13 ms·
Sal Khan is pioneering innovation in education again
- belter 2y ago[flagged]
- cr125rider 2y agoI’ll bite. Why is Khan Academy so bad? It seems like a good collection of high quality classes, at least the ones I’ve tried from Sal himself.
- belter 2y agoKhan Academy is great. It's their agreement with Microsoft that will be their fall. https://educationblog.microsoft.com/en-us/2024/05/enhancing-the-future-of-education-with-khan-academy https://educationblog.microsoft.com/en-us/2024/05/enhancing-...
- wumbo 2y ago[flagged]
- cinntaile 2y agoWhat else would you call Khanacademy if not a pioneer of innovation in education? You can learn all kinds of subjects using their platform in an incremental way on a massive scale. The platform includes little tests to test your understanding after you watched the videos that explain the concept.
- red_admiral 2y agoA pioneer of a form of education that works for some, but not others.
- olooney 2y agoThere has always been a split between students who are there to learn and those who are there to get a diploma. AI will simply make this divide wider. Students who actually want to acquire knowledge and skills will benefit enormously, while students who are trying to skate through with minimal effort will find themselves hitting the job market with literally no skills or knowledge beyond copying-and-pasting in and out of chat windows.
- jasondigitized 2y agoThat’s a feature of a job market, not a bug.
- croes 2y ago>Picture this: You're a seventh-grade student who struggles to keep up in math. But now, you have an AI tutor like the one Sal describes by your side. Picture this: You're a seventh-grade student who struggles to solve the equations in math. But now you have an AI that solves it for you. I bet that there will be more students of the later type than the former.
- chii 2y ago> But now you have an AI that solves it for you. and then the AI explains how it was solved, step by step. You can repeatedly ask it to clarify, and it has endless patience and won't get bored or sick of you. Eventually, you understand how the equation is solved. No human teacher would be able to achieve this.
- GolfPopper 2y agoBut sometimes it makes up answers that are wrong but sound plausible to you. You have no way to tell when it does this, and neither does it.
- arresin 2y agoOr when you tell it you think the answer is something else it agrees with you and apologies that yes, now it can see, 2+2 does equal 5.
- neuralnetes-COO 2y agoThat is the entire purpose of LLMOps. Provide guardrails to prevent hallucination and ensure precise control of GenAI output.
- tayo42 2y agoHow can you tell what's true or not?
- 2y ago
- nbzso 2y agoIf you have some form of financial independence in your life, some form of the grid backup, you know what is all this about. Did you think the richest of the elite will give their kids this form of education? Seriously? My kids learn in a classical way. No aid, no electronic devices, no "modern" bullshit. Critical thinking is a must in a world of corporations greed and digital dystopia. The school mandatory program is just a form of training ground. They learn how to see the real problems around and how to adapt to ever-changing hypocrisy. Never trusted a word coming from the corporate monster Microsoft. Never looked at Bill Gates as more than a greedy manipulator and sociopath. Downvotes don't change the reality:)
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoI agree the endgame is turning all education (and other areas of society) into McDonald's type crap because it's cheapest to offer. But it's weird to make this about Microsoft when AI is being shoved down our throats from all directions. Like you said, it's a "world of" greed.
- nbzso 2y agoGreed is contagious. But looking at Closed AI and seeing Azure all over it is not easy to ignore. Looking at hostile takeover of FOSS at GitHub to train commercial product Copilot is another thing. We all knew the strategy when they bought it, and we all complied with the move. They have power because we refuse to challenge the lack of intervention from authorities. It is all a big scam.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoThe elite will give their kids this education when it is better than what a team of dedicated humans can provide. We are no where near that stage though.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoI'm as excited about the potential as anyone. I would love to give my child an AI tutor like The Primer. But nothing like that exists today, as far as I know. I was disappointed with Khanmigo when I tried it back in August. Although I have a year's subscription to it, I've not asked my child to try it. It seemed too boring and told me my answer (to a problem it had given me) was wrong, even though I was right. I'm optimistic, but I think there's work to do. I've not seen an AI system that can apply the pedagogy of George Polya: give the student a small hint by asking a question that could have occured to the student themselves.
- gnicholas 2y ago> told me my answer (to a problem it had given me) was wrong, even though I was right. This is a fatal flaw. It absolutely cannot make mistakes like this if it's going to succeed because that will undermine the confidence that teachers and students have in the system.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoHere's a screenshot of the conversation: https://imgur.com/a/MYOQRK3 https://imgur.com/a/MYOQRK3 Aside from the wrong answer, I also didn't like the fact that it just told me to multiply the numbers, instead of giving me a smaller hint that might allow me to realize this for myself.
- gnicholas 2y agoAmazing that it made such a basic mistake, so many times. I thought they wrapped the AI in enough layers of meta-cognition that it wouldn't make mistakes like this. Maybe AI in education really is like FSD, as another commenter said (so close, yet so far).
- rahimnathwani 2y agoAIUI Khanmigo uses GPT-4 under the hood, so honestly I'm perplexed.
