16 ms·
Copyright is not a moral right, it's a monetization strategy
- stupidadd 3y ago[dead]
- andsoitis 3y ago> Copyright is not a moral right, it's a monetization strategy that enables some information related business models at the expense of others. The reality is actually more interesting than this post. The US Copyright Act of 1790 was meant to provide an incentive to authors, artists, and scientists to create original works by providing creators with a monopoly. The monopoly was limited in order to stimulate creativity and the advancement of “science and the useful arts” through wide public access to works in the “public domain.” Major revisions happened in 1831, 1870, 1909, and 1976. Source: https://www.arl.org/copyright-timeline/ https://www.arl.org/copyright-timeline/ As to moral right, from Wikipedia: "Modern copyright law has been influenced by an array of older legal rights that have been recognized throughout history, including the moral rights of the author who created a work, the economic rights of a benefactor who paid to have a copy made, the property rights of the individual owner of a copy, and a sovereign's right to censor and to regulate the printing industry. The origins of some of these rights can be traced back to ancient Greek culture, ancient Jewish law, and ancient Roman law.[2] In Greek society, during the sixth century B.C.E., there emerged the notion of the individual self, including personal ideals, ambition, and creativity.[3] The individual self is important in copyright because it distinguishes the creativity produced by an individual from the rest of society.[citation needed] In ancient Jewish Talmudic law there can be found recognition of the moral rights of the author and the economic or property rights of an author.[4]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright#Early_developments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright#Early_dev...
- pbhjpbhj 3y ago>Major revisions happened in 1831, 1870, 1909, and 1976. The 1980s ('88?) accession to the Berne Convention presumably was also a 'major revision' as the convention, then over 100 year old, removes the registration requirement. Copyright is, somewhat ironically, essential for FOSS licenses that place conditions on a distributor. Governments could no doubt use some other instrument for this purpose.
- GalahiSimtam 3y agoIn copyright law, moral rights are the right to attribution, integrity, that sort of stuff. It's a loan translation from French 'droit moral' Unsure if the original baiter meant this
- hef19898 3y agoAs a hobby content creator, I absolutely disagree. My content is mine, if someone else wants to use it for whatever purposes, that party has to ask for, and get permission, to do so. Which I might or might not give. I absolutely do not want any AI model to use my stuff as training data, to be used on a website or for advertizing. You want to make money off my stuff, you pay.
- keiferski 3y agoYes, I find the anti-copyright position to be quite anti-creator and pro corporation that can afford to outspend competitors on marketing. In a world with limited copyright laws, I see no reason why Disney/OpenAI/Google/etc. wouldn't just end up functionally owning anything that a less well-funded person creates.
- lifthrasiir 3y agoThe problem is that there are also corporations behind copyright as well. In fact, a more constructive way to see this might be that there are two groups of corporations---say, traditional media conglomerates for copyright vs. tech megacorporations against copyright---and creators and consumers are rather stranded between them.
- Adverblessly 3y agoWith no copyright law, how would they own anything? If anything, I'd expect the funding will go to those who can sustain themselves on things like Patreon and Kickstarter, where money is provided before the work is created, making the copyright protection irrelevant. And while the big corporations will get to own those Patreons and Kickstarters, hopefully there will be enough competition to keep their greed in check. (Also, maybe more people will learn to tip for content even when they receive it for free)
- keiferski 3y agoThat's why I wrote "functionally own." They'd own the distribution, eyeballs, and sales of merchandise. Without copyright laws, large media corporations have the budget and institutional know-how to simply copy and out-market any new creations that are made by less well-funded people. Good luck making a new kids cartoon if Disney is going to copy it and put billions of marketing dollars promoting it. It would be a death sentence to any smaller creator and services like Patreon would probably not even exist.
- lifthrasiir 3y agoI had to check whether this is a tongue-in-cheek joke or a genuine statement with arguments elsewhere. His argument is, in my understanding and reinterpretation, that copyright benefited publishers much more than authors for quite a while, so attempts to keep or strengthen copyright should have been for publishers' interest [1]. Not really surprising once arguments are provided but quite a stretch without them. [1] https://twitter.com/Plinz/status/1740605059367367068 https://twitter.com/Plinz/status/1740605059367367068 and https://twitter.com/Plinz/status/1740606348935491648 https://twitter.com/Plinz/status/1740606348935491648
- gdsdgttjd 3y agoI mean yeah OK sure. But it’s also a law.
