16 ms·
Why YC went to DC
- rwasco 2y ago[flagged]
- 7e 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hn8305823 2y agoIf you are going to play the founders game (get rich slow, then all of a sudden), then you should not be surprised by the slow and painful part.
- tptacek 2y agoNo, you cannot craft an exploitation narrative out of tech startup founders. We have to draw the line somewhere. Say their directors of engineering and customer success are suffering under the lash of founders and investors, fine, but not one level of seniority higher than that.
- datadrivenangel 2y agoSame reason we all do: lobbying.
- AlexErrant 2y ago> Open source AI models allow for greater transparency, collaboration, and innovation by making the underlying code publicly accessible and modifiable. I feel like open models do virtually nothing for transparency, collaboration, or innovation, and are only modifiable in that they can be fine-tuned. It's "open source" training processes and data that will lead to "transparency, collaboration, and innovation", and I'm unaware of any large company that does this. Am I wrong?
- dbish 2y agoCorrect. Worse is that there are models being touted as "open source" that don't allow for a bunch of different uses and specify their own custom licensing (look at what Falcon originally had, Meta's models with specific commercial carveouts, etc.), we need an rms of the new age to call these fake OSS approaches out as they feel more like they are being done to get the OSS marketing shine, without actually being free and open. Your "source" is not open nor is it transparent if training code, original dataset, model architecture details, and training methodology are not all there.
- Xunjin 2y agoAs someone layman in that field I do agree with you, would love inputs from specialists in the area.
- lolinder 2y agoYou're correct if you're focused exclusively on the work surrounding building foundation models to begin with. But if you take a broader view, having open models that we can legally fine tune and hack with locally has created a large and ever-growing community of builders and innovators that could not exist without these open models. Just take a look at projects like InvokeAI [0] in the image space or especially llama.cpp [1] in the text generation space. These projects are large, have lots of contributors, move very fast, and drive a lot of innovation and collaboration in applying AI to various domains in a way that simply wouldn't be possible without the open models. [0] https://github.com/invoke-ai/InvokeAI https://github.com/invoke-ai/InvokeAI [1] https://github.com/ggerganov/llama.cpp https://github.com/ggerganov/llama.cpp
- no_wizard 2y agoTaking the broader view of this nature feels like an attempt to change the narrative. The entire point of having transparency is around building those foundations so they don’t inherit the biases of humans, for starters. Right now, we have zero introspection into this and no ability to improve upon it with the widely deployed models being used today, and that has already created problematic situations, let alone situations that are problematic and not known yet. Transparency around this is a very good thing to prevent AI from inheriting negative human ideas and biases, and broadens access to improve training data that benefits everyone
- siliconc0w 2y agoIf you need more things to fix: * Software R&D Amortization - taxes on make-believe profits * Patent law - protect small businesses from patent trolls * Automate government-driven compliance standards - enable small businesses to sell into large companies/government entities, automatic certification when using pre-approved cloud solutions. * Healthcare insurance - employees of SMBs automatically get access to medicare
- superfrank 2y agoCan you remind me what the issue with software R&D amortization (or point me to something that explains it)? I remember reading about the issue in the past and thinking it was a problem, but I've forgotten all the details.
- romanhn 2y agoI assume they're referring to Section 174 changes. Here's a primer: https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/section-174 https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/section-174
- singleshot_ 2y agoThis seems like a very strange take on 174. The author seems to be saying that all developer expenses can be expensed under old 174, but that’s not true (under my reading). My take was that exclusively research and development - where you are unsure of the outcome - is eligible under old 174. Notice the analysis of big companies and their tax bills. Author notes that Google only expensed software development expenses until the software met some qualification threshold. After that, it’s not research anymore. What am I missing?
- throwaway5959 2y agoFrom what I understand a lot could be classified as R&D. More than one would think.
- reducesuffering 2y ago> to disastrous effects, in the form of social media harms > There are many reasons to be optimistic about AI Without a modicum of awareness. Paul G [0] and Sam Altman both have recognized the potential dangers.[1] [0] https://x.com/paulg/status/1651613807779667968 https://x.com/paulg/status/1651613807779667968 [1] https://blog.samaltman.com/machine-intelligence-part-1 https://blog.samaltman.com/machine-intelligence-part-1
- alexfromapex 2y agoIt was funny how the closing statement was admiring rugged individualism too when that philosophy is encouraging a lot of the damaging effects similar to how social media has been harming the world.