- ebr4him 2y agoYour country isn’t eligible right now. At this time, only people who live in the United States are eligible to use Khanmigo.
- moomoo11 2y agoAI is like the promise of back when consumer internet was just popping off. You can have all the knowledge at your fingertips! What actually happened: ads shoved down our throats and way more distractions (porn, games, etc.) Meanwhile math and reading levels continue to plummet. So I don’t have high hopes. Those of us who use tools to succeed will continue to do so. Others who can’t control themselves will keep complaining. Nothing new. AI will give us an answer with ads shoved into it with companies bidding to show their ad with the answer. People will do degenerate shit with AI, and gaming addiction will continue. People will still keep blaming the system and wondering why they can’t get ahead while spending most of their free time wasting it on gambling, porn, and games instead of learning. The world will be split unevenly into people who research to contribute to AI knowledge base, and people who simply consume AI content. The question is. How will we (the enlightened ones lol) make money off it?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoThe consumer internet is a blessing and a curse. Without consumers the internet doesn't have much economic benefit. To use the internet to sell things you need the normies- so you pull all the non-technical people onto the internet where they are scammed, hacked, and manipulated at scale.
- moomoo11 2y agoThat's my point. Same with AI.
- AlexandrB 2y agoHaving been through a few technology cycles now, I am also skeptical. We're in the honeymoon phase where anything seems possible and everything is cheap or free (VC/company subsidized). What will AI look like when it comes time to pay the piper? More ads? Perpetual subscriptions?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 7thpower 2y agoI am a high school dropout and who learned math using Khan Academy after never having completed more than pre-algebra in middle school. Sal Khan’s work changed my life and allowed me to build a foundation in not only math, but also finance and economics, that allowed me to feel confident enough to go to college. I did not have a support system or people in my life who could teach me these things, but I had the internet and patience, which meant I had opportunities that did not exist even a few years before (this was in 2014). Now I work in AI and generally have a life I could not have dreamed of. Every time I go to the grocery store to buy something and don’t have to worry about my card being declined, it feels like magic. Even years later. If I had been in that situation a few years earlier, my life would be very different. I’m excited to live in a world where my daughters and countless others will have a tutor that can help them maximize their potential throughout their lives. I’m excited not only for them, but for society. What a time to be alive.
- sonabinu 2y agoA very powerful story! thanks for sharing
- bertil 2y agoI have significant concern about this—that it is a story. I don’t doubt that it’s true in OC’s case. But I don’t think it’s representative of the impact of technology. It’s the example that will get Bill Gates’ attention and end up on the stage at TED, but it might not be representative of 90% of how people are affected by technology. It might, and the story of how videos will change how people relate to each other (what made Chris Anderson buy TED, what Salman Khan has built, what Grant Sanderson a.k.a, 3blue1brown has done). It is true, anecdotally. It is a fantastic, compelling, clear story. I love that story: video is the easiest way to share any practice; people watch, learn, practice, and get good at something no one in their village knew was possible. Hurray. But when I trained as a statistician, i.e., epistemologically someone working for the state, I was told I was the opposite of a journalist: my job is not to tell stories that explain what a problem is. My job is to tell the boss how common that story really is. A story tells all the details to pull your emotions, and journalists (at the time, at least) were telling fact-check, double-verified stories. “Truth” wasn’t our goal. It is too easy to get numbers that argue for any position. Representative was what we were told we should be aiming for—so that the government makes the right decision. I’m not seeing a lot of “representative” here.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- red_admiral 2y agoBoth Bill Gates and Sal Khan (and, for good measure, Mark Zuckerberg too) have tried revolutionizing education with technology before. If we look at exactly how and where past attempts went wrong, we might find some challenges for this one too. I remember when MOOCs were the future of education, as students across the world would have free access to the best lectures from the best teachers and could watch them over and over again at their own pace. That ... didn't result in the second coming of Christ, to put it politely.
- olooney 2y ago"We try things. Occasionally they even work." —Rob Balder
- wisty 2y ago> But drawing on his experience creating Khanmigo, an AI-powered tutor, Sal makes a compelling case that AI-powered technologies will be different. That’s because we finally have a way to give every student the kind of personalized learning, support, and guidance that’s historically been out of reach for most kids in most classrooms. As Sal puts it, “Getting every student a dedicated on-call human tutor is cost prohibitive.” AI tutors, on the other hand, aren’t. Personalisation fails for a simple reason - people don't really want to learn. Classes work because the teacher can inspire (or at least push), and there's peer pressure to learn (or at least keep up with the herd). I'm sure there's a dozen or so self-taught Python or Rust programmers here who will loudly refute what I'm saying, and point out that they were perfectly capable of learning something they were very interested in, but I bet a lot of them would also like to learn a foreign language or quantum physics and haven't gotten that done. AI will fail for the same reason Youtube, DVDs, video cassettes, radio lessons, and phonographs all failed to be a revolution. If you want to learn something, and have the motivation, then reading the textbook is easily good enough (for theoretical subjects) and for less theoretical subjects you barely need a textbook, just lots of practice. Yes, you can probably learn a little tiny bit faster with AI, if you (or someone staring over your shoulder) have the motivation to play some AI learning game rather than a more fun-optimised game that's purely about having fun, but it's a small optimisation.
