14 ms·
Hacking Kia: Remotely controlling cars with just a license plate
- ivewonyoung 2y agoDoes Kia have a bug bounty like Tesla does? Tesla paid out 200k and a Tesla a few months ago.
- daghamm 2y agoAlmost all vehicle manufacturers have bug bounty programs of some kind (open or closed) but I seriously doubt Kia is one of them. BTW, the Tesla bug from April is really scary. $100K is peanuts for the ability to remotely control the engine from an adjacent vehicle.
- voxadam 2y agoFrom https://www.hyundaiusa.com/us/en/vulnerability-disclosure https://www.hyundaiusa.com/us/en/vulnerability-disclosure: In submitting reports, please note that although Hyundai Motor America sincerely values vulnerability reports, we do not provide monetary compensation (“bounties”) or non-monetary remuneration in exchange for submitted reports. This program is only meant to facilitate the responsible reporting and resolution of cybersecurity vulnerabilities. Note: Kia is owned by Hyundai.
- omoikane 2y agoKia America Vulnerability Disclosure Policy: https://www.kia.com/us/en/vulnerability.html https://www.kia.com/us/en/vulnerability.html Please also note that we do not award bounties for reporting vulnerabilities.
- myself248 2y ago"thanks to a simple website bug AND TELEMATICS HARDWARE in the vehicles that had absolutely no relevance to their ability to get from point A to point B"
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- josefritzishere 2y agoCan we stop connecting cars to the internet now?
- bell-cot 2y agoWhy would any of the decision makers want to do that? It's not like 99.9% of consumers appear willing to pay 10 cents more for an unconnected car.
- squidgedcricket 2y agoThe only way a connected car would be cheaper is if money is made from the data sent over the connection. Clearly that's the case right now. Up-front NRE, per unit HW, perpetual cloud backend maintenance. There's a lot of cost to connect a car to the internet. It should be a luxury option that I can decline to have installed.
- sroussey 2y agoRecalls that can be fixed with over the air updates is a large financial reason to connect cars to the internet. Personally, I’d rather connect to my WiFi where I have control, but that’s a lot to ask for regular consumers.
- barbazoo 2y agoMy Kia Niro is connected to the internet yet I can't OTA apply anything. Updates to the navigation data (~80GB) have to be done via USB and recall related updates have to get applied by the manufacturer. So I get 100% of the attack surface and ~0% of the convenience.
- sroussey 2y agoOh god, that’s terrible! I wonder how many years that will take. Five years?
- deleted 2y ago
- sxcurity 2y agoStop connecting vehicles to the internet pls & thanks
- yupyupyups 2y agoOk, I wont.
- carabiner 2y agoThanks.
- AdamJacobMuller 2y agoIf it's done well, there are some useful features there. App unlock, remote start + remote temperature control. All very useful. I couldn't imagine buying a car without carplay now.
- rwmj 2y agoSorry no. App unlock is a stupid anti-feature, do people genuinely think it's better than pressing a keyfob? Remote start is very useful in very cold climates, but guess what, it doesn't need a phone, an app or the internet. My friend in a snowy part of Japan had a radio keyfob that did this literally 10 or more years ago. As long as you were within about 100 ft of the car you could switch it on and turn on the heaters.
- AyyEye 2y agoI installed an aftermarket remote start kit in the 90s. It cost less than $100.
- kube-system 2y agoMany of the earlier aftermarket remote start kits were cheap and simple because the vehicles had fewer security features. They are more complex and expensive today, and some are questionable in their implementation.
- johnsutor 2y agoWith the advent of "Kia Boys" and now this, it's a miracle people still buy Kias.
- thrtythreeforty 2y agoThey have the best EV architecture on the planet currently; despite all the hacking issues, I'm still considering an EV6 for my next vehicle. Probably with a yanked cell radio fuse...
- solarpunk 2y agocan you explain what you mean by ev architecture?
