15 ms·
How Amazon’s ambitious new push for same-day delivery will destroy local retail
- peppertree 14y agoAmazon is playing chess while the brick and mortar stores are playing checkers.
- enraged_camel 14y agoCan you elaborate?
- jmonegro 14y agoAmazon is playing a complicated but more rewarding game with millions of moves and therefore ample opportunities to innovate, while old fashioned brick and mortar stores are stuck in a simple game with little to no room for more innovation.
- kamaal 14y agoI think the small stores have had their chance, which has come and gone. Simple rule while you do anything it to ponder the 'next steps'. You just can't keep waiting and expect your competition to do nothing in return.
- api 14y agoMore technology driven hyper-deflation on the way. The future: high inflation in food, energy, fuel, and consumables, hyper-deflation in everything else except to the extent that it depends on or consumes the former.
- GFKjunior 14y agoSolid analysis, the only other online community I frequent is zerohedge and they have been calling it biflation for some time now. Things like housing, equity, and bond prices will deflate while commodity prices will continue to inflate.
- Codhisattva 14y agoThe act of predicting the future alters the future. Especially true with economics.
- themgt 14y agoExcept to the extent that stuff like this cannibalizes existing resource use (e.g. all the people driving an SUV to the shopping mall who instead buy with one-click), and to the extent technology & automation end food/energy/resource scarcity as well (which is underway, but hard to tell timeframes)
- tokenadult 14y agoThe future: high inflation in food, energy, fuel, and consumables, hyper-deflation in everything else except to the extent that it depends on or consumes the former. The reply below your reply that says "The act of predicting the future alters the future" indeed expresses a truth about economics. But as a person who once predicted the future, by writing down my predictions and putting them (with classmates' predictions) in a time capsule that was opened thirty-one years later, I'd like to explore this process of predicting the future a bit more. What exactly do you mean by "high inflation in food, energy, fuel, and consumables." Do you mean that in the developed world it will take more units of time at typical paid work to buy a meal or light up a room in 2050 than it does in 2012? That suggests a bet, a bet on which I would be willing to take the side contrary to your side. (I think so, as soon as I figure out if that is really what you are predicting.) What is included in the category "consumables," and what is not? What is your definition of "hyperdeflation"? Does that basically mean that you or I or anyone else in the developed world will be able to obtain more and more of that "everything else" (WHAT everything else?) for fewer and fewer units of time spent in paid work? What kinds of goods or services do you have in mind here?
- mindslight 14y agoWhat else could you expect when the explicit goal of monetary policy is to fight natural deflation? (how does any upstart win in a competitive market? doing better things cheaper). The costs of manufacturing and services are dropping the quickest, so feedback-driven monetary inflation causes the price of raw resources to skyrocket.
- tomfakes 14y agoI bought 2 things on Amazon this week, both with free 2 day shipping with Prime Item 1 spent 13 hours on a UPS truck driving around my city and was delivered about 7pm in the evening 2 days after ordering. Item 2 was delivered 14 hours after purchasing by Amazon Fresh at 9am. For the same price of shipping, which service would you rather have? EDIT To Add: The delivery guy for the 14 hour item works for Amazon - the whole experience was produced by Amazon without needing a third party. UPS is another company that will be in trouble if Amazon can make this scale.
- PotatoEngineer 14y agoIt depends on how well I know the item. If it's a commodity where I've bought exactly the same thing before (Charmin Extra-Strong Toilet Paper), then price rules all. If it's a new item that I'm not sure what I need about it (chef knife, bar stool, etc.), then seeing the item in person helps determine which item I need.
- jaggederest 14y agoI'm not sure if you've used Amazon's return system before, but it's absolutely immaculate. In my opinion, this is more an issue of perception than reality - in many ways it's easier to return things to Amazon than to your local store.
- adestefan 14y agoExcept for the times they charge you $8 for return shipping on a $5 item.
- dvdhsu 14y agoEvery time I've tried returning an item less than $20, they don't make me send the item back in. They just give me a refund and tell me to keep the item.
- mh- 14y agoI've never been charged for return shipping. was this purchase an item sold _by_ amazon, not merely fulfilled by them (a la amazon marketplace)?
- JoeCortopassi 14y agoIsn't this just one step away from Amazon just being another brick-and-mortar? If this is the case, is not having an actual store that is accessible by customers (and coincidentally, the neccessary staff), that much of a operational advantage? Or is this just a case of the more efficient company (Amazon) beating out less efficient companies (Best Buy, Barnes and Nobles, etc...)?
- badusername 14y agoI don't think Amazon would ever go the brick-and-mortar route, but having these facilities in major metropolitan areas might enable it to have a lot of 'Pick up at location' kind of shopping.
- jdminhbg 14y agoIt's not just the staff, I think -- it's the real estate. Amazon doesn't have to have conveniently located distributed locations and the inventory headaches associated with them; they can just have one gigantic warehouse in Jersey that provides goods to all their customers in Manhattan.
- Ixiaus 14y agoNo it isn't, because it's markedly less efficient. Amazon is, literally, taking the concept of the "store" and putting it online - yes they've done that already, but the instant gratification of receiving your item same-day; that's a true shopping experience that you, previously, could only really have with Brick and Mortar shops. Instead of physically shopping inside of a store where you will have fewer selection, you shop online with a lot more selection, a powerful search based interface, recommendations, reviews, etc...; then have the items efficiently sent to you same-day. Amazon is very successfully grounding the "internet" in the real world - and they are eating quite a few lunches.
