20 ms·
More misdrilled holes on 737 MAX in latest setback
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://archive.today/MWMPG https://archive.today/MWMPG
- rossdavidh 3y agoI do get the impression that the current Boeing CEO is attempting to turn the culture around, to a more "admit the problem and fix it" kind of attitude. The problem is that, if you are doing this after many years of "deny the problem and ship it", the number of apparent problems is actually going to go up for a while. I wonder if Boeing's customers and shareholders will have enough patience for him to complete the transformation (assuming that's even possible in a company this size)?
- Workaccount2 3y agoBoeing needs to dump the CEO and install someone from an engineering lineage if they want to build their reputation back. An engineering company run by a longtime manager with a background in accounting is in large part how Boeing got here. Fire the guy and get someone with a technical background in there.
- BoxFour 3y agoLike this guy? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Muilenburg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Muilenburg
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BenoitP 3y agoI've read that he was the token engineer in the see of accountants, MBAs and consultants. Cultural change goes much deeper than changing the CEO. Boeing might not be salvageable on the cheap side. Decapitating the company at levels 1-4 may not even be enough. It may require acknowledging that changing the flight envelope and software-patching it was a mistake. This is a major can of worms on itself. This means a plane redesign, 6-8 years delay, and probably another round of WTO-unfriendly subsidy.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> I've read that he was the token engineer in the see of accountants, MBAs and consultants The myth that engineers make better leaders may have originated with Andy Grove. In truth, there is no evidence for the claim. Jack Welch was as much an engineer as an asshole.
- bee_rider 3y agoInteresting that Grove’s company would go on to provide some of the best evidence that putting an engineer at the wheel is no magic bullet.
- galleywest200 3y agoIt is not about them being better leaders, but the engineer (hopefully) considering the efficacy of their design over bean counting.
- shiroiuma 3y agoHaving an engineer as CEO can get you dumb decisions like thinking the Pentium4 Netburst architecture and dependency on expensive RAMBUS memory is a great idea.
- shiroiuma 3y ago>The myth that engineers make better leaders may have originated with Andy Grove. Quite possible, and what's really ironic is that Grove's successor, Craig Barrett (who helped start the company with Grove), also an engineer, was a terrible CEO. He was the one who made a bunch of bad moves: P4/Netburst + RAMBUS, Itanic, refusing to adopt amd64 or make their own x64-64 ISA before AMD, etc. The company did poorly under his leadership and only turned around when his successor, Paul Otellini (an accountant IIRC) took over and moved to the "Core" CPU architecture.
- dv_dt 3y agoThis is the guy that Boeing should have made CEO https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Mulally https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Mulally who has a much deeper background on the civil aviation side of things. Turned down for the Boeing CEO position, went to Ford and carried them through the Great recession as one of the big 3 auto makers that did not need a govt bailout. I'd say call him back, but he's probably enjoying retirement by now.
- Gravityloss 3y agoSome people at Boeing criticize Mulally though. 777 program involved already a lot of outsourcing. There's a nice documentary about the program on youtube, "21st Century Jet": https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=21st+century+jet https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=21st+century+je...
- dv_dt 3y agoAfter Mulally left, Boeing went all in (to an extreme imho) on outsourcing. I don’t know enough to say if he would have done the same. But imho spinning off fundamental items like fuselages is a big source of inefficiency and risk right now for Boeing.
- strangattractor 3y agoMore like this guy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk Someone with an engineering background and a pinch of Vlad the Impaler;)
- belter 3y agoIf you would hire Elon Musk as CEO, he would substitute all the pilots by FSD beta version 2.3.4, and change all the airplane seats USB chargers for a Neuralink plug.
- BoxFour 3y agoWhatever your opinion of Elon is, it’s extremely generous to say he comes from an engineering background and just flat-out wrong to say he comes from the type of traditional engineering background relevant to companies like Boeing (the PE type of engineering). If you approve of Elon as a leader, he is basically the embodiment of “you do not need to be an engineer to run a highly technical company”
- rpmisms 3y agoI think describing Elon as a small-e engineer (not designing powertrains, but at least understanding them) is accurate, and saying that an an engineering-first mindset is important for companies like Boeing and SpaceX would ring true. Engineering background is different than engineering mindset.
- afavour 3y agoPeople contain multitudes. While I would agree that Elon has more of an engineer mindset than other CEOs I’m still not convinced that would amount to much. A look at Tesla build quality, or that ridiculous demo where the Cybertruck window smashed are just two things that immediately come to mind to cast doubt on Musk’s commitment to engineering. I think he’s a big picture guy, I absolutely think issues like those we're seeing with Boeing could happen under his watch.
- 3y ago
- balderdash 3y agoI don’t think this a technical problem - it’s a matter of changing culture.
- wongarsu 3y agoIt's frequently framed as an issue with Boing now having an accounting-driven culture instead of an engineering-driven culture. In that framing a CEO with engineering background is a logical choice to effect that culture change.
- NoboruWataya 3y agoIt was arguably under Muilenberg, an engineer, that many of the current issues with Boeing's culture were either created or allowed to flourish. I think it is "frequently framed" as an engineers-vs-accountants thing by engineers or others who like to think that STEM people can do no wrong.
- hef19898 3y agoI am an engineee of sorts, and have zero illusions about the shit engineers can cause, and do.