- i80and 2y agoHyundai and Kia use an 800V high voltage electrical system. The upshot is their vehicles charge scary fast, peaking in the mid 200kW's
- thrtythreeforty 2y agoExactly. It makes a DC fast charge session (on a reasonably spec'd charger) take 20 minutes, not an hour like on competing EVs that peak at 150kW. EV companies haven't quite figured out that the only two things consumers care about are range and charge rate (well, and cost, but there's an untapped market of people willing to pay if the featureset is there). Everyone has settled on 300mi range, which in my opinion is a little low but workable (at 80mph you'd have to stop every 3.5 hours), but for some reason nobody can get their act together on charge rate. Consumers need to purchase a car for their 99th percentile use case, which for much of America includes at least one road trip per year. The DC fast charge experience is basically the whole story there.
- MostlyStable 2y agoObviously better charge rate would be better, and would be a bigger improvement than more range, but I've found that long road trips (10+ hours total driving time) with my 2023 Hyundai Kona, peak charge rate of ~70kW, is tolerable. I'd like my next EV (whenever I get it), to have a higher charge rate, but if I'm being honest, I'd care more other features such as V2H capability and physical media/HVAC controls. Now, fundamentally there is no reason that I should have to choose between these options. They are orthoganal, but if I was choosing between different vehicles, I'd give up charge speed to get those other features.
- mass_and_energy 2y agoI wonder how many LEAs knew of this and used it to bypass having to get a warrant, instead of responsibly disclosing it for the benefit of public safety.
- bena 2y agoThe warrant is still necessary, evidence obtained through illicit means is generally not acceptable.
- bobbylarrybobby 2y agoTechnically you don't need a warrant if you just ask for the data and it's handed over. You only need a warrant if someone doesn't want to hand over the data.
- bena 2y agoBut that's not what this would be, this would be gaining access to the system without permission. It doesn't matter if my door has shitty locks, you still can't enter my house unless I invite you.
- fragmede 2y agoif this metaphorical door is already open and something is in plain view though. I guess the question is what constitutes plain view digitally.
- alistairSH 2y agoTrue, but parallel construction/evidence laundering is a thing.
- like_any_other 2y agoThe article isn't clear, but it sounds like the cars were already being tracked, only now also "unauthorized" people could track them (when before, only Kia and car dealers could track your car). Why is it okay for Kia/manufacturers to spy on our cars, and only a problem when others do it? This attitude is pervasive in reporting on hacks like these - the initial spying by corporations is always given a pass (or rather, it is implied that's not even "tracking", as the title implies the tracking happened only after the hack).
- datax2 2y agoAlmost all modern cars have a way of providing or grabbing location data, however most manufactures do not "Spy" on your car by default, this would violate CCPA, colorados privacy act, GDPR... ETC. The users need to opt-in to telematics data. For example in Hyundai case when you create a "Blue link" account and accept their terms of service you are connecting whatever vehicle you have verified on your account to their telematics system, and subsequently opting in to tracking. Manufactures like VW/Audi place an opt out within the vehicle itself so if you opt out of telematics in the vehicle you are in a full privacy mode and the manufacture cannot get the data or override this request. This covers the scenario if other "Users" of the vehicle are driving and would choose to opt out outside of the main users/owner. So some bake it into your app registration and signup, and some leave it in the vehicle. The gist is you can opt out, and if the manufacturer does not respect that you have grounds to sue, Currently there is a lawsuit against GM/Caddy because a user did not opt-in to Usage Based Insurance, but their information was captured and brokered blocking them from acquiring new insurance.
- like_any_other 2y agoThe EFF [1] is less optimistic that all of this spying is opt-in and clearly-stated (instead of buried in legalese), and Wired [2] likewise mentions cases where it's opt-out instead of -in. [1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/03/how-figure-out-what-your-car-knows-about-you-and-opt-out-sharing-when-you-can https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/03/how-figure-out-what-yo... [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20240705093406/https://www.wired.com/story/car-data-privacy-toyota-honda-ford/ https://web.archive.org/web/20240705093406/https://www.wired...
