10 ms·
Against all odds, an asteroid mining company appears to be making headway
- AlbertCory 2y agoContracting their asteroid lander for various science missions is also a good opportunity. My bet is, that's where all the revenue in the next 10 years will come from.
- cletus 2y agoI'm not sure what substance you could mine on an asteroid that could possibly be economical. The first obvious assumption is would have to be launched from space and return to space because the cost of getting a payload from Earth to LEO is a huge extra expense. Then you have to consider the delta-V of getting to the asteroid, doing a rendezvous and getting back. If that's so significant that the Earth launch cost is trivial then the delta-V budget is so huge, it must make the endeavour even more uneconomical. I believe humanity's future is in a Dyson Swarm. There are simply too many advantages. This is a deep topic. The question is how do you bootstrap that? Where do you get raw materials? I don't think it's from asteroids. I very much suspect it's from a larger body and my money is on Mercury. Why? On pretty much any body in the Solar System you're living underground so Mercury is at no disadvantage here. It has no atmosphere. That's an advantage. Mars's super thin atmosphere is the worst of both worlds. Additionally, Mercury is metal rich and due to its proximity to the Sun, energy is abundant (ie solar power). Interestingly, it has a higher orbital speed than Earth (47km/s vs 30km/s). That's really interesting because it's free velocity to leave the Solar System. Resources on EArth are so ridiculously cheap. You can mine iron ore for a few dollars a ton at scale. You can convert it into steel really cheaply too (again, at scale). Doing anything in space requires having truly stupendous amounts of cheap energy available.
- ck2 2y agoThere are neutron stars that create chunks of gold and platinum larger than the size of earth itself. Highly doubt such chunks are floating around our solar system but it's an amusing thought that one day hundreds of years from now we could nudge a (much) smaller chunk into orbit or park it in a Lagrange point and shave off pieces to return to earth.
- arunabha 2y ago> There are neutron stars that create chunks of gold and platinum larger than the size of earth itself. Aren't neutron stars 12 miles in diameter on avg?
- ck2 2y agoNeutron stars are the literal limit to how much matter can be collapsed before it turns into a black hole and yet still remain a star. A neutron star 12-16 miles in diameter contains the mass over HALF-MILLION earths, it is very hard to fathom but yet they exist! So popping out an earth-sized chunk of gold after collision with say another neutron star (kilonova) and ejecting matter to "normal" density is plausible.
- julius 2y agoMercury sounds interesting. Requires a certain scale though (gravity is a bitch). Considering just the initial mining and construction, bodies with low gravity and proximity to the earth feel like an efficient starting point, right? I always thought the moon would be a good place to bootstrap the first few thousand space habitats. Your point about energy will probably be the biggest deal. Wondering how complicated it would be to ship a bunch of nuclear reactors to the moon. There seems to be quite a few companies working on small, "mass produced" reactors currently.
- ikekkdcjkfke 2y agoSend a piece of lead in orbit around the sun so it heats up but not melts, when it comes around heat some water to steam. Free power!
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoOnce all of your water is steam, how do you get it back into a liquid phase so that you can do it over again? Or so that you can do other things, like drink it...
- marcosdumay 2y agoThe internet is a messed-up place, because as much as I'm convinced this is a joke, I'm also certain somebody could write the same comment in all seriousness and think they are making a great discovery. We can't even just laugh.
- kragen 2y agothe idea is actually workable, it just isn't competitive with other ways of exploiting solar energy
- marcosdumay 2y agoIt has some really serious drawbacks, like needing to repeatedly synchronize and desynchronize orbits. That makes it crazy complex even on the context of crazy futuristic space machinery. That "isn't competitive" is quite an understatement. But yeah, technically it doesn't break any law of Physics.
- patall 2y agoIn terms of delta-v, the asteroids are much closer to us than mercury. A small one in the belt is like delta 1.5km/s from earth escape, versus 11km/s to mercury. Heck, the Mars moons are technically closer to us than 'our' moon. (Overview i.e deltavmap.github.io/) And the sun is a gravity well. Mercuries higher orbital speed will not help you leave the solar system. In fact, it is the other way around. Oh, and solar cells are already crazy good. With all the space you have out there, higher energy density on mercury will be very marginally important.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agore: delta V, the chaotic nature of orbits involving many bodies means that a very well-timed nudge ought to be sufficient to move certain asteroids quite a long distance for "free". So the problem becomes finding the right asteroid, and the right time, and the right nudge vector. More about computation than rocket fuel: the deeper into that chaotic system we can penetrate, the less we have to spend on influencing it. You've also got to slow it down when it gets to where your smelters are. For that I'd propose we just let it smash into the moon and then mine it on the surface. We can alternate which sides we smash into in order to prevent the moon's orbit from changing significantly. Of course you still need to provide the initial nudge, which ain't nothing, but it's a far cry from towing an asteroid or towing a smelter.
