10 ms·
Verizon, AT&T customers sue to undo T-Mobile merger
- FactualActuals 3y agoI would prefer to see Verizon or AT&T broken up before T-Mobile is. TMobile wasn't anywhere near as big as Verizon or AT&T pre-Sprint merger. And they still aren't as big.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoMaybe at this point we should be talking about all three major players as opposed to selecting one victim for partition. They all suck hard. They all stand to benefit from TMobile raising prices, because it will give them an excuse to do the same. I am personally tired of the oligopolies in US. Bring in some competition. I thought the free market was a thing here ( or is it just lip service ) .
- FactualActuals 3y agoI 100% back breaking up Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile to create more wireless carriers. More competition is good for everyone.
- nradov 3y agoRealistically the huge capital expenses involved in building reliable nationwide 5G networks make it impossible to have more than three carriers. Breaking up one of the incumbent carriers could only be done along regional lines, so regardless of where you live you wouldn't actually have more choices.
- genewitch 3y agowe don't need 5G nationwide. You (or someone copying and pasting you) have said this two or three times in this thread, and i am not sure why we need to be educated that there's "huge capital expenses" for building out a network that requires orders of magnitude more points of presence than the LTE networks. None of the three actually have unlimited service (at least on post-paid) as an option, so giving us "gigabit cellular" at a huge capital expense doesn't make sense to us, as consumers. The only way it makes sense is if the wireless companies have other customers that are served by having orders of magnitude additional antennas everywhere. And regardless of the arguments against the above, the cellular carriers were given billions and billions of taxpayer money, and tax breaks, and all manner of kid-glove court and legislative decisions in the past 30 years. Consumers are getting screwed from every side possible, more taxes, more fees, and more monthly service charges. but at least the ads load blazing fast while i'm on the train, i guess.
- nradov 3y agoYou seem to be making things up or are just ignorant of the market dynamics. Regardless of your personal limited needs, there is actually huge demand for fast, reliable 5G service nationwide. Customers have voted with their wallets. Moving to 5G with more antennas also allows for more efficient spectrum use in most cases. Spectrum is extremely expensive, and a limiting factor in some areas.
- mynameisvlad 3y agoHow have customers “voted with their wallets” when all of the major players released 5G to all their customers? It’s not like any actual choice was made by the customer.
- jasonlotito 3y ago> we don't need 5G nationwide. I mean, I want 5G when I go travel without needing to pay extra, and that happens right now. I don't want to pay roaming charges just because I fly to Detroit or a small town in Missouri. And history has shown that smaller carriers aren't going to provide that kind of service.
- danaris 3y agoRoaming charges have nothing inherent to do with the presence or absence of 5G. You can have multiple networks with their own 5G hardware that charge roaming fees, and you can have a mixture of 4G and 5G but agreements that no roaming will be charged. If you've got a plan that specifically limits you to 5G if you want to avoid roaming charges, then that's between you and your (likely oligopolistic) carrier.
- autoexec 3y ago> The only way it makes sense is if the wireless companies have other customers that are served by having orders of magnitude additional antennas everywhere. The big reason to push 5G is surveillance. You could always be tracked to within half a mile or so with cell phone towers, but with 5G the cell towers alone can track you within a specific building. mmWave 5G provides location information with sub-meter precision. Telecom companies sell our location data, and with 5G that location data becomes much much more valuable.
- brewdad 3y agoYou have the freedom to choose between 2 identical services and one inferior one. At least where I live, T-Mobile stops working if I head 10 miles west or north. There's even a dead zone half a mile from my home in the middle of a suburb of 100,000 people. Free market has always been lip service in the US.
- taf2 3y agoT-mobile was the main driver for all the user fees against every smb in the US though… IMO they did the most damage to text messaging as a reliable method of reaching a customer…. Telco industry is massive so yes break them all up
- Johnny555 3y agoAs a consumer, I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing, I don't want businesses to find it cheap and easy to reach me by text message.
- swells34 3y agoHonestly, with things being as they are, I think the general sentiment of customers is that they do NOT want customer outreach; or, they want a single, high quality, hand written outreach. Apparently we don't like being brow-beaten into purchasing anymore. Basically, like being treated as something other than cash cows.