- jaggederest 14y ago> is not having an actual store that is accessible by customers (and coincidentally, the neccessary staff), that much of a operational advantage? Absolutely it is. Real estate, depreciation, maintenance, utilities, not even to mention salaries, insurance... there's a lot to go into that.
- ktr 14y agoThis is crazy - I ordered 3 things from Amazon today through Prime and started wondering if/when a day would come when you'd have same day delivery from Amazon and what it would look like. I figured it would happen someday, but thought the complexities would be too much to handle for a while. Looks like they're way ahead of me. This is why I love Amazon.
- Gustomaximus 14y agoI think this will come into it's own with driverless car technology. Once we combine the current automated warehouses with automated delivery the timescale and costs will drop dramatically.
- sage_joch 14y agoI think the implications of emerging technologies are greater than most people realize. Between driverless cars, voice-recognition systems, and the Internet, it doesn't seem far-fetched to imagine saying, "Computer: deliver one large pepperoni pizza and a Sprite", and having it appear on your doorstep within 15 minutes. All without human intervention.
- Gustomaximus 14y agoAnd then we have 3D printing. This is one tech that IMO is going to come fast as companies continue advancing this tech. And then we can swap delivery time for print time on basic items!
- S201 14y agoLooks like Amazon is finally bringing Webvan to fruition. Only took 11 years.
- cjensen 14y agoBy building many warehouses before proving the idea works, they appear to also be repeating Webvan's greatest error.
- jlgreco 14y agoAccording to wikipedia, Amazon has been operating Amazon Fresh since 2007 (the article draws a direct comparison: "It is reviving the business model of ordering groceries online for home delivery first popularized by such companies as HomeGrocer.com and Webvan in the late '90s.") and seems to now own Webvan. I'll leave analysis up to somebody else, but I find this interesting. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AmazonFresh http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AmazonFresh http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Webvan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Webvan
- alanfalcon 14y agoThey are offering same day delivery in some markets today, including Las Vegas. I've used it twice, with the $10 same day delivery being less expensive than other expedited shipping options. It was very cool having a courier drop a package at my door with my purchase the same day I bought it. Even with $10 delivery the final price was cheaper than buying from a retail store at retail prices. I think with these test markets, Amazon has proven to themselves already that the idea works. I know that I'm very happy with the results so far!
- timee 14y agoThey've had same day delivery (local delivery) for quite a few product categories in the Seattle area for some time with Amazon Fresh trucks. I've bought a book recently with same day shipping for an additional 3.99 (Prime) that was on my door step when I arrived at home. http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=200105970 http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=2...
- 14y ago
- ddt 14y agoIt'll destroy larger B&M stores but I doubt it'll fully outdo local specialty shops. What you'll see is a stratification between hyper specialty B&M that sell luxury items only a tiny subset of people want, but are willing to pay out the nose for, and places like Amazon filling the role of Target and Walmart, being the catch-all for everything else that most people need on a week-to-week or month-to-month basis. While you might be able to buy a certain brand of organic mustache wax on Amazon, I don't see a day coming where they'll be able to do that same-day.
- rflrob 14y agoThere's certain classes of non-luxury stores that should survive OK. If I need to find a screw for my (insert doohickey here), I'll go to Ace hardware, where I can try out the different screws in their bins, then pick the one that works. The same logic applies to lots of other hardware store type items.
- ddt 14y agoAbsolutely, any product that you need to physically inspect before you buy seems like it'd survive.
- GuiA 14y agoI wonder how that'll change with 3D printers. What if Amazon gives you a "preview" file of the object you want for your 3D printer?
- ippisl 14y agoLike shoes ? and clothes ? those are starting to move online using some interesting technologies[1][2] and there's no reason to believe that we won't find a way to help with buying other physical items. [1] using the kinect to virtually measure clothes on your TV. [2] using a variable robot to show you how a specific garment would look on your specific measurements.
- eshvk 14y ago
- craze3 14y ago(Disclosure: Slate participates in Amazon Associates, an "affiliate" advertising plan that rewards websites for sending customers to the online store. This means that if you click on an Amazon link from Slate—including a link in this story—and you end up buying something, Amazon will send Slate a percentage of your final purchase price.) Do they really think that they'll get more affiliate conversions by being the honest guys? Seriously, what is the point of this?
- Codhisattva 14y agoNothing wrong with "over disclosure".
- suresk 14y agoIt looks like they are just trying to disclose a potential conflict of interest.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rads 14y agoSlate probably thinks it's worth giving up short-term profits for long-term reader trust, which is particularly important for an online newspaper. The referral money is still money, but it's icing on the cake.