- wccrawford 3y agoIMO, it's pretty obviously all 3. Not letting people using the fruits of your labor (without permission), especially mental labor, seems like it's really akin to the right to privacy. That said, once you share something publicly, I think you automatically give up a lot of that right, and the law only protects against people making money on it directly. IMO, the question is: Is training an AI a direct use of that work, or indirect? And how does the law come down on that question?
- CaptainFever 3y agoLaws can be immoral.
- lhoff 3y agohttps://nitter.net/Plinz/status/1740606348935491648#m https://nitter.net/Plinz/status/1740606348935491648#m
- lou1306 3y agoOf course the AI posse weeps about copyright.
- juped 3y agoThe problem is the clash between the American concept of copyright (copyright is economic; it's a method of paying authors for their contributions to the public domain) and the European (copyright is the enforcement of an author's moral rights in their work). The latter is embodied in the Berne convention, which the United States unfortunately acceded to, leaving the concepts of American copyright and a strong public domain essentially dead. Regulatory capture by entities which extract rents past all possible sense has also helped kill it.
- Alpha3031 3y agoI think there are certain benefits various continental models have over the British one. Assignment of copyright to the author, with a degree of non-transferability, advantages individuals rather than monopolistic corporation. Of course, a dualist system where the financial rights are explicitly separate and less enduring would perhaps be better still.
- juped 3y agoThe financial rights are the good part. People should be paid for their work; this is how to get the incentives aligned and promote the progress of science and the arts. Making them into incredibly long-lived rent fiefdoms is bad, and the terms should be much shorter. However, the "moral rights" part should simply not exist at all; the only restraint a copyright holder should have is the ability to demand payment. In money. Possibly at a statutory rate, like with existing compulsory licensing in songwriting.
- Chris_Newton 3y agoBut there are other forms of compensation that some creators are evidently willing to accept in exchange for their own contribution: see FOSS, Creative Commons, etc. If you restrict the compensation to purely financial forms then copyright is no longer an effective incentive for arguably the second most successful model for creative work that we’ve found so far. Why give that up?
- cromulent 3y agoI really think Bill Watterson would disagree. "Only thieves and vandals have made money on Calvin and Hobbes merchandise."
- andy99 3y agoI agree, I think a majority does because of attitudes and behaviors towards sharing copyrighted works generally. There has always been a loud and "righteous" opposition though. I do find the vibe in online discussions different this time around compared to the file sharing discussions 20 years ago, ie more pro-establishment but I think that's a broader trend. Edit to add: copyright as a moral right has no current bearing on AI training, the current question (ie in lawsuits) is whether or under what circumstances such training violates copyright, not about the morality.
- CaptainFever 3y ago> I do find the vibe in online discussions different this time around compared to the file sharing discussions 20 years ago, ie more pro-establishment but I think that's a broader trend. I feel this is due to HN becoming more mainstream, which is generally pro-establishment. Some smaller servers in the Fediverse still have the old anti-establishment, anti-copyright, wild west vibe of the old Internet.
- shagie 3y agoMany in the Fediverse are aghast at the idea of some large corporation reading their data, processing, and using it; and seek to protect Meta (and others) from consuming it. Yet, without copyright on the content they publish they have no legal standing to say "no, you don't have the right/license to be able to do what you want with my content."
- smeej 3y agoThe problem with copyright is that it tries to apply property laws, which mattered because property is scarce, to things that are not scarce. If you have an idea first and I copy the idea into my own mind, you still have your brain cell connections. You still have your idea. Now I do too, and you have no right to tell me how I can connect my brain cells just because you connected your own similarly before me. Same thing with computer data. You don't get to tell me I can't arrange bits on a hard drive I own in the same order as the bits on a computer you own just because you arranged them first. That's nonsensical.
- andsoitis 3y agoThe problem with copyright is that it tries to apply property laws, which mattered because property is scarce, to things that are not scarce. If you have an idea first and I copy the idea into my own mind, you still have your brain cell connections. You still have your idea. Now I do too, and you have no right to tell me how I can connect my brain cells just because you connected your own similarly before me. Copyright does not protect ideas, only their expression or fixation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright
- superkuh 3y agoHistorically, yes, pragmatically and in terms of current legal actions, copyright in the USA is almost all about protecting ideas regardless of the medium of their expression.