- throwway120385 3y agoI think the real problem here is over-reliance on cost-savings as a single dimension of quality.
- hef19898 3y agoCost savings and quality live on different scales so.
- throwway120385 3y agoIf a customer wants to buy thousands of a widget at $1500 and you usually sell them at $2000 a widget but you can move the slider on maintainability or make an agreement that the customer accepts some reduced quality -- if that's something the two businesses can agree on and it's not a negligent change to make then it's probably worth prioritizing that. I think we might agree on that. Trying to figure out what to do in any given business situation is usually challenging because the devil is in the details. It happens that in this particular case, Boeing should be checking that their supplier installs bolts and drills holes correctly because their supplier has screwed it up so many times. But in a lot of industries, cheaping out on materials is a reasonable thing to do if your customers agree it's a reasonable thing to do and it's not going to kill anyone.
- tsunamifury 3y agoAh yes the fantasy that an IC can just magic this all away. This would likely result in a CEO with no pull and a CFO that had all the hard power to call the shots. The reality seems to be, for some reason, building profitable and safe planes in America is becoming increasingly difficult. A company most be able to do both: build a quality and safe product and make a margin. It can’t exist without revenue. I’m guessing the real problem is somewhere between low quality or overworked and poorly trained line workers, complex systems, and a revenue strategy that obscures what the company is selling. It takes more than a random ic manager to fix that — but I agree they should come from that past maybe.
- sebzim4500 3y ago>The reality seems to be, for some reason, building profitable and safe planes in America is becoming increasingly difficult. Is there another data point or are you just basing this off Boeing's issues?
- jacquesm 3y agoThe other datapoints have been merged into Boeing or they went away, Lockheed hasn't made a passenger plane for decades. Gulfstream doesn't really count I think, because it isn't in competition with either Boeing or Airbus.
- TylerE 3y agoBuilding airplanes it a bit like running a restaurant... it's a business no sane person would willingly go in to.
- randmeerkat 3y ago> Building airplanes it a bit like running a restaurant... it's a business no sane person would willingly go in to. Other people with a similar perspective about rockets tried to convince Musk that as well. Thankfully he didn’t listen. You’re never going to realize gains that surpass the return on the S&P if you don’t take risks in business.
- spamizbad 3y agoI don't think having an engineer as a leader is some golden ticket to success. Its ultimately what ruined Nortel for example.
- Twirrim 3y agoSame for Sun Microsystems.
- hef19898 3y agoNor is it an indicator for good business ethics: exhibit A, the VW Diesel scandal.
- fch42 3y agoSun Microsystems never had an engineering-career CEO; whether Scott McNealy, Ed Zander, or Ponytail ... all on the sales side. No doubt it had strong "CTO" type people. Though not in the CEO, chairman or president/COO positions.
- avalys 3y agoSelecting an engineer doesn’t absolve the board of the responsibility to choose the right guy. There are incompetent engineers, unethical engineers and there are engineers who are bad leaders. But an accountant as CEO is not going to restore a culture of engineering excellence.
- lrem 3y agoWhy? The CEO of a company this big, no matter their background, has no business building an intimate understanding of the tech. They’re there to set up an incentive system to further the goals of their choosing. Neither seems to call for deep understanding of neither. And no background absolves a CEO from building a surface understanding of all aspects of running the business. TBF, from my experience with VPs, technical background might be a hindrance to executives. The guy who used to work on databases worries about persistence, even though nobody raised that issue. Networking background? Oh well, good that I know why we put this many bits into this field, despite it only needs a couple bytes and we can afford megabytes. Sure, they know their job enough to leave enough time for the actual question. I even understand why they first interrogate the room about some arbitrary cog in the machine. Still makes me wonder if there aren’t better ways to do this.
- acomms 3y agoThe "engineer CEO" you speak of is the one who was at the helm when all the mess kicked off.
- bookofjoe 3y agoInteresting. Last night I watched the excellent 2018 biopic "First Man" (starring Ryan Gosling) about Neil Armstrong and was struck by NASA's selection criteria for Gemini and Apollo astronauts: they required pilots with an engineering background. Frank Borman, chosen for Gemini and Apollo missions, "earned a Master of Science degree at Caltech in 1957, and then became an assistant professor of thermodynamics and fluid mechanics at West Point." [Wikipedia] "After retiring from NASA and the Air Force in 1970, Borman became senior vice president for operations at Eastern Air Lines. He became chief executive officer of Eastern in 1975, and chairman of the board in 1976. Under his leadership, Eastern went through the four most profitable years in its history...." [Wikipedia]
- saalweachter 3y agoI think you also need to be expecting the CEO to "clean house" at the top if you realistically want anything to change. The CEO may set the culture, as much as that is set from the top down, but by the time a company actually starts having problems visible to the outside, its entire suite of executives, VPs, etc, have optimized their career for the sort of problematic attitude the previous CEOs demanded.
- andyjohnson0 3y ago> Boeing needs to dump the CEO and install someone from an engineering lineage if they want to build their reputation back. I'd argue they need an effective engineering culture, and leadership that enables and values and fights for it, not a former-engineer figurehead. Good engineers within Boeing need to be enabled to do their job properly, within normal business constraints, and bad engineers need to be removed. The business needs to understand that good engineering is a necessity and a profit centre in aerospace. I don't know how they'd achieve this change. The company seems to have rotted from the head down since it merged with McDonnel Douglas, and its possible that the senior leadership lack the self awareness to comprehend the problem.
