8 ms·
The Double Irish Dutch Sandwich: End of a Tax Evasion Strategy
- exabrial 2y agoI'm not really mad at companies for doing this, I'm sad that the same ways are not available to ordinary overtaxed people.
- dvh 2y agoAs designed
- Mordisquitos 2y agoMaybe part of the reason ordinary people are "overtaxed" is that companies are able to do this.
- yieldcrv 2y agoGiven that 100% tax compliance at the highest rates would not solve any high tax nation’s budget holes You should be asking the same questions that companies are asking: instead of “why arent we getting hosed equally” its “why are we getting hosed at all”
- mystified5016 2y agoCapitalism only works if someone gets hosed. And of course as we all know, the only alternative to capitalism is communism which is scary and evil! Don't you see how good you have it under the hose?
- tirant 2y agoGiven the nature of the human being, there’s no way to live in a free society without someone being hosed. And even then, capitalism has improved the life conditions of those hosed. Communism removes the freedom for everyone and it is effectively hosing everyone at the same time.
- SiempreViernes 2y agoThat's not true, Soviet communism generated wealthy elites just like any other dictatorship, they just didn't have formal wealth.
- apetrov 2y agoIt’s been very tightly intertwined with the position. When you retire, your wealth is gone, and sometimes retirement equals a purge. I wouldn’t call this being among the wealthy elite by any means. Today, you live in the center of Moscow, and tomorrow you’re an ‘enemy of the people’—good luck proving otherwise.
- SiempreViernes 2y ago> and sometimes retirement equals a purge That's just dictatorships man, you gotta keep playing the game well or you end up tortured to death in a salt mine.
- tirant 2y agoThat is right. Communism only brings wealth to those high in their political hierarchy.
- nabla9 2y agoImproving IRS tax collection enforcement could generate significant funds In fiscal year 2021 the IRS managed more than $4.1 trillion in tax revenue. The annual tax gap was estimated at $688 billion in 2021, with $625 billion remaining uncollected even after enforcement efforts. 16.7 percent.
- yieldcrv 2y agoand you don’t realize that this proves my point? ~$5.3 trillion doesn't solve the US’ budget holes, while the US government tells you what transactions to make to not be taxed
- fwip 2y agoThat's the amount of taxes that companies/people legally owe but don't pay (and are collectable). It's not really related to the amount of taxes that are legally avoided by big businesses through techniques like this "double Irish Dutch sandwich."
- intuitionist 2y agoSo collecting all those extra taxes would cover somewhere south of 25% of the budget deficit for 2021. You aren’t wrong, but the parent isn’t wrong either.
- kvgr 2y agoAnd most important questions: why is the government so expensive, do we really need all of this, is it efficient? How is the efficiency evaluated?
- epolanski 2y agoI really despise some of these anarcho capitalist arguments. A society that isn't lifted by redistributing wealth through taxes creates nothing but a more inequal and dangerous society for everyone. We can all argue about inefficiencies, what is the right amount of spending and funding, but redistributing taxes by creating socially needed projects, from roads that you use, to ports through your shipments to policing streets so your daughter is safer when she goes out with friends. The list is so long. People don't even realize how much wealth and prosperity has been created by redistributing wealth through taxes.
- ajsnigrutin 2y ago> A society that isn't lifted by redistributing wealth through taxes creates nothing but a more inequal and dangerous society for everyone. I mean.... the government is taking tax money from the "poor" (so, normal workers, who cannot avoid paying taxes the way the article described, and whatever new way will be used after the changes), and giving them to a few friendly corporations who give back a percentage to politicians and normal peple usually get nothing.
- epolanski 2y agoThis is again worth debating, but many comments here imply that the best amount of taxes is 0. I don't think they realize the kind of place they would end up living in.
- kvgr 2y agoPeople would be mich happier if the taxes were 50% less, the waste and corruption would be gone. And services were at similar level. Right now, US health care is redistributing money from poor people to rich.
- VieEnCode 2y ago“Given that 100% tax compliance at the highest rates would not solve any high tax nation’s budget holes“ Can I ask where this claim originated from please?