- no_wizard 3y agoFor ads, I don't. For customer support however, a verified phone number (that I can look up myself, easily, perhaps as part of a FCC website function, for example) would be a huge win though. I used the Apple Business Chat feature for support for a shipping issue I had recently with Everlane and it was actually amazing. It had its own verified icon, so I knew it wasn't a scam, I could answer when I was able, and they were able to respond as they were able (though, I did find it quite timely, even when I wasn't) and not at all did I have to call someone, or talk talk to a chatbot (as far as I could tell anyway). It was a seamless experience and it got my issue resolved. I personally like this model of customer support. No reason this can't extend to SMS
- no_wizard 3y agoThis, plus break up the broadband carriers (Comcast et. al) and enshrine open access to infrastructure into law, bonus points for net neutrality. That would be honest wins for the US telecom market, and drive lots of competition, while preserving some common sense / fair access to shared infrastructure for all.
- Veliladon 3y agoI don't think we want to see national carriers broken up. If you don't think a mid-size carrier won't make fucking bank on roaming fees you haven't seen what a lot of them did in the '80s. What really needs to be done is the monopolistic elements of cell phone service like spectrum, tower, and backhaul provided at cost by a neutral (state owned) entity and the retail services built on top of reselling that. The barrier to entry on a ground up cell network is almost impossible to surmount without billions in capital but an MVNO that can work on the same cost basis and network as the national chains?
- THENATHE 3y agoI absolutely do. In my area, the Verizon and ATT towers are so unbelievably crowded that we literally cannot use data anywhere in a 20+ mile radius. Maybe if there were 5 companies here instead of 3 we would have more -> less congested towers
- iAMkenough 3y agoYou're asking to rely on a smaller company with fewer spectrum licenses, fewer towers, and therefore spottier coverage.
- toast0 3y agoYou might have more towers, or you might have all 5 companies on the same set of towers. Regardless, I think the spectrum is fully sold, so a challenger network isn't going to have spectrum to use, and if they get spectrum reallocated, existing towers that lose spectrum will be less effective. Edit to add: If your towers are as congested as they seem, the carriers should be aware, and the problem is likely a lack of available tower sites; either because of geographical considerations, site owners don't want towers, or local regulators don't want towers. Additional networks won't really help with that either.
- _ea1k 3y agoI think it is more likely that they'd all outsource tower construction to a small handful of companies and leave congestion roughly equivalent to the current state. TBH, this happens a lot in large stable industries.
- mixdup 3y agoThis is not correct. As of Q3 2023 T-Mobile is number two by subscriber count: * Verizon Wireless: 143.3 million (Q2 2023) * T-Mobile US: 116.7 million (Q2 2023) * AT&T Mobility: 105.2M million (Q2 2023) source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mobile_network_operators_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mobile_network_operato... By stock market cap: * TMUS: $170.51B * VZ: $150.84B * T: $113.22B (of course, VZ and T both have significant businesses outside of wireless so this isn't a super great comparison) Hard to argue that you should break up either of Verizon or AT&T and not T-Mobile by literally any metric, unless you think wireless companies shouldn't also have terrestrial networks
- chiefalchemist 3y agoThe gov broke up "the phone company" once before in the 80s. And here we are again looking to do the same? Sure. Why? But let's pause for a moment and make any other systemic changes necessary not to end up here again so quickly.
- adoxyz 3y agoGood luck with that. I'm pretty sure that it has been the case in 99% of scenarios were consolidation always ended up in a shittier experience for the consumer and employees regardless of the promises the merging companies made. But money talks at the end of the day.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd the alternative was that Sprint would have gone out of business. Sprint hadn’t made money in over a decade
- ewoodrich 3y agoMy brief experience with Sprint a couple years before the T-Mobile merger had basically unusable coverage. Was genuinely surprised how far it had fallen.
- whaleofatw2022 3y agoThey stopped maintenance on some cell sites in anticipation of selling to 'anyone'. Source: used to deal with permits for them in a metro area.
- no_wizard 3y agoexcept Dish network, because they tried multiple times[0] Ultimately they got some assets in the merger though [0]: https://www.cnbc.com/id/100637184 https://www.cnbc.com/id/100637184
- yborg 3y agoAnd T-Mo inherited all that and is now the bottom feeder. It's just a matter of time before one of the other two merges with them to "increase customer value and create jobs".