- red_admiral 2y agoThis. The people for whom personalized learning works well, can do it with any technology, even books. I recently learnt a new programming language from an O'Reilly book just fine, then did some exercises in a (non-AI) online REPL/tutorial tool, then went off to code a project of my own.
- lolinder 2y agoOn the flip side, I've absolutely never been able to pick up a new programming language from a book. Most of the languages I've learned I started with YouTube video tutorials, but most recently when I wanted to learn Rust do you know what worked really well for me? GitHub Copilot. I started a new project, and when I didn't know what syntax to use I made a comment and examined the output. By the time the project was done I'd learned how Rust worked and could write code without help. Before making sweeping pronouncements about what does or doesn't work for learning, it would be worth considering that people vary widely in which learning strategies work well for them. You might just be projecting your own preferred learning style out on the world.
- mihaic 2y agoAll the articles I've read about AI improving education make the same assumption: AI will help students learn that same things as we teach them now easier. If AI will be so revolutionary to me that first mean a complete overhaul of what students should learn? We haven't even properly done this reevaluation of the curriculum even for being constantly connected to the internet. Students really need to learn a lot fewer things on average, but the fundamentals matter even more now. Honestly, 90% of the population doesn't need more than elementary math, but they really need to understand how percentages or pro-rata work. In the end, looks like a puff piece by Bill Gates is still a puff piece.
- arresin 2y agoI never found the Kahn academy videos good. His teaching style was just totally off. I found some videos by a company called The Teaching Company. Really old school, very early 2000s or late 90s. Incredibly high quality truly gifted teachers—-just less well known online.
- nothrowaways 2y agoCan agree. Did a pretty good PR and first comer advantage.
- rramadass 2y agoI am glad somebody mentioned "The Teaching Company" and their offerings - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Teaching_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Teaching_Company I used to checkout their "The Great Courses" dvds from the local library (in the USA) long time ago. They were a set of presentations each a full lecture length and delivered by respected professors in their fields. No flashy animations/music/narrative distractions but sedate multimedia in support of the lecture. I am not sure how it has changed nowadays but people should definitely check it out; there is a lot of good content there.
- arresin 2y agoI learned calculus there and in a way that gave me an advantage when I studied it formally with a much much lower quality teacher.
- domtoretto 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LI7UOuX9Qjs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LI7UOuX9Qjs ("Sal Khan on why Khan Academy is a non-profit")
- emacsen 2y agoThis has seemed like the next logical step in education for a while now. I recently used ChatGPT to help me understand some Kubernetes and Terraform configuration. It was able to talk to me about the configuration and also help me understand some of the larger context- how information flows between the systems, what the terms mean, etc. It provided direct explanations, and metaphors when I needed it, and let me ask clarifying questions. This kind of learning system would be especially useful for people like myself who have Learning Disabilities, where once I understand a topic, I can speed ahead, but sometimes I'll just get "stuck", sometimes for days/weeks. Having a tutor can help, but there's a lot of embarrassment and that can lead to anxiety, which can in turn make it harder to learn. Obviously such a system will need some safeguards around it, but having a system like this be able to both explain and point to primary sources could be a complete game changer for students.
- Pulcinella 2y agoBackground: I taught high school science for half a decade and now I am in tech. This will never take off. One, there is no money in Ed.Tech. There is no money in Ed.Tech. There is no money in Ed.Tech. What little money there is goes to the obvious stuff like student records databases. Anything that requires an ongoing subscription fee is dead in the water. The only reason those stupid smartboards took off is because they make school boards look cool, they are a one time cost, and can be paid for with bonds (because they are a one time cost). Teachers don't want them (projectors and document cameras are good, though). Ed.Tech is a wasteland of failed startups. Part of the problem is also that classic "the people with the purchasing power are not the people who will be using the product" problem. Two, everyone outside of education thinks "well has anyone just tried sitting down with the kids and talking to them/explaining it to them?" Yes, obviously. The problem isn't that they are lazy, snot-nosed kids (that's a problem well within an experienced teacher's skill set to solve). The problem is what is the AI going to do with the kid says "fuck you" to the AI because they haven't eaten since lunch the previous day (school is the only place they get regular meals), or they don't even know what to ask because they are basically 4 grades behind in math, or the wifi is dead for the 8th time that month because the school board will never pay for infrastructure. Three, what if the AI is just wrong and starts confusing the student? Even GPT-4 fabricates things all the time. Sure it can generally put words in grammatically correct order and is passible for writing no one is going to read anyway (like marketing emails). But the moment it requires actual domain knowledge all these AI models completely fall down because, again, they don't actually understand anything, they just are really good at guessing what word comes next.
- tangjurine 2y agoIdk... My company is doing pretty well (ixl learning)
- hinkley 2y agoI suspect there’s a difference between selling to school boards and selling to individual learners. I know college kids are using edtech, but they don’t like it much. And there was one-time purchasing during the quarantine. And obviously Khan academy must be doing okay.
