12 ms·
No Bitcoin ETFs at Vanguard (2024)
- vincefutr23 2y agoIf you’re saying “blockchain, not crypto” in 2025, you need to revisit your research process
- xyst 2y agoAs the price of digital currency goes up, the number of hit pieces from banking industry increases proportionately.
- paulgb 2y agoI know it's more fun to believe there is a sinister conspiracy among the financial industry to keep bitcoin down when it starts to go up, but occam's razor here is that these firms get asked more about bitcoin/crypto/etc. when retail interest is up which also tends to be when the prices go up.
- bongodongobob 2y agoYeah what would they know about risk analysis. You're defo smarter.
- andrewfromx 2y ago[flagged]
- tossandthrow 2y agoThere are only 77200sqm of land in Nebraska, do you want to be one out of the 77200 people to own a full square mile?
- s3graham 2y ago> Do you want to be one of the 21 million humans out of 8 billion that own a full BTC? No?
- andrewfromx 2y agoTo be in the top 21 million richest people world wide, you would likely need a net worth of approximately 4 to 5 million USD. It seems like a no brainer to pick up 1 BTC for 100k and hold it.
- TheBozzCL 2y agoNo thanks
- seanhunter 2y agoUnless it’s just nonsense and worth nothing. Then you’ve just set fire to 100k.
- paulryanrogers 2y ago> It seems like a no brainer to pick up 1 BTC for 100k and hold it. Based on what evidence will BTC be going up to 4-5 million? And how many of us can drop 100K on some speculative multi year (decade) bet?
- basejumping 2y agoWhy would the people holding all the 21mln bitcoins be the richest people in the world?
- andrewfromx 2y agoThey are not. My logic goes currently how many billionaires are there world wide: about 2,640. Then work backwards, how much networth do you need to be in the top 21 million people world wide: 4-5 million.
- basejumping 2y agoWhy did you pick up 21 mln people? Just to make a contrived connection to the number of bitcoins?
- the_gastropod 2y ago
- jgalt212 2y ago> And yet no one has broken bitcoin encryption and there will only ever be 21 million bitcoins What if the chain by consensus agrees there can be 210 million bitcoins?
- andrewfromx 2y agoabout as likely as someone breaking the secp256k1 elliptic curve algo.
- kinakomochidayo 2y agoBitcoin will need to add tail emission due to the security budget issues as block rewards go down and there isn’t enough transaction fees to support miners
- napierzaza 2y ago[dead]
- auc 2y agoAnd what will I do with this full BTC?
- Ekaros 2y agoCertainly not spend it. Which brings the whole issue clear. What will you do with "currency" you won't spend.
- dghlsakjg 2y ago> And yet no one has broken bitcoin encryption and there will only ever be 21 million bitcoins. Do you want to be one of the 21 million humans out of 8 billion that own a full BTC? This in no way rebuts the argument that Vanguard makes.
- hendersoon 2y agoSure, if you're offering. Otherwise they're a speculative investment that carries a ton of risk, so I won't be investing my own money. I've had this stance since the very beginning and obviously have been wrong the whole time, so take that as you will.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y ago> Do you want to be one of the 21 million humans out of 8 billion that own a full BTC That, it a nutshell, is the epitome of every scamming huckster hawking anything from all time. Don't recommend it for it's underlying utility or value, just try to build FOMO because it's rare (and artificially so, at that!) Your pitch is exactly the same as the Beanie Baby and NFT salesmen.
- andrewfromx 2y agoSo gold is ok because it's natural and BTC is not because its rareness is artificial? But in the year 2085 if BTC is still rare what does the natural vs artificial matter?
- ceejayoz 2y agoGold sucks as a backing for an economy (for similar reasons!), which is why everyone moved off it.
- andrewfromx 2y agobut surely Vanguard has funds with gold?
- Polizeiposaune 2y agoNot really. Jack Bogle (Vanguard's founder) saw little value in speculating on commodities. Vanguard used to a have a "Precious Metals and Mining Fund" but they renamed it to "Vanguard Global Capital Cycles Fund" and broadened its mandate/portfolio.
- zeroCalories 2y agoGold is better because it can be used(industrial applications, bling, etc). Value investors like Buffet still hate gold for the same reasons listed by vanguard.
- 1of21million_ 2y ago
- TheAmazingRace 2y ago> Do you want to be one of the 21 million humans out of 8 billion that own a full BTC? This reeks of culty in-group speak.
