7 ms·
Quality of care declines after private equity takes over hospitals
- turnsout 3y agoWait, I thought the free market would solve everything! /s
- skfingngihg 3y agoWhy? You can’t even build a hospital or practice medicine without government permission. It’s an industry ripe for regulatory capture.
- lostlogin 3y agoAre you suggesting that less regulation would make healthcare better?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> suggesting that less regulation would make healthcare better? No, but more competition would. If we want to have private healthcare, we have to actually let free markets work. Our current system is the worst of both worlds.
- pc86 3y agoI think they're pointing out that heavily regulated industries are very easy to fall prey to regulatory capture, which benefits incumbents at the expense of users and those trying to enter the industry from outside. Healthcare in the US is nowhere close to a free market, so it seems perfectly reasonable to question the GP if it's asked in good faith (it's not).
- FireBeyond 3y ago> You can’t even build a hospital ... without government permission. You are talking about Certificates of Need which are investigations to show that an area needs a new facility... The concept of a CoN was lobbied for by hospitals and healthcare providers who wanted "guarantees" of profits before they'd commit to building new facilities. The CoN process helps existing facilities get a say in whether a new hospital should be allowed in the area. The government itself generally doesn't care.
- jokethrowaway 3y agoI'm sure hospitals owned by private equities still have regulations and face little competition. They just shouldn't exist. It would be interesting to compare small private clinics performance vs hospitals.
- TarasBob 3y agoIt does if the government is not involved.
- nobodyandproud 3y agoAny actual data to prove that assertion?
- thefaux 3y agoHow exactly does the market work without the government enforcing contracts and property rights?
- xyzzy4747 3y agoLots of cryptography and security guards?
- nobodyandproud 3y agoSo threat of violence? In other words, a defacto government?
- xyzzy4747 3y agoThe most profitable companies can afford the most security. It would probably work to some extent. I imagine it would mostly be for defensive purposes and to protect employees but you never know.
- nobodyandproud 3y agoSure but as a profitable company not accountable to customers, what stops them from giving poor service at a premium?
- xyzzy4747 3y agoThe customers would buy less of their services probably.
- hnbad 3y ago> "When health systems buy hospitals, they generally do not use borrowed money," said Song, who is also an internal medicine physician at Mass General. "In contrast, the classic private equity buyout uses a small amount of cash, but a large amount of debt." This is a red herring. Health systems have different metrics for success than "the market". The former, ideally balances QoC with costs. The latter by definition only cares about ROI in terms of profits (either from revenue or from playing hot potato with other buyers). There's no reasonable argument why we should expect private equity to result in anything but a degradation of QoC if it doesn't have a considerable negative impact on profitability or resale value (and that's even ignoring situations in which a loss may be desirable or acceptable).
- hlieberman 3y agoSeems obvious. Private equity is all about sacrificing everything on the altar of cost cutting, quality be damned. Why should we be surprised they do the same to the hospitals they buy?
- dv_dt 3y agoIt’s pretty clear to me that the overriding economic issue of our time is how do we systematically realign delivering quality and efficiency with profits. It’s pretty obvious that there are major breakdowns in both the current practices of laissez-faire and of regulation. Its seems to be an exception when a company delivers on all three of quality, efficiency, and profits.
- VancouverMan 3y ago> how do we systematically realign delivering quality and efficiency with profits. Free entry into the market, along with competition, are the free market forces that naturally balance those attributes over time. Keep in mind that within a given market, there can be multiple different balances at once, depending on the varying needs and priorities of the buyers and sellers involved. > It’s pretty obvious that there are major breakdowns in both the current practices of laissez-faire and of regulation. Even if it may be somewhat freer than in places like Canada or the UK, for example, the US health care sector shouldn't be considered a real free market or laissez-faire in any meaningful way. The US health care sector is highly regulated. This significantly reduces competition, and also makes it extremely costly and difficult for new entrants to participate in the markets. Regulation-imposed distortions that decrease competition and impede market entry should be expected to result in the inefficiencies and other problems we see. Fixing the problem is rather simple: remove the regulations, allow free market entry and competition again, and put the onus back on market participants to choose for themselves what's best for them and their own particular situations.
- hlieberman 3y agoExcept that, in basically every other developed nation, healthcare is _more_ regulated, if not nationalized, and has better performance for substantially lower cost. The invisible hand(job) can't save you from areas where there is no significant profit to be made. In many cases, it's most cost effective to simply let people die. That's the problem with focusing exclusively on profit motives in healthcare.