- andsoitis 3y ago> copyright in the USA is almost all about protecting ideas Can you give an example where copyright is protecting an idea? I’d be curious to learn more.
- smeej 3y agoIf I forget that you were the source of an idea and fail to cite you for it if I make any form of expression about it (paper, podcast, blog post) and fail to cite you, people pitch a fit, even if the idea wasn't all that big a breakthrough, or even if I actually didn't learn it from you, and just came up with it on my own from immersion in a similar milieu. No, I'm not technically restricted from having the same thought, but if I tell anyone about the thought, then it's apparently plagiarism.
- LocalH 3y agoCopyright was a way to give rightsholders incentive to do what they do, while still ensuring that the work enters the public domain, which is and always has been the absolute endgame of copyright. Today's copyright is much different, due to massive lobbying efforts by those who would benefit most. Authors life + what, 100 years or so, is way too long (and that's completely discounting those who would want copyright to be perpetual). So you have a situation where a person creates a work, a large rights owner buys it up, and then they get to milk all the benefits while preventing the public from having their rightful free access. Restore copyright to 14+14 years (with a single exception, the original artist and only the original artist gets 28+14, if they sell their rights to the work then the recipient only gets 14+14). Destroy the DMCA. Those are the two most important things to restore copyright to a proper moral standing. Otherwise, copyright as it stands right now is immoral and unjust, and thus (some of) those who pirate are doing so for fully ethical reasons, and are on the better side of history in the long run. Of course, some people just want free shit. However, those people will always exist no matter how reasonable copyright is. Hell, I don't mind getting free shit when I pirate something, even if I'm doing it for moral reasons.
- dexen 3y agoI subscribe to your and broadly follow your arguments. It's also worth pointing out the speed of information propagation, speed of manufacturing, and speed of distribution & logistics has dramatically increased since 14+14 years was the pragmatic standard. At present, the same economic effect is achieved in much shorter cycles. Keeping economic and moral parity would entail shortening the protection times a fair bit.
- loupol 3y agoAgreed on all points, the tweet feels like an allergic reaction to what copyright has morphed into, which is a tool for big corporations to extract money from existing IP for an insanely long duration. But it's important to remember that no copyright at all would hurt small and medium creators immensely. Big corps could just pick things that are trending up, rip them off instantly and scale their ripoff much better thanks to their great workforce and marketing reach. That would create a big disincentive for independent creation of IP. Like you, I would just prefer if copyright was kept in place but its duration decreased drastically compared to now. It doesn't seem likely given the lobbying strength of the corporations that benefit from the current situation sadly.
- spit2wind 3y agoThe RMS essay on the "Copyright Trade-off" expands on what I think this post hints at. https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/misinterpreting-copyright.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/misinterpreting-copyright.en.... > When the US Constitution was drafted, the idea that authors were entitled to a copyright monopoly was proposed—and rejected. The founders of our country adopted a different premise, that copyright is not a natural right of authors, but an artificial concession made to them for the sake of progress. Specifically, > The copyright system works by providing privileges and thus benefits to publishers and authors; but it does not do this for their sake. Rather, it does this to modify their behavior: to provide an incentive for authors to write more and publish more. In effect, the government spends the public's natural rights, on the public's behalf, as part of a deal to bring the public more published works. Legal scholars call this concept the “copyright bargain.” It is like a government purchase of a highway or an airplane using taxpayers' money, except that the government spends our freedom instead of our money. But what "natural rights"? > the freedom to lend a book to your friend, to sell it to a used book store, to borrow it from a library, to buy it without giving your name to a corporate data bank, even the freedom to read it twice. ...as well as > fair use I find his perspective compelling. Yet, he only cites the Constitution and one court case. Copyright has a long and complex history. I wonder what the essay "leaves out" and what other "categories of interpretation" exist.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoA bunch of "categories of interpretation" are dead, because they lost court cases. And, the original intent is pretty clear, because the people back then left a record of why they made the law the way they did.
- psychoslave 3y agoCopyright is a common law perspective. In France for example, and I guess most of the Civil law area, authors do have morale rights, which are explicitly named thus, which are imprescriptible and inalienable. But that is in extra to patrimonial rights which cover most of what you get from a common law copyright.
- 3y ago
- amadeuspagel 3y agoIf the only thing it takes for something to get to the HN frontpage is a title that people agree with, why is an article behind it necessary - a tweet is enough.
