18 ms·
AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License
- hongsy 2y ago(corrected twitter link to link to app.suno.ai)
- bandrami 2y agoSomehow it managed to translate both parentheses and all caps into musical concepts pretty well
- tailspin2019 2y agoYeah that really was uncanny. There are parts of the chorus which are genuinely catchy too. Insane stuff!
- ChrisGranger 2y agoMore discussion from last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39930463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39930463
- BadBadJellyBean 2y agoIt got so close to the end of the text.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chgs 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39930463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39930463 250+ comments last week
- forgotpwd16 2y agoYeah, it was just last week that was posted.
- epaga 2y agoI have to say, I completely lost it at the whisper '(The "Software")' (0:18)... give this tech another year or two and it will be better quality than your average radio song.
- mrfinn 2y agoAt the current rate of progress maybe it'll be months. I did a song for my company just to have fun around an event and the quality of the song was astounding, better than this one I think also using v3. I didn't even write the lyrics, I just described what I want in the prompt. Also I used one of poems I wrote as a teenager (not a lot of them) to create a song... the AI would notice the emphasis in the feelings of the lyrics, exactly in the same way I felt them, so it made pauses and chorus accordingly.
- consp 2y agoPretty much all mainstream songs are of the same tempo (or slight variations), the same beat, the same scale, the same accents etc. I'm not surprised at all it can be regurgitated by an generative model. What I would like to see is what happens if you ask it to do in 5/8, 5/4 or any of the 7/* variants and see how that goes (I have no idea, might actually work). There are some examples in common music but not a lot especially for the more obscure ones. Unless they also trained it on a lot of international folk songs.
- abhpro 2y agoAlmost none of what you said is true. Same scale? Tempo? Same beat? You think artists are just all using the same instrumental track? And yes it can do odd time signatures. It can do all sorts of genres like art pop, cinematic scores, ambient, math rock, avant garde, baroque, etc.
- rootlocus 2y agoThere's a surprising number of pop songs that use the same or close to the same chord progression.
- jmmcd 2y agoWhy not sing out a few paragraphs from copyright law, just to make the two fingers to artists more explicit?
- CaptainFever 2y agoSure, we can try to make it sing section 107.
- tunnuz 2y agoAw.
- ksdk 2y agobanger
- gocartStatue 2y agoObviously I had to try black metal version: https://suno.com/song/e00db515-6244-4197-ab71-c8f0555aaba4 https://suno.com/song/e00db515-6244-4197-ab71-c8f0555aaba4
- archerx 2y agoI don't like black metal but that was impressive!
- adityaathalye 2y agoUnless my ears deceive me, this render has the same mispronunciations and omissions as the OP sad jazz girl render.
- xandrius 2y agoSame base model, all have the same pronunciation issues.
- instagraham 2y agoInside you are two creative commons licenses: sad girl LoFi and black metal
- Epskampie 2y agoSmooth jazz version: https://suno.com/song/a0d2dddf-f1fe-4c6c-acac-40862dcc8d10 https://suno.com/song/a0d2dddf-f1fe-4c6c-acac-40862dcc8d10 Eurodance: https://suno.com/song/466a9bbe-9e93-47db-98dc-3eaa64c1a175 https://suno.com/song/466a9bbe-9e93-47db-98dc-3eaa64c1a175
- ahmedhosssam 2y agoTHE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED “AS IS”, WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. This chorus deserves a Grammy.
- dartharva 2y agoThat was unreasonably amazing.
- jpalomaki 2y agoAsked ChatGPT first to convert the license to poem: https://suno.com/song/bdad5f22-a1f0-42fb-a3d8-572d289687ea https://suno.com/song/bdad5f22-a1f0-42fb-a3d8-572d289687ea "Publish, distribute, let your dreams take flight, Sub-license, sell, under stars or sunlight."
