11 ms·
Fire risk assessment of battery home storage compared to general house fires
- kelnos 2y agoTo save others the clicking and scrolling (if you're mainly interested in the conclusion, as I was), the summary at the end says that the risk of fire starting in your battery energy storage (or in your EV) is lower than that of your average house fire (or in your ICE car). They liken the risk of a fire starting in the battery storage to that of fire starting in a clothes dryer. But, depending on the placement of your batteries in/around your home, the severity of a fire, if one should happen, could end up being worse than a fire that starts in some other household appliance. I was pleased to read that the risk of fire is reasonable and low; I wasn't sure what to expect, but was afraid the conclusion would be that they're higher-risk. I suppose I expected to see the result that a fire that included large batteries could be a much worse fire. Li ion battery fires can be pretty bad, and those batteries are much larger than what you'd find in your phone or other small electronics. I still would like to add rooftop solar to my house (even though California's metering system is all kinds of anti-rooftop-solar now). When I last looked into it a couple years ago, battery storage seemed like it was a little too pricey to be worth it, but it seems like that's been changing.
- Sayrus 2y ago> The fires in HSS in Germany were determined using web crawling for the year 2023 because no other data was available. All other probabilities were calculated using researched data. HSS may also be underrepresented in the scrapped data due to the method used. The document sections Discussion and Limitations and Outlook touch about this. The authors highlight a lack of common categorization of fires types and count as well as the need for a standardized reporting framework. Another warning made by the author is that their document investigates the number of fires but not how much damage was done.
- mindslight 2y agoNote that the research is centered on Germany, where there is a bit more of a default-deny approach to electrical safety. Here in the US, some of the pictures I've seen of sample finished installations that the installer is proud of have been downright scary. Like giant wall of 2V batteries with terminals coming out horizontally, open bus bars tying them all in series to make 48V, and then the leads going to the inverter just draped over the entrance to a wiring trough with a rough edge! There was probably a fuse as part of the inverter itself, but no protection for the batteries themselves. I'm guessing it has to be a case of code inspectors not particularly caring or knowing about the DC side? Although with that kind of current capacity, perhaps the wiring itself is considered a fuse...
- gottorf 2y ago> I'm guessing it has to be a case of code inspectors not particularly caring or knowing about the DC side? I don't know what you saw, but it could have been a "homeowner's special", or some kind of proof-of-concept? Professionals are certainly capable of hackjobs, but I have a hard time thinking that a client would be satisfied enough to pay for what you describe. You don't have to be an electrician to know that some stuff just looks dangerous and poorly done!
- mindslight 2y agoNo. It was a Faceboot page of a decently popular solar installation company showing off their completed works. There could have been some anti-abrasion thing I couldn't see in the picture, but the lack of fusing was still concerning. (And FWIW I did check the battery datasheets to make sure there weren't internal fuses). I suppose those particular installations might have gotten a pass on inspections due to "off grid", but still.
- neither_color 2y ago>I'm guessing it has to be a case of code inspectors not particularly caring or knowing about the DC side? I'm inclined to agree with this. US electrical code, especially in recent years, is pretty robust and has gotten to the point where people groan about excessive safety features(tamper resistant outlets required in all new dwelling spaces, arc fault circuit breakers, whole home surge protection all make wiring a house significantly more expensive than 15 years ago). Inspectors are pretty good at catching grounding and other issues. That said we don't yet have generational knowledge of PV and battery systems. A lot of installers are still learning by doing, it feels. Are you sure it wasn't just DIY un-permitted work, though?
- ssl-3 2y agoIt is always important to remember that the National Electric Code isn't national. It is up to the states or other (more-local) AHJs to adopt it (or not). And many simply have not done so. For example: A person building a single-family home in Meigs County, Ohio, has no electrical code to follow, nor any electrical permits to pull, nor any government inspections of any electrical work. (Lacking code, there's no standard by which to permit nor to inspect the work.)