- theptip 2y agoA medium-sized asteroid identified had something like $3T of titanium on it. Of course, that's gross value and you can’t clear your supply at that price. But even if it costs hundreds of billions to extract you should be able to net a profit.
- luqtas 2y agobreaking news: asteroid mining company mismatch calculus and the rock hits a rural city in Texas
- kibwen 2y agoAsteroid mining only makes sense for constructing things in space. For applications here on Earth, the logistics of both leaving and re-entering the gravity well mean that it will never, ever be economical for anything other than materials that literally don't exist on Earth. Bringing platinum and gold from asteroids to Earth doesn't make economic sense, let alone iron.
- Teever 2y agoBut once you have that infrastructure in space that can mine and construct in space won't that greatly shorten the supply chain for asteroid mining and bring the cost down? It seems to me that when people make the kind of argument that you're making they're forgetting to price the negative externalities that Earth based mining cost our society via environmental damage. If the environmental damage and species decline that we're experiencing from our planet-side economic endeavours were properly priced in space based manufacturing and asteroid mining would look a lot more attractive.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoThe key to manufacturing is humans. Robots help yet need a lot of human maintenance. Human-free spacecraft require a lot of lead time and still begin from a human touch on earth. NEO is too resource starved for it to ever be independent enough to be cheaper than just managing resources better on the surface of Earth.
- im3w1l 2y agoMaintanance is hard, but there is a solution. Design the robots out of materials that can be found in space. Then make them capable of reproduction. Then you can just scrap damaged robots as long as you can replace them fast enough. This also has the benefit that you just need to send up a tiny bootstrap population, but with time you will have quite the formidable workforce.
- paulryanrogers 2y ago
- therediterator 2y agoThe cost of getting the asteroid to orbit, transportation (back and forth), and mining it would be too much. Even if we do this, keeping in mind that we can find some elements that we are aware of, I think it is way more important for humanity overall to execute this mission because there is always an upside that we can discover something that is much more valuable just like the company can sell the piece of just an asteroid as a souvenir.
- inamberclad 2y agoI recently did an interview with them and found their perspective to be a little... flippant? A bunch of screw NASA, we sleep in the office, etc etc. I admit that I only spoke with one person in the company but it was enough that I realized it wasn't the work environment I wanted for myself. Regardless, I wish them all the best.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- devit 2y agoUsing the rocket equation, it is possible to compute the ratio between the $kg launch cost and $/kg material sell price that would make it economical. Based on my calculations, with optimistic assumptions (including the asteroid being made solely of the desired material), you need 5 Falcon 9 launches and in-space assembly to bring back one ton of material, which would require selling the material for 350k$/kg for parity. But gold is only 80k$/kg, platinum is 30$/kg, etc. Doesn't look feasible with current technology.
- Teever 2y agoCan you share your calculations and assumptions that go into them?
- withinboredom 2y ago> Doesn't look feasible with current technology. If you don't pay the demanded price before it arrives in orbit, it will be delivered a full speed on your lawn. Your entire city will be destroyed.
- zizee 2y agoWhat about with StarShip tha, whilst unproven, looks to be on path to the goal full reusability?
- AwaAwa 2y agoThis gives me the same vibes as OceanGate's Titan, and Boeing's Starliner capsule. Better these two as a role model than Theranos though. Obviously the lack of any squishy humans that need to be part of the process makes it less of an issue when nothing comes of it.
- MarketingJason 2y agoI'm no rocket scientist, but to me it makes sense to try and redirect asteroids to enter our atmosphere. The only thing I'd seek to "mine" on the asteroid is H2O, Hydrogen, or something that could be immediately converted to power/propulsion by the unit-itself. I guess one risk would be introducing unknown biological or chemical nastiness. Another would be how precise we could be to target open ocean/desert/etc.
- dyauspitr 2y agoThat’s insanely irresponsible. Even if everything goes perfectly you’re going to have volcano tier dust plumes altering the local climate and in the worst case you could kill millions of people by wiping out entire cities.
- PaulHoule 2y agoPlatinum-group metals on earth: $965/oz Water, volatiles and carbonaceous materials anywhere else in the solar system: priceless
- credit_guy 2y agoNot really. You can't set up a "gas station" somewhere in the Solar system. It has to orbit. Anything in orbit goes many, many times faster than a bullet. Aligning yourself with such a fast moving object is doable, but costs a lot of fuel. Then detaching yourself from that orbit in order to go to your original destination burns a lot of fuel too. But let's say you get more fuel from that station than you burn. Who is going to replenish the station, and how? They need to burn a lot of fuel too, to go to an asteroid and back. It's not completely impossible, but it's quite unlikely.