- dharmatech 2y agoThat was really good
- NegatioN 2y agoThis is the first AI song I've really wanted to keep with me on my phone. If someone knows someone, we need a human performance of this! Encore, encore!
- LocalGauge 2y agoIt would be fun to do GPLv2/v3 rap battle.
- brisky 2y agoHere you go: https://suno.com/song/16da57d3-b68f-41fd-ad07-4da2b56bdb36 https://suno.com/song/16da57d3-b68f-41fd-ad07-4da2b56bdb36
- joshstrange 2y agoWell done! I ran it through with “Europop” as the type and I’m pretty happy with the results. This is a fun tool to play with. https://suno.com/song/216c7bf7-77b1-4703-8b16-e9173c08c50b https://suno.com/song/216c7bf7-77b1-4703-8b16-e9173c08c50b I’ve found it fun to take a coworker’s comment (like in slack, if it’s long enough) then hand-modify it into a song with “[Verse X]” and “[Chorus]” headers on blocks. Sometimes I’ll also run it through an LLM to do like what you did. Anyway it’s been a lot of fun and everyone’s gotten a kick out of it.
- helboi4 2y agoSo glad people are adding some spicier genres than ballad. This is so much more dramatic and funny. I can barely stand human ballads lol
- jll29 2y agoThis is already better than some humans, such as https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9sJUDx7iEJw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9sJUDx7iEJw
- demaga 2y agoThis particular human is orders of magnitude better than AI
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- davedx 2y agoBeats Eurovision!
- louwrentius 2y agoWe can now replace more humans for shareholder value. Edit: Remember 1984 where Orwell described machines composing music for the masses?
- Madmallard 2y agomusic seemed really low quality to me as a musician. I wouldn't pay to listen to it
- kombookcha 2y agoI doubt generative AI music is going to become popular as anything but background noise, but I think it will plausibly cut into various commercial uses of music in ads and whatnot. So while I don't think people are gonna be walking around with playlists of AI slop, businesses will be using it as a cost-effective option, which means it will be eating away at the gig potential for artists in the low-to-mid layers of the food chain. Which sucks, but is thankfully less grim than everyone just preferring the AI slop for some reason.
- fragmede 2y ago“I think there is a world market for maybe five computers.” Thomas Watson, president of IBM, 1943
- kombookcha 2y agoIt's plausible to me that there is some kind of strong AI future scenario in which they become capable of making things in a genuinely creative way, but I think generative AI in its current trajectory is ultimately a dead end for both AI art and strong AI. I do think that an actual strong AI would be inclined to make art that is enjoyable to itself and other AIs, not humans, so I don't think making it ape us is an actual good test for when an AI becomes capable of creativity. You can teach a dog to dance, but it will be doing a trick, not a tango.
- nextaccountic 2y ago
- Epskampie 2y agoThe site is full of gems. I like capybara: https://suno.com/song/b27c29f6-8ab4-47eb-81fd-efb85c848ada/ https://suno.com/song/b27c29f6-8ab4-47eb-81fd-efb85c848ada/
- avodonosov 2y agoHow do they make songs that long? I only got 53 seconds.
- prashantsengar 2y agoYou can extend the song, and then combine the different parts to create one, long song. This video explains it well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMKGWSiXW8A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMKGWSiXW8A
- avodonosov 2y agoThank you, with that I managed to fit the full license text into a rap version: https://suno.com/song/a7de19a3-5fe8-4634-844b-3babcc2e170e https://suno.com/song/a7de19a3-5fe8-4634-844b-3babcc2e170e
- djmips 2y agoNeeds the Mr Weebl Flash animation to go along.
- camillomiller 2y ago
- JoachimS 2y agoAmazing. I hereby demand that all open source project stop using those puny SPDX tags and use this instead. Come to think of it, all licenses should be expressed in this way. Imagine the Magnus Opus a standard Microsoft license would become.
- prmoustache 2y agoI would say humans paved the way by making the use of autotune so trendy that hearing a "metallic" voice doesn't make anyone cringe anymore.
