5 ms·
It's not just internationally. China has done that to its own people. Or worse. Look at Evergrand and Sunac. The government of China let developers sell un-bui
by Animats 3y ago
It's not just internationally. China has done that to its own people. Or worse. Look at Evergrand and Sunac.
The government of China let developers sell un-built apartments to future residents. The residents not only paid down payments, but took on a mortgage obligation for an un-built building.
"The majority of new properties in China — about 90% — are sold before being completed." - CNN.
This produced a terrible incentive for developers to do huge numbers of housing starts and then not finish the building.
In most of the rest of the world, developers have to finance construction with their own money or a high-interest construction loan, then sell the completed building. This gives developers a strong incentive to finish the job. Building quality control is often a problem, but unfinished projects less so.
- eklavya 3y agoNot in India, developers can sell before building but the money is in an escrow and released as the construction progresses. Also penalties and interest on any delays. I don't think selling unbuilt buildings is the bad thing, it's having no regulations or protections alongside that. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_Estate_(Regulation_and_Development)_Act,_2016 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_Estate_(Regulation_and_...
- rfoo 3y agoChina has > the money is in an escrow and released as the construction progresses. too. The problem is it doesn't work: the fund release schedule can't be perfectly aligned with each stage of the constitution on a cost basis. There's a large amount of unfinished buildings (rather than not started at all) at a certain stage - it's the point when the_amount_of_fund_released - the_construction_cost_so_far is maxed. I like the USA solution more - no mortgage for unfinished buildings. Developers can still sell it, but good luck.
- jxramos 3y agoThere's something very powerful behind incentives level thinking, it really does push you into second and third order effects and meta level interactions to think "if this then what next". I've been wanting to step up my level of engaging and contemplating incentives in the generic.
- dopeboy 3y agoSame here. If you find some literature about it that you're willing to share, would love to read and swap notes.
- ipnon 3y agoRead an introduction to economics textbooks. Use one from a popular MOOC syllabus. Cowen and Tabarrok is a great example. Once you can turn everything into a model and an equilibrium the biggest systems of the world become much clearer.
- reisse 3y ago> The residents not only paid down payments, but took on a mortgage obligation for an un-built building. So what? They had a choice between paying more money for already built house now or paying less money but accepting the risks of developer's failure. > This produced a terrible incentive for developers to do huge numbers of housing starts and then not finish the building. Ugh, it's not like venture investing when developers are not liable for the failure of the company. The law usually (don't know exactly about China) skews the balance in favour of property buyers. > In most of the rest of the world, developers have to finance construction with their own money or a high-interest construction loan, then sell the completed building. And the cost of that high-interest construction loan is paid by the future residents. Not something you want when your goal is to give most of the population cheap housing.
- stickfigure 3y ago> So what? A very large number of Chinese citizens will lose their savings to these ponzi-esque construction schemes. Vast waves of defaults may take the banks with them. In Albania something similar caused mass civil unrest.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIn case anyone wants a cite on the Albania bit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1997_Albanian_civil_unrest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1997_Albanian_civil_unrest Ponzi/pyramid schemes captured two thirds of Albania's population.
- callalex 3y agoWhy don’t poor people just get more money? It would solve most of their problems.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> Why don’t poor people just get more money? It would solve most of their problems. Well, every clever businessman will simply increase the prices in such a situation since more people can now afford to pay more. Problem solved *not*. Markets are self-calibrating.
- wheelerof4te 3y ago"The majority of new properties in China — about 90% — are sold before being completed." - CNN" Not sure if this is some kind of joke. Many countries have laws that permit selling appartments when they are about 80% complete. Some have lower, some higher percentages. Just your average low-tier negative CNN propaganda, I guess.
- 26fingies 3y agoi was gonna say - a lot of places you can put a bunch of cash down for an apartment that only exists as a picture on a sign somewhere.
- shawabawa3 3y agoIn the UK you can buy "off plan", but you only pay a deposit, and that goes into escrow until you get the keys, the developer can't touch the money until then I assume it's similar in most countries
- phanimahesh 3y agoNot quite. In india properties get loans during early construction as well, and the amounts are disbursed in tranches based on completion progress. Timelines must be filed publicly with RERA and a non RERA approved property is a red flag. No escrows as such for loans taken by buyer. What I call loan is a similar arrangement to mortgage. Buyer pledges property as collateral, pays about 20% out of pocket, rest is a debt to be paid. Defaults result in loss of ownership of property. The agreements are tripartite. Builder gets paid from the loan taken out by buyer in tranches and builder reputation matters along with market value assessment and buyer's credit profile for obtaining a loan.
- vondur 3y agoOther countries have the rule of law and you can sue a developer. That’s not possible in China. I did read where disgruntled Chinese are withholding payments on these unfinished buildings. Not sure what the repercussions could be for those who do it.
- littlestymaar 3y ago> In most of the rest of the world, developers have to finance construction with their own money or a high-interest construction loan, then sell the completed building. This gives developers a strong incentive to finish the job. I don't know how it works in other countries but in France for new apartments you almost always buy them before or during construction, which allow new residents to settle in right after the construction has finished instead of waiting for months for the sale. The way we deal with the incentive alignment is simply by having a justice system that makes sure contracts are actually enforceable and mandatory insurance policy for developers should anything bad happen to their company.
- lenkite 3y ago> The government of China let developers sell un-built apartments to future residents. This happens in India also.
- hatsune 3y agothis was banned recently (around 2020), also that sounds as legal as how stocks work in the first place during age of exploration and an intervention within seems maybe not strictly necessary.