33 ms·
Valve says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS not happening, there aren't enough players
- russelg 3y agoHow has no one yet mentioned that Dota 2 (also running on the Source 2 engine) has a completely playable Mac build? I play Dota from time to time on my M1 Max Macbook Pro and it runs more than fine. It's very odd the Dota team can justify it but the CS team can't.
- Shekelphile 3y agoI think it's more about not wanting to port the steam client to arm than it is about porting the game. There's source engine games ported to ppc and arm platforms after all. > I play Dota from time to time on my M1 Max Macbook Pro and it runs more than fine. Dota on macOS doesn't ship an arm binary and uses moltenVK to translate graphics api calls, it's on borrowed time if valve doesn't want to ship proper binaries as rosetta isn't gonna exist in a few years.
- russelg 3y agoThey still keep it updated and even fix macOS specific bugs so I'd hope they'd keep that up. But yeah, I guess once Rosetta goes they'll probably just throw the towel in.
- Shekelphile 3y agoI hope they don't. Source is already pretty much isa agnostic, it isn't difficult at all for them to set up the infrastructure to ship universal binaries for macOS and it just seems to be a power play on Valve's part.
- whalesalad 3y agoThe irony is that the steam client is basically a web app container. It’s high time they invest in making steam a universal cross platform and cross architecture app. They’ve gotten by with a mediocre app for a really really long time.
- Shekelphile 3y agoI miss the old flat style steam had when I was a kid - the simple vgui toolkit used in all their games of the era was simple and responsive. Now they have the same 2003 vgui elements in the app still but entire sections of the app have been redesigned with some CEF based web view thing that randomly likes to turn into a nonresponsive black blob on the screen until you force kill and restart or simply not appear on the screen at all.
- svennidal 3y agoNow I just need to access a windows computer to sell my skins and never buy anything valve related again.
- Pr0ject217 3y agoThe feeling I get when I run into cool software that only runs on Mac.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI saw the announcement and was quite excited as I haven't played CS for a long time, and the new version looks great. I was looking forward to playing it on my speedy (last gen Intel) Mac...but I guess that's not happening. I doubt it will run better than mud on my Windows box, and I don't feel like buying a new computer just to run one game.
- cushpush 3y agoSure, just refund all the in-game purchases from mac players and we'll call it even.
- scubadude 3y agoWhen you can't upgrade the video driver until Apple provide you with a new one, MacOS was never going to be even a half-serious gaming platform.
- danielEM 3y agoA price of keeping that ecosystem closed and pricey.
- ed_mercer 3y agoI wonder if Apple would have sponsored CS2 development for Mac. Doesn’t seem like they even asked.
- rldjbpin 3y agobefore i spent thousands of hours in it, i first saw and played csgo on a friend's macbook pro. given how much they are lagging behind target on key features of the old game, i can understand why they decided this (for now). even their own darling platform (linux by proxy) is not currently well-supported. EDIT: forgot about MacOS and Vulkan.
- WentFullRetard 3y ago[dead]
- highwaylights 3y agoPart of this is probably related to Apple's pushing gaming a little harder with Sonoma. The pool of players is so small because gaming has been neglected on the Mac for so long, while tech like Vulkan that might have opened the possibility of gaming on a Mac has been blocked entirely. Valve is probably spot on in saying it's not worth the effort for the users they'll pick up right now. That said, now that Apple is at least presenting as if they're trying to change this, that user base could grow over time. The problem is that in the shadow of Epic's big battle with Apple over App Store rules, it would make sense that Valve is wanting to just NOPE right out of this arrangement. Why help build gaming on the Mac when the balance of evidence suggests it's just going to be used to drive you off the platform? It presents a risk to a chunk of Steam's install base for little to no benefit. I'm honestly pleasantly surprised macOS still gets the support it does by Unreal engine, it would be really easy for Epic to deprecate macOS support entirely (albeit not in the consumer's interest).
- 0dayz 3y agoCan't really blame Valve here, the issue at hand is that Apple have deliberately choosen to shun games and believe that they can wall garden even the graphics stack. When in reality it's just more cost for the studio to port over and debug.
- xinayder 3y agoFYI: Valve had macOS binaries and scripts for CS2 since the Limited Test. They were constantly updating the depot with macOS files and when it finally released to the public, a few weeks ago, they decided to sack macOS support. Can't totally blame them for their decision but the developers that worked on the macOS port either wasted their time or they figured out it wasn't worth the effort with all the restrictions Apple has on their OS.
- Aeroi 3y agoI think this is laughable. The excuse that "there aren't enough players" is wild, because by all metrics Counter-Strike and CS2 is one of the largest multiplayer games of all time. Currently #1 with over 1,200,000 active concurrent users on Steam by a margin of 2x over the closest game as I write this. So if a game that is consistently in the Top 5 most played games by concurrent users (For the last 20 years) doesn't have enough to support MacOS. What does?
- zaptrem 3y agoIf their ~1% figure is accurate, 10-12,000 Mac DAUs is significant at that scale.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- leetharris 3y agoI can empathize with giving up a platform that has little ROI. As a Mac-only computer gamer (after 30+years of PC gaming) it still makes me sad to see it abandoned. I can say that the game seems to run fine on Crossover. GeForce Now is also a great option if you're on Ethernet on great Internet.
- nicolaslem 3y ago> GeForce Now is also a great option if you're on Ethernet on great Internet. It's a competitive shooter, the kind of game people play at the lowest settings to reach 400 fps. I doubt many CS players will tolerate the added latency of streaming.