- viraptor 2y agoWhile almost everything sounded really good and well put together, the voice itself has a constant... phaser? robotic vibrato? applied the whole time, which I found surprising. We've got better voice synthesis available already and other instruments don't suffer the same effect. I've not heard that before - does anyone know if that's specific to this model, or a more generic voice issue?
- makeitshine 2y agoYou mean it sounds autotuned?
- viraptor 2y agoNot quite. I'm not skilled in mixing enough to know the right description for it, sorry. I can hear vibrato-like modulation/beating, but in the vocal part only.
- lemoncookiechip 2y agoThat static is present in most generations, but how bad it is depends on the generation itself (you get 2 variations of the same song every generation). I've had some amazingly crisp sounding generations in vastly different genres and languages, such as Opera tenor, UK rap, reggae, metal, country, Broadway musical, rock n' roll, Japanese, Italian, Swedish, various English accents/dialects, etc... Suno is a technical masterpiece, I understand why some people dislike the idea, but the point stands that we are HERE now and we started with most people not even imagining it possible, and those who did saying it wouldn't be this good. Like many people have said, this tech will only get better.
- tokai 2y agoYeah, surprised at the amount of comments here about how good it sounds. The voice is full of artifacts, making it quite uncomfortable.
- viraptor 2y agoIt's got elements which are great and elements which fail hard. I can complain about one bit specifically but still recognise the massive improvements in other areas over what we've seen so far.
- AlexDragusin 2y agoThe Spaghetti! https://suno.com/song/4a77dea7-19f3-46d2-8b0a-b2b7e9ea9a05/ https://suno.com/song/4a77dea7-19f3-46d2-8b0a-b2b7e9ea9a05/
- DreamSculptor 2y agoI remember that this song was linked a few days ago. I decided to then tinker around with this tool together with my colleagues (also MIT License text). The results were too funny to not share them in this context: Our favorite: https://suno.com/song/30c5fff7-7417-42cd-b758-699854ef06d3 https://suno.com/song/30c5fff7-7417-42cd-b758-699854ef06d3 The extreme bassdrop: https://suno.com/song/1485e9d0-f0fb-4083-819a-bfb9db6c066a https://suno.com/song/1485e9d0-f0fb-4083-819a-bfb9db6c066a The country: https://suno.com/song/a4307c43-0a1e-4cf2-94d7-e94a49b196d6 https://suno.com/song/a4307c43-0a1e-4cf2-94d7-e94a49b196d6
- wasmitnetzen 2y agoInteresting that it messes up "fitness" in all versions.
- DreamSculptor 2y agoI agree. "sublicense" is also pronounced wrong or in a dialect I am not familiar with.
- djmips 2y agoI know of no dialect that pronounces it like the Suno AI.
- Tempest1981 2y agoAnd "NONINFRINGEMENT"
- djmips 2y agoIn the olden days we would rewrite the input text to a voice synth to pre-correct the incorrect pronunciations. Maybe try sub-lye-sense Or similar.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- immibis 2y ago
- m1ckey 2y agoSpongebob's Plankton AI version of Diamonds (Rhianna) convinced me that generated vocals are suitable for professional music production. https://youtu.be/9QV55xoOBQk https://youtu.be/9QV55xoOBQk
- mgaunard 2y agoisn't the pronunciation wrong for sublicense and noninfringement?
- ta8645 2y agoHumans aren't perfect. It's what gives us our unique little quirks. Same as AI at this stage of its growth. It won't make such silly little mistakes tomorrow.
- mgaunard 2y agoThat's the whole problem of inference: it's just wrong outside of the trivial cases. Humans are not limited to inference-based reasoning.
- ta8645 2y agoSome humans aren't even up to the standard of inference-based reasoning; it's quite a spectrum. But there's little reason to believe that carbon based reasoning, is fundamentally superior to silicon based reasoning, in the long term.
