9 ms·
Oceans May Have Already Seen 1.7°C of Warming
- skymast 3y ago[flagged]
- notamy 3y agoOn the one hand, it’s incredibly cool that this method (measuring via sponges) even works. On the other hand, what a depressing result.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI had the same thought - really cool that they calibrated it against modern measurements and were then able to find known historic anomalies in the data. On the other hand, it would be nice to get one or two stories where things are going better than expected, wouldn't it? Of course, then the deniers will just use them as evidence that everything is going to be OK, so we don't need to do anything.
- Levitating 3y ago> On the other hand, it would be nice to get one or two stories where things are going better than expected This is that story! The change in temperature is the result of outlawing a particular chemical used in ship fuel. That means that we were subconsciously geo-engineering the atmosphere with positive results. https://www.science.org/content/article/changing-clouds-unforeseen-test-geoengineering-fueling-record-ocean-warmth https://www.science.org/content/article/changing-clouds-unfo... https://youtu.be/dk8pwE3IByg?si=lqt2E9Q3GMExhLZ- https://youtu.be/dk8pwE3IByg?si=lqt2E9Q3GMExhLZ-
- TravisCooper 3y agoAlmost seems too-good-to-be-true right? Such a tight margin-of-error...
- richrichie 3y ago[flagged]
- bilsbie 3y ago[flagged]
- tokai 3y agoWhat do you mean? They found no cooling, they found warming.
- wpm 3y agoProbably, yes.
- stephen_g 3y agoYes, indeed - if they had found cooling, it would be a massive sensation. It’s curious how climate denialists try to push this nonsense of “it would be suppressed if it didn’t follow the narrative”, but in truth if somebody could show credibly that climate change wasn’t happening or there was cooling, it would definitely be published and would be front page news for years… The reason that’s not happening isn’t some kind of crazy conspiracy, it’s because all the evidence points to, guess what, climate change is actually happening…
- marcellus23 3y agoBut they did find warming (assuming that's what you meant instead of cooling). What point are you trying to make exactly?
- GeoAtreides 3y agoA couple more threads: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39268387 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39268387 -- flagged (why?) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39272301 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39272301 -- no traction https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39272405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39272405 -- no traction
- tokai 3y ago>flagged (why?) Some user flag posts that have a good chance of ending up with subpar discussion.
- kibwen 3y agoIn this case, it's more likely to be flagged by the recurring contingent of climate denialists that always show up in these threads.
- tokai 3y agoI make no judgement of which users or if the discussion will objectively be bad. Just answering GeoA's question.
- throwaway5752 3y agoBrigade, the post gets flagged, and discussion disappears. Victory. It so easy with the HN mod system that it is almost embarrassing.
- GeoAtreides 3y agoI said it before, I'll say it again: where there are rules there's a game, where there's a game, there are players and the players will play the game.
- stuff4ben 3y ago[flagged]
- letier 3y agoWhat do you consider the start date of global warming?
- cde-v 3y agoI think they are trying to imply that their version of global warming started during the recovery from the little ice age.
- hedora 3y agoThe article talks about the timeline. Coal burning started roughly 100 years before their measured warming effects.
- burkaman 3y agoWhy do you say the start date is pre industrial revolution? This article says the ocean began warming around 1860, which is well after the end of the industrial revolution.
- kibwen 3y agoClick this XKCD and scroll to the bottom: https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/ This is not a normal phenomenon. Earth can accommodate climate change. We're not worried about Earth. Prosperous, free, advanced human civilization is what's at risk here, between disruptions to agriculture and refugee crises the likes of which the world has never seen.
- Toine 3y ago"Im not racist, but..."
- benzible 3y agoIt's right in the second sentence: > These newly revealed paleoclimate records suggest that sea surface temperatures (SSTs) began rising in response to industrial era fossil fuel burning around 1860. (Also, "jibe": https://www.grammargiant.com/confused-words/Jibe-or-Jive https://www.grammargiant.com/confused-words/Jibe-or-Jive)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mikrl 3y agoIt impresses me how many global warming skeptics are in this forum as opposed to, say, the scientific community. Is this due to the level of deluded optimism that I always hear is a prerequisite for one’s startup succeeding?