- RockRobotRock 3y agoThe way the camera works in FPS really strains the compression. It works way better for games with a top down camera. let me know if i'm wrong, this has just been my hunch.
- dagmx 3y agoAnything with low variability frame to frame will do better with compression.
- rjst01 3y agoI don't think the situation is as bad as it's made out to be. Yeah, you're not gonna get the latest triple-A looter shooter 3000. I've never enjoyed those. It may be a small minority, but enough games still get native ports that when I'm travelling with only my mac I'm never short of things to play.
- gehwartzen 3y agoNot enough games on mac > So nobody buys macs to games > So no players on Mac > So games not made for mac Sad little loop :(
- salil999 3y agoApple wasn't also the most helpful when it came to motivating developers to port their games over. 30% fee for apps and no native development until 2014 with Metal. Windows had DirectX for a much longer time.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> 30% fee for apps You can just skip the app store, can't you?
- wahnfrieden 3y agonever mind
- KennyBlanken 3y agoYou're confusing code signing (which only requires a developer account) with store publishing. I don't have a single store-installed app on my mac and I only get warnings (once) from 1-2 open source apps whose developers don't code-sign.
- qwytw 3y agoSteam games don't have scary dialogs. Neither do apps distributed directly by third parties as long as they are signed etc. (you just need the $100/300 per year apple dev. account for that).
- easeout 3y agoYes, especially if you're Valve and you operate the preeminent game store.
- Traubenfuchs 3y agoIt would be very interesting to see how many players of Baldurs Gate 3 were/are on mac, it is one of the blockbuster games of the decade after all. It runs flawlessly and mostly on ultra settings on a M1 max. Instantly swiping between a browser and the fullscreen game without flickering is just as good as it gets, regarding gaming user experience.
- zaptrem 3y agoI'm not sure I'd call a (very very good) turn-based RPG a blockbuster game of the decade when titles like Fortnite and Minecraft exist with orders of magnitude more players from a much wider range of demographics.
- _cenw 3y agoYour stats would be off, because the macOS build took another 2 months to move out of early access. I do play on my Mac now, but I also did on my Windows Handheld before due to availability.
- denzlwashington 3y agoJust use GeForceNow, it is really good if you have a mac.
- Insanity 3y agoAs far as I know that does constrain you in e.g mod usage. If you stream it from the cloud you can’t mess with the game files. (I accept that this might nowadays make me a minority, although in games like GTA I think the modding community is pretty active still)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- romanovcode 3y agoNoticeable input delay if you are used to PC gaming yourself.
- vachina 3y agoit is really good if you live next to a data center, and don’t mind paying money every month to maintain the right to play the games you bought.
- kube-system 3y agoHave you tried to play CS on GeForce Now? I have, the added latency makes it impossible to be competitive with anyone of even a moderate skill. It's probably great for other types of games where reaction times are not critical, but for competitive FPS esports titles, it's a nonstarter.
- Insanity 3y agoThe only reason I still have a windows desktop is to play games at this point. Not a top of the line rig as I’m not too fuzzed about the graphics. I do wish I could go mac only - my desk would definitely look tidier. But I don’t see it happening soon.
- wand3r 3y agoExactly. I am a casual gamer at best. I am an Apple power user. I lucked into a gaming PC a couple weeks ago for $50 at a thrift store. So I have a PC just for gaming. I think non MS users who game probably have the same. Likely a dual boot Linux/MS computer. It is kind of annoying you can't game on Macs, however thats just how things are. Cars handle better than Trucks, and Trucks can haul more than cars. There is a lot of overlap in what they can do, but ultimately they have different specialties. That said, my experience with Microsoft from a long time *nix users has been pretty horrible. I do think a lot of this is Microsoft, but a lot of it is going from being a poweruser to being a total novice is quite annoying.
- sleepybrett 3y agoI'm also a primary mac user and have been almost my entire life. I have a pc that literally does nothing but play games, it's a stupid expense at this point. I may not bother to buy another to replace this one when it's finally to slow to bother with. May be a console life for me.
- hotnfresh 3y agoSteam Deck is OK. Probably too expensive if you're not gonna play it as a portable ever, but not awful. The desktop experience is a jank-fest (the usual amount of Linux desktop jank, plus a whole pile more for some reason) but it's pretty good, actually, as long as you avoid desktop mode and stay in the Steam experience as much as possible. It is too underpowered to do much gaming at 1080p (let alone 4k) except older games, but handles its native ~720p pretty well. You have to go into desktop mode to get higher res than that (on an external monitor), but you'll only want to do that for games that are both older (so that it can run them at tolerable frame rates at 1080p) and that really need the extra pixels, anyway. The Proton stuff works quite well, most things that run well on modern Windows in widescreen without a bunch of hand-ini-editing config tweaks or whatever work fine on the Steam Deck without much pain. Decent option if you catch it on sale. Depends on what you play, though. Some folks find its mouse emulation touchpad thingy decent, but I found it a fun-killing chore for any kind of pointy-clicky-draggy games (Paradox, various tactical war games). But, you can play those games docked with keyboard & mouse and they're ok. It's a hell of an emulation system for older console games....
- gclawes 3y agoHow much of what was done with Proton for linux is transferrable to macOS?
- kcb 3y agoThe whole reason Proton came into existence is because of very efficient translation layers from DirectX to Vulkan, DXVK and VKD3D. WINE was compatible and performant before the Vulkan translation layers but lacked modern DirectX version support to make it viable for gaming. So without Vulkan support from Apple, Proton is not really transferrable at all.
