual exercise. Moreover, the failure of education to keep with the times and adapt a realistic curricula for the modern era is also inhibitory. Indeed I would argue that the current academic zeitgeist is working against itself. At once being a trade program and while also trying to facilitate the development of "academia" itself are forces acting against one another. The number of premed students running the gauntlet in my program far outweigh the number of people with [let's say] legitimate interest in learning about the concepts in the program, which are also made to compete with the premeds in the limited slots available for lab internships. In my experience this leads to a chilling effect. Fortuitously, once in a lab things tend to be a little more facorable in terms of rapport.
- robertclaus 2y agoOn the surface it's pretty obvious that classroom learning doesn't immediately translate to real world experience, but the paper's finding seems to be more about the extreme degree of discrepancy between the two cohorts. It almost feels like a comment on social class distinctions - there are children who get classroom educations that don't have to use it, while others have to use the skills but don't get the related education.
- cjs_ac 2y agoJean Piaget was one of the foundational researchers in cognitive development, particularly in 'constructivist' circles. Constructivism is the theory that learning is an active psychological process, and is contrasted with behaviourism (often associated with B.F. Skinner), in which learning is a passive process. Constructivism is popular amongst school teachers and behaviourism is unpopular. Piaget's theories are very much rooted in learning about the physical world, and are thus more popular amongst teachers in the 'STEM' disciplines. The other foundational researcher in constructivism was Lev Vygostky, who worked in the Soviet Union under Stalin, and his theories reflect the political pressures of that environment; his earlier work remains influential especially amongst humanities teachers, whereas his later work is excessively ideological. Piaget proposed a stage-based model of development, in which children progress through four different stages of cognition. The last two stages he called the concrete operational stage and the formal operational stage. In the concrete operational stage, children become capable of one layer of abstraction or symbolic indirection; it is not until they reach the formal operational stage that they are capable of multiple layers of abstraction or symbolic indirection. It is interesting to note that Piaget suggested that the transition between these two stages usually occurs around the age of eleven, which is when British children transition from primary to secondary school. So, to contextualise the linked article, the studied children developed an applied understanding of mathematics that fit their concrete operational cognition: the mental operations were readily made concrete by manipulating coins and banknotes. However, when children study mathematics in school, it is very much done as formal operations: the numbers are not intended to represent anything physical at all. Consequently, many children learn mathematics as a set of arcane rituals for manipulating symbols on paper, because they can't yet understand the abstract meanings of those symbols. Piaget's theory on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Piaget#Theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Piaget#Theory Paul Lockhart writes something parallel to this argument in A Mathematician's Lament: https://archive.org/details/AMathematiciansLament/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/AMathematiciansLament/mode/2up
- greentxt 2y ago"many children learn mathematics as a set of arcane rituals for manipulating symbols on paper, because they can't yet understand the abstract meanings of those symbols." In the US? I had pretty typical US public school education. Word problems and application were ubiquituous. Perhaps my experience is non-representative, or you like the study authors are speaking of other educational contexts (Asia).
- hyeonwho4 2y agoI'm surprised this was published now, given that I saw a talk on this at a math conference in either 2008 or 2009. The memorable anecdote was that they filmed children who worked with cash in the market, brought them to the classroom, and given pen and paper in the classroom they would be unable to duplicate the calculations they had already done in the market. The speaker was promoting VR to simulate the market context in the classroom. I guess what this paper adds is a higher N and the reverse case, that classroom skills don't transfer to the market.
- tombert 2y agoWhen I was an adjunct a couple years ago, I would use money for the more introductory stuff in Python. I figured that for better or worse, every single person in that classroom will have to deal with some amount of "money math" in their life, and "money math" is still "real" math, and programs involving money are still "real" programs. If nothing else, I couldn't really get the "when will I ever use this????" kinds of questions. A lot of people seem to have almost a "phobia" of mathematics; they are perfectly fine doing the relevant calculations in regards to stuff that's directly used, like money, but seem to shut down when mathematical notation is used.
- WillAdams 2y agoMy father's comment after we finally nagged him into buying the family a copy of the boardgame _Monopoly_ and playing a game: >If I'd known you kids would get so much math practice from this I would have bought it a long time ago.
- tombert 2y agoYeah, similarly, a friend of mine's kid got really into Kerbal Space Program. That friend didn't mind his kid playing that one for long periods of time, because there's a ton of real math and physics being used, but the game is relatively fun.