- seanhunter 2y agoI am selling digital rocks that scare away digital tigers. There are only going to be 21 of them. They should therefore by your logic be a million times more valuable than a BTC. Don’t you want to be one of only 21 humans out of 8 billion to own one?
- cr125rider 2y agoI have 12 unique rocks at my house. No other one in the world is exactly like it. Want to be left out and not have on!? I’ll sell you one for $100,000!
- arp242 2y agoLord Percy, are they nuggets of pure green?
- jitl 2y agoAt the end of the day, it’s some bytes with no inherit value other than the memetic fomo of artificial scarcity. It’s only interesting or exciting (to me) because there are people who will buy it, so you can get rich “speculating” that if you hold, the price will go up so you can unload to a bigger fool. At least with Etherium there’s some intrinsic value in terms of distributed computation.
- leishman 2y ago"We do have a lot of interest in blockchain, the technology behind cryptocurrencies. We believe its application to a number of other uses besides crypto will make capital markets more efficient, and we’ve been actively involved in research to use blockchain technology." The exact opposite is true. Blockchain "technology" is useless beyond its ability to enable Bitcoin - a monetary innovation. Using it for anything other than that is simply trying to find a problem for a solution. Crypto beyond Bitcoin is also largely useless beyond serving as a democratized casino.
- MuffinFlavored 2y agoWhat about ETH/SOL stablecoin USDC and the whole "the blockchain validators/stakers can run programs/smart contracts/instructions"?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- leishman 2y agostablecoins are useful but you don't really need a blockchain. you just need enough of a rube-goldberg machine to claim it's "decentralized". The most popular "blockchain" for stablecoins is Tron, if that tells you anything about why the technology itself doesn't matter
- tyre 2y agoNone of the smart contracts have done anything materially useful without huge risk of scams, rug pulls, or enabling criminal activity (e.g. mixers for money laundering.) After a decade, there are no examples of widely used smart contracts or even long-running projects that haven't been fueled by boom and bust speculation cycles (e.g. NFTs.) Every time there is a "code is law" gone wrong with large $ at stake, people immediately fall back to real life police. Because "code is law" is either a bad idea or immediately has to compromise to meet real human uses (for example, people forget their passwords all the time and not supporting password resets—which right now requires a centralized key store—is a non-starter.) There is both a ton of money in crypto and it has completely failed to reach its promised potential. The largest uses in the next half decade will continue to be scams, pump-and-dumps, speculative frenzies, and money laundering. We'll see shockingly open corruption with the president of the United States having a coin for on-chain bribery.
- wheaties 2y agoTL;DR - We think it's essentially gambling and not fit for a long term portfolio. I agree.
- Ekaros 2y agoIn sense investing is gambling. But at least you can make informed decision on what you think go up or down in value based on real world. Where as crypto is purely speculative with no actual tie to economy or anything.
- afroboy 2y agoWhat does make it different than let's say Gold? Bitcoin has a really good and nice use case, you can move millions of dollars between countries with words in your head. No customs will ever find out. Can Gold, diamonds or even paper dollars do that? You can hit met with the ethics subject but another matter.
- lr4444lr 2y agoI don't often get a chance to commend a financial company for making a decision true to values and a long term view of the mission over making a quick buck, but Vanguard in this instance is such a chance. I've been a customer for over 10 years, and am ever more proud of their commitment to promoting long term average investor goals.
- BadCookie 2y agoSame. I own a mix of ETFs, some from Vanguard and some not. I will be even more inclined to buy Vanguard ETFs going forward. I am so, so tired of trying to explain to my retired mother why she should not buy any more bitcoin … with money that she really cannot afford to lose.
- eric_cc 2y agoAre you willing to live with the fact that you may be wrong and she’s right?
- BadCookie 2y agoPerfectly willing, yes. I believe in making decisions for the right reasons regardless of the eventual outcome. I wouldn’t support her putting her retirement savings all on black either, even though she might win plenty.
- strix_varius 2y agoI've also been a customer for over 10 years, and recently moved everything to Fidelity purely based on convenience. As far as I can tell, Fidelity is better equipped to be a full bank replacement (consolidating my various accounts held in various places & opening a brokerage line-of-credit). This blog post, along with the fact that Vanguard is the only one of my accounts that immediately transferred my funds with no bullshit slow-walking the move, trying to keep them (looking at you, Schwab & E-Trade!), makes me sort of regret that transfer. I want to support companies like Vanguard!