- devjab 2y agoIt will be interesting to see what it does for fire fighting if we start adopting batteries on large scale in our homes. EVs already pose a significant challenge in European cities. Easy enough for electric cars which can be put into some sort of container to handle the fire, less easy with electric busses. I’m not sure we have a good strategy in place yet here in my city. So far the strategy seems to be “well, it was lucky it caught fire outside the main streets”. I imagine it’ll be wild if a fire breaks out in a line of town houses with battery storages. If it’s as difficulty to put out as EV’s then you’re probably going to have a hard time containing it to just a few houses.
- thebruce87m 2y ago> If it’s as difficulty to put out as EV’s EVs do not all share the same battery chemistry. Many have LFP batteries, and these are common for home batteries too. You can go on YouTube and see people drilling into an LFP battery with only a little smoke to show for it.
- giobox 2y agoRight exactly. Any discussion about this topic that doesn’t separate LFP (lithium iron phosphate) based batteries from the wider discussion about lithium ion is missing one of the biggest changes to battery tech in recent years. Not all lithium based batteries share the same fire risks - there are enormous differences now. Increasingly EVs and especially backup batteries use the LFP tech - you can charge it to 100% without harming the battery unlike previous lithium ion batteries, and they don’t really catch fire. This paper even acknowledges LFP is significantly safer, mentioning it once, but doesn’t dive into the significant improvements. Again, many EVs (including brands like Tesla etc) already use LFP packs in many cars, and the usage is only increasing. Tesla’s generation 3 powerwalls (home backup battery) are LFP too, its really taken off for home power storage for very obvious reasons - they don’t really catch fire, and you don’t need to worry about charging to 100% harming the battery over time.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoI wonder if the reduction in entire houses being reduced to a rubble filled crater by gas pipeline explosions will counterbalance these home battery fires as we electrify homes.
- WalterBright 2y agoI'd prefer to have the battery outside the house, with a concrete wall between it and the house. Or just have it 10 feet away, like where you'd put a generator.
- 1970-01-01 2y agoMost generators are installed within 4ft of the exterior house wall.
- WalterBright 2y agoSeeing how hot a battery fire is, I'd want it 10 feet away. Or a concrete wall between. None of that is expensive. And you can sleep safe!
- gerdesj 2y agoA genny does not have a Li-Ion battery.
- Dylan16807 2y ago"it" in that sentence refers to battery banks and not generators.
- WalterBright 2y agoA genny: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtiss_JN_Jenny#/media/File:Flying_jenny_cropped.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtiss_JN_Jenny#/media/File:F...
- gerdesj 2y agoA genny has a 12V car/lorry battery to start it. My work one is basically a lorry diesel motor on a floor bolted chassis. It is the other side of an external wall (double skin of brick). Ironically enough the genny is inside the same room as the hot water boiler which is gas powered. The original heating was a coal fired boiler which was converted to a weird oil squirting "hair dryer". That's all gone now. The fire risks that I worry about do not really include the genny. The fridge in the kitchen is potentially far worse. I have, of course, put in a fire detection and suppression system inside the computer room. At home I actually have a more involved fire risk assessment than at work. My wife does dog boarding at home and one day I will stop her leaving a cloth to dry on the cooker ... sigh. Anyway, making sure that humans and dogs get warned and get out safely is quite involved. As we all know there are three ingredients required for fire: a source of ignition, a combustible material and finally: oxygen. Remove one and fire does not happen. Unfortunately some reactions will generate copious amounts of heat and oxygen, ie all three requirements for combustion and become self sustaining. Lithium batteries for example can do this. It's a bit of a nightmare but techniques are being developed to deal with "self igniting metals" and the like. I drive an EV.
- sidewndr46 2y agoIsn't this entire discussion academic? You could just not mount it on the structure you live in.
- alias_neo 2y agoWhere do you propose people mount their home battery storage?
- shadowpho 2y ago>even though California's metering system is all kinds of anti-rooftop-solar now How do?