- Joel_Mckay 2y agoThe development challenges posed by wealth inequality was quantified in numerous studies: "Outliers: The Story of Success" (Malcolm Gladwell, 2011) https://www.amazon.com/Outliers-Story-Success-Malcolm-Gladwell/dp/0316017930 https://www.amazon.com/Outliers-Story-Success-Malcolm-Gladwe... And the psychological impact on vulnerable children has also been studied: "Inducing learned helplessness: video fragment" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTqBP-x3yR0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTqBP-x3yR0 Notably, the advanced mathematics guidance programs from the institutional outreach for children were usually by invitation only. Thus, unless you were identified as "gifted" early on, the academic content for your development is very different. Personally, I think grade-school kids in grade 7 should be introduced to physics with calculus, discreet mathematics, and linear algebra. However, the content should not be part of a graded curriculum, but rather a set of trivial daily puzzles to solve. The current academic institutions are often engaged in all sorts of policies that have nothing to do with science, or students cognitive development. YMMV, and hold out hope for tenure... lol =3
- taeric 2y agoI'm curious on this. My gut would be that NOTHING transfers between contexts by default. Instead, learning to transfer something between contexts is itself a skill that needs effort. As an easy example, just counting beats is clearly just counting. Yet counting beats and aligning transitions/changes on or off a beat is a skill you have to work on. Indeed, the same counting can help people that are running to start to even breaths out. Simple meditations often have you count a breath in, and then count it out. Just because you can count doesn't mean you will automatically be good at any of these things. There is also the question of what it means to count? Do you literally hear a voice in your head speaking the numbers away? Do you see a ticker? Do you have some other mental tally system?
- milesvp 2y agoWhat you describe is one of the fundamental “problems” of associative memories. Which is doing or recalling a thing in one context does not mean you are capable of doing or recalling the exact same thing in another context. Neurons light up based on all the current inputs, and if none of the current inputs light up the neurons that can trigger a skill, good luck doing that skill. This is why practicing in a wide variety of contexts is really important for mastery, you’re essentially increasing the odds that different inputs have a chance to trigger the knowledge that’s locked away in the structure.
- taeric 2y agoIs that, essentially, what the article is looking at? My curiosity is that this is my prior. The article is clearly framed in the opposite direction. Am I just putting too much emphasis on the headline?
- Someone 2y ago> My gut would be that NOTHING transfers between contexts by default. Once you’ve learned to write, you can write with a pen between your toes (crudely because of a lack of fine motor control), with a chisel in wood, with a spray can, men can write while peeing into snow, etc. > As an easy example, just counting beats is clearly just counting. Agreed. > Yet counting beats and aligning transitions/changes on or off a beat is a skill you have to work on. But that’s not just counting, is it? It’s counting _and_ aligning transitions/changes on or off a beat, so it requires detecting transitions/changes while counting.
- jrm4 2y agoCompletely unsurprising. (Former?) Math nerd and common core hater here; having watched myself and other kids go through all of this; beyond EARLY algebra, maybe earlier we literally should not teach any math that doesn't have an immediate and obvious use to children. (My biggest pet peeve is how Common Core teaches fun -- but unnecessary for learning -- math nerd tricks. I LOVE math nerd tricks, but they should be discovered independently and entirely optional) Now, the silver lining here is; we have a thing that does hit a lot of advanced high-school math easily. Just let them kids learn video game programming and be done with it.
- wordpad25 2y agoAdvances math helps with developing logical thinking and in general makes you smarter. But I agree we could achieve same results by teaching more practical skills. Maybe, programming (data structures and algorithms) over calculus?
- SamoyedFurFluff 2y agoI would say data structure and algorithms are not more practical to actual literal children. Better off letting them cook/bake, where they have to work out ratios, temperatures, giving one third more or quartering other portions, etc etc. let them do scoring, figure out how to split 300g of chocolate between 5 friends and the like.
- MajimasEyepatch 2y agoCalculus is so important for understanding the natural world. Being able to reason about rates of change is a valuable skill. That said, spending a bunch of time memorizing stupid identities to compute integrals is probably not the best way to teach introductory calculus.
- imtringued 2y agoDo something crazy and teach kids to write their own QP solver. That will force them to learn quadratic functions, vector norms, solving linear equations using LU decomposition, dot products, vector matrix and matrix vector multiplication, convexity, Lagrangian multipliers, etc. The quadratic programming solver can be used to calculate ordinary least squares for linear regression and controlling robot arms in real time or linear model predictive control.
