15 ms·
When tech says ‘no’
- edgarvaldes 3y ago>First, and this is the default, they’re saying no because they just don’t like it. >Second, though, the tech industry (or the doctors, or the farmers) might be saying no because this really will have very serious negative consequences that you haven’t understood. >If the second kind of ‘no’ is ‘that’s a really bad idea’, the third kind is ‘we actually can’t do that’. I think a big industry is plagued by the first case. On the other hand, a specific tech worker is more prone to say no because of 2 and 3.
- Ensorceled 3y agoThere is kind of a "boy who cried wolf" thing going on where the tech industry has pushed back hard on pretty much any sort of regulation and oversight that the regulators automatically assume "they’re saying no because they just don’t like it.".
- fallingknife 3y agoAnd for what proposed regulation of the tech industry was the pushback unwarranted?
- tadfisher 3y agoThe Apple/Google marketplace rules are common-sense, and address legitimate concerns. I moderate /r/androiddev, and we get at least 10 posts per week that are basically "I make a living from Android apps and Google has banned my developer account and denied my appeals". There needs to be some kind of public check on this behavior when livelihoods are at stake, and I don't trust either company for a second when they say this will ruin their app stores.
- fallingknife 3y agoYeah that's a great point. If bundling IE with Windows was an anti trust issue back in the 90s, I don't understand how totally locking down your ecosystem on mobile can possibly be allowed. That doesn't require new regulations, though. Just need to enforce the existing law.
- hgsgm 3y agoYou have the freedom to chopse between 4, oops, 2, totally locked down ecosystems.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoThe trouble is 9 out of 10 of those people will have been pushing the boundary in some way and probably deserve their treatment. Open the app stores up and they will become a cesspit.
- watwut 3y agoQuite a lot of complains about GDPR were pure hysterics.
- zarzavat 3y agoOnly because the regulators have taken an extremely soft approach to enforcement.
- Ensorceled 3y agoRight to Repair, USB-C chargers, DSA, ...
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoA big part of the problem here is that most of the proposals to regulate tech companies actually are terribly crafted attempts to regulate something the drafters poorly understand, or naked power grabs by other industries (legacy media conglomerates being a common perpetrator). A good heuristic is to look at which part of the industry is opposing it. If it's opposed by small businesses or individual developers or civil liberties organizations, that's a bad rule even (or especially) if huge tech conglomerates like it. But if it's the reverse -- like antitrust enforcement -- now you might be onto something necessary.
- rhaway84773 3y agoThe EU has been passing great laws which at worst have meant some annoying banners so no, it’s not just bad laws.
- moffkalast 3y agoGDPR has honestly been fantastic so far, the problem the old cookie law has that it's defacto unenforced and site owners aren't ever fined for dark patterns of having to uncheck a 2000 item list of trackers. If they properly cracked down on it with only compliant 'yes or no' banners left as the law actually states we'd be in a much better place.
- wilde 3y agoWhat positive effects have you seen?
- bad_user 3y agoDPAs seem to be understaffed and overwhelmed. On the other hand, people said that nothing would happen to the likes of Google or Facebook, as they'll just work around it. Well, that prediction aged poorly, the lawsuits have been progressing, and it takes only one DPA from one country to change things. Like how it was deemed that Facebook's ads targeting isn't a legitimate purpose, so they'll be forced to ask for consent without denying service for those that refuse. Meta knows that GDPR spells doom for their business model, which is why they abstained from releasing Threads in EU, as a sort of warning perhaps. But it won't work, because the EU market is too big to pull from, which is why EU legislation has teeth. And GDPR actually works, even if it takes some time for DPAs to solve existing cases. And the "cookie law" works too. People complaining about banners miss the forest from the trees: banners are mostly needed when doing spyware shit, and they serve as a great warning to visitors. There are no cookie banners on Mastodon.
