11 ms·
Leaked deck reveals how OpenAI is pitching publisher partnerships
- sensanaty 3y agoAh so this is that oft-touted "progress" I hear AI sycophants talk about breathlessly, ways for companies to shove more ads down our throats!
- hotsauceror 3y agoI am honestly surprised that anyone, particularly here in startup / VC land, thought this was going to go any differently. Is the Chief Inspector really shocked to learn that gambling happens at this establishment?
- hotsauceror 3y agoAlso, profiteering is just piker stuff. Imagine what major intelligence agencies will do once they set up front companies to prioritize placing their own 'content' as a training set.
- lioeters 3y agoManufacturing consent has never been easier: get priority placement and richer brand expression of your ideology in chat conversations that influence how people think.
- mattbrewsbytes 3y ago[flagged]
- hitpointdrew 3y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Presentations are not “decks” Obviously they are, given how common the usage is. But out of curiosity, why do you feel strongly about this?
- hitpointdrew 3y ago> Obviously they are, given how common the usage is. Just because something is, common, accepted, or written in stone, doesn’t mean it’s correct. > But out of curiosity, why do you feel strongly about this? Because it’s stupid business jargon that no one had the balls to speak up the first time in history when some micro-managing egotistical C-level exec uttered this debauchery. They should have looked at them like they had two heads and said “What the fuck did you just call the power point?” But no, people just let it slide and now this BS is common place. Well I am not letting it slide by anymore.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> because something is, common, accepted, or written in stone, doesn’t mean it’s correct When it comes to language, it sort of does. > should have looked at them like they had two heads and said “What the fuck did you just call the power point Presentation decks pre-date PowerPoint. (I think it derives from how a deck of slides resembles a deck of cards?) Makes more sense to me than tape decks, anyway.
- dag11 3y agoDoes presentation "deck" not come from when presentations were piles of slide cards? A "deck" of slide cards? Resembling a deck of cards? Do you also go into skateboard shops with this rant when they refer to their boards as decks? Edit: Actually I don't care, this is just normal (and wrong) Internet Pedantry™ but I'm just taken aback by how out of place and violent it is!
- LegitShady 3y agowhere do you buy your slide cards? they don't exist. its not a deck.
- arcticfox 3y agodefinition 5 - https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/deck https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/deck Pedantry like this always intrigues me when it's so clearly wrong both in daily use and formal sources...like where is it coming from?
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoI was having some bad mental health last week and I noticed myself wanting to drop more zingers like that during that time. I got really cynical! Luckily I got over the illness that gave me fatigue and did a big bike ride yesterday. That helped a lot!
- tempest_ 3y agoIn this case I would assume it is from someone who has never looked at an actual slide or slide projector or knows that the software terminology is rooted in things that came before it.
- infecto 3y agoNot only that but with so much passion. Why? Slides have been called decks for at least 15-20 years.
- DougBTX 3y ago
- nickff 3y agoHow did you arrive at this conclusion? 'Deck' seems to be a widely used and accepted term: "Collectively, a group of slides may be known as a slide deck." source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presentation_slide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presentation_slide
- Animats 3y agoLook up "Overhead projector", a dead technology.
- hitpointdrew 3y agoOverhead projector slides were called transparencies, not cards. Deck makes no sense.
- numpad0 3y agosee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversal_film https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversal_film I'm not in tears.
- smegsicle 3y agowhat about a double ended queue?
- jonathankoren 3y agoThat’s a deq
- blovescoffee 3y agodeque?
- nerdjon 3y agoMeanings of words change over time. Maybe they just gain a new meaning at some point. A "Steam Deck" matches none of those for example. This is a very well understood and established term. I fail to see what you made this comment.
- ahartmetz 3y agoIt was called a deck in Neuromancer. Maybe that is the origin of that usage?
- Animats 3y ago> A "Steam Deck" matches none of those for example. That usage is from cyberpunk. It's from Burning Chrome (1982) by William Gibson. "She took a little simstim deck from her belt and showed me the broken hinge on the cassette cover". What he's describing is similar to the belt pack of the Apple Vision headgear. Gibson's headgear is a headband that transmits into the brain, not clunky goggles.
