11 ms·
Sprint, T-Mobile Merger Killed Wireless Price Competition in U.S.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoAh, yes, that's what did it, not the reunification of Ma Bell.
- dehrmann 3y agoWe're in a better spot then with the AT&T monopoly because there are three viable carriers almost everywhere. The Baby Bells were local monopolies, and you had to get long distance service from the national monopoly. I never understood how people see that as a win.
- blihp 3y agoThe point being made is that AT&T should have never been allowed to reform itself as it did, probably along with numerous other acquisitions/mergers that the government approved that they should not have. There was a period of time late in the last century when many of us had numerous (i.e. 5-6) options for a while.
- vl 3y agoAT&T we have now is not really related to this old evil AT&T. Actual company that uses this brand in mobile space is used to be called Cingular. They bought AT&T remains and promptly rebranded.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> AT&T we have now is not really related to this old evil AT&T. Yes, it is. > Actual company that uses this brand in mobile space is used to be called Cingular. So, in the beginning there was AT&T, the telephone monopoly. It was broken up into 7 RBOCs (Regional Bell Operating Companies, also called “baby bells”) providing local service (each of which got a corresponding chunk of the AT&T subsidiary doing mobile work as their own mobile subsidiary), and the reduced AT&T, which did long distance, and some other things. There were also two other local service providers (which, before the divestiture, weren’t AT&T subsidiaries but did partial AT&T control.) The modern AT&T is the result of mergers of, among other things, the long-distance AT&T and 4 of the 7 baby bells. As part of the road to getting there, Cingular Wireless, which was formed as joint venture of two of the Baby Bells (SBC, which had already acquired Pacific Telesis, one of the other Baby Bells, and BellSouth) from their mobile units and other mobile and other firms (like, more than 100 in total), acquired AT&T Wireless (not AT&T), which became part of Cingular (which was still an SBC/BellSouth joint venture) Then AT&T merged with SBC, making Cingular an AT&T/BellSouth joint venture. Then it was announced that the AT&T brand would be used for Cingular service when packaged with AT&T services. Then AT&T bought BellSouth, making Cingular an AT&T/AT&T joint venture…or, rather, just part of AT&T. So AT&T is the old long-distance AT&T after eating a bunch of other companies, but it’s also a very large portion of the older monopoly AT&T. Part of the wireless business was Cingular for a while between being AT&T before and then being AT&T again. (This leaves out a lot of mergers that went into forming the current AT&T that are not related to the claim that some company called Cingular that was completely unrelated to the old AT&T bought some minor remnant of AT&T and clothed itself with the name.)
- kbolino 3y agoVerizon (originally Bell Atlantic)'s history is much the same. There's even some back and forth between it and what is now AT&T over who gets what of the RBOCs and their spinoffs/successors. Now, if Verizon and AT&T merge, then Ma Bell really will be back.
- exabrial 3y agoDOE needs to stop approving mergers and acquisitions over $150 mil or so. Every such merger: Facebook/Instagram, Google/Youtube, etc has been a disaster.
- nashashmi 3y agoThey were great investments for soon to be has beens. And helped the acquisition flourish too.
- robertlagrant 3y agoGoogle and YouTube seems pretty good. YouTube is the most old school webby experience I have these days, although now in video form, now that the web web is so walled off.
- TeaBrain 3y ago$150 million is way too low today. Nearly every small acquirable company will meet that threshold. I do think that a limit could possibly be set though for companies with significant market share in the same sector. The Sprint acquisition was over $20 billion. Exxon's acquisition of Pioneer last year was around $60 billion.
- bklyn11201 3y agoWhat do you think would happen to the venture-capital-funded tech ecosystem and the resulting tech salaries if this were to happen?
- exabrial 3y agoThe hope would be a vast increase in employers available rather than consolidation down to FAANG, increasing demand and driving salaries up.
- mavelikara 3y ago> increasing demand and driving salaries up. Despite the demand, the revenue per employee for the company might be low, and those companies might not be able to pay high salaries to employees.
- voisin 3y agoI’d love to see an economist tease apart the contribution of industry consolidation to inflation and wage suppression.
- jahewson 3y agoSeveral have! There’s no consensus on the relationship though. Some cases it does, some cases it doesn’t. Unions are a big factor.
- TheAmazingRace 3y agoI will say, I'm not terribly fond of mergers on principle. However, based on my insight as a former customer and shareholder of the company, Sprint's goose was most definitely cooked to a crisp. If this merger had not happened, I could have seen Sprint file for bankruptcy, with Verizon and AT&T picking the carcass clean. I think folks forget how dire Sprint's straits were at the time, and this specific merger truly was the least of all evils.
