8 ms·
Hertz is ditching even more electric cars
- jseliger 3y agoLast time this came up I wrote: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39934120 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39934120: A few weeks ago I rented a Model 3 from Hertz in San Diego, and the car didn't come with an SAE J1772 Charging Adapter (this covers most level 2 stations). That's crazy. I was staying primarily at UCSD for cancer treatment, and there are a million level 2 chargers that I couldn't access without the SAE J1772 dongle. The Tesla my wife and I have always has a SAE J1772 dongle in the center console. I complained about the lack of this essential part. Hertz would charge for the dongle and then refund upon its return. The car itself was good!
- dreamcompiler 3y agoI parked my Model Y in a garage in LA about a year ago and was sitting in the car charging from a J1772 port while my family shopped. Two women in a Model 3 parked next to me and tried for 20 minutes to plug their car in. I watched but didn't intrude. Finally they saw me and knocked on my window to ask me how to charge. I asked them if they had a J1772 adapter and they had no idea what I was talking about. They said they had rented the car. They looked everywhere in the car but no adapter. I suggested a supercharger and showed them how to find one on the car's screen. This was also the first time they had heard the word "supercharger." Whoever they rented the car from (likely Hertz but I didn't ask) had done absolutely nothing to describe the charging procedure to these unfortunate customers.
- wl 3y agoEvery time I've rented a Tesla from Hertz, I've been bombarded with emails I could not opt out of all about how Teslas operate differently than normal cars and how to charge them.
- orev 3y agoAnd I can guarantee most people ignore them. Any time you book anything on travel, hotel, or airlines you get a daily stream of useless “prepare for your trip”, “we’re so happy to have you”, “there’s still time to upgrade to first class”, etc. emails that can be safely ignored. It’s no surprise that an actually important message gets lost in that stream of junk.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoLOL Average Joe has 16932+ unread emails. IF they have an idea they have an email account and email app.
- sireat 3y agoNot sure what it says about me or google but my original 2004 gmail until recently had about 300,000 unread emails. Granted most of the 300k emails were in tabs like social, forums, updates, promotion. After a bit of spring purging the inbox is down to more managable 91,078 unread emails. Then again, I've seen the first sentence for these emails so I expect I am not missing out on much.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoI'm not aware of any email service what would allow you to tag some incoming messages with an "expire in 30 days" or something rule. Except the spam folder. But again, the main purpose of Gmail is to harvest your behaviour data, not providing you a good email service.
- renewiltord 3y agoThat’s surprising. I rented a Bolt from them and they were very clear it was different. I figured that I could work it out so I told them to skip it and I’d just go work it out if I needed to. They handed me a pamphlet with instructions or link to. I paid no attention because I didn’t need to charge the car. Perhaps these women did the same thing as me but they did need to charge the car.
- Tagbert 3y agoI rented a Tesla from Hertz last summer. They sent me several emails before the trip explaining about an EV, how to find a charger, and how to charge. There were also videos showing the processes. When I picked up the car, the desk person asked if I had any questions about using an EV. Perhaps other people ignore those emails?
- effluvium 3y agoIt's electric SIR, how would forced induction help? Lol Send them to an auto parts store and have them ask for a supercharger for their Tesla just to confuse the clerk. Obligatory: I wouldn't actually do this but it's amusing to think about.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoI do find it annoying that Elon Musk redefined a well-understood automotive term to refer to a completely different automotive term. Of course we're not innocent here. What does gate mean in electronics? What does persistent mean in computer science? What does memory mean in computer engineering? Context matters.
- effluvium 3y agoI just make a new words. Such as "dojober". Dojober (noun): A handcrafted thing that makes it possible to do a job (i.e., complete a task). Synonyms: widget, contraption
- _ea1k 3y agoI've seen many posts in the forums sharing similar experiences. People are given the car with no instruction and have no idea where to go to charge them or how to charge them.
- adamomada 3y agoEvery thing I’ve ever rented was the same. I do believe you would be laughed at if you had to ask how any tool worked when you picked it up from the rental desk. Or that they would just deny you from renting it, since you obviously don’t know what you’re doing. Why should machinery that comes in a vehicle shape be different?
- _ea1k 3y agoBecause in a lot of cases they are being given to people that thought they were renting gas cars. "You get to learn how to charge in an unfamiliar place with no help" isn't a welcome surprise for many people.
