8 ms·
30% of Children Ages 5-7 Are on TikTok
- akira2501 3y agoI think we're going to need more than a survey of 1500 British households before we arrive at the conclusion suggested in the headline.
- gabriel-uribe 3y agoAnd it's only worse for 2023 results.
- hwbunny 3y agoYeah, children should be on the fields, working and socializing with other children, not watching the interwebz.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoi guess you're being sarcastic but i literally spent some part of my youth running around in corn fields socializing with other children. not as old fashioned as my dad who made some pocket change shucking corn as a kid. it wouldn't be a bad thing for kids these days to get out of the house and touch maize.
- jareds 3y agoAs a parent sending my children to the fields once in a while sounds great!
- Sharlin 3y agoNot sure. 1500 sounds like a fairly normal sample size for studies like this and more or less representative if it's reasonably unbiased.
- jareds 3y agoThe headline doesn't specify UK only. I wonder what the numbers are in other contries.
- l5870uoo9y 3y agoI wouldn’t be surprised if the numbers are similar in the rest of Europe and North America. Even national deviations, the numbers are high.
- falcolas 3y agoI personally agree. But I've also seen quite a few parents who use ipads as nannies, so it also wouldn't surprise me if it were accurate. I've come around to the screen-free childhood plan, but most people who I know that have implemented it are affluent enough to have a stay-at-home parent or a high quality daycare. Not using screens as a babysitter requires a significant amount of a parent's time and energy, so I also won't condemn any parents who use that strategy.
- jareds 3y agoI like the kids version of the Kindle Fire as a way for giving kids screen time. I don't think it's perfect but it offers a fairly large library of applications, games, and videos for a few bucks a month with out allowing internet access. Not all the content is educational but I haven't found anything inappropriate yet. It also offers pretty good options for setting limits. I'm sure you could do something similar on the iPad but I think it would require more effort to set up.
- cheeseomlit 3y agoI condemn them wholeheartedly. If you don't have the time and energy to raise your kids without regularly hypnotizing them via chinese doomscrolling then please just don't have kids.
- falcolas 3y agoRespectfully, with as flippant as employers can be with employees lives, a "good" parenting situation can become a bad situation in a matter of months. And that doesn't even cover scenarios where someone can become an only parent. Ideally, it's a place our social safety nets would be better, but they're pretty bad when it comes to helping children right now in the US.
- cheeseomlit 3y agoFair point and I realize not everyone has the resources to raise their kids the way they want to, but I get the impression most parents don't even want to keep their kids away from this stuff, regardless of their financial situation. There's a lot more awareness and concern in tech-related places like this, but the majority of the general population does not seem to have a problem with putting an iPad in front of a toddler, I see it all the time- in fact probably more commonly with middle-class families than working-class ones.
- hwbunny 3y agoAnd the rest of them on yt shorts? :D
- xyst 3y agoAnecdotally speaking, this is kind of true. Most parents just give up and instead of disciplining and raising their child. It’s just easier to give them a tablet loaded to the tits with “YouTube kids”, parental controlled Netflix, TikTok, and other short form video services. Have even seen children get access to unfiltered YT, TT, IG.
- realusername 3y agoYouTube clearly quickly became the world's biggest nanny. I don't think there's any way to undo that one anyways so I'm interested to see what will be the long term impacts of that in the future.
- 082349872349872 3y agoIt occasionally produces art: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1BneeJTDcU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1BneeJTDcU EDIT: Mr. Burnham is vintage 1990, so he's a bit too old to have been weaned onto it
- nkassis 3y agoReplaced the TV from the 80s and 90s.
- gen220 3y agoNot quite. There was 1 TV in the median household in the 80s and 90s, which made TV a contested common resource from one point of view and a focal point of social gathering from another point of view. The median American household today has >1 internet-enabled screens, many children from the age of 5-7 have their own "personal device".
- AlexandrB 3y ago90s TV at least had physical boundaries on its use. Most people couldn't watch TV in the bathroom for example. Phones and the Internet can be used anywhere at this point.