- Moomoomoo309 3y agoThe performance hit from Rosetta makes it tough, and Proton hasn't worked on MacOS since before the first public release (before that, it actually did). It's not worth the effort for a platform that routinely snubs the gaming sector.
- zaptrem 3y agoI disagree. I was running Overwatch 2 (via patched CrossOver) on my M1 Pro MBP over the summer at ~110FPS at ~900p.
- dathinab 3y agoidk. about performance the list of steam games which even with a huge perf. hit would still run quite well on modern macs is quite long tbh. but I agree that it's not worth putting in the effort to make it work
- dathinab 3y agoit's complicated for many (probably most) ideas and concepts you probably could apply them to macOs with just a few tweaks but code reuse will be much more tricky in multiple ways. 1st while both macOs and desktop Linux are unixy what proton has to interact with is much more OS specific for quite a bunch or parts; 2nd when proton devs run into some issue with linux OS services/tooling they can (and have) fix the problem upstream, they can't with macOs; 3rd you can do much more "unusual" things with linux, some of them might matter for proton most importantly proton for mac would be either way a non small money investment and that investment has to pay of in some form if you only look at game sails I would be surprised if is worth it for either mac or Linux I my opinion what Valve gains from proton is not earning more money through Linux game sales but a "safety net". Windows has shown that if they can they would (at least for non enterprise licenses) love to lock down Windows similar to iOS, e.g. allow only their app store and and not allow 3rd party stores on their store. While the last time they tried that it didn't work out and EU is pushing regulations to reduce how much such app stores can be locked down this is still a _sever_ risk for Valve. So by making large parts of their library "good enough" usable on Linux they always have a way out by providing a in-between of a console and a open Linux desktop which people can run on their hardware or for which they provide hardware ... like the Steam Deck (which is a bit different focused as a handheld but Windows is also not locked down at this moment in time). As a bonus the know-how and code stack they are building allows them to fan out in more areas even if Windows never get's locked down. E.g. they could create an actual console os with a immutable locked Linux core but then use stuff like flatpack-like container technology to still allow using it like a fully free Linux desktop for most use-cases but due to it being locked down at the core they can promise copyright protection and anti-cheat similar to a console to investors and game (weather that is ethical good is another question unrelated to this argument.) So proton provides value in form of "potential" and "safety net". But proton for macOs doesn't have any of this benefits. More so then windows macOs is increasingly getting more locked down and you could call Apple "king of the walled garden business strategy". So for proton for macOS it has to be clearly profitable, which it doesn't seem to be. And while Apples seems to wanting to get back into gaming on desktop slowly, they also tend to have quite a strong preference for software being developed with their proprietary tools. So while it might seem a good idea for apple to cooperate with Valve short term, long term I would speculate they wouldn't even like something like proton, because that can diverge sells away from their app store and isn't under their control but (Steam being) a part of the "experience" people might start to value a lot.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- afavour 3y agoThey're probably right but it does feel like a negative feedback loop. I used to have an Intel MacBook, during COVID I had a blast playing COD: Warzone with friends while in isolation. But then I got an M1 Mac and that door closed. If it were possible to play I'd probably still do it from time to time. That said, I probably wouldn't be spending enough on battle passes/whatever to make it worth their time. To be cynical, I wonder if it's less the total number of Mac players and more the amount of money earned from those players. Stands to reason anyone that didn't buy a specialized gaming rig is going to be more of a casual player.
- chuckwnelson 3y agoYou may be interested in Wineskin for M1/M2 Macs. I use this to play some old school games on my 2023 M2 Max Mac. https://github.com/Gcenx/WineskinServer https://github.com/Gcenx/WineskinServer
- afavour 3y agoLooks cool but unfortunately the only games I'd be really interested to play are the more modern ones my friends are playing, my understanding is the copy protection etc always gets tripped up by Wine.
- nani8ot 3y agoThanks to Valve investing a ton into proton (wine, dxvk, vkd3d) copy protection are usually no longer an issue. The problem is kernel-level anti cheat like EAC, BattleEye, Vanguard and EA's AC. The first two work flawlessly (on Linux) if the developer enables support for Linux (Halo, Apex Legends).
- littlestymaar 3y agoOh, Apex is working on Linux now?!
- gattilorenz 3y ago
- bakugo 3y agoNo point in releasing and maintaining games for a platform that is actively hostile towards them. Even disregarding the whole Vulkan/Metal situation, Apple's complete disregard for backwards compatibility means any game that does get ported will probably just stop working in a year or two if it's not updated, so why bother?
- pjmlp 3y agoJust like a games console, they should be used to it.
- CJefferson 3y agoGames consoles don't release OS updates which delete a chunk of old APIs and break your game -- once you've released for a console, you can generally assume the game will work on that console forever.
- pjmlp 3y agoLikewise, you are free not to update the OS, it is the same as not buying another console.
- bakugo 3y agoNo, it's not the same at all... losing software compatibility because you installed an OS update and buying an entirely new piece of hardware that never had compatibility with your software are entirely different and unrelated things.
- Macha 3y agoConsoles give 6-8 years of guaranteed compatibility for a single console life cycle, and often extend that compatibility for another 6-8 years for the next version of the console. Is there any game that does not run on the console hardware that was current at the time the game was shipped that now doesn't because of OS updates?
- bluSCALE4 3y agoThis seems like a mistake if CS2 can run on stock M1's.
- vachina 3y ago[flagged]
- chrisco255 3y agoI play the full Blizzard suite on my Mac. It's nice that some game makers support the platform.