- natch 3y agoThe adapter is often either in the large undertrunk which some people don't even notice, or in the small well on the left corner of the trunk.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoThe question is what will consumers be ditching Hertz for? Electric cars as an economical proposition have already proved themselves. That debate is pretty much over. So, why can't Hertz make it work? And who else can disrupt them and how quickly?
- tuatoru 3y agoRepair costs, negative sentiment from customers, much lower than expected residual value. Those are why.
- cjk2 3y agoAs a regular Hertz customer, I will still use Hertz. They are mostly zero hassle, even that time I destroyed a Fiat 500 :) I never rented an EV from them and never would because the charging logistics are a pain in the ass at return. Out of petrol? 10 minutes, run it through the car wash at the same time, sorted. Out of charge? Oh I'm right next to one of the biggest airports in Europe and all the chargers are rammed. No thanks.
- echoangle 3y agoWhat happens when you return it with a lower charge than when you got it? Don’t you just have to pay the difference? Is that more expensive than charging it yourself?
- resolutebat 3y agoYup, same as returning an ICE car with a half-empty tank.
- patja 3y agoIt's a flat fee. I forget if it was $25 or $35. They were pricing EVs at a discount for a trip I took through Atlanta last month. Still came out ahead with the recharge fee.
- cjk2 3y agoWaaaay more expensive.
- IshKebab 3y agoYeah, electric cars definitely don't make sense for car hire. The main advantage of electric car ownership is cheaper fuel costs long term if you charge at home overnight. That obviously isn't going to happen for a hire car, and even if it did the fuel cost of a hire car is insignificant compared to the cost of the hire itself. On top of that, charging is still way less convenient than refueling an ICE car, and when you hire a car it's usually in a situation where you can't afford inconvenience. I think electric cars are the future and hopefully I'll never buy an ICE car again, but car hire has got to be the last domain to transition surely?
- apgwoz 3y agoWe use Zipcar for a second car at the moment and the closest one is an EV. I’ve only used it to go (at most) 10 miles round trip, but I’ve picked it up at 15% charge before and had anxiety the whole time… I agree that EV is a poor choice for rental.
- Symbiote 3y agoCan you not see the charge amount before renting it? The equivalent services in Copenhagen show the state of charge of the cars on the map, before paying anything. (There's also free minutes for leaving the car plugged in to a charger at the end, and perhaps because of that it's rare for them to be at a low charge.)
- rokkitmensch 3y agoThis has gotta be the ultimate EV gaslighting I've ever seen. You're clearly not doing EV right, GP!
- Symbiote 3y agoThe FAQ on Zipcar's website says "Our Electric Vehicles are charged overnight by our team, so they’re good to go whenever you are" — but this isn't the case for the GP, so the failing is with Zipcar.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoLast week on a trip to Florida I rented a Polestar 2 from Hertz. It was in abysmal shape. Both tires on the left had been installed backwards, with the inside on the outside, and something was badly wrong with the front left wheel, I suspect the rotor was warped because it scraping, loudly, with every rotation. I read about Hertz having problems with EV maintenance but experience leads me to believe that it's nothing to do with being EVs. They're simply not maintaining them. I told them about the problems on return, and the guy just shrugged.
- nradov 3y agoThe Polestar 2 that Hertz gave me last time kept flashing warning messages on the dashboard about problems with the airbag (yikes) and the cooling system. The front seat headroom was totally inadequate for a tall person like me. When I tried to recharge it before returning it just said "Error" and refused to charge at all (tried multiple chargers). A total piece of junk. When I complained upon return the Hertz employee was nice about it and gave me a voucher that covered the cost of the rental.
- malfist 3y agoI had a friend rent a model 3 from them and ran into similar issues, plus the first two they pulled out for him had <20% state of charge. Maybe don't build a fleet of EVs if you're not equipped to at least charge them
- reindeergmz 3y agoHow to make electric cars fail; established entities can intentionally neglect and drag their feet, half ass implementation. Over time it fosters routine of negative experience, fostering a viral meme that ultimately squashes demand.
- throwaway5959 3y agoOn a long enough time horizon those that won’t drive electric won’t be driving. It’ll just cost us all a ton more the longer we wait to transition.
- WalterBright 3y agoEVs are only practical if you have a garage and can charge it overnight. (Outdoor chargers don't work because thieves steal the copper wires.)
