10 ms·
Harry Browne’s Rules of Financial Safety (1999)
- raintrees 3y agoBrowne wrote a number of books I found helpful, such as How I Found Freedom in an Unfree World. http://harrybrowne.org/ http://harrybrowne.org/ (corrected title)
- cryptoboy2283 3y agoRule 18: Don't trust a Generic Wall Street Dude in a Suit, especially his own selling book (to be fair this is already mirrored in the several rules, Rule 8 and others)
- iambateman 3y ago> “Rule 9: Don’t ever do anything you don’t understand.” In 2021 I bought $500 of stock in a VR software company who was crowdfunding. Price per share was $4 on a valuation of $60M. Fast forward two years and they raise again…this time at a valuation of $170M. Naturally, I assumed my $500 was worth close to $1500 on paper. Wrong. By some magic, the common stock share price went from $4 to only $4.75 even as the company tripled in value. Even though I “picked” well, my investment still lagged the general S&P of the same time period. I thought I understood what I was doing, but evidently I was the sucker.
- quonn 3y agoProbably due to „dilution“ where the number of shares is expanded, leading to lower value per share. I was surprised by this, too. It‘s perhaps the most important thing to know when working for startups or investing in them.
- blitzar 3y agoListed companies can and do this as well, typically not on a scale that is so noticeable.
- chii 3y ago> not on a scale that is so noticeable. it's more likely that the equity raised are deployed to produce more value than the "loss" due to dilution. For a startup, this might be harder, since the revenue is less clear, and thus the valuation is very inaccurate. For a mature/listed company, the revenue is much clearer and thus the valuation is more accurate.
- TuringNYC 3y agoSame story for most employees getting tons of equity in startups with a preference overhang https://www.holloway.com/definitions/liquidation-overhang https://www.holloway.com/definitions/liquidation-overhang
- ghaff 3y agoOne thing is that with small, especially non-public company investments, even if you have reasonably expert opinion that they're doing something special that isn't really on the radars on the mainstream investment community, market timing can still be off and you probably have no idea what's going on behind the scenes in terms of financing etc.
- ajross 3y agoThat kind of scam is exactly why securities trading is regulated. Before the IPO though, all bets are off and unless you're the VC writing the term sheet, you're the sucker.
- matsemann 3y agoIt doesn't have to be a scam. The pie got bigger, but perhaps because other people added more stuffing (money) to it. So one's original piece remained mostly the same.
- ajross 3y agoThe point is that with public securities, the SEC makes sure that it's not a scam. A public company can't just decide one day to issue a ton of stock and hand it over to an arbitrary entity, there's a regulatory process and legislated veto power held by the shareholders/board. When you buy an unregulated security (like shares in a "crowdfunded" startup), that's the protection you're not getting. Most people in this community tend to see the SEC as the enemy, but this is the value it provides.
- matsemann 3y agoHmm, where I live at least (not US) the company still have to act in a way that's in the interest of its owners. They can't do shady stuff just because they're not publicly traded. Or, they can, but it's not any more legal.
- robbintt 3y agoYou can sue in the US but there's really no case for OP. The company is "trying its best to deliver value".
- NhanH 3y agoPractically speaking, when getting stocks/ stock options in startup, you have to trust the integrity of the founders to the point not only for them to do the right things, but to fight for it. Preferred stocks (which VC gets) + dilution means there are a lot of ways to screw over common stocks, and at time when liquidation (that isn’t IPO) happens, a lot of lawyers will have the jobs of minimizing your stake. Which is to say that crowdfunding stock is a baaaaaaaaad idea. You are faceless to the founders, hard to see a scenario when things can go right.
- iambateman 3y agoFor sure. Meanwhile this latest round raised $12M from 5,600 investors in a couple days. So the management team is getting a massive signal that “this is good.”
- oezi 3y agoInvesting in any VC investment as a crowd investor at a valuation of more than 5m-10m is a near certain recipe for disaster.
- 303uru 3y agoPreferred stock. IE the rich get to dilute their risk by passing it on to you!