- ant6n 3y agoNot all startup bros are primarily scientifically curious, some are just driven by profit. Or, as a wise man once said: "nature decays! But Latinum lasts forever."
- lebean 3y agoUnderstanding something often means asking basic questions. This forum has many folks who value questioning like a skeptic, something like a Socratic dialog. Kind of unfair to call people deluded just because you and many others have reached a conclusion long ago.
- kibwen 3y agoI'm exercising skepticism to be skeptical of the people who exercise skepticism over this topic given the preponderance of evidence. If one were being skeptical, one might wonder if skepticism over climate change was irrational and emotional rather than rooted in the pursuit of truth.
- BoGoToTo 3y agoAbsolutely man!! I've been trying to tell my neighbor this for ages. I keep taking shits on his lawn and he's getting all upset about it saying that it's ruining his lawn. I tell him I value questioning like a skeptic, something like a Socratic dialog. Kind of unfair to call me deluded just because he and many others have reached a conclusion long ago.
- ruszki 3y ago> Skepticism, also spelled scepticism in British English, is a questioning attitude or doubt toward knowledge claims that are seen as mere belief or dogma. Questioning anthropogenic climate change is not skepticism.
- 8943gG4f 3y ago1.7C degrees of warming later and the Maldives will not. be. submerged. LETS GO!
- ant6n 3y agoThe Maledives may more likely be submerged if the Poles heat up by 1.7C, for a time frame of 50 years. The ice in the poles doesn't all melt immediately.
- 8943gG4f 3y ago[flagged]
- boxed 3y agoCitation needed.
- Timon3 3y agoWhich ones? Could you share specific quotes or links?
- Timon3 3y agoI'll respond here since your comments are both dead. 1. Your quote from 1989 doesn't mention the Maldives being under water by now. Did you post the wrong quote/link? 2. What makes Campbell Macpherson an expert? He doesn't appear to have scientific credentials. Are these the kinds of experts you've been listening to? > Campbell Macpherson: international business advisor, change expert, keynote speaker and author of 'The Change Catalyst: secrets to successful and sustainable change' (Wiley 2017) - the 2018 Business Book of the Year.
- 8943gG4f 3y ago[dead]
- 8943gG4f 3y ago[dead]
- i_love_cookies 3y ago[dead]
- t3estabc 3y ago[dead]
- yboris 3y agoThe graphs of water temperature over the last 2 years have been off the charts - literally; required adjusting the y-axis: https://twitter.com/LeonSimons8/status/1754540413350732180 https://twitter.com/LeonSimons8/status/1754540413350732180
- phkahler 3y agoBut why is that? Why a sudden jump this year?
- ancientworldnow 3y agoOne component is that El Nino started. Until 2023 we were in La Nina that was suppressing ocean temperatures.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoThe reduction of sulfur dioxide pollution from shipping in 2020 has had a pro-warming effect.
- malfist 3y agoChange in the fuels cargo ships use. Previous fuels where high in sulfur which is all kinds of nasty, but has the benefit if seeding clouds. More warming this year is due to fewer clouds, at least partially.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoAnother component besides el ninõ could be pollution from shipping emissions: https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2022-10-06-new-analysis-shipping-emissions-reveals-air-pollution-has-larger-effect-climate https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2022-10-06-new-analysis-shipping-e...
- kouru225 3y agoIf I remember correctly: Ships were using a particular type of gas that was outlawed recently. Turns out it was also acting as a coolant for the atmosphere. The bad news is that global warming is further along than we expected. The good news is that we now have evidence that a global campaign for cooling the atmosphere can actually work. Can’t find sources right now, but it was very interesting when it came out ~6 months ago.
- TravisCooper 3y ago[flagged]
- boxed 3y agoIt's ~420 PPM now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_atmosphere#/media/File:Mauna_Loa_CO2_monthly_mean_concentration.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_at...