- simonw 2y agoThis new essay by Jack Clark, who was at OpenAI when they made the decision not to release GPT-2 for safety reasons five years ago, feels relevant: https://importai.substack.com/p/import-ai-375-gpt-2-five-years-later https://importai.substack.com/p/import-ai-375-gpt-2-five-yea... > [...] history shows that once we assign power to governments, they're loathe to subsequently give that power back to the people. Policy is a ratchet and things tend to accrete over time. That means whatever power we assign governments today represents the floor of their power in the future - so we should be extremely cautious in assigning them power because I guarantee we will not be able to take it back.
- ralegh 2y agoWell said, also applies to many human dynamics - friendships, relationships, work relationships, etc. Ceding power is a ratchet and you either put your foot down to start with or it grinds away.
- redserk 2y agoHard disagree. Healthy relationships include negotiating when potential boundaries are in question, or if things change that require re-aligning boundaries. It's reasonable to give more to the other party from time-to-time, and reasonable to discuss with the other party if it becomes a point where it feels unfair. Instead we (Americans) take an unnecessarily adversarial stance against what our government could do, ensuring it is perpetually unprepared.
- LeafItAlone 2y ago> Healthy relationships In reality, the vast majority of relationships aren’t actually healthy in this way. Most people get that only from their parent and family, if that. So parent’s advice is important.
- JohnFen 2y ago> the vast majority of relationships aren’t actually healthy in this way The vast majority? I'd love to see data backing that claim up.
- mrb 2y ago"This year, we’ll fund more than 500 companies out of 50,000 applications, and almost all of them are related to AI in some way." So, what this means: that in 2024, if you want to get VC capital, your startup must be related to AI.
- candiddevmike 2y agoIt's like VR in 2018. I'd love to see a Silicon Valley season for the current tech environment.
- jrockway 2y agoI think 2018 was the year of FinTech, which translates mostly to "altcoins". I was looking for a job in the summer of 2018 and that's what all the ads were for. Ended up working for an ISP though, which was nice.
- pram 2y agoHaven’t seen any “Web 3” shills for a long time, gone right out of style it has!
- jrockway 2y agoEveryone spent the cash they were going to invest into startups on NFTs, I guess.
- reducesuffering 2y agoDidn't stop YC from funding almost 100 of them[0] including signal boosting[1] this obvious scam that blatantly ripped off another's website and company too.[2] [0] https://www.ycombinator.com/companies?tags=Crypto%20%2F%20Web3 https://www.ycombinator.com/companies?tags=Crypto%20%2F%20We... [1] https://x.com/ycombinator/status/1517556338750074881?lang=en https://x.com/ycombinator/status/1517556338750074881?lang=en [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31686140 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31686140
- 2y ago
- eganist 2y agoI was hopeful YC coming to DC would've meant YC would've been tapping into DC's startup scene. Wishful thinking. Linked is the more common reason (lobbying), but I'm looking forward to more institutions recognizing the talent we have in the DC region.
- tptacek 2y agoThere's talent in every region, and I think it should be a priority to figure out ways to unlock it without re-siting companies in SFBA and NYC, but it's worth noting here that YC's SFBA-centricity is not an outcome of their belief that there's no talent outside SFBA. It's the opposite: they assume they're importing that talent to the area. The YC SFBA thing is about network effects from companies working in close proximity, and about the investor market (1) believing the same thing and (2) having themselves an even more significant network effect that keeps them all in the same area.
- FactKnower69 2y agowoah, locking your investments into a single geographic area, how innovative and forward thinking! especially for a tech company! I really hope nothing bad happens that reduces the value of in-person networking or shared commercial office space, or God forbid someone invents a gadget that lets people work from places other than where they live
- tptacek 2y agoYou don't have to like it, and it doesn't have to rationalize with whatever your conception of how innovation works is. I don't like San Francisco either. My point is that you have to at least engage with the SFBA argument that YC is making. I work for a large-ish all-remote YC company in which none of the founders live in the Bay Area (or in the same city, for that matter). People have some odd ideas of how YC actually works.
