11 ms·
US spent more on health care in 2022 than 6 countries combined with universal
- cassianoleal 3y agoThis is about US Government spending on healthcare. Add to that what individuals pay on top and the US situation is even bleaker.
- nolongerthere 3y agoMany would argue that this very clearly shows the US gov is unable to provide cost effective healthcare, if they’re already paying through the nose and not even covering the entire population how would adding a single payer system be more efficient?
- bisRepetita 3y agobecause if you are the single payer (govt), you can negotiate much much better rates.
- masklinn 3y agoUnless of course you are barred by law from negotiating rates.
- addandsubtract 3y agoLaws that you, the govt, make?
- masklinn 3y agoYes. There are different levels of governments and those can be at odds (witness: laws limiting or barring municipal internet). And there are people who specifically aim to be elected to kneecap government services.
- mysterydip 3y agoMissing "combined" in the title, which changes the meaning a bit.
- frenchman99 3y agoNot really. The original title is a bit misleading in that the 6 countries combined have the same population ad the USA alone.
- Sharlin 3y agoAnd the point is that those countries have combined population roughly equal to the US, they’re not, say, the Nordics. A technically correct but almost useless title.
- pseudolus 3y agoIt's a lengthy title that didn't fit into the HN title limit. I've edited it to include the word "combined" although the result is still a little unwieldy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- selfselfgot 3y ago[dead]
- Y_Y 3y agoThe original title finished with the word "combined". Even still is not clear what they're saying until halfway through the article. > This means the U.S. government spent more on health care last year than the governments of Germany, the U.K., Italy, Spain, Austria, and France combined spent to provide universal health care coverage to the whole of their population (335 million in total), which is comparable in size to the U.S. population of 331 million. They lumped together six countries to get something with a similar population and use that as the comparison. Of course you may argue that the US is too exceptional to compare, this wasn't addressed.
- rpastuszak 3y ago> Of course you may argue that the US is too exceptional to compare In what sense?
- iteria 3y agoPopulation density relative to population. The US is not dense. There are legitimately strategies that will not work for us given some of our "large population centers" are actually pretty tiny when considering hpw developed we are. This is also why the US has 3rd world problems like issues getting water and electricity to some citizens. The population density in some states can drop very very low and we have a lot of people on those low density areas. It becomes a horrible last mile problem. Honestly, I'd like to hear from Canadas and Australians about the rural experience. They have the same density problems and I think their solutions are nore relevant. That said, I'm not really a fan of the outcomes from Canada, so who knows maybe high population, low density is just a bad hand for a country in this context.
- Jensson 3y agoScandinavian countries are less dense than USA and do just fine.
- thatwasunusual 3y ago"Combined" is missing in the title, but the per capita spending in the US is staggering compared to other countries.[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea...
- robertlagrant 3y agoOnce more, with feeling: it's not the lack of spending or taxes or too many billionaires that make healthcare difficult in the US. It's the unholy system created by generations of governments over there.
- napoleoncomplex 3y agoFor those who will click directly into the comments: The US GOVERNMENT (not the US as a whole) spent more on health care ($1.8 trillion) to provide non-universal healthcare than 6 European countries with a combined population similar to the US did ($1.2 trillion) to provide universal healthcare. The article's premise being, it costs the government significantly more per person, and 50% more in total to run a non-universal healthcare system serving a subset of the population, than it does a universal healthcare system which covers everyone. As a whole, the US spent $4.5 trillion (private+public).
- pseudolus 3y agoI believe the numbers you're quoting are "trillion" and not "billion".
- napoleoncomplex 3y agoThank you, fixed!
- neuronic 3y agoThis is correct, US total healthcare spending equals 16.6% of GDP with less bang for the buck than many other nations. "The United States perfoms better than the OECD average on 29% of indicators" https://www.oecd.org/unitedstates/health-at-a-glance-United-States-EN.pdf https://www.oecd.org/unitedstates/health-at-a-glance-United-... Most European nations hover around 8-12% of GDP.