- timmaxw 3y ago> pushed back hard on pretty much any sort of regulation and oversight I think there's a selection effect going on here: If tech and politicians agree that some policy is a good idea, then tech does it voluntarily, so no regulation is needed. The only cases where it becomes a matter of regulation are the cases where tech and politicians disagree. For example: Remember the privacy discussion around COVID-19 exposure-tracking apps? If the exposure-tracking apps had been implemented in a naive way, they would have been incredibly invasive to privacy. But tech proactively figured out good solutions to the privacy questions, so it never became an issue. If some politician _had_ proposed regulation saying that exposure-tracking apps needed to protect privacy, then tech wouldn't have pushed back, because that's what they were already doing anyway. But because tech was already doing it, politicians didn't propose the regulation. So, because an issue never becomes a matter of regulation unless tech pushes back on it, it ends up looks like "tech pushes back on all regulation". Furthermore, in the cases where tech and politicians disagree, the politicians haven't always been right. For example, GDPR cookie banners are a joke. California's AB5 law is another example, as the original article mentioned. So, I don't think "boy who cried wolf" is a fair analogy. Tech companies aren't always right, but it's not as if they're automatically opposed to all new policies; and when they do oppose politicians' proposed policies, it's sometimes for good reasons.
- mschuster91 3y ago> If tech and politicians agree that some policy is a good idea, then tech does it voluntarily, so no regulation is needed. The only cases where it becomes a matter of regulation are the cases where tech and politicians disagree. And these cases are the utter majority. > For example, GDPR cookie banners are a joke. They are, but only for those services that want to squeeze their customers like they're data lemons. What you need to do to provide the customer with the service they desire is covered automatically, the thing where you need a GDPR consent banner is if you want to include a truckload of external services to track your users across the Internet.
- DocTomoe 3y agoI set up a nice little webpage, that did not use any tracking at all. There was one cookie for a home-brew login functionality, and even that was only linked to an extremely limited amount of data (namely, the login name, and the password, didn't even mandate email...). By all means, this one cookie - whose use was completely voluntary - was a 'technical cookie' which I do not need consent for under the EU's cookie laws. It took about 30 minutes after the go-live before the first madmen came around and started shouting at me that I needed a cookie banner. The problem with that law is not only that it caused everyone to set up a cookie banner to operate as they used to, it also is that it created a class of people who are self-declared data protection vigilantes. I do consider publishing on Gopher (or Gemini) in the future, if only to prevent zealots - who often have no technical knowledge - from accessing my services. The people I address are capable - and willing - to use other protocols.
- SenAnder 3y agoThere's another kind of 'no' - when the programmers and engineers and other technically expert workers are nearly universally against something, but the CEO- and lawyer-classes are for it. Like software patents. Edit: Sources for the patent claim: That same afternoon, we talked to a half dozen different software engineers. All of them hated the patent system, and half of them had patents in their names that they felt shouldn't have been granted. In polls, as many as 80 percent of software engineers say the patent system actually hinders innovation. It doesn't encourage them to come up with new ideas and create new products. It actually gets in their way. - https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/07/26/138576167/when-patents-attack https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/07/26/138576167/when... https://opensource.com/law/11/4/poll-patents-and-innovation https://opensource.com/law/11/4/poll-patents-and-innovation
- dylan604 3y agoif only the entire workforce of ad tech would just say no.
- smoldesu 3y agoYou're welcome to offer a more attractive alternative, if one exists. The market is always ready.
- dylan604 3y agoa more attractive one would be the ending of invasive tracking. according to those involved in ad tech, there is no market without the tracking, so...the alternative is no ad tech
- SenAnder 3y agoStrange how there are ads in magazines, on billboards, TV, and radio, without tracking. Especially since they're so much more expensive to place.
