11 ms·
The Netherlands has returned some stolen artifacts to Indonesia
- snapcaster 2y agoNice! I think about this every time i'm in an English museum
- matrix2003 2y agoI know some of the museums aren’t the right place to keep some of the artifacts, but I also feel that in general they have been good stewards. My counterpoint is wondering how many would have been destroyed by ISIS or civil unrest in some of the less stable regions of the world.
- mikrl 2y ago>My counterpoint is wondering how many would have been destroyed by ISIS or civil unrest in some of the less stable regions of the world. This line of thought is fascinating to me. We should preserve them for all of humanity? Who chooses the custodian? We want a more nationalist case for repatriation to country of origin? If they get destroyed, it’s not the self-professed custodian nation’s problem or loss. Cynical, perhaps, but you need to balance self-determination with preservation. Maybe having their artifacts back will provide a drive to stability for the sake of heritage.
- matrix2003 2y agoI’m actually not sold on my argument, but was rather playing devil’s advocate. I can’t help but feel that all future generations should have the opportunity to learn from artifacts as well, but I’m saying that from a Western perspective. I have no idea how one should fairly choose a custodian or determine what “stability” really means. Maybe as humans touch all corners of the globe, we just accept that historical artifacts are ephemeral things and enjoy them while they last.
- TeaBrain 2y ago>Maybe having their artifacts back The idea that modern Egyptians have any claim over the artifacts when they don't share a culture or civilization with those who created the artifacts is tenuous. The artifacts don't belong to the land itself. They belonged to people of a no longer existing civilization that once inhabited the land.
- mikrl 2y agoConsider this though. In the case of Britain, they got the artifacts because they established a protectorate over Egypt and thus were able to excavate and do civil engineering. However, the fact that the artifacts were there to be discovered in the first place was because the Arab and later Ottoman overlords left them there. So who should rightfully claim them? One of the historical suzerains of Egypt? Or the current nation of Egypt who inhabit the ancient Egyptian territory? I can’t think of the ‘right’ (ie just) answer to that question… only practical ones.
- interactivecode 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- noworriesnate 2y agoSounds good, we're using it just for show anyway. How would you like it delivered?
- AlotOfReading 2y agoThere's 2 separate Hague conventions establishing an international framework for how to protect heritage in conflict regions. They're not perfect (like pretty much any convention), but they address all the basic issues like sheltering artifacts abroad and dedicating military units to prevent destruction. Also, western institutions have not been ideal stewards themselves, historically. The Pergamon kept the Ishtar gate through bombings in WW2 and the GDR. The British Museum has lost untold numbers of artifacts because they don't even have the resources to do a complete catalog of their collection, let alone properly conserve them.
- arethuza 2y agoSpeaking of the Pergamon Museum I think the actual Pergamon Altar might be better off back in the actual site of Pergamon - now in Turkey. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pergamon_Altar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pergamon_Altar
- matrix2003 2y agoAll good points! I did not realize military units were dedicated to this. I’m personally saddened by all the artifacts destroyed recently in the Middle East over ideological differences.
- gadders 2y ago>>There's 2 separate Hague conventions establishing an international framework for how to protect heritage in conflict regions. It's not working well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhas_of_Bamiyan#Destruction_by_the_Islamic_Emirate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhas_of_Bamiyan#Destruction...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- notpushkin 2y ago> While some critics of repatriation have raised concerns over how poorer countries will care for their returned artifacts, Marieke van Bommel, director general of the National Museum of World Cultures, tells the New York Times’ Lynsey Chutel that “the thief cannot tell the rightful owners what to do with their property.” But the government of the country the artifacts are being returned into isn’t the rightful owner. (I do think returning is the right thing to do, but it should be a bit more thought through.)
- pfortuny 2y agoThis is spot on. Why should a “mosern country” be the owner of an artifact? I wonder honestly, I am not just whining.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoYou steal a mummy from egipt, take it to london, put it in a museum. Who has more claim on the item... someone who stole it and kept it for 100, 150, 200 years? Or people of egypt represented by their government,living in an area where the mummy was stolen from?
- umvi 2y agoYeah but it gets absurd if enough time passes. "Your ancestors wronged my ancestors 1000 years ago, so now modern you owes modern me"
- soco 2y agoYes, and repay it by giving back said object. Egypt or those countries didn't ask for rent or back payments so let's stop imagining strawmen.
- TeaBrain 2y agoRepay what? The people of modern Egypt have no connection or inheritance claim to the ancient artifacts, other than their having been created in a similar place where the modern Egyptians are currently living. They don't even share a remotely similar culture. The same is true of many other places that had their artifacts collected, in that the people have no legal claim to the artifacts other than their having existed in a place in time nor do they often have any shared culture with the people who created the artifacts.