- mchannon 3y agoA Sprint bankruptcy may have been inevitable, but Verizon and AT&T would have been forced to steer clear (a failed merger having made that inevitable). The private market would have provided a bounty of suitors for Sprint if it couldn't recover from bankruptcy. It may have emerged in a far weaker fourth place, but it would still be around.
- TheAmazingRace 3y agoThe only other possible dark horse that could have emerged was either in US Cellular or Dish Network. However, I believe there were concerns with issues like market capitalization (in the case of US Cellular) or having different priorities (like Dish) that would have jeopardized a proper fourth option for the US. I'm not suggesting the merger was "good" or anything like that. Just that the other options seemed quite unlikely.
- Aloha 3y agoUS Cellular is actually pretty probably, same tech stack, same hardware, similar customer bases, but they didnt have acres of capital. The issue was the albatross of the debt from the Nextel merger.
- derefr 3y agoAs a Canadian (so possibly biased here), my own hypothesis for what would happen if a sufficiently-large long-tail power vacuum emerged in the US cellular data market — either back then or today — is that one of the major Canadian carriers would try to move in, beginning by serving cities just across the border from major Canadian cities. You could easily do cell-tower-maintenance truck-rolls from offices in Vancouver BC to towers in Seattle or Portland; from Toronto to Buffalo (or, less plausibly, to Chicago); or from Montreal to Boston. And that's only if they even bother to operate towers — if they tried today, they could just as well operate as pure MVNOs. In fact, flagship plans on Canadian carriers today, already usually build in no-cost full-speed US roaming data access through partnership with US carriers operating on the same frequency bands. It's a very short distance from there to operating an MVNO atop the same carrier's network. (I would say that I'm surprised they haven't tried to do this already; but until recently, Canadian carriers were addicted to the extremely-high-profit-margin rate plans they built up through oligopolist price fixing. Our current government has seemingly broken that up for now, with much cheaper plans finally appearing — so they might finally decide it's time to expand their TAM to stay profitable.)
- leeoniya 3y agoand they acquired Mint, which almost certainly means my $30/mo prepaid plan will disappear soon.
- stevenicr 3y agoReally sad to see the got Mint.. Cheers for the people that profited, but I feel this is a more serious blow than the sprint takeover.
- nerdkid93 3y agoCheck out US Mobile. They follow a similar ethos of prepaid plan, but you don't necessarily even need to sign up for months at a time like Mint.
- tiltowait 3y agoT-Mobile was the worst, most incompetent company I have had the displeasure of working with in recent years. I fled to Mint. To say I’m chuffed by that acquisition is an understatement.
- bagels 3y agoI'm confused by this. You don't like T-Mobile, but you're happy you'll be returning?
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoLong ago I had a T-mobile prepaid plan that had the wrong caller ID info. They claimed it couldn't be fixed because it was prepaid and they were unable to properly manage those accounts. Mint has been much better and will remain cheaper for now.
- meragrin_ 3y agoReally? In 2018, a voice only family plan was more than twice than a voice, text, and data plan I have today. Mind you, it just went down $10/month a few months ago so it isn't like all the price drops happened years ago.
- yuliyp 3y agoI'm struggling to feel the lack of price competition here in the US. It feels like mobile service has continually improved over time with fairly constant competition from MVNOs serving to experiment with different pricing models, as bandwidth has continued to be deployed. T-Mobile needed that Sprint merger to remain a viable nationwide competitor to Verizon and AT&T, and now they've done that.
- hersko 3y agoAnecdotally, i'm now paying far less then I used to for wireless service. $26/month on verizon's network for two lines through US mobile.
- toast0 3y agoPost merger I went from a $25/month t-mobile plan to a $15/month t-mobile plan. Not entirely apples to apples, but close. My spouse went from $30/month to $25/month on Verizon for more data. And there's lots of options at https://prepaidcompare.net/ https://prepaidcompare.net/
- Schnitz 3y agoPrepaid sounds great unless you ever want roaming, it’s either straight up not possible or priced in a way that makes it impractical.
- throwaway5959 3y agoI’ve been on prepaid since at least 2015 and never have had a problem with roaming in the US.
- bt3 3y agoData-only global eSims are super cheap. Having done a lot of international travel lately, this is undoubtedly the best way to go. Cheaper and better coverage too.
- hedora 3y agoAlso, things like iMessage, FaceTime and Signal definitely work with those sims. Not sure about "wifi" calling or SMS with your home country's plan though.