- 3y ago
- latchkey 3y agoMy partner and I kid sat for a family of 3 brothers, while the parents were out of town. The youngest, about 7 I think, would come home after school and just watch a TT-like show on TV where it was just endless "scrolling" through short videos that appeared as though they were straight off TT/Insta. He was literally addicted to it. Imagine someone producing/moderating that in a way to get kids to just continue to watch it non-stop. My point is, you don't even need an app and age verification... this stuff is just right there on regular old TV.
- rightbyte 3y agoIs the 'TT-like' show on one of the thousand Rakuten channels Samsung bother me with? I've seen some what seems like to be endless loops of short TT like videos there of like dogs doing dances and stuff.
- nostromo 3y agoTV and video games had similar issues in generations past. The solution is parents need to be involved with their children and set limitations on their use.
- latchkey 3y agoAgreed on the poor parenting. Video games are a very specific genre and in some ways, actually activate the brain. Not trying to defend gaming (I'm not a gamer), but my point is that we are regressing even further away from generations past. We get enough generations of this, and it becomes normal. This kid will grow up, have kids... and they will do same thing.
- pelagicAustral 3y agoIf both mom and dad are in the workforce, both are climbing the ladder, grinding everyday... commuting hours every day, always tired... and still not even making enough for a good mortgage... who's going to take care of the kids? I think maybe let's just buy a tablet or a phone to keep the kids quiet while we mull in the many ways we're not going anywhere in life.
- dj_mc_merlin 3y ago30% of Children Ages 5-7 Are Watching TV > People nowadays are letting their TVs be nannies instead of caring about their children. > This is fundamentally different from the last thousands of years because <some bullshit>
- dmm 3y agoPeople were panicking about opioid abuse in the 80s therefore concerns about fentanyl today are invalid. People were worried about computer security 30 years ago therefore computer security is nothing to worry about today. Russian aggression was a concern throughout the 20th century yet we are still here, Ukraine shouldn't worry so much. What is this general form of argument called? Appeal to nothing-ever-happens?
- dj_mc_merlin 3y agoYour examples are decades old. People have been worrying about technology spoiling their children since we've had writing. Are you arguing you were ruined by TVs and computers growing up? Or satanic music?
- cheeseomlit 3y agoAre you arguing that TVs and computers are not capable of ruining lives? There are a legion of washed up WoW addicts that would indicate they can, to name one example
- atonse 3y agoThe difference is that those other technologies weren't fine tuned to individuals to literally short-circuit their brains to get the most perfect amount of dopamine at the right time to keep them addicted. People aren't getting addicted as a side-effect. Addiction is the primary-effect of the way the companies have designed these experiences, and addition (or the more harmless term "customer engagement") is a direct measure of success at these companies. So the analogy breaks down pretty quickly. They're more like Slot machines, which are highly regulated and age-gated.
- 3y ago
- pesfandiar 3y agoThis is sad. As a parent of a grade-schooler, I feel helpless with a complete lack of awareness around this. It feels as if everyone is calming their kids with opiates and Xanax, and no one bats an eye because that's what everyone else is doing. Even if you're aware of the mental health issues associated with social media use, you have the option of either giving up and losing your kid to the phenomenon, or giving them FOMO and complexes by depriving them of a phone. The only positive trend I've seen is school districts banning smartphones. That could relieve some of the social pressure to hook your kid up with a smartphone so early in their life.
- squigz 3y ago(I'll preface this by saying I'm not a parent, and I don't raise children. I imagine it's not an easy endeavor. But...) > you have the option of either giving up and losing your kid to the phenomenon, or giving them FOMO and complexes by depriving them of a phone. Are these really the only 2 options you see? No "teach your child about the issues with being on a phone all day" or "set reasonable restrictions on phone usage"? Edit: People replying to this comment seem to have forgotten the role of parents.
