14 ms·
It's still easy for anyone to become you at Experian
- chris_wot 3y agoSounds like the beginnings of a class action.
- electrondood 3y agoI noticed this as well... you didn't even need to verify the phone number you enter to sign up as someone else when I last checked. It's unbelievable
- ledgerific 3y agoI think a tit for tat system could help. Anyone which views your info should also allow you to view theirs. Regardless if you work for some legitimized cause or not. This should be codified into law and should be punishable via a fine/debt which could not be canceled(gov loans, taxes).
- NegativeK 3y agoOur legal system typically isn't built around vengeance. And if Experian knew who was viewing our info inappropriately, they'd know it's not us -- and stop it. Instead their lame system assumes that anyone who has minimal information about us _is_ us.
- zzzcsgo 3y agoI locked my credit at all major credit agencies.... Not sure if it helps
- 0pteron 3y agoWhat the heck, I signed up for an account at the advice of the article just so someone else can't register and looks like they automatically signed me up for a digital checking account. I never wanted this
- arciini 3y agoGiven there are 3 credit bureaus, is there a way to avoid having a credit score at one of the credit bureaus? I think that's a way that we as consumers could try to increase competition in the field. I did some Googling and it didn't seem like there's an easy option.
- ssgodderidge 3y agoI feel like this has to happen. They operate like a private utility company, with little to no other options. Imagine if they were like password manager apps? We could evaluate all of them, choose what we wanted, and migrate whenever something happened.
- djbusby 3y agoBusinesses report data to them. So, you'd have to avoid businesses that report to one. But, they all report to multiple.
- paulddraper 3y agoAs a consumer? No As a business? Sure, report to the ones you want to
- atrettel 3y agoThere is no way to opt out of credit reporting. Lenders report the information to the credit bureaus, typically all three of the big ones, so if you want no information reported, simply close all your credit cards and loans, etc. and place credit freezes on your credit reports. I don't think that "increased competition" will work here. We are not customers of the credit bureaus. We are the product. The customers are lenders and other people who need your information. From the lenders' perspective, this is all working out fine, largely because the onus for "identity theft" is placed on members of the public as individuals rather than on lenders to accurately verify applicants' identities before extending credit. As many people have pointed out before, "identity theft" is a misnomer designed to pass the buck onto individuals. Ideally, it should be the lenders' responsibility to prevent criminals from misusing your information and to make things right whenever a criminal tries to use your information fraudulently, but right now the onus is placed on individuals. A better solution would be to have higher standards for identity verification by lenders. That would shift the burden onto lenders to actually verify people's identity before extending credit. Some lenders actually do a pretty good job of verifying people's identities before extending credit in my experience, while others just seem to accept the information given uncritically (as far as I can tell!). High industry-wide standards should help solve this (either voluntarily or mandated by law).
- theonemind 3y agoExperian reminds me of enshittification, except it never had any interest in providing actual value to the general public to betray, so started off one step further along the process in a way. No individual in a personal capacity ever wanted to do business with Experian, like they wanted to buy an iPhone or something. You're introduced to the unpleasant fact of its existence at some point. They don't have anything you want, you're the product from the start, and you don't have to walk into their net, you're probably born in it.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoWe're amidst the proliferation of a class of entity that Joe average doesn't quite have the political vocabulary or tools to deal with yet; Things that deal in you. They make money from you, indirectly. You have no business or social relation with them. You didn't vote for them. They have immense power to harm you. You have no recourse. You may not even know they exist. Until recently this was the preserve of a few government agencies that had a very narrow focus on a few "persons of interest". Today it is every dime store startup in "big data", search, spammers, social network, and the entire grubby, yellow maggoty underbelly of "surveillance capitalism" and all the mushrooms that grow on it. So far the promised "benefits" of this have never materialised. Will we be able to keep pretending "nobody cares" as public awareness, and governments' will to enact legislation grows? At some point surely "credit agencies" and their ilk will essentially be outlawed under a dozen different digital rights acts.
- city41 3y agoEvery time I log into experian.com, I am greeted with an offer to "upgrade" my account for $0.00. At the top is small text that says "Try Experian CreditWorks℠ Premium for 7 days for free, then pay just $24.99 each month†. You may cancel anytime if not satisfied." First of all, $25/month for an Experian product? I can't possibly fathom how anything they provide can be worth even 1/100th of that. That price just absolutely blows my mind. But worst of all, they proudly say it is $0.00 and have the pay button the most prominent. How many people get roped into this? They are just slime all the way down.