- 2y ago
- Gshaheen 2y ago“Jackson: In Vanguard’s view, crypto is more of a speculation than an investment. This is at the root of our decision to not offer crypto products, whether our own or others. With equities, you own a share of a company that produces goods or services, and many also pay dividends. With bonds, you get a stream of interest payments. Commodities are real assets that meet consumption needs, have inflation-hedging properties, and can play a role in certain portfolios. While crypto has been classified as a commodity, it’s an immature asset class that has little history, no inherent economic value, no cash flow, and can create havoc within a portfolio.“ Well said, this has been my own thinking on crypto, nice to see it so succinctly summarized.
- slekker 2y agoI'll share this every time someone asks me about crypto, beautiful!
- ein0p 2y agoWhat do you own if you hold a money market cash position? The exact same thing as Bitcoin - faith of other people that currency is worth something. Look, I'm not a crypto bro or anything, but Vanguard talking about speculation is the absolute comedy gold. They operate a casino.
- klipt 2y ago> They operate a casino. On average you lose money at a casino because it is a business designed to make you lose money. My vanguard funds on the other have gone up very nicely on average. Because they are invested in businesses designed to make shareholders money.
- ein0p 2y agoYou forgot to say "so far". One of my managers was also flying high circa 2000 - multiple lakefront properties, Porsches you name it, the guy was living the life. In 2002 he was bankrupt - didn't sell his tech stocks in time, thought they'd "bounce back". But I'm not talking about stocks. I'm talking about cash here. Cash is literally an article of faith and nothing else. It's not backed by any asset.
- gist 2y agoSo generally I agree with this. But I will note the following: 1) Vanguard offers Gold ETFs. Now they would say something ike 'oh that's because gold is used as an actual product ie has a purpose'. But most people accept that gold is also speculative and is the way it is simply because it's been that way for such a long time vs. it's inherent value or purpose. Yes the swings are not as wild and not as easily manipulated (there was the situation with Silver that was years ago) but still it could be done. 2) Stock investing is by and large gambling and whatever income the stock owns in no way really flows measuably to the person who owns stock in the company but seems to drive some type of accepted value going forward. No it's not entirely chance (like traditional gambling) but there are many players and much skill level and 'the regular guy' is not in a position to compete so they must interpret signals and they don't have access to all the signals that a higher level investor does. 3) The entire 'long term' for stock is similar mantra to HODL with crypto. 4) The 'problem' with both crypto and stocks is not really when to buy but when to sell.
- loeg 2y ago> Vanguard offers Gold ETFs. Now they would say something ike 'oh that's because gold is used as an actual product ie has a purpose'. But most people accept that gold is also speculative and is the way it is simply because it's been that way for such a long time vs. it's inherent value or purpose. Bogle was kind of a gold bug. It's unsatisfying and inconsistent and I agree you could make a similar argument for excluding gold if it wasn't already kind of grandfathered in. > Stock investing is by and large gambling and whatever income the stock owns in no way really flows measuably to the person who owns stock in the company but seems to drive some type of accepted value going forward. No, stock investing and gambling are absolutely incomparable. Income clearly and directly flows to owners; it's not obscure.
- teitoklien 2y ago> that gold is also speculative gold has stayed as a value of store that is tradeable, longer than any civilization has existed. USD or Stocks or Bonds for that matter any other currency is 1000x more speculative than gold Gold is also a “commodity” which vanguard stated has inflation protection properties If Satoshi Nakamoto’s Dormant BTC wallet wakes up tomorrow it’ll burn down the whole market…
- sowbug 2y agoAs the post says, Vanguard also missed out on Internet funds in the 1990s, and they're OK with that. I am, too. Nobody puts their money in Vanguard to jump on the latest thing (or in the case of Bitcoin, the latest 16-year-old thing). If you really want to speculate, move some of your money elsewhere from Vanguard.
- yieldcrv 2y ago> Nobody puts their money in Vanguard to jump on the latest thing Most people that I've met who use Vanguard did not have an objective view on finance, or their risk-profile, the concept of a risk-profile, and were completely surprised to find that they had such a handicapped custodian > If you really want to speculate, move some of your money elsewhere from Vanguard Yes, this is the solution. You would be surprised how crazy of a thought that is to people. The idea of opening another bank or broker, despite how simple it is, just blows so many people's minds and is pretty controversial or involved to them. They would prefer that Vanguard had all trading options.
- zemo 2y ago> The idea of opening another bank or broker, despite how simple it is I would wager that there are a lot of people that have money in Vanguard because Vanguard provides their employer's 401k, and their choice was "Vanguard or no 401k", not "Vanguard or something else of your choice".