- markles 2y agoStudents are not lacking access to information, they're lacking motivation.
- w10-1 2y ago> lacking motivation Isn't this for lack of tutors, which AI solves? With teaching now (even via videos), there's no way to present material for 30 students when they vary widely in background understanding and attention span, so only the high middle gets targeted. This creates a vicious cycle where the spread only gets larger as students age. If slow kids can be tutored to catch up, they'll be much more motivated as part of the class, instead of the losers. If fast kids are given a taste of how ignorant they remain, they might have more sympathy for others, and might try to help instead of compete.
- djeastm 2y ago>Isn't this for lack of tutors, which AI solves? I would argue there's a very human element to tutoring that AI does not provide. Having been a tutor and also having been tutored myself, the personal relationship is very important. To know some other human is taking their very human time to help you is a powerful motivating factor that an AI can't simulate. To see another human performing some task that you can't activates some kind of primal desire to emulate them. AI can't simulate that.
- n4r9 2y agoCalling this "Brave New Words" reminds me of a recent submission: "For tech CEOs, the dystopia is the point" - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40371835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40371835 > a time-honored internet tradition: pointing out that the science fictional reference point a tech founder put forward was not an aspirational one, but, in fact, a dystopia containing a warning meant to be heeded, not emulated.
- bertil 2y agoThis is a lot of words for not saying that students keep sending essays entirely written by ChatGPT and never proof-read by their “author.” Never having to do homework is affecting students dramatically, according to many teachers. What Gates and Kahn describe is interesting, but it’s a little bit like talking about color theory and how the fact that a baseball bat is purple affected you after you just got whacked in the head with it.
- d_burfoot 2y agoThere's always been an economic contradiction in a common education. The skills that a typical high school education will teach you are not very valuable, because they are oversupplied. No one is going to pay you to solve AP calculus problems or write an essay about the French Revolution; not because these are easy tasks, but because the world is full of people who can perform them. AI education will continue this trend. AI can certainly teach you all kinds of remarkable skills. But the value of those skills will now plummet, because these are exactly the kinds of jobs that will be automated by AI!
- schmidt_fifty 2y ago[dead]
- Jtsummers 2y ago> As you work through a challenging set of fraction problems, it won’t just give you the answer—it breaks each problem down into digestible steps. When you get stuck, it gives you easy-to-understand explanations and a gentle nudge in the right direction. When you finally get the answer, it generates targeted practice questions that help build your understanding and confidence. You don't need an LLM for this. Since the topic is specifically math, consider what that actually entails, especially for K-12 math education. The example is fractions. The rules for fraction problems are well-defined, we don't need an LLM to guess at the steps, we can literally write a simple program that encodes all the individual steps and prompts the student when they make a mistake to step back and walk through each small step (instead of taking big steps, like going from 1/2+1/4 to an answer have the student fill out each step like how to make the denominators the same and then adding the numerators and then, if applicable, simplifying). Generating problems is also not something an LLM needs to be involved in. Such a strange and wasteful use of these tools.
- w10-1 2y agoSo then what if the generative LLM is simply the "UI", tailored to the student, but working from a topological map of the subject matter in the form of quizzes? And if it were able to present questions targeted at student gaps, broken down to be challenging but achievable, i.e., to build success patterns? Wouldn't that work for any subject matter - not just math?
- dorkwood 2y agoSal jumped on the NFT wagon, now he's jumping on the AI one. Not surprising, but hopefully something good comes from this play at least.
- cmcconomy 2y agoReally depressing that Bill Gates is impressed by the idea of "chatting with lincoln". Is this what we were missing in school? Our teachers dressing up with a tophat and bullshitting that they're lincoln and making stuff up?
- djeastm 2y agoRight? In twenty years, people are going to be comparing their imaginary conversations with Lincoln as if they're historical fact.
- Apocryphon 2y agoThis clip was making the rounds in response to some AI hustler startup making an Alan Turing AI chatbot their CTO: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEMbLt4B4iA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEMbLt4B4iA
- stevarino 2y agoThat's an interesting "what-if" though... How would a future generation be affected if they have a parasocial relationship with Lincoln? Or any historical figure? Or a currently running politician? I feel sci-fi authors have their work cut out for them...
- jamilton 2y agoI'd probably find that kinda entertaining as a kid, and being entertained is useful for teaching/learning to a degree.
- akira2501 2y agoI sort of feel he's impressed by the size of his investment in a technology that has mostly failed to live up to it's promises. The rest is an attempt to spin himself out of this negative value position.