- yieldcrv 2y agoKia Boys Who Code
- bityard 2y agoWell, I am already pretty firmly against buying any car that requires you to create an account online to "activate" the vehicle. But I definitely won't buy another Kia anyway, based on the fact that our last one burned a quart of oil every thousand miles WELL before it hit the 100k mark.
- barbazoo 2y ago> car that requires you to create an account online to "activate" the vehicle I have a 2023 Kia and that's not necessary. You only need the account if you want to use the optional online services.
- sahmeepee 2y agoAs the article says, you don't need an active subscription to be vulnerable. In this case it seems that if the model supports the features at all, you are vulnerable. This makes sense, because they want people to be able to subscribe to their services later without having to visit the dealership, so they make it possible to remotely enable the service. I'm not sure if you can buy a tinfoil hat for a car.
- nis0s 2y agoI was just going to say the same as it's stated pretty early in the article > These attacks could be executed remotely on any hardware-equipped vehicle in about 30 seconds, regardless of whether it had an active Kia Connect subscription. If this should tell companies anything is that most of these services should be opt-in instead of opt-out in favor of security and privacy.
- mikepurvis 2y agoIt should be possible to physically disable the cellular modem in the vehicle, wherever that is. I have a 2020 Volvo that is definitely online, waiting for me to activate some pricey online subscription that I don't want or need. Would be nice to have a organized online database of how to disconnect various "smart" devices— cars, TVs, appliances, etc.
- alexandersvozil 2y agoi cannot connect to kia anymore, would have bot worked in me
- meindnoch 2y agoWhat if we had laws that required car manufacturers to have software with slightly better quality than the utter syphilitic diarrhea they currently ship?
- dopylitty 2y ago[flagged]
- psunavy03 2y agoToday I learned that counterintelligence and sabotage concerns about a major geopolitical rival are "xenophobic trade war reasons."
- bluSCALE4 2y agoWhy would the average consumer car about intelligence of a foreign state? I, for one, have no fear of China presently but the climate in the USA isn't very pro free speech.
- lostmsu 2y agoYou missed the obvious elephant in the room with the word sabotage.
- kube-system 2y agoThey don't (at least, not in peace time), but the US government does. They also buy cars. Also the concerns of the average consumer aren't a really good barometer for what should be legal. Most consumers gladly sign up for services that violate their privacy, because they don't understand the consequences at the time of purchase. Also people are pretty bad at estimating risks of unknown certainty even when they do know about them. If 'buyer-beware' worked, there would be no need for consumer protection law... but this segment of the law has originated from necessity.
- wahern 2y agoI think you misunderstood the insinuation.[1] I believe they're suggesting that otherwise legitimate vulnerability concerns are discounted in favor of a laissez faire market policy unless and until the concerns are framed by a xenophobic narrative. IOW, xenophobia trumps capitalism, but not measured security concerns. [1] But that's why sarcasm is usually frowned upon on HN.
- tptacek 2y agoThis won't have nearly the same impact, but when you're considering how vulnerabilities like this might influence your future purchasing decisions, remember that Kia's decision to omit interlocks from their US vehicles (but not Canadian ones!) led to a nationwide epidemic of Kia thefts so large it fed a crime wave, something a number of US cities are suing Kia over. If you've read about carjacking waves in places like Milwaukee and Chicago: that was largely driven by a decision Kia made, which resulted in the nationwide deployment of a giant fleet of "burner" cars that could be stolen with nothing but a bent USB cable.
- wasteduniverse 2y agoDon't anthropomorphize the lawnmower and blame Kia for this, blame the NHTSA for making it legal to skimp out on immobilizers in the first place. Regulations matter!
- tptacek 2y agoSince Kia/Hyundai is the only automotive group to have this problem, I'm going to go ahead continuing to blame them.
- piva00 2y agoI agree and still it's also the lack of regulation that enabled it to happen, and 2nd order effects of it is the increase in carjackings. It's a pretty good argument for the regulation, since everyone else is already doing it just make it the standard.