- sleepybrett 3y ago... how exactly are you playing diablo 4? Blizzard did not ship osx support for it. Another in a long line of 'The Blizzard you loved is dead.'
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoThe same way Steam Deck users do, with Wine based tools https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wcMwHh8XP0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wcMwHh8XP0
- sleepybrett 3y agoI've done this on my steamdeck as well, but knowing how shitty blizzards 'warden' is it seems like a risk. However that doesn't change my point, the op said: > I play the full Blizzard suite on my Mac. It's nice that some game makers support the platform. I'm simply pointing out that that blizzard is gone, diablo4 is not native on the mac.
- BakaRakuda 3y agoMac computers are more capable than they have been for a long time, if ever. All it takes is for a developer to have the will to make it work on Mac. Recent game releases for Mac include: - Lies of P - Baldurs Gate 3 Soon - Resident Evil 4 Slightly older release - Resident Evil Village Maybe Valve just can't hack it? They also flamed out on their VR support a few years back, only releasing a few betas before they gave up and cancelled the whole thing.
- 3y ago
- lizardking 3y agoThis is a chicken and egg problem. I've been playing Baldur's Gate 3 on my M1 Macbook pro, it's been a fantastic experience. The only reason I keep my Qindows machine around at this point is for the occasional game session. I've talked to many mac users over the years who were gamers but were marooned on consoles. So many unique experiences on PC that either can't be found on console or are objectively worse without a mouse and keyboard. Seems like money on the table waiting to be picked up.
- justinclift 3y agoAnyone know if Steam has ARM64 support? If so, then dual booting a mac into Linux for gaming purposes might be a workable option at some point.
- _cenw 3y agoSteam doesn't even have ARM64 support on Windows or macOS. And neither do most games.
- justinclift 3y agoDamn. Oh well. :/
- ThatPlayer 3y agoSteam doesn't even have a native x86_64-only Linux version, you still need x86 runtimes. Though it is possible to use FEX-EMU to run it on Linux on a Mac: https://youtu.be/_tG3kfgqPhc https://youtu.be/_tG3kfgqPhc
- justinclift 3y agoThat's a 7 and a half hour video. Is there any particular piece of it that's relevant, or "just watch the whole thing"? ;)
- ThatPlayer 3y ago
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoI feel for the Mac users in spirit: Linux users have often received the same answer ("There aren't enough Linux buyers of this game to justify the development/support costs of porting."). OTOH, Counter-Strike 2 actually has a native Linux build even without Proton, so, this particular title isn't a problem for us.
- HansHamster 3y agoIt would be weird for Valve not to support Linux, given that the Steam Deck runs it. They could of course use Proton to run it, but AFAIR (most of(?)) the previous CS versions also had native Linux support. (Not sure about Mac support in the previous releases?)
- milesvp 3y agoIt would also be weird to me for them to not have linux ports of their engines after blogging about the performance and bug squashing benefits of doing so for previous game engines.
- Matheus_17 3y agoI would be interested to read about that, could you post the source on it?
- milesvp 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4327908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4327908 This is one of the threads I remember reading about this. The blog seems to be offline, but you might find some luck with the wayback machine. https://web.archive.org/web/20190323200813/http://blogs.valvesoftware.com/linux/ https://web.archive.org/web/20190323200813/http://blogs.valv... In any event, around this time they found a lot of optimizations porting to linux that they then back ported to the windows client. This was 10 years ago, so the zeitgeist in the company may have changed, but I've certainly taken to heart the idea that you should be cross compiling to at least one different target whenever you can to improve your engineering. The earlier you start the cheaper the cost of doing so as well. (This isn't the only company doing so at the time talking about gains of cross compilation either, and not just games)
- nick_ 3y agoI use https://github.com/Whisky-App/Whisky https://github.com/Whisky-App/Whisky to play CS2 on my M1 Mac. It runs really well if you change the launch options to `-nojoy`, turn on vsync (or else it may crash every couple minutes), and can bear some audio glitches.
- cptcobalt 3y ago> Whisky is built on top of CrossOver 22.1.1, and Apple's own Game Porting Toolkit. Oh, this is so sick—I didn't know that anything that used the Game Porting Toolkit as something better than a developer tool existed yet. I'm going to make use of this. I have a M2 Pro Mac Studio as my primary computer, and I tend to use steam's streaming from my gaming PC to my mac for casual gaming, but there are sometimes I just want to natively run a game that isn't supported in macOS or streams quite poorly with Steam's streaming. (Why is my setup the way that it is? My gaming PC is in the garage—primarily to have a big VR playspace—and on early mornings it can just be too cold in there.)
- dansalvato 3y agoThank you for the `-nojoy` suggestion, that seems to make it playable on CrossOver as well. It's a shame that Valve made this decision, because Apple is pushing hard to make a gaming comeback on Mac (hence Game Porting Toolkit), so we might see those numbers change in the next few years.
- TinkersW 3y ago
- SigmundA 3y agoWas really hoping M series would open up Mac gaming, but definitely a chicken and egg situation along with Apple not really doing much to help. Still hoping things get better with game port toolkit and Mac Gpu getting better every generation. For now the best way to game on a Mac IMO is Sunshine/Moonlight and just run a gaming PC somewhere in the house, works perfect.
