9 ms·
Lessons in creating family photos that people want to keep (2018)
- dano 2y agoThere was a similar journey for our family after our parents passed and indeed, the photos with people doing ordinary things are the ones we share and enjoy. The Grand Canyon has a way of looking the same now as it did in 1955 and so those photos were discarded. Five boxes of photo albums were examined and the photos to keep were cut out and sent to be digitized organized by year and topic. I am glad someone wrote about their experience and the tips that come from having spent examining a life well photographed.
- pigcat 2y agoJust to share my experience: My brother and I recently digitized all our family photos. The process doesn't have to be so daunting. We found someone on facebook marketplace with a high quality scanner, and paid them to scan every photo and put it on a USB stick. I don't remember how much it cost but it was pennies per photo.
- suddenclarity 2y agoNot a dig at you but I laughed a bit when reading it. "it's not hard, just pay someone to do it for you" I get the sentiment though. I've spent countless of hours trying to read up on digitizing our VHS collection while the proper thing would've been to just have a company do it for me. The main concern for me though is that they might just run the most basic settings and I'm telling myself that doing it myself will allow me to future proof the format a bit better.
- ghaff 2y agoOutsourcing video is generally a lot more expensive. Probably worth thinking seriously about how much you really want to do.
- pigcat 2y agoHaha, yeah fair point. My comment does seem trite when you put it that way ;) The point I was trying to make (which I think you understood) was that it was _surprisingly cheap_ to outsource. In the range of ~$100 for our entire collection. I should mention that this project was undertaken because a relative's house burned down and, with it, all their family photos. So my comment is meant as encouragement for anyone sitting on a treasure trove of family photos who is thinking to digitize: do it! And to inform that this process that I thought would be very painful/tedious is something that can be outsourced for relatively cheap.
- ghaff 2y agoI agree with most of that. After doing some in-house scanning I sent a bunch of stuff out. At the time, there was a company in CA that put stuff on a pallet to India. A bit butt clenching but it was great and I wrote a review for CNET where I was in the Blog Network at the time. https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/reviewing-the-results-of-a-scancafe-order/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/reviewing-the-result... Was probably more selective than you. And agree that a lot of the day-to-day stuff outside of the house in particular simply wasn't recorded. No photos of my mother's chemistry lab for example. I've thrown a lot of stuff out but could probably get more scanned but not sure after looking at it if another pass is worthwhile.
- dtgriscom 2y agoMy dad took thousands of photos of us over the years. His big rule: every photo should include some family, and some landscape.
- netsharc 2y agoMy startup idea is to put all those rules into an AI-engine and feed it my photo collection. Just kidding..! But damn, a lot of my photos are of the scenery...
- raldi 2y agoThis is excellent, though modern cameras (let’s be real, phones) tagging photos with timestamps and geolocation obviates a few of the recommendations.
- bredren 2y agoiPhone handles face recognition as well. Also memories provide automatic collections of note, taking into account view and sharing patterns. I suspect the process of making photos meaningful and surfacing gems will continue to improve. So yes, take certain kinds of photos but more than anything capture photos (and video) in highest possible quality when it doesn’t disrupt experiences.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- barrettondricka 2y agoI just scrolled through my gallery, and the number of meaningful photos I had was zero. Snapped a photo of my room first thing.
- Brajeshwar 2y agoI tend to keep the first picture taken by a new device to be that of my daughters. :-)
- bombcar 2y agoThis is something that I find surprisingly hard to locate - even in a house with thousands of pictures taken in it, simple pictures of how the living room is laid out are rare to non-existent. You have to piece together the evidence from other photos just to remember how it was.
- esafak 2y agoGood lessons. If you are using a cell phone, make sure the location is recorded.
- pinoy420 2y ago[flagged]
- nejsjsjsbsb 2y agoUser name checks out
- Lammy 2y agoThe location metadata is just for me. They already know where you are at all times if you carry a cellular-networked device at all. Modern 5G tech enables them to track you with centimeter-level precision and in fact “““requires””” spying on your precise location to work at all thanks to the beamforming/MIMO: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2209.01183 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2209.01183
- aaronax 2y agoAnd if you use Nextcloud on Android to back up your photos, it may have been not syncing the location since mid-December when Google removed certain permissions from the App Store version. I bit peculiar and specific but came to mind and may save some person's geotagging.