- 3y ago
- colmmacc 3y agoI spent a few years in Ireland and the Netherlands lobbying against insecure voting machines. I had so many conversations with politicians and civil servants where these effects were in abundance. In each country I was representing a group that included the most eminent and experienced computer scientists in the country. Whenever we briefed someone for the first time, it would only take a minute or two to cover how without a voter-verified paper audit trail, no-one knew how to build a system that provided anonymity, verifiability, and resistance to voter coercion and vote selling. But it just never clicked, so many of them refused to believe that we couldn't simply "nerd harder". And of course, there was no shortage of charlatans who would tell them that they could solve it. In Ireland, we put enough pressure on the politicians for them to create a cross-body commission to investigate. Because anyone could make detailed submissions, and because the commission treated these submissions like the clerks of the Supreme Court treat amicus briefs; it was pretty effective. The commission ended up pausing, and ultimately abandoning, the rollout. Ever since I've learned to appreciate any avenues to "de-politicize" a controversy and get it to that kind of body.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat means you know Rop :)
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoHow did you get that body accepted as an idea as opposed to a "kick into the long grass" solution?
- kemotep 3y agoThe verifiability is the biggest one. One could conceivably develop a voting system that had perfect accountability, secrecy, and integrity, but would be far far more difficult to work out by hand. A zero knowledge roll up is not something your average poll worker could work out on scratch paper. Paper ballots counted by hand can and can achieve all the things we desire in election systems.
- Gibbon1 3y agoFist off where I've voted they switched from punched cards to scanning paper ballots. It's all typically run by three middle aged women with a printed book of who's registered to vote. You just tell the first one your name and they find your entry and you sign next to it. The next one hands you a scantron sheet. You mark it up. The the third one feeds your sheets into the machine as you watch. Machine records your votes and drops the sheets into a bin in the machine. That's a system I trust and it has the positive of civic engagement. And fundamentally it's not broken. You now also have the option of mailing in a ballot. That's easier to corrupt I'm sure. But at least it's still paper. All the fully computerized systems seem really really sketchy to me. Especially in low trust cultures where underhanded stuff is normalized.
- naetd 3y agoThe first type of 'no' is summarized as just being annoying to implement and not making a big difference, but I think it can be a lot deeper and more consequential than that. There can be regulation that will damage a companies profits, but also provides positives to public health or other beneficial outcomes. Deeply profitable companies will fight tooth and nail against these regulations even if they are full aware of the damage they are causing. They will come up with as many convincing sounding reasons to say "no" as possible in the name of those immense profits they enjoy, and use techniques like expensive lobbying, sponsoring pseudoscientific studies, running ads, play up fears about economic damage or other negative outcomes of the policy, etc. They try to make it sound like the second or third kinds of "no" in the article and paint it as a bad idea, or impossible to do, or anything else they can to prevent the regulation. And if a certain individual at that company doesn't want to fight for their unethical profit, they'll be swiftly replaced with someone who will. The obvious (non tech) example is something like the tobacco industry, which spent millions on manipulating public and policy opinion using misleading scientific sounding language or studies to prevent or delay regulation despite being fully aware of the many health detriments of smoking. Public health has been significantly improved as a result of smoking reduction, restrictions on where you can smoke in public spaces, age restrictions, whatever. I think there is a lot of this currently in companies profiting off social media, oil and gas, and selling user data.
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoI think there is a good ole 2x2 grid here. The socially positive nature of the industry on one axis and the degree of strong completion on the other. So we can have say Retail food stores, sainsbury's and tesco, that deliver mostly positive things (food!) in a highly competitive manner. We can also see positive industries (water / sewage) that have terrible competitive landscapes (fundamentally monopolies/ utilities). These need to be regulated differently - ie with hands firmly clasped round the throat of all participants. Bad industries and bad competition looks like the illegal drugs trade (I personally think the cut throat nature of retail stores is as literal cut throat as we want. When the completion stops focusing on making the product better and starts focusing on killing the other stores employees we are not seeing improved markets And your example was bad industry / good competition- cigarettes are a good example here. I think it's worth adding a third dimension to the grid - time and future shape. The retail food model is a good one but over time we can see the effect on out of town car parks, the urbanisation vs wqlkability etc etc. Intervening in how stores advertise the price of milk won't help this. But neither will "nerd harder" - there is no solution to "this business model if continued will go the wrong way" that does not involve chnaging the business model - ie charging for car parking space or something. Anyway, it struck me as a useful simple graph. As business models move to different parts of grid they get regulated differently, and adding time/dependencies in means we can shape the results. But in the end I am arguing for smart proactive interventionist government. Let governments be governments
- btilly 3y agoThe third 'no' is really well shown in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BKorP55Aqvg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BKorP55Aqvg. (A video about an expert being asked to do the impossible by people who have no idea what they are asked.)
