9 ms·
Others are saying this article is bearish, but then... > A huge amount of economic value is going to be created by AI. Company builders focused on delivering v
by ryandrake 2y ago
Others are saying this article is bearish, but then...
> A huge amount of economic value is going to be created by AI. Company builders focused on delivering value to end users will be rewarded handsomely.
Such strong speculative predictions about the future, with no evidence. How can anyone be so certain about this? Do they have some kind of crystal ball? Later in the article they even admit that this is another one of tech's all-too-familiar "Speculative frenzies."
The whole AI thing just continues to baffle me. It's like everyone is in the same trance and simply assuming and chanting over and over that This Will Change Everything, just like previous technology hype cycles were surely going to Change Everything. I mean, we're seeing huge companies' entire product strategies changing overnight because We Must All Believe.
How can anyone speak definitively about what AI will do at this stage of the cycle?
- glitchc 2y agoWhenever I hear the AI hype cycle, I'm always reminded of expert systems and how they were going to revolutionize the world.
- awahab92 2y agothere were probably people who doubted electricity, vaccines and indoor plumbing.
- ryandrake 2y agoThere were also people who doubted the Segway, Magic Leap, Theranos, 3D TVs, Windows Phone, and Google Glass. I think doubt is OK, at least it is before any particular technology or product has actually proven itself.
- fragmede 2y agothe gap between participants in this conversation is that some have had it proven itself for themselves and others around them, and others have not seen that same proof.
- rsynnott 2y agoThing is, that comment would have worked in a thread three years ago about ‘metaverses’. Sometimes, the early adopters are the only adopters. Not saying that’s definitely the case here, but it is looking like it’s going in that direction - huge hype, absurd levels of VC spending, a bunch of ultra-enthusiastic early adopters, but real mainstream application still absent.
- glitchc 2y agoThis is false equivalence and you know better. Electricity is foundational technology. What we call AI are LLMs, which are great and useful, but not in the same league as something foundational like electricity.
- pixl97 2y agoNow, the question of "Are LLMs intelligent" is debatable, but intelligence is foundational itself.
- rurp 2y agoThe ration of hyped technologies that turned out to be overhyped, versus ones that turned out to be as impactful as electricity is... I don't even know how many orders of magnitude different, but it's a lot.
- llm_trw 2y agoYou should also be reminded about the internet. After the dotcom bubble it was extremely common to hear it outright dismissed as never being useful for anything. Sometimes the future just gets here before we're ready for it.
- glitchc 2y agoRepeat after me: An LLM is not AI. The internet enabled a whole new world of possible applications. It's unlikely this or even the next upgrade to ML will get there. If we get to AGI, sure, that's grpund-breaking, but we're still a few steps removed from that.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoRepeat after me: "AI hype" is not like Bitcoin hype, it's like Dot-com boom. Generative models are already changing how people live and work. Ignore the grifters, and ignore the entrepreneurs. Look at civilians, regular folks, and watch how it impacts them.
- glitchc 2y agoOh the belief is so strong! Wouldn't it be great if this were true.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoIt's not hard to have strong beliefs about something that's real.
- pphysch 2y agoTo be fair to Bitcoin, the world's largest economic bloc is actively building an alternative to USD/Western banks for international settlements, with blockchain technology. It doesn't have anything to do with the libertarian vision of BTC but it's the same technical concept.
- SoftTalker 2y ago
- cjbgkagh 2y agoThis really is different, and I say that as someone who spent a lot of time on expert systems, not as someone who is overly bought into AI hype. The problem with expert systems is that even if the tooling was perfect the people using them needed a rather nuanced and sophisticated understanding of ontologies. That just wasn’t going to happen. There is not enough of that kind of expertise to go around. Efforts to train people largely failed. I think the intentional undermining of developer salaries pushed a lot of smart people out of the software industry making the problem even worse. That’s what makes AI special, the ability to deliver value even when used by unsophisticated operators. Many workflows can largely stay the same and AI can be sprinkled in where it makes the most sense. I use it for documentation writing and UI asset production and it’s better in that role than the people I used to pay.