- pjmlp 3y agoThere are enough games to play, https://www.macgamerhq.com/opinion/macos-metal-games/ https://www.macgamerhq.com/opinion/macos-metal-games/
- dansalvato 3y ago> with Apple not really doing much to help. I think Apple is starting to push hard to get into the gaming market. You already mentioned Game Porting Toolkit as an example, but they have been regularly giving the floor to AAA game studios during Apple's big keynote presentations. Notably, Capcom is bringing RE4 Remake to Apple devices, following Resident Evil Village. Death Stranding is also getting a macOS port soon. If I had to guess, I think Apple is actually going out of their way to financially incentivize these companies to port their games to Mac, even if sales are low (e.g. paying them to port the game). Throwing money at it may be a good way for them to get out of the chicken and egg problem.
- pjmlp 3y agoThere are enough engines with Metal support, including Unreal and Unity, regardless of what Valve thinks.
- kcb 3y agoAnd yet countless PC games built in those engines still don't ship with Mac support.
- red_trumpet 3y agoWhat does this have to do with engines? AFAIK, Valve developed their own engine "Source 2". At the end the article contains > Regardless of numbers, one of the reasons Valve is reluctant to develop CS2 for Mac is that Apple devices do not provide native support for the Vulkan API that the game is based on. Vulkan was designed to succeed OpenGL and address some of the latter's shortcomings, and while there is an open-source library called MoltenVK that provides a Vulkan implementation on top of Apple's Metal graphics API, it still lacks some of Vulkan's advanced features.
- russelg 3y agoValve successfully use MoltenVK (they even acquired it) to run Dota 2 on macOS, which also works on Apple Silicon, albeit through Rosetta.
- pjmlp 3y agoIf you bothered to read what you posted, they don't want to support Metal natively like the other engines.
- mcpackieh 3y agoValve isn't saying there is some technical problem with Metal that prevents game engines from using it, so how are other game engines supporting it relevant? Valve isn't supporting it because too few of their customers use Macs for it to be worth it to Valve. It may be worth it to other engine developers, or maybe those other engine developers are wasting their time/money, but in either case that has nothing to do with it not being worthwhile for Valve. Valve publishes the relevant statistic btw. They have less Mac customers than Linux. Mac users are fringe and just aren't very relevant to Valve.
- thefz 3y agoThe current situation of gaming with Apple computers makes complete sense. Most of the people dedicated to playing games on their computer will at least want to upgrade the occasional part from time to time to keep up, which is impossible when everything is soldered together. It simply has never been a decent platform for games, bar some mobile ports, due to its closeness.
- _cenw 3y agoThat's a weird argument. The M1 is quite capable and can keep or or even outperform many current gaming value builds. And eSports titles generally do not change their minimum requirements too much to keep their entire audience engaged and FPS high. Not to speak of Intel rarely to never reusing the same socket anymore and the switch to AM5/DDR5 specifically making incremental updates unavailable to most people.
- Zetobal 3y agoIntel and AMD have multi generation sockets both newest generations can run on ddr4/5 and for most the bottleneck is still their GPU... stop inventing.
- _cenw 3y agoIntel has Sockets for one tick/tock generation. AMD is much better there, but especially right now AM4 is not exactly futureproof and AM5 is still quite expensive. And which component bottlenecks is always relative to your resolution.
- ansible 3y ago> The M1 is quite capable and can keep or or even outperform many current gaming value builds. At the same price? I would be surprised if that is the case. You can get a used M1 Mac Mini for around $300 on eBay. For that money, you can get a used i5 business desktop and a new low-profile RX 6400 for about that. At that price point, you'll see much better visuals and framerate for most games on the Windows PC (or you could run Linux). The PC owner can then later buy a better desktop system and put the same GPU in it. And later still the PC user can upgrade the GPU. With the M1 Mini, that's basically it, and if you want to upgrade anything, you are buying a completely different system.
- criddell 3y agoAre those older online games even playable anymore? A few years ago I listened to a podcast[1] where they described playing Team Fortress 2 - spawn, get killed by a bot. Spawn, get killed by a bot. [1]: https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/emh36dn https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/emh36dn
- dharmab 3y ago...yes? I don't know what that podcast is on about. These games are very popular and still updated. TF2 was n particular has been updated several times in the past few weeks (https://www.teamfortress.com/?tab=updates https://www.teamfortress.com/?tab=updates) and has a healthy player count (https://steamcharts.com/app/440 https://steamcharts.com/app/440).
- enragedcacti 3y agoThe situation has been fixed but it was a pretty big issue for multiple years and took a coordinated outcry from players to get Valve to properly address it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Team_Fortress_2#Bot_accounts_and_%22#SaveTF2%22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Team_Fortress_2#Bot_accounts_a...
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agoApple insists on making everything difficult. No support of opengl or vulkan. You can use moltenVK, but you own the issues and bugs that arise from that layer, get fucked. No openXR on their upcoming headset either. The fun doesn't stop there in Apple Land if you're interested in hobbyist development, you get obnoxious code signing requirements, you can only deploy a few iOS app to the devices you paid for per week, and they only last a while before they cease working and you have to redeploy them. I'm glad Valve isn't wasting their time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wronglebowski 3y ago100% this, Apple wants complete control over the distribution and tooling used on their platforms. While it does provide advantages for their hardware development I think it just ties back to them wanting 30% of any application or gaming revenue.
- CharlesW 3y agoI don't see the connection. If Apple unveils a Game Porting Toolkit with Vulkan support, that won't affect the 30%/15% App Store fee.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoPC games that could be ported to Mac and published on the App Store are less likely to do so since there's a lack of support from Apple's side. They care more about mobile games it seems.
- JimDabell 3y ago> them wanting 30% of any application or gaming revenue. 15%. They only charge 30% to people making more than a million dollars a year through the App Store.