- PaulHoule 2y agoWhere did I say I’d waste volatiles moving things around? (1) Build a solar sail factory on a CC asteroid and you can deliver sunshades to Earth-Sun L1 without wasting volatiles as reaction mass (2) If you read this paper and really thought about it https://arxiv.org/pdf/2011.07487 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2011.07487 You’d realize that it strictly dominates all other space colonization schemes that have been proposed because it doesn’t waste volatiles for transportation. Certainly O’Neill’s ideas look infeasible in comparison (where do you get the nitrogen to fill those big airspaces? My plan for a baby Bernal sphere intended to be a luxury hotel in LEO still takes 15 starship loads of LN2 for the atmosphere) Even Musk’s plan to colonize Mars is something that only makes sense to people who were born on a planet. If “grabby” aliens capable of interstellar travel and building such things here they might find the Earth a curiosity at best.
- mapt 2y agoSolar sails are at this time quite useless for most purposes, and always will be if we can't build, fold, and deploy working sails of micrometer thickness, and/or build gigawatt-scale laser launch projectors. Using ion thrusters it is already the case that we have access to power-generation-limited domain of specific impulse; Nobody thinks a mission at 30,000isp instead of 3,000isp is superior for interplanetary because of the sheer amount of waiting time and the extreme mass fraction of the solar panels. Solar sails, even moreso. And one more dream to kill - large open volumes are probably never going to happen. This is implied by the mathematical engineering reality of the thin-walled pressure vessel, whose minimum mass scales directly with (volume * pressure) / tensile strength. Contrary to my naive expectations, there is no square cube ratio to the structure of a pressure vessel, so every cubic meter costs mass.
- dylan604 2y ago"The docking mechanism is simple—since the asteroid is likely to be iron-rich, Vestri will use magnets to attach itself." While that sounds simple, it does make it sound like the mining part just became much more difficult. Thinking about some of the sci-fi regarding asteroid mining, I've always liked the idea of bringing the asteroid to park into an orbit around earth to make it easier/cheaper for multiple deliveries, but I've always wonder what kind of ownership claims that would imply. If I took the time and effort to park an asteroid in orbit, would I have sole ownership of it or would you be able to mine from it as well?
- choeger 2y agoI don't think that moving the whole thing into our orbit would make much sense. The biggest amount of delta-v is necessary to leave Earth's gravity well. Once you're there, going from and to asteroid is time-consuming but doesn't need that much delta-v, moving ore from the asteroid to Earth would cost some fuel, proportional to the mass. So moving it into orbit would save time but require us to pay for the fuel all at once. So why should someone do this, unless you need a permanent human presence on the asteroid?
- dylan604 2y agoI think we're all scared of the actual question posed or something as we've totally ignored it in everyone of these responses. Nobody cares in sci-fi about whether something should/could be done. That's not the purview of the plot. It's also not the purview of the original comment.
- nordsieck 2y ago> So why should someone do this, unless you need a permanent human presence on the asteroid? Activity is only economically valuable if it is valued - i.e. by people. Unless there's a population of people living in space, the ore or products derived from ore need to eventually make their way to Earth in order to be worth while.
- nordsieck 2y ago> I've always liked the idea of bringing the asteroid to park into an orbit around earth to make it easier/cheaper for multiple deliveries I think you're dramatically underestimating the difficulty of doing this. If you look at rockets, they're 90-95% propellant. Even relatively svelt upper stages like Centaur III (the upper stage from Atlas v) are more than 50% propellant. And that's for just taking payloads to LEO - for higher energy missions, the usable payload gets smaller, which means the percent of the upper stage that's propellant increases. How difficult would it be to get an amount of propellant, say, 5 times the mass of the asteroid to the asteroid? You'd also have to get the engines and other structures to let you use the propellant in a productive way. It's way easier to extract valuable parts from an astroid and move a lot less mass there and back.
- poikroequ 2y agoThe title is far too generous. They've only launched a single spacecraft so far which failed due to communications issues. They're planning to launch a second spacecraft in Q4 this year which will fly by an asteroid and take pictures. They're planning a third spacecraft which they say will dock to an asteroid using magnets because it's "likely iron rich" and basically take measurements. Nothing about actually mining resources and returning those materials to Earth. So they've gotten funding from investors? In the past, even dumber endeavours have gotten even more funding than this, it really doesn't mean anything.
- lurquer 2y agoWhy not a mining operation in the Antarctic? Or the Sahara? Or in the Mariana Trench? As all these options are cheaper and easier than asteroid mining, and as none of these bright-eyed ‘entrepreneurs’ are undertaking these tasks, I can only assume the things being ‘mined’ are gullible investors. (Not that I’m blaming them… what’s easier? Finding an asteroid with a precious metal, mining it and getting it back to earth at less the cost of mining it here? Or, finding a gullible venture capitalist who will cover your salary for a few years? Probable the latter…)
- joemazerino 2y agoI for one love the idea of space extraction, even if it is a pipe dream. Gathering minerals from dead space rocks seems better than from our planet.