8 ms·
My experience has shown that USB C connectors are far more fragile than A, and every time I plug one in, for some reason the fit just feels vague and unsatisfyi
by userbinator 3y ago
My experience has shown that USB C connectors are far more fragile than A, and every time I plug one in, for some reason the fit just feels vague and unsatisfying. An A plug, when you get it the right way, slides in solidly. As others have mentioned, C seems to have been designed to be the smallest possible, which makes sense for mobile devices, but not for a desktop and its peripherals.
- al_borland 3y agoI recently moved my display over to running on USB-C, so I could have one cable to charge my laptop and feed the display. Plugging it in was a very unsatisfying experience. The port seemed misaligned, so I had to be a fair amount of effort into it, and once I got it, it felt like nothing. I was worried when I rotated the monitor back into position, or adjusted the hight, that it would fall out. I haven’t thought about that in years with other ports. It works, and I like that it’s one cable, but the feel is awful.
- iknowstuff 3y agoSeems fine on MacBooks
- JohnFen 3y agoThis is my experience as well. I have had substantially more problems with USB C connectors failing than with any of the prior USB types.
- gloosx 3y agoIn a macbook pro build it certainly feels like this. I have an old 2015 mbp with A connectors serving for almost ten years now. When I plug something in it is tight and solid and feels right. On my latest mbp with C connectors, they are loose already after a year of service, I need to wiggle and shake the connector inside the port to get a nice contact and make peripherals work, of course, that breaks it even more over time.
- karlshea 3y agoI think that’s dependent on the port, there are some I’ve plugged into with a very satisfying click and it felt very secure. But you’re right the cheap ones are pretty vague.
- arcticbull 3y agoInterestingly enough, they're specced the opposite way. > Standard USB has a minimum rated lifetime of 1,500 cycles of insertion and removal, the Mini-USB receptacle increased this to 5,000 cycles, and the newer Micro-USB and USB-C receptacles are both designed for a minimum rated lifetime of 10,000 cycles of insertion and removal. [1] > To accomplish this, a locking device was added and the leaf-spring was moved from the jack to the plug, so that the most-stressed part is on the cable side of the connection. This change was made so that the connector on the less expensive cable would bear the most wear. [1] I suspect that would make it the responsibility of the cable, not the receptacle, to give you that satisfying feedback. Which is good, because the cable is much cheaper and easier to replace than the receptacle. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB_hardware https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB_hardware
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- picture 3y agoI think it's a bit ironic that the cable is considered more costly than the receptacle, which is generally true if you consider the device as a whole, but now we have multiple hundreds of dollars thunderbolt cables and the cap on the actual receptacle component is below $10 even for ones with support for higher speeds. But then again, most people don't have the SMD rework tooling to be able to easily replace receptacles
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chx 3y ago> now we have multiple hundreds of dollars thunderbolt cables This is mostly an exaggeration. Apple has a $160 3m 40Gbps cable but Cable Matters has the same for $70 (and Trebleet has a 2.5m one for $50). The 25 feet 40gbps cable from Pure Fi is the only I can think of that fits the "multiple hundreds' description at $200 but then again it's an active optical cable (it's not compatible with plain USB). > the cap on the actual receptacle component is below $10 even for ones with support for higher speeds. Maybe the actual C connector they started with is below $10 but you are looking at rather expensive redriver chips inside and careful engineering to care for the signal integrity at 40gbps.
- demondemidi 3y ago> but not for a desktop and its peripherals. This doesn't make sense to me. Why should it be bigger?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- prerok 3y agoBecause the bigger connector, if it's attached at its corners or throughout the length, can phisically better withstand the shearing physical forces applied to it.
- simooooo 3y agoThat mushy feeling has caused me to push it into the wrong port multiple times and cause my pc to turn off instantly. Think the mushy feel is due to the io plate on the mobo
- epigramx 3y agothey should make it big as A, and reversible as C, why do I have to think of solutions so obvious?
- hulitu 3y agoAnd this will help also with power delivery. As an EE, putting 100W in such a small connector gives me shivers.
- labster 3y agoYou’re a genius. Of course, no one wants a big connector in their cell phone, so we’ll have to make a mini C. And then a micro C. And then they’ll make USB D to try to simplify all of these competing standards. That said the form factor of type C is a little too small to be wieldy to me.
- imiric 3y agoThose exist[1]. I reckon connector size is an issue on smaller devices, but there's no reason why USB-C couldn't be improved to make the connection more secure. [1]: https://tripplite.eaton.com/main/search?q=reversible%20usb%20a https://tripplite.eaton.com/main/search?q=reversible%20usb%2...
- makach 3y agothat is a very good observation and I agree. I guess that can be fixed, and high quality c-connectors will provide this sensation, just look at the iphone lightning connector which IMO provides something similar.
- imiric 3y agoSame here. I've experienced flaky connections with several USB-C ports, and sometimes the port itself gets dislodged. I've had devices RMA'd because of it. Nowadays I'm very careful when plugging in USB-C, doing my best to not pull on the cable, etc. It's overall a worse UX than with USB-A, and being reversible doesn't make up for it. Then you have the mess of protocols and standards that use the connector, where I need to use specific cables for specific devices, and I'm never sure which one is which. The term "universal" in USB has completely lost its meaning.
- Aerbil313 3y agoRather, the cable became universal and the protocols diverged. But I’m fairly sure the situation will be fixed by the adoption of USB-PD as the ultimate power standard. As all the other standards (QC and else) are including it in their own. And the remaining HDMI devices will be phased out in a decade or so. Then you’ll need to only care about the wattage rating when charging devices. Seems like future for me.