- bdcravens 3y agoI agree. I didn't buy my first EV until I bought my house. (And now we are all in, a two-EV household)
- somerandomqaguy 3y agoI have a garage and I made a conscious decision to buy an ICE car over a BEV, even though I could afford it. Last time I ran the numbers is was 8 to 10 years before I hit break for an ICE vs an equivalent EV (in feature set that I cared about) given my driving habits and operating costs for either. And there's some electrical work that needs to be done to properly support charging a BEV without juggling what's drawing power when all the time. Upgrades to happen either way but they'd have to be rushed if I had bought a BEV, vs taking the time over the next few years. So at least to for my situation it makes more sense to stick to ICE for now. If the BEV evangelists are right and battery prices drop down to the point where the purchase price of a BEV is the same as an ICE, then it makes more sense to wait. Buy ICE now, get everything in place, evaluate everything again in a few years.
- D13Fd 3y agoThis math works as long as you don’t care about your personal contribution to climate change.
- WalterBright 3y agoI remember from the Obama "cash for clunkers" that the CO2 emissions from constructing a car was about the same as the CO2 emissions for driving 20,000 miles on it. This foundered the entire rationale for "cash for clunkers" to switch to more fuel efficient cars, but facts didn't matter. Politics did.
- daft_pink 3y agoTo me, the issue with renting an electric car is the news stories where they either don’t give you the car fully charged or they expect you to return it fully charged or at the same level of charge as when you receive it. They should build recharging the car once into the price and only give the customer a fully charged vehicle. In theory, I would love to try out an electric car and rent a Tesla. When I read the news stories about the hassles, I don’t want to add dealing with charging hassles to my busy trip.
- ooterness 3y agoTo be fair, that's their model for gasoline as well. Every car rental company I've used charges you $10 for every missing gallon when you return the car. But most don't actually refill it before they hand it off to the next customer.
- deadbabe 3y agoYes but filling up gasoline is trivial where as charging an electric car is an infuriating task that has you sitting around waiting potentially 30 minutes for the car to be charged so you can get on with your trip. No patience for that shit after a long flight.
- thehappypm 3y ago30 minutes is likely a best case scenario as well
- CitrusFruits 3y agoYeah me and my wife rented an electric car once, and we'll never do it again. Recharging it before returning basically adds another hour to the return process (between the detour and the charge).
- grobgambit 3y agoCouldn't agree more with all this. I would love to rent a Tesla exactly as mentioned but waiting 30 minutes at the start or the end is just unacceptable to me. I would need to be given a pretty good discount on the rental to even consider it.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoGot forced into an electric car on a trip. The experience was all around awful. I had to learn how to manage the regenerative braking, the car was a nagging beeper which took even more time to figure out, finding charging stations and then paying for the privilege was a pain, and the biggest FU hertz did for me was I prepay fuel so I can expense it out easier for work. They charged me me 35$ for having it 10% below the charge. Previously the charge for a fuel return at a 1/4 tank prepaid would have been 15$ at most. I will purposefully not be selecting an electric car for my next rentals. Awful experience all around.
- s1k3s 3y agoIt's funny that the reasoning seems to be drivers not being able to run the cars properly. I assume most of them are Teslas, which makes me wonder how things would've looked like if Tesla didn't decide to do everything backwards in terms of driver-car interface.
- techdmn 3y agoAs a Tesla owner, couldn't agree more. The interface of the car itself is actively hostile to new users. Without instruction, most people cannot get into or out of a Model 3 without significant struggle. Regular door handles and a regular gear selector would go a long way. And they seem intent on making it worse. Why would I EVER want the car to decide if I should be going forward or back? Happy to have helped (however little) in making electric cars more mainstream. Doubt I'll buy another Tesla.
- toddmorey 3y agoYes, so true! I listened to the lady at the counter rent out a Tesla and she had no training or clue on how to even open the car, much less operate. I'd pay money for the video of this poor couple, once actually in the car, trying to operate it. When you buy a Tesla, you want to figure out all the features. When you rent a car, you just want to get to the dang hotel before you pee yourself.
- bagels 3y agoHandles are different for efficiency. Just be glad they weren't able to get rid of the side mirrors for the same reason.
- hedora 3y agoI rented an EV a while back, and it was great. The main annoyance was that the EV charging station near our airbnb (a few hours drive from the airport) was a trickle charger that didn’t allow overnight parking, but then I figured out I could charge in the garage with the supplied 120/240V cable (costing the host a few dollars, tops). The rental company (avis) charged market rate to recharge it when I returned. They also let me select EV ahead of time, and I confirmed it would work before selecting it. FWIW, I’d rented a tesla “or similar” and ended up with a bolt, so there weren’t any issues with charge dongles, etc. The savings in gas meant the rental upgrade more than paid for itself.