- rnk 3y ago
- scarface_74 3y agoSprint was losing money for over a decade. There was no world where they would be an ongoing concern and jobs wouldn’t have been loss anyway
- mixdup 3y agoThere is, however, a world where they might've been bought up by Comcast and/or Charter and turned into a real 4th competitor DISH is about 12-24 months from bankruptcy and is losing subscribers, and does not have a true national network The cable companies are just MVNOs riding off Verizon, so that is kind of limited in how much actual competitive pressure they're applying to the market
- scarface_74 3y agoI can see Comcast’s slogan now. “Comcast - bringing all of the customer service you relied on as your cable provider into your pocket”. Besides, it would have been scientifically impossible for Comcast to be a real competitor with Sprints limited spectrum allocation.
- mixdup 3y ago>Besides, it would have been scientifically impossible for Comcast to be a real competitor with Sprints limited spectrum allocation. But, they could've done what they're doing now: use a limited amount of spectrum in areas where their customers are concentrated and offload the rest to their MVNO partner (Verizon) Comcast and Charter both are buying up CBRS licenses and putting up both CBRS radios and outdoor strand mounted wifi hotspots in their wireline service territory. Since that's where 100% of their customers live, that will work to offload the bulk of the traffic they pay Verizon for. For the people who travel outside the service area, they'll just roam onto Verizon For sure it's not the same as VZ, T, and TMUS having a national network that competes for every single wireless customer period, but it would probably be more effective than the zombie DISH out there that supposedly has a network covering 70% of the US population, but a vast majority of their customers are on their MVNO partners in T-Mobile and AT&T.
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoHas this ever worked in the past? I can't recall ever hearing of a merger being forcibly un-done. It seems like if you lie your way through the approval process and everyone's worst predictions come through, the worst that will happen is the US government will slap you with a monetary fine that amounts to less than 1% of your yearly profits.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI thought this was an excellent question. It's easy to argue that the merger shouldn't have been approved, but seems like the plaintiffs want a time machine. Perhaps they're just looking for some sort of financial settlement? Has there ever been a similar suit against a large merger like this in the past, successful or not? I'm really curious how the legal system views these "please undo the past" requests.
- pasttense01 3y agoNo, it's not the plaintiffs. If successful each subscriber might get a few dollars--while the plaintiffs' lawyers would get millions.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoHistorically through divestiture or rescission (the later is effectively impossible to do with a publicly held corporation). Though the Clayton Act has only been infrequently applied in recent decades. https://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4184&context=clr https://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti...
- cogman10 3y ago> I can't recall ever hearing of a merger being forcibly un-done. That's pretty much what antitrust actions are. It's super rare and I can't imagine there's a case here against T-Mobile as both Verizon and AT&T are bigger.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoIt took a bit of searching, but yes! https://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/hospital-doctor-merger-undone-in-ruling https://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/hospital-doctor-m... Claude summary: A U.S. district court judge ruled in favor of the FTC in an antitrust case, ordering St. Luke's to undo its acquisition of the Saltzer Medical Group. The FTC and others alleged the acquisition violated antitrust regulations by lessening competition and potentially increasing healthcare costs. St. Luke's argued the acquisition was vital to achieve healthcare reform goals and maintain business viability. The judge disagreed, saying there are other ways to improve care without violating antitrust laws and risking increased costs. Here is an FTC press release detailing how the un-doing of the merger was carried out: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2017/05/ftc-obtains-court-approval-divestiture-saltzer-medical-group-idaho-based-st-lukes-health-system https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2017/05/...
- taf2 3y agoThe main thing in mind that it did do is cause massive fees and restrictions for businesses to send text messages. The idea is this is to reduce spam. However it has fees and effectively was like this: Hey smb, we see you send notifications to your customers . It’s be a real shame if those messages stopped delivering to your customer . Good thing you can pay us a brand registration fee just $50 and oh for each type of message a recurring $10 fee. It wasn’t a price hike to consumers directly but really was mob style shake down.