- 3y ago
- bee_rider 3y agoOf course, we aren’t the customers for these spying companies. But it is surprising that the total lack of security isn’t a deal-breaker for their actual customers. I mean if you can basically impersonate anybody using this service, what is the point of using it?
- civilized 3y agoIf identity theft were to get so common that the data became statistically unreliable, we would be long past the point that even Congress would feel compelled to do something about it.
- godzillabrennus 3y agoYou give Congress too much credit.
- bee_rider 3y agoThere’s no such thing as identity theft, it is impossible to steal an identity, the person still has their identity. It is impersonation. The victim is the entity that has fallen for the impersonation (likely a bank, etc), the perpetrator is the one who did the impersonation, and the impersonated person is just some uninvolved third party. I know it is pedantic but it is important to keep in mind because dumping the need to seek redress on the uninvolved third party is ridiculous, so we shouldn’t use language that plays into that point of view.
- alistairSH 3y ago100% agree, except the impersonated person is impacted when their credit score eventually gets screwed and they can no longer get loans themselves. So, in that regard, they are also a victim.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- breadwinner 3y agoThe fundamental issue here is that maintaining security is expensive, and it is cheaper to just deal with occasional hacks. The only solution is to make hacks extremely expensive to the companies that get hacked — through fines as well as lawsuits by victims of identity theft.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIt is not that expensive. It is a couple pennies per pull (of a credit report/file) for somebody seeking identity proofing to use knowledge based authentication (the usual “where did you live, are these trade lines you?”). It is $1.50-$2.00 per proofing attempt with the government credential using ID.me or stripe identity. The problem is that no one is incentivized to slightly increases costs to reduce fraud because the burden falls on consumers instead, and credit reporting agencies don’t want to see their moat and revenue stream cannabalized. Bit of a public good Innovator’s Dilemma. TLDR A better national digital identity story makes this problem go away. (responsible for customer IAM including identity proofing at a fintech, doing some lift for Login.gov independently as a citizen activist)
- golem14 3y agoI would imagine that most of the data for the ID checks based on public records (where did a person live; own a car/house/boat; ...) are trivially handleable. Just takes one person to leak the database, which is probably only a few TB compressed) for all of the US and fits on a single HDD/SDD. I would be surprised if these DBs aren't already sold on the darknet. And this DB doesn't have to be super up to date b/c security questions often go back years. Interpreting the DB should be easy to hardcode but even easier handled with an LLM. So the protection afforded by these checks is IMO at best nominal.
- everybodyknows 3y agoID.me supports hardware 2FA, including Yubikey.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago
- kome 3y ago[flagged]
- pests 3y agoHow does Equifax or TransUnion handle the case where someone else creates the account before you do? You try to sign up correctly, then it emails the fake persons email for permission? How does that make any sense. "Hello scammer, John Doe would like to access his Equifax account. Do you want to give him permission?" I agree the Experian way is not good either, but how is the above handled?
- Lacerda69 3y agoDo you need to sign up for any of these services? Sounds horrible all around to me (not from the US)
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Do you need to sign up for any of these services? (not from the US) They already have the well-shared data that determines much of your life. Signing up is so you can glimpse it too.
- xienze 3y ago> How does Equifax or TransUnion handle the case where someone else creates the account before you I can speak for Experian. If you already registered the account, and someone else knows your SSN and the answers to the credit bureau security questions, then _they_ get to register your account. You as the person who originally registered will get an email that your email address changed. Supposedly the thinking is that they want to make it impossible for someone to truly be locked out of accessing their own Experian account, so they just let you do these stealth registrations as long as you can answer all the security questions. Clearly they need a better solution.
- pests 3y agoThank you yes but isn't this the topic of the article we're commenting on?
- mike503 3y agoThey should be suspended from being able to do business with this kind of bs and their track record. I wonder if any of this violates people's FCRA rights, in which case that's a lot of fines.
- latchkey 3y agoI tried to log into their website the other day to just get my profile set up and see what was going on in my account. Their site was so broken, I couldn't even get logged in. How is anyone going to become me if I can't even become myself?