- stackskipton 2y agoAs someone who was in DC area but isn't any more, talent in DC area is not anything to write home about. We have a ton of talent on paper because government requires gobs of tech workers and prefers they have advanced degrees but since it's just boring enterprise work, the spark of innovation is snuffed out quickly. Most of startups in the area are catering to the government. There are already VC/PE/Startup accelerators more equipped for the unique market.
- willsmith72 2y agolittle tech? i don't buy it. the entire point of YC is growth
- dang 2y agoGrowth starts little.
- dredmorbius 2y agoSave for elephants and blue whales ;-)
- dbish 2y agoIt is interesting that you have current YC head lobbying for small and open, while previous lobbies for large and private and is a big driver in why the government wants to regulate so much already. Thought experiment, if YC had not allowed for or jump started OpenAI would they even have to be lobbying now for openness and “little tech” (at least for AI side of things)? Is this the appropriate saying now https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoist_with_his_own_petard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoist_with_his_own_petard
- zh3 2y agoSomewhat with you on this one, I assumed the title was YC (being big tech) were upping their lobbying game - it was after reading it that I came to your point of view.
- gpsx 2y agoI am assuming YC will be lobbying on their own interests, which, at least for typical VCs is getting some of their small companies to go big, rather than promoting success among all their companies. They probably won't be lobbying for the companies that do not get/take VC funding, which are the less capatilized ones that probably need more representation. And, their interests with go big or go bust doesn't always align with the funded companies' interests, since optimizing for their portfolio of many is different from optimizing for the founders' portifolio of one.
- kemitchell 2y agoThe line about being the voice of "little tech" rubbed me pretty hard the wrong way. Nothing's stopping me or my clients from contacting senators, reps, and regulators, joining political organizations, or signing open letters. We have our own voices. Some of us know enough to use them. It's hard to tell what, exactly, the position on "open source AI" was. It's presented here in glittering generalities. Given the many conversations I've had on-theme with not-public-tech-co people, I don't think it's fair to say all of "little tech" has one view or position, when you really get down to details. I rather doubt the whole YC-o-Verse sees it all one way, either, given its burgeoning size. More broadly, I'd expect positioning off as "little tech" to flop. Policy players know how to follow the money. They know "Big Tech" brings the money that buys startups—they've read about it in exec summaries of the committee reports. They're also plenty aware that startups get founded by, and recruit from, a lot of the same pools of people. They've been lobbied by various policy groups speaking for smaller tech companies, often funded by the bigger tech companies, for years. If they dig just a little bit, they'll see the barriers to entry, and resulting big-co dependencies, for small-cos doing AI work. There's bipartisan support for "going after Big Tech" competition-wise. I don't think the pols need a tech-co splinter group as reinforcement there. Unless and until IPO becomes the main path of successful ascent again—perpetually private isn't popular—I don't have great arguments against generalizing startups to Big Tech Farm League. There are plenty of gripes up from startups against the Great Houses, especially from investors. But that's feudalism for you. Compare, say, DHH's lobbying. 37signals had the Bezos investment, but it was an unusual deal, not within the usual system. Speaking from a different place.
- Bjorkbat 2y agoI'm tempted to be cynical about this, especially since me and Garry Tan really don't seem to have the same political alignment, but I'm honestly pretty glad this happened. The tech community (outside of big tech) ought to be more politically active rather than complain when senile politicians get behind a law that doesn't make sense. I want to say there are about as many software developers in the US as there are farmers, and yet the latter has enormous political power, while we have virtually none. I mean, imagine if we could get the federal government to subsidize us in the same way it subsidizes corn farmers. Don't get me wrong, I kind of fear what laws and legislation a tech voting bloc would pass, but I'm also optimistic that we could push forward some genuinely progressive legislation as well. Maybe we could pass laws that encourage more housing development. Perhaps some bureaucratic reforms similar to the ones that occurred in Estonia, the kind that result in major cost reductions without any loss in quality of service. Universal healthcare? Those slightly strange policy ideas we like to talk about that are clearly progressive, even "socialist", but are also palatable to libertarians? Mixed feelings about lobby for open source AI, but nonetheless, glad it happened. Hope to see more of it.