- wellthisisgreat 3y agoCS2 looks and feels wildly outdated for 2023. I can’t fathom who could be interested in it outside of peer pressure or nostalgia. I could barely finish one full round. Haven’t touched CS in years but did enjoy 1.5 and 1.6 quite a bit back in the day. Just move on.
- Vt71fcAqt7 3y agoCS is currently at an all time peak of 1.8 million concurrent players, including an actively growing pool of new users. There is no marketing for game, let alone "peer pressure." It is exactly the chase to outrun becoming "outdated" by adding faulty game mechanics that these players are looking to avoid.
- ejj28 3y agoPart of why I like CS so much vs modern 'live service' games is that I can play whenever I feel like it and I never feel like I'm missing out on something happening, and when I come back after not playing for weeks or months, everything's the way it was when I left.
- wellthisisgreat 3y agoNot disputing the popularity. It’s just that not having ADS into iron sights or vaulting in 2023 game feels archaic. The movement is incredibly clunky; I suppose to preserve that 2000 feel. Sure Valve didn’t want to break the expectations, and lose a skin-selling cash cow. I was just hoping it would be more than a VERY subtle facelift and more of a very incremental update than a 2.0 The marketing was simple - they replaced CS:GO with the new version. It’s like Twitter changing to X.com without marketing the new brand
- pityJuke 3y ago> It’s just that not having ADS into iron sights or vaulting in 2023 game feels archaic. And thank god. Nobody was asking for thi.s > The movement is incredibly clunky Clunky to some is incredibly layered to others. Simple, yet oh so difficult to master, but crisp to input (well... there's some nonsense with the subtick system currently making it less crisp than players want, but that can be overcome). CS has multiple movement based subcommunities for a reason. (from your original comment) > Just move on. Because you enjoy the mechanics of other competitive shooter titles, doesn't mean that everyone does. You seem to think that if everyone played Apex, Warzone or Tarkov they'd suddenly enjoy it, and presumably their PC or some other factor limits them. Newsflash: plenty have played the others and come back to CS. It's akin to telling a rugby player: hey, why are you still playing rugby? American Football is so much better. Rugby is an archaic game from the 1900s.
- etchalon 3y agoI'm not sure why this is generating such debate. CS:GO is a competitive shooter. Macs are not widely popular with that type of customer. It has nothing to do with the technical limitations or business decisions of Apple (especially since Valve would distribute via Steam, where Apple's cut wouldn't factor into it). If they ever ship to iOS, they'll have to support Metal, and once they have to support Metal, they'll get Mac support essentially for free. That will change the calculation on whether Macs are worth supporting for them.
- fastball 3y agoBecause instead of releasing CS2 as a separate thing, they released it as an update to CS:GO. So those 1% of CS:GO players that were happily playing on macs a few weeks ago are SOL now.
- 1propionyl 3y agoFor those who haven't seen, Crossover 23.5[0] has integrated (some of) Apple's Game Porting Tool Kit (GPTK), in particular D3DMetal. This only works on macOS Sonoma currently, unlike Whiskey[1], but it's a good sign for the future and support for Windows games not ending at D3D11. [0] https://www.codeweavers.com/about/news/press/20230927 https://www.codeweavers.com/about/news/press/20230927 [1] https://github.com/Whisky-App/Whisky https://github.com/Whisky-App/Whisky
- littlecranky67 3y agoInterested in how they integrated the GPT - is it under a permissive license?
- cglong 3y agoIsn't one of Whisky's system requirements that you're running Sonoma?
- tempodox 3y agoYep, Apple Silicon + macOS Sonoma.
- rjst01 3y agoTangentially related - I recently made a fun discovery. Many older Steam games on mac are marked as 64-bit incompatible, but it turns out this is just a backend flag that's not always set correctly. Steam will let you install the game in spite of the warning, and if it does actually contain 64-bit code, it'll run just fine. The days of this being relevant are probably numbered though, because at some point we will lose Rosetta. But I'm going to enjoy Antichamber [1] on my mac while I can. 1: https://store.steampowered.com/app/219890/Antichamber/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/219890/Antichamber/
- perryizgr8 3y agoThe forced 32 bit incompatibility on Macbooks is so weird. My laptop is perfectly capable of executing 32 bit codes. Why does the OS start lying to me that it can't after an update? It's one thing to offer a new product without some backward compatibility, but to remove it via an update? How is it remotely acceptable?
- ericswpark 3y agoBy capable, the hardware is, but the software isn't. IIRC macOS removed the libraries required to run 32-bit applications back in Mojave or Catalina. So it's not really lying. While it is annoying that we can't use legacy software without resorting to workarounds like VMs, it does move the industry forward to 64-bit apps, on macOS at least.
- RockRobotRock 3y agoNumerous source games that you could play on Mac before 64 bit was mandatory. Why can't Valve just update the binaries??
- IntelMiner 3y agoSource 1 is extremely old (branching off from the "GoldSrc" engine that Half-Life 1 used which came from Quake 2) Valve seems to be making a pretty strong effort to distance itself from working with that engine where possible (though it's unclear if their lagging tentpole title Team Fortress 2 will get the Source 2 treatment) It's possible that rebuilding these games for 64-bit Macs specifically would encounter an undesirable amount of bugs
- Angostura 3y agoI'm pretty irked by Valve's Mac support - no 64 bit support for Team Fortress 2 etc etc. So update to a M1 and you're done.
