5 ms·
Three of the oldest stars in the universe found circling the Milky Way
- rthnbgrredf 3y ago> Interestingly they’re all quite fast — hundreds of kilometers per second I bet that the milky way could only capture these ultra fast moving stars because of dark matter.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoBut they're in the halo. Can they actually be gravitationally bound at that distance at those velocities? Is even the (computed by other means) amount of dark matter enough for them to be captured?
- Keysh 3y agoIf they weren’t gravitationally bound, they would have left the Milky Way billions of years ago. Also, “in the halo” doesn’t necessarily mean “far from the center of the galaxy”; it means “not orbiting in the disk”.[1] Some of these stars are closer to the galactic center than the Sun. [1] And further away from the center of the galaxy than the bulge — but the bulge is much smaller than the orbit of the Sun.
- klyrs 3y agoThis echoes a thought I had recently -- stars traveling at relativistic speeds should look deceptively young due to time dilation. But while this is certainly speedy, mere hundreds of km/s isn't enough to significantly prolong the observed lifetime of a star.
- malfist 3y ago> should look deceptively young due to time dilation That's not how we date stars. We typically date the star by it's metallic content. More non-hydrogen elements in it's spectrograph, then we know it's an older generation of stars.
- Starlevel004 3y ago> More non-hydrogen elements in it's spectrograph, then we know it's an older generation of stars. It's actually the exact opposite, but yes.
- malfist 3y agoYes thank you, got it backwards
- pfdietz 3y agoThere's some weird caveats, like so-called "Lead Stars". These are aged stars with very large amounts of lead relative to other heavy elements. This happens because lead is the end nuclear of the so-called s-process, where neutrons are captured at a slow rate in large stars whose internal processes produce some neutrons by (alpha,n) reactions. In lead stars, there are so few seed nuclei (those metals) that each of the seed nuclei that are there can capture many more neutrons.
- jddj 3y agoDoes it matter in this context whether it's metals or tree rings or wrinkles around the eyes? It's all time, right?
- klyrs 3y ago> It's all time, right? Sure, but we can measure time dilation between the peak of a mountain and the base of a mountain, due to the differing velocities. Time is relative!
- pdonis 3y ago> stars traveling at relativistic speeds So far, to my knowledge, we have not observed any. As you note, hundreds of km/s is way too small to have any appreciable effect.
- ChrisGranger 3y ago"The fastest star ever seen is moving at 8% the speed of light" https://www.space.com/fastest-star-ever-moves-8-percent-light-speed.html https://www.space.com/fastest-star-ever-moves-8-percent-ligh...
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago0.08c translates into a gamma of 1.0032. That's not enough for relativity to be doing much...
- bloopernova 3y agoHow much relativity effects occur at 0.2c? A sci-fi book series I'm reading has warships unable to hit other ships if their relative velocity is above 0.2c. I was wondering if that was realistic.
- klyrs 3y agoI found this to help me not sound completely ignorant in this thread https://www.omnicalculator.com/physics/time-dilation https://www.omnicalculator.com/physics/time-dilation
- luyu_wu 3y agoAs the lorentz factor calculated above, not much! Time would only be dilated by that much, and length by the the same amount. It'd definetly be hard to hit something at that speed, but not due to relativity!
- pdonis 3y agoThe gamma factor at 0.2c is only 1.02, which isn't much of an effect. The main difficulty with aiming at something moving that fast wouldn't be time dilation, it would be light travel time delay. For example, suppose the other ship is one light-second away from yours and is moving at 0.2c. You're seeing the other ship where it was one second ago, and in that time it has moved 1/5 of a light second. Plus, supposing you're firing a laser at it, the laser will take another second to get to the target, so you have to aim 2/5 of a light second away from where you're seeing the other ship. And during that time the other ship could change direction and spoil your aiming calculation. The sci-fi book series probably is making some assumptions about how fast the ships can change direction, how fast and accurately they can aim, and typical distances between ships during combat to come up with the 0.2c number.
- chasil 3y agoThe stars that are going beyond our cosmological horizon are effectively traveling away from us faster than their light towards us. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_horizon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_horizon "Or, more precisely, there are events that are spatially separated for a certain frame of reference happening simultaneously with the event occurring right now for which no signal will ever reach us, even though we can observe events that occurred at the same location in space that happened in the distant past. "While we will continue to receive signals from this location in space, even if we wait an infinite amount of time, a signal that left from that location today will never reach us."
- jajko 3y agoSun is moving cca 230 km/s around Sagittarius A*, so something even further from the center would have even higher speed if rotating at same speed (don't know if that's the trend in our galaxy, very much a tourist in astronomy)... doesn't sound that unusual unless its those 999km/s corner cases
- deciduously 3y agoExcept these stars are rotating the other direction
- ashes-of-sol 3y agoOrbital velocity increases as you get closer to the middle, not the other way around. An example closer to home, our orbital velocity around the Sun is 29.8km/s. Mercury is 47.9km/s (on average, it actually varies throughout its orbit). Neptune is 5.4km/s.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoThis doesn't apply to stars in the Milky Way. Unlike planets around a star, stars in the Milky Way don't follow Keplerian physics in their orbit around the galactic center. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_rotation_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_rotation_curve ``` The rotational/orbital speeds of galaxies/stars do not follow the rules found in other orbital systems such as stars/planets and planets/moons that have most of their mass at the centre. Stars revolve around their galaxy's centre at equal or increasing speed over a large range of distances. In contrast, the orbital velocities of planets in planetary systems and moons orbiting planets decline with distance according to Kepler’s third law. ```
- ck2 3y agoSo a vaguely related question for an astronomy thread about our galaxy since smart people lurk here: If the center of most galaxies is a super-massive black hole, including the Milky Way, and most of those SMBH have relativistic jets with lobes throwing out particles near light speed 1. Have we detected such lobes in the milky way? why not? 2. If those particles are going near the speed of light yet have no reason to slow down unless captured, unlikely outside of their original galaxy, they are still going for billions of years? (wow if so!) 3. If some of those jets from other galaxies are pointed at earth and contain physical particles with mass near the speed of light, why don't they do measurable damage? reference: https://www.nustar.caltech.edu/page/relativistic_jets https://www.nustar.caltech.edu/page/relativistic_jets
- Dylan16807 3y agoThey do do measurable damage! The amount we measure is extremely small because of how wide the beams are by the time they reach earth.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoHey! Making extragalactic gamma-ray astronomy possible is not damage!