- szundi 3y agoThere are stuff that the government should doc, like public healthcare, military etc.
- alwaysrunning 3y ago"After a hospital was acquired by private equity, admitted Medicare patients had a 25% increase in hospital-acquired complications, compared with patients admitted before acquisition. Patients also had 27% more falls and 38% more bloodstream infections caused by central lines, which are temporary surgically inserted ports that allow easy intravenous access for patients receiving repeated drug infusions or other treatments. The increase was seen despite private equity hospitals' placing 16% fewer central lines than before the buyout." I am not sure who the private equity firms are, but I thought it was alarming when insurers started purchasing hospitals, urgent care facilities and even your standard family med doc, as they would be negotiating with themselves on how much profit they could make off each appointment. But I didn't consider lower standards when it comes to patient care, this adds a whole different dimension.
- Voultapher 3y agoYou know, it's maybe a bad idea to privatize some things https://www.economist.com/by-invitation/2023/07/10/mathew-lawrence-on-why-privatisation-has-been-a-costly-failure-in-britain https://www.economist.com/by-invitation/2023/07/10/mathew-la... water in the U.K got more expensive and the service worse. A terrible deal for everyone but a handful of private equity investors.
- giantrobot 3y agoNo one wants to learn the lesson that while government administration of some things might be "inefficient", any efficiencies brought about by privatization will be turned into margins by the private entity rather than savings to the end customers. Private entities need to maintain margins and will cut service to maintain them.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Private entities need to maintain margins and will cut service to maintain them This is a false dichotomy. Public v private is so often framed as a political agency versus free-market bonanza. In reality, we have independent agencies and public-private partnerships. But on the private side, we also co-operatives, a model which seems well-suited for community hospitals.
- edgefield 3y agoI’m struggling to understand how the standard PE model works, particularly the debt component. PE firms seem to target mediocre businesses, load them with debt, and then harvest returns and eventually the assets. Why would a bank loan money for such an arrangement, given how often these businesses end up in bankruptcy (Toys R Us as an example)? Is the debt collateralized and bundled with better performing debt or sold off to an unwitting buyer?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> PE firms seem to target mediocre businesses, load them with debt, and then harvest returns and eventually the assets Private equity no longer necessarily involves large amounts of debt, i.e. LBOs. Most managers have an economic effect they deploy to bring efficiency to an industry. The first popular one was deconglomeratisation. Then capital structure management. Digitisation and supply chain management followed. In each phase, they delivered then overcorrected. Hospitals initially started on the scale side. The thesis was that the biggest cost centre is administration, so if you linked together the administration of many hospitals you could reduce costs compared to private practices. This initially panned out. But hospitals are natural monopolies; those initial theses were rapidly corrupted. > given how often these businesses end up in bankruptcy Private-equity backed companies tend to be more resilient, not less [1]. [1] https://siepr.stanford.edu/news/private-equity-firms-show-resilience-downturn https://siepr.stanford.edu/news/private-equity-firms-show-re...
- Projectiboga 3y agoIt is a mix of tax loopholes. They can load up on debt, pull cash out. The big scam is share buybacks, they use the loans to by up their own stock. That was illegal from the 30a-80s, the Regan administration legalized it and it's been a race to the bottom. The other part is banks create money at multiples of their deposits. Fractional reserve lending. This creating money and then charging interest that isn't created is the root of this mess. They system worked well when there was fresh land and slaves to grab. It has continued w industrial growth. But now we are running out of oil to pump and other resources are starting to become scarce. This whole private equity is becoming a shackle on our economic system, almost 24% of the economy is controlled by private equity, and a chunk of that is carry forward profits which aren't taxed until withdrawn. They get to sell not pay capital gains and go into the next one. Good luck trying that yourself.
- dopylitty 3y agoThis is such a silly quote: > "Hospital success is measured not only in dollars or the number of patients who pass through the doors, but also in lives saved" As if profits are the primary goal of hospitals and saving lives/treating patients is just an afterthought. The capture of all life sustaining efforts by for-profit entities is probably the number one problem in the western world which is driving all others. Climate change, famine, homelessness, death from preventable disease. None are caused by unsolvable problems but instead by the inability of the for-profit/market based system to provide for human needs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Dalewyn 3y agoManhours cost money, equipment and infrastructure cost money, supplies and consumables cost money. If the primary goal of a hospital is to save lives, which it is, then the hospital needs to generate sufficient revenue to enable that goal.