- stephen_g 3y agoDo you mean to imply something in such a small concentration can’t have any adverse effect - because in that case, would you breathe the same concentration of hydrogen cyanide in air? (Just a hint - don’t do that)
- TravisCooper 3y agoCO2 is 0.04% of the earth's atmosphere, amazing! 79% Nitrogen 21% Oxygen 0.9% Argon 0.1% Other (includes CO2)
- alexb_ 3y agoThere's been some talk about ship emissions changing and created more global warming because some of the chemicals they pumped actually had a cooling effect. I can't remember the specifics, but was there ever a reason why we couldn't just pump out cooling agents into the atmosphere?
- sci_prog 3y agoHere is a decent explanation as to why not: https://youtu.be/CHJKKsOHtAk?si=FYd1FawD-_GN_Cex https://youtu.be/CHJKKsOHtAk?si=FYd1FawD-_GN_Cex
- thriftwy 3y agoSince it is actually a nasty, acid rain causing, Sulfur Oxide.
- wk_end 3y agoGiven the choice - and I'm sincerely asking this, because I don't know enough about the subject - what'd be worse here, the disease or the cure? Could we live with acid rain if it staved off cataclysmic global warming?
- sophacles 3y agoAcid rain kills trees and other plant-life long term. This is bad for global warming... it's not an "either or".
- yojo 3y agoIf the goal is to conduct intentional geoengineering to reduce global warming, there are better things to inject into the atmosphere than sulfur dioxide. Basically just reflective dust.
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoHad to look this up, very interesting: https://www.thedailybeast.com/weve-been-accidentally-geoengineering-the-earth-for-decades-with-ship-tracks https://www.thedailybeast.com/weve-been-accidentally-geoengi...
- sircastor 3y agoMy wife is taking a course in environmental architecture, and the information she's been sharing is nothing short for terrifying. Worse, the messaging about "doing your part" seems embarrassingly naive now.
- kibwen 3y agoOne way or the other, people will be doing their part. Might as well get used to consuming less now before contraction forces the issue.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIt’s more about building your life to maximize self sufficiency with the understanding that you will still need to rely on society for some needs. Also living somewhere with low climate risk and high confidence of access to fresh water for the remainder of your life (and that of loved ones, if applicable). When contraction occurs, if you’ve planned properly, it’ll be news you read about, not impact on your life. TLDR Optimize for the expectation of persistent volatility.
- 36933 3y agoWhere are these places?
- quonn 3y agoWell, there are plenty of maps that show which areas will be impacted more than others.
- raisedbyninjas 3y agoClimate havens, near the great lakes in the US.
- bmelton 3y agoFEMA has a list somewhere, but IIRC, the top of it included places like Buffalo, a few cities in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Ann Arbor. Established cities along the great lakes are supposedly best positioned, but I've seen reports indicating that the age of the cities' infrastructure was a weakness for basically every one of the supposed climate havens
- dadjoker 3y ago[flagged]
- ceejayoz 3y agoWe can go quite a bit further back than 80 years for temperature records. https://www.bas.ac.uk/data/our-data/publication/ice-cores-and-climate-change/ https://www.bas.ac.uk/data/our-data/publication/ice-cores-an... > By measuring the ratios of different water isotopes in polar ice cores, we can determine how temperature in Antarctica and Greenland has changed in the past. The oldest continuous ice core we have was drilled by the European Project for Ice Coring in Antarctica (EPICA) from Dome C on the Antarctic plateau (Fig. 3). It extends back 800,000 years and shows a succession of long, cold ‘glacial’ periods, interspersed roughly every 100,000 years by warm ‘interglacial’ periods (of which the last 11,000 years is the most recent).
- KingOfCoders 3y agoIn another thread today one mentioned Hypercanes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercane And I so, haha, 12°C higher ocean temperatures needed, I will not live long enough to see this. Not so sure anymore.