- zozbot234 2y ago> June 19, 2024 > When Brian and Ben reached the lab, the computer was running but the tree-robot was folded and motionless. “Robin, activate.” ... > “There now exists a procedural model for the behavior of a human individual, based on the prototype human described in section 6.001 of the CYC-9 knowledge base. Now customizing parameters on the basis of the example person Brian Delaney described in the employment, health, and security records of Megalobe Corporation.” > A brief silence ensued. Then the voice continued. > “The Delaney model is judged as incomplete as compared to those of other persons such as President Abraham Lincoln, who has 3596.6 megabytes of descriptive text, or Commander James Bond, who has 16.9 megabytes.” Quoted from https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/09/remembering-doug-lenat-1950-2023-and-his-quest-to-capture-the-world-with-logic/ https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/09/remembering-doug... see also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37402925 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37402925 . June 19, 2024 - looks like we're right on schedule, or thereabouts.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoI'll admit I haven't read the book mentioned in the article. But I can't help but feel this is just dreaming about "AI" as a magical intelligence that we can perfectly instruct and trust, instead of having an actual plan for how current SotA AI could deliver that experience. I personally wouldn't trust any current LLM to train my child, without having to go over all of its content and see if it was actually trustworthy or not.
- w10-1 2y agoGenerative AI works by selecting the most likely next words. But students misunderstand in many different ways. How would it be tailored instead of another way of delivering lesson plans? Even assuming you already had the topology of the problem space, you'd have to interrogate the student with all possible ways for each question to determine what's missing for them. But part of the problem is impedance matching: failing students get little positive feedback because they have to correct many mistakes before they start getting things right. Interrogation makes the impedance-matching problem much, much worse (no matter how sweet and enticing the voice). Sure, I believe in success patterns and strong leaders. But I'd need to see a sketch of how Khan understands and addresses the problems before I'd invest or rely on this as anything other than a stop-gap that continues the under-funding of mass education.
- educaysean 2y agoHow would an excellent human teacher work with such a failing student? Can that technique be something that the AI could model?
- newtone 2y agoAs someone coming from a Tech background and has become deeply involved in education recently, I cannot agree more. There is just so much difference in terms of understanding education among people who have worked with children and people who have not. For majority of the time the active 'response' from the student is 'no response'. Teachers are amazing at understanding silence and building conversation on silence. Knowing the social background of the a student, and hence knowing realities of their hardships is the begining point of starting to enable a student who is laggning behind. AI-tutors are(potentially) great, much like how videos are way better than reading books from a childs perspective, but it is far from innovation in education that few influencers are trying it to be.
- from-nibly 2y agoDisclaimer I'm talking about the US, but I believe it applies at least somewhat to most of the modern education system everywhere. The problem of education isn't the lack of resources it's the lack of purpose. The internet is all the resources you will ever need. Sure AI could augment this a little. Maybe it could re-explain something you can't quite wrap your head around. The problem is that kids know that the education system isn't even kind of preparing them for what's to come. Knowledge work and trades couldn't be further from what public school prepares you for. Having a teacher for every kid wouldn't change this. The problem is so fundamental, and the solution is so destructive that we can't just tack on one more thing to "fix" education. Learning comes from doing, augmented with reflection. Public Schools don't ever do either of those things. The closest you ever get to doing anything that another human could want is building something in shop class. The closest thing you get to reflection is a grade that can only be negative feedback or the lack of feedback, plus there's no time for building on that reflection, just move onto the next thing.
- balls187 2y agoIs your comment based on recent experience? I have two young school age kids, and my experience with them does not align with your assessment. Their schooling is vastly different from the "Sit still, do what you're told" model that was used to train the an upcoming generation of factory workers.
- csa 2y ago> Their schooling is vastly different from the "Sit still, do what you're told" model that was used to train the an upcoming generation of factory workers. Not op, but this is an area I know a bit about. 1. You’re right that instruction methods have evolved over time to be less teacher-centered. This might be considered an improvement. That said, good teachers who implement these methods well are mostly in good school districts (no surprise). 2. The issue comes more in secondary ed, imho. The issue is with the curriculum. In 1900, only about 4% of HS-aged kids went to HS. These folks were the elite, and the HS education was preparing them for a 2-year or 4-year program after HS (again, mainly for elites). The curriculum that existed then is largely the same one we have today, and it’s completely absurd. We get odds things like lower level math (non-calculus track) basically being re-heated middle school math. We get four required years of “English” that focuses on grammar (often taught in a dubious, prescriptive manner) and literature largely written by dead people (when there is plenty of good modern lit and poetry to learn about/through). We have science education that largely does not train students to engage scientific thinking (again, except maybe for the honors classes at good schools). To summarize, we have a curriculum designed for college-bound elites that has been ungracefully shoe-horned into a one-size-fits-all train wreck. All of the curricular issues are solvable, but it there will need to be a critical mass of support in local communities to be able to implement change through the inertia of the existing system of education administrators and (to some extent) teachers. Until this happens, imho it’s best to look at secondary ed as very expensive child care for the vast majority of students, with the exception being in better school districts (usually where the elites or elite-ambitious live). Primary ed is ok… the main learning outcomes that folks need are the three Rs. Some folks, especially on HN, seem to think scientific thinking should be included. They’re not wrong, but that only flies in schools/communities of elites.