- Buttons840 3y agoTo become you, I just have to go through the channels that Experian customers use. You were not using the channels that Experian customers use. You were using the channel that Experian liabilities use.
- cynicauliflower 3y agoMy Experian was hijacked, unfrozen, and used to get a $100k loan from Ford Credit. Took me ages to clean up. Bastards.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> used to get a $100k loan from Ford Credit This sounds like it was used to get a vehicle - which are fairly trackable things. How did the ordeal unfold and conclude?
- fordholes 3y agoSame exact thing happened to me. I only dealt with the various credit agencies and Ford. And I had to make a police report to my local PD despite the crime occurring at a dealership across the country — the officer was very kind, and made clear that they would do literally nothing other than produce the case number I needed for the credit agencies. I wonder if Ford in particular is more susceptible? In any event, I’ve no idea whether a law enforcement eventually looked into it. But the sense I got was no one was going to do a damn thing. (Oh and Progressive, because they got insurance for the vehicle in my name and also didn’t pay that. But it was 1000x less dollars, literally, so when I told the debt collector “lol not mine” they just went away).
- toast0 3y agoYeah, afaik, most Police won't do anything with this. My spouse's id was used to rent an Oakland luxury appartment in 2021, along with opening a credit union account and trying to open an amex. Thankfully amex called to check because there was already an account opened, and we were able to get the credit union account closed before it was usable, but the apartment complex seemed unable to do anything and Oakland PD didn't do anything other than acknowledge the report, they wouldn't return calls from our local PD either. IdentityTheft.gov is also a black hole. Credit freezes are a joke, because if you have a person's credit report, you have enough information to cancel the freeze, even if you can't temporarily thaw it. Still, maybe it's better than nothing, so might as well. But it's then a pain if you need to interact with the credit system; some of the bureaux have such poor systems that your accounts will regularly not work; anyway, credit issuers don't tend to tell you what bureau they'll pull from until after they pull, so may as well unlock the big 3 before you do anything; and batch all your credit increase requests together.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoI am still livid on a weekly basis when some strangers create an account for a service using my email address (non-maliciously, usually); I get a "verification" email; and I can only choose "YES, Please verify", or ignore at my peril. From tiny little mom-and-pop shops, to FAANG giants, nobody is giving me the opportunity to say "NO that's NOT me!". And though it's a "verification" email, typically account is usable and vast majority of functionality is allowed even without verification. So I get to vicariously and angrily "enjoy" the follow-up emails and updates while the users gamble, purchase, sell, review, invest, write, game et cetera using my email address. Boo to this, I tell ya, boo!
- throwaway54_56 3y agoI get these every so often and I'm curious what you mean my ignore at your own peril. My approach has been to ignore it and assume they will realize their mistake and reregister.
- throwaway914 3y agoOP said so: The functionality of the account is usually partially or mostly available to an unverified email.
- throwaway54_56 3y agoYes, but I don't understand what problem that poses for him. After he verifies the incorrect email address, they have full functionality.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoThere's any number of risk scenarios, assign likelihood as you will : * owner of account doesn't pay, service sells the debt to collection agency, and they come after you because it matches your email and profile. * owner of account subscribes to something unsavoury or does something illicit, which is now traceable to you * given email is a big part of the incredibly ridiculous and overly pervasive tracking economy and profiling of the interwebs, your profile will now be even more annoying then before and be associated with things you don't want them to be. Etc. Or just, to your point, one day they'll realize their mistake and be mad at YOU (because people aren't generally good at taking responsibility :) and now it's a thing. I should mention I have a dozen email accounts of various degrees of protectiveness. Thia happens, annoyingly, to my most private address that I have never ever once used for business or signed up for anything, only for friends and family. So among everything else I'm peeved that my pristine email and identity is being polutted by other crap. And again... The reason this frustrates me, is this should.not.be.and.issue in any sane world. If you're sending verification email it should have a No option. Anything else is grossly neglible or evil or both.
- ge96 3y agoI've been getting mail that is a variation of my name, wondering if someone used my identity damn. I did put some lock thing on my credit so it's harder to open new accounts, forget what it's called. I have stuff like credit wise, karma, etc... have not seen weird/unknown accounts so hopefully I'm good.
- Covzire 3y agoI'd like to see Experian shut down at this point to send a message to the rest.