- Rygian 2y agoNot sure to follow. My Nextcloud app on Android doesn't require location permission. And its job is not too geo-tag photos (that's for the camera app instead), but rather to sync whole files.
- aaronax 2y agoThe automatic sync function of the Nextcloud app ends accessing the photos in a way that doesn't include the location metadata of the photo. So the file it puts on your Nextcloud server does not have the location metadata. https://github.com/nextcloud/android/issues/14409 https://github.com/nextcloud/android/issues/14409 Fortunately (I think?) the auto-upload seems to become unreliable in general so people are more likely to notice that funny things are happening.
- s2l 2y agoWorth mentioning photoprim, if you maintain photos on local hardware, nas, etc. https://www.photoprism.app/ https://www.photoprism.app/
- elric 2y agoMeh, not too fond of it. Great concept, but poorly executed. E.g. there's automatic people tagging based on faces it recognizes, but no way to tag additional people that it missed. Maybe it will get better in time, but for now it isn't really helping me organize my pictures.
- SoftTalker 2y agoI inherited similar boxes of thousands of unorganized photos when my mom died. I threw them all away. They weren’t meaningful enough to her to organize, and they meant even less to me. My lesson is I don’t take photos. I realized long ago that I never look at them again.
- elevatedastalt 2y agoI've read lots of bizarre stuff on HN but this one really takes the cake. I'm not even going to argue coz something tells me it's going to be futile.
- akaru 2y agoBots, or people who think like them.
- dsego 2y agoI think the vernacular nowadays is NPCs.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThere’s nothing to argue about. If you like taking pictures and enjoy looking at them later that’s great. I don’t. I have maybe 10 photos saved on my phone over several years. I never look at old photos or albums. Certainly not going to spend tons of time organizing thousands of old photos that I didn’t even know about and that had just been sitting in boxes for 30 years.
- preommr 2y agoNot OP, but I also don't like taking pictures nor do I ever keep any. I just don't like thinking about the past and the feelings they often bring up. Whether that's guilt over not talking to relatives that have passed, or the sadness from remembering how a good relationship ended badly, or even the good times that my current life doesn't allow to continue because people have gone their separate ways. I don't know if it's healthy, maybe, maybe not. But it lets me go through the days a bit easier.
- CharlieDigital 2y agoIf you can, get yourself a DJI Osmo Pocket 3 and a drone. Completely transformed our catalog of memories. When you weave scenery with experiences and people, something magical happens. Our recent trip to Taiwan: https://youtu.be/7LWxVzZco0A https://youtu.be/7LWxVzZco0A
- rawgabbit 2y agoI heard a lot of good things about the DJI Osmo and their action camera. I have been reluctant as they require you to install an app to use their products?
- CharlieDigital 2y agoNo app required; you can bypass the registration of the cameras. Drone is a different story; I think you have to register that (can't remember).
- WhyNotHugo 2y agoRecent models will brick themselves after a few shots if you don’t do the online registration and activation process.
- prawn 2y agoI have six drones, an Osmo Pocket 2, Insta360 Go 2, GoPro, etc but I barely use the pocket cameras because the workflow to extract content for day-after story-telling via phone feels quite tedious. If you were only going to ingest footage post-trip and make a piece (as per the YouTube example), then I think it's less painful. A decent phone with good stabilisation can handle that though. That said, two advantages for the Osmo Pocket: - footage is not clogging up your phone storage, which can be particularly annoying if you are often unable to backup to the cloud - it is literally pocket-sized, a nice form-factor compared to GoPro, and pretty quick to get out and use.
- CharlieDigital 2y ago
- arscan 2y agoGreat tips in here! And I know this isn’t about videos… but, don’t forget about videos. I love taking pictures. In particular, candid moment-capturing portraits that reveal something about the subject. Also, technically challenging ones with really long exposures (eg around a campfire), or narrow depth of field (eg of my kids playing in the backyard). I like to think I’ve taken plenty of “good” photos of my family over the years. But something I’ve found is what I go back to the most are those poor quality, poorly edited, silly little videos I take of my family just living life. I used to avoid video because the outcome was just too hard to control. They would never turn out “good”. But flipping through my digital albums now, I wish i took more videos. A poor video can capture a lot… maybe even more than a great picture. So I find myself taking a lot more videos now.