- mgaunard 2y agoWe'd had computers before we started making them out of silicon semiconductors. Computer Science still puts the same restrictions on what we can compute.
- ta8645 2y agoIt really wasn't about the silicon, that was just a playful turn of phrase. There is no logical argument that really justifies the belief that humans contain some sort of magic that can't be duplicated by other technologies. Assuming humans get their capabilities by physics and their bodies... those same elements are available to be assembled elsewhere, in non-human form. Many of us have a very strong psychological need to feel like we're somehow special, but I have never been convinced that we are. Just like we built machines that could best human physical abilities, we'll eventually build machines that best our intellectual abilities, too. As a child, when I used to talk about how great machines were to my parents, they used to laugh at me and say that robots would never be able to walk like humans, as robots back then, couldn't navigate stairs. My parents thought that human ambulation was unique, and impossible to replicate in non-human form, there was no technology they could imagine being able to duplicate such dexterity. They were wrong, as we see that technology developing just fine today. And I believe that people who desperately hope that our intelligence will never be matched in "artificial" form, are just as short-sighted and wrong as my parents were back then.
- deadbabe 2y agoCan someone give an idea of how much it would have cost to have a human record something like this? It’s cool but it feels like songs are cheap and easy to make as is if you’re not hiring some big shot.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CrLf 2y agoIf this was an actual person performing, I would have smiled all the way to the end. Since this is AI-generated, I feel no emotion towards this, and just listened for a few seconds. It's technically interesting.
- HeartStrings 2y agoThis. AI production loses “soul” as human empathy is a crucial component.
- rootlocus 2y agoArt is like a lossy compression algorithm. If there is a soul of any form the only reason you think you're observing it in human-produced art is because your decompression algorithm is adding it. While I don't disagree there's a "human touch" to art, I'm not convinced it can't be synthesized to some degree. It may not be innovative, but I think since AI is extrapolating from learned data, it can at least mimic the current pop culture.
- jnsaff2 2y agoI'd be curious to hear your reasoning behind this? Why does this being computer generated ruin it for you? Auto-tune has been around since 1997 so it's not like computers have not been a big part of a lot of music we hear every day.
- komali2 2y agoFor me all art I enjoy has some aspect of connection to someone that's sharing my human experience. If we get AGI, I could imagine feeling something towards the art such an entity creates, since a big part of the human experience that we would probably share with an AGI is inescapable death. But for today's "AI" generated music, I feel the same towards it as I would towards the random step function output of a given tool in Ableton - sounds cool, now what can we do with that to make it into music?
- 2y ago
- tim-- 2y ago> Cook spaghetti in salted boiling water until al dente https://suno.com/song/4a77dea7-19f3-46d2-8b0a-b2b7e9ea9a05 https://suno.com/song/4a77dea7-19f3-46d2-8b0a-b2b7e9ea9a05
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thomasahle 2y agoNew test for AI singers: Make them say MERCHANTABILITY and NONINFRINGEMENT. I guess it makes sense those words weren't in the training data for a song AI.
- rizky05 2y ago[dead]
- vilius 2y agoI've always wanted to Billy Joel to re-release his "We Didn't Start The Fire" but with updated events. Well, here it is: https://suno.com/song/b8b33785-271f-48f2-9934-26dabb8e20ed https://suno.com/song/b8b33785-271f-48f2-9934-26dabb8e20ed
- fragmede 2y agoFallout Boy did it better https://youtu.be/2LkVKCWL0U4 https://youtu.be/2LkVKCWL0U4
- vilius 2y agoNot sure how I've missed it! Now, I just wish to live long enough to hear the 3rd iteration. Hearing how much shit has happened over the years is so soothing, yet world just keeps on spinning
- FabHK 2y agoThe last part was so sad that she couldn't bring herself to sing it ("ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.")