- csharpminor 3y agoI’ve received two data breach notices in the past week, one from my healthcare provider and the other from the bank that holds my mortgage. In both instances they said to lock my credit, and provide free credit monitoring for a year. I find this egregiously insufficient to the point where I think we need more regulation in this space. They should provide lifelong credit monitoring and full insurance on any financial fraud that now occurs on my behalf, as well as immediate presumptive financial compensation. That aside, the root cause here is that identity in the U.S. is a dumpster fire. We have no distinction between unique identifier (SSN) and secret (also SSN). Every other security question is just another version of the same factor type (something you know) which is easily accessible to scammers. There is quite literally no agreed upon way to prove you are who you say you are. We need DMVs to begin issuing IDs that are physical with digital capabilities, like credit cards. We need the equivalent of Apple/Android Pay for identity online. We need to mandate that banks support digital IDs. And we need strict enforcement for people who misuse a digital ID. I believe that the consequence of ignoring this problem is at least tens of billions of dollars in GDP annually lost to fraud. And perhaps more importantly, it’s an insidious erosion of our status as a country of laws.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> We need DMVs to begin issuing IDs that are physical with digital capabilities The problem is that there is a very vocal segment that views such things as "government overreach" through to the literal mark of the devil. And then there are the challenges of issuing them. There are states (the same states, typically, who shut down voting locations in working class areas and defund their DMVs) who will fight tooth and nail about having to implement this in a way that is free to all.
- gchamonlive 3y agoMaybe this is why for the past few weeks I am receiving countless emails from major retailers like Casas Bahia or Americanas and even Magazine Luiza with purchase confirmation listing several smartphones and notebooks whose invoice bare my name and cpf. I tried contacting every retailer. Only Magazine Luiza seem to have acknowledged the fraud and issued a warning but to no avail, as I am still receiving invoices from them. I contacted the local police and issued a boletim de ocorrência (which I am not quite sure how to translate) that describes the problem and how I was unable to apply countermeasures. I am expecting fallout from this. I am really anxious about this whole situation and how I am utterly powerless in protecting my identity.
- tmcz26 3y ago[flagged]
- saagarjha 3y agoWell I am from the fraud remuneration department of Brazil and know the person who pays out compensation for these crimes. Simply send me all your personal information and credit card details and I’ll make sure you get your appropriate payout.
- Aeolun 3y agoThis is a scam.
- saagarjha 3y agoExcuse me, you're calling me a scammer? I suggest you click on my username and see that it is a very legitimate account, with twice the karma as you to boot. I think you're more likely to be the one scamming! Don't listen to 'Aeolun, everyone!
- Aeolun 3y agoLook, you are literally posting on the internet, on an anonymous account, that if someone sends you their personal details and credit card info everything will be taken care of. Your first reaction should absolutely be that it’s a scam, and only then further evaluate if it might possibly be true because this is HN. I could have potentially used the word ‘looks like’, but it’s just a matter of degree.
- narrator 3y agoThis all goes back to the social security not being changeable and morphing from some thing to claim benefits with to it being your universal password. In contrast, I lost my drivers license and in order to get a new one I had to go the DMV in person and put my thumb print on a biometric scanner which pulls up my picture for the DMV person to look at before they authorize the request. I can also file an affidavit of identity theft with a police report attached and they will give me a new license and A NEW DRIVERS LICENSE NUMBER. The federal government trying to shoehorn an unconstitutional universal identity system into social security is the source of all this nonsense.
- hiatus 3y ago> go the DMV in person and put my thumb print on a biometric scanner which pulls up my picture How does the state have your fingerprints on file?
- narrator 3y agohttps://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/driver-education-and-safety/educational-materials/fast-facts/requirements-for-a-california-identification-card-ffdl-6/ https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/driver-education-and-safety/ed... It's a basic requirement in California to get any form of ID.
- hakfoo 3y agoI was somewhat surprised to find that when I got my driver's licence at 39, it was the same number as the non-driving ID card I got issued at 18. So at least Arizona doesn't seem to be eager to hand out new numbers.
- narrator 3y agoThey won't hand out new numbers unless someone has actually used your drivers license fraudulently and you've filed a police report. Seems reasonable enough.