- wmf 2y agoVanguard is a good choice for managing retirement funds. If you want to speculate on high-risk investments, whether doctoms or crypto or whatever, it's better to do it outside your 401k.
- yieldcrv 2y agoyeah but the point is that the brand recognition is what occurred and they moved additional money in taxable accounts there
- Razele 2y agoThe real reason: there are 7 other ETFs to pick from and Vanguard has no way to differentiate itself.
- loeg 2y agoDo you think Vanguard has any reason to lie about their motivations here? Do you think their S&P500 MF/ETF distinguishes itself in any way from Fidelity's or is a motivating factor for having one? This is just a bizarre conspiracy theory to espouse on the basis of no evidence.
- andy81 2y agoBeing anti-cryptocurrency as an organisation really is an important differentiator. Fidelity knows that investors in their cryptocurrency products will lose money in aggregate, but offers them anyway. It's a black mark against their integrity.
- syntheticcdo 2y agoIf it were that simple, Vanguard wouldn't have taken the additional step to prevent trading in these products on their brokerage. Telling customers "you can't buy Bitcoin because we can't sell it to you at a profit" would be ridiculous.
- breadwinner 2y agoJohn Reed Stark, former Chief of Internet Enforcement of SEC on 60 minutes: Crypto is a scourge, it is not something you want in your society. It has no utility. It is pure speculation. There is no balance sheet to crypto, there is no financial statements. There is no audit inspection, examination, net capital requirements, no licensure of individuals involved, and there is no transparency into it. That creates real systemic risks, not just risks for investors. But the other part people don't talk about enough is the dire externalities that are enabled by crypto. Every single crime you can think of, is easier to do now because of crypto. Especially ransomware, human sex trafficking, sanctions evasion, money laundering. North Korea is financing their nuclear program using crypto. --- Meanwhile, crypto investors, companies and executives accounted for almost half of corporate donations in the 2024 election cycle, with some contributing tens of millions of dollars to help Trump win a second term in office. See https://www.cnbc.com/2025/01/23/trump-signs-executive-order-on-crypto-digital-asset-stockpile.html https://www.cnbc.com/2025/01/23/trump-signs-executive-order-...
- loeg 2y agoJamie Dimon: > Bitcoin itself has no intrinsic value, > It’s used heavily by sex traffickers, by money launderers, ransomware. So I just don’t feel great about Bitcoin.
- dnamlin 2y agohttps://www.blackrock.com/institutions/en-zz/literature/whitepaper/bii-investment-perspectives-december-2024.pdf https://www.blackrock.com/institutions/en-zz/literature/whit...
- ArtTimeInvestor 2y agono inherent economic value I wonder if they mean the technology or the tokens. As in: Do they mean that the existence of the Bitcoin blockchain has no economic value, or that owning Bitcoin tokens has no value? Both have value though. If you want to store data publicly and tamperproof for a long time, the Bitcoin blockchain is by far the best solution. So the Bitcoin blockchain has value. And the Bitcoin token lets you use the Bitcoin blockchain. Without Bitcoin tokens, there is no way you can write anything to the Bitcoin blockchain.
- pbhjpbhj 2y ago>If you want to store data publicly and tamperproof for a long time, the Bitcoin blockchain is by far the best solution. // Don't you get 80 bytes per transaction? That seems like about $7M per GB... maybe storing hashes is reasonable but storing data actually on the bitcoin blockchain itself doesn't seem great?
- ArtTimeInvestor 2y agoHashes are a good example of a very small amount of data that is very powerful. By storing a single hash, you can notarize an infinite amount of documents. Another very powerful type of data is transaction settlements. With a single onchain transaction, an infinite amount of second layer transactions can be settled.
- loeg 2y agoNot mentioned but a good reason is Bogle fucking hated crypto (some might say, with good reason). > I would say avoid bitcoin like the plague. Did I make myself clear?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mmoustafa 2y agoCan we get a (January 2024) tag on this? Bitcoin ETFs had barely debuted a week before that statement. The offerings and even many institutional stances have largely changed since then.
- dang 2y agoAh thanks! Year added above.