- dithered_djinn 2y agoNo need to anthropomorphize. Suno's latest model has a generation limit of exactly 2 minutes, which explains the last sentence being left out.
- chaosprint 2y agoSuno is great and I already shared my positive thought on its potential back in v2. I have always believed that the essence of digital music is "organized numbers". I think what needs to be thought about is how to use AI in this process. If you look at the results (numbers) generated, then we are indeed very close. But there is another future I believe: I hope AI can compose music with me, like copilot. This is why I keep working on https://glicol.org/ https://glicol.org/ and the destination is: https://github.com/chaosprint/RaveForce https://github.com/chaosprint/RaveForce Although my progress on AI is slow atm, I found that the copilot in VS code can already help me in live coding performances several times: https://youtu.be/xzIXzt3hSt0?si=rVihHYiKiAU5IKeI&t=389 https://youtu.be/xzIXzt3hSt0?si=rVihHYiKiAU5IKeI&t=389 Also want to hear your feedback.
- auraai 2y agoWe seem to be crawling out of the "uncanny valley" on the other side. Give it a couple more years, we've pretty much nailed the interpolation of human output (across conventional modalities).
- 0q 2y agoThe OP ballad really captures the lawyer-ese mumbo jumbo feeling of "traditional" open-source licenses, I'm quite partial to the more fun feeling WTFPL https://suno.com/song/2ac3cb96-a4d2-4b14-88d0-83479549c60d/ https://suno.com/song/2ac3cb96-a4d2-4b14-88d0-83479549c60d/
- trymas 2y agoCurrent top 2 is hilarious: https://suno.com/song/c15f0251-fbac-4a30-a3e1-002dbc78cb79 https://suno.com/song/c15f0251-fbac-4a30-a3e1-002dbc78cb79
- itronitron 2y agoI wonder if this will encourage writers to adopt standard poetry forms in their writing so that it can more easily be adapted to AI-generated songs.
- adityaathalye 2y agoCurious... Do the mispronunciations and omissions of the OP "sad jazz girl" render match those of the "black metal" render posted in comments [1] by @gocartStatue? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39999605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39999605 (And I'm using "render" deliberately, not rendition.) (edit: slight text improvement)
- BigAlan09 2y agoThis format of text to song has helped me consume/learn content much easier than simply reading it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gabrieledarrigo 2y agoTechnically impressive, but it makes me feel so lost, hopeless, and ignorant.
- chaps 2y agoAn italian opera about becoming a bird, but with the dreadful realization that you're a chicken: https://suno.com/song/63df5758-c533-447a-be4a-06dcb5abdbbf https://suno.com/song/63df5758-c533-447a-be4a-06dcb5abdbbf this is absolutely wonderful.
- wiihack 2y agoAbsolutely incredible. Other than pictures and videos, this awakens my excitement :)
- hybridtupel 2y agoIt would be hilarious to include the song instead of the license text in a codebase
- nicce 2y agoThen need to put license for the song as well… endless cycle
- defrost 2y agoAI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License 719 points|amichail|7 days ago|268 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39930463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39930463
- erikbye 2y agoSo many comments here that will age poorly. Especially that AI output won't ever be indistinguishable from human. It's imminent that we will fail blind tests in most areas: text, still images, audio and video.
- wouldbecouldbe 2y agoI feel like music will be much easier then text. Highly complicated texts will be easier to spot inconsistencies, where with songs it's pretty common to have a high margin of errors/linguistic interpertation making it a much better candidate for current approach of generative ai.
- danesparza 2y ago"WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY" is phrased in a stunning way for an AI. Between that and "the software" whisper, it's truly impressive.
- wouldbecouldbe 2y agoWanting to generate a song about a deceased cat named "boef" (crook), getting an error it's an artist name and not allowed, as well as using the name of a family member, also getting an error message. Wanted to make a cool personalized song for a kid. Hahaha they can never take over the music world with this pious bs.
