7 ms·
The tech industry has such bizarre economics. If I told you I had a business with: - $120M in annual revenue - 1M fiercely loyal customers who paid every mont
by paxys 3y ago
The tech industry has such bizarre economics. If I told you I had a business with:
- $120M in annual revenue
- 1M fiercely loyal customers who paid every month
- 5 distribution centers spread across the country
- 100 happy employees, each with a tenure of a decade or longer
You'd probably say that I had achieved the definition of success in the business world and should be proud of myself. To Netflix, on the other hand, this business is so irrelevant that they'd rather take it out back and shoot it in the head just to save the bother of continuing to run it.
- ekianjo 3y agoStopping services for loyal and long time consumers is insane. Even if your profit margin is lower in that business you keep it alive because you respect people who have carried you to where you are now. The hubris...
- chii 3y ago> Stopping services for loyal and long time consumers is insane it's not, unfortunately. If the business isn't making _enough_ money (where "enough" actually means maximum possible out of all of possibilities), then you are better off switching the investment to the other investment that is returning more.
- tspike 3y agoEven better would be selling it to someone who wants it.
- whatshisface 3y agoNetflix is a public company, so that investment tradeoff decision is being made about allocating money not between online netflix and mail netflix, but more like borax and mail netflix.
- sharts 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y ago"Please don't fulminate." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- beachy 3y agoYou didn't mention how profitable the business is - thats the only metric that really matters. All those happy employees have to be paid. The 1M fiercely lyal customers will only be 950K next month. The lease on 3 of the 5 distribution centers comes up this year and business would have to commit to another 5+ year lease.
- usefulcat 3y agoNot even profitability, but growth. Even if it wasn't profitable now it could be worth doing for a growing market, but surely the market for physical discs is shrinking and will continue to do so.
- walteweiss 3y agoIt baffles me so much when people put ecology out of the question. Great Netflix is shutting down the business that produces so much unneeded plastic. Sad others would gladly keep that business forever when it makes money. Fuck the planet, hell yeah.
- squokko 3y agoLOL. Imagine the amount of plastic created by Netflix DVD. How many people you can rent one DVD to and how much plastic is in one DVD compared to the packaging in your trash can right now.
- walteweiss 3y agoI assume it all delivered by bicycles.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou said plastic specifically. And the postal service, to a rough approximation, already goes by every mailbox every day. Adding an envelope has a smaller impact than a bicycle delivery.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- moneywoes 3y agowhat about the margins
- chillee 3y ago120M in annual revenue for 100 employees is not that high. That's only about 1.2M in revenue per employee. Netflix's main business makes 2.4M per employee (31.6 billion for 12k employees), and given the nature of such businesses, is almost certainly much more profitable per employee.
- hef19898 3y agoThanks for making OPs point is just so many words.
- chillee 3y agoIt's not about the "unusual tech economics", it's about the profit. Making more money than you spend is not a tech-specific concept.
- hef19898 3y agoSeeing 1.2m revenue per employee as a something you might loose money on as "tech", or rather VC backed SV bubble, specific as it gets. Even more hilarious when people utterly fail to see that. If people weren't serious, it would be peak meta irony.
- hnbad 3y agoYou're not thinking of "tech", you're thinking of late stage capitalism. "Tech" is just one of the clearest manifestations of that because the revenue per employee is less tightly bounded than in manufacturing or direct services, especially now that rent-seeking has replaced selling.
- alephnerd 3y agoRevenue per Employee alone is bullshit. To calculate operating costs it's best to look at Net Income per Employee, which is $378k [0] Out of that $2.1m, only $378k is left after expenditures, payroll, R&D, etc. [0] - https://www.macroaxis.com/financial-statements/NFLX/Revenue-Per-Employee https://www.macroaxis.com/financial-statements/NFLX/Revenue-...
- lisper 3y agoOr sell it.
- yankput 3y agoIf it was so profitable there would be many copycats, like with their streaming business. I don’t know of any copycat.
- fragmede 3y agoRedBox, those kiosks that dispense DVDs. Extremely popular in areas less well served by streaming services. $80 million in revenue in Q2 2023.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoso it sounds like RedBox will increase in revenue. however reading on company "Redbox shares were down 40% in recent trading. Redbox shareholders on Tuesday approved the company's acquisition by Chicken Soup for the Soul Entertainment." in August. You would think Netflix getting out of the business should be a sign for shares to go up. Maybe they're not that profitable either.