- linsomniac 2y agoMisleading: "Over just the past three years, the price of bitcoin has increased by as much as 150% and declined by as much as 77%. Double-digit percent price drops are routine among cryptocurrencies. Remember that you need a 100% return just to make up for a 50% decline." I agree with the article that Bitcoin isn't an investment, it's a speculation, but... They are mixing an overall return with a time-period return to promote some fear. That 100% return you need is from the bottom, but they are quoting the 150% return from before the drop. Specifics: Jan 1 2022 @ $47K to Nov 2022 @ $16K, Jan 2025 $98K. At $16K, yes you need like 150% return just to get back to where you started. Actual return from the bottom was over 600%. If you got in at $47K, you do not need a 150% cumulative return to recover from the big drop. The average investor shouldn't have the majority of their money in speculative instruments. However, my FIL gave me some great advice: Take a little of your money and invest it in something you like. Say, 5%. It makes the investing a little more fun. Of course, I love it because after he said that I invested in something I liked and it went up 15x...
- kgwgk 2y ago> Misleading: "Over just the past three years, […] > They are mixing an overall return with a time-period return to promote some fear. > Specifics: Jan 1 2022 @ $47K to Nov 2022 @ $16K, Jan 2025 $98K. The article is dated January 24, 2024. It was roughly in the $40-$50 range.
- olddog2 2y agoThe problem is that if btc is a once in a 200 year “creation of a global reserve currency” event, those with bitcoin exposure (even 1% of portfolio or whatever) will be minted and those without will be fighting over the scraps. You can buy insurance to ensure you’re not left behind this very cheaply, for just 1% of your portfolio. Yes, it is coordination dilemma with ponzi characteristics. Yes, sticking to your principles may feel like the intellectually correct thing to do. But its a big coordination dilemma which so far is only going in one direction, and the risk that anyone not getting involved ends up having fun staying poor increases as btc ascends.
- olddog2 2y agoAlso, the “blockchain not bitcoin” talking point in 2025 is cringe.
- soared 2y agoI don’t really see how/why/etc Bitcoin would achieve that use case. If governments and financial institutions aren’t bag holders then they are extremely financially motivated to stop that from occurring, and afaik those groups aren’t holding huge Bitcoin reserves (maybe fidelity is, or at least was).
- dnamlin 2y agoThis seems like a comment from 10 years ago. In 2025, Larry Fink just announced he's a "big believer" at Davos, and the President of the United States ordered his team to evaluate creating a huge reserve.
- dutchbookmaker 2y agoMeanwhile, Huawei Harmony just embedded the digital yuan at the system level. All the ETFs mean is that it will be so much easier to get out of the position and cause even bigger cascades of selling than before when the next shock happens. You can't have a reserve currency with an asset that has so much volatility it can't even function as a currency.
- rsynnott 2y ago
- saos 2y agoSounds like they are more interested in Ethereum
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ankeshk 2y agoChristopher Columbus reached the Americas in 1492. He traded colourful beads and small mirrors. In return he got gold. Both the indigenous people and the Spaniards thought of each other as fools. Value does not arise out of usage or cash flow or how something is classified or even its history. Value arises out of perception. Its all a narrative. It always has been. People thinking crypto is useless is a narrative. People thinking money will always lose value due to inflation is a narrative. Both are true based on your point of perception.
- dennis_jeeves2 2y agoThere are plenty of scams in the cypto world, in fact mostly anything related to crypto is scam/speculation. But I believe there is also a quiet revolution. As far as mainstream financial organizations/economists/experts etc. are concerned, they have really no clue on the underlying revolution and transformation that is secretly underway because of crypto. Either that, or it dawns on them that the status quo will be disrupted, and then have a very predictable outburst: cite every imaginable crime being preferentially enabled by crypto.
- svara 2y agoCould you show us examples of that secret revolution? It does seem to be very secret because I've been waiting for it for fifteen years, first excitedly, then frustratedly.
- dennis_jeeves2 2y agoIt's mostly happening in the 3rd world with unstable/high inflation currencies but who have internet access. We here in the 1st world have relatively stable financial systems so most people do not feel the need for crypto, except the anarchists.
- oblio 2y agoLinks? I've been hearing this for probably 8 years now.
- dennis_jeeves2 2y agoNo links, I know an acquaintance of mine who knows somebody in the third world.