- blitzar 3y agoWhat was The Founders’s ownership share diluted down to? It wasn’t. What was Peter Thiel’s ownership share diluted down to? It wasn’t. What was your ownership share diluted down to? Point-zero-three percent.
- jsmith99 3y agoRule #0: before investing in a privately held company make sure you understand the capital structure and obligations and if there are classes of investor with guarantees or seniority.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThere are other replies saying you were "scammed", but just examine your own statements to see how something had to give (in this case, the common stock valuation) for anything to make sense. That is, look at your statement (emphasis mine): > Fast forward two years and they raise again…this time at a valuation of $170M. Naturally, I assumed my $500 was worth close to $1500 on paper. If they raised again, it's completely nonsensical to think your stock would have tripled in value. The only way to assume that's even possible is if the company tripled in value without raising more money. After all, "raising" is just another word for selling part of the company to other, new shareholders. When you sell part of something, that means the existing shareholders own less (as a percentage) of it. Yes, there are other bad tricks companies can play with different share classes and obscene preference rights for preferred shareholders (1x is pretty standard and totally fair in my opinion, anything more than that means to me that the company needed to raise under duress or has bad management). In other words, the outcome you described seems perfectly reasonable just by the rules of math. It says to me that many people just don't understand that "raising money" means selling a part of your company.
- iambateman 3y agoFor sure, I think I was a sucker, not that the company was acting outside of the law. In this case, I’m learning that my perspective on dilution is different from the founding team, who evidently feel fine tripling the share pool - as they should! Their odds of a major exit go up with millions in the bank, and the market is willing to bear that dilution, so of course they dilute. Meanwhile, I end up feeling like I would have been better off buying $450 worth of Dogecoin and a really big pack of oatmeal crème pies.
- username135 3y agoEveryone tries to get cute with financial strategies and investments, chasing those huge returns. You would be hard pressed to consistently beat the returns of a market fund over the life of your portfolio.
- jboy55 3y agoTo correct, the Fair Market Value of the common stock went from $4 to $4.75. Saying "Price" indicates you can sell at that value, you most likely can not sell your stock for any price right now. You should value those shares at 0 in your future financial planning. tldr; You bought $500 in lottery tickets with an undetermined draw date in the future with a high chance that it won't happen.
- iambateman 3y agoYea, I understand your point. Price is convenient shorthand for funny money. You’re right that I probably lit my cash on fire.
- jboy55 3y agoHey, I spent 6 years at a company collecting over 200k options, spending $2k exercising and having new money come in and try a 200:1 reverse split. Now, 15 years later, I'm a proud owner of common stock in a private company that is marginally profitable.
- glutamate 3y agoMissing: If the promised interest rate is higher than the market rate for bank accounts, there is an implied risk of default, in which case you would likely lose your entire investment.
- dalyons 3y agoNot missing. “ The cash portion should be kept in a money market fund investing only in short-term U.S. Treasury securities, so that you don’t have to evaluate credit risk. These securities are safer than bank accounts”
- dehrmann 3y agoThe funny lesson I got from SVB was why bother putting cash in a bank when they're just going to put it in treasuries, MBSes, etc. It's not exactly insured, but a short-term government money market fund seems safer, or a state muni fund if you're worried about the federal government defaulting.
- ghaff 3y ago>why bother putting cash in a bank In general, banks are set up to deliver consumer services that brokerages are not. However, in these days where treasury funds have ~5% interest rates, it makes sense to keep checking account balances at a level that they have a comfortable buffer for your preferences but no higher. I see my brokerage makes the case for maybe not needing a separate bank. Which may be true at this point. On the other hand having one doesn't really cost me much and would probably be a bit of a pain to change.
- soared 3y agoLike 15 of these can be replaced by having a financial advisor that you fully trust. Finding one is obviously a huge challenge, but makes almost of all this knowledge you can offload onto an expert. IMO fidelity is probably the closest you’ll get, they’re call centers/etc are all fully certified us-based people who aren’t on commission/etc.
- williamdclt 3y agoDoes anyone has a UK advisor they're overwhelmingly happy with?