- stale2002 2y ago> Such strong speculative predictions about the future, with no evidence. How can anyone be so certain about this? The evidence is all around you. For anyone who has made any serious attempt to add AI to your current life and work process, you will fairly quickly notice that your productivity has doubled. Now, do I as a random software engineer who is now producing higher quality code, twice as fast, know how to personally capture that value with a company? No. But the value is out there, for someone to capture. > It's like everyone is in the same trance and simply assuming and repeating over and over that This Will Change Everything It already is changing everything, in multiple fields. Go look up what happened to the online art commission market. It got obliterated over a year ago and is replaced by people getting images from midjourney/ect. Furthermore, if you are a software engineer and you haven't included tools like github copilot, or cursor AI into your workflow yet, I simply don't consider you to be a serious engineer anymore. You've fallen behind. And these facts are almost immediately obvious to anyone who has been paying attention in the startup space, at least.
- GenerocUsername 2y agoIve added "how have you incorperated generative AI into your workflow" as an interview question, and I dont know if it is stigma or actual low adoption, but I have not had a single enthusiastic response across 10+ interviews for senior engineer positions. Meanwhile, I have chatGPT open in background and go from unaware to informed for every new keyword I hear around me all day everyday. Not to mention annotating code, generating utlity functions, and tracing errors
- ilaksh 2y agoWould you consider hiring on a contract basis? I use AI tools like Copilot in vim, and have my own agent framework to ask questions or even edit files for me directly, which I have been trying to use more. And I could use a new contract. You can see my email in my HN profile.
- devjab 2y agoI think if sort of depends on the work you do. If you’re working on a single language and have been for a while then I imagine that much of the value LLMs might give you already live in your existing automation workflows. I personally like co-pilot but I work across several languages and code bases where I seriously can’t remember how to do basic stuff. In those cases the automatic code generation from co-pilot speeds my efficiency, but it still can’t do anything actually useful aside from making me more productive. I fully expect the tools to become “necessary” in making sure things like JSdoc and other domination is auto-updated when programmers alter something. Hell, if they become good enough at maintaining tests that would be amazing. So far there hasn’t been much improvement over the year we’ve used the tools though. Productivity isn’t even up across teams because too many developers put too much trust into what the LLMs tell them, which means we have far more cleanup to do than we did in the previous couple of years. I think we will handle this thing once we get our change management good enough at teaching people that LLMs aren’t necessarily more trustworthy than SO answers.
- simonw 2y agoIf, like me, you're using LLMs on a daily basis and getting real personal value out of them, it's hard not to conclude that they're going to have a big impact. I don't need a crystal ball for this. The impact is already evident for us early-adopters, it's just not evenly distributed yet. That's not to say they're not OVER hyped - changing the entire company roadmap doesn't feel like a sensible path to me for most companies.
- ryandrake 2y agoEarly Adopters are always True Believers. That's why they are early adopters. Every single one of them is going to say "The impact is clear! Look around you! I use XYZ every day!" You really don't know what the adoption curve will look like until you get into the Late Majority.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoWe're already entering Late Majority stage. Early Majority is like a good chunk of the western population, which already should tell you something - the "technology adoption model" might not make much sense when the total addressable market is literally everyone on the planet, and the tech spreads itself organically with zero marketing effort. And/or, it's neither hard nor shameful to be True Believers, if what you believe in is plain fact.
- llm_trw 2y ago>Early Adopters are always True Believers. Early adopters were using gpt-2 and telling us it was amazing. I used it and it was completely shit and put me off openai for a good four years. gpt-3 was nearly not shit, and 3.5 the same just a bit faster. It wasn't until gpt-4 came out that I noticed that this AI thing should now be called AI because it was doing things that I didn't think I'd see in decades.