- yieldcrv 2y agoyeah absolutely, I look at the nation’s debt load - which it does pay interest on from tax revenues - and its increase of debt load alongside actual spending of debt sale proceeds, and compare that to how much it collects in taxes I use that government’s official sources to do that math Additionally, in some nations, there are underfunded liabilities, future necessary spending And it all far eclipses what the nation makes in revenue from taxes, tariffs and productive industries it owns - if any If there an aspect of accounting that I’m misunderstanding, by all means enlighten me
- lucianbr 2y ago> I use that government’s official sources to do that math You mean the source of the claim is you, you personally did the math for all "high tax nations" whatever those are, and you're presenting the claim without any of the math or explaining any qualifier like "high" from "high tax"? Swell.
- yieldcrv 2y agoI typically look at the US, France, Germany, UK
- fleabagmange 2y agoNo it’s because an un-elected class of political invents new ways to launder our money over and over. How else does a politician with a small salary end u on millionaire over and over? They do not get book and consulting deals out of the goodness of the public hearts
- knodi123 2y agoIt's fine to believe this. But you should be aware it's a partisan political opinion, and it's inflammatory to present it as an objective fact. Is this site really the place for partisan political opinions?
- sensanaty 2y agoHow is it partisan? They mentioned no parties or politicians. What they said applies equally to all politicians regardless of leaning.
- Mountain_Skies 2y ago@knodi123, what is partisan about fleabagmange's statement? They don't mention any politician, political party, or even political ideology.
- AnthonyMouse 2y agoMore to the point, it isn't the politicians of only one party who are getting rich this way.
- 9dev 2y agoWell, apart from medicine, irrigation, health, roads, cheese and education, baths and the Circus Maximus, what have the Romans ever done for us?
- exabrial 2y agoGreat so that’s like .05% off the tax i paid. Whered the rest go
- ErigmolCt 2y agoIt can definitely contribute to the feeling of being stretched thin
- earnesti 2y agoOrdinary people can buy the stock of the said companies and benefit from the tax saved. Probably they already own them through pension funds.
- consp 2y agoOrdinary people do not buy stock. Most people here are in the highest percentile and it shows.
- amarcheschi 2y agoThat take feels kinda... Detached from the average person to me? I don't know how to take it, just like when you hear gates saying a banana cost 10$. Common Joe would benefit much more from taxes being actually paid than profits being accumulated by companies just so they can crush the competition more and earn more and (...)
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> just like when you hear gates saying a banana cost 10$ When was that?
- amarcheschi 2y agoI've never seen a real video, it may as well be a common saying after being on the internet for a so long time. However, there is a video of gates trying to guess grocery prices on the internet, and he's not that bad. I think at this point it's just an internet meme that exist to reference billionaires being disconnected from reality
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> I've never seen a real video, it may as well be a common saying after being on the internet for a so long time. I mean, I can show you the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl_Qyk9DSUw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl_Qyk9DSUw But that has nothing to do with Bill Gates or any other person named Gates. (You might be aware that Bill Gates isn't a woman.) It's a joke on a comedy show. It's not something anyone has ever said.
- toast0 2y agoOrdinary people can't do this because they missed the window, but also because their labor has a clear nexus. This scheme worked because when a product is designed in one locale, built in another, and sold in a third, there's some reasonable question of what the nexus of the income is. Ordinary people that have written books or songs or otherwise earn royalties from creative works on a regular basis could probably have arranged for ownership of their royalties to be owned by a complex corporate structure as well, but I don't know that very many ordinary people earn enough in royalties that tax avoidance is worth the setup and maintenance costs.
- BobbyJo 2y agoI mean, the clear way to deal with this is to make them choose, and allow import tariffs. Get taxed where the nexus is, and pay to bring the value to other jurisdictions. I understand that the web of various tax laws and trade agreements makes this impossible though. 80 years of cruft is too much to sift through to improve things in one fell swoop I suppose.
- lucianbr 2y ago> the clear way to deal with this is to make them choose My understanding is that the whole problem stems from companies being able to choose. Apple chose to pay taxes in Ireland for some things, because Ireland gave them a tax advantage, thus avoiding taxes in other European countries. Allowing import tariffs between EU countries would maybe help with this but cause other problems. The EU free market isn't a whim, it has good reasons to exist and significant benefits. There is no "clear way" to fix this. If there was, it would be used already.
- BobbyJo 2y ago> There is no "clear way" to fix this. If there was, it would be used already. What do you mean by "this"? When I said "this", I meant this specific form of tax avoidance. There is a clear way to fix it, as I mentioned. When you say "this" it seems like you mean tax avoidance in general, in which case I would agree that there is no clear way to fix it.