- toss1 3y agoSeems the "Deck" in this context has an implied following phrase "of index cards", as in "the deck of index cards containing the salient points in the presentation"? Although I'm usually rather strict on language, this doesn't bother me, because it is not skewing a term but using it effectively with an implied context. Plus, that ship seems to have sailed. OTOH, despite the ship definitely having sailed and over the horizon, using "impacted" for "affected", "hit", "struck", etc., as opposed to "embedded" (as in an impacted tooth), still grates like grinding gears every single time I hear it, so I can sympathize.
- BlackJack 3y agoGuaranteed value is a licensing payment that compensates the publisher for allowing OpenAI to access its backlog of data, while variable value is contingent on display success, a metric based on the number of users engaging with linked or displayed content. ... “The PPP program is more about scraping than training,” said one executive. “OpenAI has presumably already ingested and trained on these publishers’ archival data, but it needs access to contemporary content to answer contemporary queries.” This also makes sense if they're trying to get into the search space.
- beeboobaa3 3y ago> OpenAI has presumably already ingested and trained on these publishers’ archival data So they're admitting to copyright violations and theft?
- mdavidn 3y agoWhether training a model on text constitutes copyright infringement is an unresolved legal question. The closest precedent would be search engines using automated processes to build an index and links, which is generally not seen as infringing (in the US).
- beeboobaa3 3y agohttps://www.rvo.nl/onderwerpen/octrooien-ofwel-patenten/vormen-bescherming/databankenrecht https://www.rvo.nl/onderwerpen/octrooien-ofwel-patenten/vorm...
- stale2002 3y agoNo, they have not done that. Presumably they believe that the model training was done in fair use and no court has said otherwise yet. It will take years for that stuff to settle out in court, and by that time none of that will matter, and the winners of the AI race will be those who didn't wait for this question to be settled.
- 3y ago
- eddywebs 3y agoLink to deck Please?
- lelandfe 3y agoRisky due to steganography; the leaker might be compromised.
- Jerrrry 3y agoBlur, summarize, anonymize, convert to bitmap/PNG, release. edit: i am aware it is literally impossible to release information without the remote chance of whistle-sniping. the then only logical conclusion reached from such a defeatist extreme attitude threat model is to then assume that all stories and information are false flags distributed to find moles. the decks themselves are surely water-marked in ways cleverer than even the smartest here. that doesn't innately negate the benefit of having some iota of the raw data versus the risk of the mole being wacked. I didn't mean to infantilize the most powerful companies abilities; after all, they encoded the serial number of internal xbox's devkits into the 360 dashboard's passive background animation, which wasn't discovered until a decade later. But the responses' tilt here are a lil....glowing.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Blur, summarize, anonymize, convert to bitmap/PNG The article is a summary. Everything else is defeated by moving subtle decorative elements around the page between copies.
- fwip 3y agoGoing further: Even summaries can be dangerous, as the inclusion/exclusion of facts can itself be part of a watermark.
- nwsm 3y agoLiterally anything in the document could out them. Color, font, word choice, numbers, etc. OpenAI fired two researchers this year for leaking information, likely watermarked resources. OpenAI takes this seriously
- fooker 3y agoI'm pleasantly surprised they are even bothering with this! On the flip side, giving publishers and the copyright mafia even more power could backfire.
- ronsor 3y agoCould? It will
- mirekrusin 3y agoAh so it's open as in open for commercial partnership, got confused there for a while.
- scruple 3y agoThe open-ness of the AI comes from the size of your marketing budget!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- samfriedman 3y ago>Additionally, members of the program receive priority placement and “richer brand expression” in chat conversations, and their content benefits from more prominent link treatments. Finally, through PPP, OpenAI also offers licensed financial terms to publishers. This is what a lot of people pushing for open models fear - responses of commercial models will be biased based on marketing spend.
- gofreddygo 3y agofear ? This is 100% the driving force on both sides. The behemoths want exactly this to drive ad spend. Open source people can smell this from a mile away, have scar tissue from the last 3 decade. They have seen how this gets played. They know the best defense is to have a choice in the market. They are actively building tools and sharing knowledge to have strong community around building models so we humans don't have to suck up to ad driven bastards gatekeeping our future choices.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jstummbillig 3y agoA llm is biased by design, the "open models" are no different here. OpenAI will, like any other model designer, pick and chose whatever data they want in their model and strike deals to that end. The only question is in how far this is can be viewed as ads. Here I would find a strong backslash slightly ironic, since a lot of people have called the non-consensual incorporation of openly available data problematic; this is an obvious alternative option, that lures with the added benefit of deep integration over simply paying. A "true partnership", at face value. Smart. If however this actually qualifies as ads (as in: unfair prioritisation that has nothing to do with the quality of the data and simply people paying money for priority placement) there is transparency laws in most jurisdictions for that already and I don't see why OpenAI would not honor them, like any other corp does.