- phkahler 3y agoNo doubt. But skimming some of the revenue for profit goes directly against that
- Dalewyn 3y agoProfit is necessary to invest in the future. If revenue matches cost leading to a gross profit of zero, you can only ever keep whatever it is you have today with no room to advance or adapt or even maintain.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> skimming some of the revenue for profit goes directly against that Non-profit hospitals don’t fare better or worse on health outcomes than for-profit hospitals [1]. They are run less efficiently [2]. If you’ve been on a non-profit Board, particularly a service-model non-profit, this makes sense. [1] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/hospitals-converting-to-for-profit-status-show-better-financial-health-no-loss-in-quality-of-care/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/hospitals-c... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7439627/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7439627/
- thinkingkong 3y agoIm endlessly fascinated by the cultural angle on technology of well being. We have enough resources to solve poverty, education, and access to medicine yet social determinism is the driving force in all these areas. There have been recent calls for the human population to hit a trillion people (by billionaires). The reasoning is we’d “have more einsteins” but personally Im way more worried about the genius physicist working in an amazon shipping center.
- lostlogin 3y ago> by billionaires I think you are right, the billionaires want minimum wage workers who are making less than a living wage.
- armchairhacker 3y ago> We have enough resources to solve poverty, education, and access to medicine yet social determinism is the driving force in all these areas. Do we? We have enough food, but not the logistics to distribute it. I doubt we produce enough of some medicines because they have constant shortages. Whether we have enough education depends on how you define it: I believe we have enough to give everyone access to online resources, but we have an education crisis in the US which is driven by unmotivated students, and the factors which are causing the lack of motivation cost much more (old-style teaching, large classes with disruptive students, poor school infrastructure, poverty at home). It's a social problem because I'm sure even if we had enough resources, there are people who would get in the way of distributing them, because they don't want people to be educated or feel they don't deserve assistance. Already we have countries which block parts of the internet, and countries at war which block aid. But I don't think it's only a social problem.
- stuartjohnson12 3y ago> We have enough resources to solve poverty, education, and access to medicine Access isn't binary, nor is it ever "solved". Every person in wealthy 1st world countries has access to enough food that they won't starve, access to secondary education to 16/18, and emergency medical care. I'm sure you would consider those things insufficient. A right asserted without any degree is pretty useless.
- aquafox 3y agoI don't understand why governments allow to privatize hospitals or other public ressources, often with the reasoning that otherwise they wouldn't be profitable. We don't expect other public services like fire departments or road construction to make money. Why should hospitals be treated differently?
- ImHereToVote 3y agoBecause there is no practical way for rich people to use luxury fire departments that deprive the filthy proles of protection, or luxury roads for that matter.
- derbOac 3y agoMy sense (as someone with generations of family in healthcare) is, at least in the US, there's a massive gap between what the healthcare system was like decades ago and how it functions now. At one point in the distant past there was probably a better balance of population size and number of providers, service demand and provider type, a greater number of more independent and locally run hospitals and clinics, less regulation about certain important issues, more permanent employee positions with more standard employer benefits, and so forth and so on. At least in some areas of the US there used to be public hospitals, run at the local (state or county level) but they were essentially privatized or defunded to the point where they had to close or become privatized. I could give lots of examples of this, but things now are less local, more controlled by centralized, private but national entities, more regulation, more consolidation of clinics and hospitals, and so forth and so on. I'm for putting more central resources in public control (government insurance, more public clinics and hospitals) but also believe there needs to be more deregulation of important elements and more competition to drive down costs on the supply end. In my opinion, there's a lot of hidden factors driving up healthcare costs, in the form of insulating providers and hospital and clinic chains from competition, taking choice aware from consumers, decreasing transparency about costs, as well as "hiding" public funding of healthcare that's already happening. It feels a bit like, in the US at least, we have this system that likes to pretend it's 1960, at least insofar as doing so benefits certain people and groups.
- api 3y agoIf we do enter an era of slowing actual growth, we will really have a problem with the financial industry trying to cannibalize the entire economy to find "alpha" somewhere. Everything in our economy could work just fine without a lot of growth except finance, which absolutely cannot work and collapses completely unless number always goes up forever.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago>Everything in our economy could work just fine without a lot of growth except finance Which includes all taxpayers, since all those government employees are paid with the "growth" in the form of underfunded defined benefit pension and retiree healthcare. Or the people counting on their 401k numbers to go up.
- faeriechangling 3y agoThe free market is the most efficient system we have for optimising profits. Not sure why people think that means it's a good model for hospitals.