- fhe 2y agothe article makes it as if the solution to education is "a dedicated tutor to every student". I do not think that's the case. The problem is that not every student has the motivation, and having a tutor on call 24-7 doesn't change it. the article goes on to describe how such an AI tutor might work: "As you work through a challenging set of fraction problems, it won’t just give you the answer—it breaks each problem down into digestible steps. When you get stuck, it gives you easy-to-understand explanations and a gentle nudge in the right direction. When you finally get the answer, it generates targeted practice questions that help build your understanding and confidence." reading it, and watching the demo of gpt-4o tutoring math (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBrdd7xg-dg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBrdd7xg-dg), I felt the opposite -- that if I had such a tutor, whatever motivation I had would have been stripped away by such a tutor. I really needed the quiet struggle with a problem, and feeling that I conquered it on my own, instead of being guided through a paint-by-number kit. I acknowledge that I might have an unusual learning style, or that I simply belonged to a generation that grew up without such tools, hence the aversion, much like my parents grew up without digital calculators (although they don't harbor any aversion to the use of calculators).
- from-nibly 2y agoYeah that's not an unusual learning style. No one can learn without struggle. There has to be some reason for your brain to remember something. If the AI is right there ready to do it for you, then why would you remember anything?
- smugglerFlynn 2y ago> Chapter by chapter, Sal takes readers through his predictions—some have already come true since the book was written—for AI’s many applications in education. His main argument: AI will radically improve both student outcomes and teacher experiences, and help usher in a future where everyone has access to a world-class education. I'd argue that the very thing that made Khan Academy successful in the first place was not "accessible education" or "cost prohibitive" practices, but Sal's human attention to the students needs and all the amazing content he created. Thousands of people will pick up from this article that AI is the solution to the education, while in reality it is people like Sal who are the actual solution, with YouTube, AI and other tech just being the tools to help scaling human talent.
- the__alchemist 2y agoI began a Journey in my mid-20s that I'm still on. (38) I took math classes, starting at middle-school grade. Did most of the Khan material. Moved on to MitX classes in further math, and sciences. Now I am working on an ab-initio atom/molecule simulating for funsies. Khan academy is an invaluable resource. When I have kids, it will be a core part of their curriculum!
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoIt's amazing how many people here know more about education than Sal Khan. /s Not that Sal Khan is infallible but he is a good-egg. You're gonna have to give me more than, "this'll never work because of <cynical dime-a-dozen take>."
- gwern 2y agoNote that when Bill Gates praises GPT-4o, he is at least partially "talking his book": he retains large amounts of equity in Microsoft, and has been intimately involved in MS's big bet on OA - in 2019, when Kevin Scott was lobbying a big investment in OA (https://gwern.net/doc/reinforcement-learning/openai/2019-scott-2.pdf https://gwern.net/doc/reinforcement-learning/openai/2019-sco...), Bill Gates was CCed, Gates invested in Inflection (recently rolled up into MS), and Sam Altman & Greg Brockman personally demoed GPT-4 to Gates at his mansion (https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/03/technology/ai-openai-musk-page-altman.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/03/technology/ai-openai-musk...) to show that GPT-4 could solve the AP Biology test that Gates had said would convince him LLMs were real. And I'm sure his involvement now goes well beyond just those few instances I've happened to note.
- jimmar 2y agoI work in academia and look forward to embracing AI tools. Students motivated to learn will do great with it. Others will need AI to really push them to learn, and it's not clear to me how that will work. Many students just want to know what they have to submit to get a grade. Spending 20 minutes chatting with AI about a topic might be a good learning activity, but incentivizing that with grading will be tricky. I've sometimes wondered when I'll get called to the Dean's office because a student died in class because breathing wasn't specifically listed as a grading requirement on the syllabus.
- balls187 2y agoMy son is a second grader who is behind on his english reading and writing. He's smart, able to understand and convey complex ideas, and can solve math problems beyond his grade level. He is classified as learning disabled, and has IEP through the school district which gives him accommodations including access to assistive technologies--such as an OCR reader that will read the words on a page to him to allow him to answer questions. At the very least, AI for ed-tech is the next evolution of those technologies, which may even be allowed without the need of a 504 or IEP (e.g. each student in his class has a school issued laptop). I'm also curious what subjects would be made obsolete because of the power of AI assistants. I certainly was not taught Latin, and my kids will never need to learn cursive writing.
- jerome-jh 2y agoThe article made me smile by how much disconnected to reality it is: - kids give their assignments to AI so that it solves it for them, not for getting a hint. - it has long been demonstrated human interaction is required to learn difficult things (such as reading/writing), otherwise kids would learn those skills on video. - learning is about practicing difficult stuff. AI is about having the computer doing difficult stuff for you. "Employees who can use AI effectively will be far more valuable than those who can’t." The point of AI is that there is absolutely nothing to do for it to digest your problem. Show me someone who can't use AI? Must be illiterate? "jobs of the future—which will become more enjoyable and fulfilling" ... finding and fixing the errors the AI made. My parents are much better at counting with no calculator than my kids. Mental calculation is no more seen as a valuable skill now that everybody effectively has a calculator in his pocket (smartphone). AI will make some skills once valuable obsolete. The question is not how are we going to teach with AI but WHAT are we going to teach?
