10 ms·
I Stayed
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- butterfly42069 2y agoBelieving in the work the author was/is doing is one thing, but I can't help but wonder if/how they still believe in their boss.
- emn13 2y agoI don't have faith in wordpress nor really care about them, but I find this particular aspect of Zeldman's story pretty believable. It's not hard to see Matt's actions both as bad and yet well intentioned, especially if the underlying problem of freeloading is perhaps existential to the current maintainers of wordpress (no idea if it is). It's pretty easy to forgive mistakes if you believe people made them for the right reasons, and especially if those reasons are important and the consequences of the mistake fairly diffuse, as might be the case here. Also, given Zeldman's prior work he clearly believes in the power of big ideas; he's surely more likely than most to see the need for pain now to prevent much more later on. Doesn't mean we have to agree with him; just that it's not hard to empathize with it.
- butterfly42069 2y agoThankyou, that's a good perspective. Just to clarify, I wasn't disagreeing (or agreeing) with his actions, I was just curious about what I felt was missing from the article.
- pastaguy1 2y agoWhat's the background on doing a soft layoff (or w/e) and hiring at the same time? Many of us have seen one of these close-up, just wondering what the case is here.
- f3z0 2y agoIt’s an alignment layoff “I’m an asshole and if you aren't on board GTFO”. It’s right out of Musk’s playbook. Although I think Musk does it better.
- threetonesun 2y agoMusk is an ideological asshole, this is Matt recognizing further growth probably requires pushing WP Engine out of their market. If you disagree with him on this, you probably disagree where Automattic as a whole is going.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jzb 2y agoI hope the decision works out for him. Six months salary is really only a big bag of cash if 1) you have a decent salary, and 2) you can be confident of landing a job of equal or better salary within the six-month window. Otherwise you're just going to burn through it. Given the way hiring has been in the tech world of late, it's easy to imagine it taking six months or more to get a decent job -- you can easily spend several months interviewing to have a role disappear. FWIW I'd have to be pretty pissed and/or have no confidence in the direction of the company & its leadership and/or have another job/work lined up already to jump ship on a few days' notice like that.
- peteforde 2y agoZeldman would have zero trouble getting hired anywhere tomorrow if he indicated that he was available. This isn't the case for most people, but he is anything but most people.
- ValentineC 2y agoI'm guessing one other reason he's staying is that he's probably still on Automattic's advisory board [1], and has significantly more influence on the company's direction than most other people who have taken the offer. [1] https://twitter.com/zeldman/status/403874979512877056 https://twitter.com/zeldman/status/403874979512877056
- gspetr 2y agoEven on the face of it this sounds too far fetched. If he's in it for the mission, and not for the money, then surely you can't claim that there aren't companies with a more meaningful mission than blogging? And if there are, could it be that he can't get hired there? He's been literally offered money to leave and he's struggling financially, but he doesn't.
- rendaw 2y agoIt's a nice sentiment, but are you helping people by granting the wishes of an unshackled combative owner? Could you take the money and help people more by working for a company with more careful leadership? Wordpress isn't the only CMS out there...
- cobertos 2y agoIs it really that easy to just leave and find a company/work you vibe with? It seems just as hard as trying to find a quality partner
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vouaobrasil 2y agoCome on, pretty much all work is hurting the world now by furthering unsustainable capitalism. I have yet to find a job that truly helps people in the tech line of work.
- hitekker 2y agoThe "We're hiring" link shows the first position offered is a "Happiness Engineer", https://i.imgur.com/zSVeuYq.png https://i.imgur.com/zSVeuYq.png. > Our software and services aim to provide a seamless experience, but when things don’t go as planned, our customers rely on us for help. Happiness Engineers are the frontline heroes ensuring we deliver the best experience for our users. Their role is crucial because they interact with our customers the most and make the biggest impression in their time of need.
- vunderba 2y agoAs if the title of engineer couldn't get any more diluted. Reminds me of how everyone now is a "specialist". Call Flow Optimization Specialist - Works at the front desk answering the telephone
- talldayo 2y agoGeorge Orwell is kicking himself for not thinking up that name first.
- wojciii 2y agoSomeone should rewrite "1984" as it would work with todays technologies..