- prismatix 2y agoI gave my daughter a toy camera around age 2.5 or 3 and didn't realize it also captured video. She had unintentionally discovered the video function and has since captured many conversations, photos of our old house, videos of car rides, and loving moments between our family. She's had it for almost 3 years now and it's been one of her longest lasting toys and is, without a doubt, the most meaningful. It gives "seeing the world through her eyes" a whole new meaning.
- ErigmolCt 2y agoThat’s absolutely beautiful! It will be so priceless for her when she grows up...
- _tom_ 2y agoI suggest backing it up in multiple places. Electronic forms are so much less durable than physical.
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 2y agoWhat kind of toy camera?
- kleinishere 2y ago
- julianpye 2y agoThere are two categories of family photos: 1) Photos you look at when the subjects are still alive 2) Photos that you remember people by and cherish people for 1 = are all the typical family group pics, lots of posing 2 = the photos where the subjects may not even know that they are being photographed, while doing the things they are cherished for by others. Sometimes they might not even like the presented actvities, but everyone else around them appreciates it . - Photos of people repairing their family's gadgets - Photos of people doing mundane tasks, ironing their clothes, cooking dinner for everyone, being exhausted, reading to others... - This is what prevails while people are still alive who remember you. What you will be remembered by. Mostly what you did for other people and how people observed you. Take photos of your parents and loved relatives during daily life and their tasks. You will be far more moved and inspired by these pics, than by typical family group photos.
- MarkMarine 2y agoAgree, but the other part of the advice I think is important and maybe even not fully explained in this blog post. Taking great photos is about using great light, this matters more than composition (you can crop in post) in my opinion. Rule of thirds is just a guideline, not a rule, if you’ve got great light and an interesting subject I couldn’t care less where those thirds lines sit. I mostly shoot on an old hassleblad with 6x6 square negatives and I often frame my shots with my subjects in the middle of the frame. I have also done what the OP is describing, scanning all my family’s negatives. I wanted to devote the amount of time it takes me to scan and color correct a frame to a scant few of the images. My family liked to take “snaps” of places and vacations (think non-descript cornfields or national park visitor centers) and hostage photos of the kids clearly taken against our will. I taught myself how to shoot on film to learn what I was doing, but going to the community darkrooom was the real education. I learned how good photographers used the light and saw the world by watching them develop and seeing the end product. Photography is just like any other endeavor, you get out of it what you put into it. For your kids and your kids kids, don’t just put into it some AI-computationally adjusted selfies and snaps of the tops of kids heads. Put some effort in, figure out what good light is, and take candid photos.
- 2y ago
- Lammy 2y agoI need to do this with the giant pile of Polaroids I found in my dad's closet. For me it hasn't been any technical or logistical barrier, just an emotional one. I know I need to do it before something happens to them that makes me regret waiting, but I just haven't had it in me yet even after two years. > I bought a heavy-duty slide scanner to help me process the images. It’s a Canon CanoScan 9000F. I like it, in case you’re shopping for an affordable unit; in particular, I do not loathe the built-in software, which sets it apart from other scanners I’ve used. I hope this is not unwelcome as it is admittedly tangential to the actual topic of this post, but this line makes me want to throw out an unsolicited recommendation for VueScan from Hamrick Software: https://www.hamrick.com/ https://www.hamrick.com/ I am not affiliated with them in any way aside from being an extremely happy customer. Easily the most value I've ever gotten out of a piece of shareware, perpetually licensed, supporting Windows, Mac, and Linux. I got into it to revive a '90s scanner whose software wouldn't work at all on modern computers, and I've come to prefer it over all OEM software even on my newer gear. Truly the great equalizer that makes the hardware features the only things which matter. I currently use it with a Microtek ScanMaker 9800XL (when I want CCD+CCFL scanning and/or large-format scanning) and an Epson PerfectionV700 (when I want CMOS+LED scanning). It supports the film/transparency scanning features of both if you have the appropriate expansion lids. Here's a random screenshot from my shots folder, not of transparency scanning but it's what I have on me. It does have a lot of built-in cleanup options which I use with about a 50:50 mix of cleanup in Photoshop CS3. I especially like its built-in debayering https://i.imgur.com/xfBwZq8.png https://i.imgur.com/xfBwZq8.png > Include the photographer. I have few pictures of my father, because he was always the guy behind the camera. When he did ask someone to take a picture it was always posed, such as “Mom and Pop standing in front