- insane_dreamer 2y agoThis is perhaps one of the best use cases for AI. (Khan Academy is excellent. Over a decade ago, my home-schooled daughter [we were not living in the US at the time] used Khan Academy throughout high school, scoring 2300 on the SAT and getting a full scholarship to a prestigious US college to study engineering.)
- maccard 2y agoI studied engineering in university, and as part of that I took enough calculus, numerical methods, statistics, and logic courses to earn a math degree along side my engineering one. I spent hundreds of hours poring over 1500 page textbooks and being given the driest lectures imaginable by people who were delivering them on autopilot. I would estimate that one hour of khan academy was roughly equivalent to a weeks coursework, which was 3 lectures and probably an extra 2 hours of self study per lecture. It was undoubtedly the only reason I succeeded in the way I did.
- nicetryguy 2y agoIf 3 delicious cans of Pepsi: The Taste of a Generation cost six dollars, how much does each thirst quencing soda can cost individually? We solve this by...
- couchdb_ouchdb 2y agoI am currently using ChatGPT 4.0o to help me learn Japanese. If you have learned Japanese in the past, you know that the Genki textbooks are invaluable learning resources. The problem is that it's hard to find the motivation to work through a textbook and workbook alone. I am navigating through a textbook with the audio feature. I take photos of the pages with my phone, then use ChatGPT as my language partner to work through the problem sets. When i switch to the notebook, i complete the work and then take another photo of it and have ChatGPT verify my work. I agree with Gates here -- if you are motivated this changes the education game.
- yuki96 2y agoWhat kind of prompt do you use for it? My friend is studying with Genki and I am curious.
- andai 2y ago> AI tools and tutors never can and never should replace teachers. This part confused me on several levels. Let's break it down. --- 1. Tutors (human) can not replace teachers on a mass scale True, and the article touches on this: human tutors simply don't scale! 2. Tutors (human) should not replace teachers False. Bloom's 2-sigma problem [0] states that on average, 1-1 tutored students outperform 98% of classroom-educated students. (!!!) Therefore, if we could replace 1:30 education with 1:1 education, the evidence very strongly says that we should. In other words, the only reason we have teachers, instead of tutors, is because we don't have enough tutors. If we had enough tutors, we would simply 1-1 tutor everyone -- assuming our goal is educational achievement. 3. AI tutors can never replace human tutors This is a strange claim. It seems to imply that all technological progress will suddenly cease after today -- not just in AI, but human-computer interfaces, robotics, etc.? (Note: the article doesn't make this specific claim, so perhaps I'm straw-manning here.) I don't expect convincingly human androids for a while. But are androids really necessary for teaching math? GPT-4o seems to do fine! [1] --- As far as the tech goes, I think the only thing missing is memory and personalization. Currently GPT doesn't know what I know, and what I don't know. What is the dependency graph of knowledge? (KhanAcademy had one, but they've taken it down...) Where in that graph are there gaps in my understanding? What are my specific goals and interests? Can we present the most relevant learning materials to me in alignment with all these parameters? Or else, can we generate them on the fly? It's all a solvable engineering problem. --- [0] https://nintil.com/bloom-sigma/ https://nintil.com/bloom-sigma/ [1] Math Problems with GPT-4o [video]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40347320 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40347320 [1] Math Problems with GPT-4o: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nSmkyDNulk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nSmkyDNulk See also: One study predicted human-level AI tutors by 2025 [2] Achieving Bloom's Two-Sigma Goal Using Intelligent Tutoring Systems (2020) - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/339246677_Achieving_Bloom's_Two-Sigma_Goal_Using_Intelligent_Tutoring_Systems_Application_to_Management_Education https://www.researchgate.net/publication/339246677_Achieving...
- nutanc 2y agoAI in education will be the FSD in driving. Everyone thinks we are very close and the tech is just about there. 10 years later we will have made some progress but nowhere near the utopia promised. Education has a lot more edge cases than driving.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- nothercastle 2y agoI hate edutech with a passion. It just saps away resources from the teachers and invests it into tech that is both expensive and ineffective. It’s mostly just a giant pathway for grift
- abhgh 2y agoIf you're in the bay area he has an upcoming event tomorrow, at Kepler books [1], where he would be talking about AI in education and his new book Brave New Words [2]. [1] https://www.keplers.org/upcoming-events-internal/salman-khan https://www.keplers.org/upcoming-events-internal/salman-khan [2] https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/740806/brave-new-words-by-salman-khan/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/740806/brave-new-wo...
- zmmmmm 2y agoLLMs are famously bad at math. It's one of the prototypical examples of problems they can't solve. Yet it's the prime example presented here. So I am curious, is Gates suggesting that we will overcome the fundamental issues here or is he saying that (which is kind of interesting in itself) it's plausible to have a technology that is fundamentally bad at something, be an effective teacher of that thing to others?
- EarthAmbassador 2y agoDon’t think so. When my daughter needed the AI-powered Khan tutoring service last year for assistance with math, it was at a time when I had lost my job and depleted the family savings supporting the family. I pleaded for a waiver of the subscription, which was flatly and repeatedly denied. The result, my daughter’s math grades fell to the low 20 percent, and at no point did the teacher notify us. We’ve been repairing the damage ever since. I wonder if Sal Khan approves of abandoning low-income families, because his staff are stuffing families bad.