- epolanski 2y agoI personally am. Because people are often overtaxed due to high tax elusion/avoidance/evasion. E.g. in Italy, around 10 to 15% taxes are evaded in many ways. That bill is then paid by regular taxpayers. If even more people avoided taxes that would just make the issue worse.
- throw310822 2y agoFrankly I don't even understand why companies are taxed at all. Taxes are proportional to individuals' income so that the pain of contributing to the collective good is distributed fairly. Companies don't feel any pleasure or pain, they need money as a commodity- it pays people, investments, innovation, talent. Money and other benefits should be taxed when they are transferred to individuals, not before.
- bandyaboot 2y agoThis seems like a really backward way of thinking. You seem to be advocating for complex tax loopholes to be opened for individuals rather than advocating for simple, but lowered taxes.
- yieldcrv 2y agowhat's backwards about that? driving to the neighboring town for cheaper gas (because the gas tax happens to be lower) is just as legal as these complex multijurisdiction incongruencies yes, I believe car ownership should be more accessible to people to be able to ponder such a drive
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoI understood it more as "the individuals should be taxed the same (so, much lower amount) as corporations". If company X can pay just <small percent> of their income as taxes (all together), why can't random bobby do the same? The law requires you to have a fire extinguisher in your office? Sure, buy one, but since it's a cost of doing business, that money comes from the pre-tax pile and is not taxed extra. The law requires me to wear pants when I go out, why do i have to buy them from post-tax pile of money (so, after ~50% gone to the government), and still pay 9.5% VAT on them? I can buy those same black jeans as a company (eg. consider black jeans a work uniform), and avoid all those taxes). Rent? Pre-tax money for a comoany, post-tax for an individual. In some countries (eg. mine, slovenia) you have even bigger stupidities... you have a CO2 tax (and some other) on gasoline (and other fuels), and you pay VAT on top of that tax... the co2 tax included in the base to calculate the VAT... you literally pay taxes on taxes. Again, businesses don't have to pay that VAT (they deduct it) because well.. they need the company car to do business.
- morpheuskafka 2y agoThe distinction is business vs personal, not company vs individual. A sole trader can usually do avoid income and VAT on all those things (except some deductions pertaining to payroll benefits). Some countries have an alternative arrangement where very small traders pay VAT but also retain VAT on the products they sell rather than actually netting out the VAT on a return.
- Nursie 2y ago> I'm not really mad at companies for doing this I am, regardless of the effect on individuals, it skews the market away from smaller entrants and allows those that have reached enough of a size to be able to afford to play these games to leverage a huge advantage.
- Lio 2y agoAs well as killing local competition there's also the pure hypocrisy of firms such as Apple (and they're not the only offender) passing themselves off as some kind of moral authority whist at the same time aggressively refusing to pay taxes towards hospitals and schools in the local markets they operate in. They can present themselves anyway they like but it does leave a bad taste in the mouth.
- sanj 2y ago“ The obvious loss is to government revenue, but the more subtle and still very real loss is the diversion of high-powered talent from what could have been gains in efficiency and productivity to focus instead on corporate reorganizations and tax evasion games.” I’d expect very little overlap between those talent pools.
- mtnGoat 2y agoWhy? Talent goes where to best pay is, if you’re not paying taxes you can pay your agent more.
- immibis 2y agoHow many computer programmers moonlight as tax avoidance accountants?
- tux3 2y agoTax avoidance is a legal problem instead of a tech problem, but it has many parallels wherever there are bad incentives. These are fundamentally not pro-social activities, but trying to get an unfair advantage through loopholes. More computer programmers might moonlight as SEO gurus, if search engines didn't put up at least a token amount of resistance against scummy low-effort SEO tactics. Fewer tax avoidance accountants would still be tax avoidance accountants, if we made a bigger effort to prevent it. (And that doesn't mean accountants would have to be programmers instead, there are many other kinds of talent)
- smallnamespace 2y agoHigh finance and crypto are two places where a high concentration of technical skills intersect with using those same skills to game our financial and legal systems.
- jacobr1 2y agoMore like how many people with degrees in Business go into Management Consulting, would like to join a startup as a Product Manager, or accountants that want to be Associates at a VC firm rather than work a big 4. But even for programmers, plenty of people make the decision to go into programming or medicine or law because they are well paid and respected careers. And interests in secondary school and university are influenced by parents, teachers and the culture promoting certain directions. Kids these days are bombarded by STEM everything.