- ericd 2y agoEh I'd revise that to say it's anti-rooftop-without-storage. Basically, the CA grid now has a massive glut of solar generation at midday, and so they changed net metering to not pay anywhere near 1:1 on backfed power (it's a really bad ratio, but I don't remember, maybe like 1:5). On the literature around this change, they noted that it's to encourage people to install storage and do time shifting on the power they generate, to help even things out for the grid.
- shadowpho 2y ago>Basically, the CA grid now has a massive glut of solar generation at midday, and so they changed net metering to not pay anywhere near 1:1 on backfed power (it's a really bad ratio, but I don't remember, maybe like 1:5) 1:5 isn't "anti-solar" though, it accurately reflects the fact that power is worth significantly less at that point in time. >it's to encourage people to install storage and do time shifting on the power they generate, to help even things out for the grid. Yep makes sense. Someone has to bear the cost of providing power when it's expensive to do, and it makes sense to more accurately price the solar energy.
- ericd 2y agoI’d agree with you that it was accurate pricing if they sold power for similarly cheap at that time, such that you could just install storage and profit off of time shifting by backfeeding when there’s not a glut. But I’m pretty sure they still charge their absurd rates at noon on a sunny day.
- mmooss 2y ago> To save others the clicking and scrolling (if you're mainly interested in the conclusion, as I was) Thanks. Another solution is to read the abstract at the top.
- pjc50 2y agoI do think this stuff would be better off at utility scale, but there's another kind of regulatory arbitrage going on there: some people will accept much lower safety standards in their own houses, while other people are keen to clobber anything with any sort of risk attached in the public sphere. (climate change is of course not seen as a "risk" in the public sense, more of a "business as usual", because it's too diffuse for blame to attach)
- nkrisc 2y agoMy suspicion is that people simply overestimate their ability to asses risk, thus are tolerant of increased risk in their own home as they’re responsible for it, while other people are responsible for risk in the public realm.
- carimura 2y agoWe put a 15 kWh battery storage system in our garage and had to build a fire-rated room around it with a 60-minute fire-rated door to maintain code -- which is a pretty heavy weight steel door. It wasn't easy. All to maintain county code. The funny part is by the time we got the inspection, the fire department had a new inspector and he said "wow, you did all of this for the battery?"
- kelnos 2y agoHow much did that cost, as a percent of the total cost of the system you built? My feeling is that a requirement like that could make the project financially infeasible for a lot of people.
- cf100clunk 2y agoConsider the U.S. insurance industry and their desire/need to refuse payouts when possible. If a fire occurs and the location contravenes just about any code their staff can find, they will likely refuse payout and it will be time for you to lawyer up. So, in that case, the expense of that special room might be seen as a bargain in the long run.
- kelnos 2y agoSure, I don't disagree with that, but someone looking to do an installation might just decide not to do it at all, seeing the cost of the protection setup. That may or may not be rational, but I could easily see that happening. Sticker shock is a thing, and solar+battery installs are already plenty pricey, even with the cost renaissance we've been seing. GP/sibling says it added on another 5-10% for them, though, so that's not too bad, though I guess it was a DIY job, and would have cost more to pay someone else to do it.
- carimura 2y ago5-10% of the battery itself. required 1/2" sheet rock, that 60-min door, etc etc. would have been more if I hired someone to do it.
- mvkel 2y agoIsn't there some recency bias in this, considering home battery backups are relatively new tech (at scale), and the other measures of fire risk are millennia old?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- debacle 2y agoWe had a home near us in the last decade where the propane tank exploded. I don't know the details, there are a lot of things that go into something like that happening, but one of the things found during the investigation was that, per the building code, the propane tank was too close to the house. The news went on to say that some non-trivial percentage of residential propane tanks were positioned in a way that wasn't up to code. Because most manufactured homes don't have traditional financing, they aren't subject to the same code inspections, yadda yadda, house goes boom. The risk of a fire with a home battery system might be lower, but the outcome is an unknown. I've had engines and stoves and fryers and furnaces and chimneys start on fire on me. I know how to deal with those things, even if they are scary. A battery fire, I have no idea how to deal with. Coupled with code standards that are probably not as mature as they should be, and may not see the enforcement they should, and I am content to wait.
