13 ms·
Great visualization of the unintuitive nature of special relativity. It's kind of mind blowing to realize that if we could accelerate our spaceship at a mere 1G
by ryandrake 3y ago
Great visualization of the unintuitive nature of special relativity. It's kind of mind blowing to realize that if we could accelerate our spaceship at a mere 1G continuously, we could visit the center of the Milky Way in under 20 years (spaceship time), totally do-able in a human lifespan. Of course 27900 years would have passed on Earth, so you wouldn't be able to tell anyone about your vacation.
- m3kw9 3y agoI wonder what is a safe acceleration to get to light speed for long periods without hurtin too much
- jtriangle 3y ago~9.8 m/s sounds pretty comfortable.
- bee_rider 3y agoYou can’t “get to” light speed, that’s one of the big punchlines in relativity. If you pick an acceleration equal to the acceleration we experience on Earth (aka 1g, aka ~9.8m/s^2), you hit relativistic speeds (speeds at which you need to take into account the effects of relativity to do anything) surprisingly fast. On the order of hundreds of days. So, it is not really a matter of safe acceleration on a long space trip. Instead you have to worry about the actual speed you are traveling at—even though space is very empty, there are still atoms floating around out there, and you’ll be moving at very high speeds relative to them, leading to interesting collisions.
- ryandrake 3y ago> Instead you have to worry about the actual speed you are traveling at That's the other big punchline in relativity: There's no one "actual speed" because that implies that there is a single "important" frame of reference wherein those atoms are floating around waiting to be hit by a spaceship.
- acchow 3y agoWhat if you define the "important" reference frame as the speed of light's (in the same direction you are going). Since c is universally constant, it seems like a reasonable privileged reference.
- richardw 3y agoNot a physicist, but my impression is that you're always going 0 percent of the speed of light (in all directions) from your own frame of reference. All you notice is that our solar system is moving away, faster. I guess you'd notice a change in light frequency based on the light in front/behind. Redder behind, bluer in front. Edit: supposedly we can measure our speed compared to the cosmic microwave background which is fairly uniform, which gives us a value of 400 to 800km/s relative to the CMB: https://www.researchgate.net/post/How_can_we_practically_measure_the_velocity_of_earth_in_Cosmic_Microwave_Background_rest_frame https://www.researchgate.net/post/How_can_we_practically_mea...
- eru 3y agoSee also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comoving_and_proper_distances#Comoving_coordinates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comoving_and_proper_distances#...
- raattgift 3y ago> I guess you'd notice a change in light frequency based on the light in front/behind. Redder behind, bluer in front. The light in question is not uniform like white noise; the spectral power distribution has relatively light and dark lines in them as a result of the physics of the bright sources and intervening gas and dust. Those features also get redshifted. If one is moving relative to the sun, one would pay attention to the sun's Fraunhofer lines <https://physics.weber.edu/palen/clearinghouse/labs/Solarspec/sunspec.html https://physics.weber.edu/palen/clearinghouse/labs/Solarspec...>, which would be Doppler shifted to different wavelengths. These lines also appear in reflected light from bodies in the solar system; if you were flying towards Pluto you would see a corresponding blueshift of the reflected Fraunhofer lines (plus some additional structure related to the chemistry of Pluto; it has some luminescence, as does our moon, as do the leaves of plants, and luminescence tends to impinge on the narrower Fraunhofer lines). Indeed, measuring the Doppler shifts of multiple known-chemistry light sources is a useful technique in navigation of spacecraft within our solar system; it can in principle do better than precision measurement of angles to multiple light sources. The spectral distortions of the CMB are certainly interesting, but it's hard to imagine their utility for spacecraft navigation within the Milky Way, rather than helping to physical cosmologists understand why there even is a Milky Way. In the solar system we have kind-of the opposite problem: in order to get reliable anisotropy data of the Milky Way, probes like WMAP need excellent almanac data for the ephemeris of Jupiter (it's a bright reflector of sunlight and its cloud-tops at ~70 kPa are ~22 GHz microwave-bright; I gather other outer planets are used too, but the details are beyond me) to check its 22-GHz-band detection of the CMB Doppler shift in the directions it looks.
- AlexAndScripts 3y agoI suppose you would also have to worry about surviving the trip - every atom in the interstellar medium would damage your ship, likely penetrating the entire way through, and electromagnetic repulsion would only work with charged particles.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoEvery proton would have the energy of a baseball. It's bananas. Granted, space is really empty, but it's not that empty, somewhere around a hundred atoms per cubic meter. Your ship might look like a very, very long shooting star. Probably dialing the speed down a touch would be worth it for whatever your shielding material is, but who knows? We're talking miracle engines here. I think in the "Valkyrie" ship-on-a-string concept, they had some sort of magnetic thingummy that generated more power as more stuff smacked into it, then as they decelerated they let out this sort of gas mist to go ahead of the ship and smack into things.
- foota 3y agoThese regenerative braking schemes are getting out of hand.
- robertlagrant 3y agoI like that old Arthur C Clarke novel, The Songs of Distant Earth[0], where they travel with an ablative shield in front made of ice, and they can make new shield segments by finding planets with water. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Songs_of_Distant_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Songs_of_Distant_Earth
- slowmovintarget 3y agoAlistair Reynolds also used this in his ship designs.
- M_bara 3y agoPushing ice… a brilliant book - my first foray into hard sci-fi
- thatwasunusual 3y agoWe would also need to find a way to slow down.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoYou just turn around at the half way point
- notfed 3y agoAt which point shielding gets even more complicated.