- foobiekr 3y agoIn the US I have friends who are deliriously happy with their absolutely incompetent financial advisors. The problem is that it’s a sales role and the usual customer manipulation applies strongly.
- thenerdhead 3y agoRule #1 literally talks about why you don't. > Can you make big profits by relying on an expert who does have the proper qualifications? How do you find a true expert? That task is no easier than picking the right investments. If you don’t understand investing as well as the pros, you won’t know how to check those who seek to advise you. And you can’t rely on an advisor’s track record, even when it’s presented honestly. Track records tell you only how advisors did in the past – not how they will do next year.
- soared 3y agoThis is true historically where you needed to pick an individual advisor who managed your portfolio based on their experience/etc. That’s not really how the major companies like fidelity run it anymore - an advisor gets their certification and then fully plays by the playbook and isn’t allowed to even have their own track record. So you’re not getting some guys advise, you’re getting a company’s extremely researched strategy they built for individuals who match your needs. But really calling up any company and asking for a rep isn’t going to be great - I think being friends with someone who you trust as a friend first and then as someone who converts the playbook to your investments is best.
- insamniac 3y agoI haven't heard about this guy in a long time (2001 or so) but one thing he said has stuck with me for some reason, and pops into my mind often. I think he framed it as good general life advice to his young adult daughter. "No one owes you anything."
- roenxi 3y agoRule 11 deserves a rethink. There is an official policy that cash will lose some % of its value each year! Holding 25% of your wealth in cash is planning to throwing away years of life. For this sort of dead-basic investment advice, there is no point being ready for situations where a cash position is advantageous. People are much more likely to panic, do something stupid or get ground down by inflation. It is better to hold enough cash for an emergency fund then a mix of productive and hard assets. Gold is good as a hard asset, but anything that is durable would be ok. The advantages of cash are small compared to the risks and locked-in losses. EDIT Although thanks to other commentators I see that the fine print says that cash isn't literal cash and is actually "short-term U.S. Treasury securities"; making the whole complaint a bit moot. Once the money is in bonds it becomes a matter of strategic thinking rather than a simple "don't do that". I wouldn't do that right now, but given the level the article is pitched at I think it is fair advice as long as people read that cash doesn't mean cash cash.
- ghaff 3y ago>Rule 11 deserves a rethink. There is an official policy that cash will lose some % of its value each year! Holding 25% of your wealth in cash is planning to throwing away years of life. That depends on lots of things including how old you are and the current economic situation. For someone on the older side, getting a very low risk 5% on a chunk of their money doesn't seem like a half-bad strategy at the moment especially if they already own their home.
- roenxi 3y agoThey could hold gold. Similar risk profile, much more likely to hold value long term and be better to hand on to the kids if there is some left over. I'm not saying cash is so terrible that a nervous, confused and delicate grandma can't just eat the losses for security. I mean, sure. If you think you're probably going to lose money anyway then <10% a year is better than >10%! But a 25% allocation by default is just giving money to wealthy men wearing suits. They already own suits, they don't need it. Keep the wealth. Donate it towards lobbying for Georgism instead of new wars, maybe, if you feel like burning a few % on a cause.
- Eisenstein 3y agoRule #18: No one consistently follows a list of rules unless: they have personally learned why each rule exists from experience; they are the type of person who would have followed them anyway without knowing what they were; they are legally obligated to.
- kaycebasques 3y agoRule #1 (your career creates your wealth) is a gem. Rule #8 (make your own decisions) lacks self-awareness, especially after you read Rule #11 (bulletproof portfolio). I have been on a quest for a truly bulletproof portfolio for years. It's not easy. TANSTAAFL. Rule #11 also contradicts Rules #6 (no trading system works forever) and #9 (only do things you understand). That criticism aside, the author did a service to us all by writing this. If I had followed all these rules consistently throughout my life, I would probably be a wealthier man today.
- ghaff 3y agoWhere I've ended up is keeping some money aside to scratch whatever (mostly pretty conservative) investing itch I have and leaving the rest to a financial advisor. He's done stuff for my family for years and my feeling is that especially if I'm not going to actively manage my full portfolio, I'm better off with someone else doing it than just throwing the money into some index funds and calling it a day. (Though there have certainly been periods where that's probably been the right strategy.)