- gaze 3y agoI don't think the personal responsibility of someone with a developing mind is any match for 10-20 years of extensive AB testing.
- squigz 3y agoWell... no, but neither is it a match for, say, thousands of years of drug abuse. And yet... Perhaps our parents have something to do with that?
- barbazoo 3y agoWhen I was a kid, all drugs were illegal, at least to me as a minor. My parents had the alcohol is bad and cigarettes are bad talks with me but even if I wanted to drink and smoke, it was hard to access until I got closer to the age where it was allowed anyway.
- jawns 3y agoWe're a homeschooling family with a single Pinwheel phone shared among our three kids. It has no browser and no way to access social media. But it does have basic smartphone functionality, like phone, texting, photos/videos, music, etc. In contrast, our kids tell us all the time that their peers in various extracurricular activities almost all have unrestricted phone and technology use. I would like to hope that if we raise our kids with "healthy" technology use, then they will ultimately be better off. But my fear is that unhealthy technology use is so pervasive that they'll end up in the same sort of unfortunate situation as being the only humans left after a zombie outbreak.
- winrid 3y agoI fear it will be difficult for me to do this and not make them social outcasts. Part of being a parent is also helping your kids fit in and be successful "socially". I think what you're doing is good. Hopefully enough parents do this that it doesn't seem weird when a little one doesn't have a phone. My one year old can already steal my phone, hold it, and scroll/mess with buttons with her thumbs, open camera to look at herself... so I try not to use it around her anymore.
- 9dev 3y agoAt some point we somehow decided being an outcast is bad all around. However, looking into the past, a lot of people who used to be loners became artists later in live, or scientists, or tinkerers. I know how this sounds at first, but having the time to drill down to the absolute core of something, uninterrupted by a big social circle or crushes yields its own merits.
- paulcole 3y ago> However, looking into the past, a lot of people who used to be loners became artists later in live, or scientists, or tinkerers. A lot of people who used to be loners become loners later in life, too. And a lot of artists, scientists, and tinkerers weren't loners early in life. You can make up whatever story your heart desires to convince yourself you're making a good decision.
- swalsh 3y agoVery troubling. In my opinion social media in general is like smoking. It's a generally negative thing that's addictive... but also pleasurable. Adults should be allowed to made decisions on what they do to themselves, but children should be protected. At the same time, society should make an effort to ensure everyone knows the risks.
- noobermin 3y agoThis seems to generate disgust in me, but it isn't much better than sitting in front of the television for hours which older generations normalised to be honest. I feel like the early internet was a little more intellectual than tiktok but essentially television returned just in a more purified dopamine releasing form. Perhaps the sense of disgust is due to comparison of what could have been?
- SSJPython 3y agoHow is this allowed?
- Ancalagon 3y agoKids from 5-7 have cell phones? And not only that but 25% do? News to me and that seems insane
- elzbardico 3y agoWell, so facebook or instagram or whatever else is fine? Kids that young shouldn't be using social networking that is also used by adults.
- pphysch 3y agoYeah. Suppose Big Bad Chinese TikTok were banned in USA. What is stopping someone from ripping a compilation of TikToks and uploading them to YouTube? How is that any different? It's good that TikTok is bringing attention to this issue but don't let anyone tell you for a second that it is the sole problem.
- elzbardico 3y agoTikTok Reefer Madness
- bjacobso 3y agoI don't think the TikTok ban is an adjudication of the TikTok scrolling behavior or addictive feedback loop. It's an adjudication on the idea that a company that controls those technologies could be help accountable by the United States. I think the current US stance is: we are allowing the crop dusting of american high schools with digital heroine, however, we demand the right to potentially regulate it in the future. A Chinese owned TikTok sits outside that potential regulation where a Facebook or YouTube exists within that potential regulation. China themselves ban TikTok for kids, and only have an educational version available.