- pimlottc 2y ago*quiet
- 2y ago
- currymj 2y agoto the extent that executing transactions on a fully decentralized, trustless database or distributed computer is something people demand, and transaction fees must be paid in Bitcoin or Ethereum or Solana or whatever, cryptocurrencies do have some amount of actual use value, so are sort of like "commodities". I believe this is a correct argument in theory. In practice, at the moment, everything is exclusively driven by speculation, and if you took the degenerate gambling out of the system, I don't know what would be left. It's just gambling at all levels. There are legitimately "useful" services on blockchains, but the useful services they provide are mainly facilitating more gambling on stupid garbage coins. And even such useful "picks and shovels" services often still choose to make their own token for people to speculate on, because crypto people aren't interested in anything else. And then the L1 cryptocurrencies also have their prices driven by speculation. there is a core of actual technical innovation, which is almost totally irrelevant to the phenomenon of "crypto" today. But there may be a future world where cryptocurrencies provide real value. In that world where all the true believers have their wildest dreams come true, the price of a cryptocurrency would be much higher than zero, but even then, it might be much lower than they are right now.
- 627467 2y agoHey, speculation <> investment is a spectrum, it's fine to not care about the full spectrum. But let's not pretend (for example) that gold price reflects it's industrial value more than it's speculative value. The same can be said of venture backed tech companies (ie. Wework?) early in their public lives.
- skybrian 2y agoIt's not something Vanguard would do, but I'm wondering if there's a good way to trade on Bitcoin's volatility? Matt Levine has written about how buying convertible bonds from Microstrategy is sort of doing this [1] but it seems complicated to do. > This is the more practical meaning of hedging your stock-price risk. It means that every day the stock moves around and you rebalance your hedge. When the stock goes up, you sell some stock at high prices. When the stock goes down, you buy some stock at low prices. Hedging the convertible means buying stock low and selling it high. ... > a convertible bond is a bet on volatility: The more the company’s stock bounces around, the more money convertible arbitrageurs can make. [1] https://archive.is/S9kOi https://archive.is/S9kOi
- oa335 2y agoYes, you could trade options on Bitcoin futures, or options on Bitcoin ETFs. You could buy calls and puts, which would make you "positively exposed" to volatility - i.e. if people's expectation of volatility goes up, the price should go up. By "delta" hedging them every so often you could "realize" some of that volatility - you would be buying when the price goes down, selling when the price goes up. Of course, this is all baked into the option price itself, so its not "free money" - its a bet.
- skybrian 2y agoI'm certainly not going to do that, but I'm wondering if there are ETF's doing something like that. Aren't there ETF's for everything these days?
- oa335 2y agoMaybe, but I’d stay very far away from bitcoin options or any funds that deal in them. They are likely paying a lot in fees and taking hidden risks that will be passed on to shareholders.
- clamprecht 2y ago> I'm wondering if there's a good way to trade on Bitcoin's volatility? It is with options on MicroStrategy (MSTR). I think one strategy is holding MSTR and selling calls (i.e. covered calls). There are probably other strategies that don't require holding MSTR shares, like selling a call and buying a put, but I may be messing that up. Check out the youtube channel called "Quant Bros" (cringe name, I know), and the /r/MSTR subreddit.
- svara 2y agoDo you think cash will still be a thing a hundred years from now? Do you think the cocaine trade, tax evasion, illegal gambling, money laundering etc. will still be a thing in a hundred years? Personally my "bull case" for crypto is that I am pretty confident about answering no and yes to those two questions, respectively. I'm being cynical, but I also think that's true. I haven't owned any crypto in a long time and won't going forward.
- r33b33 2y ago> Do you think cash will still be a thing a hundred years from now? Do you think you will be alive hundred years from now?
- janderland 2y agoNo, but their children or a worthy inheritor will be. There’s reasons to make investments which exceed your lifespan.
- Ekaros 2y agoWith that in mind, I would certainly say the choice for those won't be pseudo anonymous currency. As one sting operation and someone keeping too many records will get plenty of people discovered.
- ltzkcH 2y agoWho would be buying bitcoin right now? The price steadily went up after sanctioned countries removed from SWIFT started settling their transactions in Bitcoin. It exploded after the US election after it became clear that the crypto bros are in charge. It is now theoretically possible to buy a president by launching a new coin and have the "lobbyists" buy the coin. Previously this needed to be done using high speaker fees and book deals after the presidency. If the wars and sanctions stop and if more people are aware of the oligarch influence, Bitcoin will drop. Trump is continuing the Blinken policies in Gaza (make the Palestinians leave to Jordan and Egypt and build Kushner seafront properties in Gaza) and the Bolton policies in Greenland. So perhaps he'll continue the Blinken policies in Ukraine, too, despite election promises to the contrary. That is the only hope for the Bitcoin scam.