- hinkley 3y agoMove headquarters back to Puget Sound. It’s the only way.
- AaronM 3y agoI think the MD merge gets the blame by many, however, it seems as though the shift in the market that started around the same time to optimize shareholder value at all costs is really to blame.
- kelnos 3y agoI think it's both in a sort of chicken and egg sort of situation. The MD execs taking over Boeing had a terrible effect on safety culture, but the reason the MD execs took over in the first place was because of this shift in the market that you describe. If the pre-MD Boeing management had managed to retain control of the company things may have been ok from a quality and safety perspective... but the stock would have declined because they would have refused to chase short-term quarterly success at the expense of the long term.
- p_l 3y agoPhil Condit was a Boeing engineering lifer who spearheaded the first steps that led to things described as "MD takeover". And was still in charge of 7E7 (today's Dreamliner) when the excessive outsourcing and cost targets began.
- _xerces_ 3y agoMuilenburg was an aerospace engineer by training, that is how he ended up at Boeing. To be fair, though it sounds like he was on the management track early on, so not sure how much engineering he did after graduation.
- OhMeadhbh 3y agoI think you think Boeing's purpose in life is to make planes. I think it's primary objective is to make money for execs and short term traders. If airplanes come out of the company, it's a random side-effect.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> I think it's primary objective is to make money for execs... Plausibly, yes. > ... and short term traders. Nope. Not even on the radar. Stockholders, maybe. Not short term traders. Short term traders have no say on the makeup of the board, nor on executive compensation. They therefore have zero input into the direction of the company.
- denton-scratch 3y agoI don't buy the oft-repeated claim that you can re-make a company simply by replacing the CEO. I don't believe that CEOs in large companies have much influence on the company's direction, except in terms of decisions to downsize/outsource, how to use money, and who's on the board. There's only so much one person can do (and accordingly, I think all big-company CEOs are vastly overpaid). Moving the deckchairs in the boardroom isn't going to solve systemic problems in a company.
- twh270 3y agoYou can't "re-make" a company by replacing the CEO/CxO, but I wouldn't be too quick to dismiss the influence of the c-suite either. What they care about and talk about filters down, often through unofficial channels of communication, and it does have an impact on how front-line employees do their work. Of course, this does take time and often involves some changes in management as well.
- denton-scratch 3y agoI've been watching the Post Office Horizon Inquiry sessions, and reading transcripts. From what I've seen, a completely new board would have no noticeable effect on the PO; they'd have to remove most of the management. It looks as if the company ethos is driven by line management. Well, that really means tearing the company up completely. I can't see how a new board could effect reform. And replacing all the middle management would destroy the company. And as you say, it takes time for a new culture to move through the layers; but the PO doesn't have time. Does Boeing? I realize the companies are very different, but both have marinated in an unhealthy culture for a long time.
- kelnos 3y agoIf replacing all of middle management to effect an essential change will destroy a company, then that company maybe needs to be destroyed. Because that's how the CEO makes big change happen: management -- from the C-suite down to line managers -- needs to get on board with that change. If they refuse, they get fired and are replaced by people who will carry out the change. If this process will take too long to save the company, then... again, maybe the company needs to fail.
- ken47 3y agoBoeing apparently can't withstand the immense quarterly financial scrutiny it is under without making dangerous engineering trade offs. Time to take the company private?
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]
- hef19898 3y agoAt 420?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBoeing’s customers have no choice. There is only one other option in town, and Airbus is at capacity for quite a few more years. The only threat Boeing has is governments fining them. So as long as governments (or the US government) let Boeing continue to function, there should be sufficient time to fix culture.
- wasmitnetzen 3y agoShareholders might have an opinion though, and Ryanair buying MAX's at a discount when nobody else wanted them might not make them happy.
- magicalhippo 3y ago> Ryanair buying MAX's at a discount I mean, to be fair this plays right into Ryanair's strategy. Want a door plug? Pay extra.
- anticensor 3y agoNo, want a door plug? Pay less (as you would be paying by risking your life).
- magicalhippo 3y agoYea they could play it both ways, before and after the plug leaves the plane...
- xattt 3y agoThey could still charge extra depending on your pro/con door plug attitude with rationale matching your beliefs as to why they’re charging more.
- phkahler 3y ago>> I do get the impression that the current Boeing CEO is attempting to turn the culture around, to a more "admit the problem and fix it" kind of attitude. I thought I read they were planning to cut back on quality control staff this year. Was that true? Did it change?
- barbazoo 3y agoInteresting, source?
- procflora 3y agoI'm not sure about this year, but here is an article from 2020 between the MAX crashes about that very thing. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boeing-overhauls-its-quality-controls-more-high-tech-tracking-but-fewer-inspectors/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein... Ed Pierson, a Boeing whistleblower on quality, has also commented on similar efforts by the company a couple of months later. https://www.edpierson.com/removal-of-quality-control-inspections-adds-risk-to-boeing-airplanes https://www.edpierson.com/removal-of-quality-control-inspect...
- mc32 3y agoI’m sorry, but too little, too late. It’s time for a new executive team incl CEO. They breached the trust of their customers. I want to see new leadership, not someone who suddenly turns a new leaf.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoIf this is what is happening, then that is encouraging. Anytime a corporation had 'culture of silence'. Then turns it around to be 'speak up'. There is a backlog of issues that comes out before the situation improves.