- doron 2y agoIt's well and good to advocate for change within the industry (large and small) but realistically, all of this is missing the forest for trees, or equating symptom with the cause. The only way out of this long term, is to take money out of politics, repeal citizens united, revolving doors and other methods of lining politicians' pockets.
- HideousKojima 2y ago>repeal citizens united So you think it should be illegal to make documentaries critical of Hillary Clinton? Because that's what Citizens United was about, but most people who are against Citizens United don't seem to understand what the case was actually about.
- whimsicalism 2y agoI'm pretty unsure about CU, but the context is the film was created by a political action committee to get standing so they could challenge election law, it's not like they were a bona-fide commercial film-maker (which is why the FEC blocked the film in the first place)
- downrightmike 2y agoYou don't even get it.
- whimsicalism 2y agoIt is frankly challenging to reconcile 1st amendment protections and a CU repeal. I'm not sure what the solution is, but think recent events should show that govt can abuse campaign finance law to pick winners and losers in the town square.
- ethbr1 2y ago> It is frankly challenging to reconcile 1st amendment protections and a CU repeal. I'm not sure what the solution is, [...] Reconciliation: Companies aren't human entities. Non-human entities aren't entitled to 1st amendment protections. Campaign finance is equally simple: run your campaign on public funding. Give all candidates who meet a threshold equal amounts of money. I have yet to hear a convincing argument about what benefit a democracy receives from campaigns having different amounts of funding. That feels like the tail wagging the dog (your supporters fund you, so you can spend that money to buy more supporters).
- probably_wrong 2y agoApologies for the negative tone: > First, let’s prioritize open source models and more tailored AI applications to shape the competitive landscape and create real opportunities for startups. How does YC square this statement with the fact that their ex-president closed their models with the explicit intention of slowing down competitors [1]? Or is the argument "we want politicians to discourage people like us from doing what we did"? [1] https://www.theverge.com/2023/3/15/23640180/openai-gpt-4-launch-closed-research-ilya-sutskever-interview https://www.theverge.com/2023/3/15/23640180/openai-gpt-4-lau...
- jrockway 2y agoI mean, they parted ways long ago, and pg released a statement recently as to the nature of that breakup. People and organizations can change their mind.
- probably_wrong 2y agoYes. But AFAIK the official reason for the breakup was "we wanted him to pick a lane" and not "we disagreed with his defintion of the word 'open'". I cannot say whether YC changed their mind because I don't know what their mind is. Therefore I commented with the hope of an official answer.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- avarun 2y agoLink to said statement?
- probably_wrong 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40521657 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40521657
- threeseed 2y ago
- sneak 2y ago> We need decisive action to compel more interoperability by the largest firms and curb self-preferencing so we restore competition and innovation, similar to measures called for in the American Innovation and Choice Online Act that Big Tech lobbying killed at the eleventh hour in 2021. At the end of the day, we need an open and neutral app ecosystem where consumers and developers can maintain a direct relationship. Cure this, and the rest will follow. Two companies gating access to the app market is what is destroying competition at its core.
- islewis 2y ago> First, let’s prioritize open source models and more tailored AI applications to shape the competitive landscape and create real opportunities for startups My read on this is YC believes that small companies will (are?) be locked out of the AI arms race, and are pushing for legal action to hold the door open for them. Pushing disruptive technologies has made YC insane hoards of wealth- the fact that they feel like they need government intervention for this to continue is scary. It feels like a canary in the coal mine in regards to who is in control of AI's future.
- lmeyerov 2y agoHe is referring to laws like SB1047 that will make open source model makers liable for who uses them, and may scare companies like Meta from releasing any more. E.g., preventing the release of llama 3 400b, which might be the first GPT4-grade OSS release. Locked out maybe, but more about 'not closing the door' vs 'keeping the door open'.