- DwnVoteHoneyPot 2y agoYou’re blaming Sal Khan and Khan Academy for your daughter’s math grades?
- tracerbulletx 2y agoI agree that the LLMs of today 100% work for education. It's how I use them anyways, constantly have it open when I'm reading or doing a learning activity and throwing questions at it, or generating summaries, and it is extremely enriching as a layer on top of that self directed work. I'm sure people like Sal Khan will continue to innovate ways to make them more useful for guided curriculum and other capabilities without needing any real fundamental technology research. I think to play devils advocate though, there is a ceiling on learning placed by how much the student cares, can focus, and is motivated. That will still exist, we can just make the motivated students path easier.
- kebokyo 2y agoThe title of this book is a really funny but also very sad bit of Torment Nexus-ing (Brave New World)
- ajonit 2y agoBill Gates has been a long-time fan of Sal Khan. In fact, I first learned about Sal Khan over a decade ago when online publications reported that Bill Gates was using Sal's videos to teach his kids.
- Guthur 2y agoIf the AI is at the stage of understanding these topics, debatable as that is, then why would you learn them as you can't compete against the computer, it can work 24/7 with no sleep. If the AI doesn't understand then you are just learning a script you are being fed. Some automation is obviously useful for transmitting information about various topics but the way this is being framed would seem to undermine the very need to learn in the first place.
- gorbypark 2y agoHas anyone played with Khanmigo yet? Is it basically Khan Academy with a chatbot to help with questions, or does it differ completely from Khan Academy? About ten years ago I was thinking of returning to university and was required to pass a high school level math exam to prove I still could do math as an adult (I couldn't, really!). Khan Academy was a pretty incredible resource. I was in a time crunch so I also hired a tutor for two hours a week and the combination worked really well for me. I could see swapping out a real life tutor with an LLM being pretty amazing and much more affordable! I didn't end up returning to school, but now I've gotten the AI bug and need to upgrade my math skills, and I'm thinking that using a LLM to help learn about foundational math that applies to LLMs would be pretty neat.
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoA problem with AI assistants offering answers or reducing work in an education context is they harm cognitive labor (are "cheating") needed for learning by thinking and doing that leads to mastery. AI assistants in a learning context could instead be used ask context-sensitive quiz questions and point to other examples and learning resources.
- drones 2y agoAs someone who loves Khan Academy, who was taught math from it when my High School teachers couldn't, it really saddens me this is the emphasis Khan Academy chooses, instead of creating more material. The fact is, Khan Academy was so useful to me in school precisely because it was NOT a resampling of a Wikipedia page, of every uninspired textbook I was ever forced to read. It was a smart, real life human being who understood the nuances of how actual human beings understood concepts. Sal didn't just break down complex mathematical subjects for me such that I was able to solve linear equations in echelon form, there was also a particular way he emphasised the words he spoke so I understood why something was important. The human factor is so important, and we're fucking over our next generation for market hype. A few years ago, I was bullish on online learning. But no-one with common sense is as the helm. I am incredibly concerned that Microsoft is believing its hype at the cost of something that was at one point incredibly valuable to society.
- bitnasty 2y agoDoesn’t anyone else have issues with the idea of putting education in the hands of a hallucinating parrot?
- crawfordcomeaux 2y agoThe environmental cost of AI is cost prohibitive when each prompt is equivalent to dumping a 16oz bottle of water on the ground. The only ethical usage of AI is revolution, including the revolution to stop AI. And only then if it's used immediately and effectively for it, not a few years down the line.
- rldjbpin 2y agohaving used his videos more than a decade ago, i recognize that he has been a trailblazer in his field. i appreciate how he applied emerging tech in the past for improving access to education. at the same time, i see the limitations with this project in terms of what it wants to achieve. tech alone is not the answer, AI or not. i had very positive experiences with teachers only using blackboards or whiteboards, and forgettable moments with those with the newest smartboards. to me, it is the teacher that brings out the value of these tools. today's LLMs, no matter how large and expensive to run, do not capture the personal ingenuity that can replace teachers. this is not an old man shouting at the clouds opinion or any arrogance about humans being superior. critical thinking is a rare idea taught in schools, at least when i was growing up. these systems do not give an opportunity to do that. i am happy to be proved wrong in the future but while i get the costs associated with researching and running the service, i feel it is unethical for them to be the ones charging for its access. it seems against the foundation's goals.
- renegat0x0 2y agoWith AI is like with ring of power. There is only one master. Google chatbot only serves google. Microsoft serves microsoft. It will always cater to some agenda, it will have some biases. It will be nice, but it will play neatly their part in perpetuating corporatocracy. As a unit you will have to play a long, or live in the woods without AI.
- Log_out_ 2y agoIf you a innovative outlier you have nothing to fear from AI. First they came for the interns jobs and i was afraid, for i wasn't an intern.