- hnbad 3y agoShareholders like VCs generally want growth and even if Redbox could gobble up Netflix's DVD rental market share, the market itself is stagnant if not shrinking at this point so a short-lived growth opportunity is not particularly appealing. Redbox could monopolize the DVD rental market and investors still wouldn't be excited because it can't move anywhere from there and it would end up plateauing in a very boring niche. Investors don't care about profit of the business, they care about profit of their investment (ROI). Whether a company is profitable or bleeding money only matters as part of the prediction on where the share price will go.
- alephnerd 3y ago> VCs generally want growth and even if Redbox could gobble up Netflix's DVD rental market share, the market itself is stagnant Netflix IPOed in 2002 and Redbox's parent company is a penny stock (Chicken Soup of the Soul Entertainment // NASDAQ: CSSE) VCs do not invest in public entities. The companies that invest in public entities are Investment Banks and Private Equity, both of which are different industries with different norms and regulations from Venture Capital
- renewiltord 3y agoI can build that selling a dollar for 95 cents. How much are you willing to pay for that business?
- agilob 3y agoBut you need to save the other business of "renting and not owing stuff"
- zaphirplane 3y agoThat is correct, the missing piece is that companies are not valued only on their current p&l they are also valued on the future that is P/E ratio Netflix has P/E ratio of around 40, when the stock doesn’t look like it’s meeting the ratio why would I buy the stock at that price, I’d buy it (your point) but at a lower price
- solatic 3y agoHere's the hole in your logic: even if Netflix has no desire to operate a particular business anymore (despite presumed profitability), if the business was, in the general sense, desirable (i.e. because profitability), then it would be worthwhile to Netflix to simply sell the business to another entity. Surely, for a desirable business, Netflix should be able to find a buyer for $1 or higher. That would let Netflix liquidate the asset / business while keeping the business running. Tech industry economics are besides the point. Suppose tech industry economics expects (for the sake of argument, insanely) an internal rate of return of 300% on every dollar spent, while the IRR of the disc business is some measly fraction of that. By liquidating the disc business, Netflix gets to take whatever proceeds from the liquidation - even if it's only $1 - and put it towards other internal usages that it expects that 300% IRR from. A price like $1 is so small that, presumably, you would go to whoever the current salaried worker is responsible for managing the disc business, offer them ownership for $1, and the manager-worker would happily take the opportunity to become a manager-owner of the desirable business that employs him at a price that anyone could afford. Of course, in the real world, there are various costs involved. So presumably, (a) the costs associated with liquidation are lower than the costs associated with spinning off the disc business, and (b) whatever the cost associated with spinning off the disc business, no buyer could be found for at least the sum of that cost plus $1; that such costs are indeed above what the salaried manager-worker of the current disc business could afford. Maybe that's bullshit, maybe not, I don't understand enough about Netflix's disc business to know. But Hanlon's Razor is the better guide here. Either Netflix's board is going where the money is leading them to go, or they're leaving money on the table for malicious reasons, and the second doesn't make sense since it would expose them to shareholder lawsuits.
- jstanley 3y agoEither the board knows something we don't know, or they're actively malicious? Are those the only 2 options? What if the board is just too busy, or mistaken, or stupid?
- solatic 3y agoToo busy: what typically happens is that the concern of the spin-off of the disc business would be delegated to one / a few board members whose responsibility would be to examine the issue and make a recommendation to the rest of the board. The board member(s) themselves are rarely the people doing the analysis of the options; instead they delegate to salaried workers (either of Netflix, a contractor, or working directly for the board member) who do the legwork. So the amount of time that a board member themself will spend on the deal is either zero (they're not a member of the committee responsible for sourcing the recommendations) or fairly minimal. Mistaken is another form of stupid. And do you really think you get to be on the board of a ~$168 billion market cap public company by being stupid?
- ACV001 3y agoLook at this as 1M new fiercely loyal netflix streaming customers. They may bring less than 120 M per year, but at much lower cost per customer..
- MereInterest 3y agoWhy would they be fiercely loyal to a company that has just canceled their preferred product?
- _tom_ 3y agoIt's worse than that, they want it dead. Presumably because it competes with (and is better than?) the streaming service. IIRC, Redbox offered to buy it. No interest.
- _tom_ 3y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2023/4/21/23692665/redbox-netflix-dvd-business-save https://www.theverge.com/2023/4/21/23692665/redbox-netflix-d...