- tiahura 3y agoThis is the daily two minutes of hate directed at those who prevent them from being able to download whatever they want for free.
- emsign 3y agoSomeone's upset at the NYT
- october8140 3y agoSo many people who have never had an original creative idea in their life advocating for weaker copyright laws.
- CaptainFever 3y agoAll humans are creative.
- Levitz 3y agoNo human has ever had an "original creative idea". That's the point. No art exists in a vacuum.
- TheAceOfHearts 3y agoMy perspective on copyright is that it lasts too long, which I suspect can end up harming innovation. The way I roughly think about it is that if you grow up consuming some form of media, by the time you're an adult (maybe 20 years later) it should enter the public domain allowing you to remix it or do whatever you want with it. The media which you grow up consuming forms near-permanent structures in your brain. If by the time you're an adult the creator of your favorite childhood media decides to become a bigot you should be allowed to reclaim it and take it in whatever direction you want. I also don't think it makes sense that we allow a small number of companies to buy the rights to most of our music, this grants them too much control over an important part of human culture. Finally, the software world is forced by copyright to constantly waste engineering effort in rebuilding perfectly good tools that are no longer on sale. Imagine a world where source code were released as soon as some codebase is no longer under copyright! Isn't that essential for allowing us to build upon the work of those who have come before us? Otherwise we're forced to keep rebuilding the wheel, despite the fact that a group of top-tier engineers already built a near-perfect wheel 30 years ago. Honestly, I think the devil is in the details. I'm not particularly dogmatic about any specific duration, and could probably be convinced that the rules should vary slightly based on different factors such as corporate vs individual ownership. There's probably a lot of edge cases that I haven't fully considered carefully, and I'm really open to exploring the topic. Copyright is a topic which I contemplate often, and I'm thankful that the emergence of new AI tooling is forcing us to take a closer look. I think in general we should look to empower individuals, because they're the ones who will ultimately grow the game.
- nicklecompte 3y agoAnd specifically "a strategy that enables some information related business models at the expense of others." Of course if you phrase it in general abstractions, copyright sounds like arbitrary regulatory capture. But if you say "Copyright is a monetization strategy that enables business models which produce novel ideas at the expense of business models which repackage existing ideas" then as a matter of public policy this makes a lot of sense! Novel ideas are far more rare than repackaged existing ideas, and generally much more valuable. Governments should build a regulatory structure that incentivizes the former over the latter. People rely on pointless abstractions like "monetization strategy" when the actual facts of the case are unflattering to their ideological/financial priors. "GPT-4 blatantly plagiarizes from the New York Times" is extremely unflattering to AI evangelists and entrepreneurs, so it's easier to go with "OpenAI has a different information business model than the New York Times."
- Chris_Newton 3y agoCopyright seems to be a less than ideal solution to a real problem. Most of us would probably agree that if someone provides something of value to someone else then the beneficiary providing something of value in return is “fair” on some basic level. If there’s a physical item involved then it’s obvious how “providing” it works. We can exchange a certain amount of money for a certain item and everyone understands the trade. If there’s some kind of personal service involved then again it’s obvious what “providing” it means. Again, we can exchange a certain amount of money for a certain service rendered and everyone understands the trade. There are at least two other things that we value greatly as a society but which can’t be supported in the same direct ways. One is public services, which is essentially work that is done for the common good that would probably not be arranged by any given individual beneficiary. For this we have established governments and we typically fund them through taxation. Naturally this is controversial because it represents (usually) the only lawful way in which someone else can come along and take your money from you, ultimately backed by a threat of force if you don’t hand it over, and there will never be universal agreement about what should or should not be provided and funded in this way. Another tricky thing to support is creative work. There is no reasonable doubt that this provides enormous value to our society, nor that many people contribute to creative endeavours and if we want them to continue providing their contributions then most of them must be compensated sufficiently by those who benefit from them to make their ongoing work possible. But unlike everything else mentioned above, most of the work that goes into the creative process naturally happens before the end result is ready — before there is anything of substantial value that will benefit others who might provide something of value in return. So how to incentivise this kind of creative work? The way I see it, that is the problem that copyright tries to solve, or at least tried to solve originally. It’s an attempt to apply the more familiar economics of selling physical products to creative work, to provide a system where it’s worth creators investing their time and resources into making something that others might want, in the knowledge that if they succeed then they will receive compensation accordingly. Like any uncertain investment, it can still result in better or worse returns, in this case depending on how much benefit they do create and for how many people, but that is essentially the kind of market that copyright creates and how it functions as an incentive for creative workers. Looking at the evidence so far, it appears that the basic principle of copyright has been highly effective in motivating creative work compared to other funding models or volunteer efforts. It also appears that the original link between the creators doing the work and the beneficiaries of that work who pay to support it has been subverted by numerous intermediaries and changes in the legal/regulatory framework. This often results in the creative workers usually receiving only a small fraction of the money paid by the recipients of the work, and the recipients paying a lot more for the benefit of the work than the creators who made it will ever receive. IMHO, this is the fundamental problem with modern copyright and where any attempts to “fix the system” should first be targeted.