- c0pium 3y agoHave you back tested this hypothesis? It’s very unlikely to be true over a long period, say 15 years.
- ghaff 3y agoHard to say. Everything invested in the NASDAQ over the past 15 years would have been a great strategy. (Edit: high return strategy. Not necessarily a "good" one.) The 15 years before that probably not as good. Putting money in a small number of index funds and not even looking at them probably isn't a bad strategy and the costs are pretty low. But it's not bulletproof. I look at the financial advisor/firm as a form of diversification in part. I also keep my own portfolio small enough to have some (hopefully) intelligent opinion on whether the investments still make sense. (Including a decent weight on index funds.)
- 3y ago
- oezi 3y agoThe asset split of 25% each of gold, stocks, bonds and cash would have fared relatively bad over the years since 2007-09.
- soared 3y agoInvesting in gold now seems real not smart, same with that much cash.
- Ekaros 3y agoI think we might be in point of time where cash could make lot of sense. It is uncertain if we are in an other long running bull market yet. And certain sectors might be approaching a top already. Namely the biggest technology stocks.
- ghaff 3y agoAs someone on the older side, I generally agree with that. The tech sector has been very good for me over the past 10+ years and I still have a fair bit invested but I look at my portfolio and go "that's probably enough." I've been around long enough so that "Don't get greedy" is pretty ingrained. On the other hand, getting 5% on basically a treasuries fund looks pretty good on a risk-adjusted basis.
- sacado2 3y ago6% or so per year, in fact. Not so bad.
- prepend 3y agoWorse than a more typical 80% stock/15% bonds/5% cash. Having half your assets in cash and gold is very not smart.
- sacado2 3y agoI myself tend to lean toward stock-heavy allocations, but this is not something I'd recommend to everyone. I don't know if you remember the 2008-2009 period, or if you even were an investor back then, but those were... interesting times, to say the least. Almost-retired and newly retired didn't sleep well back then. Your portfolio lost 26% of its value that year, and losing 1/4 of your life's saving isn't something most people are ready to stomach, especially when they need it the most (year just before or just after retirement, typically). At the same time, Browne's allocation lost less than 1%. Since 2007 it had just one really bad year (2022, -13%, and even then it wasn't as bad as the above allocation), other than that, it was always positive or close to zero. A simple portfolio that almost never loses money and still has a decent, yet significantly smaller than its competitors, CAGR. That's a pretty good option for very conservative investors, IMO.
- spacedcowboy 3y agoAlternatively: buy AAPL :)
- jboy55 3y agoI remember in around 1998 I just started my career and one of my duties of my job was to go around to our alpha testers of a photography product we built and make sure things were going well. These customers were often pretty angry at my company due to them not being told it was an alpha version, but most often they were happy to see me try to help them out. Anyhow, at one of those customers, the designers, photoshop artists, and I got lunch and started talking. Prime topic was the 'outspoken IT guy' who had all sorts of 'theories' and 'rules' he lived by, often to the amusement of his coworkers. They goaded me into asking about his rules, "Ask him why he only uses chopsticks!". A: "Because they've never been able to train monkeys to use chopsticks" "Ask him his retirement strategy! He only invests in one thing, he's a true believer!" A: "I am a believer, I'm a believer in Steve Jobs, I put all of my money in whatever he does. I had money in Pixar, now I'm putting all my money in APPL". note: If he had 100k he put in at that time, he'd have 63 million now.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- spacedcowboy 3y agoFor some reason, I can't edit the above, but it was supposed to be a joke, hence the smiley. Seems like some people lacking a sense of humour (or at least, their sense of humour is sufficiently different to mine to not correlate).
- tqi 3y ago> GOLD not only does well during times of intense inflation, it does very well. In the 1970s, gold rose twenty times over as the inflation rate soared to its peak of 15% in 1980 Is this still true? As a layperson looking at the chart, it seems like gold has moved up and down a lot, but is more or less in the same place as it was 2 years ago.