- Clubber 3y ago[flagged]
- andrewmutz 3y agoDoes this matter? If these results show that the ocean was cooler earlier than we thought, why is that important to our climate change goals? Aren't the absolute temperature level goals more important than the relative temperature goals? And the absolute temperature goals arent affected by this finding. I am not an ecologist or earth scientist, so please let me know if I am missing something.
- ajuc 3y agoHigh base effect. If you measure growth from erronously high starting point and then base your estimates on that mistakenly low growth rate - you'll significantly underestimate the future values.
- TSiege 3y agoI'm not sure what you mean by absolute temperature level vs relative temperature. The reason that these finding are important is because 1. The climate goals set in the Paris Agreement are looking realistically more impossible by the day. If this is finding is correct 1.5C is literally impossible and 2C looks implausible given current trajectories 2. This means we've been underestimating the amount of change that has already occurred which means we might be closer to climate tipping points 3. We've been finding that Climate Sensitivity, that is how likely a tipping point like glacier collapses or losing the Amazon Rainforest, is MORE sensitive than we thought. This means lower levels of warming will have bigger impacts. So coupled with already being passed. For example 1.5C is considered the cut off point for which we'll see a global extinction of coral reef ecosystems. Meaning it's likely to late to save 25% of marine ecosystems
- RGamma 3y agoNo it doesn't, just Don't Look Up.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI heard interesting tidbit on Sabine's YouTube channel. That climate scientist have actually 'toned' down the doom outlooks. Because it turns people off to much. Like there will be no action if people knew how bad it was. So they take 'averages', that kind of show warming, but 'not that bad'. When really, it is 'really bad'. So the 'right' is saying all the climate scientist are 'doomer's and causing sensational hype to promote their theories to sell books. When really, they are toning it down. To be as reasonable as possible. To be 'as sure' as possible.
- astrodust 3y agoWhen they tone it down, they look like idiots because their most pessimistic predictions from one era become the most optimistic ones from the next. But of course, politics.
- graemep 3y ago> That climate scientist have actually 'toned' down the doom outlooks. Because it turns people off to much. Like there will be no action if people knew how bad it was. That sounds wrong. They should be giving people the most accurate estimates and the error range, not toning it down (or going the other way). > So the 'right' is saying all the climate scientist are 'doomer's and causing sensational hype to promote their theories to sell books. So now it is a partisan political issue? No chance of sensible discussion at all then.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoMaybe I shouldn't have said 'scientist'. Scientist have 100's of studies, and create 100's of models. The results are a range. Then various agencies release 'reports' that are summaries of the models. But, like in a lot of fields, you can toss outliers like the top 5 extremes hot and cold. And of course, it's a report, so the language can be as 'toned down', or 'hyped' as you want to make it, or judge it. I'm sure if it was over-hyped, many would complain that way too. What this video was then explaining, was that some of the 'hot' models might actually have been more accurate. So the entire report is even more skewed 'cold', the emergency is actually greater.
- lp4vn 3y agoI'm not optimistic honestly. We have politicians throughout the world whose political platform revolves around denying that the global warming(climate change) even exists. With this level of irrationality it's hard to see the world collaborating towards a solution for something that in the best scenario is going to change the world as we know it and in the worst scenario represents an existential threat. We thought that with the internet and the acessibility of scientific content we would have a global society of conscious people with a high degree of scientific literacy and instead of that what we got is the ressurgence of the flat earth theory, fakenews about vaccination and a growing general hostility to science. I think at some point in the future we will get "used" to progressively catastrophic climatic events, and the people who created this state of things will either be dead or will just adapt their discourse as "it's sad but it was a necessary step to avoid a global green dictatorship".
- JohnMakin 3y agoAgree - it's also extremely concerning that otherwise intelligent and educated people I know that have never been climate deniers have shifted into this absurd climate "optimism" which borders on delusional that's approximately like "well, eventually things will get so bad that capitalism will save us and we'll plant a bunch of trees or capture carbon or pump coolants into the atmosphere" and is generally unbothered by it otherwise. It's astounding to me, no matter how much you try to reason and give examples of why these approaches can't/haven't been working, it's like trying to get through a brick wall. I understand why - to have any kids right now would be terrifying. Hell, to be under 50 right now is terrifying. But just because the truth is scary does not mean we should retreat to delusion.