- angry_moose 2y agoStuff the British Stole is a really good podcast (Australian Broadcasting Corporation) that explores the difficulties of these situations: https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/stuff-the-british-stole https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/stuff-the-british-sto... Things like: - The current government in power may not allow the artifacts to be returned to the original people, but will accept them and place them in the national museum. In many of these cases; the original people actually oppose the "return" for now, and are waiting for the political situation to change. - The current government actively blocks the return of artifacts as it would be victory for their opponents - In some cases, the artifact would have been wholly unremarkable except for the fact it was taken by the British; that is it has a lot more significance as a "Thing the British Stole" and would have been lost to time otherwise - Many artifacts require very intricate preservation activities that the receiving country isn't equipped for - If the artifact involves human remains, there are all kinds of laws preventing the movement/transfer/relocation of human remains in both countries In general I think returning them is a good thing, but more often than not there's an enormous legal/moral/ethical quagmire surrounding them Edit: No judgement intended either way on this particular instance. I just wanted to provide a good resource if others are interested in learning more about the general situation.
- arethuza 2y agoThe UK government occasionally does give things back on the understanding that they can be returned for a bit when required... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_of_Scone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_of_Scone
- tivert 2y agoI don't really see how that example is "giv[ing] things back." That stone is still the property of the British government and kept continuously on British territory.
- bell-cot 2y agoIt's Complicated(tm) - Scotland and England are, currently, both part of Britain. Historically, not so much. And they were often far-from-friendly, with wars fought and everything. In a referendum 10 years ago, ~45% of Scottish voters wanted to separate again.
- virtualritz 2y agoThere is a great comedy sketch from James Acaster that sums up the situation in- and the stance most other Western countries take on this, unfortunately: https://youtu.be/x73PkUvArJY?si=hFbY9_ySJGlnh4Ys https://youtu.be/x73PkUvArJY?si=hFbY9_ySJGlnh4Ys
- sflefties 2y ago[flagged]
- MitPitt 2y agoUnfortunately artifacts returned to their origin country are often sold off to private collection or are otherwise lost. First world countries are better at preservation of such things and should keep it.
- jadtz 2y agoHow often and can you give some examples in recent history?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- smabie 2y agoHaving had a few interactions with the Indonesian government, the Netherlands should have just kept them.
- gaoshan 2y agoThe labeling of things in museums as "stolen" is lacking, IMO. In some cases, yes... straight up looted items are in museums. In other cases, though, the items could easily have ended up lost to time (or political, economic, social turmoil) if they had not been taken and put in museums outside of the places where they originated. Additionally some of these places would not have had the means to care for antiquities back in the day. The discussion is important and the history of how these museums came to have the items they do is fraught with depredation but that is't the whole story. I feel like there is nuance around how many of these items that have ended up in the museums of the West and that nuance is paved over by labeling everything as stolen.
- jltsiren 2y agoAnd in some cases, the items were lost because they were put in museums. Europe was not exactly a stable place in the 20th century. Many things were destroyed in the wars, and many items were stolen from museums by conquerors, individual soldiers, and looters.
- jahewson 2y agoSuch as? I don’t see a single missing artifact on this list that was taken by Europeans and lost in WWI or WWII: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missing_treasures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missing_treasures Plenty lost in other parts of the world though!
- jltsiren 2y agoThat is a very short list of particularly notable lost items. European museums had hundreds of millions of items in their collections, and many of them were lost. The number of documented pieces of art and artifacts lost in WW2 is in millions. The actual number is likely much higher, as the documents were often also lost. Nazis looted as a matter of policy. Soviets practiced wholesale destruction. Even Americans did widespread looting, often taking items that had first been stolen by Nazis. For a more concrete example: The Colonial Collections Committee report behind the article discusses a total of 390 items. 10 of them were known to be lost before the 1990s. Further 17 were not found in an inventory at that time. One additional item was determined to be a loss that had been reported earlier. Two further items had been reportedly transferred somewhere else, but their current status is unknown.
- aunty_helen 2y agoI've stood in the Cairo museum and looked at a wooden sarcophagus that's had all of it's gold chiseled off of it. Something that was once a work of art reduced to a wooden box for the price of a few ounces of gold. I have mixed feelings about repatriation and the elephant in the room, the British.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoSeems to be a major bias in this perspective against the British. The contemporary Egyptians at the time of collection had even less interest in preservation. Do you even know that the gold was removed by the British, and not some enterprising locals? The British were not cultural outliers in their graverobbing. They were outliers in that they saw historical value in items and chose to preserve them, instead of deconstructing them.
- waffleiron 2y agoThere literally was an curator of the British Museum that stole 1800 artifacts and sold them for personal profit. Don't pretend this doesn't happen to the British. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/03/26/british-museum-sues-curator-accused-selling-items-ebay/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/03/26/british-museum-s...
- BoingBoomTschak 2y agoDon't like the word "stolen" in this context, it sounds very newspeak-y compared to "plundered" or "looted". Ever heard of Vae victis?