- necovek 3y agoWhat about bandwidth? There are 10Gbps, 20Gbps and 40Gbps cables, along with "wattage" (really, amperage/current). Both will continue to go up.
- aifooh7Keew6xoo 3y agoIt's worth noting I suppose that newer USB power delivery standards are scaling voltage rather than amperage/current to deliver more power to the device. The pins are specified for 1.25A each yielding 5A and I believe the 5A cable specification came at the same time as 20V with the 100W power delivery specification. Every power increment since then has been a voltage rather than current increment.
- necovek 3y agoGood point, I was aware that newer USB-C PD standard offers bigger power delivery (up to 240W, I think), but I didn't know it was achieved through increased voltage. That means it goes up to 48V DC, so that's certainly curious, thanks!
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoYeah USB-C is horrendous. Broke my light macbook air from being so tightly connect it dropped, macbook also had very short charger cables for a while. While being so tight it often refuse to charge because of it being so good in collecting dust and having a long neck that makes a small hit bend it so it doesn't work.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hulitu 3y agoI have the same experience. The USB-C on my phone is dyin. Charging the phone has become a challenge. Yet on my 12 years old computer, the front USB A ports are a bit loose, but still working properly.
- TrueSlacker0 3y ago100% agree with this. My 2.5yr old phone will not longer register the usb-c port and I have to charge it wirelessly. My PC still has a few USB connection ports from 2009 that still work. (Although most are newer than that)
- rezonant 3y agoConnectors which have consistently shifting pressure applied, especially from side to side, are going to fail faster regardless of the design. It just so happens that the side that's most likely to be in this state is the side connected to the phone you're holding, the headphones you're wearing, etc. I have seen USB and Lightning ports fail on tons of different devices where the user is actively using the device while it is plugged in, even when they treat it gingerly and even without any identified sharp tugs or the like. I've taken to using Volta plugs for all my USB devices at the device side to prolong the life of their ports, and it's great for unifying micro USB, Lightning, and USB-C onto one cable. Highly recommend them! That said I agree USB-C connectors on desktop motherboards are particularly poorly made, and indeed make an unsatisfying connection.
- mordae 3y agoI don't know. I can easily lift my phone by the USB-C cable. And as for the connectors, sure USB-A usually has 4 through-hole mounting and through-hole live pins[^1] so the connection to the board is rock solid, but USB-C connectors, despite having surface-mounted live pins tend to have shallow mounting pins as well[^2]. I find it pretty durable. [^1]: https://jlcpcb.com/partdetail/ShouHan-10_0_4C6_3ZB/C6386909 https://jlcpcb.com/partdetail/ShouHan-10_0_4C6_3ZB/C6386909 [^2]: https://jlcpcb.com/partdetail/Dealon-USB_TYPE_C018/C2927038 https://jlcpcb.com/partdetail/Dealon-USB_TYPE_C018/C2927038
- Hedepig 3y agoAt the risk of sounding a bit dumb, I shorted my motherboard with a USB A, it felt like I got it right, and pushed it in, at which point it shutdown. Fortunately there didn't seem to be any permanent damage
- throwuxiytayq 3y agoHappens to the best of us. I also had a bit of a scare like that recently. The only thing worse than a non-reversible connector is one that breaks (or fries your device) when you insert it the wrong way...
- meiraleal 3y agoNot my experience at all. USB-A would very often break. Never I had a USB-C break.
- fennecbutt 3y agoI notice a lot of people are arguing against usb c, but in reality: devices are designed for the average consumer, not us special HN peeps, usb c is the way forward, we can't use a bulky almost industrial USB connection forever, having a single type of connection has so many benefits, if someone exceeds the plug/unplug rating or the socket breaks for some other reason...it can just be repaired. Everyone arguing against c like they wanna go back to old style serial port connectors or something.
- ryukafalz 3y agoI like USB-C myself, but I don't think this is a good argument: > if someone exceeds the plug/unplug rating or the socket breaks for some other reason...it can just be repaired. ...when consumer tech companies these days tend to make repair much more difficult than it used to be.
- phero_cnstrcts 3y agoI’d honestly prefer usb a if it wasn’t for the fact that I have to try plugging it in four times before I succeed.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoI think it's just because the C cabels tend to be newer and companies van get away with more disposable build quality now than when A was booming.
- kubiton 3y agoI got my HTC vive.out of the closet today and as usual hate USB micro and love USB c. Usb-c just fits. Do you mean the real USB plug the bigger one? Those are dependent on my device. The USB a port on my desktop case are okay, the ones at the back of my Mainboard way to tight.
- rowanG077 3y agoInteresting. This is completely the opposite for me. I have bend a ton of usb-a cables over the years. Has never happened to me with usb-c the connector for industrictable to me.
- readams 3y agoOne issue with USB-C is that dust gets packed into the female side. I've found it can be in there so tight that even after attempting to clean it, the dust remains. But going in with a sewing needle, rubbing alcohol, and really scraping you can fix the port.
- wjdp 3y agoWe've had a problem with the cables provided with ThinkVision USB-C monitors. They're so horribly stiff either end gets quite a lot of force exerted on it. We use them for hot-desk setups at work and I've seen multiple with the metal part of the plug broken off from the plastic shroud. I've asked for some "Cable Matters" ones to be bought as that's a brand I recognise and _think_ is good, we'll see!
- libraryatnight 3y agoNo matter how much I baby USB-C connectors on phones, I eventually end up in a place where I'm wiggling the cable to get it to pick up that it's plugged in to charge - usually around the time i start looking for a new phone. I'd like a Framework style swappable USB charging port already.