- timschmidt 3y agoLess complicated. The rocket exhaust literally forms a plasma shield in front of the decelerating rocket.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoWell then, it's easy: Just always face the exhaust in that direction! It's not rocket science!
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> always face the exhaust in that direction! It's not rocket science! You don't see a problem with trying to accelerate with two exhaust streams at 180º to each other?
- ithkuil 3y agoWhat if the front one is only a small fraction of the thrust at the rear? Would that be enough to "clear the path". Surely it would cost some efficiency but it may beat he alternative
- EA-3167 3y agoIt's worth saying that 1G is heavy acceleration to maintain, nothing "mere" about it. When you run the numbers the amount of energy involved basically adds up to needing a rocket made entirely of antimatter, and a similar mass of 'normal' matter to react with. Keep in mind that when talking about long-distance journeys in space under any sort of constant acceleration, the numbers are generally in thousandths of 1G.
- slow_typist 3y agoBut accelerating by 1 g is very convenient for the crew. No muscle and bone degeneration, no space sickness, etc.
- EA-3167 3y agoIt would be cheaper in every sense to turn something like a giant asteroid into a rotating habitat ship than achieve a constant 1g to even the closest systems. Realistically interstellar travel is not a thing that (biologically modern) humans will ever be suited for, robotic probes don't need thousands of kg of food and water to stay alive, don't need artificial gravity, air, or entertainment. The fact that the trip is inevitably 1-way won't bother probes and robots either.
- eru 3y agoYou are right. One addendum: many humans would be bothered by one-way trips, but humanity is large, and in absolute numbers there are still plenty of volunteers for one-way trips to the planets and stars.
- BHSPitMonkey 3y agoAnd how many in that group are actually fit to spend many years living that lifestyle without losing their mind and getting into deadly fights with one another? And who's covering the great expense of building these generational colony ships and training their only inhabitants, only to have them zip away never to be heard from again? (With no benefit other than believing there's a slight chance we've succeeded in making our species multi-plantary)?
- jcadam 3y agoCould use such a ship as a time machine (well, that only goes one way).
- tshaddox 3y agoDo you mean that someone in the space ship could, without extending their own lifespan beyond what is already expected, use the space ship to "travel" to Earth's distant future?
- hackerlight 3y agoKip Thorne said it's theoretically possible. One end of the wormhole is on earth, the other is on the spaceship. Then you fly the spaceship and hop into the wormhole and arrive into the future on Earth.
- wholinator2 3y agoYou don't even need the wormhole. You just accelerate away to relativistic speeds then turn around and come back. It doesn't matter which direction you're going, just that you're going _fast_.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ithkuil 3y agoPrecisely. That's the famous Twin "paradox" (which is not a paradox)
- daedalus_j 3y agoThe Forever War novels have this as a key plot point, if you're interested in that sort of thing.
- Tostino 3y agoThe whole Ender's game series also uses this as a plot device.
- lostmsu 3y agoIt does not take much more years to the edge of the visible universe.
- EA-3167 3y agoIirc to get to Proxima Centauri at a constant 1g would require a fairly impressive mass of antimatter, to continue to the edge of the observable universe would be so many more orders of magnitude more energy than that it's barely worth discussing. Even though we can't reach c, as we start to approach it the energy requirements rise catastrophically, along with the risk of colliding with some random mote of Hydrogen and remembering that your relative velocity is .99999c, in the moment before you and your ship are atomized.
- robofanatic 3y agoHow many years will it take to accelerate from normal speed to that speed and decelerate back?
- multiplegeorges 3y ago10. Assuming a straight line and assuming 1G is your max acceleration: you accelerate for 10 years, reach your maximum velocity then flip and do the same thing in the other direction. You'll reach your destination with 0 velocity.
- huytersd 3y agoTime travel seems so easy and we could do it with the tools we have now for the most part. Maybe we’ll never go into the past but relatively contemporary humans are going to be all over the future in all kinds of places. After the first time it happens people in the future can start to expect a human from the past to keep visiting every so often.
- tempestn 3y agoIf that did start happening, it's not like the people from the past would just pop up suddenly. We would be aware of their journey. It's not like a time machine where someone just disappears from the past and appears in the future.
- huytersd 3y agoSure, and we would probably be able to tell when they were from based on the approaching crafts. It’s going to be amazing to be able to step 50,000 years into the future to see how humanity has turned out. I’d give up anything to have a chance at that.
- tempestn 3y agoYou could always take a flier on cryonics.
- lp4vn 3y agoIf you stop to think, a trip to the future is a trip to immortality because you can go to a time where the technology to live forever will be available.
- gbin 3y agoUnfortunately humanity is constantly on the verge of self destruction so I would expect to come back to a radioactive smoldering place with some survivors roaming around still trying to finish one another with sticks and stones.
- alberth 3y ago> accelerate our spaceship at a mere 1G continuously Do you mean accelerate at 9.8 m/s^2 ?
- mcswell 3y agoBut think of all the leave time I'd accumulate!
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoNot doable. There exists nothing, even theoretically that you can put on the spaceship to get you that 1G continuous acceleration. I don't remember exactly what is the maximum achievable delta V but if I remember well it is not a high portion of the speed of light, more like 60% of speed of light. And that assuming you have crazy things like carry a small black hole with you and use it to convert mass into energy at 40% efficiency.
- 867-5309 3y ago>27900 years would have passed on Earth, so you wouldn't be able to tell anyone about your vacation you could tell them when they overtake you due to incessant obsolescence
- monkeydust 3y agoIts a true mind f*. A round trip would take the best part out of a normal human lifetime but it would appear that you have travelled over 55 thousand years into the future when you return the earth...assuming it's still there.
- camelliahmmm 3y ago[dead]