- philfreo 14y agoit's about full disclosure: for readers to fully trust a a publisher they should disclose when they are getting paid to discuss certain things
- kek 14y agoIt has to do with journalistic ethics. By disclosing this now, they avoid a bad reputation when someone "discovers" that they participate in the affiliate program.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 14y ago
- bennesvig 14y agoThe only advantage local retail stores have is immediacy. You can buy it as fast as you can drive there (and park/find it in the store/wait in line). Amazon has almost every other advantage. Ive come to find shopping local retail stores more and more frustrating. Shopping without reviews or videos, and having to flag down employees to help you locate items. It's really hard to beat online shopping with one day or two day shipping. Not impossible, but challenging. Target, Best Buy, and other generic mass retailers would be hurt the most
- wh-uws 14y agoForget the review and videos. What about service? Stores as large as mighty Wal-mart itself are hardly staffed anymore. When I want to ask where something is I find myself increasingly having to bother an already busy person at the cash register...
- brigade 14y agoTheoretically, being able to try the product before purchase is another advantage. Particularly for me where it seems no one complains about terrible user interfaces or noise anywhere near enough in reviews. But in practice, outside of clothing and furniture, very few stores are set up to allow this almost at all. So screw them. Returning stuff adds additional complexity for consumers (you have to repack it and drive to a drop-off point) and eats into profit margins, especially for non-clothing items that can no longer be sold as new.
- impendia 14y agoNo, local retail stores can be (depending on what you're shopping for) a lot more fun to shop at. You get to talk to salespeople and other customers, and you get to browse around the store. Now most shopping isn't fun. Toilet paper? click But if I decide I want to take up drawing? I'm going to drive to a store, look around, and have fun. But I certainly agree with your last point. As I see it, the advantage of Amazon Prime is that I never have to go to Target.
- ekianjo 14y agoYeah, but most of the time your local retailers will not have the right product in stock (unless you are very vague about your requirements). On top of that, local stores are annoying: it takes time to go there, you need to deal with traffic, weather condition, sometimes shop employees being too intrusive and wanting to see you additional services (or recommending you bad products), waiting in line just to pay. etc... It's just not worth anymore. Amazon delivers at my door usually 2 days after I order something. In case of defect they even come at my door to pick the malfunctioning product. They are clearly doing what's BEST for customers. I don't even understand why local shops who have stores a few kms away from me don't even offer delivery services. They don't even think about improving anything, and they well deserve to disappear. No regrets.
- andyl 14y agoRetailers pushed to impose the sales tax on Amazon. Now it looks like they are going to get what they asked for.
- tmuir 14y agoIn the chicago area, you can order from McMaster Carr (mechanical hardware), and get same day delivery. Any company that builds anything mechanical is probably ordering something from McMaster Carr. This isn't an impossible problem.
- Caerus 14y ago> Amazon has long enjoyed an unbeatable price advantage over its physical rivals. When I buy a $1,000 laptop from Wal-Mart, the company is required to collect local sales tax from me, so I pay almost $1,100 at checkout. This is such an over blown argument. Sure, Amazon is ~7% (where I live) cheaper than traditional stores due to sales tax. But that $1000 Wal-Mart laptop has a $900 sticker price on Amazon, and most non electronic items are 20-40% cheaper than in stores. If laws change and I have to start paying sales tax on Amazon, it won't change a thing about my buying habits. Edit: They also have an inventory many times larger than any brick and mortar store. Whenever I go shopping, I have to choose between the least crappy option Wal-Mart decides to stock. On Amazon, I get exactly the one I want.
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoBut you're picking a fairly non-representative product for this issue. I doubt any of us are going to be buy a laptop from Walmart, looking at their stock, I don't think many other people are either. They have a couple but this is not their bread and butter (which actually is their bread and butter).
- Caerus 14y agoI only picked that because it was the example in the article. Looking at my recent Amazon purchases: Amazon: Oxo Coasters $9.99 for 8 Walmart: Comparable set, Silicon Coasters $30 for 6 Amazon: DVD Rack $29.99 Walmart: Comparable model from same company, $39.00 Amazon: American Crew Pomade, $21.49 for 2 Walmart: $16.98 for 1 Amazon: 13 Watt CFL, $15.98 for 8 Walmart: Same model, $16.88 for 4 Those were the first 4 items I tried to compare.
- muhfuhkuh 14y agoIn almost no category that I've sampled has Walmart ever been the absolute rock-bottom cheapest compared to several places (Big Lots, Dollar General, local grocery chains, Amazon... even Target, believe it or not). People, however, can't go to Amazon to get infant formula, a car battery, ammunition, and a jar of pickles at 1AM and have it in hand immediately. Walmart used to be about "made in the USA", then it was "always low prices", now it's about "live better". It's Walmart's ubiquity, convenience, and momentum that keeps them dominant (and their ability to loss-leader competitors out of business).
- Scene_Cast2 14y agoThere are a few fundamental, hard problems : energy and transportation. Amazon is trying to solve a subset of the latter here. However, I like to see/feel some things in person before buying. I often go through lot of items before finding "the one". Examples: food, pens, shoes. It would revolutionize the industry if Amazon could solve that. Until then, it's just a really large online store. Also - USA isn't the world. Non-US Amazon is heavily sub-par to other online stores: worse prices, small selection. So there's that, too.
- ippisl 14y agoI think amazon is concentrating on the clear and really hard pieces of eCommerce: warehouses everywhere, robotics, pack stations and leaves the fuzzy and less hard pieces to start-ups. So now for example there are many start-ups working on the clothes and shoes fitting problem. In the future when the solution will be found , amazon would buy them , or just use their eCommerce muscle to force them into good terms or just copy them if possible.