- ceejayoz 3y agoYeah. Twilio's process was entirely focused on "campaigns", too, whereas we sent exclusively transactional ones. Very confusing, and we wound up removing our texting features entirely from our app.
- taf2 3y agoIt wasn’t twilio it’s driven by the monopoly organization- the campaign registry.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe registration requiremenet may not be Twilio's doing, but there not being any significant guidance on what transactional senders should do for their particular set of processes is.
- JustARandomGuy 3y agoGlad to see someone else had that problem too - I spent hours reading through the Twilio documentation to try to figure out if transactional sms was allowed because all I kept seeing was campaign registration, campaign fees, and etc all about campaign sms. And if we had to pay the campaign monthly fees even if we sent transactional sms, not campaign. I understand that it's not Twilio's fault, but they desperately need to hire some developer evangelists to write some documentation.
- 3y ago
- HillRat 3y agoNot totally sure this is eventually going to survive a Twiqbal appellate review, and even then it's hard for me to buy the judge's "first step" harm analysis here. I'd love to see the bar for private antitrust suits loosened up, but the fact pattern (Sprint was not a particularly stable company at time of purchase, and no one's alleging any kind of price-fixing, collusion, or monopoly of essential facilities) and legal framework in this case don't feel like a great opportunity to do so. In general, I'm skeptical that we should punish a company, especially one that isn't the largest player in the market, based on (pretextual IMO) actions taken (or not taken) by its competitors. I don't think the merger should have been approved, but once that bell is rung I think the standard for judicial intervention needs to be very high, and I don't think bare market forces apply.
- bobthepanda 3y agoThere is a better case against the airlines since like you said, Sprint was clearly about to go bust had the merger not happened, and there still would’ve been three cell phone companies.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoPre consolidation airlines were not any more stable than Sprint. Even now, JetBlue is about to get merged with Spirit.
- bobthepanda 3y agoJetBlue and Spirit are both profitable. IIRC the deal is more about the fact that they share a common aircraft type, and Airbus’ order backlog is measured in years.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoJetBlue and Spirit do not have profits in recent years: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/JBLU/jetblue-airways/net-income https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/JBLU/jetblue-airwa... https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/SAVE/spirit-airlines/net-income https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/SAVE/spirit-airlin... I am not an expert in airlines, and I am sure there are COVID effects, but it seems like the other domestic airlines have bounced back quicker since they are showing profits. But more importantly, I remember Jetblue wanting to provide a better than average flying experience when the airline started, so I presume the only reason they would want to merge with Spirit, a company who does the exact opposite, is because they are facing financial headwinds.
- dangus 3y agoDid prices go up adjusted for inflation? I don’t think they did. The original iPhone plan didn’t even have unlimited minutes (450 + 5000 night and weekend) and only came with 200 texts, for $60 in 2008 dollars ($90 today). The current T-Mobile “essentials” plan is $60 with no taxes/fees besides sales tax, and it comes with unlimited voice/text with 50GB of data before throttling. I don’t have a history of every single plan ever, but I don’t think T-Mobile ever offered an “unlimited everything” plan for less than $50 or so, pre or post-merger. If you include T-Mobile subsidies like Mint Mobile, there’s an argument to be made that prices have dropped dramatically. The other truth is that Sprint was always cheaper because it was by far the least reliable and desirable carrier. Sprint had the lowest prices and the lowest nationwide subscriber count because their product was inferior. Instead of two great carriers (AT&T/Verizon), one okay carrier (T-Mobile), and one god-awful carrier (Sprint), now we have three great carriers where you are likely to be able to reliably choose any three regardless of where you live. That wasn’t really the case pre-merger. And of course, there’s a great argument for the fact that Sprint would have probably gone bankrupt and been liquidated without its merger.
- slaw 3y agoT-Mobile offered unlimited everything for $100 for 4 lines before merge. Sprint had $25 unlimited bring your own device plan.
- dangus 3y agoT-Mobile charges that exact price for an unlimited plan (essentials).