- CodeWriter23 3y agoI said this in a previous thread, a QA/QC/SOP firm either has a culture where nobody would dare violate SOP or it doesn’t. It’s not about “admitting” a problem, they already have the SOPs and inspection protocols that reveal defects and proscribe ways to identify, document and address any defect. But as the QA guys where I work say, they are a cost center. There are two real questions here, can Boeing strictly follow their QA/QC regime and remain profitable. Second, can they get through their current period where FAA inspectors have set up shop on their premises and are now effectively another layer of supervisors. They’re in the stage now where the FAA are on the shop floor basically as cops to ensure Boeing actually does what they said they would do via the documentation in their Quality suite. They either have the war chest or the financial backing to pull that off without an immediate price increase or they’re toast.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoWonder if this is problem. Current QA/SOP's are onerous and very expensive to follow. But are based on having someone 'monitor' and 'check' everything. So two people, someone doing the work, and someone checking the work. But seems like the old Boeing culture, was each employee cared about quality, so would check themselves. So needed less QA people, because everyone would 'do the right thing'. So now that the culture is broken. Enforcing current QA/SOP's with additional QA people is un-profitable.
- dylan604 3y ago> they already have the SOPs and inspection protocols that reveal defects and proscribe ways to identify, document and address any defect it's great to have those protocols, but when employees are retaliated against for bringing issues with no corrective changes made, what's the point in having the protocols?
- CodeWriter23 3y agoAny of that happens at the supervisor or mid-level manager level and should be taken to HR. By complying with bullying, the employees are not only committing a federal crime, they also risk being debarred by the FAA. That means they no longer work in the Aviation Industry.
- marcosdumay 3y agoDid the CEO change last month or are you talking about the same one fully into covering everything up just until now?
- mayneack 3y agoFor what it's worth, in "Flying Blind", the book written about the first round of 737 max issues, the author has a pretty negative outlook on Calhoun as being mostly aligned with Muilenburg. > Robison, however, finds little reason for optimism. While Boeing has now accepted responsibility for one of the crashes as part of a settlement, no one at the company besides Forkner has been charged with a crime. Muilenburg was ousted as C.E.O., but still collected a $60 million golden parachute. After being grounded for more than a year, the 737 Max is back in service. And today, Boeing is led by Dave Calhoun, another Jack Welch protégé who was on the Boeing board for years, and was intimately involved in the company’s botched response to the crashes. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/01/books/review/peter-robison-flying-blind-boeing-737.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/01/books/review/peter-robiso... https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/646497/flying-blind-by-peter-robison/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/646497/flying-blind...
- eduction 3y agoYa, Calhoun has been there four years already, so he's had plenty of time. Also, he decided to continue outsourcing to Spirit despite Spirit's known issues. Everything in your post indicates he's not inclined to make fundamental alterations to the post Stonecipher strategy which fits with all this.
- OhMeadhbh 3y agoCalhoun's been at Boeing as a Director since 2009. Dude's definitely seen some things.
- datavirtue 3y agoSpirit is technically not Boeing. It's Boeing.
- nimish 3y ago> Jack Welch protégé At this point pre-emptively firing any Jack Welch associated executive would probably be a good idea
- missedthecue 3y agoMuilenburg was an engineer who worked his way up to CEO at Boeing. He totally mishandled the 737 Max crisis. Meanwhile, Airbus had an engineer CEO who nearly bankrupted the firm with the A380 project. I think trying to put management into buckets doesn't work very well. Some engineer CEOs have bad product sense and some sales CEOs have great product sense. I mean, Steve Jobs for crying out loud.
- foobarian 3y agoCouple other modern examples are AMD and Nvidia leaders.
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt's not just about safety, it's about the flying experience and environmental responsibility. If you think "flying sucks" it's probably because you've flown in a 737 and similar (A320) aircraft. Many people find it highly stressful to fly in a 737-class airplane because the curve of the fuselage is circular. My neck starts to lock up just thinking about it, but you don't have the same problem riding in a car, bus, or train because those vehicles have straight sides. Modern aircraft like the A220 and E2-Jet have a shape compatible with the human body such that today's "regional jets" feel more like riding in a widebody airliner than a 737. It's the kind of thing that's hard to believe until you experience it for yourself. The 737 is exceptionally loud, particularly for the flight crew, but also for the passengers and innocent people on the ground. If you think flying sucks it could be because you remember walking out of a 737 with your ears ringing -- and nobody told you it doesn't have to be that way. The A320 has a reliable fly-by-wire system with numerous benefits, not least the plane being able to automatically cancel out some turbulence, another small thing that leaves you feeling better when you reach your destination. The 737 struggles to take off under good conditions, requiring much more runway than many much larger planes. Next summer you'll see headlines that "airplanes" are grounded at some airports in the US Southwest, you should replace "airplanes" with "737s". Airplane manufacturers have wasted enough resources on widebody airliners that nobody wants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A380 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A380 and the industry needs to get real to the fact that narrowbody airliners are responsible for most of the flights and most of the social and environmental impact of aviation: domestic flyers in the U.S. deserve something better than a 1967 design.