of the Grand Canyon.” In my experience as a frequent traveler of the US West, it's rare now to even be asked. For me probably fewer than five times. I don't know if people these days feel uncomfortable asking due to how damaged and low-trust society has become thanks to those who need us all to hate each other so they can stay in charge, or if people have just been out of the habit for so long that they never had that example and thus don't even think of it. I've started keeping an eye out for groups of people posing for photographs, especially when they are visibly families vacationing with kids, and I will ask them if they want a group shot if I read them as amenable to it. Some people say no, even once in a while aggressively so, but the acceptance rate is incredibly high and it makes me happy to be able to give them those memories. It probably helps that I am visibly non-threatening in a privileged way that society does-but-should-not enable, and that I'm usually carrying a chonky mirrorless camera on a strap so people are less likely to think I'd steal their phone lol > Even though I spent much of my childhood writing letters, there is only one photo of me with a pen in my hand — and that was taken by a friend at summer camp. Yet my friends and family all recall me with a book or pen within reach. My father never captured that essential part of who I was. It's interesting to see the way the human mind works here. We take photos on vacations and of unique events due to their novelty making them feel like something that can't be re-experienced, and we don't photograph the day-to-day activities because they are so familiar to us while we're in those stages of our lives. Turns out it's the other way around: the Grand Canyon will always be there, and the people won't :/ > Crop photos closely. My father took a lot of photos of “Mom in front of a pretty vista” but in the long run I care more about Mom’s expression than the expanse of mountains in the background. Thanks to iPhoto I can zoom in, but a lot of detail is lost. These days when we're all digital and not paying per roll of film, I take both. Zoom with your feet. It doesn't have to become an overwhelming number of photos — just two. Tying back to my earlier comment, when I offer to take a photo for people I usually tell them I'm going to take one of the scene and then walk forward and take one more. I did this just two weeks ago for a very appreciative family at the National Museum of Nuclear Science & History at Kirtland AFB. One wide landscape shot of them where you can read the building façade and tell where they were, and one tight portrait shot of just them :)
- __mharrison__ 2y agoI wish I had more videos of my kids when they were very young. That is what they seem to me the most interested in right now.
- larusso 2y agoI can understand the sentiment not to add extra work of scanning pictures of items that have seemingly not changed over the years. But I personally find these pictures interesting. I love to look at old pictures of say a square or a street and see how much or little has changed. I guess it depends on the viewer but I hope my kids don‘t feel the need to dump the hundreds and thousands of pictures of things they’re not a focus of. But I agree 100% on the non staged photo motive part. I took a lot of photos of my kids over the years and other people asked me to do the same for their kids. With the question why the fotos looked so good. I always explained my two secrets. 1. Go down to the same level as your kid. Most parents snap pictures of their little ones from above. This looks like a screenshot from the eye. The different perspective to see a kid how another kid sees it is more fascinating. 2. Don‘t Stage the Fotos. Try to capture interesting moments. You may have to lurk or wait. If you know the person well you get a feeling when a certain emotion will show on their face. That is something a staged photo won‘t give you. Doing group photos like this becomes more and more difficult of course. And when kids age they become more and more aware of the camera.
- genewitch 2y agoMy wife and I* scanned 4000+ film prints with an Epson scanner I bought in frustration at not finding a well regarded negative scanner. It took a weekend. They're untagged except by any writing on the film packs or the photos themselves. It isn't that big of a deal. I'd do it for pay for other people if someone absolutely needed it, but it isn't that hard. 100GB including the static gallery site I set up, currently in glacier and on two NAS.
- wrboyce 2y agoToo late now I assume, but I use an OpticFilm 8300i and it is great (software wise I use VueScan and Lightroom paired with Negative Lab Pro).
- genewitch 2y agothat didn't exist in 2017 when we did these scans - all the negative scanners were approaching $5000 or more, and were very fiddly and manual. However they did give great output. The epson print scanner did great, though, and there was no fiddling. Put prints in the top, push a button, collect prints from the bottom 15 seconds later, type a folder/collection name, repeat the process. good to see there's a competitive negative scanner in the sphere, now!
- gue-ni 2y agoI really wish people would stop using medium.com. There is no real benefit, it is so easy to host a website and Medium keeps paywalling content that other people have written.
