8 ms·
Desktop Windowing on Android Tablets
- exe34 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jjice 2y agoI'm a full desktop OS kind of person, but even just enabling windowing on a tablet OS makes it feel like so much more of a full OS. The idea of having your browser and a notes app in a configuration that isn't a forced hard split is a massive win.
- justmarc 2y agoThere is quite simply an incredible amount of productivity that can be extracted from a speedy, full sized laptop or desktop that smaller screen devices are not likely to reach no matter what fancy features they come up with. What I can do in seconds on a fast, responsive, non-bogged down modern laptop can take orders of magnitude longer to accomplish on a tablet. Tablets surely have their uses, but high paced productivity is not one of them.
- jjice 2y agoI would assume that I'd agree, but I've never attempted to use something like a Surface with a keyboard. For me, a desktop OS and a full size laptop keyboard are just two non-negotiables if I'm working on pretty much anything.
- analog31 2y agoMy spouse and I recently got identical Lenovo tablets. I got mine for reading sheet music, but of course can't pass up the chance to see how close it gets to being a laptop replacement. It's the first device that was close enough to leave my laptop at home on a recent trip... and travel 2 pounds lighter. Don't know if it's unique to Lenovo or part of Android in general, but these tablets do support the windowing feature. It's Android 13.
- tredre3 2y ago> Don't know if it's unique to Lenovo or part of Android in general So-called Productivity Mode is a Lenovo thing and I agree it's actually decent. I know that Android has some windowing support built-in but it's basically unusable (hence why this announcement is good news).
- mattlondon 2y agoYou've always been able to do split screen (i.e. 50/50, 25/75 etc but not floating windows) even on phones, FWIW.
- wongarsu 2y agoLenovo tablets have split screen, floating windows over fullscreen applications, and the option to put all applications into windows kind of like in the post. Though admittedly split screen is the most useful of those
- KeplerBoy 2y agoAlways is a bit of a stretch. The split screen feature came with Android 7 in 2016.
- kmarc 2y agoWait until you try Samsung's Dex. It could replace my Linux laptop, with my tmux/vim dot files environment
- mschuster91 2y agoNow if DeX would actually be performant... unfortunately Samsung just loves putting dogshit SoCs and flash into anything that is not the Galaxy Phone lineup, not to mention their own pre-installed bloatware and general Android bloatification causing further performance issues.
- criddell 2y ago> Now if DeX would actually be performant Well, that all depends on what you were expecting. It works about as well as I figured it would (including the pre-installed bloatware), so in my eyes, it’s performant.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoI hope that this works on foldable phones, as well.
- nishant098 2y agoIts phone hack
- robgibbons 2y agoCan confirm that it does, at least on the pixel 9 pro fold, after enabling it in developer options. However, I don't see the top window handle they show in the animation. I have to long press the app icon in the running apps view, then I get a free form option. At that point, I get the floating windows with controls. You can tap and drag the sides and corners of apps to resize windows, seems intuitive enough.
- idle_zealot 2y agoWhat a disappointment. They had freeform mode as a dev option for years, but avoided pushing it as a supported feature. I assumed this was because it fucking sucked. I've tried it. Freeform, desktop-like windows on an 11 inch tablet are simply terrible for multitasking. But no, here they are, releasing the feature with no meaningful changes. The state of tablet multitasking is a travesty, but neither Google nor Apple seem interested in fixing it in any way other than a shitty reproduction of clunky desktop windowing. How about letting us tile more than two windows together? How about letting us stack apps into tabbed panes? How about a sliding environment like PaperWM? Just off the top of my head, any one of those is more likely to increase tablet productivity than "here's a bunch of rectangles; you wrangle them!"
- gedy 2y agoSure, but I'm one of the kooks who will plug a tablet into a monitor and use keyboard and mouse. Seems handy for that.
- idle_zealot 2y agoEven in that case it's pretty weak. It lacks workspaces/spaces that desktop OSes have these days, and isn't extensible the way Win/Mac/Linux desktops are.