- meheleventyone 3y agoEpitome of "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it."
- jackdaniel 3y agoCopyright was a moral right until 3 or 4 years ago, now AI training is the moral right. /s Sarcasm aside, this take is very disappointing. People leverage copyright for many purposes - copyleft, recognition, exclusiveness and many more.
- CaptainFever 3y agoCopyright is an immoral restriction on the general public. Recognition can be achieved via... moral rights, copyleft can be achieved via copyright abolition, and exclusiveness is not something to strive for in a world of abundance.
- jackdaniel 3y agoCopyright was not an immoral restriction on the general public until Meh Valley noticed more bucks in LLMs. I agree that copyright is very much broken for various reasons, and the Public Domain day is a day of celebration for me. Having that in mind it is an irony that such broken law is the only thing that stands in a way of automatic and unattributed exploitation of people effort at scale. And it stands only on one leg at that :)
- notahacker 3y agoCopyleft isn't achieved by copyright abolition though. Abolish copyright and the AGPL is literally impossible rather than merely impractical to enforce, but OpenAI/Microsoft still get to decide who gets access to their model.
- mobiuscog 3y agoCopyright should be about crediting the creator. Whether that be financially or just as a source to be cited. What is should not be, is a way to remove the sharing of knowledge, which is detrimental to society as a whole. Fictional works, editorials, opinion pieces - these may be based upon facts but do not explicity provide knowledge that needs to be shared. Science should always be open, for the sake of humanity. Those who make the discoveries may gain status and reputation, but those discoveries should not be kept for personal/commercial gain. Art and music, much like celebrity status, are more difficult to judge. Wanting to make everyone aware of who you are or what you have created, whilst simultaneously demanding that they pay for the privilege, seems at odds. You can create for commission, the payment being from the person that made the request, but then they should be free to keep it private or make it public. We are obsessed in modern times, that we must be paid for everything we do - largely because governments and businesses have made this so. We barter our skills for things we cannot ourselves produce, but knowledge should never be kept private for an inclusive society - that is the way towards elitism and power, which is clearly where copyright has travelled. Should you be given food for free ? No. Should the knowledge of how to grow food be free ? Yes. Barter the tangible, not the intangible. The 'knowledge' economony is a parasite on humanity.
- spencerflem 3y agoNot that I disagree exactly, but how do you see the people making the knowledge being rewarded for their work?
- mobiuscog 3y ago> Not that I disagree exactly, but how do you see the people making the knowledge being rewarded for their work? I don't have the answer. I do know that all of society would need to change. The simple approach would be that they are provided food and shelter, but this brings in the modern societal desire for 'more' than just needs. How many people just work to afford to live, and why is that often so expensive... typically because others somewhere, indirectly, are making more than they need to live. Landlords, businesses, etc. Profit and 'growth' all break the basic concept of bartering to live; they take more than they give, in the name of status and power. I don't think we can go back to a simpler approach, but at the same time I don't belive copyright is fit for purpose even in the simplest forms any more. What people are willing to pay for seems to have become confused in the modern day compared to what they 'need' to live.
- rich_sasha 3y agoThe whole of western civilisation is built on the idea of investment. We found that incentivising people do out extra effort and reap the fruit of success is great, for themselves and for the society in the long run. It's not just plain capitalism. Art, journalism, sport, all reward people who invest time, money and effort, knowing that they can personally benefit if they succeed. That gives us centuries of beautiful art, quality newspapers and worthwhile spectator sports. I don't understand the hostility to the idea that, say, a writer can control their work, other than maybe people would rather not pay and feel good about it. How would you feel if someone decrees you charging a monthly subscription for your SaaS is evil and they're going to outlaw it. Or, dunno, declare that after 7 years of using it they get it perpetually for free...