- barrkel 2y agoThe word chosen at the end of the article: > I’m sure the international tax lawyers around the world are strategizing new tax evasion strategies even as I write these words. It should be clear that tax avoidance and evasion are quite different things, and the Double Irish Dutch Sandwich was tax avoidance and not evasion.
- immibis 2y agoThis is a technicality created by legal tax evaders. To evade is to avoid. If you're avoiding tax you're evading tax. Sometimes it's moral, many times it's legal.
- yieldcrv 2y agoIts a technicality created by government tax authorities and prosecutors They say avoidance is legal, evasion is illegal and the name of a prosecutable crime
- Alupis 2y agoSo are you telling us when you prepared your recent tax return, you spent zero time ensuring you paid only the required amount? Avoiding paying taxes you are not legally required to pay is not tax evasion.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- immibis 2y agoThat's correct. Deliberately restructuring your activities beyond common sense in order to reduce taxes even further, however, is legally evading them, by the normal definition of the English word "evade". If you are running a business and someone points out you can reduce taxes by registering a corporation, that's normal - most businesses are some type of corporation. If someone points out you can reduce taxes even further by registering an Irish subsidiary and sending them license fees, that's abnormal, and now you're using trickery to avoid taxes. UNLESS your business really does do R&D in Ireland at an arms-length subsidiary which charges license fees. In that case, the legal structure mirrors what is actually happening, so it's fine!
- gwd 2y ago> The obvious loss is to government revenue, but the more subtle and still very real loss is the diversion of high-powered talent from what could have been gains in efficiency and productivity to focus instead on corporate reorganizations and tax evasion games. It's also a loss to all of us who find ourselves owning a "foreign" corporation for legitimate reasons, and having to do a lot of work proving that we're not playing shell games. I'm an American living in the UK; I've started what's now a one-man bootstrapped company and it just makes sense for it to be incorporated in the UK. I don't mind paying taxes, but I don't want to have to pay them twice. UK taxes are generally higher than US taxes, and there are tax treaties to avoid double taxation, so no problem, right? Wrong. First, if a US citizen owns more than 10% of a foreign corporation, there's an insanely complicated form you have to fill out, two pages of which are incomprehensible questions ("Is your company considered an X corporation under sections Y and Z of the Blablablah act?") that simply require an expert to fill out. Secondly, if a US citizens owns more than 50% of a foreign company, by default, income from that company counts as personal income, but taxes paid by the company to another government don't count as personal taxes. You can get around this, apparently, but it's even more complicated. So because of [REDACTED] lawyers and accountants that have come up with these schemes, I have to spend precious starting capital to a bunch of accountants to prove I'm not evading taxes, rather than actually doing something useful with that money (and that accountant doing something more useful with their time).
- jmyeet 2y agoThis is completely unrelated to the post. What you're complaining about is overreach by the IRS in relation to foreign assets held by US citizens (ie FATCA) and the reporting requirements (eg Form 7938 and FBAR). It's worth noting that real estate is carved out as an exception for reporting purposes somehow, even though it's a common vehicle for money laundering. That has literally nothing to do the Double Irish Dutch sandwich, which has historically been used by US companies (particularly Big Tech companies) to avoid taxes by moving their IP to a foreign subsidiary and then paying "royalties" to avoid paying US taxes.
- gwd 2y agoYou seem to think that the IRS doing that just for a laugh, or just because they hate rich people, and that Big Tech companies are the only ones playing shell games with their revenue in order to shirk paying their fair share to support the society they've benefitted from. I think it much more likely that rich people also play shell games with their assets / revenue to avoid paying their fair share to support the society they've benefitted from, and that the IRS requires the extra reporting to try to counteract that. This article is specifically about a specific loophole invented by unethical accountants and lawyers, but it's also generally about all the effort spent by unethical accountants and lawyers to come up with such loopholes, causing not only harm to society (in the form of free-riding on those who are paying taxes), but which in turn forces effort on the part of tax agencies and legislatures, which then forces effort on normal people like me who just want to make some money and pay our fair share. It's pure wasted energy.