- mikewarot 2y agoIf you just start taking photos (with permission) and keep taking them eventually your subjects will get used to you being there and start acting normally again in most cases. It doesn't cost anything to take photos, except your time, so just keep spamming the trigger. Each exposure is a chance at a good photo, for the most part. The thing about family photos that's most important is to have THE NAMES of everyone in the photo, not "mom" or "lucy"... actual full names, so that someone in a generation or two can actually understand who is who. My wife's family had that... but then the photos were ripped out of the album, and all context was lost. 8( As much as possible, I've got every face tagged in my photos so sproutlet has something useful when the time comes.
- Pooge 2y ago> It doesn't cost anything to take photos, except your time, so just keep spamming the trigger This, this, this, and this!!! My mother is the one that takes the initiative of taking pictures of people during events (whether important or just small outings). What she has a hard time understanding is that you must spam the trigger. She tries to frame the picture perfectly, and everyone on their most photogenic faces. Then, she takes ONE shot and oh... somebody closed their eyes a bit. "Let's go for another one, everyone go back in place!" What she doesn't understand is that the best and most memorable pictures isn't the one where people are smiling straight into the camera. It's when people are doing something they enjoy and don't even notice the camera and don't do a perfect model pose. I'm lucky if I delete only 9 of the 10 photos I took!
- wrboyce 2y agoI’ve actually found a lot of benefit in the exact opposite. I started shooting film which does have a pretty big cost per trigger press and it has forced me to consider each shot a lot more. For me, I found having hundreds of photos on my DSLR’s SD card a daunting task and the raw photos would sit for months before I’d get around to reviewing them (if I even bothered at all). Sitting down and spending an evening developing/scanning/converting negatives, however, I find rather enjoyable. To each their own; I think the important thing is to find a workflow that works for you so you can capture as many memories as possible!
- spiffotron 2y agoDoes anyone have any recommendations of a site or a self-hosted option for uploading photo collections? I’d love to share photos of our child with the grandparents but end up just sending the odd snap through WhatsApp, it would be nice to make an actual collection.
- Bishonen88 2y agoSynology NAS with their photos app can do that. I.e. create albums and share them with other people
- spiffotron 2y agoI even have a Synology NAS and for some reason have never thought to use it for this
- reddalo 2y agoI highly suggest Immich [1], it's an open-source and self-host alternative for Google Photos. It's still under very active development, but I think it's the best out there. [1] https://immich.app/ https://immich.app/
- spiffotron 2y agoThis looks really nice
- rsolva 2y agoCheck out ente.io, they offer both hosted and self-hosted.
- ochrist 2y agoI self-host an instance of Lychee for all my family photos: https://lycheeorg.dev/ https://lycheeorg.dev/ There are things I really like, e.g. that you can restrict access per user. But there's no comment/chat/discussion facility, so you cannot easily get feedback on your photos. There's also NextCloud, but I think the solutions there are a bit more rudimentary. However, if you already use NextCloud (or a similar solution like a CMS for example), you could look for a plugin. https://nextcloud.com/ https://nextcloud.com/
- ErigmolCt 2y ago> Take the best quality photos you can. Your grandchildren will appreciate it Really resonates! Any photo taken could become a priceless window into the past for future generations
- anal_reactor 2y agoI don't know, I never really cared about photos other people take, and I neither did I show my photos to other people. When I die, there will be nobody left to care about any of the photos I took. I guess I'm just not a family type Strangely, the thought that my porn collection will be dumped is more unsettling
- 8fingerlouie 2y agoOur photo library currently consists of 300,000 photos. It goes back 20 years, and while i would like to say it is curated, the sheer amount of photos makes that task pretty much impossible. We take a lot of photos, both of family/friends/pets, but also landscapes and nature, and when curating the photo library, i often find myself deleting the landscape photos of 10 years ago. We don't need to keep 200+ photos of sunsets. Yes it was a pretty sunset, but there are hundreds of those every year, and unless it includes photos of our family or something else "special", the photo doesn't stand out, and will eventually be a candidate for being deleted. I just finished the years curating, and have deleted almost 60,000 photos from the library. Sunsets, blurry photos (that doesn't have any other value), screenshots, and lots more. Eventually i will however have to curate it even more. When our kids eventually "inherit" the photo library, they'll most likely be overwhelmed by the sheer size of it, and simply discard it. On the other hand i don't want to leave them without photos of their childhood, and who's to say what matters to them as memories.
- cm2187 2y agoIf you can code, you can run them by AWS rekognition to do face recognition. It works amazingly well (you need a score >98 for a match). Where I am impressed is that it is also remarkably resilient to faces aging, and in some case identify some toddlers from an adult face. In your case if it only goes 20 years it is maybe less critical, but in my case I have photos going back to late XIX century, and good luck guessing who was that toddler without a legend!