- jtc331 3y agoIt’s not true. And using the 70s as proof is either dishonest or lacking knowledge: gold rose in the 70s because an artificial pinning of its price was removed.
- jonhohle 3y agoIsn’t that the point, though? It’s a hedge against inflation, a low risk, static asset to keep in place of cash. In 1970 a Carolla would have cost about 40oz of gold and today it would cost about 20oz. A barrel of crude was ⅒oz, today 1/20th oz.
- throw0101a 3y ago> It’s a hedge against inflation, a low risk, static asset to keep in place of cash. It is not a good hedge against inflation: * https://www.nber.org/papers/w18706 https://www.nber.org/papers/w18706 * https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3667789 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3667789 From Roy Jastram's The Golden Constant: The English and American Experience 1560 to 1976: > Andre Sharon, head of the international research department at Drexel Burnham, Inc., notes, “the value of gold essentially derives from its capacity to preserve real capital and purchasing power.”† I select this particular quotation because of the prestige of the organization and the position of the spokesman, but statements in this vein can be found in great numbers. They can be traced back for generations and in many countries. How can this proposition so contrary to statistical fact become so widely believed and quoted? Possibly because gold has preserved capital in cataclysmic cases it is easy to infer that it can be trusted to do the same in less severe circumstances. To extrapolate from gold’s protection in singular catastrophes to its use as a strategy against cyclical infation is an example of faulty inductive reasoning. * PDF: http://csinvesting.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/RoyJastram-TheGoldenConstant.pdf http://csinvesting.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/RoyJastram... * https://www.pwlcapital.com/will-gold-save-the-day/ https://www.pwlcapital.com/will-gold-save-the-day/
- tempaway12114 3y agoThe economy is like an opaque operating system that none of its users truly understand, and in 2008 it blue-screened and had to be crash-restarted using hacks that we don't really know the repercussions of yet.
- anon1199022 3y agoThis has some information but if you use all of them, this leads to a lot less or no oppurtunity in real world. It's like opposite of open mindset and being optimistic. Definitly works for average mind? and those who don't want to crate long term wealth. And 0 mention of index funds? sp 500 history and returns? For me that defines the limited view and limited information of the author (whoever he/she is) Gold has very little returns against real inflation in last 10 years. ok this has some mindless advices too, funny
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- StopTheWorld 3y ago> Rule 7: Don’t use leverage. > Using margin accounts or mortgages (for other than your home) puts you at risk to lose more than your original investment. As this says, margin accounts used in a certain way can put you at risk to lose more than your original investment. However, they are sometimes necessary to make investments with little to no additional risk. For example I may own $50,000 worth of XYZ Corp. and want to sell it on a Monday so as to buy $50,000 worth of DEF Corp on that same Monday. I can't do that if I don't have a margin account - settlement is usually T+2 days. You can incur additional risk with a margin account, but not as much if it's just to borrow money you are almost certain you will have in a few days.
- pjfin123 3y ago> As this says, margin accounts used in a certain way can put you at risk to lose more than your original investment. However, they are sometimes necessary to make investments with little to no additional risk. For example I may own $50,000 worth of XYZ Corp. and want to sell it on a Monday so as to buy $50,000 worth of DEF Corp on that same Monday. I can't do that if I don't have a margin account - settlement is usually T+2 days. This isn't really leverage. Your brokerage is just extending you temporary credit to paper over the fact that stock trades take two days to settle. You're never net long more than 100% of your investment.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dennis_jeeves1 3y ago16. Have relationships with functional/reliable people who will help you in a crisis. ( easier said than done)
- andruby 3y agoThis seems to have been easier in the past than it is now. Family traditionally played that role and I hope for a lot of us still does. We do seem to be living in a society more disconnected than before.
- pjfin123 3y agoYeah financial crises wouldn't be as bad if more of people's economic activity was more embedded in a family or local community with people they know personally.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- prepend 3y agoWhat’s the minimum wealth level where these are applicable? > Rule 13: Keep some assets outside the country in which you live. This is very impractical unless you have even money where 5% of your wealth international makes up for the cost to maintain. It could easily cost$5-10k in travel expenses to travel somewhere and establish accounts, plus the costs to account for and audit and maintain.