- nilamo 3y agoI still find it infuriating that the punitive settlement for giving away extremely sensitive information was only... $34.34 per person impacted. Why even have laws or fines if they're so toothless?
- coldcode 3y agoThat's the point. Politicians get paid (donated, contributed, whatever) to vote businesses' laws to benefit the business, not you. Toothless laws make a good sound bite but do nothing to help you.
- happytiger 3y agoHow is Experian not sued out of existence for their total failure to protect their customers? I just don’t understand what law allows organizations that compromise large portions of entire societies to continue.
- electrondood 3y agoThey didn't even ask me to verify my phone number when I entered it. Anyone with my SSN and phone number from an all-too-common data breach could easily pretend to be me and unfreeze my credit file. That's criminal-grade negligence.
- Implicated 3y agoWe're not the customer, we're the product.
- jessriedel 3y agoBut why can't people successfully sue for libel/slander/defamation by individuals when they give false damaging information about the individual to creditors?
- fedorareis 3y agoThose types of suits generally hinge on proving malicious intent
- janalsncm 3y agoMalicious intent is the standard for public figures. The vast majority of people in Experian’s database are not public figures.
- fedorareis 3y agoOne of the best ways to affect this is to make complaints to the CFPB. They are the regulatory body that is responsible for making sure the credit bureaus aren’t harming consumers
- alexfoo 3y agoI’m guessing this will continue to happen until, I dunno, some the execs at Experian continually have their accounts compromised in the same way again and again.
- InCityDreams 3y agoThe execs may be incompetent, they're probably not stupid, though- they don't use that shit.
- mulmen 3y agoThis isn’t an opt-in service. It’s a dragnet surveillance system. All it knows is slurping up data. Are there case statements all over the codebases to exclude the execs of three different companies and congress?
- rwestergren 3y agoIf you have any sort of Experian bureau activity, you're at risk by this issue whether you manage your profile with this site or not
- tiffanyg 3y agoYes, it sure would be a shame if, I dunno, some execs at Experian were to experience some of the same issues that so many others have - due to the existence and ... 'management' of their own business ... Why, going through such trials, ex opere operantis, might just sour a 'true believer' in the "invisible hand" on the whole novus ordo seclorum.* Hahahhahahaha! Urghk, briefly part-swallowed my tongue from laughter, excuse me... * As the undoubtedly distinguished graduates of Yale SOM, for example, might phrase it
- saulrh 3y agoUnfortunately, the people in charge of these systems have enough money to hire people to do all of this crap for them. They don't do their own taxes, they don't open their own credit cards, they don't negotiate their own mortgages or car loans, nothing. They just tell their butler or financier or real estate agent or whatever "Go get me an X" and that other person deals with all the shit. Being the target of identity fraud just means they hire another gofer to deal with it full time for six months which costs them so little money, relative to their wealth, that's it's not even worth thinking about. And they're not even using their own credit, most of the time, they're using the "credit" of some shell corporation or limited liability corporation or trust or whatever other financial bullshit they hired a dozen lawyers to set up to commit tax fraud. So no, they experience none of the shit they perpetrate.
- nathants 3y agoi froze my credit across all providers a few years back. only experian failed with silly bugs. tried again just now and it worked. progress!
- bozhark 3y agoBet they stole his information from setting up the Experian account to begin with.
- ycombinatornews 3y agoThere’s a petition on resistbot now to get some legislative eyes on this issue https://resist.bot/petitions/PONADR https://resist.bot/petitions/PONADR
- schleck8 3y agoI'm seeing this for the first time given I'm not from the US, but its reach seems limited https://resist.bot/petitions https://resist.bot/petitions In Germany there is Campact for example which usually crosses 200K signatures per petition, if something like this doesn't exist in the US then I think someone with money should create it or promote an existing solution like OpenPetition to enough recurring signers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campact
- nulbyte 3y agoI'm not sure what you mean by limited reach, but for added context: Resist Bot is an automated service that can be used to contact elected officials in the U.S. Believe it or not, some elected officials actually pay attention to what their constituents say when writing to them.
- LetsGetTechnicl 3y agoThere needs to be a better alternative to credit reports. They only exist because banks and lenders could no longer discriminate on race directly, so they created a roundabout way to discriminate based on "credit score", which happened to be worse for the people the wanted to exclude in the first place.
- mrspurposefull 3y agoMaybe it is designed like this on purpose.