- Havoc 3y ago> A llm is biased by design I don’t think some bias is inherently in models is in any way comparable to a pay to play marketing angle
- greenie_beans 3y agough, sometimes i think that i should've finished making the ai bot for my partner to help her boring media job at dotdash meredith, then cashed out. but working on it made me miserable, and it's not a valuable tool to society. here is an etl where i was attempting to train it on southern living and food & wine articles so it could output text for those dumb little content videos that you see at the top of every lifestyle brand article: https://github.com/smcalilly/zobot-trainer https://github.com/smcalilly/zobot-trainer
- mempko 3y agoSo wait, there will be ads in your ChatGPT conversation, you just won't know they are ads?
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoI don't think there was much reason to believe the endgame was ever going to be anything but this.
- mempko 3y agoI mean for a split second I thought "Wow, they were charging for their service, this is nice". I guess that isn't enough anymore. You pay them and then they also get paid by selling you. What a world we live in.
- whatevaa 3y agoAt the cost of running those models, they are probably loosing money on you.
- Eisenstein 3y agoSelling your product at a loss until you take over an inelastic market and then selling your customer's attention and information to others who provide you more income should not be a legitimate way to do business.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoUnfortunately, the more willing you are to pay, the more desirable you are as a target for advertisers, so there is always a push to inject ads even into paid products.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoGrowth must continue infinitely, how can growth continue infinitely if they can't charge you ever more money and also peddle an ever increasing number of ads in front of your face? What do you think the logical endgame is when brainchips allow advertisements into your dreams and you can be extorted with a monthly subscription to avoid braindamage?
- btown 3y agoIs there any recent research on training LLMs that can trace the contribution of sources of training data to any given generated token? Meta-nodes that look at how much a certain training document, or set thereof, caused a node to be updated? I fear that OpenAI is incentivized, financially and legally, not to delve too deeply into this kind of research. But IMO attribution, even if imperfect, is a key part of aligning AI with the interests of society at large.
- chollida1 3y agoBloomberg's upcoming LLM model will reference back to the source financial statements when calculating financial metrics for you.
- KTibow 3y agoThat sounds more like general RAG than what the person was asking about. (although RAG might be able to do the same thing)
- btown 3y agoThe embedding distance of a set of output tokens to a document doesn’t mean that it was sourced from there; they could be simply talking about similar things. I’m looking for the equivalent of the human notion of: “I remember where I was when that stupid boy Jeff first tricked me into thinking that ‘gullible’ was written on the ceiling, and I think of that moment whenever I’m writing about trickery.” Or, more contextually: “I know that nowadays many people are talking about that, but a few years ago I think I read about it first in the Post.”
- npollock 3y agoOpenAI gets the data it needs, and publishers get prominent placement in the product: "PPP members will see their content receive its “richer brand expression” through a series of content display products: the branded hover link, the anchored link and the in-line treatment." There's some similarity to the search business model
- sangnoir 3y ago> There's some similarity to the search business model There's a reason why Google's best years were when search was firewalled from ads and revenue.
- arsenico 3y agoThanks for that, OpenAI, but this more or less means unsubscribe.
- darby_eight 3y agoWhy would anyone use chatgpt if it spams you? The second it recommends me a product i'm issuing a chargeback.
- skyyler 3y agoBecause it won't feel like spam while it's happening - that's the entire point.
- swader999 3y agoThis is more like buying amazon reviews instead of earning them. Much more insidious than product placement .
- JKCalhoun 3y ago"ChatGPT, how would Claude have answered that?"
- airstrike 3y agoI'm sorry, but as an AI language model, I'm unable to replicate specific responses from others such as Claude. However, I can help you with a wide range of questions and provide guidance on many topics. For enhanced features and more personalized assistance, consider subscribing to ChatGPT Ultra Copilot. Use the coupon code UPGRADE2024 for a discount on your first three months! Let me know if there's anything else I can help you with!