- outrun86 2y agoIt is, in fact, being written. It’s called the modern West.
- robin_reala 2y agoWe’re more Brave New World than 1984.
- sbuk 2y agoAbsolutely. The problem here is that people that generally parrot the “1984” meme haven’t read the book, let alone read any Orwell, or Huxley for that matter.
- madeofpalk 2y agoI have a tough time relating to "[believing] in the work we do" at a for-profit company, especially one that just makes blogs. I work at a somewhat similar commercial open source company, I really enjoy my job, and I adore my direct collegues, but I've thought a lot over the past few years that if in a similar position I would almost definitely take the offer. A job you like where ~10% of your colleges leave is a job I would probably enjoy a whole lot less.
- vunderba 2y ago100% agreed - given that they published this under their own name though, I wonder how much of that was just echoing the corporate mission statement of Automattic for the sake of any colleagues who happen to stumble across the blog.
- saghm 2y agoI was a bit dubious about this point of view before reading the full post, but wow, the last couple paragraphs lay it on thick. Suing someone for using your open source product in their own product takes "courage"? Comparing the work of developing Wordpress to Rodney King? I want to give the author the benefit of the doubt, and maybe I'm too cynical, but this sounds even more corporate-y than a lot of stuff I've read on company-hosted blogs.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI don't think there was a comparison between WordPress and Rodney King. If so, what is the comparison being claimed. Is WordPress the cops? The one saying can't we get along? The way I read it at least, it was a simple reference and sentiment, not a comparison.
- saghm 2y agoFair enough. It still feels shoehorned in to me though, almost like an essay in school students are told to include a quote in their conclusion (something that happened in my English class at least once from what I can remember), which just adds to the vibe of this being "homework" to support their employer rather than coming across as authentic.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mplewis 2y agoWhy? This is someone else’s fight. Do you have a high amount of equity in Automattic? You have to look out for number one.
- throw16180339 2y ago"It's not the rats who first abandon a sinking ship. It's the crew members who know how to swim." - Antonio Garcia Martinez, Chaos Monkeys: Obscene Fortune and Random Failure in Silicon Valley
- sonofhans 2y agoFWIW Jeffrey Zeldman is a living legend. He was one of the first print designers to transition to the web, did it well, and wrote about it constantly. He designed the “Batman Forever” website in 1995; it was visited by something like one-third of all Internet users. He created the Web Standards Project, hugely influential in getting browser manufacturers to support standards rather than pee in the pool. And if you think cross-browser support today is rough, at the time you could reliably crash production browsers with valid CSS. Never mind A List Apart, one of the best early mailing lists on the web, a kind of transitionary form between Usenet and forums/Discord. And A Book Apart, which published lots of high-quality stuff. If you develop for the web today, every time a browser behaves as the spec describes, thank Jeffrey Zeldman.
- rudasn 2y agoZeldman, Bowman, Molly, ppk are the ones I remember reading and learning from back in the IE6, pre-firefox days. Legends indeed.
- robin_reala 2y agoRIP Molly.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hardwaresofton 2y agoThank you for this — I was uninformed.
- ddingus 2y agoAs was I. Now off to read about these interesting people.
- triyambakam 2y ago> I already miss them, and most only quit yesterday. I feel their departure as a personal loss, and my grief is real. The sadness is like a cold fog on a dark, wet night. I can't understand this. I do not view my coworkers as part of my personal life, so while I enjoy working with some, I wouldn't say I'm sad if they leave. This sounds unhealthy
- syndicatedjelly 2y agoIs it possible for you to understand why others might feel this way about their colleagues and work?
- peteforde 2y agoWhy are you spending your finite life working with people who you wouldn't fight for? This might not be a "them" problem. I'm not advocating that your coworkers have to be at the same rung as your family or [in-group X] but it's weird/sad to many reading this that you're okay not caring about the people you spend your days working towards a common goal with.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MiscIdeaMaker99 2y agoLOL When you spend 8 hours a day around folks and become friends with them, it's natural to miss them when they leave. It's OK if you don't have any meaningful relationships with your co-workers, but, to me, that sounds unhealthy.
