7 ms·
Why Tolkien Hated Dune
- cratermoon 3y agoShould be titled "what the author speculates made Tolkien hate Dune", because Tolkien never elaborated on his reasons.
- reanimus 3y agoThe title of the post isn't exactly inaccurate either. If we assume titles can be the subject matter, "Why Tolkien Hated Dune" is the subject being discussed isn't it? It's not like the author titled it "Here is why Tolkien hated Dune".
- ganzuul 3y agoHe could have hated it because he thought it was good. People are not one-dimensional.
- lordfrito 3y ago[flagged]
- marginalia_nu 3y agoDune is pretty good, deserves talking about. It's good that the movies are bringing it back into the public eye.
- melling 3y agoYes, the second movie is out and it got great reviews, better than the first. I bought the book to read before seeing the second one.
- mock-possum 3y agoThe book still holds up, imo, I reread it this year for the same reason.
- BMc2020 3y agoI know. Back in the day there were two movies* out at the same time about an asteroid hitting the earth and suddenly there were lots of asteroid hitting the earth stories in the media. * Deep Impact and Armageddon * * (studios did this to piggy back on the marketing expenses)
- cgh 3y agoA lot of people going to be disappointed when Dune Messiah gets made into a film. Even more so if (I can only hope) God Emperor hits the silver screen.
- petsfed 3y agoMan I sure hope so. The first book expends a lot of pages on the wonders of this magical boy (and a little bit of time about the misgivings he had from it). The second one is nowhere near as coy about its thesis: singular heroes must necessarily cause, either directly or indirectly, a lot of suffering, and do a lot of evil, to be become singular heroes. Maybe magical boys aren't a thing we should celebrate so much. The idea that singular people can so embody goodness that we need to build statues or found religions around them is really a thing that needs to die in global society. Celebrate the act, not the person doing it.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoWhy? Do you think it cannot be well adapted, or that chances are low?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bossyTeacher 3y agohow come? the movies are not made to be perfect adaptations. As it stands, they are likely the best adaptations of dune to date
- n4r9 3y agoInteresting article, thanks for sharing. I've never come across Tolkien's opinions on other books/authors before so for me it's fascinating. The article frames their differences as deontology vs consequentialism, but I think absolutism Vs relativism (or subjectivism) also had a part to play. It feels like Tolkien imagined that there is an overarching principle of goodness, and that practising goodness is reward in itself. OTOH Herbert imagined that good and evil are in the eye of the beholder, and that one's power to control ones environment and persuade other people is what counts in the end. I'm reminded of a similar rift that I recently discovered on HN, between CS Lewis and Stapledon (author of First and Last Men, and Starmaker). Lewis apparently regarded Starmaker as "devil-worship". This surprised me because there is no devil or indeed any religion in the novel. As best I can tell after a lengthy debate with other HN users, in Lewis's eyes it is devil-worship even to imagine a world bereft of absolute good and evil. Sometimes it feels like those with very strong faith inhabit a quite different world to me.
- drbig 3y agoThanks for the opinion! I have Starmaker on the shelf, bought lifetimes ago and... never read. Likewise I have not read Herbert not Tolkien... And now I think I'll slot the Starmaker and then perhaps Dune for the upcoming summer balcony reading period. ...Which makes me point to the core point: there are those low-level notions that are pretty much mutually exclusive. I for one learned quickly that there is no "true good", and that there is no "true evil", either. Managing to get older my current perspective on this dichotomy is thus: 1) Perfect Good = you're with everyone and everything is perfect... But it's a static frame. Nothing can ever change - as the only change would be straying from the attained perfection! 2) Perfect Evil = and you're fully free to do whatever you want! And have the power to do so! But... you're fully and truly alone. And being the supreme evil of this multiverse you can't end yourself. As in, you can _obviously_, but then you... come back. And thus both ends of this coin are different but equivalent. Nothing of interest at the logical conclusions.
- coldtea 3y ago>Perfect Good = you're with everyone and everything is perfect... But it's a static frame. Nothing can ever change - as the only change would be straying from the attained perfection! If it is indeed perfect why would it "have to change"? Just for the sake of it?