- klipt 3y agoFor markets with lots of competition it's pretty good at optimizing customer satisfaction at reasonable prices too. Consider food and electronics. It fails with monopolies though.
- thinkingtoilet 3y agoNot even monopolies, literally no market forces. If you have a heart attack or a stroke, it doesn't matter what the prices listed for care are or customer reviews. You get to a hospital as fast as you fucking can. There are literally no market forces in play a lot of the time. Also, if you don't live in a big city, there may only be a single hospital by you that provides the treatment you need. Again, no market forces.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoIt’s useful to separate medicine from ER in healthcare discussions. In ER, there is no market. In healthcare, we have a deeply-flawed market. But in most zip codes, there is some competition.
- bakedoatmeal 3y agoThe ED is the primary source of hospital admissions so I don’t think the two are that separable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago
- pierat 3y agoWhy aren't VC's and PE also found directly complicit when physicians and nurses are found guilty/liable of $badthing? In the US, we love faulting individuals doing $badthing, but refuse to look at policymakers when they knowingly do so. And in the end, the policymakers play musical chairs or Pokemon (gotta buy them all), and do the same company after company.
- pc86 3y agoI'm trying to take this comment as an honest question in good faith and not as political bait or "rich ppl bad." Some random PE investor or analyst isn't the one putting needles in people's arms or writing prescriptions, so does it make sense to send the analyst to jail when someone dies from negligent causes in a hospital? I don't think it does. It probably doesn't make sense to send anyone to jail unless there's actual malice involved but if you're looking to punish someone for something it probably makes sense to look first at the person actually pushing the drug or doing the procedure.
- asadotzler 3y agoWhen PE takes over and cuts resources or otherwise "optimizes" leading to bad outcomes, the medical staff are on the hook for those bad outcomes but the PE firm that caused the cuts that caused the bad things are not. Make sense?
- pierat 3y agoLet me see if I can elaborate further. PE company comes in to a med facility. We have proof that when they move in, they make new policies. These policies have a demonstrable proof that they reduce standard of care, cause X% more incidents, and Y% more deaths. From the article is: > After a hospital was acquired by private equity, admitted Medicare patients had a 25% increase in hospital-acquired complications, compared with patients admitted before acquisition. Patients also had 27% more falls and 38% more bloodstream infections caused by central lines, which are temporary surgically inserted ports that allow easy intravenous access for patients receiving repeated drug infusions or other treatments. We have demonstrable proof that policies put in place have directly caused this harm. I'm not trying to alleviate blame when a med professional does something wrong and causes an injury. However when we see increases like "25% increase in hospital acquired complications", tells me that there is underlying policy that caused a significant increase in injuries/deaths. We can point towards a policy that causes mass injury, yet the policy people are beyond reproach. Instead, the 25% more injuries are looked at as an individual bad action. Now we should be looking at the individuals and how their decisions caused a bad thing to happen.... however when we see trends from multiple people towards the same reasoning, and the reasoning is "policy", then absolutely those policymakers should be in scope. I would also look at policy decisions of 2nd derivative effects too. However those can take quite a bit of time to appear. Again, if policymakers want the responsibility of policy, ethics, legality, and direct result of policies should also be what they look at and are responsible for.
- spacedcowboy 3y agotbh, my experience is the other way around. When a hospital locally ran out of money and was taken over by the county, the quality of care dropped drastically. My wife had a good experience giving birth in our local hospital 12 years ago, but this year, after having been taken over, they completely screwed her brain up in what should have been a routine procedure. 10 months later and she’s still suffering. i’m not sure she’ll ever recover :(
- michaelmrose 3y agoFirst let me say I'm sorry for your wife and I hope she recovers. Respectfully that hospital may not be an apt comparison because it was taken over because it was already failing under private ownership whereas PE is more apt to buy something because it is functional and therefore profitable. It seems likely that both causes are an example of failure of private ownership wherein the county is being blamed only because it was left holding the bag.
- nine_zeros 3y agoWhen the metric is "return on investment" let me assure you that all the PE investors, execs, managers, individuals involved are only looking to eek out more profit - quarter after quarter. If it ever comes down to helping a patient (or employee) vs a quarter with lower than expected growth, they will predictably not help the patient (or employee) in favor of meeting that quarter's target.
- avidphantasm 3y agoLBOs should probably be illegal. They seem to ruin everything they touch. Also, we should probably nationalize a lot of the entities PE has taken control of. Might be a nice way to back into nationalizing a lot of industries that have no business being private.