- ZYbCRq22HbJ2y7 2y agoFor above ground tanks, minimum distance from structure according to NFPA 58: No restriction for tanks < 125 gallons 10 feet for tanks 125 - 500 gallons 25 feet for tanks 1,000 - 2,000 gallons A summary here: https://www.cfins.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Propane-Container-Distance-Safety.pdf https://www.cfins.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Propane-Con... > A battery fire, I have no idea how to deal with If its a small battery, like any other fire.
- bsder 2y agoBut you also need a generator to go with that propane tank. And that generator has quite a few code restrictions, too.
- themaninthedark 2y agoOnly if using the propane for power. Parent talked about manufactured homes and non-traditional financing, I would be hazard they are talking about single and double wide trailers. In this case, the propane would most likely be used for heating and cooking.
- nativeit 2y agoDoes anyone know what they’re referring to when citing the risk of fire as similar to that of “tumblers”? Is this a euphemism for clothes driers? My first thought was rock tumblers, but surely they’re not common enough to be statistically significant in determining risks for house fires….
- chrisandchris 2y agoI would assume so. Tumblers are known for causing fires (hot air and dust due to not good cleaning by owners).
- lowbloodsugar 2y agoMany years ago I got to see a neighbor’s tumble dryer on fire. He’d dragged it out onto his driveway and let it burn. No fire extinguisher apparently. Had this been a battery fixed to his wall, he’d have lost his house.
- pretendgeneer 2y ago> HSS share roughly the same probability of catching fire as tumblers Does "tumblers" in this context mean tumbler dryer? I've only ever heard tumbler meaning the type of cup.
- Animats 2y agoThis is Germany. Here's a summary of the safety regulations.[1] Safety testing by an "accredited laboratory" is required.[2] The New York City Fire Department reports that lithium-ion battery fires are a leading cause of fires and fire deaths in NYC.[3] NYFD got the city to require UL or equivalent testing for lithium battery fires.[4] This is working for sales within NYC but Amazon is still selling batteries with fake UL stickers. NYC's big problem is e-bikes and scooters being charged in apartments and stores. Several hundred of those a year now, and they tend to be severe fires. Entire e-bike stores have blown up. Those things need to be lithium-iron phosphate until solid state batteries become affordable. (A good political move would be to get the incoming administration to require UL or better certification for anything imported that has a lithium-ion battery or a wall plug.) [1] https://www.batterietechnikum.kit.edu/downloads/Safety_Guidelines_Li-Ion_20150217(1).pdf https://www.batterietechnikum.kit.edu/downloads/Safety_Guide... [2] https://www.tuvsud.com/en-us/resource-centre/blogs/mobility-and-automotive/understanding-the-new-eu-battery-regulation https://www.tuvsud.com/en-us/resource-centre/blogs/mobility-... [3] https://www.nyc.gov/site/fdny/news/Y40203/fdny-warns-lithium-ion-batteries-now-leading-cause-fires-fire-deaths-new-york https://www.nyc.gov/site/fdny/news/Y40203/fdny-warns-lithium... [4] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/fdny-is-trying-to-curb-lithium-ion-battery-fires-but-online-sellers-may-be-putting-new-yorkers-at-risk/ar-AA1uL2pY https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/fdny-is-trying-to-curb-lit...
- metacritic12 2y agoThe incoming administration doesn't seem to really be pro upregulating anything. In fact core members of their team believe the firefighters have had way too much political power already in building requirements, etc.
- Syonyk 2y agoThey don't have to add regulations. They just have to suggest that Amazon actually enforce the regulations on the books, instead of allowing fake UL/ETL listings to be accepted as seems Amazon's common practice.
- 2y ago
- nanomonkey 2y agoShouldn't home batteries be lithium iron phosphate and not lithium ion, and thus almost a zero fire hazard? At least as far as cell chemistry goes...electricity is always a fire hazard if discharged incorrectly.