- CaptainFever 3y ago> How would you feel if someone decrees you charging a monthly subscription for your SaaS is evil and they're going to outlaw it. Or, dunno, declare that after 7 years of using it they get it perpetually for free... This isn't a relevant example because server space on SaaSes are scarce, so it makes sense to use capitalism to deal with this. Data, on the other hand, is not scarce, so it requires a more communal way to deal with it. For example, > I don't understand the hostility to the idea that, say, a writer can control their work, other than maybe people would rather not pay and feel good about it. The hostility comes from the fact that the writer is trying to control and restrict what other people do with their work. It is very anti-social. The only excuse for this is financial (as you say, investments), but even that can be debated as there are alternative ways to fund such works. Essentially, copyright is like a world full of private toll roads. It's a way to encourage companies to invest in private roads and raise funds. But it also degrades the road, and we're better off having public roads instead.
- rich_sasha 3y ago> This isn't a relevant example because server space on SaaSes are scarce, so it makes sense to use capitalism to deal with this I'm not convinced. For a typical semi-successful SaaS hosting costs will be small compared to dev salaries that went into creating it. Also you pay licensing fees for self-hosted products too. Also it's not like there's a moral duty for price to only reflect the marginal cost. Reportedly SpaceX launches are now quite cheap, but are priced relative to the competition. Nothing wrong with it IMHO. Ditto for charging whatever for creative work. > The hostility comes from the fact that the writer is trying to control and restrict what other people do with their work. It is very anti-social. Again, software licensing is the same. Renting a home, or a car, is the same. Also let's not get too carried away. If I buy a book, I can resell that book freely. It's just that I can't write my own sequel to it, or turn it into a film without the author's permission. This strikes me as a very good thing.
- deng 3y agoAs usual on Twitter, this lacks nuance. Copyright allows creators to decide how their works can be used. See for instance the GPL as an example for creative use of copyright, and RMS has always stressed that the GPL is a moral issue. It has nothing to do with monetization (it obviously does not require it, but it also does not forbid it). You might say Copyright was initially not be intended to be used like this, which makes the GPL a clever hack, but it shows that Copyright is not a single-edged sword.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aragonite 3y agoI remain unconvinced by the argument that without financial incentives, creative individuals will cease to create and society will be deprived of their creative contributions. That argument is more compelling for inventions and patents (the original context in which it was popularized) than it is for creations and copyright. If a piece of creative work would not have existed without the prospect of financial gain, it's unlikely to be very good. Society would not have missed out on much if some famous author published only their first 3 truly inspired works, which they wrote to satisfy their creative urge, but not the 20 potboilers that followed. We need to distinguish discoveries, inventions, and creations. Discoveries cannot be protected by patent/copyright. Inventions can and should (within reason). Creations might also deserve protection, but the incentives argument here is much weaker IMO than in the case of inventions. Ironically, the NYT, which prides itself on being a neutral and objective purveyor of facts, isn’t challenging OpenAI for using the factual elements of its reporting in training data. Facts, being discoveries, aren’t copyrightable. Instead, they are focused on the part where journalists exercise "creative freedom" – the specific wording, narrative, and "spin" journalists put on reported facts. Let's apply the incentives argument to this context: is it clear the world would be a worse place if NYT journalists lose the incentive to exercise creative freedom in their news reports?
- ethanbond 3y agoWhat do you do for work and how much do you charge? Art is a profession, not a charity.
- Calavar 3y agoToday, yes, but that's not universal across human history.
- ethanbond 3y agoYes the cave drawings were for funzies. That sort of art still happens, also for funzies. We get higher quality art via professionalization, as is readily apparent in the historical record (not many hobbyists in there).
- CaptainFever 3y agoRelated article from TechDirt: "If You're Arguing That Someone 'Deserves' Copyright, Your Argument Is Wrong" (2011) Specifically: > For many years, we’ve explained why the debate about copyright is not a moral issue at all. Yet, whenever we get into discussions on it, sooner or later, someone makes an argument about how this or that creator “deserves to make a living” from their art. (...) https://www.techdirt.com/2011/04/08/if-youre-arguing-that-someone-deserves-copyright-your-argument-is-wrong/ https://www.techdirt.com/2011/04/08/if-youre-arguing-that-so...
- skywhopper 3y agoI mean, yeah, this is basically a rephrasing of the Copyright Clause of the US Constitution which gives Congress the power “To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.”