- foobarian 3y agoLiterally none of those issues were a problem for me and I've flown a lot over the past 30 years. The #1 issue for me is leg room, being unusually tall. Headroom was never a problem :-)
- gruez 3y ago> domestic flyers in the U.S. deserve something better than a 1967 design. Or maybe the market has spoken. Similar to how people complain about lack of legroom but proceed to book with airlines that have less legroom because it's cheaper, they're happy to fly on 1967 design planes to save a buck.
- PedroBatista 3y agoUnfortunately no. He now adopted the "admit the problem and fix it" attitude because he was "caught", before that was business as usual for Boeing. It was/is more a "don't ask, don't tell", dump the risk on other separate entities/companies and cross your fingers because we need to get those planes out of the assembly line as fast and cheaply as possible no matter what. Boeing is and has been under pressure, but it's their own fault. They have been fucking around for DECADES now and when there were "difficulties" they always called the US government to "facilitate" sales or their buddies inside the regulatory bodies to put the green check on their garbage. Nothing about this is news, it has been known for years and years. Unfortunately Boeing always has a sweet defense contract waiting to compensate any "rough year", so they keep fucking around..
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Unfortunately Boeing always has a sweet defense contract waiting to compensate any "rough year", so they keep fucking around. And because once airlines have their fleets locked into a specific airplane brand, swapping it for the competition is almost impossible without crazy expense, so they coasted on this vendor lock in for decades knowing their existing customers have no choice but to keep buying their planes. And also probably because "nobody ever got fired for buying Boeing".
- kccqzy 3y agoThat doesn't sound likely. They can wait for existing planes to age out and then buy a competitor's planes. For many reasons including fuel efficiency, when an airline retires a plane they are not going to replace it with the exact same plane. So some levels of pilot retraining is expected.
- cschmatzler 3y agoThe A320neo family has a backlog of over 7000 orders. As much as Airbus is ramping up production in the past few years, with their current ~600 goal for 2024 that’s still a 12 year wait if you order one today.
- throw7 3y agoI don't get that impression at all. He only went on a PR fest the day after boeing stock tanked (which was after the weekend the door plug flew off). He was actively trying to get faa exceptions to other max's to get them in the air prior.
- guardiangod 3y agoI have the exact opposite impression. I don't know why the board hasn't fired him yet. He was brought in to change the company culture. It's been 4 years and this happen. 4 years is a long time, and this failure shows that he failed at what he was hired for (no, making money is not his main job.) Of course he is going to say whatever is needed to save his job, but in my eyes Boeing should move on and choose someone else. Time is running out.
- cm2187 3y agoWhat can those customers do? The airlines that have lots of 787 max have a vested interest in being able to use them. The whole max mcas debacle happened because of the high cost of pilot re-certification. So what are they going to do, re-certify all their boeing pilots to fly airbus? Airbus won't even have the capacity to take over all of boeing's market share. And the US can't let that happen anyway from a strategic point of view. It's not like customers picking a brand of detergent on a shelf.
- sandworm101 3y agoThey cannot drop the aircraft. They simply have to keep using them. The only option is lawyers. The airlines could demand compensation from Boeing for any time/effort put into rectifying unreasonable issues with recently-delivered Boeing aircraft.
- user3939382 3y agoThis is to the point where, although it's irrational but I know statistically I'd be fine, I'd be scared to fly on any new generation Boeing.
- electric_mayhem 3y agoRemember this simple rhyme for for your safety whenever you’re booking a commercial flight: “If it’s Boeing, I’m not going.”
- tboyd47 3y agoAirlines can switch your plane after you've booked already.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoInteresting opportunity for travel insurance: a policy that refunds your ticket if the plane turns out to be a 737 (even at the last minute). I realize it's not a viable business idea, but I'd feel such Schadenfreude if Boeing had to deal with the optics of that.
- dwallin 3y agoJetBlue doesn't fly any Boeing planes so as long as it isn't a codeshare flight you should be great.
- PaulHoule 3y agoBetter yet, fly Breeze Airways https://www.flybreeze.com/home https://www.flybreeze.com/home which is building an all new fleet out of modern A220 and E2-Jets. Breeze is cheap enough that I am thinking about riding to some random city and discovering a reason to go there because I want to ride in an A220.
- TylerE 3y agoI'm not sure it's irrational at this point. The entire program seems to have been grossly mismanaged, and that includes on the FAA side.
- rootusrootus 3y agoThis transparency is good, don't punish them for it. There's no guarantee whatsoever that other plane manufacturers don't run into similar problems and don't announce them.
- jsiepkes 3y ago> This transparency is good, don't punish them for it. There's no guarantee whatsoever that other plane manufacturers don't run into similar problems and don't announce them. Make no mistake, there is no real transparency here. There is no sudden "culture shift". Boeing is under a magnifying glass and no-one is going to stick their neck out and say: "Well, geez this is such a small mistake I'm going to ignore it". Because if planes start falling from the sky (again) you want your ass covered. There is currently just very little incentive for anyone (employees, managers, FAA, etc.) to led things slide.