- tannhaeuser 2y agoI guess I'm not really understanding what you're complaining about. Why not use a desktop OS then in the first place? MS Surface Go 11 tablets have been selling for like ten years now, and so have "convertibles"/2-in-1's.
- kccqzy 2y agoI tried out Apple's implementation of desktop windowing on tablets called Stage Manager with a borrowed iPad. It's still not a real replacement for actual laptops. Sure you get multiple windows, but switching between them it still inconvenient: you don't have Command-Tab or Command-` like on a Mac. All window manipulations have to be done with fingers touching the screen. I end up believing a real desktop windowing system is still superior.
- marcellus23 2y agoOther weaknesses of Stage Manager aside, iPad has command-tab and other keyboard shortcuts. You do actually need a keyboard attached though -- otherwise, well duh, of course all manipulation has to be done with fingers.
- neilalexander 2y agoStage Manager is disappointingly over-engineered. Managing the workspaces is much more mentally taxing than having windows just fade into the background, every new app somehow always seems to open up at the wrong size and then annoyingly takes everything else off-screen with it. I am a heavy iPad user but Stage Manager is rarely useful for me.
- LegitShady 2y agoI was very disappointed with it as well. doesn't work as well as a windows 95 computer window management.
- crooked-v 2y ago> you don't have Command-Tab Yes, you do. There's a pretty extensive set of keyboard shortcuts, actually.
- kccqzy 2y agoThe person who lent me the iPad didn't have a keyboard. I'll note that though.
- 2y ago
- rock_artist 2y agoAndroid Stage Manager… I do know similar window managers for Android existed in the past and Samsung still got their Dex but making it official emphasizing the responsiveness reminded me a lot of stage manager which Apple decided to make available only for the expensive iPads.
- dekhn 2y agoCongratulations Android, you've successfully recapitulated the evolution to desktop windowing. Took you only 15 years!
- qwertox 2y ago> If you don’t have a Pixel Tablet handy, access the Pixel Tablet emulator in Android Studio Preview, and select the Android 15.0 (Google APIs Tablet) target. Once your device is set up, select Enable freeform windows option in Developer options to explore the capabilities of desktop windowing and how your app behaves within this new environment. I noticed this last year on Android 13, and I found it a bit unusable on an 8.4'' tablet and useless on a phone. But i think it has less features in Android 13/14, as the management (maximize/restore) looks a bit different on 15. It still looks like it doesn't have a minimize icon (also not when maximized), which for me is essential in a desktop environment.
- yonisto 2y agoPixel Tablet is the biggest let down I have ever had from a product (SW + HW combination) mine has so many bugs, so many unnecessary changes from previous versions. I don't understand how a company can release such a bad product after so many iterations.
- entropie 2y ago> mine has so many bugs What bugs? I have mine for like 3 month and its probably the best expierence I had on any android device over the last dekade. Everything works so well and smooth. The only thing i critize is that the dock is not USB-C powered (so I could relocate it in the kitchen to watch stuff while cooking).
- yonisto 2y agoEven today, The 'Hey Google' stopped working. Restart didn't help. The microphone works (I did a video call) but 'Hey Google' stopped working. I used to have the Lenovo Smart Screen 10, which was great. But it didn't support Netflix or Disney+ so I thought that the Pixel Tablet would be an upgrade. There so many things that don't work any more. For example after starting a timer, the Lenovo know the command "re-start" while The pixel for the same command starts a new timer. I have many more examples, but it just make me sad to think of it.
- drcode 2y agoGoogle in 2057: "We're excited to announce that Android Tablets now have a terminal, with full support of terminal applications like 'ed' and 'grep'!"
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoI mean, termux is a thing. Although, having it officially supported instead of Google constantly trying to break it would be great.
- surajrmal 2y agoYour wording makes it sound like you think Google out of its way to break termux. What makes you believe that? Its execution model is at odds with the security model Android pushes for so of course it'll come with some challenges. It tries to provide an environment suitable for a legacy application model that doesn't really take security as seriously. The only real way to win here is by using a VM which is what ChromeOS did. That allows sufficient isolation such that it need not try to force something to work in an environment not built for it.