- learc83 14y agoThe other day I ordered something from Amazon, and it showed up in a small cargo van, delivered by a guy without a uniform, and in a package with no UPS or FEDEX label (or any other delivery label I could discern apart from the amazon labels). Was this some kind of test for Amazon ran delivery from a local warehouse?
- alanfalcon 14y agoAmazon does a bunch of drop ship orders. If a vendor gets a local order, I can imagine they may decide to save on shipping by sending an employee to hand deliver the product. Or it could have been a local courier service (same day delivery uses couriers).
- mikeash 14y agoAmazon often uses smaller regional delivery companies. I assume they're cheaper for the areas they serve. In the DC area, a lot of Amazon orders are delivered with Lasership, which pretty much fits your description. They drive shoddy white cargo vans with PACKAGE DELIVERY slapped haphazardly on the side. Their deliveries often don't make it. Once they delivered my package 30 miles away for no apparent reason (completely unrelated family name, no similarities in address, etc.). Amazon's use of them seems to have declined recently, but they're still using them and it really doesn't seem like a good idea.
- tomfakes 14y agoThe package I had delivered today came via Amazon Fresh - the grocery delivery service they are testing in the Seattle area. It looks like they're also using it for non-Fresh items too for small, commodity items like CDs This is Amazon owning the entire process from order until the item is in my hand.
- MartinCron 14y agoI use Amazon fresh all the time, and it's possible to get all sorts of non-grocery things through it. I think it's whatever Amazon.com stuff they have available in the local warehouse.
- grandalf 14y agoI already don't shop locally except on a whim and when there are items I'm not price sensitive about at all. Well, groceries are an exception but I like to pick my own produce.
- wheels 14y agoAmazon has been doing this in parts of Germany since 2009. The results haven't been nearly as dramatic as the article predicts. As others have indicated, the limiting factor isn't so much speed of delivery as the inclination to physically inspect items before buying them. That said, Zappos, now a part of Amazon, has succeeded in doing that in one of the markets that tends the most towards such. Even so, there are still a lot of places to buy shoes.
- AncientPC 14y agoI suspect this is a uniquely American thing. Similar to Dell's failed entrance into Asia, Americans are uniquely content with purchasing plenty of merchandise without ever physically examining the product.
- eswangren 14y agoWhy wOuld I feel the need to inspect a book before buying it? I am working under the assumption that no pages will be missing. It's worked out fine thus far. You do realize that purchasing items over the Internet has been working well for some time now, right?
- greghinch 14y agoYou've obviously not tried purchasing things in a 3rd world market, such as in China
- mseebach 14y agoYou're failing to account for the fairly sizable chunk of the world that's both not the US and not the third world. Such as Germany, where people do seem to prefer physically inspecting items.
- latch 14y agoChina hasn't been a 3rd world country for some time. It isn't even close. Sure there are massive pockets of poverty (with 1 billion people, there are massive pockets of everything)...but visit India or parts of Africa if you want to see what 3rd world is.
- ck2 14y agoWhat this is going to do is punish people in non-metro areas. The way that happens is the same way supermarkets work. In very competitive areas, cut rate prices, coupons and promos like doubling, etc. are offered very liberally. To make up for that profit loss, they pump up the prices and cut out promotions in areas where there is little to no competition. In areas with a walmart and target and now amazon local delivery, prices are going to be crazy good. Everyone else will suffer as they supplement the profit-loss.
- lliiffee 14y agoThere is no reason to think that prices elsewhere will get worse. If they could get away with charging higher prices in non-metro areas now, they would do it already. It is likely, however, that non-metro areas will fail to see the price lowering that other areas do.
- einhverfr 14y agoI don't know about that. In Chelan, WA (population 3000, plus tourists, whole valley population maybe 10000 + tourists) 2 supermarkets, 3 if you count the fact that one of them has another location the next town over), prices aren't any higher than they are in Seattle, and both supermarkets have amazing deals occasionally. I once bought a whole beef tenderloin for $5.99/lb during one of the specials. One supermarket has themed specials every 2-3 weeks during the summer and reasonable prices the rest of the time. They also really focus on meeting needs of everyone around, so you can find goat meat, intestines, tripe, cow feet, and shank for sale in their meat department, and the shank is about half the price that they originally quoted me when i requested it. The fact is that if you are in a rural area, you already end up with lower housing prices and some other benefits. So I wouldn't be surprised if that compensates for the increased shipping efforts. I am not saying I like the supermarkets. I wont do business with the local Safeway because of ways they have treated family members. However, I wouldn't say prices are higher.
- jusben1369 14y agoRemember when home videos were going to obliterate movie cinemas? Who would go out when they can watch a movie on their couch?! For a while too things dipped. Then people realized there was a social element to going to the movies that made it a compelling experience. Add to that iMax and 3D etc. Heck, who would bother going to an Apple store when you can buy everything online! Amazon is to shopping what McDonalds is to food. We all know what happens when you have McDonalds every day.
- ricardobeat 14y agoYou get fat? I rarely go to the movies because I can watch netflix on my couch (and save $20-$30). Movie attendance still grows because of economic growth, but in relative numbers it's falling (down 4% in the US/2011).