- colechristensen 3y ago>"Well, geez this is such a small mistake I'm going to ignore it" There are "mistakes" you ignore when you're building an aircraft but you don't call them mistakes, because they aren't. You have tolerances for everything. To be "correct" a dimension is specified, must be no bigger than this, no smaller than that. And that's it. You're either in the spec or not. If you're not there's no ignoring, parts were delivered out of spec. There isn't some secondary "out of spec but only a little". Subcontractors (like Spirit), the prime contractor (Boeing), and everyone responsible for verifying (FAA, perhaps others) all share culpability for things going quite wrong. Hopefully the NTSB still has it's head on straight and the coming scathing reports will attract attention in Congress to light a fire under the FAA's ass to do its job, preferably with some direct legislation for things the FAA must do. (i.e. no more manufacturers doing self-verifications)
- drstewart 3y ago>no real transparency >There is currently just very little incentive for anyone (employees, managers, FAA, etc.) to led things slide. What is "real" transparency?
- golemotron 3y agoIs there a travel site that allows you to filter out 737Maxes?
- Etheryte 3y agoThis question comes up every time articles like these come up and the answer is no, there is no reliable way unless you check what airplane you're boarding right as you walk on it. Airlines regularly swap out planes to cover up for delayed flights, weather, mismatched demand etc and the plane model you're shown as you're buying the ticket is not necessarily the plane you're gonna fly.
- repiret 3y agoI’m not convinced that actually happens very often. I can’t remember a case where it has happened to me, and consider that changing to a type with a different number of seats would require issue in new tickets. And you need to balance demand not on a single route, but on the entire circuit the plane needs to fly.
- kayfox 3y agoThis happens a lot when your flying with Alaska or Southwest. Both airlines have significant MAX fleets and will change the dispatch schedule for aircraft fairly often, in my experience on Alaska it happens about 10~20% of the time. Also, Southwest does not assign seats and Alaska does not have a difference in seats between their -900 and MAX 9 aircraft. Although with Alaska I have had my seat reassigned because they changed from a -900/MAX 9 to a -800 before.
- kiwijamo 3y agoHappens quite often in airlines that operate a range of types. E.g. Airlines that operate both the 320 and 321, 777-200 and 777-300, etc often swap aircraft between pair of similar types but slightly different number of seats to match demand but still draw from the same pilots/crew due to common type ratings. But I've also had 320 to 777 swaps, 757 to 321, etc do it does happen especially on routes where they operate a range of different aircrafts. Yes some tickets may need to be reissued but that's better than cancelling the fight where all the tickets have to be rebooked onto other flights. Some changes are due to low demand so in those cases no ticket reissue are needed. It also depends on the airline, you'll see swaps more often on airlines that operate many different kinds of aircraft and also depends on the route as some routes can only be served by a particular aircraft (e.g. ultra long haul routes, airports with short runways, etc) while other can be served by a wider variety of aircrafts lending itself to operational flexibility. YMMV.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoDoor blow out Engine on Fire 'Many loose bolts'. etc.. Now This. Have a flight in couple weeks? Time to worry?
- Rantenki 3y agoIf you're on a 737-max-anything, then worry a _tiny_ bit, otherwise, no. All their other planes have excellent safety records. For comparison, Russia had a 2.29 fatal accidents/million departures safety rating in 2021, which is terrible, worst of all operating regions. 737-maxes had a 3.08 in 2019 when they got grounded. Every other plane in North America is averaging about 0.20 right now. Granted, the 737-max's stat is based on a fairly low number of crashes. Regardless, the odds of a fatal crash are still vanishingly low on any given trip.
- SirMaster 3y agoNo, because the problems aren't worse than they were a few months ago before anyone was re-inspecting things for this. And you wouldn't have worried about this months ago, so there is no reason your worry should be greater now. If anything your worry now should be less since they are actually double checking these things now.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agowell technically. We didn't find out about these things because of increased inspections. We found out because it was in the news when there was videos of a door blown off, then a few days later an engine fire. THEN, they started more inspections. So, it seems more like a trend, where there were more and more problems until they piled up far enough to breach the surface. So how many haven't been found, the ice-burg below the surface.
- SirMaster 3y agoMy only point was that hearing about the issues found by more inspections shouldn't change your mind about the safety because performing more inspections and reporting on the findings doesn't reduce the safety of what it already was (what you were presumably already OK with before simply hearing about the new inspections and issues found).
- everybodyknows 3y ago> As of Friday, the "non-conformance" or quality defect had been found in 22 fuselages out of 47 inspected up to that point, spread between Boeing and Spirit, and may exist in some 737s in service, the sources said. https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/exclusive-boeing-delays-737-max-002835681.html https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/exclusive-boeing-delays-73...
- armchairdweller 3y agoI've read in a different place that the many problems could be a result of uncareful and miscoordinated outsourcing, particularly in the software domain. Is there any good information / insight on this?
- a321neo 3y ago[flagged]
- wongarsu 3y agoBoth this issue and issue with the door bolts were caused by Spirit, who Boeing outsourced the production of fuselages to. There's lots of info on the quality troubles with them going back years. For example here is an article from May of last year [1] about a quality issue with Spirit that had been going on for 4 years. Here [2] is one from last October which says "The goal of the agreement is to stabilize Spirit’s production system, by stemming the flow of quality defects that have afflicted the 737 MAX and the 787 Dreamliner jet programs this year and positioning Spirit to ramp up to Boeing’s planned rate increases." The agreement was Spirit running out of cash and Boeing swooping in to save them despite their poor quality, because they were the only supplier for these fuselages. The financial times wrote a good article about it [3]. This is absolutely a story of outsourcing gone wrong. But they didn't outsource it to China or Mexico, they outsourced it to Kansas, USA. 1: https://theaircurrent.com/industry-strategy/boeing-spirit-reintegration-ramp-up-special-report/ https://theaircurrent.com/industry-strategy/boeing-spirit-re... 2: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boeing-pumps-cash-into-spirit-aerosystems-to-shore-up-troubled-supplier/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein... 3: https://archive.is/prHOK https://archive.is/prHOK
- armchairdweller 3y agoThank you, this is exactly the information I was looking for.