- capableweb 3y ago> It could easily cost$5-10k in travel expenses to travel somewhere and establish accounts, plus the costs to account for and audit and maintain. Maybe don't travel to Dubai (or similarly most-expensive-countries-in-the-world) then and establish accounts in a country that doesn't wildly out-rich you. Also, you don't have to stay longer than just a few days most likely. Besides, many places to allow internationals to signup for accounts also allow you to do a video call with account manager rather than going there in person.
- prepend 3y ago> Besides, many places to allow internationals to signup for accounts also allow you to do a video call with account manager rather than going there in person. I’m not so sure about that. No reputable banks where you’d want to have your other country account. And I don’t think the author considers “first cyber bank of Barbados” to fit this rule. And it’s certainly a horrible idea. > Maybe don’t travel to Dubai Please attempt to put together a travel budget from the US to some country that makes it cost reasonable for a “normal” person to travel and open an account. I picked $5-10k because if you have enough cash to keep overseas, you probably don’t want to take a mega bus to Toronto or Mexico City and scrimp to open the account and visit it.
- capableweb 3y agoSure, Seattle>Tokyo 1st October to 5th, $1000 flight ticket, hotel for 50-100/night, and you have like 3500 before you reach 5k.
- 3y ago
- ttul 3y agoRule #0: Be born into a privileged family. Your parents will raise you in a wealthier suburb where the schools are good and you network with other similarly privileged kids. The crime rate is low, so you’re less likely to end up injured or killed by violence. Air pollution is also likely lower, so less odds of death by asthma. Privilege gets you into college, where you study with other even more privileged kids, obtaining a designation that further cements your advantages. From this basis of privilege, your privileged ancestors will perhaps gift you some capital with which you can start your portfolio or purchase a home. You now begin you career and can start following the other steps to maintain your advantage. * edited to replace “white male” with “privileged family,” which is a bit fairer and less controversial.
- Racing0461 3y agoHow are white males a privileged class? The top 1% sure, but the average white male? If anything, white females are a privileged class.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoBeing privileged doesn't mean one's life has no hardship. There are plenty of poor, white men, and Oprah Winfrey is a billionaire. The way to think about it is take one of those poor white men and imagine he is black while the other things (wealth, schooling, location, etc) remain constant. While anything might happen, statistically that person's outcome would be worse as a black poor man than as a white poor man.
- Racing0461 3y agoYeah but that isn't because of race. Replacing the race doesn't work with asian men nor black men that come from africa as 0th gen/1st gen immigrants. This is uniquely an african american problem suggesting alternative reasoning (culture, education/values etc).
- threadweaver34 3y agoI'm a solid white male engineer at a FAANG. If I were a woman, the company would bend over backwards to make sure I advance. 80th percentile as a male, they're happy to keep me, but investing in me isn't a priority.
- jebarker 3y ago16 is the most important but needs expanding/modifying. Have a budget for everything, not just having fun. The easiest way to feel wealthy is to desire spending less.
- dehrmann 3y agoDamn you hedonic treadmill!
- pjfin123 3y ago> Rule 1: Your career provides your wealth > Build your wealth upon your career.You most likely will make far more money from your business or profession than from your investments. Only very rarely does someone make a large fortune from investments. This is good advice. If you're getting 2% dividend payments from stocks you need 5 million dollars to make 100k $/yr.
- robbintt 3y agoThe general thinking about this is to use a "safe withdrawal rate" of 3% to 4% of assets per year. Dividends are out of fashion since they don't offer tax deferral, they also aren't really easy to properly diversify although dividend funds are offered.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI'll call out Rule 14: Beware of tax-avoidance schemes. I'm always meeting people who are obsessed with avoiding taxes. It's better to just pay the minimum you owe legally, and sleep at night. They think "Oh, it's deductible" means "Oh, it's free."