- disgruntledphd2 2y agoHilariously, Google photos is really bad at this. It's decided that my daughter and I are the same person, and refuses to let me update this (i keep trying and it keeps getting set back to my name).
- austin_y 2y agoI had a similar experience with Google Photos where it merged the "profiles" of my two children. Like you, I tried separating them back out manually, with no real success. Ultimately, I turned the face identification feature off entirely (which has the effect of deleting all of the face data), and then turned it back on. It took a day or so for Google Photos to start re-indexing the photos in earnest, but that fixed the issue for me, and it was less work than the manual re-tagging that I had tried before.
- cm2187 2y agoI second his opinion. No point to take the 15 million's photo of the eiffel tower. Loved ones of course. But also the street! What I find the most interesting in old family pictures is a window into how people I know, or only apart by only one degree of separation, lived at a completely different time. What seemed mundane at the time is often the most amusing a century later. That's also what I like in old movies. Like just the streets of Paris in the early 70s look foreign to a modern eye. Hardly any traffic, you could park anywhere, hardly any advertising boards.
- pbhjpbhj 2y ago>No point to take the 15 million's photo of the eiffel tower. // One proviso to this - it's a travel record. The next picture is a couple standing at the door to an apartment... but where is it... 'oh yeah Paris; your mother and i visited college friends. Forgot we'd even been there'. Sure, way better with a person on the frame, but recognisable landmarks can still have utility in a photo collection. I was working through my parent's slides and found pictures of St.Marks square -- didn't even know they had been to Italy.
- alistairSH 2y agoAbsolutely. For capturing memories, try to think about photos in small series... Family at a Metro stop Generic Eiffel Tower photo Family at Eiffel Tower Family eating a baguette walking down a random street Etc. As you say, they all provide context and often tell more of a story than a single candid of the family.
- torbjornbp 2y agoI'm in the middle of a similar project but using a mirrorless camera with a macro lens and a repro stand. I second most of this, but would like to offer a different opinion about triage. In my experience, doing the triage often takes as much time as digitizing the slides. "Mindless" mass digitization where I just optimize for throughput has been a good strategy for the collections I've worked on. Instead I'm more careful of what I choose to post process after I digitization. I haven't been throwing much away yet, I usually just don't process the stuff I don't find interesting. Storage is cheap these days.
- turbojet1321 2y agoI thought that was a strange approach, too - I'd have thought it'd be far quicker to cull post-scanning. Plus, then you have the whole catalog digitized in case someone else wants to come along and make different editorial choices later on.
- simmschi 2y agoThese points are also useful for your own photo library. Forget about your relatives going through your stuff after you die, that doesn't matter. But which of the hundreds of photos you took over the past few years would you look at again? Right, it's the same kind of pictures mentioned in the article. Life happening. The kids helping you cooking, mom goofing around, the family hiking etc etc. It's not the landscape, some flowers, fireworks, a beach usually. What you care about are people and the moments you spent with them.
- z3t4 2y agoI wonder what will happen to the photos we take today, if they will "bit rot". The HDD and cloud storage wont last forever, maybe 20 years if we are lucky, or until someone stops paying the monthly fee. Meanwhile these films have lasted for 40+ years.
- turbojet1321 2y agoThis is a good point. I have a backup strategy that includes cloud and offline HDDs, but at some point, when I'm not around to keep it all running, it'll probably just be family getting them off my laptop. I should probably look at writing to bluray at some point.
- z3t4 2y agoI got hold on a bunch of classic PC games that where 10+ years old and lots of the CD's had data errors, so I wouln't bet on disc burning although plastic can last a long time so it has potential, maybe a startup idea, burning family albums on special bluerays that will last a long time =) also the lasers get old as well, so there might be difficult to find a working blyeray reader 50 years from now, but just like the environment it's not our problem right now :P
- jwr 2y agoThere is a related problem, which I hit while scanning family archives going back slightly more than 100 years. There is no good photo archival software. If you now rushed to click "reply" to say that yes, of course there is, right here, hold your horses. You probably do not understand the problem. Good photo archival software would let me keep my photos in formats that will be readable 25 years from now. It must not rely on any company being in business or offering any service. It must support storing the same picture in multiple formats. It must support assigning dates to pictures that are not the same as the file date nor the EXIF date. It must support assigning imprecise dates (just a year, or ideally an interval). It must support storing multiple files as part of the same "image", and I do not mean multiple versions/formats of an image here. Examples: front and back of a scanned paper photo, or 24 scans of a large format picture that are then merged together into a resulting stitched image. All that information must be preserved in ways that will let me recover it even without any software (e.g. files in the filesystem). I used many solutions over the years, and got royally screwed by most, the most recent one being Apple shutting down Aperture (which did most of these things pretty well). I am now close to writing my own software. EDIT: to all those who respond with "just store it as files" — yes, of course they should be stored as files. But that's not an answer. You do want searchability, nice visual access, and other niceties on top of the basic plumbing.