- magicalhippo 3y agoThe US has a significant higher percentage of obese people[1] than the EU countries they combined. Obesity is known to be a significant risk factor for a large number of health issues[2]. Eyeballing an average of 25% obesity among the EU countries with the US having 36%, means the US has 44% more obese people per capita. While that doesn't explain all of it, it surely is a significant contributing factor. [1]: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/obesity-rates-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/obesity-r... [2]: https://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/effects/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/effects/index.html
- Mattasher 3y agoThere is no such thing as "universal health care" in a country, in any meaningful sense. Every country with government run health care rations with limits on availability, wait times, excluded treatments (mental health, dental, vision, drugs, acupuncture, etc), and often by personal clout/connections (this is the case in Canada, where I lived for many years). Note this is in no way a defense of the US system, which is messed up six ways from Sunday.
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoI have lived in Norway for a number of years. And yes, there is. At least in comparison to the US system: "Universal" means everyone gets a basic level of care. ... Rations? There are no set limits, though they might not build another MRI machine if the existing ones aren't being used enough. It isn't like health insurance doesn't limit your care: They just tell you they won't cover x or y. And your denial of care will be different than what your neighbor gets in the US instead of everyone being treated nearly the same. My drugs are covered in general. And when I purchase them, most are fairly cheap compared to the US. Wait times definitely exist in the US as well, especially if you are waiting on a specialist, who likely isn't in your area unless you live in a big enough city. At least when I have wait times here, I get paid time off work if it is necessary. Mental health is included. Acupuncture isn't actual medicine. Dental and vision aren't included here: Vision isn't generally too expensive (my partner and I both wear glasses) and dental has a discount. I think these should be included, though. Still better than dental insurance in the US - at least i can afford a dentist here. The dental is included in some systems (looking at you, Brazil). In short, the complaints are the same in most places. Especially in the states.
- pxmpxm 3y ago> Wait times definitely exist in the US as well, especially if you are waiting on a specialist, who likely isn't in your area unless you live in a big enough city. That is simply untrue, the only thing reminiscent of "wait time" is the actual scheduling of an appointment - ie call the office and they pencil you in for next Thursday or something. Or if you actually walk into an ER with something trivial.
- twoodfin 3y agoAverage physician salary in France: $154,000[1] Average physician salary in the US: $352,000[2] That’s a big chunk of the difference. Simply changing who pays for your healthcare won’t close that gap. [1] https://www.erieri.com/salary/job/physician/france# https://www.erieri.com/salary/job/physician/france# [2] https://weatherbyhealthcare.com/blog/annual-physician-salary-report https://weatherbyhealthcare.com/blog/annual-physician-salary...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aldarisbm 3y agodo you understand why they get paid that much in the US...?
- alephnerd 3y agoSchool is expensive, there's more money to go around, and the opportunity cost is much higher.
- Jensson 3y agoUSA has too few so it pushes wages up. That is what happens when you don't have a free market, lots of people who want to become doctors aren't allowed to creating artificially high wages. Physicians per 1000 people: Germany: 4.25 France: 3.27 USA: 2.61
- Grustaf 3y agoWhy aren’t they allowed to become doctors?
- sct202 3y agoLack of residencies which are funded by the government. Medicial schools in the US try to get as many students placed into residency as possible so they control admissions to match residency slots, because if you don't have a residency you cannot become a doctor and med school costs $200k-$500k so it's life wrecking if a student doesn't match. The side effect is that we have a lot of pseudo-doctors who have roles that overlap in capabilities with doctors like Physicians Assistants and Nurse Practitioners to fill in the gap.
- pers0n 3y agoIt won’t change, too much money is being made and they can buy all our politicians, all of them
- cies 3y agoYes, I think too the problem is lobbying. Also: if the gov't buys as a "single buyer" it has a lot of purchasing/bargaining power. The system in the US is (lobbied) to not give the govt any power, and put it all in the hands of the market (insurances, etc). It's be said many times: never let a capitalist come near your healthcare system.
- mfer 3y agoThe US doesn’t typically spend on health care. It spends on sick care targeting things which can be dealt with via medications or surgery. For example, most doctors don’t help people avoid heart disease. Instead they watch for it or things they can treat with drugs that can lead to it. Then try to help people manage it that. I’m not blaming doctors, it’s the system. If we targeted health care and generally good health over the course of our lives, cost could radically go down. And people would have far fewer issues. </rant>
- mattmaroon 3y agoMedicare and Medicaid
- pharmakom 3y agoTotally agree. The biggest failings in the US are around public health. In the US, the path of least resistance is to drive everywhere, sit at a desk and eat fast food. It’s really hard as an individual to overcome these forces.