- zer00eyz 2y ago> And finally, we need more steps like the FTC’s recent move to ban all employee noncompetes (no carve outs, no limitations, no exceptions). YOU need to be out there beating the drum for a major exception to this. With out laws to ban raiding (and we dont have those on the federal level) this is a bad policy. It means that google doesn't have to aquire-hire your team, they can just poach all of them wholesale. > Second, we need to prioritize forceful remedies to foster competition If history does show us something its that outside a pure monopoly (ATT) these business have a shelf life. Roll the clock back 60 years, US Steel had the same market share as apple. ATT was a thing (and as a monopoly got smacked). But no one talks about GE or IBM or RCA as major players in tech... and they were tech giants of their day. I am all for restrictions on these sorts of enterprises. But the bigger major step we can take is taxing them appropriately, not letting them all get the pass they have. Shift the tax burden to the largest players and you make room at the bottom and solve a host of other issues. As for the rest of these proposals, it sounds like a lot of bureaucracy. I feel like we need to revisit our history and re-read our Orwell desperately, were literally repeating the mistakes of the past.
- whimsicalism 2y agoI would strongly oppose any governmental attempt to ban poaching/cold-calling and would see it as a blatant power grab for owners against workers. If you want to retain your team, match the offer.
- worik 2y agoNo thanks. (I am not in the USA, I am in a country where on-competes must be paid for and short) Exemptions and carve out will be used for (and politically paid for, with the mind bending official bribery system the USA runs in politics) by the powerful to consolidate their power. Small firms have a lot of power over their employees. Small firms have to give their employees a reason to work for them, money is part of the picture, and small companies have to be well capitalised to pay competitive salaries. But small companies need to be places people want to work. Giving employees the power to contract an employee into not quitting is a recipe for very bad behaviour. In my experience the best and the worst employers are small firms. We need more of the best and fewer of the worst, laws that incentivise being bad do not help
- temptemptemp111 2y ago[dead]
- luma 2y agoWhy should healthcare be tied to employment? "Quit fucking around" and institute a national, single-payer plan that covers everyone, like every other modern industrialized country.
- bumby 2y ago>"Quit fucking around" and institute a national, single-payer plan that covers everyone, like every other modern industrialized country. Except we're not starting from a blank slate. So short of heavy-handed, dictatorial decisions how would you propose to get to a single-payer plan that covers everyone? You'll have to work with the existing hospital infrastructure, insurance companies, and citizens who don't want a single-payer system. They all get a say, too. People who act like its a straightforward solution don't really understand the problem. But to avoid sounding overly cynical, I'll throw out a couple of recommendations. 1) Expand the VA system to cover all vets, regardless of whether it's a service-connected health issue or not, without insurance. This is politically possibly the easiest step because its hard for a politician to stand up and say they aren't an advocate for better care for the troops. However, the VA is entwined with medical schools and you'd have ensure you expand the funding proportionately to avoid pissing off that constituency. 2) Gradually ratchet down the age for medicare, over decades. (I'd also argue you'd have to get money out of politics first for any really change to have a chance)
- luma 2y ago3) Medicare for all, starting today. Stroke of a pen I just fixed everything. > existing hospital infrastructure Hospitals already deal with medicare. > insurance companies Oh no the vultures in the system will go hungry whatever shall we do > citizens who don't want a single-payer system Buy premium insurance above and beyond the public option, same as every other modern industrialized country. If you don't like the offering for free, the market can cover whatever gap exists.
- bumby 2y agoIgnoring that a “stroke of the pen” is a dictatorial solution almost by definition… Considering Medicare/Medicaid are currently approaching $1T annually to serve less than 20% of the population how dues your stroke of the pen plan pay for the increase when everyone is enrolled? Hospitals are forced to accept Medicare, but in many cases this is at a loss, subsidized by private charges elsewhere. So you’ll need to find out how to shore up that cost, too. These types of naive solutions assume everyone else is very very stupid or very very corrupt (or else why didn’t such a simple solution get implemented already?)
- rurp 2y agoI'm not sure what I was expecting, but I had a surprisingly positive reaction to this piece. It will be hard to avoid, but I think that preventing GenAI from turning into yet another tech oligopoly is hugely important. For one, it absolutely will stifle innovation if one or a few companies can control the market. Just look at what Google has done with their money printing monopoly money over the past decade. Competition will be doubly important if modern AI can fullfill much of the current hype. That kind of power in the hands of a sophisticated used car salesman like Sam Altman will be bad in so many ways.