- tomjen3 2y agoSounds like you need to store photos in a folder structure. That’s about as universal as it gets
- DavidPiper 2y agoThis was my first reaction too, but it scratches an itch for me as well - I've thought about making a proper photo archival system many times and just never got around to giving it a shot.
- michaelt 2y agoMy photo archival software is jpegs in a directory called 'photos'. Sometimes with subdirectories by date. Backed up however I'm backing up my computer. For true durability, you've got to embrace the lowest common denominator. Those rare features you can only get from Software X will lock you into Software X. If you want your archive to outlive Software X, you gotta do without them.
- DanielBMarkham 2y agoI lost all of my photos (along with everything else) when growing up, so taking pictures and videos was important to me as I became an adult. I'm 59 now. In the 1990s I started taking VHS videos of family events. Sometimes I would walk around "interviewing", sometimes I would walk around and try to normally talk to people while holding that huge recorder. (That didn't work). I even set it up on a tripod and just let the recorder run while my parents and others visited. This past year I've ripped a couple of dozen DVDs out of all of those tapes. In the past two weeks I've then ffmpeg'ed them to mp4s and loaded on an SD drive and put in a e-picture frame. Now we have 30-40 hours of "family memory TV" playing constantly in our living room. It is one of the most amazing things I've done with technology. I can't describe the feeling of looking back 30+ years to see folks who are long gone -- or now adults with their own kids! God I'm glad I didn't record all of this on a cell phone or use social media. It would have been impossible to have the patience and time to scale all of those walled gardens for this project. Best videos? The "family interview show", where I ask questions and everybody performs some kind of art. Wish I'd done one of those every year. Second best? Just setting the cam up and letting it run. Third place are videos of family members doing things that'll never happen again, like watching a sonogram of a new baby on the way. Worst videos? As I know (and knew at the time!), a bunch of videos and pictures of things we were looking at that were interesting to us at the time but stuff you could find online in a couple of seconds. Unless it has audio commentary, it was a pointless exercise.
- kowlo 2y agoBeautiful and inspiring. Can you share the specific e-picture frame you mentioned?
- Damogran6 2y agoNot the OP, but I've had great experience with Aura frames...Costco sells them each year on the run-up to Christmas.
- slumberlust 2y agoThanks for sharing, this is wholesome.
- yakkomajuri 2y ago"Whereupon, three days after my father formally retired in 1988, he died in his sleep." There's a deep point here about approaching life as it pertains to all the things we say we'll do after we retire.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoMemento mori
- TwoFerMaggie 2y ago> I remember Pop telling me how much cheaper Ektachrome was (compared to Kodachrome) gone are the days when ektachromes are considered the cheaper options.. now they are one of if not the most expensive 35mm format films
- jccalhoun 2y agoI'm scanning in my family slides and right now I'm scanning in when my dad was in the Vietnam war. The shots of the Vietnamese and the town are fascinating.
- alekratz 2y agothere's this wisdom I read a long time ago: "there's millions of photos of the Grand Canyon. There's only one or two photos of the Grand Canyon with you in it."
- qq66 2y agoMy advice? Never take a photo again. Only video. Video is so much more powerful for re-experiencing memories.
- BeetleB 2y agoI've been doing both for the last decade+ I have a daily cron job that shows me the entries for this day in past years (i.e. all Jan 27 entries). Yes, videos are more fun to look at. But people don't have the patience to watch more than a minute or two at a time. They can quickly scan 20-30 images and focus on the interesting one(s). But if they see 10 videos, they'll start a few, and after a number of seconds start "seeking" forward to see if there is something interesting. Or they'll watch the first 1-2 videos completely, and skip the rest. So take both types!