- philjohn 2y agoThey should, but quite a few are still NMC chemistry.
- r00fus 2y agoLike most deployed Tesla Powerwalls only most recent is LFP.
- numpad0 2y agoLFP has different full/empty voltages so chips and boards has to be re-made. Unless mandated or made comparatively economical, manufacturers won't switch out infrastructures overnight.
- danans 2y agoUnless I missed it, the paper didn't indicate what the battery chemistry breakdown of the data set was. If it is heavily weighted for Sonnen (German home backup battery manufacturer) batteries, then those have always used Lithium Iron Phosphate (LFP) chemistry, which has much lower thermal risk. In contrast, most historical home backup batteries sold in the US have been early generation Tesla Powerwalls, which are Lithium ion batteries and thus inherently more thermally risky (they must have active cooling systems [1] inherited from Tesla's cars). Most home batteries currently sold (Enphase, Tesla, etc) now use LFP, so the thermal risk going forward for new installations should be significantly lower. 1. https://wanakasolar.com/knowledge-hub-posts/tesla-powerwall-is-the-only-home-battery-with-thermal-management/ https://wanakasolar.com/knowledge-hub-posts/tesla-powerwall-...
- lolc 2y agoI can't relate to per-year risk percentage numbers. But the inverse is quite illustrative I find. Here is the expected time between events for each category according to the paper: General house fire: 360 years ICE fire: 1100 years EV fire: 4200 years Battery storage fire: 20'000 years Tumble dryer fire: 27'000 years PV system fire: 71'000 years This way I can understand that while I might see my house burn, the battery storage is very unlikely to pop in my lifetime. Because these numbers are not very accurate anyway, I've rounded to two digits. The authors note that the number for battery storage in particular are very unreliable. On the other hand: just looking at probabilities of events does not tell you how lethal or destructive the event will be. And lithium fires are very bad in both categories. Comparing to tumble dryers is not very useful when you factor in the properties of the fire. Quite possibly the danger to life is higher with an EV compared to an ICE, even if the ICE is assumed to catch fire at four times the rate of the EV. In addition, the wear-out failure rate of EV is to be discovered yet, because the fleet is so young. The EV rate may still climb. Or maybe battery manufacturers improve and the danger will be reduced? Some things do get better after all!
- kreyenborgi 2y agoThe years perspective is useful. But I'm not sure it's useful to compare the danger from different sources of house fires. The bad ones happen at night, and then have more than enough time to cause catastrophic damage whether it starts from a dryer or a candle or whatever. (There are some instructive videos on YouTube of how quickly fires spread in rooms)
- roenxi 2y agoAfter a few years of arguing with people about nuclear safety I'm not sure that this sort of perspective is useful. People make a gut-feel check on whether they feel safe and then just rationalise it. The actual level of risk doesn't seem to factor in to the conversation. If we're going by the numbers this should probably disqualify the use of home battery storage on safety grounds. We're talking something like 1 home/year catching fire in a large town, those are some crazy levels of damage. If it was 1 home/year being hit by no-harm-detected-but-higher-than-expected radiation people would be seizing the numbers as evidence that a reactor needs to be shut down.
- donavanm 2y agoThere are some specific requirements here in AU/NZ for battery home storage, AS/NZ 5139 2019, and I think another update last year. In short, cant be in the way of or next to an egress, window, or door. Cant be in a habitable space or other enclosed area like attic, roof, wall, or crawlspace. If near habitable space it must have fire resistant material (cement board, steel, etc) between the two and 0.6-1m around the battery. An overview https://www.evergreenelectrical.com.au/blog/best-location-solar-battery https://www.evergreenelectrical.com.au/blog/best-location-so...
- Havoc 2y agoNgl those videos of scooters catching fire in elevators kinda spooked me about lith tech in general. Hoping sodium becomes more common but I gather thats not hugely likely due to chemistry diffs
- left-struck 2y agoI don’t know anything about sodium based batteries but sodium itself is a serious fire danger. Sodium is explosive in water, more so than lithium I believe.