- benlivengood 3y agoThe best outcome is to have minor fraud (someone tried and failed to open an account in your name, or your name+address appears in a data dump somewhere) occur because then you can register a fraud alert and credit freeze in all the agencies which stops a lot of nonsense (random junk mail, risk of actual fraudulent accounts getting established) for a year or so by enforcing extra authentication steps. I wish I could put a permanent fraud alert on my credit accounts, but would probably have to hire a lawyer or something.
- albroland 3y agoCorrect me if I’m wrong, but I’ve signed up for all 3 bureaus and enabled the credit freeze. My understanding, and experience years later, is that it is still frozen. I had to unfreeze a specific one last year for an auto loan. Is there something else I’m missing that’s only temporary?
- fordholes 3y agoIf someone hijacks your account they can unfreeze your credit. It’s easy to hijack accounts.
- albroland 3y agoI understand that, I’m curious if reporting fraud activity helps prevent that in some way like the parent comment seems to suggest, if only for a year.
- benlivengood 3y agoThe fraud alert adds a requirement that potential lenders call a phone number added to the credit file to authorize new loans/accounts, making it significantly less likely that fraud can take place.
- albroland 3y agoTIL! Ty, I'll keep this in mind next time my credit card number is inevitably compromised.
- eh_why_not 3y agoMaybe naive question: if you never create an account on any of the credit bureau websites, would you be less likely to be an identity theft subject?
- darkclouds 3y ago[dead]
- EGreg 3y agoNot as easy on Fox News: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2p0J65FOIgQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2p0J65FOIgQ
- EGreg 3y agoIt's not just Experian. We publish an article every couple years or so with the same content and just the names changed: https://qbix.com/blog/2021/01/25/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-industry-where-this-regularly-happens/ https://qbix.com/blog/2021/01/25/no-way-to-prevent-this-says... https://qbix.com/blog/2023/06/12/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-industry-where-this-regularly-happens-2/ https://qbix.com/blog/2023/06/12/no-way-to-prevent-this-says... And then of course there is this: SIM swapping - someone can just steal your SIM and then get into a lot of accounts https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2023-08-04/teen-gamers-targeted-michael-terpin-in-major-sim-swapping-theft https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2023-08-04/teen-game... Amazon - someone can just take over your account https://www.reddit.com/r/cybersecurity/comments/hsj4x8/my_amazon_account_with_2fa_has_been_hacked_3/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cybersecurity/comments/hsj4x8/my_am... Apple and Amazon together, they can take over ALL YOUR ACCOUNTS (the most terrifying read): https://www.wired.com/2012/08/apple-amazon-mat-honan-hacking/ https://www.wired.com/2012/08/apple-amazon-mat-honan-hacking... I recommend to everyone to use a email alias at gmail or a similar service, different once for every site, instead of your actual email, as the login to Amazon and other services. That way the attackers can't guess your actual login, let alone your password.
- kahnclusions 3y agoAlso, enable the SIM lock on your SIM! This will help prevent someone from receiving verification codes if they stole your SIM card.
- itissid 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29834753 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29834753 I was shocked to learn that last year about the level of detail they had. 1. All your mortgage, credit inquiries and bank account names 2. All your previous addesses and perevious employers 3. Your MONTHLY salary and combined comp per yer going back to 20XX when I came to the US. 4. Dates of employment per employer, bonus, overtime, RSU comp Does Experian and Transunion have that too, and can we block that as well?
- fnordpiglet 3y agoYes, and no. I would note that they are definitely not alone and are much better scrutinized than the other data vendors you’ve never heard of that have much more detailed and person data about you. The credit agencies however offer you a real and valuable service. Without credit history it’s impossible to get credit. It’s also harder to get jobs and to rent. So while it’s creepy, at the very least you gain some demonstrable advantage and benefit. The data brokers and vendors however collect without your permission or knowledge, compile much deeper profiles of you as a human being and what you do and enjoy, along with these other details, and sell it for a profit you never get a share of. Perhaps one day we will have a functioning legislative branch and from it will come a real privacy bill. I’m hopeful it’ll be better informed than the EU ones by taking lessons learned. But I hope for a lot of stuff, like world peace and cures for cancer.