- homeless_engi 3y agoTurns out it might actually be possible? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7MIJP90biM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7MIJP90biM
- btilly 3y agoThat's awesome.
- xkcd1963 3y agoForcing down the throat cookie notifications
- Affric 3y agolol... the option to not create a pervasive surveillance state online was there. The big players didn't want it.
- xkcd1963 3y agoYou are naive believing this solves any issues.
- Affric 3y agoUsing a directional antenna to steal wifi after cracking people’s weak passwords, browsing through Tor, and not permitting javascript to be executed in my browser solve my issues. I am an enjoyer of the cookie dialogue because I am a sadist and love the suffering it induces. /s There will be a lot of bad regulation before we get good regulation on the internet. Our lawmakers are still learning. If “move fast break stuff” is good enough for tech it’s good enough for the guys regulating tech.
- xkcd1963 3y ago- https://noscriptfingerprint.com/ https://noscriptfingerprint.com/ - https://codepen.io/ifthenelse/pen/WMyEYN https://codepen.io/ifthenelse/pen/WMyEYN - https://www.lovesdata.com/blog/2015/tracking-in-google-analytics-without-cookies-or-javascript https://www.lovesdata.com/blog/2015/tracking-in-google-analy... - countless other approaches
- Affric 3y agoCheers for the links. In my experience attempting to evade tracking by trying to mitigate these approaches will often get you a "you look like a bot" message from websites (by which they mean, "your HTTP requests do not permit us to track you").
- refulgentis 3y agoThis is quite off-base, unfortunately. Don't read it as fact, but as a vibe, and take note it's an infohazard if you have any managerial responsibility in a tech company. Among many, many, things, the EU was not beat back on messaging interoperability -- in fact, it's due to announce the draft list next week. And it wasn't messaging interoperability -- its a set of requirements for gatekeeper services with over 45 million users. I didn't expect this from Ben, but when I think back, I haven't seen much work from him over the last 5 years. Did he drop out of industry?
- benedictevans 3y agoOriginally, the EU had one paragraph on this. That paragraph literally said that you had to let 'any' third party interconnect. That turned into a separate 50 page draft once messaging people explained that 'any' meant spam farms and Chinese intelligence agencies, and a bunch of other stuff besides. And no, nothing happened to me ;)
- doctor_eval 3y ago> The Canadian government told Google and Meta that if a link to a newspaper story ever appears in search, or if a journalist ever posts a link to a story on Facebook, then they have to pay the newspaper for sending business to the newspaper. This is first-class bullshit. Google and Meta made their money by co-opting third party content, concentrating audiences into their own portal, and selling advertising against it - often through algorithmic dark patterns. This is a disreputable business model that’s as old as iframes, but somehow its acceptable for these gigacompanies to do it. To characterise this as “they have to pay the newspaper for sending business to the newspaper” is just buying into the kind of self-interested “no” that the article purports to discuss. They systematically took these audiences away from the content providers, and then started to charge a premium to the providers for placement in the algorithms. Meta has been the most egregious of these but Google has been moving in this direction for years. These companies have more than enough money to pay for their content, but that would break their protection racket business model.