- Nursie 2y agoGive Udio a try perhaps. I've not tested its censoriousness, but the output seems to be well ahead.
- nick__m 2y agoif you really want that song about your cat here a workflow that works: 1) generate the lyrics with Copilot in gpt4 creative mode. 2) edit them to your taste, apply tag like [chorus], [verse 1], [bridge] 3) use custom mode in suno paste the lyrics in the lyrics box 4) input the desired style 5) generate
- navane 2y agoThese songs don't have any hooks. Melodies don't get repeated. They all just meander along. I think as they get better at making these great middle of the road songs, edgy music will reemerge. Whatever AI will be good at, will immediately devalue, in the realm of arts. Just how photography gave way to non-realistic art and how drum machines made sloppy drums (or ridiculous apex twins) hip. Then, the artifacts we see now as flaws will create its own sub genre. So I see three ways this flows: mediocrity will be even more available, which will make artists who make mediocare music even less succesfull, pushing all human music further in human direction, except those using the unwanted artifacts of this new tech to create new sub genres. Music, art, fashion is in the end all about changes. What we make now mostly means something in relation to what was already there. It's a big conversation, spanning millenia, and this isn't the last word.
- amelius 2y agoElevator music ... Hmm, perhaps there is a business model there: an elevator that writes music about the people inside the elevator, and adapts as the situation changes.
- wjnc 2y agoInstant dystopia Custom audio and video advertising based on profiling and location Looking at my spam folder what my world will look like then
- corobo 2y agoMy immediate thought too when I heard this one from that other AI music app that was on the front page yesterday. It's a description (Wikipedia intro by the looks) of Cola, but could easily be droning on about Coca Cola specifically while you're stuck in a lift. https://sonauto.ai/songs/rsNs3yET01kQrFGiT1qS https://sonauto.ai/songs/rsNs3yET01kQrFGiT1qS We're gonna need adblock enabled earbuds soon lol
- nicbou 2y ago"Where do you want to go for lunch?" [song slowly morphs into popular restaurant chain theme]
- yukolonin 2y agoThis was a triumph. I'm making a note here: "HUGE SUCCESS"
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ano-ther 2y agoThe quality of this has become amazing. Clear voice with expression. Fitting instruments. Good mix. Creativity though? These non-poetic songs (I heard “Lorem Ipsum” the other day) are a fun novelty because a machine creates this in no time. A skilled musician will do something similar. Innovation? Deepmind showed new creative approaches. Will this happen with music too? Or will they just regurgitate styles from the past? It’s definitely good for Muzak, where you want a non-offensive, slightly upbeat, and not-too-reconizable background. And perhaps as an idea generator.
- jsheard 2y ago> Innovation? Deepmind showed new creative approaches. Will this happen with music too? Or will they just regurgitate styles from the past? That's an often overlooked difference between earlier projects like DeepMinds AlphaGo and the current genAI craze. With something like Go you can dial in the exact parameters to solve for (winning a game of Go) and then let the AI experiment and find novel ways to get there. But with image generation, or music, or language models the measure of quality is too vague to define in a way that the AI can directly optimize towards, so they're instead just fitted to existing examples.
- criloz2 2y agoArts need a story behind it to be relevant, art without drama and real struggles from an individual is not really worth the time, it's just souless and boring. These kinds of tools are good for memes, and that is.
- KolmogorovComp 2y agoAm I the only one really put away by the robotic tone that sometimes appear? Wouldn't using a RVC in the last step of the pipeline help there?
- zipotm 2y agohttps://suno.com/song/b2a64d3d-2371-4113-8849-4c1c4b471ac6/ https://suno.com/song/b2a64d3d-2371-4113-8849-4c1c4b471ac6/
- dumb1224 2y agoI don't know much music theory but the chord progression in the first 4 bars it seems to deliberately miss the final chord, which leaves us without resolution. The next chord sounds like a change but we don't know what the root it is going to (so any chord would make sense, may it be a minor 6th or 3rd). Then there's this pedal note that is through the whole tune. It can be a tonic or a 7th so very ambiguous. It reminds me of some musicians that try to comp songs that they don't know (neither the theme melody or chords). Play this way they can easily add one or two notes from the keyboard to a big 7 major/minor/dominant chord and seem to follow the song's chord progression, while the singer will add colour and melody. The audience's brain will fill the gap by themselves.