- rdtsc 3y ago> In fact I dislike Dune with some intensity, and in that unfortunate case it is much the best and fairest to another author to keep silent and refuse to comment However, despite the "intensity", he avoided going into details. That's such a different attitude compared to people today, who would be giving interviews and posting on social media why they hate something at length, how wrong and bad that other thing is, and the person who created it is this and that, etc. I bet if Tolkien knew his private letters would be published for the whole world to see, he might not have even written that letter to start with.
- blargey 3y ago> That's such a different attitude compared to people today You don’t notice all the people-today who do hold that attitude because, well, that’s the point! Conversely, many people of Tolkien’s time went on unfair opinionated rants, but the mediums and opportunities available at the time were a bit more limited than today so you mostly just catch glimpses of it in snippets of old magazine reviews/interviews of now-famous books, filed under the Reception section of a Wikipedia article, notable solely for having aged so poorly.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoAgree, it's the Tolkien equivalents of today that will be remembered a century from now, all the millions of ranting writers will be entirely forgotten except for the occasional curious reader who stumble across an archived copy.
- arp242 3y agoTolkien himself was frequently derided by other authors and literary critics for his "childish" writings about hobbits and goblins and elves and such. This kind of thing is hardly new, it's just there are more channels to express this. This probably also influenced his decision to just not say anything.
- staticman2 3y ago>That's such a different attitude compared to people today, who would be giving interviews and posting on social media why they hate something at length, I don't think this is particularly true. A modern working writer in the Hollywood system would probably expect to be blackballed from a studio if they dissed a studio's movie. A working writer for a comic book company would likewise expect to be fired or lose career opportunities if they dissed a comic book company's output. Individual writers working in prose seem to have a bit more leeway in what they can get away with saying, but are likely to be labeled "jealous" if they write a bad review, in particular if it's of a more successful author. And media tie in authors probably have no independence, I believe Lawrence Miles was banned from writing Doctor Who books because he once wrote a bad review of a doctor who episode. I think the default today is forced positivity if anything.
- horrysith 3y agoFollow up post: why I care about why Tolkien hated dune
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y agoDifferent tastes. Tolkien hated Dune, and I think LoTR is all style no substance.
- jkoudys 3y agoProbably why LotR translated so well into film, while Dune is very hard to capture in live action. The first book at least has some big battles and over the top villains to anchor the whole thing. Children of Dune is like 90% discussing religion and its appropriate role in government. Especially all the chosen-one tropes that are fun in a movie are pretty brutally deconstructed in Children.
- CBarkleyU 3y agoI have the same opinion on LoTR, but at the same time I found that Dune's prose is little better than fanfic (if that...) Every now and then I go for a reread, hit a passage talking about a magic sword and the book trying to rawdog convince me that this sword (dagger?) is super cool and awesome by... well outright saying '"this sword is super cool and awesome" (trust me, I'm the narrator) '
- orwin 3y ago> I found that Dune's prose is little better than fanfic I've read all dunes books 8n French, and the version I've read were old and weirdly written, I thought this was a bad translator. Fast forward 15 years, I mostly read books in English, and decide to give it a go again. I think it's worse. Probably my standards are way higher now for fantasy and anticipation (I do not thank you Sanderson). Still, I now understand Dune better and now think it's a fantastic story if you manage to endure the first ten chapters.
- tstrimple 3y agoI've started measuring sci-fi and fantasy along multiple axis. Good writing, good characterization, good world building, good story. I find that I need at least three of them to be solid for it to reach into good book territory with a few exceptions. Dune is one of those exceptions. It's pretty weak on writing. Weak on characters. World building is good, but relatively narrow in scope given the size of the universe we're exploring. The overall story is very solid and for me makes up for weak characters and writing. I like Sanderson because he's consistently good at world building and the story itself. Sanderson is one of the best and most consistent world builders in fantasy writing. His magic systems are all interwoven into his societies and reflect the impact magic would have on every day life. His characters are still quite weak, especially women. His prose doesn't seem to be anything special but it's also not a distraction. His mix of world building and story telling more than make up for those weaknesses in most cases.
- behnamoh 3y ago[flagged]
- lapcat 3y ago> Religious differences aside, the central argument between the two authors is the moral one. The article gives no justification for this claim. To me this seems more obvious: > Tolkien was a very devout Catholic and Herbert was not exactly friendly towards religion. Herbert saw religion as an inherently mutable, utilitarian institution, and Herbert was dismissive or even openly antagonistic toward religious truths.