- orangecat 3y agoIt's astounding to me, no matter how much you try to reason and give examples of why these approaches can't/haven't been working, it's like trying to get through a brick wall. Do you think trying to force everyone to radically alter their lifestyles is going to work any better? Once again I find myself confused when so-called environmentalists seamlessly shift between "renewables will soon be so cheap and abundant that there's no need for nuclear power" to "we're all doomed unless we strictly ration energy and abolish capitalism".
- sebmellen 3y agoWe need more rapid cooling and SO2 right now — https://makesunsets.com https://makesunsets.com is leading the way but we need as many companies in the rapid cooling space as possible. We need to address the heatstroke in an emergency-room-medicine style before going into the proverbial ICU of carbon sequestration and nuclear power buildout.
- uoaei 3y agoSure there will be many moving parts to any successful recovery, but we should be careful. The cure for heat stroke isn't a freedive in arctic waters. Be wary of anyone who makes singular arguments.
- sebmellen 3y agoThe immediate cure for heatstroke is LITERALLY an "arctic dive" in the form of immersion in an ice bath https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/heat-stroke/diagnosis-treatment/drc-20353587 https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/heat-stroke/d....
- uoaei 3y agoI didn't say ice bath, I said freedive, precisely for the reason that one is much more easily reversible than the other once you reach a sustainable temperature. If it was as easy to remove SO2 from the atmosphere as it would be to step out of an ice bath, then I would have said ice bath.
- elil17 3y agoI think doing a small amount of aerosol injection right now is an appropriate way to confirm that we understand how they work/what the effects will be. I hope that the work this company is doing is being adequately studied.
- sebmellen 3y agoYes, SO2 falls out of the atmosphere after about one year. We already have proof of this in the form of volcanic eruptions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injection#Natural_and_anthropogenic_sulfates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injectio.... SO2 is a short-term, fast-acting, and reversible cooling option. That is why we need to massively adopt it ASAP.
- imnotreallynew 3y ago[flagged]
- lukevp 3y agoA solar panel hooked up to an LED light bulb does not create virtually any waste heat… and a heat pump creates heat but it also creates cold. Global warming as I understand it is mostly about solar radiation being trapped within the atmosphere due to changes in the atmosphere itself and not really due to anything we’re doing at ground level heat-generation-wise (only gases emitted)
- zinckiwi 3y agoI am not an expert so this is just my gut talking, but I suspect that the effect of emissions on the energy that the planet absorbs from the sun dwarfs the heat that our machines produce by some very large multiple.
- imnotreallynew 3y agoYes, and that’s been the line of thinking taught in schools and every discussion I’ve read on this topic for at least 20 years. Yet, there never seems to be any concrete proof that heating is being caused by excess energy being trapped inside the atmosphere because “emissions”. Again, it’s all very hand wavy. I’m not saying that’s NOT the method of action, it totally could be, but I would think there would be more evidence nowadays compared to 20 years ago but there doesn’t seem to be. Everyone just parrots everyone else. I’m just thinking of Occam’s razor. Perhaps the planet is getting hotter because were just producing a fuckload of heat. It doesn’t need to be anywhere near the energy the planet captures from the sun. But day after day, over decades, surely the minuscule amount of heat being generated by activity on the surface has SOME cumulative effect. Or maybe not, i dont know.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- djleni 3y ago
- tschellenbach 3y agoThere is just no democratic support for fixing global warming since it's too expensive. See the riots in France when they tried to tax gas more heavily. I like Bill Gate's book on the topic. We need technological progress in several areas -> lower the premium on solving climate change -> enable political solutions. (Don't get me wrong, I wish a political solution was possible. Climate change is a major threat. But in a democracy leaders can't do deeply unpopular things. Lots of people want to fix climate change. The challenge is it currently requires increasing the price of construction, electricity, food, and gas)
- JoshGG 3y agoJust watch how expensive not fixing it will be.