- Filligree 2y agoPure sodium, yes. Sodium mixtures, usually not; table salt is fairly inert. So it depends entirely on the chemistry.
- left-struck 2y agoThat’s true for basically any element including lithium
- neves 2y agoDoesn't people that have money to buy premium electric cars also live in more modern homes? At least in better homes.
- jve 2y agoElectric car is no longer a premium.
- moooo99 2y agoAs much as I would love to agree, this is just objectively not true. Halfway decent used BEVs are super rare and usually expensive, so new remains to only viable option for most. And buying a new car to begin with is a huge premium. And while prices have been steadily declining for BEVs, in most instances a somewhat comparable ICE car is still cheaper to buy. Wether or not that is the case for actually maintaining the vehicle heavily depends on electricity and fuel prices where you live. Considering the article is from Germany, take it as an example. Most people do not live in single family homes, but apartments. Most apartments still don’t have a spot for EV charging, so you have to rely on public chargers. They run from anywhere to 35ct/kWh to 60ct/kWh depending on location and charging method.
- sinuhe69 2y agoI don't think it's a serious study to count the fire incidents in a single year (2023) and then use it as a generally valid statistic for an entire product category. Firstly, the interval is too short, whereas other product categories have many years, if not decades, of statistics. For low probability events, counting in too short a time frame can significantly distort the statistics. Secondly, household battery systems are all relatively new. Similarly, EVs are a recent phenomenon. Is it not reasonable to expect that the chemicals, and hence the safety, of these batteries will degrade over time, so that the fire hazard will increase over time? And if so, counting incidents only for newly installed systems is obviously biased. And third, are all household storage systems the same in general design and chemical composition? If not, then lumping them together is unlikely to be very helpful in understanding the relative safety of the product category.
- fedeb95 2y agoUnless I missed something, it seems to me that the article relays on a substantial lack of actual data.
- zx8080 2y ago> The fires in HSS in Germany were determined using web crawling for the year 2023 because no other data was available.
- dmichulke 2y agoMy main concern with HSS is actually not accidental fires. Instead, the HSS are usually all connected to the internet and receive closed-source updates. So if a malevolent actor were able to hack into one of these companies (and affect the updates) he could probably cause overheating and/or fires in all connected HSS. Of course, the damage would be multiplied by the fact that all fires would start simultaneously. Any opinions on this?
- bArray 2y agoIt's not just possible, but highly likely to occur in the near future. What if the company folds and there is a bug that causes it to halt and catch fire? What stops a RAM/ROM bit flipping? Connected HSS is fundamentally a problem, not unlike IoT. I have several UPS's and not once did I think this might occur, because they are simply not attached to my network in any way. The triggers are based in hardware with a small microcontroller and are unlikely to fail. Systems that run for long periods and could cause damage should be developed differently. Core safety features should be hardware-based, you shouldn't be able to hack it and make it do something dangerous. If it has to be network connected it should be defensively designed.
- GuB-42 2y agoI may be wrong but I think battery protection does not rely on firmware, it may even be analog. There are ICs dedicated to this task, that are cheap and effective. A malicious firmware update can increase battery wear, but it is unlikely to cause a fire.
- oulipo 2y agoOn a different note, there's been a LOT of e-bike battery fires, so that's why with designers and engineers in France we've spent some time designing a battery casing that efficiently contains explosions and flames, to safeguard your home, you can check it here if interested! (it's also a repairable battery, so it saves CO2 compared to a standard battery over the long term) https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/infinite-the-repairable-universal-ebike-battery https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/infinite-the-repairable-u...