- s1artibartfast 2y agoEven plundered and looted is often a misnomer. In many cases, they could be replaced with collected, saved, and preserved. Our current sense of historical preservation was not as pervasive in the past. In many places these materials would have been consumed or destroyed by locals who had more pragmatic concerns and no interest in the past.
- mihaic 2y agoWhile these discussions are always loaded with sentimental intepretation, and complex questions of what "rightful owner" after hundreds or thousands of years even means, I think more of an emphasis should be put on impact for the population. After all, the British Museum, the main example for restitutions, is located in a global city, given completely free access to its huge collection on display and pays for preservation. The global cultural value it adds is much larger than individual museums all over the would could provide. > Marieke van Bommel, director general of the National Museum of World Cultures, tells the New York Times’ Lynsey Chutel that “the thief cannot tell the rightful owners what to do with their property.” And in the meantime the academic establishment seem to ignore doing what's best for the artefacts or the public. Abused children are taken away from their parents, but artefact are to simply be given back to whatever state has jurisdiction over some area they were in way back? There seems to not be a simple answer on when things should be given back or not, but at least some effort should be put into figuring out some triage criteria.
- chx 2y agohttps://mastodon.gamedev.place/@rygorous/113219189748801451 https://mastodon.gamedev.place/@rygorous/113219189748801451 > art project idea: "The British Museum", which is housed somewhere outside the UK and will accept and display any donations from anonymous donors into its collection that were provably stolen from Great Britain
- bilbo0s 2y agoWell, in fairness, Britain would have the right to demand the artifacts be returned. Please don't shoot the messenger here. I'm just saying hypocrisy doesn't negate legal rights. I'm American, so no dog in the fight, but the UK would have the right to take those artifacts back.
- dijit 2y agoI agree with the sentiment, however in some ways it should be something that is permitted to move. The UK has been very stable for a long time, however they are profiting indirectly from the museums, since it s a driver of tourism. Should the UK become less stable, we should have a hard look at ensuring the continuity of the collection. As others have mentioned, a lot of these things would have been destroyed or forgotten had the British not decided it was important to keep it - and as time goes on, those things become even more irreplaceable.
- satvikpendem 2y agoPerhaps not necessarily in this case, but something I do think about is, are not certain artifacts safer in the museums that can take care of them for future generations? There are many unstable countries in the world where that cannot happen, and I would want artifacts not destroyed due to wars or other sorts of fighting such as terrorism [0] such that future generations can see them. That is why I am not necessarily opposed to so called colonial governments continuing to hold on to relics, as the British Museum has stated. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/feb/26/isis-fighters-destroy-ancient-artefacts-mosul-museum-iraq https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/feb/26/isis-fighters-...
- booleandilemma 2y agoAs always, if these things weren't taken and put in a museum in the first place, today they wouldn't even exist.
- krapp 2y agoAs always, the world doesn't owe you or anyone the artifacts of its cultures. They can be shared, but no one has the right to take them by force.
- booleandilemma 2y ago[flagged]
- krapp 2y agoCry about what? I simply stated a fact.
- Log_out_ 2y ago[flagged]
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoHow many countries does England have stuff to return to?
- luaybs 2y agoThe amount of pro-colonial sentiment in the thread here is baffling. The people that were colonized and stolen from have the right to do whatever they want with these artifacts, even if you believe they may not have the means, or will sell them to private collectors.
- jbjbjbjb 2y agoWhy not just accept the situation as part of the ebb and flow of history? They certainly weren’t the first empires in history. I think a lot of the objection is more about nationalistic sentiment than anything else and I don’t feel it needs to be done to reclaim cultural heritage.
- luaybs 2y agoI will never accept colonialism in whatever way, shape, or form.
- corimaith 2y agoUnification and Colonialism are two sides of the same coin. You think the former provinces, cities and then villages all willingly integrated in to country you live today?
- legacynl 2y ago> Why not just accept the situation as part of the ebb and flow of history? Why would you? By calling it the 'ebb and flow of history' you seem to imply that the things we do to each other is beyond the control of humans. But of course we're fully in control of what we do, so the question is rather: if we have the possibility to do good, and it comes at virtually no cost to us, then why not do good?
- jbjbjbjb 2y agoIn my opinion it’s still more driven by nationalistic agendas than the ethical imperative and as others have said there are good reasons to leave the artifacts where they are. I’ve only ever seen people make heated demands based on past grievances. A lot of this stuff happened a long time ago now, anyone influential has died, it really is time to at least take the heat of these conversations.
- anonymous18473 2y agoHere is a take I haven't seen anywhere else: according to Wikipedia, when the Europeans took the Rosetta Stone it was nothing more than rock in some wall. The European then turned it into something truely special. A hot take on this could be to just return a rock of equal size. It is not clear how all the information gathered should be factored into this.
- lotux 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Looty_(dog) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Looty_(dog)
- Managor 2y agoPreservation is what gives artifacts value.