- anon7000 2y agoI worked at Automattic and the connections you could develop with your coworkers were fantastic. Almost everyone was kind, helpful, and encouraging, and I did my best to bring a positive attitude every day. Nearly everything being written communication makes that easier! (Eg you won’t seem standoffish one day if external circumstances have you in a poor mood.) While you aren’t seeing people every day (the company is distributed), the relatively frequent meetups in cool places are a massive highlight, and just make your relationships that much stronger. There are a lot of folks who have been around for ages — even if you aren’t working with someone directly anymore, you’ll frequently see a familiar face (and helping hand!) on the other side of the company. So the grief of leaving these relationships is acute, especially if you’ve been around for a while. Processing that grief is healthy — and I might suggest that not having any kind of relationship with your coworkers is unhealthy. Or at least speaks to a cold culture somewhere.
- rkokfbrivfi 2y ago[flagged]
- tolerance 2y agoHis evocation of the assault on Rodney King and the L.A. Riots is perplexing.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoFor those of us of a certain age, the phrase "can't we all just get along" connects quite naturally to Rodney King. So if you heard it, or for some other reason wanted to use it in a written piece ...
- tolerance 2y agoI don't know what you're trying to imply. Rodney King was beaten and shocked by four police officers, 63 people died and approximately $1 billion of damages resulted from the Riots. Zeldman's grief is understandable to the extent that one can emphasize with the internal conflict of choosing to remain employed by a company that is under scrutiny by people in your professional/personal community and ran by a man who is proving to be rather unpredictable. There's likely more to Zeldman's personal struggles with respect to his health and other financial concerns than what he discloses (rightfully so). But at the same time, evoking the rhetoric of King during the Riots is indeed perplexing when measured against what Zeldman does speak about more openly: his commitment to the open web in light of the aforementioned drama. In this regard, as the kids say, "It's not that deep". Edit: +++ "in light of the aforementioned drama"
- projektfu 2y agoI think it's to say that, in the face of his beating and the aftermath, King said, "can't we all just get along?" instead of calling for the heads of the cops, the mayor, or whoever else he might have considered blameworthy.
- emn13 2y agoBut that's the whole point! The expression is jarringly mild and reasonable given the circumstances.
- 2y ago
- Kye 2y agoIt will be hard to do that work from within an embattled organization that's only in that situation because of the CEO's behavior. Things don't get better from here. Any good-faith assumptions people made before are just gone. Every action has new layers of scrutiny, every move becomes suspect.
- skybrian 2y ago> I also know that the Maker-Taker problem is an issue in open source, just as I know that a friend you buy lunch for every day, and who earns as much money as you do, is supposed to return the favor now and then Informal agreements like this work between people who know each other, not for agreements between strangers. The terms in an open source license are intended to be universally applicable, to make the obligations clear for anyone who reads them. This includes total strangers and companies that didn’t exist when you published the code. Those strangers shouldn’t be expected to abide by anything not explicitly written down in the license. If the license doesn’t document the obligations you expect of anyone, you used the wrong license. We should be suspicious of people who try to claim that there are additional unwritten obligations for reusing source code. Open source licenses have very generous terms, maybe too generous. They allow takers. That’s how it works, you can take it.
- marcinzm 2y agoIt's I think sort of clear from everything that Automattic's leadership doesn't seem to understand that running a business means you're running a business. You're not making a side project, working on a hobby or running a non-profit. You're running a for-profit business which means others will treat you as such and you can't make excuses for it.
- mlyle 2y agoNah. Or at least, not entirely. (I'm not really writing about Automattic here). Contracts -- and law in general -- describe in detail what kinds of actions will allow another to bring legal force into play against you or vice-versa. But there's all kinds of actions that I can legally take that don't conform to norms that will invite condemnation and reprisal through means other than the legal sphere. Not every obligation should be given legal force; not every action that's strictly legal will turn out to be socially okay or consequence free.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fragmede 2y ago
- nycticorax 2y agoI am just reading about this whole Automattic vs WP Engine fight today, and I'm a little surprised that most people seem to think Automattic is the unambiguous bad guy. Automattic has still given away a huge amount of open-source software away over the years. WP Engine seems like it is entirely a mercenary operation. (Which there's nothing wrong with, per se. But it doesn't exactly warm the cockles of my heart.) And paying people to leave if they don't agree with what the company is doing seems like a win-win.