- AshamedCaptain 2y ago> It tries to provide an environment suitable for a legacy application model that doesn't really take security as seriously. Erm... what? > The only real way to win here is by using a VM which is what ChromeOS did. What advantage would the VM provide, other than the host OS having even less insight into what the application is doing? (Which is, by the way, exactly the only reason Android is introducing VMs: hiding stuff from the host Android)
- fragmede 2y agoThat's not the reason. The host android has full access to the child VMs; the VM can't hide anything from the hypervisor. It's about isolation. The child VM can't leak your photos or contact list if it doesn't have it in the first place, and sticking things into their own VM provides an additional layer of isolation beyond what exists currently.
- mouse_ 2y agoImpressive work, they reinvented the Chromebook
- tholdem 2y agoProbably over 90% of what I use my personal laptop for is browsing the web, watching videos, listening to music, and writing notes. In a general purpose OS, I value security above all else. Privacy is a close second, and of course stability, ease of use, resource lightness, and application support are also important factors. I haven't found a desktop operating system that ticks most of the boxes, especially security and privacy. The only OS that ticks all the boxes is GrapheneOS, but it's not really a desktop OS. That's why I'm so excited about these updates, and why I wish there was either a good keyboard/trackpad case for the Google Pixel Tablet running GrapheneOS, or someone would make a laptop that had the necessary requirements to support GrapheneOS. I code on my work laptop, and if I really wanted to, I could probably SSH or VNC into a Linux box to code on GrapheneOS. There is also pKVM, which will probably make it easy to run Linux VMs on GrapheneOS at some point in the future.
- GiorgioG 2y ago> I haven't found a desktop operating system that ticks most of the boxes, especially security and privacy...That's why I'm so excited about these updates Android and privacy are not two things that go together.
- nixosbestos 2y agoGo on! Substantiate that. From a platform level. Please, I'm very curious.
- nixosbestos 2y agoIf I had my way every person that downvotes this kind of comment without replying would just be banned. There's no replies becuase it's utter cargoculted ignorant bullshit.
- GiorgioG 2y agoThe vast majority of Android devices run Google Services. The End.
- jsheard 2y agoThey missed the opportunity to copy Samsung DeXes best party trick, getting a desktop interface on a phone by connecting an external monitor. Maybe next year.
- sprinkly-dust 2y agoThat feature is available, albeit clunky. The latest Pixel phones have a developer option "Force Desktop Mode" which gives you Desktop-esque Windowing on an external monitor.
- mirsadm 2y agoHandling configuration changes for every resize event is horrible. I really dislike Android's design around startup/pause/resume etc of the app.
- bityard 2y agoAh, so basically mobile devices have almost caught up to the Xerox Star?
- thanatos519 2y agoIt's funny... all of the windows on my desktop are fullscreen or halfscreen. The only floating windows are transient dialogs.
- hulitu 2y agoFor me also. But 3 days a year i need 2 programs side by side.
- smokel 2y agoI tend to have another level of nested windows inside applications, also mostly full- or half-screen. It's at that level that sometimes other shapes become interesting, for example for a time slider (long and horizontal), or a list of files (narrow and vertical). If only the world had evolved into one where operating systems could interact with applications in a way that would allow persistence of window layouts, scripting of user interface elements, and allowing a user to modify application layouts to their own preferences.
- thestephen 2y agoEmacs in its final form? Sadly, for those of us not versed in Elisp, such power remains a pipe dream.
- userbinator 2y agoHow big is/are your monitor(s?)? I only maximise windows frequently when I work on a single small monitor (and sometimes I'll use window transparency to be able to see multiple windows simultaneously.) With 2 or 3 large monitors, there's rarely any need to have windows maximised.
- malkia 2y agoAs a long time chromebook user, which runs Android apps - this is more than welcome!
- spankalee 2y agoAndroid is inching closer to resolving the ChromeOS / Android split in Android's favor. Probably a really good thing to not have two OSes when they really could be one. I just with Fuchsia were powering it.