- aidenn0 2y agoI can't find it now, but there was a blog article from maybe 15-20 years ago where the author, a math educator, lamented how students seem to put math in a "math box" and completely divorce it from reality. One example given was a word-problem in which a round-trip was involved and the student complained that there was no way to know they had to double the time, but then demonstrated obvious knowledge of how this worked when asked a real-world question.
- aidenn0 2y agoMy second daughter (16 years old) can bake (including e.g. making a 50% larger amount than the recipe calls for). She can beat me at games where reasoning about probabilities and numbers is involved. She can relate exactly none of that to what she is learning in her algebra classes.
- empath75 2y agoThis really has nothing to do with pedagogy and everything to do with the difference between calculations and mathematics. It's similar to the split between science and engineering. In engineering, you're applying rules of thumb to get some desired outcome. Those rules of thumb may be based on math or science, but they could also be practices that have worked before. You don't have to understand why the rules of thumb work to apply them, although it is helpful, if you do. What those kids are doing is something similar in the world of math. They have a desired outcome -- getting the correct answer, and they have a memorized list of "tricks" that get them to the correct answer quickly. They may or may not know why they work, only that they do. None of that is really helpful for learning math in a school setting, which is not just about getting the correct answer, but about understanding why the answer is correct, and understanding why those various rules work or don't work. They don't usually even teach mental math tricks in schools because the point isn't being able to calculate quickly. Probably having a catalog of addition tricks makes it even harder to learn basic school arithmetic because you have to ignore what you already know to work back up from first principles.
- inglor_cz 2y agoEven as a maths professional (20 years ago), I had trouble programming the same abstract algorithms to be fast and generally usable. It is ... non-intuitive for me. That is why I always admired work of people like Peter Montgomery or Donald Knuth.
- anon291 2y agoArithmetic in particular is from India. Indians have a long cultural history of using arithmetic. Even today, my mom who is categorically not a technical person, will randomly use a computational technique I'd never seen before to do her sewing, cooking or measuring. My grandmother, barely educated, did the same thing. They were extremely good at daily calculations. To the point where whatever I picked up off of them helped me win several 'fast math' competitions as a kid in LA. I'm not particularly good at arithmetic. My guess is that even a not really educated / barely literate Indian kid will be able to do arithmetic, simply due to cultural knowledge. The schoolchildren do well because they've been exposed to logic as well as arithmetic, and also given a systematic overview of the whole thing, whereas the market kid is just applying whatever was passed down culturally. However, I don't think we can necessarily transfer this study outside of India to assume that kids from other areas who are forced to work in markets will be good at arithmetic either. In my opinion, this is a unique cultural condition in India which reflects arithmetic's development there. Indian numerals and arithmetical algorithms were first introduced to Europe in the 13th century. The first records of their use in India go back to the first century AD. Thus, it's had a lot more time to 'soak in' to the common culture. I think it would be a good exercise in 'ethnomathematics' (is that a thing) to document all the algorithms used by the various laborers / uneducated productive workers in India. There'd probably be a few gems there. My two cents; maybe a controversial take.
- locallost 2y agoIt means almost everything is a skill that needs to be learned. Thus being successful in a school setting could mean one has successfully learned how to succeed at exams, but not really learning anything useful. I recently needed to take a test for a license of some kind, and while preparing with a set of questions noticed I can pick the correct answer without even reading. The correct answer was always much longer than the wrong answers and much more formal which was obvious by even just skimming. It also means the differences between people and their potential are in general for the vast majority of people small. Truly gifted or special is rare, as is truly giftless.
- Workaccount2 2y agoMy pet theory is that mathematics is largely taught by people who enjoy math, and who see math as a puzzle game with rules you follow to solve puzzles. Kind of like people who are addicted to sudoku or wordle. Therefore it is taught from this totally abstract perspective and just hooks others who like the game of math. Whereas I think math would have a much greater impact if it was taught from an engineering or science perspective, where math is a tool used to explore the world rather than as something that would be a game you find on the back page of the newspaper.
- alexey-salmin 2y ago> My pet theory is that mathematics is largely taught by people who enjoy math, and who see math as a puzzle game with rules you follow to solve puzzles. Kind of like people who are addicted to sudoku or wordle. I wish this was the case.