- idoubtit 3y ago> Both this issue and issue with the door bolts were caused by Spirit From what I've read, this is not what happened for the door bolts. The New York Times report was that Spirit required access to some part of the fuselage masked by the door but did not work on the door. The Spirit request was granted, so Boeing workers removed the door, Spirit workers did what they intended to, then Boeing workers put the door back. There is a entry in the maintenance log of the plane about this. There should have been a routine check after this operation, but there was no mention of it in the maintenance log.
- a321neo 3y ago[flagged]
- flaminHotSpeedo 3y agoThat's not at all true. Spirit manufactures what is essentially a shell, the majority of the assembly (and all the work done by Boeing itself) happens in Seattle.
- coredog64 3y agoThis is a masterful troll. University of Kansas is extremely well known in aviation. Boeing Wichita has been around forever and now that it’s Spirit, it’s an Airbus supplier.
- selimthegrim 3y agoThere's also lot of private aviation manufacturing there.
- hef19898 3y agoYou should read up on where Airbus sites are, and especially why.
- flaminHotSpeedo 3y agoThis title is extremely misleading, to the point of being factually incorrect. Boeing didn't find the fault, Spirit did and notified Boeing, and the problem only affects undelivered fuselages.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- margalabargala 3y ago> the problem only affects undelivered fuselages The problem has only been observed on undelivered fuselages, because those are the ones that Spirit has on-hand to check. They are not confident the problem is absent in delivered aircraft. You could also say, "the problem affects all of the delivered aircraft that have been checked for the problem". From another article: > As of Friday, the "non-conformance" or quality defect had been found in 22 fuselages out of 47 inspected up to that point, spread between Boeing and Spirit, and may exist in some 737s in service, the sources said. https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/exclusive-boeing-delays-737-max-002835681.html https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/exclusive-boeing-delays-73...
- moffkalast 3y agoAh yes the tried and true scientific approach of "if we don't check it we won't find any problems puts hands over ears lalalalalala"
- Arrath 3y ago"We found no issues.......... (very quietly) becausewedidn'tlook"
- flaminHotSpeedo 3y agoAh thanks, I hadn't heard that, as of last I saw I was under the impression that there was only one secondary source that had actually seen/talked with any primary sources: https://theaircurrent.com/feed/dispatches/boeing-halts-deliveries-from-spirit-to-catch-up-on-unfinished-manufacturing-work/ https://theaircurrent.com/feed/dispatches/boeing-halts-deliv...
- ramesh31 3y agoBreak. Them. Up. This is a concern of national security at the highest level. Boeing needs the Standard Oil treatment, which was a net positive for everyone involved.
- flaminHotSpeedo 3y agoThat's actually exactly the wrong thing to do. The problem, at least in this case, is that Boeing chose to break off what is now known as Spirit Aerosystems into a separate entity, and now Spirit has Boeing by the balls because Boeing can't replace them and has to deal with the consequences of their shitty manufacturing and QC.
- klyrs 3y agoNah, we just need to break them up along the vertical: decapitate the company, and let the engineers run it again.
- ramesh31 3y ago>The problem, at least in this case, is that Boeing chose to break off what is now known as Spirit Aerosystems into a separate entity Spirit is nothing more than a basket of limited liability set up by Boeing for precisely such an ocurrence. Pretending that it's anything else is just buying into their BS corporate spin.
- ensignavenger 3y agoYour comment seems to imply that Spirit is owned or primarily owned by Boeing? But I can't find any support for that. See https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/SPR/holders https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/SPR/holders Am I misunderstanding your point?
- beart 3y agoBoeing originally owned the facility and sold it. Spirit was founded explicitly to buy and run the facility.
- ykonstant 3y agoFun fact, an assortment of misdrilled holes is called a 'clusterfuck'.
- hef19898 3y agoDepends in the misdrills. Can be as easy as redrilling with a larger diameter to fix. Not every Boeing issue is a clusterfuck.
- epcoa 3y agoAdmittedly not that hilarious, but whoosh.
- hef19898 3y agoThis whole comment thread kind of flew over my head.
- ykonstant 3y agoUnlike the 737 MAX.
- mynameisnoone 3y agoThe 737 MAX was grounded, so it only flew under the radar.
- mindslight 3y agoThey're also generally called "speed holes", except on airplanes and boats for some reason.
- givinguflac 3y agoWe need federal oversight for Boeing not just self reporting. Good on Spirit but Boeing should have caught this.
- bbatchelder 3y agoBut how can we blame this on DEI? -Elon, probably
- cyberax 3y agoWell, outsourcing fuselage assembly to Spirit worked so well! Now you don't have any direct control over the processes, but at the same time you can't switch from Spirit to someone else because there is no other company that can do the manufacturing.
- roody15 3y agoI cannot help but get the feeling that Boeing woes are like a canary in a coal mine for larger structural issues in the US government as a whole. Too much effort is put into spin, public relations and propaganda instead of actual just getting things done.