- internet2000 2y agoAndroid already won, Google all but gave up on improving ChromeOS https://9to5google.com/2024/07/12/chromeos-lacros-ending/ https://9to5google.com/2024/07/12/chromeos-lacros-ending/
- oblio 2y agoDidn't they gut the Fucshia dev team?
- heraldgeezer 2y agoNice, way better than ipadOS stage manager. Btw, Firefox Nightly on Android now has a tabbed interface like a desktop, making it better for tablets. Depending on if I am just reading and watching youtube/music a good android tablet is enough.
- IshKebab 2y agoThe whole "relaunch the app when the window size changes" design from Android 1.0 was such an enormous mistake. They're really going to pay for it now.
- maelito 2y agoIn 2018 I spent 1 year with my Samsung Galaxy S8 as my only computer. Developed a big national website and a new programming language from Termux. Going to work with only my computer in my pocket was awesome. No sync between devices anymore. Forced me to use monitors at work and home which is good for the neck. Had a 15 inch monitor when I was on the move, then a lapdock. Sadly, I was quite alone and Samsung Dex being not open source nor well funded, some bugs where quite irritating in the long term. I dream of a linux smartphone powerhouse. Linux smartphones have mediocre processors. Give me a linux smartphone with an apple silicon processor !
- bluedino 2y agoWould like to hear more about this if you wanted to write a rambling blog post or gasp Twitter thread
- maelito 2y agohttps://medium.com/@l4em/theres-a-computer-in-your-pocket-673196a407ed https://medium.com/@l4em/theres-a-computer-in-your-pocket-67...
- realusername 2y agoHow did you manage with the web inspector? There's no built-in web inspector on any mainstream mobile browser that I'm aware of and the only way to do it would be to use firebug.js like the good old days.
- maelito 2y agoI recompiled chromium for Android to activate the boolean option that actives the dev tools. Haha. https://github.com/laem/chromium https://github.com/laem/chromium It takes such a long time to compile chromium that this wasn't a good solution in the long term, but worked perfectly. Don't remember how I did then, long term. But yes, this was one of the major hurdles.
- rpmisms 2y agoKiwi browser has one!
- ed_db 2y agoThis is a good step forward, but I desperately want to be able to extend a display on Android rather than screen mirroring.
- ASinclair 2y agoThink of this in the context of the previous announcement that ChromeOS will eventually be based on Android.
- kleiba 2y agoAndroid is going for the PC market.
- pjmlp 2y agoAt least currently they have a more consistent UI framework strategy than Microsoft.
- gverrilla 2y agoBest usage of tablets I've been able to find is playing Fruit Ninjas. I love my mouse and keyboard
- userbinator 2y agoIt's rather amusing to see them so "excited" about introducing features and concepts have been around since Windows 95. Even the titlebar buttons look like Windows' with the obvious exception of a missing minimise. On the other hand, maybe they're finally realising the fact that "mobile UI" has been dumbed-down for too long.
- hulitu 2y ago> It's rather amusing to see them so "excited" about introducing features and concepts have been around since Windows 95. Microsoft also started presenting new features like selection of font colors.
- petesergeant 2y agoEntirely tangential, but I've been feeling serious nostalgia recently for a couple of small computers I've owned, specifically the tiny 2012 MBA, and the first-edition Asus eee. In both cases, they felt very solid, while also being very light. Does anyone have recommendations for more recent ones that are Linux based, and that I could get a small amount of work done on in an emergency? I worry the market has been completely taken over by Chromebooks that seem to be made out of cardboard
- greatgib 2y agoEverything old is new again! They are so excited to just have reinvented last decade desktop envs that were working well before fullscreen apps were imposed to us.