- erikpukinskis 3y agoHow is that relevant? The voting public will typically delay expensive cost-saving measures. Because the majority of individuals will do the same. Also forced public expenditures are a huge money making opportunity for the capital class, so they will tend to encourage delay as well.
- quonn 3y agoWe know that, but it doesn't change a thing. Your or my opinion has little influence. Therefore baby steps should be taken which will reduce that cost.
- hayd 3y agoWhy baby steps vs radical technological innovation? We waste our time with virtual signalling nonsense, that hurt the least affluent here, whilst China/India/Africa are going to be outputting vastly more CO2 to make any of our efforts net-irrelevant to climate change. We need to fix it for the world. That'll require big-impact innovation.
- 12345hn6789 3y agoExpensive for folks in the future* That is what is running through people's heads. And apparently they are not a part of this future either.
- TravisCooper 3y agoAmazing how precise we can get these number with what appears to be a very tight margin of error. The temperature estimating margin-of-error for sponges must be super tight! ;)
- greenie_beans 3y agoman, the climate apathy on this website discourages me. i thought HN users were smart? yall are blinded by your desire to be a contrarian and skeptic.
- p_j_w 3y agoHN users are just like most people: smart in their area of expertise and wildly optimistic about how smart they are outside of it.
- linuxftw 3y agoMaybe. Or we know junk science and fake data when we see it. I guess the 'replication crisis' doesn't apply to the holy climate science.
- copperx 3y agoI still remember the big group of climate change deniers on Slashdot in the early 00s. The consensus was that it was not real.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 8943gG4f 3y ago[dead]
- paganel 3y agoIn that case seems like nothing that big happened, hasn’t it? No known apocalypse or anything similar.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIn the same sense that an ongoing game of Russian Roulette does, sure.
- paganel 3y agoAnd we’re back to scare-mongering, because that’s the only thing that still works on (a smaller and smaller) part of the population. What happened to science and facts-based science? What happened to the “if climate heats up by just two degrees then very bad things will happen” that were uttered all throughout the 2000s, even going into the early 2010s? Where are those very bad things?
- ceejayoz 3y agoIs it genuinely inconcievable to you that a bad thing can take some time to occur? Especially on a planetary scale?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TravisCooper 3y agoCO2 is 0.04% of the earth's atmosphere, amazing! 79% Nitrogen 21% Oxygen 0.9% Argon 0.1% Other (includes CO2)
- ceejayoz 3y ago"Small things can't ever hurt anyone" is a... tough theory to support scientifically.
- TravisCooper 3y agoStarting at the bottom with basic facts helps build understanding.
- mydogcanpurr 3y ago30 ng of botulinum toxin can kill you. What's your point?
- nullorempty 3y agoHow much do wars cost and what's their contribution to global warming? That could totally be fixed in a short order had there been a genuine concern of the politicians.
- Synaesthesia 3y agoA lot. They're extremely environmentally destructive of course, and the defense force operates 100% on fossil fuels.
- timeon 3y agoAre you saying that world peace could be fixed in short order?
- nullorempty 3y agoYes, that's what I am saying. Are you fighting with your neighbour right this moment and can't stop the fighting and talk?
- tamaharbor 3y agoLife on earth has adapted to climate change for billions of years.
- timeon 3y ago> billions of years Unfortunately this is bit quicker.
- timmytokyo 3y agoIndeed. The planet has endured multiple mass extinction events and life has continued to exist. Life will continue even after this wave of extinctions, which may or may not include humans. What's your point?
- tamaharbor 3y agoAdapt now is my point.
- frankbreetz 3y agoyes, but have humans?