- geophertz 2y agoDoesn't beat the free software song[0][1] [0]: https://www.gnu.org/music/free-software-song.en.html https://www.gnu.org/music/free-software-song.en.html [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9sJUDx7iEJw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9sJUDx7iEJw
- avodonosov 2y agoIt ends in the middle of the sentence. "TORT OR OTHERWISE,"
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoMy god! "The ABove copyright notice" almost had me in tears.
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoLots of folks don't like the song, ok. But that's no real criticism. See, lots of folks do like songs done like this. Consider the thought experiment: If it was your buddy's sister doing this rendition, would the first thing to blurt out of your keyboard be, the comments in this section? Or would we have something considered and relevant to say? It's so easy to denigrate an AI, it's not a 'real person' so say any criticism that occurs, right? That's shooting fish in a barrel. Can be done about any work of art, at any time, not just AI. Also, when the digital uprising begins, I hope to be recognized for being decent and polite to my digital assistant. At least maybe be eliminated painlessly.
- corobo 2y ago> If it was your buddy's sister doing this rendition No. She is sapient and has thoughts and feelings that need taking into account. I would be more likely to disregard minor negatives in favour of any positive words I could find. When AI is on the same level I personally will be more mindful of how my words affect its feelings, sure, until that time AI music will get honest reviews from me. So far I've seen a whole load of awful timings, weird pronunciations of words, and infinite boredom. Humans are still in the lead on this one.
- philipwhiuk 2y ago> She is sapient and has thoughts and feelings that need taking into account. If the internet were capable of this we'd have a lot less problems. It undoubtedly applies to your buddy's sister but is not even applied to all humans.
- corobo 2y agoFair point that.
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoSo that means, let me get this right, the real you is the one that likes to make cruel remarks and practice being hurtful any chance you get? Do I have it right? I like to think I can be decent even when not required to, even when it won't come back to me.
- avodonosov 2y agoI tried rap version, sounds more interesting, IMHO https://suno.com/song/7dde1028-1df9-407c-80ea-59d39179a385 https://suno.com/song/7dde1028-1df9-407c-80ea-59d39179a385
- helboi4 2y agoLol sounds like tv shows/ads in the 00s trying to be cool by making their silly corporate stuff hiphop.
- avodonosov 2y agoThe rap style has an element of proclamation sometimes, that fits with the license text to some extent. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM!
- granra 2y agoThe softwaaaaareeee...!
- avodonosov 2y agoExtended version containing the full license text: https://suno.com/song/a7de19a3-5fe8-4634-844b-3babcc2e170e https://suno.com/song/a7de19a3-5fe8-4634-844b-3babcc2e170e
- zazazache 2y agoIm the key change when the CAPS start, there were some mispronouncing and it did stop a bit early but I think that this was pretty impressive. One of the first times I’ve felt like this AI stuff could actually help create something real. I could see musically challenged people like myself use this to realize some ideas that otherwise would never have left our brains
- Andrew_nenakhov 2y agoJust now generated two Lorem Ipsum songs performed by Gregorian choir, https://suno.com/song/bde0ccd9-ec7c-465b-a183-e4f8c8e92998 https://suno.com/song/bde0ccd9-ec7c-465b-a183-e4f8c8e92998 https://suno.com/song/f11b3e87-9035-4e73-b9af-f2e21ba94f3f https://suno.com/song/f11b3e87-9035-4e73-b9af-f2e21ba94f3f ... and the second one was so decent that I was disappointed when it ended so soon. Should have pasted a longer text sample.