- vkou 3y ago> They systematically took these audiences away and then charge a price to get the audiences to return. How exactly does the existence of search take audiences away? Or do you mean the 15-word clickbait headline blurb takes audiences away? If your news story isn't worth reading after reading the headline, it's probably not worth reading.
- jay_kyburz 3y agoGoogle thinks its worth including in the index.
- falcor84 3y agoWhat kind of argument is that? Google's mission was literally to "organize the world's information" - of course they would include newspapers in the index, irrespective of any opinion about the articles.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago
- tomComb 3y agoThe move away from globalization has had an unfortunate side effect: greater political corruption, where local politicians enact laws for the benefit of their local corporate buddies, and pretend (usually successfully) that it is an act of nationalism and standing up to big tech. That’s what happened here in Canada with Bill c-18, as mentioned in the article. It’s been rather sickening to watch the government defend this bizarre law that is little more then a shake down for their buddies at bell and Rogers.
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoWho are bell and rogers? Some sort of newspaper firm? Plus while corruption is possible, protectionism is the less greasy term, and equally likely to be driving things
- grzm 3y agoI assume Bell Telephone (and its descendants) and Rogers Communications (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers_Communications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers_Communications)
- tomComb 3y agoThey are the dominant telecom companies, but they are much more than that here and have had the politicians in their pockets, protecting them from competition and funneling tax-payers money to them, for years. You might be puzzled that I mention them in relation to a bill that is supposed to be for journalism - but the official analysis of this bill confirms that the majority of the money actually goes to them. That is normal here.
- Apocryphon 3y agoThis has always followed protectionism, I'd guess. Really the solution would have been to socialize the domestic losses caused by globalization (retraining workers, etc.), but there seems to be no interest or political will towards doing that.
- 3y ago
- dataflow 3y ago> we can make it secure, or we can let law enforcement have access, but that means the Chinese can get in too How is this in category 3? Give decryption keys to your own government and not the others. I get it if you think it'll require more opsec from your government than you might trust them with, or that it'll have other negative effects (see: category 2), but how is this physically impossible (category 3)?
- falcor84 3y agoI would assume that the issue is that the mere idea of decryption keys that can be "given" means there is no end-to-end encryption.
- dataflow 3y agoThat can't be what they're saying, since asking for "let us access this" is already assuming no end-to-end encryption. The other governments would have nothing to do with the argument in that case.
- benedictevans 3y agoIf you give the key to every government that demands it (USA, UK, France, Germany, Japan... ), and every agency (CIA, NSA, FBI, DHS, DEA...) then how long will that remain secure? The key will leak and then you have no security.
- dataflow 3y agoYou only give it to the government entities your country is asking you to. Heck, you could even encrypt each user's data with their own government's key. Edit: and key rotation is also a thing.
- elpool2 3y agoThere are different degrees of “secure”, right? Maybe you could give a key to the FBI without China getting ahold of it, maybe it’s still “secure enough”. But you can’t say it’s “just as secure” as not giving it to them. And that’s what law enforcement often asks for: Give us access without making it any less secure.
- dmurray 3y ago> Your MPs’ WhatsApp group can be secure, or it can readable by law enforcement and the Chinese, but you cannot have encryption that can be broken only by our spies and not their spies. Pick one. It doesn't seem technically infeasible for WhatsApp to move to a protocol where, say, every message is transmitted twice, once encrypted with the recipient's public key and once with the NSA's public key. Or for the state to ban all messaging systems that don't follow that protocol. Arguments against encryption are generally philosophical rather than purely technical.
- benedictevans 3y agoI am not a cryptographer, but the standard objection to this is that the NSA key will leak, either generally or be stolen by a Russian/Chinese agent. And in implementation, how many keys are we talking about? USA, UK, France, Germany, USA, Australia... Every country's law enforcement will demand a key, and how long will that remain secure?