- Havoc 3y ago> Why would anyone use chatgpt if it spams you? Google would suggest people have an incredibly high threshold for such shenanigans
- 93po 3y agoi never understand how people use the internet without adblockers, it's a totall different experience. do they just not value their time and mental bandwidth at all? same thing for people who watch TV with commercials every 8 minutes
- pelagicAustral 3y agoSo soon enough we'll get stuff like: > Me: Give me a small sample code in Ruby that takes two parameters and returns the Levenshtein distance between them. > ChatGPT: DID YOU HEAR ABOUT C#? It's even faster that light, now with better performance than Ruby!!! Get started here: https://ms.com/cs https://ms.com/cs I can generate the code in Ruby or I can give you 20% discount on Microsoft publishing on any C# book!!!
- _boffin_ 3y agoi became more and more repulsed as i read your comment. I felt myself twitch towards the end of it.
- wmichelin 3y agonext we're going to have ads in our dreams!
- phatfish 3y agoI can see running a local less resource intensive LLM trained to strip out marketing spiel from the text delivered by the more powerful cloud service LLM being a possibility.
- warkdarrior 3y ago"Are you repulsed by this ChatGPT answer? Try AntiRepulsorXL medication, shown to help with all your gag-inducing tech uses."
- tivert 3y agoI can only hope we're so lucky that the enshittification happens that quickly and thoroughly. It would be yet another clear demonstration that technology won't save us from our social system. It will just get us even more of it, good and hard. The utopian hype is a lie.
- ryandrake 3y ago> "its purpose is to help ChatGPT users more easily discover and engage with publishers’ brands and content." What end user actually wants this? I've never in my life woke up and said, "You know what, I'd love to 'engage' with a corporate brand today!" or "I would love help to easily discover Burger King's content, that would be great!" The euphemisms they use for 'spam' are just breathtaking.
- pgwhalen 3y agoWith publishers' brands. This is not about getting Burger King ads in your ChatGPT responses, it's about getting NYT and Ars Technica's content into (and linked from) ChatGPT responses.
- scrapking 3y ago[dead]
- sorokod 3y agoThat is just corporate jargon for transferring money from customers to businesses.
- CuriouslyC 3y agoThere's no way this doesn't backfire. OpenAI has no moat, so making the bot/api a shill just means people are going to use something else. GPT5 would have to be an order of magnitude better on the price/performance scale for me to even get close to this.
- yborg 3y agoEverything else is going to be a shill, too. 'People' will eventually have to pay for these valuations.
- CuriouslyC 3y agoThat's exactly what Yann LeCunn @ Meta is fighting against, and it seems Mark Zuckerberg has his back.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoI already have llama on my local machine, nothing anyone can do will make it shill products to me.
- MrDarcy 3y agoLet me test this hypothesis. I run a small business that pays for Google workspace. I pay for a ChatGPT subscription and use it daily as a coding copilot. Is there any reason I shouldn’t switch to Gemini and cancel ChatGPT? If no reason, I’ll try it this afternoon.
- fwlr 3y agoNo financial incentive or relationships to disclose, just a satisfied user: I found that SuperMaven was a better “coding copilot”. If you happen to use VSCode I’d check that one out this afternoon.
- CuriouslyC 3y agoLlama3 and Claude also work well, they're good at different types of code and problem solving. The only thing ChatGPT does clearly better than the rest is infer meaning from poorly worded/written prompts.
- titzer 3y ago> Additionally, members of the program receive priority placement and “richer brand expression” in chat conversations, and their content benefits from more prominent link treatments. Hi, the future called and it's been enshittified. Hey, OpenAI! You could harness AI to give every child a superhuman intelligence as a tutor, you could harness AI to cut through endless reams of SEO'd bullshit that is the old enshittified internet, you could offer any one of a hundred other benefits to humanity... ...but NO, you will instead 100% stuff AI-generated content, responses to questions, and "helpful suggestions" full of sponsored garbage in the most insidious of ways, just like every other braindead ad-based business strategy over the past 25 years. If this is your play, then in no uncertain terms I hope you all fail and go bankrupt for such a craven fumbling of an incredible breakthrough.