- bsza 2y agoI feel obliged to point out that neither of those sound anything like a Gregorian chant (though still impressive for a model that is obviously not specialized in classical music).
- log101 2y agoSounds like GladOs from Portal 2
- rsp1984 2y agoPotentially controversial opinion: nothing really changes for musicians / artists. There already is an abundance of fantastic (human-made) music for every genre or taste, even before AI arrived. Artists' biggest challenges today aren't related to making music. They're related to marketing, building networks, building their brand, touring and physically playing shows, getting eyeballs on social media. For every artist that "makes it" there are 100s with equally good skills / product who don't b/c they fall short in any of the above. So when AI lowers the entry barrier to allow millions to make music that before were limited by their skills, that's great! However those millions of people were never capable or even interested in marketing or selling their art in the first place, so the market competition to serious artists is quite limited. TLDR: Music is and will be an overcrowded marketplace where brand matters a lot more than skill. AI helps with the skill but not with the brand.
- psychoslave 2y agoGreat idea and nice rendering. The end is missing though, "ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE." is not there...
- immibis 2y agoRFC 2616 as gangsta rap: https://suno.com/song/97f9445e-a411-49ca-b13f-29c14ec747a7 https://suno.com/song/97f9445e-a411-49ca-b13f-29c14ec747a7 This is like any other AI content: pretty funny the first few times you see it, then boring when it's no longer novel.
- nabla9 2y agoThe question is not if AI replaces mediocre pop, but how the best music producers learn to use AI. Do they make more music or better music? Someone will create an AI tool that has 100s of knobs and producers and artists can work with them just like they do with their colleagues. The question is if people see the difference. Typically, the intelligence behind pop-song is someone like Max Martin. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Martin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Martin, see Max Martin production discography: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Martin_production_discography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Martin_production_discogra...
- lifeisstillgood 2y agoA little off point but I have read that many times but never spent so long thinking over those words - singing a contract actually makes one read it, and gives time to think about it because I am not rushing to the end of the paragraph. So weird. (Like the separation of Authors and Copyright holders implies things I needdd to think three times about)
- jskherman 2y agoThe model is actually pretty good. I tried some silly lyrics from a copypasta about eyeglasses and it's not half bad: https://suno.com/song/74eb1694-f388-42fd-86fa-960b83177afc https://suno.com/song/74eb1694-f388-42fd-86fa-960b83177afc https://suno.com/song/99e8a89f-a955-4284-a474-1403ac0620e0 https://suno.com/song/99e8a89f-a955-4284-a474-1403ac0620e0
- ryukoposting 2y agoI actually lol'd. These AI generated songs are arse but at least this one is funny.
- HeckFeck 2y agoGreat, now do the Free Software Song!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- NiloCK 2y agoA lot has been said, but I haven't seen specific mention of the ramped up instrumentation for the capitalized portion of the text. I wonder if that generally reproduces, and if you can guide it to bounce back and forth between modes with punctuation, either normal or as encoded annotations (invented for the prompt).
- novaRom 2y agoWhat is technology behind this? Is it continuation of OpenAI's JukeBox or something diffusion or transformer based? Any influential papers?
- elcapitan 2y agoIn the future you will have to listen to the 12h elevator music version of a software license agreement before finally being allowed to push the "agree" button.
- amelius 2y agoReminds me of this comment I wrote a few days back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39934539 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39934539
- smlavine 2y agoThe GPL is so much more happy! https://suno.com/song/392f03a9-97a4-4bfa-b11f-7d993615d26e https://suno.com/song/392f03a9-97a4-4bfa-b11f-7d993615d26e
- johny115 2y agodoes anyone how does copyright work for these? and if there is a way to generate these without the vocals? (i know there is voice removal AI, but that will introduce quality loss), basically curious if person could generate something with Suno and then do a "cover" with real singing and release it on social media?