- jchw 2y agoI didn't read the entire paper, but what I was really curious to hear about was battery chemistry, and I didn't see much in there (unless I just missed it.) I've been bullish on LiFePO4 because of the ostensible safety benefits, but it would be interesting if anyone has taken a look at the safety risks of different battery chemistries head-to-head. I don't necessarily think that lithium ion batteries are inherently unsafe, but even if their safety properties are in fact acceptable on a societal level, it's hard to grapple with how horrifically violent battery fires can be. There was a video going around of a battery fire where someone got trapped in an elevator with, apparently, an e-bike battery that went into thermal runaway. It's hard to overstate how utterly mangled their body was. Even as someone who grew up with access to LiveLeak and other things I shouldn't have seen, that video and the decimated (shockingly alive, but not for much longer) corpse pulled out of the elevator will be sticking with me for a long time (and reminding me to not bring potentially sketchy high-capacity batteries onto elevators, for whatever it's worth...)
- Melatonic 2y agoHow large was the elevator ? Scary but I wonder if you had time to react if you could shove the bike to the opposite side and maybe be relatively fine
- MisterTea 2y agoI saw the video. It was a very small car, the kind you would see in a small apartment building - something like 4 feet square or 1.25m square, if even. Basically a closet. Edit: to add it wasn't the whole bike but the battery pack itself. It was in his hand.
- jchw 2y agoPretty small, but I'm not sure if it matters. If any battery starts out-gassing when you're in an elevator, you're probably as good as dead, because the hydrogen fluoride release will quickly cause tremendous damage to you or just flat out kill you; I doubt there's much you can do about it. So I definitely think that the moral of the story is simply never, ever take a large battery onto an elevator Maybe solid state batteries can some day give us more peace of mind.
- buccal 2y agoIt should be noted that it is a preprint of a paper that is not peer reviewed. I would wait a bit for a peer reviewed paper.
- pwpwp 2y ago> The fires in HSS in Germany were determined using web crawling for the year 2023 because no other data was available. All other probabilities were calculated using researched data. The results show a significantly lower probability of an HSS fire compared to a general house fire. Seems legit.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoyep also: > the findings indicate that the probability of an HSS fire is very low (0.0049 %) and is 50 times lower than for a general house fire. So for every 50 "normal" house fires, one extra will be due to HSS. The bigger question is, what are the consequences of such fires? Looking at burning electric cars, that can't be put out, having burning batteries in an apartment building basement doesn't really seem that fun.
- Filligree 2y agoBattery fires are highly toxic. You’ll need to evacuate the area, and cleaning up afterwards might be fun.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoI had thought that if I went all-in on a battery system for the home it would ideally be in a cinder-block structure some 50 feet or so from the house — perhaps even below ground. I'm not sure if people are doing or considering such a thing, if it would be effective.
- Joel_Mckay 2y agoThese should be stuck in a temperature controlled outdoor pit, zoned for small skid steer access, and covered with a metal or reinforced concrete lid to vent smoke away from people. All lithium batteries fail eventually, and sometimes catastrophically. Planning for safe and easy maintenance should be part of the solution. =3
- metalman 2y agoapples to apples , would be to compare all domestic electrical risks, especialy accidents involving serious injury and fatalities,over time. There is going to be a significant drop in serious accidents after the introduction of breakers and gfi's ,vs, when there were only fuses, and all to often the fuses were replaced with a copper penny. And they were two wire with no neutral.So two different appliences could be reverse grounded in the same area, bad bad budaboom. So in these kinder ,ha!, more grounded times, its likely that total risk is still going down, as older legacy wireing is replaced. There is still many thousands of miles of tube and knob wireing, still carrying current. With.a significant rise in the proportion of transportation, bieng converted to electrical power, there will be an increase in "electrical" accidents, but I think that ,if that was compared to the accidents occuring now with gasoline powered transport, again the numbers will be falling. Gasoline is nasty, dangerous stuff, which is very similar to the electrolite in lithium batteries, except that there is much much more of it around....anf I have yet to see comparisons done, based on actual total accident rates, to the point that ,there is never any mention of the total gasoline fires.
- rapjr9 2y agoIf Tesla's Powerwall's are so safe, why does the legal agreement to buy one absolve them of all responsibility if there is a fire? This is what has been preventing me from considering buying one in Vermont.