- xyst 2y ago> This country is built on the idea of rugged individualism, ingenuity, and grit. > It’s also built on the idea of equal opportunity Anybody else get “out of touch” vibes from this post?
- SOLAR_FIELDS 2y agoI didn’t even get to that point, I got that when Tan referred to himself as a representative of “little tech”
- JohnFen 2y agoYeah, that was where I got off the PR train, too.
- xyst 2y agoyea, definitely some narcissism in the post. Very off putting. Have very little confidence this is going to do anything. But I really hope I’m wrong and we get it right, this time.
- dbmikus 2y agoI would consider YC a pretty clear representative of "little tech", albeit little tech with startup/hyperscale ambitions. So, IMO it's not out of touch, it's very on-point.
- Affric 2y agoGreat call out. Who can claim with a straight face the USA was built on the idea of equal opportunity. Who would say that country that sprang from the metropolises of the east were built on individualism? This kind of capital-C conservative appeal to the past is a political signal to light a fire under the Dems and court Republicans. Not that you’d expect such a statement to turn into a truth telling commission or a treatise on the evolution of the United States but it’s interesting it was brought up.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- preinheimer 2y agoWhat about prioritizing paying the people who made the content these models are using without consent?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- reducesuffering 2y agoRemember when YC leadership yelled on Twitter about how DC should have more regulation and should guarantee FDIC funds past 250k for wealthy VC's and startups when their Silicon Valley Bank collapsed? This obviously had the effect of entrenching large banks, because people now know that big banks are too-big-to-fail and have infinite FDIC insurance, while the little guys can kick rocks because they're not systemic enough. So they effectively lobbied for big financial business. Now they want to lobby for less regulation of their own industry in favor of the little guy? Personally, I'm a more principled libertarian-leaning type than "government for me, free market for thee."
- omskrin 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- austin-cheney 2y agoI call bullshit. YC is not interested in fixing any of these problem despite their words and actions. Real solutions are bitter pills to this industry, poison pills to investors and venture capitalists. The two universal solutions that work for every other industry: * Liability * Licensing When I say liability and I mean both personal liability, as in suing the developer(s) for harms of the software, as well as business liability. When I say licensing I do not mean product licensing. I mean human professional licensing. There is an astonishing lack of professionalism and ethics in software. None of this is fixed with band-aids or wishful thinking. Go directly to the problem: the money funnel and the often absurd absence of competence. Yes, this is scary. Get over it. You cannot both be an entitled child free from the harms of the world and simultaneously be absent from the harms that result. The upside, though, is that increased risk and liability, in financial and compensatory terms, means fewer people doing the work each owning a fair share of the rewards that otherwise just go to investors and not even as dividends.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AlbertCory 2y agoThis article is light on organizational and financial details. You don't just go to DC once, have some meetings, and announce what has to be done, if you're serious. You open a permanent office, meet with people on the Hill regularly, and spread campaign contributions around liberally. DC is crawling with people whose life it is to help you do that. Just drive around Chevy Chase and see all the luxury shops catering to those people. Is that slimy and disgusting? You bet it is.
- kemitchell 2y agoThere's a not entirely rigorous, but empirically weighty analogy here to Silicon Valley. Why don't startups just fly into SFO, rent an AirBnB for a few days, hit Sand Hill Road, and split back to wherever overhead is cheaper?
- AlbertCory 2y ago> empirically weighty analogy "Empirically" how? in SV, the idea is that you can hire people to do almost anything a growing company needs. That's true in DC as well, but it's also that the important people who can decide your future are there and continually meeting with your enemies. "If you're not at the table, you're on the menu." they like to say.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoThis PR blurb does not make any sense; YC is not interested in "little tech" that wants to stay little. YC are the ones that promoted the idea of "unicorns". YC needs these "little tech" companies to execute on ridiculous levels of non-linear "growth" to deliver a grossly inflated expected return on meagre investment. This led to the "growth hacking" nonsense that everyone was complaining about. It is absurd to pretend that YC is on the side of "little tech". YC is only interested in companies that will grow large and deliver an enormous return. PG loves people like Zuckerberg and basically stated he wished all founders were similarly sociopathic^Wambitious. "Lifestyle" software/web companies that stay small can be a good thing. Perhaps they could deliver much better than "Big Tech" if they had the chance; thanks to Silicon Valley VC greed and "Big Tech" anti-competitive practices we are prevented from knowing. YC is after "unicorns" not lifestyle or other small companies. The "success stories" YC pitches are companies like Dropbox and AirBnB. This is the furthest thing from "little tech".