- ValentineC 2y ago> WP Engine seems like it is entirely a mercenary operation. WP Engine also acquired and maintains Advanced Custom Fields [1] and Local [2] from their subsidiary Flywheel [3]. [1] https://deliciousbrains.com/wp-engine-acquisition/ https://deliciousbrains.com/wp-engine-acquisition/ [2] https://wpengine.com/blog/better-together-wp-engine-and-flywheel-make-local-and-genesis-products-available-to-all-customers/ https://wpengine.com/blog/better-together-wp-engine-and-flyw... [3] https://wpengine.com/blog/wp-engine-to-acquire-flywheel/ https://wpengine.com/blog/wp-engine-to-acquire-flywheel/
- lolinder 2y ago> Automattic is the unambiguous bad guy. I wouldn't say that's what people are saying. I've been a vocal critic of Matt's actions in these threads, and my perspective is basically this: WP Engine may be exactly as bad as Matt says it is. They may be contributing too little and taking too much. I've seen enough of corporations to believe that that can happen. None of that matters any more after Matt's actions in September. WP Engine has put forward convincing evidence that Matt attempted to extort them into paying tens of millions per year to Matt's for profit under threat of launching a smear campaign. Matt then demonstrated that the boundaries between Automattic (the for profit) and the open source project don't exist by locking millions of WordPress users out of the plugin ecosystem over this dispute with the for profit. That plugin ecosystem is the WordPress project. By messing about with that ecosystem Matt showed that he is both able and willing to singlehandedly screw over anyone who uses WordPress because he has a dispute with their hosting provider. That's the issue now. I don't see WP Engine as white knights fighting a villain, but Matt turned what could have been a united effort to improve the WordPress ecosystem into a battle between greedy corporations and it's Matt who showed that he doesn't care who gets caught in the crossfire. The issue isn't that Automattic is the unambiguous bad guy in this suit, it's that Matt has demonstrated he has more power than he can be trusted with.
- forrestthewoods 2y agoWhy does someone who works at Automattic have meaningful medical debt? That's awful. I would expect Automattic to have both good insurance and sufficient pay such that no employee suffers from medical debt.
- aithrowawaycomm 2y agoAs critical as I am of Mullenweg, I am sure Automattic is obeying the Affordable Care Act and giving employees health insurance. It would be a dumb thing to save money on when you're paying competitive wages! This seemed like an adequate explanation without needing any details: > incurred by the closing of my conference and publishing businesses.
- forrestthewoods 2y agoIt's not clear to me why "closing of my conference and publishing businesses" results in medical expenses. I'm not questioning it! I just don't understand the mechanics.
- locallost 2y agoI think those are two separate issues. He's had medical issues and he needs to deal with the closing of his business.
- tzs 2y agoI think people are misreading the statement. The full statement is: > Listen, I’m struggling with medical debts and financial obligations incurred by the closing of my conference and publishing businesses People are reading it as > Listen, I’m struggling with (medical debts and financial obligations) (incurred by the closing of my conference and publishing businesses) but I suspect it was meant to be read as > Listen, I’m struggling with (medical debts) and (financial obligations incurred by the closing of my conference and publishing businesses)
- forrestthewoods 2y ago
- causality0 2y agoMy insight into corporate legal disputes is as meaningful as my opinion on Quantum Mechanics. What an immensely cowardly statement. Zeldman is not some naive worker elf and pretending to be such as an excuse to avoid saying anything is contemptible. If you don't want people to know what you think, just say that, or say nothing. Pretending you don't have an opinion because you don't understand is just...ick.
- stogot 2y agoA Book Apart (the publishing company) closed?! When did this happen? The article linked doesn’t mention a date. So sad I had wanted to use them to publish a book eventually. I wonder what happened
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoI suspect that the current fashion for JavaScript-driven mega-sites, as well as most CMSes, is what happened. His whole Web design system was based on a hand-coded methodology that made standard HTML/CSS sites work optimally. That doesn't really scale too well, into the current world. I was unaware that the company (and conferences) closed. I am sad to hear about his medical issues. They can really clobber you.