- ZoomZoomZoom 3y agoIt is, as it functions in the wild. However, main reason for copyright to exist is to give the creators some control over associations and ways of exploitation. Repeating the examples I already posted in some previous discussion here: I don't want my painting being used for harmful product packaging. I don't want my music being used as a background for a political campaign or some hateful video. I don't want my literary characters being incorporated into some other work with a different narrative/vibe/whatever. Is there a better way to give the authors this kind of control which doesn't result in a dumpster fire of a system we live with?
- ltbarcly3 3y agoA moral right is LITERALLY DEFINED as "rights of creators of copyrighted works generally recognized in civil law jurisdictions and, to a lesser extent, in some common law jurisdictions." Whoever tweeted this seems to have heard the term 'moral right' and decided that it means the same thing as 'natural right' or something? I don't get it.
- growingkittens 3y agoCopyright needs to be reimagined. There should be different rules for "originators", legal owners, and legal entities. When the controlling legal rights of a work are separated from an originator, the speed to public domain should be accelerated. In this system: - An originator is the person who creates the work, and owns the work by default. - A legal owner is a person who buys the rights to a work. - A legal entity is any legal construct meant to represent a person or multiple people. Time to public domain would be faster if a company outright buys the controlling legal rights to a work. vs. Time to public domain would be slower if a company licenses the work from an originator. Works with no originator enter the public domain on the fastest track. Previous discussion of this idea: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37899357 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37899357
- sethd 3y agoTechnically it’s a government entitlement / subsidy, but on the plus side, at least it’s an entitlement everyone has equal access to.
- asylteltine 3y agoYes, and? What’s the problem? I would have less incentive to do things if I couldn’t profit from it.
- User23 3y agoIt’s true though. So-called “Intellectual Property,” with the partial exception of trade secrets, is all creatures of Congress (or other legislative bodies). The law itself is cognizant of this and at least nominally attempts to respect the natural right of intellectual freedom, which is why fair use and “limited” terms exist.
- sensanaty 3y agoI do like the defensiveness from the Tweet author when someone brought up one of his own pending patent, as if it weren't the same exact thing. I also find it interesting that it seems to be largely the hyped-by-AI crowd clamoring for abolishing Copyright laws. What's that famous saying about people turning a blind eye if they stand to make money off of things? Why is it that we're not seeing "Open"AI releasing all their source code if they're such bastions of morality and progress? Why is it that they want free, unfettered access to everyone else's work, but refuse to put their own work out there for free as well?
- varsketiz 3y agoCurious, what is the saying you refer to? Chatgpt suggests "There are none so blind as those who will not see."
- sensanaty 3y ago> It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it. I definitely massively butchered it, but I think the general gist is still there :D
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- h_tbob 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- steelframe 3y agoI've heard people say that we ought to return to a 28-year limit on copyright protection. I think it's interesting to note that much of what Richard Stallman and Linus Torvalds wrote would no longer be protected by the GPL if we were to do that. GNU/Linux distributions released on or before 1995 include Slackware 3.0 and Debian 0.93R6.
- whiddershins 3y agoThe overwhelming majority of people who are dubious about copyright produce work that is protected in some other way. The rise of web apps was hugely driven, perhaps primarily driven, by the fact you can’t just copy them. iPhone apps? Same thing. All enterprise contract work? The concept is irrelevant. Actually any contract work, any production of custom physical items … irrelevant. Copyright is the one where society has to “buy in” for the creator to get paid. This is an artifact of technology, and nothing to do with inherent moral or commercialization claims.
- blueboo 3y agoThe elephant in the sub-tweeting room: OpenAI getting caught red-handed memorising many many NYT articles. Now, the root cause must be attacked: copyright itself, not the intransigence of OpenAI to license this content (as they have with, say, Axel Springer). Can the rules of the game be changed before they come into effect for our heroes? Tune in to the next episode in 2024…
- 6R1M0R4CL3 3y agocopyright is a very anglo-saxon view of the thing. have a look on how the French do it, it's quite interesting. for them, the act of creation itself creates the property right of the creator. then, it is separated in several parts : what they call "droit moral" and "droit patrimonial". the first one, the moral right, stays with the creator at all times. it gives each creator a right not to see their work defiled or used in a way they don't want to be. the second one, patrimonial, contains all the rights about reproducing it (if it's a book or sculpture for example). this is quite interesting. the creator creates something. then, through a contract you give someone either for some time, or forever, the patrimonial rights so they can make copies and distribute those (akin to the copy-right) but the other part of the right, the moral one, stays with the creator. if someone wants to use your creation for something you don't like (for example, using a piece of your music for a politicial person meeting) the moral right lets you say : no. you can distribute it and sell it according to our contract, but THIS I do not want. we should replace copyright with that more evolved view.