- johnkpaul 3y agoWhere would you recommend someone find one of these? Do they expire, or could I get one to cover years worth of travel? Thanks!
- walterbell 3y agoEskimo has a 2y global SIM, excluding a handful of countries, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40382377 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40382377
- smm11 3y agoMint, or at least some time back.
- RIMR 3y agoThe only bright side to the merger was that T-Mobile inherited Sprint's permanent contract with Mobile Citizen, and now nonprofits can get extremely low prices on uncapped, unthrottled 5G hotspots from T-Mobile, something you can't get as a normal consumer. Before the merger, you were stuck with Sprint's not-so-great network, but after the merger you end up with all of T-Mobile's coverage and speeds exceeding 1gbps in some urban areas. If you meet certain income requirements, you can get one from one of Mobile Citizen's resellers (such as PC's for People) for around $15/month. Or, for like $400-500/year you can get one through the Calyx Institute as a "gift" for donors. There's no getting out of this contract either. It's part of a deal Sprint made when they took over $1B in taxpayer money to build out their LTE infrastructure. This is how they pay it back - forever. If you needed something to help swing the pendulum back towards the consumer, still, the merger wasn't good for wireless competition in the U.S.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoHow would one secure one or more of these for a non-profit? Thinking redundancy for current AT&T fiber hookup for the admin staff and voip gateway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toasted-subs 3y agoMaybe why I'm having so much difficulty working
- treis 3y agoAm I missing something or is there no actual evidence in the article that proves the title? All I can see is a comparison between countries. Which is pretty weak evidence in general and definitely doesn't show anything about what happened in the US after the merger.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mrosett 3y agoDoes this article actually provide evidence for the headline claim?
- DataDive 3y agoDid it kill price competition? My anecdotal observation is that there are more cheap phone plans now than, say, five years ago.
- brink 3y agoSame. I can get an unlimited prepaid plan at $25/mo on AT&T. I remember unlimited plans being like $70 when Sprint was around.
- dmazzoni 3y agoIt seems to have created a two-tier system. You can get a "real" monthly plan from AT&T, Verizon, or T-Mobile for $50/month with unlimited data and prioritization. Or you can get a prepaid plan with data caps and no prioritization for $15 - 25 / month.
- phonon 3y agoUS Mobile has prioritized data. https://www.usmobile.com/blog/unlimited-premium-coverage-on-5g-warp-speed/ https://www.usmobile.com/blog/unlimited-premium-coverage-on-...
- ensignavenger 3y agoIt is hard to imagine mobile prices for a national network the size of the US. I pay less than $30 per month total for 3 lines. maybe it would be cheaper if the Sprint/TMobile merger never happened, but the adticle doesn't seem to present any hard evidence.
- maxsilver 3y agoHow exactly are you doing that? The average price of a standard-feature line (i.e., not a MVNO with strict deprioritization) is approximately $70 USD a month (including taxes and fees, but not including any phone subsidy or equipment plans) Even a strict hyper-cut-down MVNO (say something like Mint Mobile) is still about $20 a month per line on average, for their cheapest plan. And T-Mobile acquired Mint, so it's pricing will almost certainly rise in a year or two. (T-Mobile did the same thing to Metro when it acquired their network + subscribers, prices were doubled after a few years)
- ensignavenger 3y agoUS Mobile, an MVNO, I am on the Verizon network as they have slightly better coverage in the outskirts around me. I have never had any trouble with deprioritization.
- aiauthoritydev 3y agoMobile scene in USA is much improved than 10 years ago in my opinion. ATT/Verizon were too expensive and T-Mobile despite that poor service made a big difference. Google Fi has been my fav though as it gives me basic connectivity when I am abroad and cheap international calling to countries I care about.
- Animats 3y agoFour. As in a European study, price competition requires four significant competitors.[1] This should be a basic rule of antitrust regulation. [1] https://www.techdirt.com/2024/05/16/report-sprint-t-mobile-merger-immediately-killed-wireless-price-competition-in-u-s/ https://www.techdirt.com/2024/05/16/report-sprint-t-mobile-m...
- CodeWriter23 3y agoMeh. Go with Consumer Cellular or other discount MVNO. Plenty of competition at that strata.
- nikolay 3y agoAbsolutely! T-Mobile started to increase prices with their newer plans, which offer less for more.