- ghaff 3y agoThe one (very modest) trust I have some first-hand familiarity with, I'm pretty sure the effort and legal/accounting fees over the years long ago negated any tax savings associated with it.
- throw0101a 3y agoWith regards to Rule 11, especially: > GOLD not only does well during times of intense inflation, it does very well. No, it does not: * https://www.nber.org/papers/w18706 https://www.nber.org/papers/w18706 * https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3667789 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3667789 From Roy Jastram's The Golden Constant: The English and American Experience 1560 to 1976: > Andre Sharon, head of the international research department at Drexel Burnham, Inc., notes, “the value of gold essentially derives from its capacity to preserve real capital and purchasing power.”† I select this particular quotation because of the prestige of the organization and the position of the spokesman, but statements in this vein can be found in great numbers. They can be traced back for generations and in many countries. How can this proposition so contrary to statistical fact become so widely believed and quoted? Possibly because gold has preserved capital in cataclysmic cases it is easy to infer that it can be trusted to do the same in less severe circumstances. To extrapolate from gold’s protection in singular catastrophes to its use as a strategy against cyclical infation is an example of faulty inductive reasoning. * PDF: http://csinvesting.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/RoyJastram-TheGoldenConstant.pdf http://csinvesting.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/RoyJastram... * https://www.pwlcapital.com/will-gold-save-the-day/ https://www.pwlcapital.com/will-gold-save-the-day/
- OrvalWintermute 3y agoGold is the least bad currency option when compared to all the fiat currencies.
- throw0101a 3y agoGold is an unproductive asset, that does not do anything useful against inflation, and when used to back currency (e.g., Gold Standard) does not help with stability (and may actually cause instability): * https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/08/why-the-gold-standard-is-the-worlds-worst-economic-idea-in-2-charts/261552/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/08/why-the... * https://archive.ph/FWKcL https://archive.ph/FWKcL
- 3y ago
- gnfargbl 3y agoRule 7 (don't use leverage) really needs some additional clarification. If you're borrowing money using a mortgage in order to invest in stocks, that's probably not particularly smart. If you're taking on debt financing to grow an already-profitable business into an even more profitable business, that might be a different kettle of fish.
- stouset 3y ago> If you're borrowing money using a mortgage in order to invest in stocks, that's probably not particularly smart. If you have both a mortgage and investments, that is almost literally exactly what you’re doing. If your mortgage is below a 4% rate, this is almost certainly a great idea. If it’s above that, it may be a reasonable approach (up to a point). I have a mortgage at 2.375% and I can assure you I intend to pay it off over the full 30 year duration. Every early payment is an enormous opportunity cost compared to leaving it in the markets over the remaining duration.
- colonwqbang 3y agoWhy would an investment into your own business be less risky than a diverse investment in the general market? It doesn't make sense. Anyone who has both loans and stocks is "borrowing to invest in stocks". Because they are investing money that could be used towards paying off their loans. As long as the risk is carefully considered (not too high % loans etc) why not do it?
- OJFord 3y agoI might not re-mortgage in order to raise capital to invest, but if the interest rate is low (i.e. not right now) why would you put up more of a deposit than you have to? It's a cheap loan for however many years, and if it rises you can just put up more then, having benefited in the meantime.
- tejohnso 3y ago> You’re violating Rule #1 if you think your investments can be the sole source of your retirement wealth What? That's exactly what I'm investing for. What the hell else should I expect to fund my retirement?
- xvaier 3y agoIt should have been phrased, "your return on investments can be the sole source of your retirement wealth." I think what they mean is that the bulk of your wealth will be the capital that you put into your investments with a reasonable amount of interest/capital gain.
- abwizz 3y agoimo it means that you should also own a place to live in.
- ghaff 3y agoIn context, it's clearer. Don't be banking on that elusive big investment win to save the day if you're not otherwise on the trajectory you want to be on. Of course, you hope your investments will preserve your savings and augment them. But outsized investment gains won't in general get you there by themselves. (Also remember that the 10 years since this was written have been something of an outlier for the stock market.)