- willsmith72 3y ago> so facebook or instagram or whatever else is fine? says who? they shouldn't be using social media full stop. handing a 5 year old a device is the cheapest and laziest way to parent, akin to feeding them mcdonalds
- lloydatkinson 3y agoPathetic parenting, or should I say, lack of.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- partiallypro 3y agoHow is this possible? Where is the parenting? I can understand maybe at the age of 13, you can let your kid go on Tiktok. Otherwise, this is pretty insane.
- takeda 3y agoAs a parent, that's crazy to me. I'm hoping to keep mine away from social media for as long as possible. It seems to create all kinds of mental issues.
- boringg 3y agoAm the anomaly here? No. one in my kids class is on TikTok and my kids don't use phones except to steal ours and take pictures or occasionally watch a shared family video. I'm not virtue signaling, I'm saying that I am surprised that this 30% is true.
- dnissley 3y agoHow can you be sure that no one in your kids class is on tiktok?
- boringg 3y agoI thought about that -- but I know the school doesn't allow phones and I see the kids in the neighborhood / after school. Noone is on phones except the parents.
- coolbreezetft24 3y agoSame, I have a 7 and 4 year old and I don't know any kids who use tiktok or even have a phone.
- thefz 3y agoWhere? Worldwide? West countries?
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoIt’s from a survey in the UK
- m3kw9 3y agoWhen shtty parents need some alone time at all costs, the perfect pairing is a phone and TikTok.
- ltbarcly3 3y agoI looked for the methodology for this study, I found it and it it seems well thought out, but there is not enough detail on how they removed selection bias to know for sure if these numbers are solid. However, everything they do say about the methodology points to it being a competent and properly run study, it's just that it is extremely hard to gather this data online in a way that ends up being representative even if your methods are sound. I would like to know more about the details of the study, but right now I would say it's reasonable to believe that there is a moderately high degree of certainty that these numbers are accurate (but of course the study was limited to the UK).
- b33j0r 3y agoMost of them don’t even bother to vote, so what did they expect? ;)
- _blz2 3y agojust maybe 5-6 years ago, attempts to regulate the time spent online by ones kids was met (on forums like *eddit and hackernews) with a sarcasm filled 'WiLl nO oNe tHinK oF tHe Kids' mockery and then pointing to the advent of books/newspapers/ipods etc having similar effects on society. Lol, techies are probably worse than the average person when it comes to figuring out how a society should function
- josephstalinOk 3y agoThe problem is not TikTok, is social media aimed at children in general. Singling out TikTok is just China bashing. Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter, Discord, all of them can be equally harmful or worse. Banning TikTok only is just the US government protecting Meta and Google businesses.
- duxup 3y agoMy kids have access to electronics, but they have to ask and they're monitored. And at 5-7 they didn't even have access that often... it is wild to me that kids that age would be out there free to roam the internet.
- pwthornton 3y agoThe Chinese Communist Party is loving that Americans are letting their kids’ brains be filled with lies and hate. What a self own.
- baal80spam 3y agoBut this is from UK.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoTranslation, 30% of parents are quite simply bad . Giving a phone or tablet to a child unsupervised . Unacceptable.
- freetime2 3y agoYouTube has also gotten pretty bad recently with Shorts.
- uuddlrlrbaba 3y agoThere is a movement on TikTok to transition to Shorts due to the looming ban
- uuddlrlrbaba 3y agoHow old were you when you gained access to the family computer? How old were you when you gained access to the internet? Personally I think the educational advantage that a tablet or phone can provide is too quickly overlooked. People assume phone or tablet equals bad with black/white thinking. Sure it can be used to scroll junk mindlessly (although this would be blocked from a child account). It also can be used to playback educational content with subtitles enabled. Kids can learn languages, math, puzzle solving, all sorts of things. A time limit can be enforced on it too. TikTok at its core is a mechanism to share information directly between parties. If you allow your kids on there, and what they are allowed to do there, is up to you as a parent. I will say there is a STEM section that can be enabled, and I'm not personally opposed to it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- drawkward 3y agoprobably around 12-13 in both cases, but this was about 30 years ago, when the web was nascent and did not learn from you, how to addict you.