- russelg 3y agoFunnily enough, Dota 2 (also using Source 2 like CS2) is supported on M1. It's not a native build but it runs fine through Rosetta
- tempodox 3y agoM1 is also 64-bit only.
- astrange 3y agoIt's AArch64 only. WINE+Rosetta can run Win32 programs.
- RockRobotRock 3y agoThis was a problem before M1 macs. There was an OS update that shut off 32 bit entirely, don't remember which one.
- pohl 3y agoCatalina removed 32-bit support, so Mojave was the last version with it, so Valve has had since October 2019 to get their 64-bit shit together — arguably since June 2018 when Apple informed everybody that Mojave would be the last OS with 32-bit support.
- astrange 3y agoApple started telling people that 32-bit was deprecated something like fifteen years before it was actually removed. Everyone except video game programmers got the message, which says something about video game programmers.
- grecy 3y agoIt can be run using Apple's game porting toolkit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNFf1y7GsFw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNFf1y7GsFw
- WatchDog 3y agoWhile it lacks a user-friendly installation process, I've had a great experience so far with running the windows version of steam via the game-porting-toolkit. I just run gameportingtoolkit-no-hud ~/my-game-prefix 'C:\Program Files (x86)/Steam/steam.exe' and a whole bunch of windows-only titles just work.
- yobert 3y agoI always struggle playing games on my Mac because they keep updating the OS to disallow third party tools to disable mouse smoothing. Mouse smoothing is the bane of my existence.
- richthekid 3y ago[dead]
- tombert 3y agoDISCLAIMER: My knowledge of graphics doesn't extend past "hobbyist". There's an alternate universe where Apple opened up Metal to work across platforms and languages, and that would be the successor to OpenGL. As it is right now, we're in this complete mess like we were in the 90s, where there's this hodgepodge of stuff being written using OpenGL and DirectX and Vulkan. Maybe if I learned it better I would learn to love Vulkan, but with the little I've played with it, it is absolutely dreadful. Doing even a minimal amount of stuff with it requires hundreds of lines of arcane, hard-to-read code. I spent two days figuring out how to make a cube rotate, and then I was done. OpenGL wasn't exactly "ergonomic", but it was substantially simpler to get something built with it than Vulkan. Metal, on the other hand, is a genuinely pleasant graphics API. I find it reasonably straightforward to do a lot of stuff, it's reasonably easy to intuit what the code is trying to do, and at least in the things I've played with, it performs just fine as well. If Apple had pushed for Metal to be the successor to OpenGL, I think the world would be a better place now.
- pixelpoet 3y ago> If Apple had pushed for Metal to be the successor to OpenGL, I think the world would be a better place now. Yeah Apple are just fantastic stewards of open standards, as can be seen from the amazing job they did with OpenCL... Still so angry at Apple and Nvidia for that.
- tombert 3y agoI mean, they've done a good chunk of contribution to open source; they're one of the biggest contributors to Cassandra, for example. I believe they also contribute a lot to the FreeBSD kernel. But I more or less agree; Apple kind of likes to "open shit up and then forget about it" a lot.
- tpush 3y ago> I believe they also contribute a lot to the FreeBSD kernel. They do not.
- 3y ago
- fideloper 3y agoIIRC playing counter strike on Mac was wonky anyway due to Mac's mouse acceleration, so I super rarely played CS even tho I had it installed and liked it.
- thescriptkiddie 3y agousing a mac is all about paying $15 for a program to change a setting that should have been a checkbox
- RockRobotRock 3y agoSeriously. macOS software looks beautiful but is all closed source and $10+
- IshKebab 3y agoYou mean you don't want your scroll wheel to have better acceleration than a jet fighter?
- robertoandred 3y agoOnly if you're scared of the terminal
- wlesieutre 3y agoFunnily enough, you can finally turn off mouse acceleration in macOS Sonoma without jumping through any weird hoops that may or may not work anymore. It's a checkbox in the Mouse preferences pane now. If Apple really wants games to bother supporting their platform of questionable financial viability, they may need to learn a lesson that other platforms figured out a long time ago: you can pay a developer a bunch of money and they'll make their game run on your system. I know that's a big ask for a small company with $166 billion of cash sitting around, so I don't expect it to happen. Sad to see Mac development shops bailing on the platform as it finally comes around to having useful GPUs in all of their computers. Blizzard used to have all their games cross platform up until Overwatch and now Diablo 4, but apparently it just wasn't worth doing anymore. I think it's just been decades of the Mac mostly sucking for gaming, people don't even think about buying games on it. If you want to play games you already own something that's better for that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tibbydudeza 3y agoWhat about running it under the Game Porting Toolkit ???.
- Eumenes 3y agoAs a gamer, I'd never invest in a Mac ... you can get 2-3x the PC for the same price, and you can upgrade it for 5-10 years. I don't want to buy a new $2k Mac every 5-10 years to keep up with game requirements. I'll use a Mac when my employer buys me a $2.5k MBP though.
- ouiouibaguette 3y ago[dead]
- philistine 3y agoI know Apple and Linux are two very different things, but this complete abandonment of macOS by Valve should be concerning to anyone who champions Valve for their support of Linux. It's a bad look for their commitment to Linux.
- Schnitz 3y agoWhy? Mac and Linux are clearly not that related here, for example there isn’t a Mac based handheld made by valve.
- raydev 3y agoI don't see how that's the case. What reasons are you thinking they would abandon Linux after they've built the SteamDeck on it?
- Kiuhrly 3y agoIt's also not the first time they've ditched macOS and kept linux support: SteamVR dropped support for macOS back in 2020 https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/250820/view/2216278054495230717 https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/250820/view/22162780...