- gwern 14y agoAnd there are other factors; 3D movies apparently have contributed to profits.
- PaulHoule 14y agoA general policy that "online stores pay sales tax" also benefits Amazon vs. small internet retailers. A while ago I sold a few bumper stickers online and ended up using cafepress. I could have made a better profit by printing the stickers in bulk and mailing them to people, but I'd have to spend $100+ on paperwork just for the privilege of paying sales tax just in case I sell any to New Yorkers. If small internet businesses had to pay taxes to the 40+ states that have sales tax plus to all the other jurisdictions (cites, counties, who knows what) in the U.S. it would be almost impossible to sell stuff and comply with the the law. For AMZN the overhead is nothing.
- einhverfr 14y agoActually a general policy that "businesses that deliver things pay sales tax per jurisdiction that they deliver thins to" (the way "online stores pay sales tax" is implemented) benefits Amazon vs small local retail stores that deliver. Where I usually live in the US, there are at least 6-7 tax jurisdictions within 20 min. by car. For businesses in Wenatchee that may deliver within an hour's radius, there are a very large number of tax jurisdictions. Most brick-and-mortar businesses ignore the rule and figure if they don't tell the state they are delivering things, they won't get looked at too closely, but it means they are in violation of the law.
- mathattack 14y agoYou're very right on all of this. Amazon is a tough competitor in any environment.
- MBCook 14y agoThe tax argument comes up in every discussion like this. It's a nice advantage, but I seriously doubt their sales are very different in areas they charge tax and those where they don't. I have to pay Amazon sales tax because they have a distribution center near me. I remember a few years ago I noticed that they were charging me tax when they didn't used to, but it never figured into my buying. The truth is Amazon's prices are generally better anyway, so they still hold an advantage. Shipping was always a bigger problem for me. I would keep lists of things to get and then when I decided I wanted really wanted something I'd order enough to qualify for the $50 or $100 order free shipping. Now I've had Amazon Prime for a few years, and it's fantastic. I don't have to pay extra for two day shipping, and overnight is just $5 or so. Two day is almost always fast enough. Since Amazon has made everything so easy (and I don't have to worry about shipping or waiting too long) I buy more than enough for Prime to pay for its self.
- adventureful 14y agoI thought Walmart already destroyed traditional local retail? This one goes in the scaremonger bag.
- dr_ 14y ago"I have no idea how Amazon made any money on my order (the whole bill was less than $30) but several people on Twitter told me that they’ve experienced similarly delightful service." Therein lies the problem. At some point there will have to be revenues to justify the company's valuation. I suppose their goal is to initially obliterate all competition in entirety and then have everyone purchase from Amazon. I'm doubtful this will work. Of late, there has been a trend towards experience stores - with manufacturers creating their own stores instead of distributing to retailers. Many luxury brands do this and even some non-luxe ones, such as Samsonite, have been getting into the game. There's some value added here, and it's something Amazon won't be able to directly compete with.
- notatoad 14y agoI think you might be underestimating amazon's position. They already have massive revenues, and better mindshare than most of the brands they sell. They aren't some new startup, they bring in millions of dollars a day and are historically proven to be a successful company. Your post would make sense if amazon were a year old. They aren't. They've been doing this for a long time now and are very very good at it.
- sureshv 14y agoQ1 2012 Amazon had $13B in revenue and basically broke even, Costco had $23B in revenue, and Walmart has $113B. Where are you getting your financials from?
- jrabone 14y agoAnd Amazon's revenue is growing 33% YoY. Costco is 8%. Wallmart is 8.5%. See where this is going?
- sureshv 14y agoWhile making very little profit; that's not infinitely sustainable in retail where margins approach nothing. Amazon 2012 profit was $650M, Costco $1.4B, and Walmart $16B. If Walmart decided to go zero profit they could drive out a lot of competition and get a visit from the DOJ...
- kfury 14y agoTL;DR: "Amazon's going to wreck retail now that they're giving up their unfair advantage and relying solely on better service." Boo hoo.
- jsavimbi 14y agoI don't shop local any more unless it's for a premium item and the customer service is beyond average. Not when Amazon can deliver consumer items the next day.
- ori_b 14y agoWhen Amazon lets me physically try out the feel of things while browsing them, see how well built a tool is, or how a piece of clothing fits, it might have a chance of killing local retail. Until then, I like to see which pants fit best, which knife is most comfortable in my hand, which tablet is most responsive. Yes, if I already know what I want, I'll go to Amazon. But if I'm not entirely sure and I want to compare things, I'll go to a local store.
- mseebach 14y ago> Physical retailers have long argued that once Amazon plays fairly on taxes, the company wouldn’t look like such a great deal to most consumers. I love the audacity of "If you can't beat them, find some other way to beat them."
- fsckin 14y agoAmazon failed to collect/remit ~270M in sales tax in Texas and has owed millions for years. So what did the state of Texas do about it? They struck a deal to erase the 270M owed, as long as Amazon starts collecting sales tax starting 7/1, create 2000 jobs and invest 200M in Texas. They were likely already planning more infrastructure in Texas, but threatened to reverse course and pull out of the state entirely. The way I see it, Amazon bluffed the state of Texas to the tune of 270 million dollars and all I might get out of it is next day delivery? I'll take what I can get, I guess.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tsotha 14y agoCompanies are only required to pay state sales tax if they have a physical presence in that state. Amazon wasn't bluffing, Texas was. We went through the same thing in California. Amazon agreed to pay the sales tax, but only after it had decided to open distribution centers in the state.