- rescbr 3y agoI had my own computer in my room when I was 9 or 10 or so. Internet access was mostly restricted as it made the single phone line busy and for a long time the ISP plan my father had was limited with only a few hours allowance. There were absolutely no filters and my parents didn't watch what I was doing. They just hammered in my mind that nobody in the Internet should be trusted, and absolutely no real names, no photos and no addresses. Stranger danger. By the time I had access to a broadband always-on connection, this was already set in my mind. Only years later that people thought that putting their real names and pictures on the book of faces would be cool.
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoI found the study this comes from: https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0025/283048/Childrens-Media-Literacy-Report-2024.pdf https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0025/283048/... They seem to find even more 3-4 year olds (27%) have a smart phone than 5-7 year olds (26%) which seems implausible.
- drawkward 3y agomargins of error. learn about it. these numbers are almost certainly the sample estimate.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoThat is really alarming from a mental health perspective. Even adults have trouble dealing with the addiction loops social media and smartphones in general create. But apart from this, I think it’s a serious national security issue to have children propagandized by a CCP controlled social media platform. As legislators have discussed in hearings, TikTok seems to have highly skewed coverage of different topics and views compared to other platforms, in a way that makes its entire operation seem curated for political chaos, rather than organic.
- JohnMakin 3y agoThis is blatant misinformation, and the legislators "discussing" this clearly barely know what the technology is, let alone the political and social ramifications for its use or misuse. Not even to mention that all the major social media platforms have similar invasions of privacy and skewed messaging on them - not at all unique to tiktok. There has been zero evidence of the CCP influencing what American citizens see on tiktok, it's pure speculation based on Bytedance being a Chinese company. And besides, if they wanted to, meta/YT/etc. make it trivially easy for them to do anyway - you don't even need tiktok or control of it. Unless your point is literally "The united states should be the only one spewing blatant propaganda to its citizens," what you're saying lacks any real substance and is just parroting talking heads on stations like fox and cnn.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y ago> Not even to mention that all the major social media platforms have similar invasions of privacy Really? Other social media platforms are exfiltrating US data to China after claiming it doesn’t happen under oath? https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexandralevine/2023/06/21/tiktok-confirms-data-china-bytedance-security-cfius/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexandralevine/2023/06/21/tikt... > There has been zero evidence of the CCP influencing what American citizens see on tiktok, it's pure speculation based on Bytedance being a Chinese company What sort of evidence could exist when it is a black box? Bytedance / TikTok are not transparent about any of it, and given that they are willing to lie under oath, why should anything they say be trusted at all? All we have is what people have studied in terms of the prevalence of certain messages and hashtags, and it is very clear from various evaluations of this, that TikTok is very skewed. And it seems to be skewed in the very ways that would create political chaos. > Unless your point is literally "The united states should be the only one spewing blatant propaganda to its citizens," what you're saying lacks any real substance and is just parroting talking heads on stations like fox and cnn. I wonder why TikTok’s parent company said they prefer to shut it down rather than sell it. It only makes it more clear that it is mainly a tool of the CCP. I am not sure what “blatant propaganda” you’re referring to, but creating any kind of equivalence between the US and the CCP is ridiculous.
- Phiwise_ 3y ago30% of parents are neglecting their child.
- AlexB138 3y agoFor all the people fretting over whether they should let their own children use these platforms, fearing that keeping them off will alienate them from their peers, I'd suggest considering the following quote: > The real hopeless victims of mental illness are to be found among those who appear to be most normal. Many of them are normal because they are so well adjusted to our mode of existence, because their human voice has been silenced so early in their lives that they do not even struggle or suffer or develop symptoms as the neurotic does. They are normal not in what may be called the absolute sense of the word; they are normal only in relation to a profoundly abnormal society. Their perfect adjustment to that abnormal society is a measure of their mental sickness. These millions of abnormally normal people, living without fuss in a society to which, if they were fully human beings, they ought not to be adjusted. - Huxley It will likely make them a social outcast, to a degree. The question is whether that's a good thing or not.