- tyoma 3y agoWhile it would be better for people who would live longer and healthier lives, it would not cost less. The reason is the same reason that smokers actually saved the health system money (source: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejm199710093371506 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejm199710093371506). People who live longer use more and more expensive healthcare.
- mfer 3y agoThat assumes high chronic diseases from other things causing high health care costs. What if we got rid of most chronic diseases? Most are caused by lifestyle but they’ve become topics we just don’t talk about. They’re taboo.
- timmb 3y ago> Between direct public spending and compulsory, tax-driven insurance programs, Germany spent about $380 billion in health care in 2022; France spent around $300 billion, and so did the U.K.; Italy, $147 billion; Spain, $105 billion; and Austria, $43 billion. The total, $1.2 trillion, is about two-thirds of what the U.S. government spent without offering all of its citizens the option of forgoing private insurance. Is it fair to include Germany here? I thought the German system required everyone to have private insurance through their (breadwinner’s) employer. But I’ve only heard this via self-employed people complaining of having to pay €300 a month in health insurance. To me it sounds more like the American system than the UK one of everything just being free and state-funded. But as I say, I only know through hearsay.
- cgeier 3y agoMost employees are part of the public health insurance system in Germany. People who are not employees and people with an income above a certain threshold can (or sometimes must) choose a private health insurance.
- glow8 3y agoPrivate insurance in Germany only applies to those self-employed or, optionally, those employed who are above a considerable yearly salary threshold. Otherwise, it's public, and the cost depends on your salary. If you're employed, your company pays for half the insurance cost, be it private or public. This means that it's expensive for self-employed people.
- Longhanks 3y agoThis is false. As a regular employee, the system is fully regulated by the state. You can choose your "state-regulated" healthcare provider (gesetzliche Krankenkasse, but the differences between those are only in extras, which are neligible - something like rewards for going to the gym, living healthy). You and your employer pay monthly fees to the healthcare provider. You never get to see the employer's part, and you never see the money that you have to pay, because it is deducted from your monthly salary before your net salary is transferred to your bank account. The monthly fee is regulated (https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/beitraege https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/beitraege). If ylur gross salaray is lower than about 62.000€, it is mandatory to stay in this state regulated system. With higher salaries, you can choose to opt out into the private healthcare system. If you are self employed, you can choose to stay in the regulated system. However, since you are now both employer and employee, you have to cover both sides of the fee. For many self employed people, switching to a private healthcare provider saves them money, because there the fee, depending on some factors, is usually lower - it does no longer depend on the gross salary, but on the insuranced person's personal circumstances. However, private healthcare provides are to some degree also state regulated; there is a minimum set of service they are required to provide. The cases of regular employees that don't go with state regulated healthcare providers are low. The cases of self-employed people that don't go with private healthcare are low. If you make enough money, you can start calculating wether switching to the private sector is benefitial to you. But it is impossible not to have health insurance, and it is impossible to go bankrupt because of health related costs in Germany.
- RA_Fisher 3y agoAmericans are relatively wealthy and hence choose to spend more on healthcare. That’s not surprising to me.
- rsynnott 3y agoI realise that it is most improper on this here orange website to read the article, but this is _government_ spending, not consumer. No choice involved. (Even beyond that, bizarre idea. “Oh, I think I’ll go for a _designer_ MRI scanner” said no-one ever; by and large, the expensive bits of health care don’t have a lot of choice involved.)
- ejb999 3y agowell it is a 'choice' in the sense that politicians campaign on it, and people vote for those politicians - so it is a choice.
- beej71 3y ago"Don't blame me--I voted for Kodos!" We did vote for Obama who gave us the ACA. And a number of states have banned surprise billing from out-of-network doctors. And hospitals are now required to post prices, but they ignore that So there has been change in the last 20 years, but clearly we're spending more than ever.
- kethinov 3y agoWhile I am very enthusiastic about reforming our system to a single payer system, one fact about the US that is unique that a lot of people on my side of the issue need to understand better is that making our healthcare system more socialized will almost certainly not bring down the costs. It may even go up. One of the big factors driving the lower costs of healthcare in other countries isn't the cost savings from socializing it, it's the fact that the US essentially subsidizes the entire drug research industry and the rest of the world doesn't have to pay for that like we do. So even with single payer healthcare, we're still gonna have to be the nation that shovels all the money into the drug industry. I don't personally see a problem with that per se. We are a rich country. We should pay the lion's share. But the cost shouldn't be so directly passed on to consumers in the form of insane drug prices. Switch to a prize system in exchange for taking stuff off patent or something, e.g. the federal government buying the patent whenever something new comes out for an extremely high one time price, then let the generics market go nuts with it. That would bring down consumer prices without eviscerating drug company profit margins and destroying their incentive to innovate.