- andai 2y agoI recently acquired an Android tablet (Lenovo M10 — a bit too cheap, but gets the job done). I also got a bluetooth keyboard and mouse. The only thing that works properly is web apps. All the native apps have terrible keyboard and mouse support. It made me wonder if I'm the only person using it this way. On that note the only GUI text editor (yes I'm learning Vim in Termux, no it's not a replacement for Sublime!) that's tolerable is VSCode running in the browser. Surprisingly comfy in fullscreen, but the fact that's it's even necessary is just a testament to what a joke the whole ecosystem is.
- mannycalavera42 2y agonope, horrible Lenovo experience here as well. battery life is a joke
- andai 2y agoTo be clear the tablet is crap (just one comical example: the Battery Saver mode enables dark mode, but the screen is an LCD! Wat!) but I'm pretty sure my keyboard/mouse issues aren't specific to the model, but due to the fact that most Android devs don't even consider that use case.
- ristomatti 2y agoI'm using Helix (https://helix-editor.com/ https://helix-editor.com/) on Termux on my 12.2" Samsung Galaxy Tab S8+. It's absolutely flying and less hassle to get LSP's to your favorite language setup. It could also be easier to learn than Vim if you're just getting into Vim. It's definitely not difficult for a Vim user* either. Helix is available on Termux repo's: pkg install helix helix-grammars *) Last year WebStorm started getting painfully slow with some TypeScript codebases I worked with. It got the point I thought to give NeoVim a try. I knew my 10y old Vim config just wouldn't cut it to replace WebStorm for me, so I spent some 3 months on and off fiddling to get LSP support properly working. I then ran across Helix around last December, and ended up as a happy Helix user instead. Edit: Fixed formatting (my fourth comment on HN...)
- sorenjan 2y agoI think a tiling window manager makes more sense for mobile devices, but maybe that's the next step. I also saw an article a while back that Android might get a task bar for phones as well, that actually seems quite handy. https://9to5google.com/2024/08/06/android-phones-taskbar-test/ https://9to5google.com/2024/08/06/android-phones-taskbar-tes...
- winrid 2y agoSo of course the next question is the long play to replace ChromeOS with this?
- dredmorbius 2y agoI've used Android devices for over a decade now, including two tablets which were largely daily drivers. Android makes a lousy desktop, and the issues go far deeper than windowing. The single application which Does Not Precisely Suck on Android is Termux. It, the wealth of directly-packaged software, and the wider universe available through other packaging tools (e.g., pip, npn, rpm, ppm, etc.), scripting and programming tools, etc., are what turns Android from a toy to a Real Operating System. But even Termux is horribly handicapped by Android: - Filesystem permissions are generally not available, nor is most of the filesystem. - Keyboard support within and between apps is horrible and inconsistent. Three specific examples: 1) Firefox/Android (a/k/a Fennic Fox) lacks the keyboard shortcuts of desktop Firefox, a longstanding bug Mozilla seem to have no interest in addressing. 2) In Readability, when editing tags, the backspace/delete key does not work, rather one must select and replace text to correct misspellings. 3) In Neoreader (the Onyx BOOX ebook reader) typing text into the search dialogue is wonky in ways I don't specifically recall though it simply shouldn't break that way. - Android memory management (courtesy the JVM AFAIU) will reap apps without warning. Some manage this reasonably well, many do not. - There's absolutely abysmal inter-app exchange through copy/paste. Free-form windowing is good and fine so far as it goes, but Android needs one hell of a lot more done to it before it's a reasonable desktop / laptop replacement. I still see tablets as most useful for reading text (and perhaps watching videos), and best suited at little else. I'd still recommend a full-featured laptop or notebook for Real Work.
- 1oooqooq 2y agofun fact. this is happening because someone sold pixel tablets as a (cheaper than Chromebook) work platform for contractors at google
- kotaKat 2y agosounds about right -- nobody's buying the pixel tablets and google needs a channel to stuff them through, so they're having CorpEng bury the hatchets.
- 1oooqooq 2y agothe blackberry-licensed android phones (priv, key, key2... i think since 2016) had a os level hack that made EVERY app windowed. you could split the window and use two apps. for everything! only annoyance is that some apps reload when you did that, which was annoying the first time only. i still think HN crowd slept on those phones. a lot.