- jrflowers 2y agoThe e/acc guy that drunkenly posts about how he wants his political enemies to die slow has decided that he’s needed in national politics? Color me astounded! https://missionlocal.org/2024/01/garry-tan-death-wish-sf-supervisors/ https://missionlocal.org/2024/01/garry-tan-death-wish-sf-sup... https://missionlocal.org/2024/01/y-combinator-ceo-garry-tans-online-rant-spurs-threat-to-supe-police-reports/ https://missionlocal.org/2024/01/y-combinator-ceo-garry-tans... https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/sf-garry-tan-x-threatening-peskin-police-report-18637813.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/sf-garry-tan-x-threat...
- EGreg 2y agoBig Tech has been allowed to operate with little scrutiny or oversight — to disastrous effects, in the form of social media harms, anti competitive practices, and more. Despite recent efforts to rein them in, a small handful of mega companies continue to wield enormous power in our economy and in Washington Garry, I’m a bit confused. I totally agree with the sentiment, but isn’t YC part of the whole machine? Seed funding to VC to Wall Street IPO exit to big billion dollar corporation? Sam Altman is a product of YC culture, he ran the place, same as you do now. I wanted to join YC in the past 12 years and applied multiple times. We never made it to the interview, but I have gotten an outsider’s perspective on the industry and the root causes of the problems you currently really want to solve with government. Instead what if I told you YC under YOUR leadership can solve them worldwide and far better? Hear me out… Peter Thiel who invested the first $500K into Facebook famously taught that “competition is for losers, build a monopoly”, and I imagine the lessons to capture and extract maximum value from the ecosystem for shareholders has affected many founders, including Mark Z: https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-losers-1410535536 https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-... Mark Zuckerberg was an open source guy on the east coast. He open sourced Synapse instead of selling it to Microsoft. He wanted to make Wirehog, a peer to peer file sharing system, but Sean Parker and the VCs “put a bullet in that thing”. I was there at TC Disrupt in NY where Parker proudly told the story: https://techcrunch.com/2010/05/26/wirehog/ https://techcrunch.com/2010/05/26/wirehog/ Sean Parker himself learned that lesson bitterly when his company disrupted a different but similar industry that was about owning and monetizing intellectual property - RIAA, MPAA, etc. After Napster was defeated he opened Plaxo and learned to play the “correct game”. He wanted to make sure Mark didn’t follow his open sensibilities too far, letting the public share stuff too freely, because shareholders need profit! We are LUCKY that Mark Z still retains some of his original open source sensibilities because his company has been the only one giving away models trained for large amounts of money, to the community. Ok maybe Llama research edition leaked but they OWNED that thing, and became to openness what Apple is to privacy. I mean when Silicon Valley Bank collapsed (set off by the same Peter Thiel), we found out that most VCs even banked at the same bank! There has been a LOT of centralization. https://www.laweekly.com/restoring-healthy-communities/ https://www.laweekly.com/restoring-healthy-communities/ This article goes into more depth than my post can, about how the incentives to enrich shareholders leads not just to enshittification of their own ecosystem but surveillance capitalism, and generally externalizing cost to society. Across the board! Teen girls have highest rates of depression. Adult men are on opiates and 20% of middle-aged women are on antidepressants. Elderly are in nursing homes and kids are in public schools (which pg once compared to prisons) and medicated for ADHD to sit still while their parents work long hours with less and less job certainty. Some even just do the gig economy, while Instacart ir Uber collects HALF of every driver’s fare for its shareholders! Our society is perpetually angry now because algorithms select for more engagement, and it turns out clickbait and outrage maximizes it even more than sex. So the market selects for one sided stories that evoke outrage, and publishers pick an audience to pander to. While social network algorithms produce echo chambers and radicalization. And this is before we get to any AI bot swarms. I believe there is ONE WEIRD TRICK that YC can do to help society at large A LOT over the next decade. I would like to see a way to transition shareholders organically to utility tokenholders before the public offering. Kind of like the differenc between Disney Dollars and shares of Disney Corp. Disney’s shareholders don’t live in Disneyworld and thus dont