- hef19898 3y agoBoeing is about as representative of the US government, or country, as German soccer is for our government.
- roody15 3y agoHmm, is it? Boeing is in the category of too big to fail. I agree its not government per say.. but it is really not a private business either.
- refulgentis 3y agoYes, the US government is not Boeing. Yes, Boeing is a private business. You are describing your general distaste for two entities and attempting to rationalize it. My only guess that steelmans that is you think Boeing would cease to exist without its defense business.
- hedora 3y agoAs of 2020, 21% of the DoD's budget went to Boeing, and was 31% of Boeing's revenue: https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2020/01/02/how-much-of-boeings-revenues-comes-from-the-us-government/?sh=60f130315144 https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2020/01/02/ho... It's unlikely either organization would exist as it currently does without the other.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ajcp 3y ago
- abtinf 3y agoI happen to have quite a bit of first-hand knowledge about aerospace rivets. AMA.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoIs this as much of a non issue as I think it is? I'm thinking non structural bits of aluminum fuselage having a few extra holes is embarrassing but probably easily fixed/painted over and not that critical. Not generally a reason to get all upset and replace the part. But kind of embarrassing to have on a new part (i.e. get a discount). I've been watching a lot of rebuild rescue on Youtube lately where a bunch of mechanics are trying to rebuild a decades old plane nicknamed the bird house (because birds were nesting in it for well over a decade and they got absolutely everywhere). That seems to involve a lot of rivets, usage of all sorts of power tools, cleaning up old lots of parts, and generally not being too delicate banging things back into shape. Massive project and makes you realize just how complicated even a relatively small plane is.
- abtinf 3y agoIt depends on how pervasive the issue is. Is it just two slightly nonconforming holes, or is it random sampling that suggests many nonconformances? It is not really feasible to test an installed rivet without destructive testing, because usually we are talking about blind rivets, which are remarkably complex fasteners. Think of them more like "small, ultra-precise one-time use machines", not "nails". This is part of the reason aircraft have so many rivets: each rivet is often capable of supporting a substantial fraction of the load where it is installed (sometimes even the entire load), but we install a huge number of them. The fact that this defect was caught during what seems like normal inspection processes also moves it closed to being a "non-issue". Manufacturing defects happen all the time and liability is massive, so there are extensive inspection and quality regimes in place.
- rossdavidh 3y agoYour best guess: if we checked closely for this sort of thing on Airbus planes, would it be found? I'm guessing not, but then I'm wondering if I'm naive.
- josemanuel 3y ago“Trust me bruh! This is the last of the screw ups!! Oh and, the plane is totally safe! Legit!”
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39256114 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39256114
- philip1209 3y agoI haven't fully thought through this, but - Why can't regulators try splitting Boeing up, anti-trust style? Part of the issue is that there's no competition. (Yes, Airbus, but tariffs seem to factor into purchasing decisions a lot.) If you create more competition, everybody should benefit.
- hackly 3y ago> If you create more competition, everybody should benefit. Except shareholders
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoSorry, shareholders. gg no re
- euroderf 3y agoBoo hoo. Own it.
- rmk 3y agoIs the "Stonecipher plan" to make such bad airplanes that they are forced to get out of Commercial Aviation? Is that even possible with the huge number of Boeing airliners in service? I'm assuming that Boeing is still on the hook, legally, for parts, service, and complying with Airworthiness Directives (ADs: https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/airworthiness_directives https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/airworthiness_direc...).
- booleandilemma 3y ago"There’s never just one cockroach in the kitchen."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- krunck 3y agoDoes Boeing's miltiary contract work also suffer from "deny the problem and ship it"?
- colechristensen 3y agoPart of the reason military equipment is so very expensive is the labyrinth of requirements and verifications. Military contract work suffering from the same problems would require a lot of straight up fraud and document forging which is different that what seems to be happening to the commercial unit which is more laziness and corner cutting. Like there is a MIL-SPEC for pop-tarts that specifies how much filling there is and frosting coverage (finding stupid MIL-SPECs was great fun as a group of interns at Lockheed Martin, also reply-all email chains of memes which started causing outlook server problems before we were gently encouraged to stop) The FAA shares a lot of blame for these problems by being negligent in their verification duties and delegating them to the companies they are verifying.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vegabook 3y agomove fast and break things
- asdff 3y agoBoeing is like Teflon. The planes are literally falling apart and the stock hasn't even sniffed October's lows.
- EasyMark 3y agoI would be very surprised if Boeing doesn't covertly have people looking for issues with Airbus planes and we'll soon be hearing about some of those in the coming months.
- stephen_g 3y agoNot a smart strategy... Unless your competitor is doing something really very terrible and dodgy, usually being found out doing that kind of thing does much worse things to your own PR than anything you find does for theirs...
- bluSCALE4 3y agoWhat blows my mind is that no one brings up that the 737 Max was an at the hip response to Airbus A320neo. I remember Boeing didn't even have a response when Airbus has already secured some contracts and had actual demo flights. Then Boeing goes "me too" and cheats Airbus out of contracts due to the "no training" needed scam. I recall thinking to myself, this is bullshit. The Airbus planes were beautiful and the Max reeked of hacks and rush jobs. This should have brought more government scrutiny as anyone could have guessed they would do anything to get these to market asap. It's truly a shame and a black eye for American ingenuity.