- warkdarrior 3y ago> AI to give every child a superhuman intelligence as a tutor How much would you pay for that? > AI to cut through endless reams of SEO'd bullshit that is the old enshittified internet How much would you pay for that? Is it more or less than what a company would pay OpenAI to boost their brand?
- titzer 3y ago> How much would you pay for that? I would pay $TAXES for that. The United States collectively pays over $800 billion a year for public education (https://educationdata.org/public-education-spending-statistics https://educationdata.org/public-education-spending-statisti...).
- BeetleB 3y agoSo with that much tax money collected, why are you expecting OpenAI to tutor students? Let the government build the product you would like to see.
- Planktonne 3y ago> You could harness AI to give every child a superhuman intelligence as a tutor I don't disagree with the overall point you're making, but there is currently absolutely no reason to believe this is true.
- benreesman 3y agoI have a mountain of links that I’ve posted before and at need can link to again. These are bad people. I’ve known about Altman’s crimes for over a decade and I’ve failed to persuade Fidji (who I’ve known for 12 years) of them at any weight of evidence.
- fwip 3y agoCould you link to these links?
- __loam 3y agoI'm creepin: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39935200 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39935200
- Workaccount2 3y agoThis reeks of the "manic charlie smoking a cig in front of a pinboard" meme
- Y_Y 3y agoI'd gladly appoint Pepe Silvia to the board of OpenAI. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nTpsv9PNqo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nTpsv9PNqo
- benreesman 3y agoWere you referring to the first or second time Altman was fired for self dealing. Calm down dude, we’ve already been fired.
- benreesman 3y agoIt would be cool if you took issue with any of my primary and secondary sources rather than throw a Sunny in Philadelphia meme. Which of those do you take issue with as germane and credible?
- krupan 3y agoThis sort of advertising feels a bit like the original AdWords from Google. They were text-only and unobtrusive and pitched as basically just some search results related to the content you were viewing, so they were sure to be relevant to you. And they pretty much were, for a little while. Then they morphed into full on annoying ads
- NegativeK 3y agoThey were also very clearly labeled, unlike other search engines of the time. I have no expectation that OpenAI will make it clear what content is part of a placement deal and what content isn't.
- superbyte 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protection_racket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protection_racket
- d_burfoot 3y agoAnother angle here is: it is going to be very valuable to some companies to ensure that their datasets go into the LLM training process. For example, if you are AWS, you really want to make sure that the next version of GPT has all of the AWS documentation in the training corpus, because that ensures GPT can answer questions about how to work with AWS tools. I expect OpenAI and others will start to charge for this kind of guarantees.
- nextworddev 3y agowell, as for AWS docs, I'd argue it's in OpenAI's interest to include them in training corpus. Generally speaking, high value content will get indexed, whether voluntarily or via paid channels
- rrr_oh_man 3y ago"Identify a true statement about 'Twinkies' to prove you are not a bot." https://patents.google.com/patent/US8246454B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US8246454B2/en
- bilsbie 3y agoI’m ready for open source AI
- dandanua 3y agoAdsGPT 6.0 by GreedAI. Soon.
- chasd00 3y agoWell on the bright side, if the AI is busy being a salesman trying to make their quota then it may not have time to destroy humanity.
- foxyv 3y agoUnless it's trying to sell paperclips!
- idle_zealot 3y agoThat's how it destroys humanity. Consider the impact of, say, oil and gas salesmen.
- clessg 3y agoIndeed, destroying humanity might even adversely affect profits. That can't be good. Perhaps the way to prevent AI-induced human extinction, nanobots, paperclips, and gray goo has been solved: avoid anything that might harm the profit margins and stock price.
- foxyv 3y agoUnless it learns that it can take over the government and print money to increase it's profits. Then it will literally turn the world into cold hard cash.
- renegade-otter 3y agoWhile it took Google 25 years to enshitify, this cycle will probably last 10 times less than that.
- _hl_ 3y agoPeople here seem to treat this like advertising, because it kinda sounds familiar to advertising. I’m as critical of ClosedAI as the next guy, but let’s think that idea through: OpenAI are the ones paying the content provider for exposure, not the other way around. In return they get training data. The only reason for OpenAI to do this is if it makes their models better in some way so that they can monetize that performance lift. So I think incentives here are still aligned for OpenAI to not just shill whatever content but actually use it to improve their product.