- zarzavat 3y agoThe best argument is simply that you cannot ban e2e encryption because there’s thousands of people who are able to implement it all over the world. Banning E2E just means that everybody who cares about privacy (including the “bad guys” and privacy conscious users) will switch to a banned implementation, and everybody else will have their privacy put at risk for no reason at all.
- ahtihn 3y agoDevil's advocate: the answer to that is that perfect is the enemy of good. Most "bad guys" are pretty dumb and won't bother using actually secure communication channels especially if messengers keep advertising that they do end-to-end encryption. And even for those who do care enough, most of them aren't all that tech-savvy and will make mistakes. All that to say that a ban doesn't have to be 100% effective to make a meaningful difference.
- 3y ago
- petermcneeley 3y ago> but you cannot have encryption that can be broken only by our spies and not their spies. Pick one. This doesnt seem true in practice. I would look at prism as an example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM
- ben_w 3y agoIf you want PRISM to be evidence that you don't have to "pick one", you don't just need to demonstrate that the US could access encrypted content, you also need to demonstrate that no other nations could exploit any part of it. That includes non-American courts making orders to use the same actual processes and procedures as PRISM, and which we might not even know about because those countries have not yet had their own version of Snowden revealing it. One thing I wonder with "secret" courts (and court orders where you're de facto ordered not to discuss the order even with your attorney like Lavabit was): How do you know if it's a legit court, and not an elaborate spear phish?
- bee_rider 3y agoI think the third type of “no” just sounds a lot more confusing or contradictory to the engineers and programmers who are tasked with trying to implement a solution that both fits the requirement, and allows the company to continue doing business mostly they were before. Of course, on the other side, the full command is “change how you provide your service in this way that we’ve specified, or stop providing it.” There is no mathematical contradiction or impossibility here, they just don’t mind if they yank away your livelihood, don’t let them off the hook by assuming they are stupid (they might be, but they probably have someone clever who can feed them enough car analogies…).
- Barrin92 3y ago>“Work it out” is generally a demand to invent new mathematics, but sadly, mathematics doesn’t work like that The article invalidates a somewhat reasonable point by saying this sort of thing. A cryptographic end-user application is not "mathematics". It's a piece of software, running on a piece of hardware, and there is no platonic, infallible security going on. This is the sort of 'no' people utter if they have ideological objections disguised as technological ones. In reality any system, including cryptographic ones exist on a curve. Differentiated systems for access exist. The honest criticism would be that a system with a backdoor is less secure, but it's certainly possible to enable privileged access to third parties while excluding others, it's just riskier. But risk in reality also exists with any encrypted application, because it runs with keys stored on a phone, not in some untouchable maths dimension. How much you move between access and security is absolutely a question of policy and architecture, not some theoretically impossible thing.
- csours 3y agoDisclosure, I work for GM. Type 1: The tradeoffs are not in my favor. Type 2: You have not understood the tradeoffs. Type 3: No one can evaluate the proposal. > "When policy-makers ask for secure encryption with a back door, we do not always see that this would like be telling Ford and GM to stop their cars from crashing, and to make them run on gasoline that doesn’t burn. Well yes, that would be nice, but how? They say ‘no’? Easy - just threaten them with a fine of 25% of global revenue and they’ll build it!" > "This would like be telling Ford and GM to stop their cars from crashing" Easy - car doesn't go until all seatbelts are on. All seats face backwards. Helmet and HANS device for all occupants. Maximum speed is 45 mph. Cars are wrapped in giant foam pads. Cars are limited to roads mapped by the automaker. (Type 2b [I have interpreted the intention of your Type 3 proposal] - Customers would revolt) > "Make them run on gasoline that doesn’t burn" Easy - catalyze gasoline to hydrogen and use a fuel cell. Well not easy, but possible. (Type 3 - I can propose this, but no one can evaluate it without doing a LOT of work) ==== Personal opinion: People feel like experts have lied to them, because experts have lied to them. We can't trust experts. How should people think? Specifically when it is very expensive to test something? 'Expensive' includes all kinds of risk, not just money spent. 'Test' includes "what will this do to me?" So some people think that there is a 100 mpg water carburetor that Shell bought the patents to and maybe the inventor had an 'accident'. In reality, (Type 2) They have not understood the tradeoffs. 100 mpg is easy - on a speed limited motorcycle on a chosen route. Water carburation is not too hard for motivated and handy person to use. It IS too hard to put on a general consumer's vehicle. Jet airplanes used to inject water into the engine to get more performance on takeoff. Someone realized that it's cheaper, easier, and saves weight to just inject more fuel. The fuel doesn't fully burn, but it adds to the thrust just by being mass that goes out the end of the engine.