- withinboredom 3y ago> Did prices go up adjusted for inflation? Under Sprint, I was paying ~$300 per month. > The other truth is that Sprint was always cheaper because it was by far the least reliable and desirable carrier. It depends on where in the country you were (or were traveling overseas). Google-fi was originally built on Sprint infrastructure and (IIRC) used the same overseas billing system. Traveling overseas with them was fantastic and inexpensive. > If you include T-Mobile subsidies like Mint Mobile, there’s an argument to be made that prices have dropped dramatically. My costs per month (same plans, same everything), are now $485. The only thing that has changed is the "fees" I pay monthly. So yeah, costs have gone up to consumers, even for us who didn't change anything and were forced to switch to T-Mobile.
- synergy20 3y agousing mintmobile here and it's reasonably priced, albeit service is so-so, but it's slightly better than tracfone which is part of verizon now, its service is such a waste of time I had to switch. Why should I care about this merge, will it raise my price because of the merge? yes I'm a prepaid phone user.
- fancy_pantser 3y agoAs part of the merger, TMO added very cheap plans called "connect" from $10 to $35/mo with no contract, 5G, and the data limit grows annually. They did this to put regulators at ease about pricing. https://www.whistleout.com/CellPhones/Carriers/T-Mobile https://www.whistleout.com/CellPhones/Carriers/T-Mobile
- pkaye 3y agoMint Mobile uses the T-Mobile network. Did it cause your rates to go up after the merge?
- synergy20 3y agonew to mint mobile, for 5GB-data and unlimited call/text at $15 a month, no contract needed, I'm OK with that and it's actually cheaper than verizon's prepaid.
- bdcravens 3y agoLaughable argument when inflation across the board has been 19% since 2020 when the merger was approved.
- JoshGlazebrook 3y agoI'm not convinced that splitting up any of these wireless companies will better the end consumer. Spectrum is already in short supply, splitting up the already finite resource even more will lead to less bandwidth overall. There also is the capital cost of erecting more towers, more antennas for each of these companies. It's not as simple as "lets split them up and it will all get better".
- epylar 3y agohow about one independent company owns the towers and wholesales bandwidth, and the brand names become resellers/customer service?
- smcin 3y agoAs has been commented, consumers [EDIT: non-rural] do not actually need or want 5G. 4G is adequate for most of their needs. 5G densities are for factory automation, self-driving cars, drones, sensors, superdense urban centers etc.
- JoshGlazebrook 3y agoI'm a consumer that wants 5G. There are many rural consumers that make use of 5G based internet. And the 5G you are speaking of is mmwave. Mid-band 5G is perfectly useable and a significant improvement over LTE. Verizon and T-Mobile push over 1Gb/s over mid-band 5G at the same reach LTE provides and much less latency. mmwave you can get up to 4Gb/s (at short distances). Even more so when Verizon moves rolls out SA 5G in place of the current NSA 5G.
- partiallypro 3y agoSpeak for yourself, I want 5G. Also, I think you're conflating 5G as a whole with the variations like low-band, mid-band, and mmWave. 5G allows carriers to have more customers in a more compact area and give speed benefits. Have you never had just random drops out in a big city or a big concert with 4G? It's enraging. 5G helps fix that problem. 5G can also help people in rural areas that have no access to high-speed internet services, something T-Mobile has been pretty good at pushing.
- jdofaz 3y agoThey had a merger condition that resulted in "Connect by T-Mobile" and I went from paying $50 a month to $15 for roughly the same service.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoI have absolutely no idea what these guys are all talking about. 15 years ago, when I was considering buying a cell phone in high school, I was looking at $40/mo for calls and texts, no data, and all sorts of crazy roaming things. Now I pay $25/mo, get subsidized smart phones, price includes fees and taxes, 50GB of data across the 4 participants in my plan, weird random freebees, etc. etc. And I'm way less price-conscious now than I was then. This lawsuit complains about something that bears no relation to reality, AFAICT. Sounds like AT&T and Verizon people should go to T-Mobile if their service is so expensive.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> Sounds like AT&T and Verizon people should go to T-Mobile if their service is so expensive. If T-Mobile works in their area (or for those with specialty phones, with their phone).
- mweidner 3y agoSame here. There is even a new $10/mo variant that is still plenty for me.
- chmod775 3y agoThat's how T-Mobile got into the US market in the first place - by buying and merging with (failing) network operators a dozen times over and fixing their operations. It's literally their thing.
