7 ms·
What China's slow-motion real estate crisis means for the global economy
- ianai 3y ago“There’s going to be less steel demand. There’s going to be less cement being used — less glass, for example. That impacts within China heavy industrial areas that really produce these raw materials.” No cocktail party can go on infinitely apparently. Some really interesting and profound dynamics at play here.
- thghtihadanacct 3y agoI see this as 'steel is going to be affordable again'
- powerapple 3y agono with the wars going on right now...
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoHeard that yesterday in comments too. I don't have any particular insight. But this kind of first order viewpoint feels reductionist. Steel & other construction suppliers have been ongoing investments, distributed wide & far across the world. Many of these suppliers & adjunct industries might not make it demand dries up too quickly. It's hard to predict what higher order effects really are.
- downrightmike 3y agoAll those industries have been on a debt restructuring cycle. They died a long time ago, this point just waiting for the Zombie to rot to dust
- alephnerd 3y agoIt's already had spillover in Canada with the layoffs and restructuring at Scotiabank [0]. We'll probably see something similar to the late 80s and early 90s when foreign assets owned by Japanese companies and funds were sold off to better balance their sheets. It'll probably be somewhat similar to the experience Japan, SK, Malaysia, and Thailand had in the 90s imo. China today is in a similar boat to SK, Malaysia, and Thailand back then anyhow. With the right leadership and investment in human capital, it can pull an SK, else it's "stuck" like Thailand (not really a bad thing - the average Thai in 2023 has a better QoL than the average Chinese in 2023). [0] - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-10-18/scotiabank-to-lay-off-3-of-workforce-take-432-million-charge?embedded-checkout=true https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-10-18/scotiaban...
- chii 3y ago> With the right leadership and investment in human capital, it can pull an SK or it uses the temporary economic might to coerce other countries to allow them to solidify their current advantage, as the first step in empire building?
- alephnerd 3y ago> as the first step in empire building Highly unlikely because the world of Infrastructure Development Financing (the closest thing to empire building without guns and soldiers) is a highly competitive one. The American, EU, Australian, and Japanese funds get the best projects, and the remaining ones (mostly in LDCs) go to upstarts in the space like China, Korea, Taiwan, Israel, Türkiye, Saudi, UAE, South Africa, India, Qatar, Thailand, Pakistan, Indonesia, Egypt, Russia, Mexico, and Brazil. Most OBOR projects failed because they were projects most other lenders like the ADB or WB wouldn't touch because of their risk profile. There's a reason why when SK was in a similar position as China today in the 90s and 2000s, they went all in on investing in China and ASEAN. Hell, the Japanese did the same thing in South Korea in the 70s and 80s. China doesn't really have a similar option. Most of the stable ASEAN members (Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia, Philippines) prefer Japanese, Korean, or Singaporean FDI, and the only other China-esque market for China to potentially invest in is India, which has made operating a Chinese owned subsidiary a living hell while rolling a red carpet to Japanese, French, Singaporean, Gulf (excluding Qatar), American, and Israeli investors.
- monero-xmr 3y agoThere has been a general vibe that America's infrastructure is old and decrepit. An alternative way to look at it is the USA doesn't build something until it's needed, and you don't know it's needed until people are complaining that the existing situation is bad. Additionally, every piece of infrastructure that is built needs to be maintained or it will decay. Sure, not every airport in America is shiny and new, but if you can land there safely then it is in good working order. Why build a new one just to one-up a communist dictatorship, wasting tax dollars? In China there are giant airports with barely any traffic to justify their existence https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2023-07-11/china-s-hidden-debt-problem-laid-bare-in-city-s-empty-housing-unfinished-roads https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2023-07-11/china-s-h... This is the fundamental problem with centrally planned economies. The malinvestment is insanely high, and while building new airports and high-speed rail gooses the GDP for a bit and makes for great politician PR, if no one actually needs this stuff then it's simply a huge waste of money. White Elephants will be stampeding all over China in the coming years.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoIt really feels like we can't have nice things anymore. Seattle goes way over budget and time on all its transit projects, to the point that it just feels like we can't get anything done anymore. In contrast, China builds subways and rail lines for a reasonable price, even if they aren't always needed. My wife's hometown (Chenzhou Hunan, 4.5 million, although just 1 million urban) just got an airport, so no more flights to Changsha or Guangzhou and then a 1-2 hour HSR connection into the city. I guess it seems a bit pointless, because HSR made the lack of an airport completely reasonable, but what do I know. But there are definitely enough people to justify an airport, like that airport in Guizhou...it serves 6.6 million people...so in 10 years they might think they didn't build it big enough.
- downrightmike 3y agoPesky land rights owned by individuals can muck things up
- Belopolye 3y ago
- mensetmanusman 3y agoI still can’t believe they will lose a few hundred million people by 2100. It’s crazy to think of the amount of empty houses/towns there will be.
- athinggoingon 3y agoTry 600 million. It's supposed to shrink by half.
- incomingpain 3y agoImagine you are China where you leveraged your economy(>350%) on the idea that you're going to be on top of the new world order. but the reserve currency never moves. Worse yet, you find out that your existence is false. You exist so long as the USA lets you exist. You only have power because of cheap labour, but that isn't true anymore. Chinese labour is more expensive then French labour. Time to move to Worse yet, Obama and Trump played the same playbook and they decided you are no longer needed. You see the UN calling you Nazis, committing genocide over the uiguyrs. They falsely saw themselves as surrounded, about to be invaded, but the truth of the matter is that the West withdrew. The complete opposite. Now the PLA is holding a bag of expensive equipment and they don't realize it's not needed, only making the leverage problem worse. Naturally, real estate is first to collapse. You also have a pretty bad incel problem in China. They killed their daughters... everytime in history this happened, the country sent their incels to die in war. Cant keep them at home. So who will it be that China will be going to war with? It's India.