- fsckin 14y agoAmazon has had a continuous presence in Texas from 2005 onward. Distribution center operated in Irving, TX from 2005 through 2011. Woot, in Carrollton, TX was acquired in 2010.
- tsotha 14y agoWell, if that's the case they have to pay, legally.
- Kadin 14y agoI think the distribution center was owned indirectly, through some sort of holding company; that was the linchpin of their whole argument. Woot was probably just one of the things they were threatening to close down and move out of state if Texas didn't give them a break. And I'm sure they had an argument ready as to why Woot wasn't a tax nexus for Amazon as a whole; there's a lot of really arcane rules that go into determining nexus. The real losers at the end of all this are going to be the tax-free states, who ended up getting a lot of Amazon (and other mail-order retail) business because putting a warehouse there wouldn't risk triggering taxation. But if the tax loopholes are closed, there's not a lot of reason to set up shop there. They are going to be the losers in the end, I think.
- mthoms 14y agoThis is the trojan horse. Once Amazon has a large presence in each major centre, the next logical step for them is use some of their massive space as a showroom (think Ikea but on a much larger scale). [Edit: To clarify, the showroom and warehouse would be in the same complex but separated. Shoppers + heavy merchandise + fast moving robots is a recipe for disaster.] Then they can satisfy both the "I want to see it before I buy it" crowd as well as the "I know what I want - just give me the best price" crowd. Mark my words. Amazon has the Costco's, Walmart's and Best Buy's of the world squarely in their crosshairs. *Of course there will of course always be specialty categories that are too niche to fit in this model, thus many specialized retailers will still exist.
- rdl 14y agoInteresting idea, but I seriously doubt Amazon would do this with their normal warehouses -- maybe paying sales tax and thus being able to have presence in major cities would let them set up dedicated showrooms for certain kinds of high-lifetime-margin products, like Kindles and maybe a Kindle Phone, though. Big warehouses are highly automated (especially Amazon's), essentially unsafe for untrained people (forklifts, robots), and potentially at risk for theft. Not the kind of place you'd want customers milling around. Amazon is more likely to promote their existing easy return policy -- buy 3 pairs of shoes and send back the two you don't like -- vs. letting people into their warehouses. Small, Apple-store style showrooms, or partnerships with someplace like Starbucks, would make a lot more sense. The lifetime value of a Kindle user far exceeds the cost of a Kindle (I probably have 200 x $10 books on mine at least), and it's the kind of product where try before you buy could be important. I'd rather have a bunch of Kindles and Kindle Fires in a cafe setting where you could check one out for a few hours, buy or get free drinks, and comfortably use the devices in an ideal environment, though. This could work for all the Amazon first-party products. Maybe there are third-party products which would benefit from this, so Apple store sized showrooms with rotating third party stock (and fixed first party stock) could work, but they are really unlikely to be the existing warehouses.
- mthoms 14y agoTo clarify: the warehouse and the showroom would be separate but contained in the same complex (much like Ikea). Each person has an app on their phone to record their purchases while browsing the showroom. When the shopper is done some items are retrieved robotically for them to pickup while some items (or all items - it's up to the buyer) are delivered later in the day. I don't believe the robot technology is quite yet up to this. But in 5-10 years it should be. This setup would feature primarily first party products but it would also be possible for third party products to be on display in the showroom (to be delivered later from a different location). I agree that Apple-sized showrooms with mid to high-end first party items would be the logical first step.
- dave5104 14y agoI'm surprised Amazon just hasn't started their own logistics company. With the spread of their warehouses now, is the next logical step becoming their own USPS/UPS/FedEx? I can only imagine what would happen once Amazon takes over the part of the process that seems to always have the most problems.
- rdl 14y agoUntil now it would have meant becoming a business in each delivery state and thus exposing themselves to sales tax. Maybe this will change in the future, and they are their own delivery company for AmazonFresh in Seattle I think.
- emperorcezar 14y agoA business is required to pay sales tax, not collect. Like some other businesses, Amazon can just include the tax in the price. For instance, bars will include the taxes in the drink tax because if they show you how much tax is in a glass of beer you'd be very surprised, it's something like 40%. It's an mental game though. Do you get people "through the door" with an item at $19.99 and hope they don't close the tab when they see the $1.00 tax, or do you just advertise it at $21.99 and hope that people are attracted to you because of name, etc even though joesonlineshop.com has it for $19.99?
- mh- 14y agonot really accurate. Businesses don't pay sales tax on purchases for resale. Sales tax is paid by the consumer, but collected by the business. In most states, there is an exception afforded to food/liquor businesses that allows them to advertise prices tax-included. Otherwise, the state laws usually look like this one: http://dor.wa.gov/Content/GetAFormOrPublication/PublicationBySubject/TaxTopics/TaxIncluded.aspx http://dor.wa.gov/Content/GetAFormOrPublication/PublicationB...