- asimpletune 3y agoI didn't know anything about the USA subsidizing the drug industry. Can you explain this?
- TuringNYC 3y agoI lived overseas for work. I once went to the pharmacy and they said "4" -- and I was like "4 hundred?" No, they meant 4. The same medicine I'd pay $25 copay (with insurance kicking in another $70 or $100) cost $4 out of pocket overseas. This is because single payer systems overseas negotiate down prices. The US does. not. This effectively means that the US is subsidizing the drug industry.
- jasonjayr 3y agoThere's a non-trivial amount of R&D being done with public funds (universities, and/or grants) that go to medicines that end up being locked up with patents and privately owned.
- throwaway85284 3y agoIf you include individual expenses, Americans pay a lot more, with on average worse outcomes. This link posted by a sibling is illuminating: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea... That said, the US system is pretty much the best in the world if you're wealthy. At the end of the day, it's completely in line with the American cultural norm of promoting the material success of the successful. It's why some of the world's best doctors are in the US, why people on this website think half a million USD "total comp" isn't that crazy, why the US has such a dynamic startup ecosystem, and so on ... When you consider that, it all makes sense. I wish Americans were more upfront about this being their culture though, and others in the world more understanding that this is what they are collectively trying to achieve, rather than an abberation. I'm not passing any judgment, just observing -- though anyone is free to of course.
- amadeuspagel 3y agoWhat an inane statistic. It looks like this is "news" because someone only come up with it now, but the reason someone only came up with it now is that it's so stupid. It would not be "news" that the US spent more on healthcare per capita then the UK, but you can actually compare and discuss the two healthcare systems, you can't compare "universal" and "non-universal" healthcare.
- gumballindie 3y agoI often see americans looking with envy at european health care, or europeans bragging about it. Well in the UK, and a lot of west european countries, health care is in a state of collapse. Just do a short google search of hospitals around the UK and rad their reviews - there are literal human rights abuses being reported, all while hospitals have an official government rating of "good". It's unbelievable - when I was in hospital I had patients next to me that had to beg to see a doctor, while a teenager was screaming in pain and nurses were mocking him. The UK doesn't have a financing problem, or a understaffing issue. The UK has an underskilling issue. Private or public the doctors and nurses I had to work with had no clue what they were doing, and there always had to be 3-4 people doing the job of one simply to confirm that what they are doing is right, and the issues working on were basic. Not to mention that health care software systems barely work - buggy, missing obvious features, not used at all because staff has no clue how to use it, and so on. All in all west european health care, particularily british, looks like east european health care used to - but indeed without the bribery and arrogance that plagued that system. At least not at the same level, yet. Not to mention that it is extremely expensive. You pay for public health care and on top of that for private health care without a tax deduction. So if you are a worker you are likely stuck waiting in long queues only to be sent home with a misdiagnosis. Your employer provided insurance will cover at most one or two visits to a GP per year and that's about it.
- gmac 3y agoYMMV here. I’m in and from the UK, and have family members who are hospital doctors. The NHS is indeed collapsing, but my understanding is that this is a combination of (1) underfunding, (2) Brexit, which caused many healthcare workers from the EU to leave the country, and (3) an incompetent, corrupt, far-right government that hates public services and would like us to move to a monstrously inequitable but profitable US-style system (but know they can’t say that out loud).
- _heimdall 3y ago> (1) underfunding In the context of comparing total government spending, that's a really important caveat. > (3) an incompetent, corrupt, far-right government that hates public services Isn't that a problem with a fully government-run system in general? Preferences and motivations in leadership change over time. If the people are dependent on the government program to function they're also at risk of being helpless if and when the government stops running the program well.
- codemiscreant 3y agoAs expected, the preponderance of comments claim US exceptionalism: why somehow it’s a unique snowflake and it just wouldn’t work there. Another comment with the classic “we pay for drug research“ fallback (ignoring that accounts for a vanishingly small percentage of the expenses). The US population is so indoctrinated with baseless propaganda that it will take a century for it to move to a better model.