- searealist 2y agoOf course you are. The alternative is to blame the governments (of places like Chicago or Milwaukee), or the people doing the theft.
- BoorishBears 2y agoWhy are those alternatives for you? I find it very easy to hold the governments, people, and companies as all culpable in the own way.
- diego_moita 2y agoOk, lesson learned. Thank you. I have a Kia Niro EV Wind 2024 and just cancelled my account at Kia Connect. Yes, I felt stupid. But a little less stupid now. Edit: does anyone know how I could disable Kia's remote access to my car? Is there any antenna I could cover with tin foil or a chip that can be disconnected?
- aftbit 2y ago>These attacks could be executed remotely on any hardware-equipped vehicle in about 30 seconds, regardless of whether it had an active Kia Connect subscription.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bluSCALE4 2y agoDon't feel stupid, feel a little angry. The only thing you could have done to prevent this was not buy a Kia.
- sjamaan 2y agoLike the other brands are any better...
- EricE 2y agoIt's hardly unique to Kia! https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/03/how-figure-out-what-your-car-knows-about-you-and-opt-out-sharing-when-you-can https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/03/how-figure-out-what-yo...
- aftbit 2y agoWait a moment, the key vulnerability appears to be that anyone could register as a dealer, but also any dealer could lookup information on any Kia even if they didn't sell it or if it was already activated!? That seems insane. What if a dealership employee uses this to stalk an ex or something?
- lambada 2y agoA Kia authorised dealer being able to look up any Kia has some very useful benefits (for the dealer, and thus Kia). If a customer has moved into the area and you’re now their local dealer they’re more likely to come to you for any problems, including ones involving remote connectivity problems. Being able to see the state of the car on Kia’s systems is important for that. Is this a tradeoff? Absolutely. Can you make the argument the trade off isn’t worth it? Absolutely. But I don’t think it’s an unfathomably unreasonable decision to have their dealers able to help customers, even if that customer didn’t purchase the car from that dealer.
- conductr 2y agoThose aren’t the only options. It would be trivial change to allow any dealer to request access to any vehicle and have it tied to the active employees SSO or something similar that at least leave an audit trail and prevents such random access. Allowing anyone to be a dealer is the real oversight. They could put some checks in place also to prevent the stalker situation GP mentioned. It’s always going to be possible but reduces risk a lot if employee just has to ask someone else to approve their access request, even if it’s just a rubber stamp process making sure the vehicle is actually in need of some service
- aftbit 2y agoIn my opinion, the better way to design such a thing would be for there to be a private key held in a secure environment inside the car which is used to sign credentials which offer entitlements to some set of features. So for example, when provisioning the car initially, the dealer would plug into the OBDii port, authenticate to the car itself, and then request that the car sign a JWT (or similar) which contains the new owner's email address or Kia account ID as well as the list of commands that a user is able to trigger. In your scenario, they would plug into the OBDii port, authenticate to the car, and sign a JWT with a short expiration time that allows them to query whatever they need to know about the car from the Kia servers. The biggest thing you would lose in this case is the ability for _any_ dealer to geolocate any car that they don't have physical access to, which could have beneficial use cases like tracking a stolen car. On the other hand, you trade that for actual security against any dealership tracking any car without physical access for a huge range of nefarious reasons. Of course, those use cases like repossessing the car or tracking a stolen vehicle would still be possible. In the former, the bank or dealership could store a token that allows tracking location, with an expiration date a few months after the end of the lease or loan period. In the latter, the customer could track the car directly from their account, assuming they had already signed up at the time the car was stolen. You could still keep a very limited unauthenticated endpoint available to every dealer that would only answer the question "what is the connection status for this vehicle?" That is a bit of an information leak, but nowhere near as bad as being able to real-time geolocate any vehicle or find any owner's email address just given a VIN.
- mlsu 2y agoThere are no new cars on the market today that don't have a slew of connected """features""", right? Will it ever be possible to have a non-connected car? If so, how? What would it actually take? This is not a ranty rhetorical question -- I'm actually wondering.