- emperorcezar 14y agoSadly the link is broken. I remember when I did a small computer repair business out east 10 years ago that this was not the case.
- sanjiallblue 14y agoOnce 3D printing tech gets off the ground, same-day delivery could end up becoming common or even the standard.
- damian2000 14y agoHere's the original Financial Times article that this one was mostly taken from (nb: this link avoids their paywall via google's url redirection): http://www.google.com/url?q=http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/9bde8748-c201-11e1-8e7c-00144feabdc0.html http://www.google.com/url?q=http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/9...
- farhadmanjoo 14y agoIt's not "mostly taken from." Read both articles.
- ilaksh 14y agoOK so pretty soon Amazon will have same day delivery. That's going to be great! Then, can we have evacuated tubes that connect our homes to all of the retail outlets, or homes to homes maybe also, and then they could have like 5 minute delivery, or however long it takes the picking robot to get it and then for it to travel at hypersonic speed through the tube? Maybe we should all live within a few hundred yards of the warehouses. Then upgrade the picking robots and streamline the warehouses and tubes so they can deliver items in less than a minute. Then we can all have robots that pull the items out of the tube, open the packaging and hand it to us on our couches/beds. I would totally buy a giant plastic jug of cheeseballs right now if it could arrive in less than a minute and be delivered to my hands.
- CitizenKane 14y agoThis is already happening in China. Because of the nature of shipping companies here it's not unusual to buy a product (typically off of http://taobao.com http://taobao.com) and get it later that day or the next day. Many of these businesses are based in Shanghai and if you live there delivery happens nearly instantly. One online shop, http://cheers-in.com/ http://cheers-in.com/ delivers cold beer in Shanghai in 1 - 2 hours from an order. Stuff like this is absolutely fantastic and it would be amazing to see it come to the US.
- msutherl 14y agoGreat for consumers like us, but terrible for all of the people who work ridiculous hours under constant stress on warehouse floors or do deliveries day in and day out. I try to buy from brick & mortar shops purely because running a shop is a job that has a shred of dignity left in it.
- zoul 14y agoA nice article about the conditions in one of such warehouses: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/02/mac-mcclelland-free-online-shipping-warehouses-labor http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/02/mac-mcclelland-f...
- arjunnarayan 14y agoSounds like some people need to unionize.
- icebraining 14y agoYes, everyone who deals with the general public knows how unstressful and dignifying that is. That is, besides having to deal with blatant sexism[1], extreme ignorance[2], elderly genitalia[3], stealing[4], destruction of property[5], physical violence[6], bigotry[7], etc. [1]: http://notalwaysright.com/man-up-and-let-a-woman-fix-it/21360 http://notalwaysright.com/man-up-and-let-a-woman-fix-it/2136... [2]: http://notalwaysright.com/spyware-is-strength/21253 http://notalwaysright.com/spyware-is-strength/21253 [3]: http://notalwaysright.com/at-least-we-know-her-natural-color/21093 http://notalwaysright.com/at-least-we-know-her-natural-color... [4]: http://notalwaysright.com/to-conjugate-a-thief/20886 http://notalwaysright.com/to-conjugate-a-thief/20886 [5]: http://notalwaysright.com/customers-can-be-tiring/20828 http://notalwaysright.com/customers-can-be-tiring/20828 [6]: http://notalwaysright.com/cuffed-red-handed/20707 http://notalwaysright.com/cuffed-red-handed/20707 [7]: http://notalwaysright.com/bigotry-gets-served/20336 http://notalwaysright.com/bigotry-gets-served/20336
- hef19898 14y agoThe biggest challenge I see for amazon to come is, besides competition and makets and all that their ability to handle their whole supply chain. Amazon already proved that in terms of warehousing and distribution they are really ggod. but if there is one thing that comes with an ever increasing number of arehouses, especially if you want same-day delivery, is a ever increasing inventory level, in both number of items and value. So from the outside one cornerstone of a strategy like this would be inventory management at at least regional if not even warehouse level. It's do-able, no question, but difficult. An advantage amazon has here is a huge history of point-of-sales data for most important regions they are operating in, no matter if there actualy is a amzon warehouse or not. And if they don't have (enough) point of sales data, well then it's to early to offer same-day service and all that. All amazon has to do now is to keep operations up to the task... :-)
- arjn 14y agoMy opinion is that this may not be the end of local retail. I would still prefer to shop at my local grocers and farmers market on the weekend. Sometimes shopping is more than just shopping, its also an outing with family.
- zeroonetwothree 14y agoWorkplaces should be an easy place to get same day delivery. At a large office you probably have 100+ Amazon orders each day that conveniently get delivered by the company's staff. Amazon could have their own truck just drive straight to the office building without getting UPS involved at all.
- stephen272 14y agoFirst the internet revolutionized music and eliminated record stores Then it revolutionized videos and took down video stores It didn't stop there, and moved on to bookstores and wiped them out. And now its taking out brick and mortar stores in general. Honestly, I LOVE IT! The internet is so great. Anything that gets stuff in my hand faster or easier is great in my eyes.
- wilki 14y agoI do wonder how much online retailers have saved by not dealing with shoplifting and the overhead involved with a fleet of loss-prevention employees.
- ams6110 14y agoI'm quite sure any warehouse operator will tell you that there is still a problem with theft.