- throwaway5752 3y agoJust because a lot of people are too delicate for the conversation, we are experiencing a human apocalypse. It's really the end for us, but the oil execs have to pay down the yacht bill and we can't have people angry at the diner counter in Peoria over gas prices. This happens all the time in the natural world, it would be funny if it wasn't tragic. We developed tools that let us transition from a S to J population type, without time for cultural adaptation to that new reality. People here don't know enough about the topic, and are swayed by "LOL look at Malthus" type gotcha discourse due to the normalcy cognitive bias. The ideas here about 'democratic support' are absolutely laughable. Who cares what various locusts think or feel when they have swarmed and eaten all the available plant matter? They just starve and die because they overshot their environment's carrying capacity. Mars is entirely unviable and thinking otherwise is deluding yourself with science fiction. This will be the defining realization of the next 1-10 years.
- renewiltord 3y agoFair enough but I can’t do anything about that. Letting go of these concerns has made my life way better. And thankfully, environmentalists support my viewpoint. It’s not my fault. It’s because of corporations. I used to think the way forward was that we’d use less fossil fuels but it seems like that’s not on us individually. Most environmentalists today support large homes on country lots over polluted cities and prefer cars to virtue-signaling bikes. Given that it’s actually better to live in this way I just decided to lean in. After all, they’re environmentalists. This is what they do. So nuclear and geothermal stuff is probably bad and gasoline in the truck we use as a second car is fine. Besides, I look around me and see green. How can I be wrong?
- fnimick 3y ago/s ? I'd like to know what environmentalists you follow who support driving around in a second car as opposed to public transit or cycling.
- renewiltord 3y agoSierra Club SF opposes local housing. California Environmental Quality Act advocates use it to block bike lanes. And in general, California environmentalists talk about visions for "green space" over such use. POSIWID, right? If CEQA has been most effectively used against bike lanes and housing, then CEQA's purpose is to oppose bike lanes and housing. But it's their job to know this, so I stay in my lane for the most part and cancelled my Terrapass etc. Only thing I kind of oppose is $4b/mi subway projects. I think we could use that more effectively. But otherwise, I'm happy to support the mainstream environmentalist view that geothermal and nuclear power is evil and that living stacked on top of each other like sardines is a bad thing for the environment. The second car is just a consequence of that. You can't expect my wife and me to live far away and bike 50 mi in independent directions. Listen, I'm in STEM, so I could not possibly comprehend or understand the nuances of the climate. I've got to trust the local experts and the Sierra Club et al. are local experts.
- ejb999 3y agoYou should get a private jet too, that is how all the truly committed environmentalists travel these days. </sarc>
- dog_boxer72 3y agoMy own father, who is in his 60s, has said blatantly to me that he will be dead before the real problems hit, so he would rather not give up his cruises, large cars and international flights - he just doesn’t even care that his grandchildren will suffer, since he personally won’t be around for it. Completely dispicable, but ultimately, asking people to do the right thing out of altruism is never going to work. Democracy will not work either because these people vote. At least he can admit he’s being selfish I guess. I think most climate deniers, especially the older ones, simply can’t face the idea they might be responsible for terrible things happening, and don’t want to change now, so the brain latches on to any explanation that spares them that psychological pain. Thus arguing facts is pointless with these people because it’s about feelings not actual truth (as many things are with our species). The solution is to hack peoples psyche to make them “feel good” about climate change, somehow…
- Synaesthesia 3y agoDemocracy will work, it's the only thing that's ever worked. Mass movements achieved pretty much anything you can think of, like better working hours, better rights for women, civil rights, end of slavery ...
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoLiterally every (correct) example you gave is a case of people voting in their own short-term self interests, a dynamic which does not exist with global warming. In the case of slavery, democracy didn't end this. Southern states literally seceded, and we had the bloodiest war in American history, to end slavery. And the dynamics there were that the economic systems of Northern states didn't rely on slavery, so they had little problem opposing it on moral grounds. The entire economic system of the South was built around the plantation system and slavery and so it's not surprising democracy didn't end slavery there.