- IAmGraydon 3y agoSome of these are good, some are terrible. The rule about not using leverage is so bad that I can't take the rest of the article seriously. Anyone who really understands the purpose of debt and how to utilize it has to be laughing at this. The very best way to make money is with other people's money - this is a very basic tenet of wealth building. I challenge anyone to find an example of a business or wealth empire that wasn't built with some level of leverage.
- ghaff 3y ago>The rule about not using leverage is so bad that I can't take the rest of the article seriously. In the context of a personal investment portfolio, I'd question there are many circumstances where borrowing money to buy stock or whatever is a good strategy. This is not about building a business empire. (One can reasonably debate paying down a low interest mortgage early vs. continuing to save in other ways.)
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt makes me think of the "efficient frontier" idea that hedge funds are based on that make a case that proper use of leverage really can improve the risk/reward distribution of a portfolio but you can just as easily get into a trap where you juice a failing strategy by applying more leverage to cover up the fact it isn't working anymore, see the "Market Neutral" funds that blew each other up in the summer of 2007. Note Harry Browne ran as the libertarian candidate for US president more than once and is really famous for https://www.amazon.com/Permanent-Portfolio-Long-Term-Investment-Strategy/dp/1118288254 https://www.amazon.com/Permanent-Portfolio-Long-Term-Investm... In my mind it is quite similar to Diallo's "All Weather" strategy where inflation protected bonds play a role similar to gold in Browne's portfolio.
- ghaff 3y agoHedge funds, VCs, and so forth are also playing multiple games multiple times--so they can afford to play win some lose some so long as they don't lose too many and hit a few home runs. On the other hand, the person who took out a big HELOC to buy Yahoo stock in 1999 shortly before being laid off was making a bet that ended up being life-changing in a way they didn't intend it to be. (That's an extreme example but playing the averages both assumes that the average doesn't change and that they get enough rolls for the average to be a meaningful concept.)
- choeger 3y agoBut how does one even buy significant quantities of gold?
- dkga 3y agoLeverage to finance something you have an edge on can be good. Leverage to finance something you have no edge, like stock picking, is a path to ruin.
- sakopov 3y ago> You’re speculating when: You select individual stocks, mutual funds, or stock market sectors you believe will do better than the market as a whole. So no individual stocks and funds - got it. What am I supposed to buy to be an investor? A financial advisor?
- robbintt 3y agoWhole market funds, but preferably multi market funds. Basically VT. But you can foray into VFIAX.
- dang 3y agoRelated: Golden Rules of Financial Safety (1999) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15586230 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15586230 - Oct 2017 (110 comments) The 16 Golden Rules of Financial Safety - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10842766 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10842766 - Jan 2016 (1 comment) I've nicked 1999 from that other title. If it's wrong, hopefully someone can figure out the right year (https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law).
- Tokkemon 3y agoA better title would be "Harry Brown's 17 Rules for Keeping Your Wealth Once You Already Have it, and Good Luck Getting There!"
- wmf 3y agoRule 1 directly addresses this point.
- vparikh 3y agoMy simple rules about money and investing for the future: - Max out 401K and place it in S&P 500 mutual fund - Take an additional 15% and but into an S&P 500 mutual fund - Don't look at it, just keep buying at regular intervals until you decide to retire. The rest of your money - do what you wish (within reason) and stay out of debt. Simple? Yes. Contrary? Yes. Proven historical returns that beat inflation? Yes - https://www.officialdata.org/us/stocks/s-p-500/1973?amount=100&endYear=2023 https://www.officialdata.org/us/stocks/s-p-500/1973?amount=1... You can thank me when you retire :)
- pallas_athena 3y agoRelated (as in: investment advice for those who don't want to think too much about it) https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Bogleheads%C2%AE_investment_philosophy https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Bogleheads%C2%AE_investment_... https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Simple_non-US_portfolios https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Simple_non-US_portfolios https://www.reddit.com/r/Bogleheads/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bogleheads/
- jdkee 3y ago"Any attempt to be clever in assigning portions to the investments probably will do more harm than good. I prefer the simplicity of allocating 25% to each of the four investments." Why would you assign 50% of your portfolio to non-productive assets?