- 8note 2y agochildren wise, i'm thinking like grade 3 where i just had the one teacher for basically everything the math was really taught by the S&P workbooks. word problems in french that you have to turn into algebra and then solve, and then write out a french answer in words for the problem. its possible that doung french immersion school is better than just the second language aspects, but i imagine there is/was similar english workbooks
- SpaceManNabs 2y ago> My pet theory is that mathematics is largely taught by people who enjoy math In most of america, until 5th grade, one teacher teaches everything. In some states, in 4th grade and 5th grade, you do get some segments of specialization in course load, but even then you still have mostly one teacher. A lot of applied math courses are also taught by people that despise math and just teach that course because it was given to them and they would much rather teach a course in their main discipline. Somewhat related but very different from the point you raised, a lot of people that enjoy math, especially research, HATE teaching math. I'd actually even venture it is the majority... People like John Conway were rare. RIP. I miss seeing him around Fine Hall. And now I think of Nash :(
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chilmers 2y agoHere's the thing: I bet if you were to take the children who performed well at complex abstract mathematical problems and placed them in a job that required complex applied mathematical skill, the ones who eventually performed best would be the same. And vice-versa for the children who excelled at complex applied mathematics. So mathematical skill might not be immediately transferable, but would be a useful indicator of innate ability. This relates to the (somewhat controversial) economic theory that much of higher education is not about training or creating transferable skills, and instead is about "signaling". Essentially, we place children in simulated quasi-work settings and use it to determine who has the most of certain economically valuable abilities. By performing well at abstract mathematics, a child signals that they have the requisite mental ability to tackle similarly complex "real world" problems. But also, they signal that they are capable of obeying authority, working with diligence, delaying gratification, etc.
- sandworm101 2y agoSignalling, and simple competition. School is also about assigning numbers and ranks to students, labels that control access to higher levels of education. Collecting the correct numbers and badges opens doors irrespective of whether they are a marker of ability.
- mr_00ff00 2y agoThis idea that school is signaling is spread so often, but so much shows it’s not true. The thing that correlates highest with SAT score is household income. Household income is also a strong indicator of GPA, school competitiveness, and college attended. I suspect those with money that like the current system spread this information because it makes them feel their success is their own, and not because it was given to them. Unless you are a social Darwinist who believe the poor are genetically worse…
- monero-xmr 2y agoIn a society that leans more towards merit, where the highest compensated jobs correlate with higher IQ and analytical reasoning ability, then incomes and SAT scores will correlate. That said there are some total dumb fuck rich kids, and absolute genius poor kids. Just because there is correlation shouldn’t imply anyone is destined anywhere.
- kopirgan 2y agoVery interesting study. I guess even without conscious rote learning there's repetition involved in selling the same set of vegetables in similar quantities over months, years and customers paying in similar bills - after all there is only a few of each. So it is not surprising those skills are not transferable. However, it does show the kids are not "dumb" and schools need to make formal maths more interesting. More than the curriculum itself, teachers can make a difference, if well trained. Anecdotally I do find common maths skills have a strong correlation to general competence as perceived by others. I have always been impressed by executives that have firm grasp of numbers, even in non-financial jobs and I find they do well in their careers. They can instantly notice something that stands out, smells bad etc. A store clerk that pulls out a calculator to do simple maths gives out bad vibes.
- defrost 2y ago> A store clerk that pulls out a calculator to do simple maths gives out bad vibes. Conversely, store clerks in corner stores that use print roll tabulating calculators to add everything and reach totals give confidence to many, particulalrly those that hand over the printouts for inspection. There are patterns of argument that serial scammers use to confuse clerks about change. One of the better defence strategies is to slow walk the asserted calculation through on a calculater with print tally.
- mmooss 2y agoEvery culture develops 'marketplace' intuitive mathematics; everyone has to make change or figure out how to divide a dozen apples 4 ways. Only a few cultures develop abstract mathematics. How many have? It's even possible, like the alphabet, that only one culture invented it and others copied that one culture. HN members may be in a bubble here. In my experience, most people, even those with college degrees (and therefore some exposure to it) have a hard time grasping abstract theory of anything, especially its usefulness, and a harder time applying it. If I say, 'There is no perfect security; we need to make the attack more expensive for the attacker than it's worth to them. The existing system A is wasting resources because it is not protecting something valuable ...'; they ignore everything and might even say 'why are you telling me that?', and then 'will system B perfectly secure this asset?' It's always alarming for me. How can our world funtion well if all the value of abstract theory is discarded?
- jaco6 2y ago[dead]
- gwern 2y agoFurther evidence that human children are just LLMs whose 'capabilities' do not generalize outside the training data or are robust to even minor variation of the abstract algorithm being tested. Very sad.