- johhns4 3y agoHere it's good to point out that most of what is published is published within a platform that owns that content. Say you post a blog post on medium, or you write something on a subreddit. Who owns that content? The corporations? Reddit can sell this content if they wanted to and they do. If someone grabs this content without the platform's explicit permission it is copyright infringement. But to what end? The user? Do you think the corporation is thinking about the user when it argues for copyright infringement? It's about money. Now, we can go further with this and argue that copyright infringement can also hurt smaller businesses. Let's say the platforms start making deals with certain corporations so they can get ahold of this content. Maybe as training datasets. Maybe they already do. Now only bigger corporations with money and contacts will get access to this content and less smaller open-source projects will have the same resources to build models of the same caliber. Now it's hurting the competitive economy. Yes, an individual should be allowed to own their own content but if they freely post something on a blog or a forum, that is owned by someone else, they have already given their content away. And whether they like it or not it is being sold for monetary gain. That these corporations use the idea of copyright infringement as a way to bar everyone from this data without paying them is not about what is right, it is about money. It's a strategy.
- kazinator 3y agoCopyright can be fixed very simply: make it an inalienable, non-transferrable property of the creating individual, which cannot be sold and reassigned any more than a birth certificate. That will do away with the corporations that amass copyright. Corporations can still promote artists, and use copyright as a basis, but not in a way whereby those artists sign over copyright to the corporation.
- hn_acker 3y agoIn the US, copyright is a statutory right granted by the copyright laws written by Congress. Congress' authority to make copyright statutes and patent statutes is dependent on promoting the progress of knowledge and inventions [1]: > [the United States Congress shall have power] To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries. ... > Some terms in the clause are used in archaic meanings, potentially confusing modern readers. For example, "useful Arts" does not refer to artistic endeavors, but rather to the work of artisans, people skilled in a manufacturing craft; "Sciences" refers not only to fields of modern scientific inquiry but rather to all knowledge.[4] Copyright is statutory law, meaning it must obey the constitution but otherwise can do anything. (Being an amendment to the preceding body of the Constitution, the First Amendment overrides the Copyright Clause where and only where the two parts conflict.) The Copyright Clause allows Congress to produce short-term restrictions as the means to fulfill a long-term purpose. Congress can add and remove from copyright, but both actions must be for the purpose of promoting the spread, development, and eventual unrestricted public access to creative works. Emphasis on both "eventual" and "unrestricted". In simpler terms, copyright is a means to ensure that the public eventually gets access to every creative work. Copyright covers creative expression. Copyright does not apply to facts and ideas, nor does it reward "sweat of the brow" [2]. Patents cover implemented inventions, which are novel implementations of practical ideas. Patents do not apply to creative expression, nor unimplemented ideas. (Well, I think that's how patents are supposed to work. But software patents would beg to differ.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweat_of_the_brow#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweat_of_the_brow#United_State...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoThe comments in this thread are missing the point of the tweet. The point is that "moral" rights conveyed by certain copyright legislation may pose a threat to "AI" companies. These rights are separate from the "economic" rights that commenters are focused on. They are not for sale. In some countries, creaters of copyrighted works retain moral rights even when the copyright, i.e., the bundle of economic rights, is owned by someone else. The moral rights are not a means of commercially exploiting works ("monetisation"). They are a means of protecting proper attribution, integrity and maybe even privacy. https://www.jtl.columbia.edu/bulletin-blog/ai-created-art-and-the-moral-rights-of-authors https://www.jtl.columbia.edu/bulletin-blog/ai-created-art-an...
- welzel 3y agoThe current Copyright is broken - literally everybody except some evil cooperations and their corrupt politicians agree to that. We all have ideas how to fix it - very simply could be to go with Authors life and when the art is sold it goes down to 10-25 years. Thats it. Simple. What seems to be unsolved is HOW we actually get to this point. It seems to be impossible to get enough money to outspend the evil cooperations in buying politicians, so what do you suggest?