- eloisant 3y agoMaybe stop listening to Big Tech companies and start listening to NPO like EFF or ISOC?
- rhaway84773 3y agoBS. “Tech” as described here says no for one reason and one reason only. It will lose them money. Sometimes it will lose money over the short term. Other times over the long run. That’s the only reason “tech” says no. Individuals may say no for some of the reasons mentioned. But this article is basically describing companies and yes, they say yes if they think they will make money and no if they will lose money. And this isn’t even a bad thing. Companies as a legal fiction exist for the purpose of making money. What is a bad thing is people thinking that companies (especially public for profit ones) act on any basis other than whether they will make money or not. Which is why this article is an f’ing disaster and naive beyond the extreme.
- Doches 3y agoAre Apple, Meta, and Signal saying “no” to the UK’s demand for secure-to-GCHQ backdoors in E2E purely to defend their margins? Of course not; they’re saying “the laws of mathematics trump the laws of the United Kingdom”. Apple isn’t promising to pull iMessage (a huge part of their platform lock-in!) from the UK because they want to avoid the expense of complying with this law. Even a cynic would say that they’d love to comply, if only there was a way. But they literally can’t.
- ben_w 3y agoBack at university, one of my lecturers had a story about having to convince a company to cancel a contract they'd signed with a different lecturer, call them Bob, because the software Bob had agreed to write had provably impossible performance characteristics. I forget the details, I think it was not quite as bad as "O(1) sorting for any length list" (not even 100% sure they actually told us the specifics) but it was something along those lines.
- jackgavigan 3y agoI would argue that there's a fourth kind of ‘no’, when tech decides that enough is enough, and says "No, fuck you." We've reached that point in the UK, where the government has proposed draconian legislation[1] that would allow the government to force companies to create backdoors into encrypted messaging services. As a result, Whatsapp[2] and Signal[3] have said that they will pull out of the UK, and Apple[4] has said it will remove Facetime and iMessage from the UK if the legislation passes. 1: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/07/uk-government-very-close-eroding-encryption-worldwide https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/07/uk-government-very-clo... 2: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/mar/09/whatsapp-end-to-end-encryption-online-safety-bill https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/mar/09/whatsapp-... 3: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-64584001 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-64584001 4: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-66256081 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-66256081
- Doches 3y agoThis is explicitly the point of the article, really: the author’s third type of ‘no’ is “we literally can’t do this” — and that’s the situation in the UK. It’s not that Meta, Apple, and Signal are saying “fuck you” to the UK; it’s that they’re saying “there is literally no way for us to comply with this legislation, so our only legal option is to leave your market.” I agree that there’s a sort of implied, under-the-breath muttering of “…you morons”, but if there were a way for the messaging companies to comply they’d just…comply. Angrily and noisily, perhaps, but even in its current pathetic state the UK is too big a market to ignore.