- ChaitanyaSai 2y agoI run a microschool where I teach math (and I am a neuroscientist) and this is pretty obvious, and also something we see every day. And it's because we still suck at understanding learning. Learning is not the acquisition of knowledge. Learning is all the things by which we learn to model the world. And we do that, our brains do that, because it matters. Math in classrooms is pretty much designed to leach out all context. Meaningless symbols that need to be manipulated to arrive at some mysterious answers. Why bother, our minds scream out. The why is evident in street settings. Also, we are designed to pick up patterns in such meaningful settings and learn. You don't even need to teach it. Fixing learning and education means being able to articulate answers to five questions: why, what, how, when, where we learn. And all our current answers are outdated and one-size-fits-all There is also the matter of learning design. Math we use is highly compact because of its efficiency. But these can be hostile starting out. There are ways to explore mathematical concepts without using mathematical symbols. Resonant learning requires the interplay of building competence (how) and comprehension (why) and this can be done well only in meaningful settings (where) https://blog.comini.in/p/why-khanmigo-will-fail https://blog.comini.in/p/why-khanmigo-will-fail https://blog.comini.in/p/what-happens-in-math-class https://blog.comini.in/p/what-happens-in-math-class Also, the most profound revelation I've had about learning is from working on our book. Journey of the Mind. Spent twenty years at the intersection of neuroscience and AI but never really got to "understand" and "learn" how the mind works and learns until diving in and then trying to tell its story in an accessible manner. If you are interested in any of this lease do check it out
- analog31 2y ago>>> Meaningless symbols that need to be manipulated to arrive at some mysterious answers. I get what you're saying, and agree but with a caveat: Please don't take this away completely. There's always going to be a few of us freaks who came to math because of this feature: Math as an exercise in pure abstraction. We have no other refuge. As I've mentioned in this thread and others, proofs were what made math come alive for me. And I didn't struggle with applied math at all.
- ChaitanyaSai 2y ago
- reader9274 2y ago"We surveyed children...who work"
- noobermin 2y agoIn some countries this is a fact of life, despite everyone else's feelings about it.
- ibrothergang 2y agoAgreed. Strong abstract math skills often signal cognitive strength and discipline, predicting success in complex real-world tasks more than direct transfer of content.
- nxobject 2y agoHow would you take into account the converse finding by TFA? > By contrast, children with no market-selling experience (n = 471), enrolled in nearby schools, showed the opposite pattern. These children performed more accurately on simple abstract problems, but only 1% could correctly answer an applied market maths problem that more than one third of working children solved (β = 0.35, s.e.m. = 0.03; 95% confidence interval = 0.30–0.40, P < 0.001). School children used highly inefficient written calculations, could not combine different operations and arrived at answers too slowly to be useful in real-life or in higher maths.
- ch3cooh 2y agoAnother commenter mentioned that a longer study window would have been more meaningful. I agree, but for very different reasons. Instead of making this all about "intelligence," I'd argue that, even when something is understood deeply, most people (both kids and adults) are very slow and unsteady when they think about how to apply what they know in a novel context. In other words: you can understand something deeply and fluently and STILL not have this second skill set for transfering between contexts. So, in summary, if you want to study how able people are at transferring skills, I think you need to lengthen your study window and give people both a lot more time and space to explore and adapt to the new context. Also, I think the ability to transfer your skills between contexts _is a separate skill_ that you need to learn, in large part, through experience. However, both work experiences and school experiences tend to stress siloing topics and skill sets to make 'test acers' and 'experts,' so very few people get to experience building a deep skill set and then transferring it to a new context early in life, if ever. As a result, honestly, I think almost everyone has a brittle understanding of almost everything they know. The exceptions are outliers. And, when you watch people (or yourself) try to do something new, usually success is, first order, a matter of how comfortable you feel trying things, failing for a bit, and slowly learning how what you know applies to the new context. ___ Source: mostly first person experience. I've been teaching math for about half of my life: ~18 of ~36 years, and I still love it. :) Also, I didn't read through all of the comments, so apologies if someone else already contributed this idea!
- programjames 2y agoIt's pretty hard to believe the article's authors when the third sentence in the abstract labels "arithmetic" as "complex calculations". There is nothing complex about arithmetic.
- teecha 2y agoAnyone else read Mathematica by David Bessis? Snagged this one recently and his hypothesis seems to jive with these findings. He suggests that really doing vs math is a largely intuitive process that is then fact checked by logic later on. School, in his view, tends to do the logic side and ignores the intuitive which leads a lot of people to think they’re bad at math especially since they don’t get to practice the intuitive side that many people feel is reserved for those who are just good at math. Real great read tho. I’ve been working my on intuitive math since then and have found it to be a great experience.