- MarkusWandel 2y agoDon't know about 2024, but my 2023 Honda Civic EX-B (Canadian market) is actually pretty old school. Yes, it has the keyless unlock and even a remote engine start button on the keyfob (can be disabled, thankfully - car is parked inside and we have kids!) But no cellular connectivity, no wifi, and all the touchscreen stuff is "extra icing" - all the controls you need are there in physical form except for some radio and cell phone call functions. Yes, the car may be vulnerable to signal boost kind of attacks (to pretend the keyfob is nearby when it's not) and possibly the "pop off a headlight and get into the CANbus" attack. But no cloud dependency and no way for the cloud to reach in and mess things up. Also, the software it does have seems "debugged" based on a year of using it.
- gen3 2y agoYour Honda almost certainly has HondaLink, which connects via cellular https://www.honda.ca/en/hondalink/hondalink-2?year=2023&model=Civic%20Sedan https://www.honda.ca/en/hondalink/hondalink-2?year=2023&mode... and they're probably selling your location data to databrokers https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/03/how-figure-out-what-your-car-knows-about-you-and-opt-out-sharing-when-you-can https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/03/how-figure-out-what-yo...
- MarkusWandel 2y agoGlad to say it doesn't. Only the top-of-the-line "Touring" model is shown as compatible with HondaLink.
- BossingAround 2y agoIn the EU, IIRC, 2024 is the year that EU starts mandating a bunch of stuff in vehicles (most notably, speed limiter IIUIC).
- r00fus 2y agoAs a Kia owner, this was what I was hoping for immediate term, FTA: "These vulnerabilities have since been fixed, this tool was never released, and the Kia team has validated this was never exploited maliciously." Kia still has a lot of work to do because of bad decisions, but at least my vehicle isn't ripe for theft/abuse.
- randomstring 2y agoThe obvious next step is to crawl the whole database of vulnerable Kia cars and create a "ride share" app that shows you the nearest Kia and unlocks it for you.
- trinsic2 2y ago[flagged]
- jshdhehe 2y agoIf you get 10x MoM growth you can lobby for it to be legal next year
- nullc 2y agoSomething kinda like that was done, TikTok apparently algorithmically identified likely 'drivers' and flooded them with videos instructing and glorifying taking the cars for a joyride... while other platforms did not promote and even took those videos down.
- not_a_dane 2y agoHow much time would you need to redevelop KIAtool with AI?
- jmyeet 2y agoWhere's the strict product liability here? Like, if Kia is making a car that's easy to steal and it gets stolen, why isn't that Kia's fault and they're responsible for the damages? We're talking gross negligence here. There have been demonstrations of hacking cars remotely to gain control of it. You could quite literally kill someone this way. This should 100% be the responsibility of the car maker. Why do we let these companies get away with poor security? It's well beyond time we hold them financially and legally responsible for foreseeable outcomes from poor security practices. That doesn't mean any vulnerability incurs liability necessarily. A 0day might not meet the bar for gross negligence. But what if you were told about the vulnerability and refused to upate the software for 2 years because a recall like that costs money? Or what if you released software using versions with known vulnerabilities because you don't want to pay for upgrading all the dependencies?
- bdcravens 2y agoEV6 owner here. Scary stuff, but honestly, I'm not shocked. I feel like the EV6 is one of the better available EVs, but is hindered by Kia, based on the experience I've had dealing with the app and the dealerships.
- georgeburdell 2y agoI’ve been telling my friends who want to avoid Tesla that an electric Kia is still a Kia
- cryptonector 2y ago> The License Plate to VIN form uses a third-party API to convert license plate number to VIN I guess that exists to make life easier for police. And because all patrol car laptops nation-wide need this, it really can't be authenticated meaningfully?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- BenjiWiebe 2y agoI don't think the police are using this software. I'm pretty sure they have their own official access to governmental (DMV) records.
- emsign 2y agoLooks to me like all cars sold by KIA are still owned by KIA. I'm not worried about that exploit at all, it has been fixed. I'm terrified about how much data about a car and therefore about the "owner" is available to KIA. That's totally insane.