- simonw 2y agoI tried GPT-2 and thought it was interesting but not very useful yet. I started using GPT-3 via the playground UI for things like writing regular expressions. That's when this stuff began to get useful. I've been using GPT-4 on an almost daily basis since it came out.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoHow can anyone not see just how impactful it's going to be? Or already is? I can't think of a single recent technology that was so widely adopted by tech and non-tech people alike, immediately integrated into day-to-day experience. The rise of mobile phones and e-commerce in the 90s would be the last time I've seen this happen (I'm not counting smartphones, as those are more of an iteration). Or social media, in purely software space. I've just had GPT-4o write me a full-featured 2048 clone in ~6 hours of casual chat, in between of work, making dinner, and playing with kids; it cost me some $4 in OpenAI bills, and I didn't write a single line of code. I see non-tech people around me using ChatGPT for anything from comparison shopping to recipe adjustments. One person recently said to me that their dietitian is afraid for their career prospects because ChatGPT is already doing this job better than she is. This is a small fraction of cases in my family&friends circle; anyone who hasn't lived under the rock, or wasn't blinded by the memetic equivalent of looking at a nuclear weapon detonation, likely has a lot of similar things to say. And all of that is not will, it's is, right now.
- ryandrake 2y ago> How can anyone not see just how impactful it's going to be? Or already is? I can't think of a single recent technology that was so widely adopted by tech and non-tech people alike, immediately integrated into day-to-day experience. The rise of mobile phones and e-commerce in the 90s would be the last time I've seen this happen (I'm not counting smartphones, as those are more of an iteration). Or social media, in purely software space. You can't know this for certain until you look back on it in retrospect. We did not know mobile phones and e-commerce were going to be huge back in the 90s. We know now, of course, looking back, and the ones who guessed right back then can pat themselves on the back now. Everyone is guessing. I'll admit it's totally possible LLMs and AI are going to be as earth shattering as its boosters claim it will be, but nobody can know this now with as much certainty as is being written.
- LorenzoBloedow 2y agoI personally attribute this FOMO to so called AI influencers who love "shilling" AGI as something that's as true as 1 + 1 = 2
- tootie 2y agoI can't see any news out of Sequoia without remember how massively bullish they were on FTX.
- fragmede 2y agothey're human and were taken in by con artists. it's a reminder that none of us are infallible.
- kibwen 2y agoIt's one thing to be taken in by con artists, it's another to publicly boast about your limitless credulity and your complete and utter lack of judgment. Sequoia aren't innocent senile grandmas who got conned by high-pressure scam calls, they're gullible trend-chasing morons who were victims of their own starry-eyed greed.
- perlgeek 2y agoRemember that this is written by Venture Capital investors, and they make high risk, high reward bets. I don't know the exact numbers, but I guess only maybe 5% of all investments in a given batch make any impact on the total return. So for a VC, if there's a 10% chance that this whole AI thing will be a financial success, it's chance of success is already twice as high as average, so a pretty good bet.
- xmprt 2y agoMy rule of thumb is that if someone was super bullish on crypto 3 years ago and is now super bullish on AI then their opinion is probably not worth that much. But if they've been consistently optimistic about AI progress over the last 5-10 years then they probably know what they're talking about.
- apitman 2y agoIDK. Blockchains have been super hyped. The tech is undeniably cool. But I have yet to see an example of them solving a real problem for anyone who's not a criminal. In contrast, I've put in very little effort to use AI, but I'm noticing things. I see high quality AI-generated images in blog posts. They look awesome. I look over my coworker's shoulder and see vscode predict exactly the CSS properties and values he's looking for. Another coworker uses AI to generate a working example of FPGA code that compiles and runs on a Xilinx datacenter device. An AI assistant pops up in Facebook messenger. My girlfriend and I are immediately able to start sending each other high quality, ultra-specific inside joke AI generated memes. This has added real value to my life. I'm starting to feel FOMO, a bit worried that if I don't go hard on learning this new tool I'm going to be left in the dust. To me at least, AI feels different.