- jmclnx 3y agoI remember my parents and Aunts/Uncles talking about the new at the time trend of for-profit health care in the 70s. Back then all the hospitals were non-profit, many supported by religious groups. They pretty much predicted the current situation for care, but missing out a bi on the tech side of healthcare.
- aubanel 3y agoA datapoint I find impressive on the debate "What should we privatize": UK Rail privatisation seems to have worked really well, as shown in this graph: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9f/GBR_rail_passengers_by_year.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9f/GBR_rail...
- bigbuppo 3y agoHow is this relevant to private equity in healthcare being the equivalent of throwing patients into a meat grinder and then charging them for it?
- deckiedan 3y agoI suspect there are a lot of other factors to take into consideration here: - population growth over that time - percent of people able to afford cars and fuel over that time - % of those numbers that are in London ( and other big cities) - so the number of people able to afford to live in London compared to jobs there... Many people were priced out, and so have to commute, and pollution taxes and parking prices are now there to discourage cars - how much train line maintenance has been dropped, and will be coming up as needing replacement "soon" but not done - how much subsidy the private companies are actually getting still. ... Trains in the UK are really not great at all... Compared to the rest of Europe anyway.
- bookofjoe 3y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/26/upshot/hospitals-medical-errors.html?unlocked_article_code=1.I00.i4bl.Z1xA2GTJEv1f&smid=url-share https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/26/upshot/hospitals-medical-...
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]
- happytiger 3y agoSo people are literally dying to help investors make a return on capital. I feel like you could be at the end of the world, looking at certain destruction approaching us, and there’d be some venture capitalist being, “listen, we have full control of this situation. Everything is fine… we’ve got a long history of managing risk in this area.”
- fsckboy 3y ago>though patients were no more likely to die right in the subheadline it says "though patients were no more likely to die"
- happytiger 3y agoK. Curiously, the study found a small drop in hospital deaths at private equity hospitals. This, the researchers said, may be due to social and demographic factors — private equity patients were younger and less disadvantaged than those at peer hospitals not owned by private equity. https://hms.harvard.edu/news/what-happens-when-private-equity-takes-over-hospital https://hms.harvard.edu/news/what-happens-when-private-equit... Also: https://www.medpagetoday.com/publichealthpolicy/practicemanagement/108014 https://www.medpagetoday.com/publichealthpolicy/practicemana... https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2023-12-26/study-private-equity-hospital-takeovers-tied-to-increases-in-patient-falls-infections https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2023-12-26/... https://www.chicagobooth.edu/review/when-private-equity-takes-over-nursing-homes-mortality-rates-jump https://www.chicagobooth.edu/review/when-private-equity-take...
- hulitu 3y ago> Curiously, the study found a small drop in hospital deaths at private equity hospitals. Maybe because the former patients died at home.
- happytiger 3y agoDarkly, probably correct; and worryingly precient.
- chank 3y agoIs there any well known instance where a private equity firm taking over a business/service resulted in a net positive for customers and not just the firm being a leech?
- supertrope 3y agoDell went private for a bit so they could pivot without having Wall St complain about a few unprofitable quarters.
- sgnelson 3y agoI would add another caveat: "and for the employees" as one of the key plays by PE seems to be to just lay as many people off as they possibly can get away with.
- fallingfrog 3y agoWhat?? Why are we allowing private equity to take over hospitals? That’s a life and death public service! You don’t just throw it to the wolves like that.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoSee also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38773426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38773426
- sydbarrett74 3y agoIs anyone actually surprised by this? Since PE is all about shaving pennies and maximising profit for the PE partners, of course they're going to sacrifice actual patient care.
- elzbardico 3y agoFrom the "Things get really fucked up for consumers, employees and society in general when Private Equity gets involved with something" Department.
- chromatin 3y agoAnd yet the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) outlawed physician-owned hospitals, when experience demonstrates they have the highest levels of care (superior outcomes) and often cost less. Hospitals and their venture-backed owners of course love this.[1][2] Don't get me started on what a farce "non-profit" status is. [1] https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/providers/hospital-groups-aim-blunt-effort-reverse-aca-ban-physician-owned-hospitals https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/providers/hospital-groups-a... [2] https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/second-opinions/105351 https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/second-opinions/105351
- tryptophan 3y ago"Non profit" = "we channnel all of our extra money(not profit) into crushing competition and empire building"
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoThere is a journalist who was covering this for years who once said in an interview that she could determine which ER Departments were owned by PE by searching the job listings for ER staff in the area. Ads placed by PE were easy to spot. She said when travelling she would deliberately avoid those hospitals.