- anon567812 2y ago[dead]
- yieldcrv 2y agomeanwhile my self-custodied solo 401k roth funds 2x'd on Unicorn Fart Dust - a meme coin that's supposed to be making fun of how people in this community view crypto - and 3x'd on $TRUMP, and then 2x'd again LPing on $TRUMP as a market maker on Meteora. all tax freeeeee it isn't important to me that this is speculation versus some form of financial game that's put on a mental pedestal it is important to me that this fits my risk profile generic advice gives generic results
- r33b33 2y agoGood. Reaffirms my trust in Vanguard's indices. People behind funds that chase trends cannot be truly genuine. They give rotten grifter vibes...
- SALCKIN 2y agoReply
- cypherpunks01 2y agoThe killer use cases of crypto are not visible to HN readers living in relatively stable North American or European countries. Take a look at the the "Global Crypto Adoption Index Top 20" [1] for the past years and ask yourself, "do Vietnamese people love trading monkey gifs? Are Ukrainians especially susceptible to Ponzi schemes? Is Venezuela laden with techbros?" [2] No. It's that people in many of the countries in the top 20 live under unstable governments and monetary systems, with extreme debasement, inflation, inability to store value without seizure, transfer value without controls, accept remittances, etc. Crypto absolutely has use cases in these situations, and these extremes inform the means. "If you’re in a developed country, and you’re happy with your banking system, and you’re not a sex worker, and you have zero concerns about your country being taken over by fascists, you probably don’t need cryptocurrency and shouldn’t worry about it. If other people say they do need it, don’t call them liars and say you know with certainty that nobody has ever used crypto for anything besides Ponzi schemes and monkey pictures. Just let them use it!" [2] [1] https://www.chainalysis.com/blog/2024-global-crypto-adoption-index/ https://www.chainalysis.com/blog/2024-global-crypto-adoption... [2] https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/why-im-less-than-infinitely-hostile https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/why-im-less-than-infinitely...
- pjc50 2y agoI'm anti-crypto and this kind of crypto advocacy I actually agree with. It's not as sound as the US dollar, but there are much less stable currencies. > concerns about your country being taken over by fascists, .. do not record all your transactions on a permanent public leger!
- r33b33 2y agoThe actual use case of crypto is censorship resistance, money laundering and sanction evasion. In a multipolar world, none of those are going away anytime soon, so crypto is here to stay.
- patall 2y agoWhy is this the case? I mean buying crypto via a ?local? exchange is possible, but it is not possible to buy a more stable currency. How is the crypto bought, does someone sell it in that local currency? Because if not, you still need zo transfer your currency to (in >90% of cases) USD and then buy crypto. So why not just use those (the same way everybody else does).
- omnee 2y agoBitcoin is commonly compared to Gold and I agree with BTC proponents who state that most of Gold's value is driven by speculative investment, however in the long term (over centuries and even millenia) it has a demonstrated real return of zero. So Gold has preserved wealth. Bitcoin might do the same, but for this to occur it will always need new liquidity as it lacks intrinsic value. But this also implies that the real return will be zero over the long term, like with Gold. Moreover, as it's value comes entirely from its price, the door to the 'price value' of Bitcoin (or any other similar asset) reaching the Moon or zero will always be open. However, Gold does have intrinsic value (10% annual use in industry) and has, over millenia and at present, an aesthetic value (40% in Jewellery). Which would probably classed under Sign Value in semiotics. So it has intrinsic, exchange, symbolic and sign values too. Note that over the long term, most commodity real returns have been zero or even negative. Unsurprising, as we have gotten far more efficient at extracting them.
- satvikpendem 2y agoSometimes I think I shouldn't have listened to Hacker News and certain subreddits like r/buttcoin over these past 17 years and should've just bought and held Bitcoin, I would've been a multi-millionaire by now like some stoners I know, who did nothing but buy Bitcoin early and sat on it until today. Sometimes it's worth it to believe in an irrational market, depending on how long you (and it) can hold out.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zcar 2y agoI remember in 2013 when I first heard about it and didn't do anything. The question is: Will your friends know when to quit? There are many bitcoin evangelists who think it will lead to freedom. The truth is that it will most likely lead to cbdc, that is why all banks, government and financial institutions are building blockchain technologies.
- satvikpendem 2y agoIt already led to their freedom, at least. Even if Bitcoin went to zero, most of them have pulled out enough into fiat to be set for life.
- zcar 2y agoFor those who bought early it is certainly the case. Those late to the game will have the rug pulled just like a memecoin. There are many people who really believe it will go to $1M and they will use it freely ( their ideal of sound money). What is really valuable is the blockchain tech, the coin is speculation. That is because governments and banks will have more control over the coin on top of the base layer.