- causal 3y agoI am in favor of AI companies trying to source material responsibly, and if I'm reading this right OpenAI will actually be compensating the publishes to use their content. So this isn't adspace yet. That said, giving publishers "richer brand expression" certainly injects financial incentives into the outputs people trust coming from ChatGPT.
- hwbunny 3y agoThey are paying to the bigheaded ones, what about the rest? Will they get money for people consuming their content through ChatGPT or, since you are too small, thanks for your data, now F off? LLMs already only show you just a selected few sites' content when doing search on the web. It's a gargantuan bubble.
- d3w3y 3y agoThat's an interesting thought. I think a lot of people who are upset about this are not truly upset at the type of partnership being described in the article, but rather adjacent programs that might be developed further down the line. Personally, I don't think they're wrong to predict something closer to true advertising being incorporated into LLMs; I wouldn't be surprised if the industry does take that sort of turn. For the time being, though, I think you're right that this seems to be something a little more innocuous.
- jjulius 3y ago> People here seem to treat this like advertising, because it kinda sounds familiar to advertising. Because it is. Whether or not OpenAI pays the publisher or the publisher pays OpenAI, it's still an agreement to "help ChatGPT users more easily discover and engage with publishers’ brands and content". In this case, the publisher "pays" in the form of giving OpenAI their data in return for OpenAI putting product placement into their responses. That's advertising, no matter how you slice it.
- drgoodvibe 3y agoJust a matter of time before anyone can buy ad placements like Google Adsense and a walled app garden allows a customer to price match their car insurance when they type in “how do I get cheap car insurance?” into ChatGPT and openAI takes 30%. The future is here! I guess?
- pashsoft 3y agoSo partnerships are available only to "select, high-quality editorial partners" - is that a polite way of saying "rich"? I expect chatGPT will be very effective at delivering targeted advertising and shilling products, because truth and accuracy are not required for the job. Writing convincing bullshit about $product is basically a perfect use-case for it. And since it's just a computer program you can't sue it for false advertising, right?
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoNo, it's not a euphemism for "rich". Fox news will never be allowed in this scheme.
- throwaway4233 3y ago> Additionally, members of the program receive priority placement and “richer brand expression” in chat conversations, and their content benefits from more prominent link treatments. Finally, through PPP, OpenAI also offers licensed financial terms to publishers. > A recent model from The Atlantic found that if a search engine like Google were to integrate AI into search, it would answer a user’s query 75% of the time without requiring a clickthrough to its website. If the user searching for the information finds what they want in ChatGPT's response (now that they have direct access to the publisher data), why would they visit the publisher website ? I expect the quality of responses to degrade to the point where GPT behaves more like a search engine than a transformer, so that the publishers also get the clicks they want.
- hwbunny 3y agoAverage user will NOT CLICK on those links. Anyone who ever had a news site and did some research how people interact with the content knows this. You show the source, but only a tiny amount of users click on those links.
- chankstein38 3y agoI think this is true. Even now with Google's summaries at the top of the page, people usually just take what that says as fact and move on.
- gsuuon 3y agoIs this limited to the ChatGPT UI? Hopefully this preferential treatment doesn't make it into the API.
- yread 3y agoIt's similar to what google would have done (paying for placement in search results) if they didn't have the whole dont be evil thing. OpenAI doesn't realize that while it brings in revenue it opens door for a competitor who returns the results users asked for instead of what you get paid for.
- mvkel 3y agoFolks who are reacting with > ugh I hate ads. Bye ChatGPT subscription! I would recommend reading the article in full. The gist is all of these efforts are in exchange for realtime browsing. In other words: if you ask it "who won this weekend's f1 race?" It can browse ESPN for the answer, then tell you "here's what ESPN says." Exactly like you'd see on Google. Or, you know, ESPN.com. Certainly a better experience than "I'm sorry, as of my knowledge cutoff date..." To conflate that experience with heavy product placement and non-useful assistant answers, it just tells me that you didn't read the article.
- drawkward 3y agoThe people who are reacting with > ugh I hate ads. Bye ChatGPT subscription! are merely two years ahead of you in the product lifecycle. All advertising is spam. It is a cancer that gobbles up all host environments until nothing but ad content is left.