- chazeon 3y agoTBH Hertz having EV is a good thing for me as a customer because they are cheap. It’s difficult to rent a gas car for $50/day near NYC but they are renting out EV at this rate. Although recharging is a hustle, I tried several times and never get a Tesla, and there’s no enough fast charger for other brands.
- while_true_ 3y agoPretty good deals to be had buying an EV from Hertz. I bought one a few weeks back; they had a bunch to choose from and some had low miles and in near mint condition, with little or no apparent wear, priced near the bottom of KBB.
- foogazi 3y agoWhat did you buy ? What deal did you get ?
- throwaway22032 3y agoI have owned an EV and I liked it, particularly the instant acceleration, but ultimately, it's not a superior product unless you heavily weight zero emissions at the point of use. It has a lower range than my now ICE car, like for like it costs more both to buy and to fuel, there are fewer charging points, and it takes longer to charge vs. fueling. Some of these points are marginal, but for a rental company that's not specializing at the high end of the market the margins aren't huge and it doesn't surprise me that the model doesn't work.
- tmnvix 3y ago> I have owned an EV... it costs more both to buy and to fuel How is this possible (the cost of charging vs purchasing fuel for an ICE vehicle)?
- natch 3y agoIf you use extremely expensive charging stations like the non-Tesla so-called "fast" chargers that are the only option for non-Teslas, they tend to do price gouging. Superchargers also vary in price and can be non-competitive with home electric rates, depending on region, but they don't seem to gouge severely like their competition. At least their pricing for Teslas is good. And maybe the poster lives in a place with very cheap gas as well. It remains to be seen what kind of premium they will charge to non-Teslas which tend to charge more slowly. Because of this slow charging issue, when they roll out more third party charging, Tesla will make non-Teslas pay not only for power, but also for time spent, because taking up a slot for a longer time has an impact on everyone.
- _ea1k 3y agoPG&E rates can make it more expensive than gas. That is by far the exception, though.
- throwaway22032 3y ago40-50mpg at £7 per UK gallon is approx 14-17p per mile. Assuming that you can't charge at home (true for a rental!), the UK rate for charging is between 55p and 80p or so. Real world my EV got around 3-4 miles per kWh which works out between 14p and 26p per mile. Source: https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/electric-cars/charging/electric-car-public-charging-costs-rac-charge-watch/ https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/electric-cars/charging/electric-... We can fiddle the numbers a bit back and forth but my real world experience was that it was more expensive in every way.
- zzz999 3y ago[dead]
- Schnitz 3y agoPeople need to think about the special use case that is car rental. Having to figure out an unfamiliar car in an unfamiliar city with tight time constraints like being on time for meetings or a flight, the car takes 30+ minutes to “fill up”, is a much bigger challenge than switching your 40 miles a day commute car to an EV, where you can work your way up to longer trips etc. I’m super excited for EVs in general, but rental? I want the simplest guaranteed to work appliance!
- _ea1k 3y agoYep... if we lived in a world where we knew that hotels would have chargers, it would be easy. Easier than gas in a lot of cases! But reality right now is a bit different. We can't even know if the Teslas will have the J1772 adapters.
- throwaway22032 3y agoIn my experience every single EV "debate" goes the same way. People who mostly return to their home with a driveway, and mostly use their car to drive around town, vs people who travel away from home. Each trying to convince the other. It's the same as public transport advocates vs car advocates. It feels like a kind of tremendous blind spot. I mean personally I've spent periods in which I've split my time between my place and my partner's place. I doubt this is particularly uncommon. Even if one of us had a charger, the other wouldn't, so suddenly it all falls apart.
- charles_f 3y ago> as it reports a $392 million loss for the first quarter of 2024. Is there any insight regarding the primary reason for that loss? They cite EVs being expensive and unreliable but surely that can't be the primary factor behind a loss of 1/3 of a billion?
- freshpretzels 3y agoI'm surprised they bought a fleet of EVs in the first place. The battery tech still has a bit to go before it can be reliable for enterprise fleets. I think we're more than halfway there based on the range and serviceability of the latest and greatest batteries. Once they're comfortably at 1,000 miles range per charge even in the winter, then I think EVs will be better for enterprise fleets. Heavy usage and heavy recharging are bound to reduce the battery's reliability, so to have a fleet car that is comfortably still at...say, 500 miles of range per charge...they'll most likely need at least 750 to 1,000 miles of total range so that battery degradation even after a few years is not noticeable.