- webjunkie 14y agoIn Germany, when you order in the morning before noon, you will most likely get your stuff by the next morning without any special shipping at all. That's how efficient the German postal service is :)
- mariuolo 14y agoI can think of several local stores I would like to be erased from existence.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoI don't think it will destroy local retail. All the businesses within a 10 minute walk of your home will be fine, it's still more convenient than same day shipping unless your very busy. It's the businesses slightly outside the core of the town that will suffer. If it takes you 30-60 minutes to drive to a store you might order same-day from Amazon.
- hrktb 14y agoI'd have died to have that in the US or Japan for e.g., anywhere delivery of basic goods actually works and isn't painful. I feel the main barrier to this is to have the local delivery company deliver things on time and in a friendly fashion. That's not something you could expect in any country amazon operates (french's chronopost delivery is really hostile for ex., but there should be a ton of others). It'd bear with it for things I expect in weeks anyway, it would be horrible to have it for goods that are supposed to be there today.
- ams6110 14y agoI don't see how they can possibly achieve the same economies of scale with a lot of small local distribution centers vs. a few huge ones. Plus coordinating deliveries in all those local markets vs. just having UPS or FedEx handle that part. To a point this may be successful, but it sounds self-limiting to me.
- parka 14y agoI hope this applies to international shipping as well. I buy stuff regularly from Amazon and their prices are even cheaper than what my country's local stores are offering after shipping included. E.g. A book from Amazon cost ~30% cheaper than the shops here in Singapore.
- Shivetya 14y agoI remember my grandmother telling us how first the bus and then the family car let her shop where she wanted to. Stores adapted. Face it, lack of transportation will allow bad service to exist simply because the customers are trapped. When your the only game in town, well. So I don't buy the dire predictions.
- stretchwithme 14y agoBecause the last mile is always so expensive and subject to theft, I think we'll eventually have a centralized local pickup location for all sorts of small deliveries. We'll just stop there on the way home if something has arrived. That will even include your postal mail if the postal service ever wakes up. There's no need to physically deliver mail every day if people could see what mail they've received remotely and can pick it up or request deliver if they can't leave home.
- ianb 14y agoWe've built a little nook for packages on our front porch, I wonder if more people will do that sort of thing as well.
- stretchwithme 14y agoIn the old days, they had milk boxes. One house I lived in as a kid had one. There's usually a door on the outside and a locked door on the inside. Here's one: http://www.wellsphere.com/allergies-article/built-in-milk-box/1077155 http://www.wellsphere.com/allergies-article/built-in-milk-bo...
- snambi 14y agoAmazon is trying to become a specialized shipping service?
- jonhendry 14y agoLocal retail is their own worst enemy, at least those that have websites. If I go to the website of a brick and mortar store, chances are I want to know what they carry in-store, because I need something specific and am planning to visit a store. Ideally I'd be able to see what they have in stock at the local stores, so I can avoid a needless trip. Instead, many retailers have larded up their online stores with online-only products. Some don't even give you an easy way to exclude those and see only in-store items. This is stupid, and just makes me more likely to not bother visiting the store at all, opting to just order from Amazon.
- baak 14y agoTo be honest, I feel this has a good outcome for environmentalism as well. Same day delivery putting physical retailers out of business means less overall driving.
- sageikosa 14y agoAt long last, the dreams of the Coyote ordering from Acme and getting immediate delivery of his latest gadget to catch the Roadrunner come closer to fruition.
- zackmorris 14y agoI thought of this November 3, 2010 :-) http://beginwithyou.org/2010/11/03/the-next-ebay/ http://beginwithyou.org/2010/11/03/the-next-ebay/
- russell 14y agoI actually have a problem with Amazon's shipping. I live in a small town. Often FedEx shipments are dropped off at the USPS, so a two day delivery turns into three or more days. The worst was 5 days. UPS OTOH often delivers the next day.
- dkrich 14y ago"I’d gotten next-day Saturday service for free. I have no idea how Amazon made any money on my order (the whole bill was less than $30) but several people on Twitter told me that they’ve experienced similarly delightful service." I've got news for you- they didn't make any money on your order. Amazon is profitable but has razor-thin margins on the whole. They take losses on several markets, including Prime, gambling that the entire seamless, low-cost user experience will cause enough people to spend enough money to push them over the edge of profitability. I for one have serious doubts about whether what the author describes (based to a large extent on pure speculation) would be a profitable business model. It's one thing to keep huge amounts of inventory in centralized locations and ship items out across the country over the course of days. It's quite another to stock all that inventory redundantly throughout every state. So if I want to buy a specific pair of shoes that I can't find at Foot Locker, is Amazon going to stock 50 pairs on the off-chance that somebody down the street is going to buy them? Probably not. In fact, the USPS runs a similar business model. One would then logically think (if this article is any indicator) that UPS and FedEx would go belly-up. I mean after all, if I can distribute mail to somebody's house for $0.50 in a day, how could UPS and FedEx compete with that? The reality is just the opposite. UPS and FedEx enjoy such enormous margins when compared to the USPS, that they want no part of the markets in which the USPS operates and it's too late for the USPS to compete with UPS and FedEx on parcels and important packages. I don't agree with the author's prediction at all.