have the incentives that customers and workers do. They become an everpresent landlord class extracting rents forever, holding earnings calls even after the original investors had sold their shares. Same with other ecosystems. The founders don’t need THAT machine necessarily, to be handsomely rewarded to the tune of billions of dollars and have the startups become worldwide movements that serve humanity. YC and VCs could still have their exits while preventing the parasitic rent extraction from getting out of control post-IPO. YC being upstream of most VCs could operate a HUGE lever, and like Archimedes, could move the world towards a better system, as you once did with SAFE notes! That’s would solve a lot of the incentive problems without the need for heavy-handed government regulation! Two years ago, a different very ambitious and politically connected Sam — Sam Bankman Fried - also went around begging for his space to be regulated. But the incentives inherent in shareholder profits (instead of stakeholder accounting) and competition (instead of cooperation) are what leads to negative externalities, in many ways, and that includes pollution, ecosystem collapse, factory farms and much more. You guys can consider introducing that one SMALL change — transitioning shares to utility tokens gradually. I would be very happy to come meet and explain more if it is of any interest. Just reply to my message and let me know how to reach out if you see potential here. PS: In addition to utility tokens, open source and protocols help create maximum value for the world, through collaboration over competition. For decades, the US government wielded its mighty antitrust regulations over Ma Bell and the phone companies it split them into. And yet long distance calls were still $3 a minute. Then, VOIP open protocols democratized the pipes and turned the telcos into dumb replaceable infrastructure. It was open protocols that brought the cost of not just calls but video and broadcasting down to near-zero, something government couldn’t do. Wikipedia beat Britannica. The Web beat AOL and all closed systems. I could go on, but open and free beats closed in the end, AND each open platform (Linux, the Web, etc) leads to far more wealth creation than when gatekeepers extract rents. That’s another aspect. And meanwhile, since 2014 people have discovered that utility tokens can help to monetize open source and digital content including journalism, in healthier ways than ads and surveillance capitalism. As my VC friend Albert Wenger from Union Square ventures wrote a book along the same lines: https://worldaftercapital.org https://worldaftercapital.org
- OoTheNigerian 2y ago"5,000 startups from nearly every state in the US" I am curious to know which States in the US still do not have any companies in YC.
- nah4 2y ago[flagged]
- zoobab 2y ago"let’s prioritize open source models" Without published open source data, it will be hard to call those models open source.
- zoobab 2y agos/open source data/open source training data/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- temp20240604 2y agoTo lobby for things good for YC :-) which happen to also be good things in general.
- ThinkBeat 2y agoI would think that the biggest obstacles for small startups in the AI space is the expense and availability of suitable hardware. Then the expense of the electricity itself. Big Cloud companies, who are also AI companies, with huge wallets have a huge advantage to start with. The regular answer is of course go to the cloud, which is by far the easiest approach. I would think the cost of intense "AI compute" over a long timespan in the cloud is really expensive as well. And you are paying your competitors for your work. If any of that is correct, which it might not be, then building the initial models would cost more than a startup couldl afford. You can also go to the cloud and used "AI APIs" usually proprietary in one way or another to the cloud vendors themselves and limiting the scope of what can be accomplished. (Plus paying the competing in order to compete)
- greekanalyst 2y agoVery eager to see the same happening in the EU.
- nuz 2y agoHacker culture was already on its deathbed and this is the final nail
- farco12 2y agoI'm grateful Gary and YC are doing this. From a communication strategy standpoint, I'm just curious what the thinking was to go with 'Little Tech' to refer to new tech startups? I understand the purpose is to succinctly stand in contrast to 'Big Tech', but the word 'Little' somehow feels a bit more cutesy or infantilizing to me than saying 'Small Tech.'
- iamleppert 2y agoCapture those regulators and get the bag!
- keepamovin 2y agoOh, come on: you went because you were called. Big tech don't like to admit the regulatory powers they exist at the grace of. Tech bros, got to learn you some respec. Hahaha! :)