- int_19h 3y agoBut then again, has there ever been a human society to which this quote didn't apply?
- outcoldman 3y agoI actually thought about that recently. Not about kids, but overall platform addiction. I don't think there is anything as addicted as binge-watching short video content. After Snapchat, and not TikTok nailed it - all other platforms (including Instagram, Facebook, YouTube etc) are trying to not improve their platforms, but keep you on their platforms for a longer period of time by switching to that binge-watching short video content. There is nothing good about it. It does not teach you anything, just a very dump spend of your time. Maybe that sounds like an old man speaking in me. But that is how I feel about myself spending time watching shorts on YouTube, FB or Instagram.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- password54321 3y agoSo in other words, the TikTok recommendation algorithm controls the collective conscious of 30% of 5-7 year olds which propagates to the other 70% and other age groups. Maybe banning TikTok is not a bad idea especially when you consider who owns TikTok.
- sebastiansm 3y agoI'm 34 now. When I was a kid, I'd spend hours daily on a Windows 3.1 computer at home and an Atari with those old 5 1/4-inch floppy game disks at my grandpa's place. Then the internet and cable TV came to our house, and I was glued to that for most of my time. Faster internet followed, giving us access to all sorts of unfiltered online content (sites like Ogrish were the norm with my friend group). Smartphones and apps hit the scene not long after. Nowadays, I have a 7-year-old son who's constantly on his tablet, playing Roblox or Minecraft on my computer, or watching YouTube videos about trains and tornado sirens on the TV (yep, he's autistic). He's been seeing me do similar stuff since he was born. No surprise he started mimicking that behavior. It doesn't really bother me, though.
- krunck 3y agoLet's not forget that this begins earlier. Yes, you've seen them: The two or three year-olds in a stroller staring at a device and never once looking up. And quite often paired with one or more parents also on a device "out for a walk".
- JohnFen 3y agoWhat are the parents of these children even thinking? I just can't wrap my mind around the idea that so many parents are OK with this.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI wonder what they really mean here. (a) 5-7 year olds are "on" tiktok producing content. (b) 5-7 year olds are watching funny videos of cats on TikTok. My 7 year old son will sometimes watch pet and food shorts with my wife on her phone with Douyin (TikTok China). He isn't really "on" TikTok, he is just consuming some of the content while waiting for his Nasi Goreng at the Indonesian restaurant. I seriously wonder if the vast majority of of that 30% are just watching funny dance videos or something like that on the web or on a phone as some form of screen time (damaging because it is screen time, but no more damaging than watching YouTube kids). I think it is crazy for a kid to have phone at that age, but a tablet with screen time limits is much more reasonable. Especially on Sunday when there aren't so many activities scheduled and they've already done their homework. Screen time in general is a challenge.
- cykros 3y agoThis sounds like ~30% of parents should be criminally liable for child abuse. As long as COPPA only applies to the platforms, it essentially doesn't apply. There is zero reason anyone under the age of 13 should be accessing social media.
- _v9nk 3y agoI think that the basis of these is that parents, especially mothers, do not pay enough attention to their children. The entry of mothers into business life left children without love, indifference and defenseless. As a result of this incident, children try to take this attention from external attention centers, such as TikTok.
- remram 3y agoThis reads so unnecessarily sexist.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoI will add something overlooked, the children might not be on tiktok but they might be on youtube watching videos made of chained tiktok videos. Based on my personal observation the rapid, repeated change of scene (5 to 8 seconds) trigger some sort of addiction combined with not understanding what's going on, as well as inability to talk with friends about the scene (too little time). i observed one of my daughter's friends completely shutdown and forgetting we were even there. We kept calling her, she didn't even respond. I'm still shocked. Granted there is way more than the tv problem, this is just the last of a long chain. I suspect the boredom signal is important.