- LorenzoBloedow 2y agoI'll admit blockchains (while they may have potential for the future) don't currently have much use in the real world, but saying the only people it helps are criminals is just that old flawed argument that undermines privacy which in turn only benefits oppressors
- Ekaros 2y agoI have followed one site that has own AI generator for certain type of content... And after a while it just start to feel samey and soulless... I kinda noticed similar stylistic patterns with text generated I have seen posted... Different styles can be asked, but I wonder how soon the AI output stops feeling worth seeing or reading.
- Terr_ 2y ago> How can anyone be so certain about this? Oh, it's really simple, you see if they don't get rewarded handsomely, that proves they didn't focus on delivering true [Scotsman] value. /s
- paulmd 2y ago> just like previous technology hype cycles were surely going to Change Everything. I mean, we're seeing huge companies' entire product strategies changing overnight because We Must All Believe. this didn’t really happen the way you want it to. Fortune 50 companies never spent billions of dollars on crypto or NFTs like they are doing for AI. No NASDAQ listed companies got trillion-dollar valuations out of crypto. There is buy-in happening this time, unlike previous times, because this time actually is different. > The whole AI thing just continues to baffle me. It's like everyone is in the same trance and simply assuming and chanting over and over that This Will Change Everything I mean, some people see a broad consensus forming and reactively assume everyone else must be stupid (not like ME!). That’s a reflection of your own personal contrarianism. Instead, try to realize that a broad consensus forming means you actually hold heterodox opinions, and if you think you have a good basis for them that’s fine, but if the foundation for your point that everyone in the world is too stupid to see what’s REALLY going on then maybe your opinions aren’t as reasoned as you think they are. You need to at least understand the values differences that are leading you down the road to different conclusions before you just dismiss the whole thing as “everyone else is just too wrapped into the cult to see straight”. Bitcoin was actually rebuttable on some easily-explicable grounds as to why nobody really needed it. Why do you think semantic embeddings, semantic indexes/generation, multimodal interfaces, and computationally-tractable optimization/approximation generators are not commercially useful ideas?
- ryandrake 2y ago> Instead, try to realize that a broad consensus forming means you actually hold heterodox opinions, and if you think you have a good basis for them that’s fine, but if the foundation for your point that everyone in the world is too stupid to see what’s REALLY going on then maybe your opinions aren’t as reasoned as you think they are. I haven't even formed much of an opinion either way, yet. Sure, I have doubt, but that's more of a default than something I reasoned myself into. I'm saying it's just way too early to make statements either way about the future of LLMs and AI that are anything beyond wild guesses. "This time it's different, it's fundamentally transformative and will obviously change the world" is a religious statement when made this early.
- geph2021 2y agoWhen you think about the promise (or hype) of crypto/bitcoin/blockchain 10 years ago, in some sense it augured equally, if not more, transformative change/disruption than AI. Crypto portended drastic and fundamental changes: programmable money, disintermediation, and the decentralization of the very foundations of our society (i.e. money, banking, commerce). Suffice to say that nothing close to this has happened, and probably will never happen. So I can see how many people are equally skeptical that AI, as the next hyped transformative technology, will achieve anything near the many lofty predictions.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoWhy is there such an effort to hitch current AI to cryptocurrency? They have nothing in common, not the tech, and not the way people interact with it.
- geph2021 2y agoPeople have been comparing and contrasting successive technology innovation cycles for a long time. OP mentions railroads, but that doesn't mean there's an "effort to hitch" AI to railroads. It's just a comparison, which may or may not be useful in understanding how the latest innovation cycle may impact the world.
- postalrat 2y agoThis whole AI thing reminds me of the early 90 and people talking about how computers would change the world. Of course they were right but probably not in the ways they expected.
- ip26 2y agoI think many of the changes actually were predicted. What seems to have been the most unexpected was how it would monetize and where market power would gather. Online banking is great, and people knew it was coming since the dawn of the internet, but they mostly didn’t predict Stripe.