- paul7986 3y agoT-mobile for years and still is cheaper then ATT & i assume Verizon. I was paying $165 for 4 unlimited lines with mobile hotspot. Now with T-Mobile same level of svc is $130 a month. Its up in the air tho if the service is a reliable and good as AT&T as i do have issues with T-mobile .. echoes heard on calls, calls not going thru/just dropping instead of connecting and no service at all where i previously had it with ATT (in southern york county pa by MD line).
- ApolloFortyNine 3y agoThe graph they chose to use in the article has to be one of the main poster childs for 'correlation does not mean causation'. I don't know what's worse, not adjusting for purchasing power, or not adjusting for country size. Also targeting 100GB screams 'writer had an agenda' to me. My screen on time is absolutely atrocious and I still rarely get over 20gb a month. I'm guessing the stats must change if you choose a number that fits in most plans defaults.
- dragontamer 3y agoI use 2GB a month and I thought I was a doom-scroller... I guess 2GB of text / forums / newspapers is very different from like, Netflix every day on the phone though.
- endo_bunker 3y agoThis is full of central-planning nonsense. He wants lower prices, but is also mad when the company does layoffs. US consumers probably have some of the highest if not the highest demand for mobile data in the world, and the cost of living is already higher regardless, yet he acts shocked that American consumers pay more for mobile data. Not to mention the fact that I pay $15 for a very reasonable Mint mobile plan that would probably suffice for upwards of 80% of American consumers.
- ummonk 3y agoI agree with your general point. However, we don't have particularly high mobile data usage. Countries with subscribers that use mobile to the exclusion of broadband (e.g. India) have higher mobile data usage per subscriber.
- icedchai 3y agoYep, you can get cheap plans like that through T-Mobile MVNOs or even their own prepaid plan. I'm generally near wifi all the time. A couple gigs of data a month is fine for me.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoPrices were always high in the US, before and after that merger. I think part of it is due to the low intelligence of an average US consumer, who wants to have his iphone "for free" with the contract, and is unable to calculate the real price he is paying.
- walterbell 3y agoA government condition of the merger was that T-Mobile had to offer low-cost prepaid plans without an MVNO. The program is called T-Mobile Connect, https://clark.com/cell-phones/connect-by-t-mobile/ https://clark.com/cell-phones/connect-by-t-mobile/ & https://coveragecritic.com/t-mobile-connect-review/ https://coveragecritic.com/t-mobile-connect-review/ & https://prepaid.t-mobile.com/connect/phone-plans https://prepaid.t-mobile.com/connect/phone-plans Monthly price for USA-only unlimited talk/text + 5G/LTE data, is $15/5GB, $25/8GB, $35/12GB + taxes/fees. Outside USA, T-Mobile pSIM Wi-Fi call/text continues to work with cellular/eSIM data from 2nd line. Eskimo has 2y ("global", excluding Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Qatar, Maldives, Morocco, Oman, Portugal, Singapore, South Africa) and 1y (regional) data eSIMs for about $4/GB, https://www.eskimo.travel https://www.eskimo.travel
- baby-yoda 3y agoIIRC, Connect was proposed as a 5 year solution, I fully expect T-Mobile to discontinue Connect as soon as possible.
- walterbell 3y agoMerger was in 2020, which implies that Connect ends next year. If 2024 wireless price competition is lacking, can US regulators extend Connect beyond 2025?
- chris-smith 3y agoNo, but I won't be surprised if the plans stick around longer. Speculating here, but I think odds are good T-Mobile continues to offer them for longer than required & just stops the annual data increase it has been doing
- nashashmi 3y agoMight be a change of guards that is causing this https://www.reddit.com/r/tmobile/comments/17tl1du/why_is_mike_seivert_undoing_everything_john/ https://www.reddit.com/r/tmobile/comments/17tl1du/why_is_mik...
- chris-smith 3y agoI'm sympathetic to a lot of the points here, but a key part of the story got left out: T-Mobile's performance used to suck vs. Verizon and AT&T. When T-Mo's network was crummy, the company to differentiated itself by being cheaper and less gimmicky than its competitors. I'm not too surprised T-Mo is adjusting its strategy as the company's network narrows the gap w/ VZW + AT&T. T-Mobile's performance was probably trending in a good direction even w/o the merger, but acquiring Sprint (and Sprint's spectrum) likely helped improve performance a good bit.
- zugi 3y agoData point: I'm on Sprint, now T-mobile, and my plan has stayed at exactly the same price in dollars for a decade, despite 30+% inflation over that time and the addition of 5G data. Verizon has slightly better service in my area, but would cost me $20-30/month more. I realize that's just one data point, but I'm not seeing any problems with pricing.