- avidphantasm 3y agoA century, or a major catastrophe like losing a major war…
- deburo 3y agoOur better model (in Canada, Quebec) is increasingly disliked by our population. The private sector is getting more popular, enough so that our government is thinking about banning it.
- wholinator2 3y agoWhy do you think that's happening? It is just a huge propaganda campaign by moneyed interests or is there some actual benefit? Maybe just the grass is greener
- foldr 3y agoUniversal healthcare isn't guaranteed to work well. The point is that it at least can work well and you can see examples of countries where it is working well. I suspect that people would feel very differently about private healthcare if it was their only option rather than an additional option for those with the money to spare. For example, in the UK I am glad to be able to make use of private healthcare for small things when I need to, but I would hate to be in a situation where it was my only option. (And that's not because the NHS in the present moment is a particularly shining example of universal healthcare done right.)
- duck 3y agoI use to work with a lot of Canadians and multiple of them traveled to the US for medical procedures in the year or so I worked with them. One older co-worker broke his arm while visiting family in Quebec and literally drove hours to cross the border to have his arm set there b/c of the wait time. I won't pretend to say I understand the systems in place in Canada nor have insight into why they did this, but I always found it really interesting.
- hardware2win 3y agoI do live in country with universal healthcare - Poland, and On one hand when my mom had eye problem that required spending 2 weeks in hospital and surgery, she didnt have to pay for it except for some simple things that were cheap On the other hand im paying not small amount from my every salary for health care and due to wait time or quality I still often go to private med (except for basic sickness where doc can give me a week or two "sick leave") Also Ive been pissed off when I had serious surgery (at private med) and my insurance didnt cover it (but ok, thats insurance not univ. health care) All of that makes me feeling like im paying a lot for mandatory health care and things like insurance And at the end of the day I must go and pay for private health care. At least my mom didnt have to pay. I feel like im getting scammed. I'd rather manage my own money and how I want use it
- addicted 3y agoI don’t understand how anyone manages their money and how they want to use it when medical expenses are concerned. Your “how I want to use it” is completely out of your control and based on when you fall sick, get injured, need advice, etc. Nonenof which are choices you make. So even an extremely efficient entirely private system doesn’t allow you to either manage your money nor allow you to choose how you want to use it. You could take insurance, but again, you’re neither managing your money nor choosing how to use it. Medical expenses are not like buying a toaster that you can decide to put off or buy whenever you want or never if that’s what you prefer. Also, in any modern decent society, if you choose never to eat toast no one is concerned. However, if you’re dying on the street because you aren’t paying for medical care society will step in. So there’s also a burden you’re imposing on society based on your choices that are not involved in most non medical situations.
- hardware2win 3y ago>Medical expenses are not like buying a toaster that you can decide to put off or buy whenever you want or never if that’s what you prefer. Some. Not all medical cases need instant contact. Proof? Months or years long wait times. Also for me 99% of the medical expenses are around 10-20% of what I pay every month. Meanwhile those medical expenses arent regular. >Your “how I want to use it” is completely out of your control and based on when you fall sick, get injured, need advice, etc. Nonenof which are choices you make. So how people do it with cars? Cars break often, especially when poorer people must use used cars They often rely on them to get to work, so they not always can delay fix endlessly You just have backup of just in case money. >. However, if you’re dying on the street because you aren’t paying for medical care society will step in. So there’s also a burden you’re imposing on society based on your choices that are not involved in most non medical situations. Thats the reason.
- coryaf 3y agoThis is a misleading clickbaity headline. Those 6 countries added up equal about the population of the US, so it's not like we're spending 6 times other countries on a per capita basis. We spend more and get less than other countries, but you don't need to mislead people to get that point across.
- Grustaf 3y agoIf they have the same combined population, then it’s not misleading. There are no other first world countries with 300 million people, so it’s pretty obvious that the comparison is with the combined 6 countries.
- coryaf 3y agoYes it is - they could have done it on a per capita basis but they didn't. Also, if you read the headline, it's very easy to think we spend 6 times per capita than comparable countries, which would be wrong
- kergonath 3y agoThis does not make sense. If spending is much higher for a similar number of people, then spending per capita will be higher by the same factor. Normalising per block of 300M people or per person is exactly the same, that’s not misleading at all. The headline says exactly what it seems to say. It does not imply any normalisation per capita.
- coryaf 3y agoPerhaps you could tell me what information, other than how big the US is, is conveyed by the headline when it says "than six countries... combined".