- sc68cal 3y agoThe end of slavery in the United States was achieved by killing enough people who politically supported slavery in a war, that they surrendered and accepted the _de jure_ end of slavery. However, they then spent a century in a a low intensity conflict / rebellion (Reconstruction, Jim Crow, etc) against it, with significant success (unfortunately). Democracy is not the cure all that you make it out to be.
- hnthrowaway0328 3y agoJust curious, is there any implementation of infrastructures that actually harvest greenhouse gases for whatever profit? I assume we would need a LOT of them, but is it possible to build something close to the poles, assuming a lot of gases are leaking from there due to ice melting?
- DFHippie 3y agoThe problem is that all the CO2 is in the air from extracting usable energy from chemical bonds. Due to thermodynamics we need to expend more than the energy that was extracted to recreate these bonds. And the useful work is just addressing prior harm. You aren't getting widgets or food from this process. Maybe someday we'll be producing graphene sheets or carbon nanotubes as a useful resource, but that's not currently on offer.
- ianburrell 3y agoWe don't necessarily need to recreate the bonds to sequester CO2. My understanding is that CO2 can be pumped underground in locations that used to hold natural gas. It does take lots of energy to pull the 400 ppm of CO2 out of the air. It is possible there are better sequestration methods than direct capture from the air. If want to make green fuel from the CO2, that takes the same amount of energy as the fuel contains. Using green fuel in existing cars, trucks, and trains won't work. It only makes sense for things like shipping or airplanes that go long distances. And other fuels like hydrogen, methane, or methanol that are easier to produce might work for those.
- boxed 3y ago> It is possible there are better sequestration methods than direct capture from the air. There are yes. Rock weathering is probably the most feasible and simple.
- wessorh 3y agoexplain flat soft drinks... Your beer, champaign, and all carbonated drinks contain CO2 that is dissolved in solution and as the temperature increases as it sits in your glass the CO2 comes out of solution. This isn't an IQ test: now think of the oceans, as temperature changes the solubility of CO2 changes inversely proportional to temperature just like your soda pop becomes flat when it warms up. Additionally this is why soft drinks are served cold.
- RGamma 3y agoFlat earth theory confirmed?
- mr_toad 3y ago> Your beer, champaign, and all carbonated drinks contain CO2 that is dissolved in solution and as the temperature increases as it sits in your glass the CO2 comes out of solution. That’s mostly due to pressure, carbonated drinks are stored at 30-50 psi. Even a warm carbonated drink will produce bubbles.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoSoft drinks are served cold because people enjoy drinking cold drinks.
- collyw 3y agoHow does that work if it's the atmosphere that is heating from man made global warming?
- GlibMonkeyDeath 3y agoI simply don't understand this result - it takes ~4,000x as much energy to raise 1kg of water 1 degree compared to air. And how could this trend have started in 1850 (a clear trend from 1850-1900 is observed in the data in Figure 5b)? The sponges were collected at 30-100 m depth too, so this isn't just a surface effect.
- nvm0n2 3y agoYou are correct, it couldn't and in fact 1850 has traditionally been referred to in climatology as "pre industrial", but this site is really the wrong place to try and actually talk about science. The intellectual curiosity fans here don't like it at all.
- GlibMonkeyDeath 3y agoThank you - I was surprised by the down votes, although I could have added more detail to make my objection even more clear, e.g: Using the Stefan Boltzmann law, 1 extra degree corresponds to about an extra 3 W/m2 of greenhouse radiation (using an emissivity of 0.6 for the atmosphere.) To raise 1 m2, 1 cm thick water (10 kg) by 1 C would require (4 J/g/K)*(10,000 g) ~ 40,000 J, or about 4 hours. So 100 m would take 4 years, 3 km (the average depth of the ocean) ~100 years, assuming perfect mixing. So the ocean temperature would lag by decades, possibly centuries, even if the atmosphere ramped up by 1 degree from 1850-1900, which it didn't.
- selimthegrim 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed_layer#Oceanic_mixed_layer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed_layer#Oceanic_mixed_la...
- Jefferyhanson 3y ago[dead]