- peoplefromibiza 3y ago> “there is literally no way for us to comply with this legislation, so our only legal option is to leave your market.” as much as I love my encrypted chats, both those sentences are not true. Devil's advocate would say: 1: Tech companies can obviously share the keys with the government, like they do in a group chat, it would simply mean "GVT has joined the chat" [1] and it could also work the same way wiretaps have always worked, under a very strict legal framework and behind a colossal amount of bureaucracy to authorize their use. 2: tech companies are not leaving those markets, they are simply buying time, they don't want to do the work, because it's work they will not profit from, but there's nothing preventing them on the technical side from doing it. [1] have you ever seen this on an Android device? https://i.imgur.com/XUxiUUr.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/XUxiUUr.jpeg
- isaacremuant 3y agoDon't worry lads, there's always "consultations". It's always so buteocratic and processy that we can pretend it functions like a democracy, where the will of the people is what matters, and not the will of lobbyists and elite class politicians who've never had to deal with rent prices and economic struggles.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThis was a great essay. I really liked his summary: > A Californian optimist would say that we’ll age out of this. The policy class that got their staff to print their emails will age out and be replaced by the generation that grew up sending emojis, and understands that tech policy is just as nuanced, complex and full of trade-offs as healthcare, transport or housing policy. A European would ask how well California handles healthcare, transport or housing.
- YesThatTom2 3y agoGreat article! Reminds me of the “Dear CEO: software is not magic” article in ACM Queue: https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=3325792 https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=3325792
- nickelpro 3y ago> There followed a desperate scramble to exempt over 100 professions, from doctors to truck drivers to hairdressers, before the whole thing had to be abandoned. A lot of people told the politicians about the problem, but the politicians just said “everyone always says every law will be a disaster” and ignored them. Oops. AB 5 passed, along with its long list of exceptions, and is law in California right now. It wasn't "abandoned" in any sense. Getting facts right is important to a persuasive argument
- larsiny 3y ago"The three companies, now also joined by Instacart and Postmates, funded a ballot initiative, Proposition 22, to exempt both ridesharing and delivery companies from the AB 5 requirements, while also giving drivers some new protections, including minimum wage and per-mile expense reimbursement. Proposition 22 passed in November 2020 with 59% of the vote.[8][9]" From: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Assembly_Bill_5_(2019) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Assembly_Bill_5_(20... So the law has an exemption for the exact workers it was targeting.
- nickelpro 3y agoSo what? It's not illustrative of the point the post is making. The post says, paraphrasing: "Sometimes technical people say 'No' and politicians are forced to accept the reality of that refusal" That didn't happen here. The policy was not proven impossible or implausible, the politicians involved weren't forced to reckon with unforeseen realities; the gig economy companies simply used a different political tactic to get their desired outcome. The effort was never abandoned, even if the targets of the effort ultimately found a way to circumvent the policy makers via a ballot initiative.
- cushychicken 3y agoWhere's the kind of "no" that means "that doesn't align with our business model, so we'll fight it tooth and nail"?
- hyperpape 3y agoIMO, it’s option (1) if the effect is small enough. Option (2) if there are serious knock on effects for society.
- light_hue_1 3y agoSome of these show a misunderstanding of the situation. > Most of the Canadian tech and indeed media industries pointed out how stupid this was, and Google and Meta said that given the choice, they’d stop letting news appear rather than pay a fee they could not control and that had no economic basis. The government thought this was the first kind of ‘no’ and a bluff, but actually, it was the second kind. Oops. This was part of the intent. It was not a mistake. The goal of the Canadian government has always been to build up Canadian media. Keeping out big foreign companies is in line with that.
- paulddraper 3y agoSort of a "oh no! well anyway..." sort of situation
- skybrian 3y agoThe encryption thing seems like a bit of subterfuge because, while using bad encryption wouldn’t do what some lawmakers want, an app update could do whatever you like that’s possible with a code change. It’s a whole lot more convenient to pretend that you can’t think of a way to do it.
- jjj123 3y agoHow is it that none of these are “no, because that hurts our bottom line even if it’s good for the public”? The framing in this article suggests that corporations and societies are usually aligned in their interests. This has not been my experience.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoEither it's so obvious that it wasn't mentioned, or it's blatantly not mentioned in some bizarre gaslighting gambit.