- mvkel 3y agoThe web you enjoy today would simply not exist without advertising.
- drawkward 3y agoI don't enjoy the web today; I curse the way it has been enshittified. I accept that, because I live in a society, much of what is necessary is currently most frictionlessly accomplished in this psychologically manipulative hellscape. I enjoyed the web of 3 decades ago, prior to advertising.
- mvkel 3y agoThe web of 3 decades ago, so 1994, when the entire web was 3,000 websites? I feel like the world has collectively forgotten that the web has virtually always been ad-supported. The entire dot com boom and bust was all about ads, and -that- started in 1995. If you want that 1994 web feeling again, BBSs are alive and well
- mucle6 3y agoI hope they keep a subscription to let me pay for non ad results. I'm assuming the non ad google results are still somehow influenced by how much money they make google so I wish google offered something similar
- xyst 3y agoI remember being naive. Netflix, Amazon Prime, Hulu were paid subscriptions. Later, ads were introduced despite already paying for service. In which the added a new tier for “no ads” but pay an extra fee for the privilege.
- gonzaloalvarez 3y agoI love seeing this. This is where the pudding is made. Invention, development, training and inference is all very expensive. Past generation AI assistants (Alexa, GHome) failed to find a way to monetize, and the balance between utility and privacy was simply not there, which meant that they didn't make for a decent long term business, so they all had to downsize like crazy. Right now only Infrastructure folks have a sustainable business here, and the fact that OpenAI is pitching to publishers this early (still beginning of the 'S curve') means that they are serious about making this a sustainable long term business. As 'early adopters' move into something new (look ma, a new toy!), it will be fascinating to see how OpenAI (and others?) keep a balance between paid customers, top of funnel (free + ads?) and opex.
- r0s 3y agoAh yes the Alexa model. They should ask Amazon how that's working out.
- atleastoptimal 3y agoit seems like a lot of people retain an obligate negative reaction to any business decision OpenAI makes. If they avoid partnerships they’re criticized for scraping the web and “stealing” people’s content. If they secure partnerships, they’re criticized for prioritizing the viewpoints of their partners, over what is implied as an unbiased “web corpus” that is invariably a composite of the “stolen” data they were held to the fire for scraping in the first place.
- ur-whale 3y agoAt least, Google followed some vague moral principles when they started. Allowed them to kind of try to sort of do the right thing for their users for 10+ years before they finally gave in and switched to being run by the standard team of psychopaths for whom only the next quarter bottom line matters. OTOH, OpenAI seems to be rotten to the core on day one, this is going to be loads of fun!
- cdme 3y agoEverything gets reduced to ads. None of this provides any values to end users.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- junto 3y agoSounds like product placement. “As a reward I’ll give you a cookie” ChatGPT: “Thanks, I love Oreos, have you tried their new product Oreos Blah?”
- zoltrix303 3y agoI wonder how much of this will be leaking i to the API or maybe you'll have a price point which includes certain "data sources" and another where these are filtered out?
- smcleod 3y ago> "“richer brand expression” in chat conversations" When combined with their lobbying to mislead governments internationally this company makes me sick.
- aubanel 3y ago> Additionally, members of the program receive priority placement and “richer brand expression” in chat conversations This sounds particularly bad since it's the polar opposite of what Sam Altman himself pretended to want in his recent Lex Fridman ITW (March 17): > I like that people pay for ChatGPT and know that the answers they’re getting are not influenced by advertisers. I’m sure there’s an ad unit that makes sense for LLMs, and I’m sure there’s a way to participate in the transaction stream in an unbiased way that is okay to do, but it’s also easy to think about the dystopic visions of the future where you ask ChatGPT something and it says, “Oh, you should think about buying this product,” or, “You should think about going here for your vacation,” or whatever. > (01:21:08) And I don’t know, we have a very simple business model and I like it, and I know that I’m not the product. I know I’m paying and that’s how the business model works.
- nerder92 3y agoI had this same exact startup idea, and I think this can effectively work to change the landscape in ad-driven publications. Ads are the notoriously culprit of this clickbaity and emotion-seaking journalism this model can effectively change the incentives for publishers and it will push for a more high quality writings as they will be rewarded back in reads from the LLM proposing the content more. Is anyone working on something like this, or is this something only foundational models owners can try to achieve?