- ukuina 2y agoIf you go back and look at the overhyped ads back then, you'd see them describing the future that we are currently living, except tainted by some institutions that were too-ingrained; things like "Using the World Wide Web, you will be able to view your checking account balance and make a payment to your utility provider with just a few clicks!" right after someone brings the milk in. i.e., They could predict online banking but not the rise of DoorDash. Given the accelerated invention/deployment cycles we're in, it's not hard to extrapolate GPT4o to $0 token cost and 0ms latency. Even assuming stagnation in context lengths and cognition, the extreme scope of impact on every computerized industry becomes self-evident.
- michael_nielsen 2y agoThere's (at least) two meanings for AI: (1) Software systems based on extensions of the LLM paradigm; and (2) Software systems capable of all human cognitive tasks, and then some. It's not yet clear what (1) has to do with (2). Maybe it turns out that LLMs or similar can do (2). And maybe not. I can understand being skeptical about the economic value of (1). But the economic value of (2) seems obviously enormous, almost certainly far more than all value created by humanity to date.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoI think they've tapped into something fundamental about knowledge, the mind, and information and this is only the beginning. How many different ways are there to train, wire these up, and integrate with other systems? Then the silicon built for it...I just don't know where the horizon is.
- root_axis 2y agoTransformers clearly represent a significant advancement in software design, this is undeniable. For example, LLMs are so good at language translation that every approach to machine translation ever conceived of is now obsolete by a very large margin. There are a few other examples and certainly some new ones will emerge, so the tech is good and it's here to stay. The question of "how do we make money from it" is a much harder to answer. Using every available computer to run quadratic time brute force on everything you can scrape from the internet is an unbounded resource sink that offers little practical return for almost everybody, but leveraging modest and practical use of generative machine learning where it works well will absolutely create some real value.
- epolanski 2y agoI can't summarize it better than saying that AI hype is deserved, but the excessive euphoria and FOMO are not.
- wayeq 2y agoYou know I hear ChatGPT is pretty good at summarizing.
- danans 2y ago>> A huge amount of economic value is going to be created by AI. Company builders focused on delivering value to end users will be rewarded handsomely. > Such strong speculative predictions about the future, with no evidence. The speculation makes sense from a VC's perspective, but perhaps not from the perspective of society at large (i.e. human workers). From the revenue-generating use cases of LLMs (== AI in the article) that I've seen so far, most seem to be about replacing human mental labor with LLMs. The replacement of workers with AI-based machines will likely happen in mature industries whose market growth is basically capped. Productivity will stay mostly the same, but the returns will increase dramatically as the human workforce is hollowed out. To the extent that AI instead empowers some workers to multiply their productivity with the same amount of effort, then it can create more economic value overall, and this may happen in industries with a long growth runway ahead. On balance, it's not clear to me whether the growth (in productivity and employment) that comes from the latter will be enough to offset the employment losses from the former. But in either scenario, the VCs investing in AI win, either from efficiency gains, or from accelerating growth in new industries.
- rsynnott 2y agoThey’re a _VC_. If they don’t believe in it, what are they even doing? You can’t really expect them to be particularly objective about it.
- from-nibly 2y agoIts because it has to. We're so far behind the 8 ball at this point if it doesn't work we are all screwed. All of society is so freaking leveraged at this point, something has to give.
- pas 2y ago> society is so freaking leveraged can you elaborate on this? in what sense?
- ukuina 2y agoI think they're implying AI has too much investment behind it to implode (i.e., it's "too big to fail").
- from-nibly 2y agoNot just AI. AI is just the latest in hopeful technologies to get us out of this debt rut we are in. Every time something fails to get us out it drags us deeper in.
- SoftTalker 2y ago$35T in national debt for one. At some point that house of cards is going to collapse.
- pas 2y ago... why would it? there's no magical limit, not even to debt-to-GDP ratio. as long as the state can collect taxes it can service debt. during WW2 it was also this high. the US economy is still growing. and inflation is around 3%. not the usual target 2, but it's crazy good considering the recent pandemic and land-war-in-europe "situation". eventually spending has to decrease ... or taxation to increase (US tax to GDP ratio is around 27% while OECD average is around 34%) ... and the US demographic stats are looking much better than a lot of countries'. the feeling of impending doom is definitely not great, but it's a (social) media phenomenon.