- moolcool 2y agoI strongly disagree. Photography can tell stories which videos can't (and vice versa). For example, compare at this image: https://i.imgur.com/pmfMUYc.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/pmfMUYc.jpeg To this video containing the same moment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UdsVO7HaJg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UdsVO7HaJg Look at the player's emotion in the image. What he feels in that split-second, the look in his eyes, gets lost if you just see the video. Look at the out of focus area. The boys in the top-right hugging, the older couple in the older couple in the top-left who can't believe their eyes, the other players reacting to the home run. Look at the bat, suspended in mid-air with no motion-blur. The object which kicked off the celebration completely frozen in time. Everyone in the photo is looking at where the ball went, but the player is looking at the bat. TL;DR: Because it (generally) takes much longer to look at a photo than it does to actually create a photo, there's a time dilation that goes on. You can freeze a single moment, and then take the time later to absorb everything which goes on in it.
- qq66 2y agoI'm not talking about 1) professional journalism or 2) sports. I'm talking about casual family day-to-day stuff.
- probably_wrong 2y agoOne criticism and one suggestion. As for "include the photographer": unfortunately the photographer (aka me) is usually the only one who reads these articles. Whenever I ask someone else to take pictures of me they ask me to strike an artificial pose and then take a full-body shot. Hopefully one day my nephews will say "we don't know what uncle probably_wrong really looked like, but his pictures were great". As for the suggestion: I stick to the rule "do not make albums with more than 36 pictures" which is the number of photos a roll of film used to deliver reliably. If you take 300 pictures and stick to the top 1% you'll quickly learn which pictures are worth keeping. Your friends and family will be silently grateful.
- patatino 2y agoHow do you guys organize your photos to give to your kids one day? We just have too many photos and videos. I like it, but I try to make some form of a library that has the best photos of each year/vacation/birthday, etc. There is no need to see 50 photos of each vacation or birthday, but it's nice to see 3-5 and have the ability to dig deeper if you want to.
- turbojet1321 2y agoI take a ton of photos. I cull probably 80%. The remaining ones are all pretty good/interesting/meaningful. I end up with maybe 1000 for a year, then pick maybe 100 of those to make into a photo book for the year, which is what the kids actually look at.
- renewiltord 2y agoDoes anyone have a recommendation for a self-hosted photo app that pushes to commercial cloud storage behind the scenes intelligently (I.e. I don't want thumbnails stored there etc) and which can use a local GPU for person-identification, scene identification etc.
- Balgair 2y ago> Labels matter. Even a few words helped me know when-and-where something happened: “1955 Nova Scotia” or my grandfather’s name. One of the saddest experiences was looking at a family-gathering photo from the 50s with several people in it, and having no idea who’s in it. Dear lord, yes. My in-laws have just boxes and boxes of photos, some going way back into the late 1800s. The old ones are mostly people and faces. But we have no idea who these people are. My in-laws think they are related to them, otherwise, why would they be kept? But not a clue who this person is. It's terribly sad in a way. My spouse doesn't want to throw it all away, it's family history presumably, but we have no idea if it'll ever be a history we know. And so they sit in an attic, waiting for some magical technology to rescue it. Labels matter.
- mc3301 2y agoMy friend owns a little "clean out old houses" business in Japan. Recently we threw out dozens of large boxes of old photographs; the grandma told us she didn't need them anymore. The rest of the family all had their own lives in Tokyo, and could care less about the past. Sad to see, but I've seen it many many times.
- lmm 2y agoOnline photo libraries have gotten much better at matching up people in photos over the last few years. I don't think it's completely crazy to assume that they might one soon be able to figure out something useful about family relations too (e.g. this mystery person was at these 3 known people's weddings, so they're likely another sibling of so-and-so).
- inasio 2y agoSays David Lynch as John Ford [0]: When the horizon's at the bottom, it's interesting. When the horizon's at the top, it's interesting. When the horizon's in the middle, it's boring as shit! [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5mAyNNBOdns&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5mAyNNBOdns&t=2s
- angst_ridden 2y agoMany years ago, I built http://legacy-labeler.com http://legacy-labeler.com so people could label their photos for posterity. It's admittedly clumsy, and nobody uses it.
- vachina 2y agoAlso: Try to give everyone the same good camera. I gave my girlfriend a pro iPhone very early in the relationship, anticipating tons of photo taking, and it paid off. The phone could capture any moment, even challenging ones and very easily share it with her family and me.