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoI'm not an astronomer, and may or may not be smart. 1. I don't know; Google probably does know. 2. Those jets aren't in a complete vacuum. They're running into galactic gas, of which, on a galactic scale, there is quite a bit. 3. Several reasons. One, they aren't a perfect "beam". They spread out. If you're a few billion years away, they spread out quite a bit in that distance. Then, to get to us, they go through their galaxy's gas, intergalactic space (not totally empty), our galaxy's gas, and finally our atmosphere. Each of those reduces the amount of radiation. Oh, yeah, our magnetosphere deflects charged particles, too.
- jwells89 3y agoFor #3, I think I remember reading that the Sun’s heliosphere (which contains the entirety of the familiar Solar System) also plays a role in cutting down what gets to Earth, but I may be misremembering.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> are still intact today I would suggest, instead, that we can still see their light. They may have popped their clogs, long ago, and we would not have known, as we're seeing their old videotapes. There's something called the "Cosmic Event Horizon," or somesuch. It's the distance from us, that we'll never be able to see, because it is more than 13.8 billion light-years away, and we'll never see anything beyond. Every time I think about the distances and scales of the universe, I get a headache. [EDITED TO ADD] I wasn't talking about the nearby stars, and neither were they. That quote was talking about distant, red-shifted galaxies.
- colechristensen 3y agoIf they're circling the Milky Way, they are close, in a cosmic sense. The milky way is only 100,000 light years across. Stars of a certain small size will also continue shining for a trillion years.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoYeah, it's interesting that folks seemed to take offense at what I said. It's really pretty much exactly what you'd hear, from any astronomer (which I'm not, but one of my favorite shows is How the Universe Works). Not all stars are created equal. Blue giants may only live a few billion years, while red dwarfs will last practically forever.
- colechristensen 3y agoThese are 13 billion year old stars that are only 30,000 light years away, that’s like one part in 40,000 of how long they’ve lived. They are most certainly still there shining. Is just incorrect to be pedantic about there light being there but maybe not them.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThat was a rhetorical statement. It's a "Here, there be dragonnes" type of thing. We say stuff like that, hereabouts, all the time. My statement was incredibly mild, compared to some of the crazy stuff people say, here.
- ErigmolCt 3y agoWow... discovering some of the oldest stars in our galactic neighborhood is a remarkable thing
- marcosdumay 3y agoShouldn't they be distributed everywhere? Finding some close to us is just expected.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoSure, it's not surprising that some exist in our galaxy, but actually finding some is still remarkable!
- actionfromafar 3y agoAren't some galaxies older than other.
- Sharlin 3y agoIndeed. And there should be plenty of them, given that a large fraction of all stars (evidently including these three) are K-type orange dwarfs slightly smaller and cooler than the sun. They last tens of billions of years on the main sequence, burning their hydrogen at a leisurely pace. A large majority of stars born back then should still be alive and kicking long after the sun is gone.
- xenadu02 3y agoThey are distributed everywhere. These three are among the oldest and presumably of similar age to other "oldest" stars in other galaxies. I take it to mean many galaxies have surviving stars from the population of stars expected to still exist. Honestly it seems obvious. Any given galaxy will either be as old as those stars, formed from the merger of other galaxies some of which are old, or will have stolen some stars from an old galaxy during a flyby. This story boils down to "at large scale stars are roughly evenly distributed".
- caf 3y ago
- labrador 3y agoThey should name them the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost
- bufferoverflow 3y agoConsidering there are 200 to 1000 billion galaxies (based on what we can see), the odds of that is not just astronomically low, it's basically impossible. Which tells you that the method for determining the age of stars is wrong.
- alexander2002 3y ago(Disclaimer: I am not an expert) In my humble opinion, because the black hole calculations and other important proven scientific equations must have taken into account the age of stars, the age of a star could be imprecise but not outright wrong.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoThey have just dropped the qualifier "known" from the title, as in it should be read "Three of the oldest known stars found in our galaxy". We obviously don't know the age of each and every star in the entire universe, calm down dude.
- munk-a 3y agoI feel like it's quite reasonable to criticize them for that though. "Known" isn't something we can automatically assume - there could be theoretical boundaries on star life and these objects were detected as being extremely close to that boundary.
- dotnet00 3y agoKnown kind of by definition implies that it's based on our current knowledge.
- munk-a 3y agoI'd clarify - there's a distinction between "oldest observed" and "oldest we think are possible" and the known in this context (for me at least) leans strongly into the "oldest observed" camp for me - though, as with all things english, technically it could mean anything.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoJournal article for those that are a bit wary of MIT press releases by now: https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/530/4/4712/7667655 https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/530/4/4712/7667655
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]