- anotheruser13 3y agoI would argue T-Mobile didn't necessarily fix the acquired companies' operations. They still use ancient systems built in PowerBuilder to run their customer maintenance and billing. (Disclaimer: used to work in tech support at T-Mobile.)
- chmod775 3y agoFair point, but they must have fixed something, given that in most years they're at least breaking even when the companies they acquired were leaking money.
- jkmcf 3y agoI'm not sure why 1. Companies say they won't raise rates, or that rates will go down 2. People believe them Every year, employees expect raises -- at least a cost of living adjustment, and every year senior management gets huge bonuses and such. Prices for parts and labor for repairs and upgrades will increase, if only because these costs are additive -- things will break, new tech will need supporting, etc... The real question, IMO, is at what frequency do costs rise and by how much? Sure, I'd like to limit the amount of big money transfers to execs, but that's not really possible.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> Attorneys for T-Mobile called the lawsuit “unprecedented,” and said the plaintiffs’ damages were “speculative.” “If plaintiffs are unhappy with Verizon and AT&T, there is a remedy available in the highly competitive market that wireless consumers enjoy today — they should switch to T-Mobile, not sue it,” attorneys for T-Mobile told the court. Okay, chump. That sounds real competitive.
- Osiris 3y agoAn argument could be made here for removing all vertical integration in communication services. Whoever owns the infrastructure shouldn’t also provide the service. They can wholesale out the infrastructure to service providers who then have a lower barrier to entry and increases competition. T-Mobile already has many wholesale providers like Mint Mobile that offer much lower rates than Tmobile directly.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoTmobile owns Mint. >Whoever owns the infrastructure shouldn’t also provide the service. How does it benefit people to have another entity with all of its costs in the chain literally just collecting rent? Tmobile/Verizon/ATT all use different brands like Mint for price segmentation, selling the spectrum at different prices to different populations. And they prioritize traffic based on how important the client is (typically related to how much they pay): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QoS_Class_Identifier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QoS_Class_Identifier https://www.reddit.com/r/NoContract/comments/tn4733/qci_level_explained_2022_march_lower_qci_is_better/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NoContract/comments/tn4733/qci_leve...
- vel0city 3y agoT-Mo only recently bought Mint. They were separate for quite a while. There are still Mobile Virtual Network Operators out there that aren't owned by the big three, but a lot of the more popular ones were gobbled up by the companies operating the networks of those MVNOs.
- mixdup 3y ago>An argument could be made here for removing all vertical integration in communication services. Whoever owns the infrastructure shouldn’t also provide the service. This doesn't make sense as a universal maxim. It does make sense in certain contexts such as government-funded monopolies (the former Bell System) or government-funded expansion efforts (RDOF and BEAD expansion being funded by the United States and separately by the several states) And it also doesn't make sense at certain technological levels. Old telephone lines were a point-to-point set of wires from your house to some central point. Allowing competitors into that central point and using the single set of wires that were dedicated to you, the consumer was very clean and easy to do Unbundling shared media like coaxial lines or radio networks where all of the traffic is intermingled--at what point do you differentiate between the different providers? What are the different providers actually....providing? It's like the deregulated natural gas market in Georgia. The monopoly no longer serves customers directly, but they still own all the pipes in the ground. The 'marketers' buy gas and sell it to us, the consumers, but it's all put into the pipelines at the same place by the old monopoly. It's all just a financial shell game with provider A essentially redeeming so many cubic feet of gas into the system. It's fungible and there's effectively no differentiation between the providers, who all have exactly the same pricing, exactly the same contracts, exactly the same policies. Except now you have half a dozen CEOs, and HR departments, and IT departments, and billing systems all adding costs--costs that are now unregulated since it's "competitive"
- dcdevito 3y ago[dead]
- tzs 3y ago> But Verizon and AT&T customers are also pissed, and are part of a new lawsuit against T-Mobile arguing that the merger raised prices for everybody due to the reduction in overall wireless market competition. But did it reduce competition compared to where we'd be if there had not been a merger? Sprint was on the way out. They were likely to go bankrupt and have their assets sold off to AT&T or Verizon. The result would be 3 national carries (just like we got with the merger) but with T-Mobile a distant third. With the merger, T-Mobile got Sprint's spectrum and became much more viable to many more people as an alternative to Verizon and AT&T. T-Mobile is now the #2 carrier, a little bit ahead of AT&T.