- karaterobot 3y agoThis is sure reading a lot into an unpublished letter that just says he disliked Dune without giving a reason. Maybe he hates sand, I hear some people do. Maybe he thought it was too long and should have been split into three volumes. Interesting way to discuss some related issues, but, like Dune and Tolkien's own work, highly speculative!
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoAnd noted fantasy author Michael Moorcock didn't particularly like Lord of the Rings, either: https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/english/currentstudents/undergraduate/modules/en361fantastika/bibliography/2.7moorcock_m.1978epic_pooh.pdf https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/english/currentstudents/under... Fantasy/sci-fi authors aren't under obligation to mutually love each other's work.
- 627467 3y ago> Deontology vs Consequentialism How deontologists learn to change their mind (adapt to change) if they prevent themselves from experiment to see the consequences?
- marcosdumay 3y agoBy principle, deontologists should be completely close for changing. On practice, nobody is completely either one of those.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoI don't think there is much of a contradiction, as deontologists do not claim perfect knowledge. Discovering new facts that throw new light on the circumstances of old actions doesn't mean e.g. an evil action became good, but that it was revealed as having been such all along.
- tlb 3y agoMost virtues aren't really suitable for self-experimentation, because the effects take a lifetime to accumulate. Consider loyalty, a key virtue in Tolkien's books. You can't just A/B test different levels of loyalty so see which has better consequences for you. Loyalty is established over many years, and the benefits come back to you over many decades, so it's not something you can experiment with in your own lifetime. It's like long-term health. You can't determine whether cigarettes are good or bad for your longevity by any self-experiment. You can only look at historical data on others. Likewise, deontologists look at other people's lives to decide which virtues seem worth adopting. It's very time-consuming, because people don't reliably self-report their own virtues. The only way to know if someone is loyal or not is by observing, over a big chunk of their life, how they treat people around them. You have to know a lot of people quite well for a long time to make reliable observations on how virtues affect people's lives. Since you have to adopt virtues fairly young to get the benefit of them, you don't have time for all this observation. The best you can do is to read the books of wise elders and adopt the virtues they agree on.
- tiberious726 3y ago
- ahepp 3y agoIs Dune (as a series) really an endorsement of consequentialism? Frank Herbert wrote a lot of books, and it was a long time ago that I read them. I don’t remember the consequences ever being particularly great for anyone.
- jkoudys 3y agoEveryone gets murdered, commits suicide, transformed into crazy magic people or giant sandworms, or repeatedly dies then comes back in different forms over centuries. LotR had them do a bunch of hero shit, then everyone either went home to hang out at the pub for a while, or took a boat out west.
- smt88 3y agoThe entire Dune series is an examination of consequentialism. There are good consequences for all of humanity. Whether Herbert endorses consequentialism in the real world is not something you could guess just from the books. The cost of the good consequences is unfathomably high.
- lapcat 3y agoIf you can find a copy, "The Maker of Dune" gives some nice insights into Herbert's thinking. The book looks to be pretty hard to find now, though. I used to have a copy, but I must have sold it at some point when I was poorer. [Edit:] The internet archive has it: https://archive.org/details/the-maker-of-dune-insights-of-a-master-of-science-fiction-by-frank-herbert-tim-o-reilly https://archive.org/details/the-maker-of-dune-insights-of-a-...
- dragonwriter 3y ago> The entire Dune series is an examination of consequentialism. There are good consequences for all of humanity. Mighty big asterisk on the “all” there.
- smt88 3y ago> Mighty big asterisk on the “all” there. As long as [unacceptable sacrifice] is objectively smaller than [benefit], it works as an analogy for real-world consequentialism like the develoment/use of the atom bomb. The book went to some lengths to tell you with certainty that the sacrifice was smaller than the benefit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- animatethrow 3y agoThere's a video that is better than the linked article about why Tolkien disliked Dune: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yDqeftRRpB0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yDqeftRRpB0 This video mentions that Tolkien started a sequel to LotR titled The New Shadow but quickly abandoned it after realizing the story would inevitably be about politics and the evil of Men, about the descendants of Aragorn becoming like Denethor, or worse. And Dune is full of politics and far-future men becoming much more sinister than Denethor. LotR is about good vs. evil, about little people having the power to change the world. In Dune almost everyone is self-interested and Machiavellian, the powerful cruelly use the powerless for their own ends.