- jiggawatts 2y agoDon’t assume “widespread deployment of the same”. Think about next-gen models running faster and at a low cost. They already understand spoken English and can respond in kind. This is Siri or Alexa on steroids. Just that alone is a “killer app” for everyone with a mobile phone or a home assistant device! What’s the addressable market for that right now? Five billion customers? Six or seven maybe? Computer RPG games are about to become completely different. You’ll be able to actually converse with characters. Etc… I’m a short-term pessimist but a long-term optimist. This all reminds me of 3D graphics a in the early 1990s. The nerds were impressed but nobody else thought it was interesting. Now we have Pixar and a computer games industry bigger than Hollywood.
- mechagodzilla 2y agoSiri and Alexa are good examples - they turned out to be incredibly expensive to develop and had extremely limited productivity benefits for users, while being almost impossible to monetize.
- jiggawatts 2y agoThat's... my point. You're agreeing with me. Siri and Alexa are bad. Very, very bad. They pretend to understand spoken English, but they don't, because they're just a huge set of hard-coded rules written out one-at-a-time by enormous numbers of very expensive developers. This is the 1990s approach to AI: Fuzzy logic, heuristics, solvers, dynamic programming, etc... That approach has been thoroughly blown out of the water by Transformers, which does all of that and much more with a thousand lines of code that can be banged out in a couple of hours by one guy while talking in a YouTube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kCc8FmEb1nY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kCc8FmEb1nY Transformers will revolutionise this entire space, and more that don't even exist yet as a market. Take for example humanoid robots: Boston Dynamics has had the hardware working well enough for a decade, but not the software. You can't walk up to one of their robots, point at something, and tell the robot to complete a task. It can't understand what it is seeing, and can't understand English instructions. Programming that in with traditional AI methods would take man-millenia of effort, and might never work well enough. If we could speed up GPT-4o (the one with vision) to just 10x or 50x its current speed, with some light fine-tuning it could control a humanoid robot right now with a level of understanding comparable to C3P0 from Star Wars!
- tim333 2y agoImagine looking back on the earth's history from a billion years in the future. There will be a divide around now between a few billion years before when biological life was the most advanced thing going on and after that when AI life was. It's in a different category to the other tech hypes. And I don't really see any possible way that it won't happen(?)
- p1esk 2y agoI don’t think anyone doubts that. The question is when exactly do we get to human level intelligence on all tasks (agi)? Is it going to be GPT5? GPT6? Or has the performance improvements saturated already? It makes a huge difference in terms of your investment and even career decisions whether you expect it to happen next year or 10 years from now.
- tim333 2y agoFair enough although some people do doubt it. I guess zooming in AI will gradually exceed human abilities in different areas like it's already much better at chess and still rubbish at going down to the shop to get a pint of milk. I'm not sure how the plays into ten year investment and career plans. There's probably a lot of opportunity at the moment for startups to take ChatGPTs abilities and apply them to human tasks involving written language.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- avereveard 2y agoThink about all the high volume processes in the enterprise world with a expensive human fallback. Llm are great after the process and before the human to reduce tasks routed to the fallback. Think about all human involved in producing unstructured document that people have to read like public councils, court of laws, teachers or other evaluators. Llm can be given a relevancy metric and flag content so that those in need of or waiting for a certain information aren't drowned in noise Llm are unlocking digital transformation in sectors that have been historically resistant to it, and because they are goal driven they do it with minimal programming, just a few good prompts and a data pipeline. And it's just the tip. They don't get tired, they don't forget nor omit, they are absolutely bonkers to find relevant products and services given a database a need and a set of preferences and they will transform how the next generation will make purchasing decisions, travel decision and all these opinion based choices. And while llm are likely not the path to agi and they will cap out in capabilities at some point, they are coming down in price super fast, which will propel adoption even for those cases where other options would be more sensible, just because of the sheer convenience of just asking them to do stuff.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]