- rileymat2 3y ago“The credit agencies however offer you a real and valuable service. Without credit history it’s impossible to get credit.” I think I generally agree that this is a reasonable service, however the main reason you can’t get credit without a credit history is these services exist that can provide credit history to lenders. It is bizarre to think that loans would not exist without these services.
- judge2020 3y agoLoans did exist before credit, but it was almost always loans from friends/family or by providing a large down payment to the bank you wanted a loan from. You needed to be a known and upstanding member of the community to get a loan for anything substantial. And technically, you can get many loans today without a credit score. For example, there are bank statement mortgage loans, but they have caveats like: - you will go through manual underwriting and will likely need to show records of payment history on any existing debts, including utilities, insurance, rent, etc - They will likely need the contact information for each one of your previous debts to verify it manually - When they run a quote, you will typically be considered at the lowest credit score possible for that program - typically 620 for a conventional loan or 500 for FHA. This means you'll be getting the worst rate possible - You'll likely need a 20% down payment, depending on if any of the PMI automated underwriting systems even give you a quote with such a low "fake" credit score. The lender might ask for more of a down payment depending on their own risk assessment. - The lender (or whoever buys your loan) will report your new account to the bureaus, giving you a score.
- itissid 3y agoFWIW 1. Freeze all your credit with experian, equifax and transunion 2. Opt out of them selling your info: https://consumerprivacy.experian.com/ https://consumerprivacy.experian.com/ https://myprivacy.equifax.com/opt-in-opt-out/personal-info https://myprivacy.equifax.com/opt-in-opt-out/personal-info https://service.transunion.com/dss/ccpa_optout.page https://service.transunion.com/dss/ccpa_optout.page
- archon810 3y agoThank you for the links, just submitted for all 3 with no issues.
- namrog84 3y agoDid this earlier this year. Its super easy to do. And recently had to temporarily unfreeze everything to open an account. Also very easy. All free. 1 of them tries to upsell hard but can do all for free. I think a law passed in 2019 ish forcing it to be free.
- dustingetz 3y agothanks i did this back in 2017 when the leaks happened and it was most definitely not easy and cost money, time to take a new look
- crazypyro 3y agoThe one that tries to upsell hard is so annoying, I can't be arsed to go find it right now, but the other two make it so easy, yet the one that tries to upsell, its like every other click takes you to a "input your credit card" screen.... Seriously annoying. Just had to deal with this for the first time in the last two weeks when someone tried to open a fraudulent account in my name... Interestingly, this happens for the first time in my life 2 months after I had to write down all my personal information to get a 0% APR credit card from a jeweler store... It should be a default frozen system, not a default open system.
- AdamJacobMuller 3y ago
- xvector 3y agoThis makes me feel pure rage. The execs should be thrown in prison and the keys should be thrown away with them. Punish this at the highest levels, severely. The government needs to make examples out of them. What even is the CISO doing? Sitting on her thumbs for a year?
- jackconsidine 3y agoGod this is so frustrating. I saw multiple ads today on TV for Experian's debit card. Wool over the eyes and a brand grab for "the Experian promise" or whatever it was
- tristanb 3y agoI would pay so much money to make these companies go away.
- lyoshida 3y agohello
- gmerc 3y agoThat’s why we need the threat of the corporate death penalty
- teeray 3y agoAnd punishments that involve the personal freedom of the C-suite members.
- snisarenko 3y agoNot a lawyer, but I wonder if Tortious interference Laws can be used by individuals to file civil lawsuits against credit reporting agencies ? In my head I am interpreting the law like this: Credit Reporting Company negligence "interferes" with a person being able to obtain a loan. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortious_interference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortious_interference
- krebsonsecurity 3y agohttps://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/statutes/fair-credit-reporting-act https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/statutes/fair-credi... IANAL either, but it seems the losses suffered from ID fraud are only recoverable via this.
- dllthomas 3y agoIn most contexts, providing false information about someone in a way that harms them is slander or libel. I think we need to revisit whether credit reporting deserves to be exempted from that, and under what circumstances.
- ryandrake 3y agoAbsolutely. We should be able to successfully sue credit rating agencies for monetary damages if they tell a lender false information about us and it causes us to not get a loan or have a higher rate than is warranted. It should not matter whether they know it’s false. The harm happens regardless of whether they were negligent or malicious.