- grahamj 2y agoI question some of this though. I have an older Kia that I’m pretty sure has no cell modem yet the support table shows it can be geolocated.
- cryptonector 2y agoNot just KIA. Most if not all major automobile manufacturers track a huge amount of data on the vehicles [and their owners/operators]. For example, many vehicles come with that OnStar thing, and so they have a baseband processor and even LTE as well as a GPS receiver, and it's always on even if you don't pay for the service, which means that the manufacturer gets to know your vehicle's location and all the places you go and the routes you take.
- hathawsh 2y agoOTOH, OnStar's remote disable feature is pretty compelling for consumers. It's not hard to find YouTube videos [1] of thieves being thwarted safely. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d9FbBgG2axE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d9FbBgG2axE
- simoncion 2y agoThe price of that feature (constant tracking of your vehicle's location) is not worth it in a world where entities who sell or give away that location data without the vehicle owner's explicit, intentional, actually-informed consent do not go to superjail forever.
- umbra07 2y agonot worth it to you
- exabrial 2y agoBy law, we need to be able to disconnect cars from the cell network. This is stupid.
- divbzero 2y agoBy law, we need to be able to disconnect any product whose core functionality does not depend on the network.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- grubbs 2y agoGlad my VW only had a 3G antenna built in. No longer works in the US.
- vlark 2y agoI just want a car that is as dumb as it can be while meeting all federal regulations to the highest degree. How hard can that be?
- croes 2y agoStrike two on KIA's car security after the USB cable disaster
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoA day ago Louis Rossman posted on Youtube: Mazda requires $100+ subscription for remote start after filing DMCA takedown of open source program" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1n0AI5aemUY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1n0AI5aemUY "I never hear the ancaps and the hardcore libertarians in my comments section... complain about Section 1201 of the DMCA. I wish I did more often."
- nkrisc 2y agoMaybe other manufacturers are also this bad, but I know Kia is this bad. I’m never buying a Kia. But wait, they patched this! Yeah, but they also shipped it.
- theflyingpigeon 2y agoKia is a terrible brand anyways
- schaefer 2y agoMy brother owns a Kia, and the constant auto break-ins are negatively impacting his mental health.
- grishka 2y agoIf I'll ever buy a car, it won't have any network interfaces.
- m_kos 2y agoI am impressed that you were able to contact relevant folks at Kia. I tried contacting their security team via Kia's customer service and Twitter and was repeatedly told they don't have anyone working on security, vulnerabilities, etc. My favorite was when they redirected my call to roadside assistance (twice).
- gloosx 2y agoConnecticut Kia Boyz here? Imagine in some states it's not a felony to steal Kias if you're under 18, so they do it for fun and even sell them for rides 100$ each. There is a great Channel 5 documentary on youtube about it, definitely recommend to check it!
- xyst 2y agoInternet connected vehicles are a mistake. Enough time out there and mistakes will get re-introduced. If it’s not Kia, it will be someone else. You should be able to take out the internet connectivity as a consumer. The fact that this exploit worked even if the consumer wasn’t subscribed is wild. Car companies just can’t do tech.
- mithr 2y agoIn Massachusetts, Kia has disabled Kia Connect for all vehicles purchased over the past few years. Any data collected by cars must be made accessible to third-party shops, and Kia opted to disable any data collection (and thus disable Connect entirely) rather than allow that to happen. It doesn't matter where you actually live — as long as you bought in MA, the car's VIN is locked out and no one can do anything about it. You're typically told this at the very end of the sales process, after everything is signed, and it's framed as "oh, by the way, MA has a terrible right-to-repair law that has forced Kia to disable Connect, you should write your state senator." It's... interesting to see just how easy it is to access this functionality if the VIN check is bypassed.
- stainablesteel 2y agoits brought about a lot of shops that can rip the electronic tracking devices out of your car pretty easily too, which is nice in case you don't feel like being someone's datapoint