- jboydyhacker 3y agoIf Sprint had gone bankrupt you would have had the same effect- the assets including licenses sold to Tmobile. That said, I don't think Sprint would have gone bankrupt but it def was underinvesting.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIf T-Mobile isn't allowed to buy Sprint then AT&T and Verizon shouldn't be allowed to buy their spectrum. There are any number of companies that would pay money for a cellular network and spectrum allocation, and those companies might have continued to operate a fourth carrier. For example, Sprint's assets could have been sold to Google (which already operates an MVNO), or Comcast, Cisco, Amazon, Samsung, etc. These are all companies that could afford to buy it, and doing so would complement their existing business, but they don't already operate a major wireless carrier and so wouldn't reduce competition.
- mschuster91 3y agoStarting up a mobile carrier is insanely capital expensive. We're seeing this here in Germany with 1&1 as a fourth provider - they got the licenses in 2019, but still have no network of their own up and running, mostly due to issues getting Rakuten OpenRAN deployed, and even the network they're planning will take years and years to get full coverage across Germany (they're planning on a roaming agreement with Vodafone for the meantime). Getting a fourth carrier established from scratch would be a serious financial challenge even for companies like Google and Apple.
- jboydyhacker 3y agoGoing from 4 large competitors to 3 has obviously hurt completion and led to higher prices. Americans tend to pay a lot more for their cell service- especially single lines than other countries. There are mitigating factors such as T-mobile becoming a much more potent competitor with the mid-band spectrum they got from Spectrum. The FCC hoped that Dish would step in to emerge as that 4th have not materialized. We need Dish or someone else to emerge as a major competitor. That said, I don't think reversing the merger is a viable option at this point. We really need a 4th national competitor to merge. Dish has potential but so far it's not made a dent.
- nikolay 3y agoT-Mobile competes with at&t for being the worst carrier on the face of our planet!
- hoistbypetard 3y agoI'm a long-time T-Mobile customer, and I believe, 100%, they're worse since the merger and it's probably at least in some measure related. The merger definitely didn't help me. Once I needed to make a change to my plan (and therefore could no longer remain grandfathered into my old plan) I was paying more for service that has not been as good. We've also got AT&T in our house, and it's far worse, even after the degradation of T-Mobile. I think if the premise behind this lawsuit is that the consolidation did the damage, though, the plaintiffs have quite a row to hoe. Sprint was circling the drain prior to the merger. Can they argue that Sprint just going away and having their assets (like spectrum licenses) sold off to satisfy creditors after they went bankrupt was healthier for competition? That seems highly speculative. I'm not sure what the solution is, and I don't think the merger was good, but I don't see that disallowing it would've improved this particular market.
- bluedevil2k 3y agoThe solution is to provide incentives to new entrants. Discounts on spectrum purchases or reserving certain bands for a separate auction only for new entrants. It’s done regularly in other countries where they’ve already figured out that 4 mobile phone providers seems to be the magic number.
- finleymedia 3y ago"T-Mobile’s reddit forums are filled with employees saying the disruptive spirit of the company has been dead since the merger." This argument has less to do with the merger and more to do with AT&T's 3 Billion in cash T-Mo (Deutsche Telekom) received when AT&T failed to buy them is now gone. It's a little easier to be disruptive when you are spending someone else's money.
- spandextwins 3y agoIt's all about the bands and frequencies.
- tahoeskibum 3y agoAs a consumer, the new T-mobile has been great. I was finally able to switch away from Verizon, as their prices are cheaper, and the 5G network equally good.
- maxerickson 3y agoYeah the noticeable difference for me has been better coverage.
- zw123456 3y agoPeople forget that Verizon and AT&T are the result of multiple mergers as well. Airtouch + Bell Atlantic Mobile + a bunch of little ones = Verizon Cellular One + Southern Bell + a bunch of little ones = AT&T The mistake was thinking to counter those two giant companies by making a 3rd giant company. Perhaps it would have been better to have not allowed the first two in the first place? Just a thought to ponder.
- mike503 3y agoMake them a utility. Just like wired internet should be now too.