- satvikpendem 2y agoI don't think either are actually valuable, I don't see any application of blockchain anywhere that's better than traditional computing. Bitcoin itself seems to be the only good application so far.
- andirk 2y agoAll valid points, but let's remember that most other stonks trade at some 40x of the value of the company.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Rafuino 2y agoAnd this is why I'm glad I mostly invest with Vanguard
- liontwist 2y agoI’m shocked to see that most criticism here is not about bitcoin being funny internet money run by self interested people, but is instead that stable currency and storing value are bad.
- yuvadam 2y ago"In a traditional portfolio with a mix of 60% stocks and 40% bonds, those seven stocks [Mag 7 stocks] each account for, on average, about the same share of overall portfolio risk as a 1-2% allocation to bitcoin" - Blackrock, December 2024 [1] [1] - https://www.blackrock.com/institutions/en-us/insights/portfolio-design/sizing-bitcoin-in-portfolios https://www.blackrock.com/institutions/en-us/insights/portfo...
- polyomino 2y ago> We do have a lot of interest in blockchain, the technology behind cryptocurrencies. We believe its application to a number of other uses besides crypto will make capital markets more efficient, and we’ve been actively involved in research to use blockchain technology Well, they clearly have no idea what they’re talking about. Next!
- anonymousDan 2y agoOne thing I recently discovered that gave me some pause for thought is what happens if you buy a vanguard ETF and either the provider or vanguard itself somehow gets into trouble. For example, what happens if the ETF provider is actually loaning out the underlying stocks and gets caught by market movements. Apparently in the UK at least there are quite a few scenarios in which the FSCS 85k guarantee would not apply (in contrast to a cash savings account). See e.g. discussion here: https://monevator.com/physical-etf-risks/ https://monevator.com/physical-etf-risks/
- wmf 2y agoI don't think this kind of situation could occur in the US because rehypothecation of shares underlying ETFs isn't allowed. See also https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Vanguard_safety https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Vanguard_safety And worst case if something did happen it would be bailed out.
- msitara 2y ago[flagged]
- kerkeslager 2y agoBitcoin and most other cryptocurrencies are not producing any product, collecting any interest, etc, with which to buyback or pay dividends. As such, investment in Bitcoin is a zero sum game: in order for you to make money off Bitcoin, someone else has to lose money on Bitcoin. As such, if you don't have a solid understanding of cryptocurrencies, and perhaps more importantly, market principles, you probably shouldn't buy cryptocurrencies because the odds are against you given you're playing this game against some very large, powerful, expert players. It's actually worse than that because it's being diluted (albeit slowly). The only way around this is for more and more money to be invested in Bitcoin, forever, which obviously isn't sustainable, at least not at historical rates of growth. If world GDP continues to grow, Bitcoin can continue to grow by sucking up that growing value, but that's limited, ultimately by GDP. And there's a limit to how much of GDP people will be willing to put into Bitcoin: for example, 100% of corn farmers aren't going to take their profits from farming corn, and stop putting them into the next year's corn crop to buy Bitcoin instead, because the more corn farmers did this, the higher the price of corn would go, so at some point it would become obviously more profitable to farm corn than buy Bitcoin. It is quite possible that we will continue to see new all-time highs for Bitcoin in the next few decades--there's still lots of wiggle room between global GDP and Bitcoin market cap. But Bitcoin growth will slow to less than GDP growth at some point. It's simply impossible for that not to happen.
- npoc 2y agoYes, at some point bitcoin will stop growing in value, I'll agree with that. Personally I think it will be at a market cap of $100T-200T (in today's dollars), but time will tell. If you measure its value relative to dollars though, it will go up forever and faster than GDP (dollars are historically devalued by money supply inflation at 7%/year)
- Murphysharon 2y ago[flagged]
- franczesko 2y agoAnd yet it still grows
- kapad 2y agoAI seems like a better use case for all the GPU and energy that goes to bitcoin mining.
- nojvek 2y agoBitcoin at its fundamental is a large pyramid scheme where you need new fools to keep on buying at an ever higher price. The current newest fool is President Trump who wants to take a portion of Federal reserve and put it in Bitcoin. The greatest fool one would say. And when Bitcoin has a 50% decline due to a scare pullout, the federal reserve also has a pullout and ……… the entire economy tanks. The market is so hot right now with absurd P/E ratios. One bad nvidia earnings and we’re gonna be in bearish mode.
- bridgetwalsh917 2y ago[dead]
- rosiesophia10 2y ago[dead]