- judge2020 3y agoThis sets a dangerous precedent. If you won, it would apply to all defamation/libel/slander cases, not just credit reporting agencies. News agencies could be sued for saying anything about someone if it later turned out to be false. Defamation laws are already on the brink of unconstitutionality.
- ryandrake 3y agoThis doesn't seem like a bad thing. If I say something untrue about you, and that causes you to suffer damages, you should be able to come after you for those damages, regardless of whether I am a credit rating agency, a journalist, or a regular joe. If I said to your employer, "I'm pretty sure judge2020 is a wanted criminal," and they actually fired you over it, you should be able to successfully sue me for lost wages (or if you sued your company, they should in turn be able to go after me).
- judge2020 3y agoActually, the way they work is "x company told me y person has <this account> with <these details>". For non-celebrities, it is only defamation if it amounts to at least negligence in verifying these facts - i.e. negligent only if they have reasonable knowledge to believe the information is false. When you report to the bureaus that an account is fraudulent, that is effectively giving them notice that the account in question is not actually yours, and by removing it from your report, it's relieving them of the liability of spreading such defaming information in the future.
- bradley13 3y agoStepping back, and looking at the situation as a whole: the real problem is a lack of privacy laws. Banks, businesses and employers should be prohibited from sharing your personal information with third parties. I live in Switzerland, where this is the case. Even the government doesn't get this information. If the government thinks you're cheating on your taxes, they have to use warrants and follow the same procedures as for any other crime. The only financial records accessible are records of legal debt collection actions ("Betreibungen"). Before offering someone credit, you can find out if other people had to sue them to collect. Yet, even with so little information - without credit reporting agencies - everything works just fine. FWIW, due to international pressure (things like FATCA), Swiss law was changed so that banks do report on international customers.
- rz2k 3y agoDo you know how Swiss financial privacy and credit reporting laws compare with countries in the EU? > Around 36 percent of the Swiss own their homes or apartments, the lowest rate in the West and well below the 70 percent average in the European Union, and the 67 percent in the United States. [1] I’m sure there are many factors, but I would be less willing to finance someone’s large purchase without more information about their creditworthiness. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/06/realestate/zurich-switzerland-renting-homes.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/06/realestate/zurich-switzer...
- all2 3y agoWhat do they mean by "own"? Is it deed in hand or debt to a banker?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mamaluigie 3y agoThis is very true. The company that I am at, not going to mention name but just going to say its FAANG, buys data from this company and uses it to allow for better tracking and graph building when we receive experian cookies. The USA does not care about its peoples privacy even though it constantly says that it does lol. If they cracked down on the privacy laws I feel that bank accounts will get affected since in the top 500 of stocks big tech sits on top.
- squeegmeister 3y agoThis happened to me and I ended up calling them to get them to reset my email. It hinged on me answering security questions correctly. Which btw, some of these were also wrong since my identity thief changed some addresses on my credit report. What a fucking mess
- notfed 3y agoWhat even is the next step if everything's been changed?
- munk-a 3y agoThe fact that we haven't nationalized credit reporting absolutely baffles me. These companies have so much power over our lives, are completely unaccountable, and are so incredibly incompetent.
- dools 3y agoYes and then people claim the social credit scoring system in china is a dystopian hellscape. I happen to think it’s far less dystopian that privately run financial credit reporting agencies.
- lwhi 3y agoI think social credit scoring is another level closer to hell.
- Aaargh20318 3y agoIsn't is pretty much the same thing in the US, where financial and social status are more or less equivalent anyway?
- lwhi 3y agoYour score isn't affected if you jay walk, so no.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoYears ago I worked in the industry and I totally agree. Fair Isaac in particular has enormous power as basically the only source of models people use, and they are very opaque.
- silveraxe93 3y agoRight, so as a solution to them having: too much power over our lives, being unaccountable and incompetent. Is: Giving the backing of the state over their actions. Move from being accountable to government to _being_ the government. And the competency of giant public bureaucracies!
- jzl 3y agoYet another reminder that account recovery is the weakest link in the security chain for online accounts. Consider all the work going into new tech such as passkeys -- none of it matters if it's possible for janky account recovery techniques to punch a hole through flawless authentication standards. Unfortunately, companies have come to expect that a large number of their users cannot be expected to reliably store and retrieve their login credentials, whether in a password manager or their head.