- INTPenis 3y agoValve never had a commitment to Linux beyond trying to break Microsoft's monopoly. Don't get any illusions that Valve loves Linux, or Linux users. They just hate being locked into a Microsoft ruled monopoly. And picking between MacOS and Linux as a platform to compete with Microsoft, it really is a no brainer that you'd pick Linux due to the freedom of development it offers.
- philistine 3y agoYou're the one with the correct point of view. If Microsoft comes to Valve with a sweetheart deal for the Steam Deck that truly unlocks more sales and compat, they'll drop Linux like a box of bricks.
- 8b16380d 3y ago[flagged]
- mrstone 3y agoExcellent contribution. A truly well thought out, concise brief answer. Bravo.
- groovybits 3y agoGaming is also the highest-grossing entertainment industry, by a large margin - worth both the music and movie industries combined.
- nickzelei 3y agoThis makes me sad. I occasionally get the itch to surf or kz and boot up CSGO on my M1 Mac to do so. It's just more convenient for me to do this on my laptop, rather than to slug over to my desk to use my windows desktop that I rarely boot up. I tried doing the same with CSS, but because it's 32bit, it is no longer supported on macOS. I'm assuming this is a similar feeling that Overwatch players went through when their game got replaced with something that they no longer enjoy. Obviously Valve ran the numbers and I'm clearly in the minority, but man this just doesn't feel good. There will be more Mac players if more games support it, so this feels like a step backwards and is a negative feedback loop (just like others in this thread are also saying.)
- arvinsim 3y ago- Apple blocking Nvidia drivers - Apple Silicon not supporting EGPUs - Apple not adapting Vulkan and went with Metal exclusively ...
- MenhirMike 3y agoThe thing that makes this a bit more frustrating is that Apple actually kinda has a solution, the game porting toolkit (Essentially Wine/Proton for macOS). Except that they don't just make it a component of the system for end users, and don't allow developers to use it as a runtime layer in their app (so Developers can't go the proton route and actually ship a Windows binary running on top of the game porting toolkit). So it's reasonable to assume that the toolkit will go away in a few years as well. Oh well, at least it's not the first time that Mac gaming has shown to be a dead-end, but without BootCamp, it really feels final. Can't even count on half-baked, outdated ports from Aspyr anymore since they got bought by Embracer and are probably trapped in their financial struggles.
- tziki 3y agoI honestly find it absurd that we have a perfectly good solution for gaming in the form of online streaming services like geforce now, but they somehow just haven't gained much adoption. Games not being available for a platform should be a thing of the past already.
- vermilingua 3y agoYou mustn’t play CS if you think cloud gaming services are anywhere near suitable for this game. Milliseconds matter, and streaming your game sets a hard cap on how quickly you can respond; a cap much much higher than most players will tolerate.
- hojjat12000 3y agoImagine playing CS on an streaming service! People are chasing more FPS and better hardware to see their opponent a millisecond sooner, talking about tick and subtick impact on the game. Playing single player games on a streaming service is fine, but competitive games? I don't think that's gonna get too much traction.
- Razengan 3y agoWell it can't be the total number of Mac users, which is higher than the population of some countries. Maybe it's just that there aren't many Mac gamers who want to play Counter-Strike, just like there wouldn't be many Xbox owners who want to play Mario, even if it was available for Xbox.
- naikrovek 3y agoof course there aren't enough players, you have barely ported any games to MacOS, at least on Apple silicon. I was excited to see how well Portal 2 performed on my Mac mini, only to discover that it isn't even playable on Apple silicon at all. color me annoyed. especially since (presumably) these games work on x64 hardware just fine (someone please verify this.)
- joeman1000 3y agoThis is stupid. There’s been an explosion in the number of gaming-capable Macs since the M-series chips came out. It’s remained largely untapped. The reason “there aren’t enough players” is because there aren’t enough people doing games for Mac! It used to be an issue of hardware and OS support, but it has now become an issue of (frankly) lazy/biased/unimaginative developers.
- mjoin 3y agototally agree, a missed opportunity
- reportgunner 3y agoIs it not possible to install windows on mac and be an iGamer ?
- joeman1000 3y agoNo bootcamp for apple silicon Macs. And virtualisation would introduce too much input lag.
- Razengan 3y agoIt's not like Valve ever tried their best on Mac: • Even years after the introduction of Apple Silicon, the Steam STILL only has a legacy Intel version which requires Rosetta. Despite being little more than a glorified web view, apparently they can't even bother to compile it for the newer CPUs. • They outright LIE about macOS compatibility: The store pages of some games show a big warning banner about being 32-bit-only and unable to run on Catalina+, BUT THEY RUN FINE! So Valve is not only not trying, they seem to be actually sabotaging Mac gaming. It's a good thing I started switching to GoG even back when I was still on Windows, and making most of my purchases there than on Steam with its additional DRM bloat. As for the hardware, even my previous fan-less MacBook Air M2 with just 8 GB RAM ran games like Baldur's Gate 3 at a playable framerate, and my current M2 Max just blazes through everything (that's available).
- russelg 3y agoDota 2 (also built on Source 2 like CS2) works completely fine on Apple Silicon, albeit running through Rosetta. Not sure what excuse the CS2 team has when the smaller Dota team can do it (they even fixed a bug preventing it from launching on macOS very quickly)
- ThatPlayer 3y agoWouldn't the store page be up to the game? I don't think Valve are expected to monitor every single game's system requirements.