- JoBrad 3y ago> This means the U.S. government spent more on health care last year than the governments of Germany, the U.K., Italy, Spain, Austria, and France combined spent to provide universal health care coverage to the whole of their population (335 million in total), which is comparable in size to the U.S. population of 331 million. I’m not sure how the headline is misleading in any way.
- storf45 3y agoI thought ‘The Price We Pay’ by Marty Makary was a great way to dive into some of the reasons of how expensive and complex the US Healthcare system is. Here’s a quick summary of the book: https://alijiwani1.medium.com/summary-of-the-price-we-pay-4b5cf6f23059 https://alijiwani1.medium.com/summary-of-the-price-we-pay-4b...
- lvl102 3y agoUS healthcare system is run by mobs. That’s my conclusion after working in the industry for a decade.
- miki123211 3y agoWhere does all this extra money actually end up? Who benefits? Is it all shareholder profits? Employee salaries? Re-investments into research? Marketing and sales budgets? Defending from liability lawsuits and liability insurance? Taxes? Construction workers that charge more for building hospitals than they do in other countries? What the hell is going on here? The fact that the US spends more on healthcare isn't very interesting to me on its own. It doesn't really say what the US can do about it, moving to a single-payer system can reduce prices due to the government's bargaining power, but it can also increase prices and decrease quality due to no competition and no reason for anybody to care about efficient spending. If consumers have no choice, they will choose the option you provide, no matter how bad it is. A breakdown on what exactly the US spends more on would be far more enlightening. If more money flows into the healthcare system, more money must flow out of it, and where exactly those outflows are is a far more interesting question for me.
- api 3y agoIt’s largely a massive ad-hoc jobs program. The number of people employed in health care administration is mind numbing.
- thereddaikon 3y agoIn my experience working the tech side of the healthcare industry, every aspect is inefficient and most players are doing their best to extract as much wealth as they can from it. There is a lot of room for improvement in terms of cost and efficiency. I've given up hope for a political solution. Nobody seems to want to talk about why everything is so expensive. They are too focused on who is going to pay for it.
- vidanay 3y agoI don't think inefficiencies are going to be the answer either. I'd bet that those other countries have just as inefficient medical bureaucracies.
- thereddaikon 3y ago
- TriangleEdge 3y agoThis article is unscientific garbage. As a Canadian who got healthcare in the US, I can say the quality of the service I got was much higher, and I waited 2 months for surgery instead of 2 years. You guys want a free lunch, expect free lunch quality.
- LeafItAlone 3y agoI am honestly curious: how that was paid for in your case. I’m an American who has needed urgent care in Canada and I was not billed. How did the reverse work, especially in your case where it was clearly planned?
- TriangleEdge 3y agoI worked on a TN visa for <big_tech>. I had a high deductible plan, so I paid up to X out of pocket. I forget the exact amount but I think something around $3000 USD. My surgery was sports related and non life threatening.
- bee_rider 3y agoThe US system does an OK job of serving well off people who need inexpensive non-life-threatening procedures, I guess? But I’m not sure this tells us much about what the policy should be.
- apexalpha 3y agoPeople in Europe also have the option to go to private facilities if they're willing to pay thousands of Euros out of pocket.
- c-cube 3y agoThat's called anecdote. If you're a skilled immigrant working in tech, you'll probably have excellent healthcare coverage through your employer. This isn't the case for dozen of millions of americans.
- 3y ago
- consumer451 3y agoSo many interesting non-technical threads get flagged these days. This post appears to have been flagged by administration as I cannot vouch for it. Or, is that because I already commented? Sometimes I completely understand, sometimes I somewhat understand, but in this particular case? There is a good exchange of ideas going on. Yes, I know the first rule of HN club, but this is a deserving topic.
- GuB-42 3y agoThis should be GDP adjusted, since most of that money goes back in the country, paying healcare workers. Both the US and Europe employs people in the pharmaceutical and medical equipment industry, and research. So really, gross numbers don't make much sense for the sake of comparison. People in high GDP per capita countries are better paid, duh. And here, if you adjust for GDP, the effect disappears. And in fact, in rich countries, it is normal for healthcare expenses to go up in proportion to GDP since health is a basic need and not a solved problem. That is, rich countries can give food and shelter to their entire population but there is no panacea. It doesn't mean it is good for the US, but it is a dubious statistic to pick when you want to highlight a disfunctional healthcare system. Try life expectancy instead.