- qingcharles 2y agoWow, I didn't know this either. I loved their titles. That's a hard business to be in, in 2024.
- breck 2y ago[flagged]
- blackqueeriroh 2y ago> This is retarded. That word is generally universally recognized as bigoted and discriminatory, so please don’t use it. > Copyright is slavery. No, slavery is slavery. And you are, at best, incredibly insensitive, and at worst, an actual bigot.
- breck 2y ago[flagged]
- brysonreece 2y agoPlease, and I say this for (almost) all of us, grow up.
- breck 2y agoDo you understand that copyright is slavery? If so, then what are you doing about it? Are you retarded or morally weak?
- bmacho 2y ago> And you are, at best, incredibly insensitive, and at worst, an actual bigot. And you are a control freak, who's hobby is to make up random rules, and insult everyone else not following them. Does this make you feel good about yourself? Can't you find anything else? Anyway, would you kindly fuck off, all with your friends. > That word is generally universally recognized as bigoted and discriminatory, so please don’t use it. Eheheh, you wish (and by wish, I mean lie). Even the fucking wikipedia doesn't agree with you: > The adjective retarded is used in the same way, for something very foolish or stupid. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retard_(pejorative) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retard_(pejorative) Period.
- 2y ago
- lovich 2y ago>I stayed because I believe in the work we do. I believe in the open web and owning your own content. I’ve devoted nearly three decades of work to this cause, and when I chose to move in-house, I knew there was only one house that would suit me. In nearly six years at Automattic, I’ve been able to do work that mattered to me and helped others, and I know that the best is yet to come. As the layoffs and hiriing hesitation has increased over the past 1-2 years I have seen an increased amount of copium coming from engineers work at prestigious jobs. If you work at a for profit company, I believe that you believe in their mission. That mission is to make money. If you work at a company where your job role pays out enough that you could retire of a few years of salary from the position, and you stay after the company pivots to something you didn't think was a good idea, you are there for money. If you work at a company where your job role pays out enough that you could retire of a few years of salary from the position, and you stay after the company lays off a large number of your coworkers that you think could have been a net benefit to the company, you are there for money. If you work at a company where your job role pays out enough that you could retire of a few years of salary from the position, and you stay after the company lays off many coworkers that you had a positive, personal relationship with, you are there for money. I see people in this thread lauding this person for making what I believe is an ultimately selfish decision, and trying to pretend he is not. I am tired of seeing all these software luminaries discussing how brave they are for {getting a fuck ton of money but pretending it is difficult to accept because they dont get to control everything}. The feeling I am getting from this blog post and the reaction to it, is the same reaction I got to hearing about how Linus Torvalds was all for the concept of Free Software and then checking his wikipedia page to find out that the chain of links to his famous ancestors goes back to at least his grandparents. Like no shit you "stayed", you got bank for it. Don't try and spin it as a moral good under > I stayed because I believe in the work we do.
- lovich 2y agoJFC His last two paragraphs are so egregious I segfaulted when reading them. Did he really quote Rodney King on why we cant all get along as a response to layoffs that he survived, and then tells everyone that his group is hiring? Fuck this guy. I don't care if it hurts my career. I wouldn't work with someone who is this big an asshole cause I wouldn't trust them to not throw me under the bus the second its expedient for them.
- echoangle 2y agoMaybe I’m out of touch but I don’t get people complaining about the „takers“ in the maker-taker-problem. If you are offended when people take your stuff without contributing, don’t make it open source. Maybe it’s just me being too cynical but people taking my open source stuff and contributing nothing is basically the expectation, everything else is a welcome positive surprise. But I would never get angry and badmouth other people because they dared taking my stuff I consciously open sourced earlier. Also, imagine other open source projects doing this. Should Linux maintainers complain about every company using Linux Servers without contributing to the kernel? Or would offering Linux hosting be the better analogy? What percentage of Linux hosting providers has written a single kernel patch and contributed it?
- gspetr 2y agoI think it just never hit close to home for you to matter. A developer I know had it happen to him. A startup raised $25M squarely off his open source work and they've donated to him a grand total of $250, i.e. 0.001% of the value. He was pissed.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]