- crtified 3y agoAt heart, both tales are of youths inheriting the most powerful position/opportunity of their generation. In one sense, the 'fantasy' being explored by the author in both cases is "how would you live, and what would drive your decisions, if that was you born into that position?". It does seem natural for ideologically opposed authors to not love each others works. I daresay they were also capable of recognising some good.
- hprotagonist 3y agoWarhammer is, at least somewhat, what you get when you ram dune and lotr together: god-emperors and space-orcs. Kind of ironically, given that it’s a world that coined “grimdark” and kind of sort of espouses it, it’s also kind of a neat example to point to as a deontologist critique of consequentialism: “see what happens if you let the ends justify the means? you get space orcs! and men who are kind of okay with that!”
- Ekaros 3y agoAt least Orks are happy. Only group you can argue truly is... So maybe ends justify means. The end just have to be building a race that is happy doing what they are doing...
- rightbyte 3y agoIs Warhammer 40K, 40 000 years after Warhammer? Warhammer seems to me to be a "LotR-world" but scrambled to not infringe copyright. Dune and Warhammer seem to have real people, while Warhammer 40K seem to be caricatures. W40K just takes the absurdness too far for me to be able to identify with the characters. Morality does not seem to be a thing in W40K.
- Ekaros 3y agoNo, it is probably 28 to 38 thousand years in future... No one knows exactly in universe probably besides emperor... Now for most purposes dead... Full timeline isn't exact. Warhammer world, could theoretically be single planet unseen somewhere in 40k, but more likely one of alternative universes with such as Blood Bowl. 40k suffers because most well-known character aren't well that human anymore. It goes for aliens, but also for Emperor, and Primarchs and Space Marines. Still there is lot of room for more human stories, butt they are often played for comedy or the grimdarkness. Or even almost lovercraftian horror...
- dragonwriter 3y agoBasically, this article invents an elaborate fantasy whose primary factual anchor is Tolkien writing that he very much didn’t like Dune with no further elaboration. That Tolkien was of a deontological philosophical bent and that this is reflected in his writings is a fairly reasonable statement. That Herbert was a consequentialist might be (based on other things), but that this was clearly indicated in, much less a focal message of, Dune, either the novel or the broader series, is, I feel, a quite strained reading, and seems to come from a place of excessive desire to read a simplistic moral argument into Dune. While Mauldin notes that Herbert, “saw religion as an inherently mutable, utilitarian institution”, he seems to have failed to realize the centrality of mutability of perceived religious and moral truth, especially as it comes with distance from the facts on the ground, in Herbert’s writing, and that Dune (in the small or large sense) isn’t a fable with a pat moral lesson. I think its usually a mistake to argue that any but the most simplistic fiction is “about” some message that can fit on a fortune cookie, but I think it is less inaccurate to say that Dune is a challenge to simplistic narratives about the present, past, and morality (whether framed in consequentialist or deontological terms) than it is about any thesis as to what the correct framing of morality is. Mauldin points out the Golden Path of God Emperor of Dune, but I think he mistakes the eponymous character’s voice for the authorial voice. Leto II Atreides clearly sees his vision of the future and what is necessary to save humanity as warranting any horrors done in its name, but is Herbert saying that? Or is Herbert framing it in a way that the reader while recoil at it even framed with Leto II’s prescience, and from that question acts that seem on their own repugnant done with mere human confidence, and not science fiction prescience, of their distant consequences?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scyzoryk_xyz 3y agoi.e. sometimes writers write because they like to write. It can be a bit much sometimes to be projecting so much onto them. Which is a shame because the interpretations are interesting - would work better as personal subjective opinion.
- buntsai 3y agoI am not sure that Tolkien was a supporter of "Deontology" (ethical systems like Kant's). He was more probably a fan of virtue ethics of Aristotle and Aquinas. There is a large gulf between them. Wikipedia does a decent job of summarising the differences. We can not lump together into one category everyone who disagrees for many different reasons why we can sum up future consequences almost mathematically to come up with an "optimal" ethical choice. I am not sure that Tolkien is particularly interested in "greatness" either.
- syngrog66 3y agoI have to respect this level of nerdbait.
- Apocryphon 3y agoBut what did he think of Gormenghast?
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoThe "anti-allegory" guy hated the "super-allegory" guy? ;p