- jmyeet 2y agoThe complexity in the tax code is why we end up with things like AMT (Alternative Minimum TAx) and the 15% minimum corporate tax. There are so many carved-out special interest exceptions that it's almost impossible to unravel, like the carried interest tax credit for hedge fund management fees. I think we've reached the point where we need revenue apportinment of profit. That means if 50% of your revenue comes from the US, then (at least) 50% of your profit is taxable in the US. It's worth noting that there are various schemes for multinationals to avoid taking profits in the US. One of the most common is transfer pricing. Example: Company A sells sofas to US consumers for $1000. It buys them from subsidiary B (in Bermuda) for $900. Subsidiary B buys the sofas from Subsidiary C in China for $300 each. So $600 in profit is moved to a 0% tax haven like Bermuda. That's transfer pricing and it's illegal. The Double Irish Sandwich is an example of profit shifting. What's the difference between profit shifting and transfer pricing? Profit shifting is legal. Transfer pricing isn't. That's functionally the difference. So an argument against revenue appointment of profit is you can use similar schemes to hide profits but you really can't. For one, companies need to report profits to shareholders so the IRS has that data point. For another, the IRS can and does go after companies to figure out beneficial ownership and whether transactions really are at arm's length or not. For anyone saying they can benefit from this by buying shares in $BIG_TECH$, I promise you that you would benefit more from that company paying taxes to fund the roads, bridges and schools that you would from your 100 shares going up by an extra 1%.
- refurb 2y agoWhat do you mean “transfer pricing is illegal”? Transfer pricing is a normal part of business and done all the time and is legal. Presumably you mean “hiding profit through transfer pricing is illegal”?
- andrehacker 2y agoDoes that mean that U2 will no longer be a Dutch band ? https://taxfoundation.org/blog/u2-abandons-ireland-name-taxes/ https://taxfoundation.org/blog/u2-abandons-ireland-name-taxe...
- gosub100 2y agoThats hilarious that this social activist who promoted progressive, socialist movements chooses to (quite literally) not put his money where his mouth is/was.
- dennis_jeeves2 2y agoThat taxation exists and is widely regarded as necessary (evil) in the first place is a sobering reminder of the average IQ of the populace.
- gosub100 2y agodid you forget that you can move, right now, to a country with no income tax?
- dennis_jeeves2 2y ago[flagged]
- matrixhelix 2y agoCat and mouse game, tax evaders always find a way
- onionisafruit 2y agoCats always take enough mice to fill their bellies.
- EarlKing 2y agoWhat? No one's mentioned how firms have been leveraging Malta as the new leg of the Double Irish / Dutch Sandwich? How disappointing.
- DoingIsLearning 2y agoCuriosity questions is the revenue that is localized in Ireland and the Netherlands because of the double sandwich, of any significance in terms of percentage of total taxed revenue in those countries? From memory Ireland and the Netherlands are also the biggest contributors to EU funding. So I am wondering how this shift would affect EU dynamics as a whole?
- neamar 2y agoThey're not large contributors to eu finance: 10th and 5th, respectively https://www.statista.com/statistics/316691/eu-budget-contributions-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/316691/eu-budget-contrib... France and Germany account for nearly 50% of the funding.
- DoingIsLearning 2y agoPerhaps the infograph I saw was per capita?
- Rinzler89 2y agoPerhaps you're mistaken?
- rsynnott 2y agoNah; Ireland's the biggest per capita contributor, and the Netherlands is fourth (after Luxembourg and Belgium). (Not sure what's going on with Belgium; Ireland, Luxembourg and to some extent the Netherlands have rather inflated GDPs, which drives up contribution amounts, but Belgium's isn't particularly high.)
- s_dev 2y agoYeah -- Ireland and Netherlands are both top contributors on a per capita basis. Though this was only accelerated recently i.e. the 2023 budget not the 2021 budget. Ireland on many occasions has be a net recipient before this while the Dutch have a longer history of being a net contributor. https://www.icaew.com/insights/viewpoints-on-the-news/2024/jan-2024/chart-of-the-week-eu-budget-2024 https://www.icaew.com/insights/viewpoints-on-the-news/2024/j...
- dathinab 2y agocan't we just add following to tax law: "if your company structure contains additional complexity which main purpose is the avoidance of tax it's a crime" I mean law has the fundamental benefit of allowing you to define what is a crime based on the outcome (tax evasion) instead of needing to explicitly rule out any way you might reach that outcome. I mean e.g. for killing people the law also does state it's not allowed without listing every way you could kill a person. So why can't we do the same for clear cases of tax evasion?
- RickarySanchez 2y agoMakes sense to me, I'm sure there's a way to word it legally
- Log_out_ 2y agoQuestion : Could a tax haven adveserial government design a lobster basket tax haven? Easy to get into, but unable to leave without paying the full taxes? So a taxhaven system becomes a financial one time pad for harvesting taxes?