8 ms·
Low dose radiation cancer 2x worse than predicted by LNT model
- pfdietz 3y agoThe large INWORKS cohort study of nuclear workers finds that in the low dose range (0-100 mGy, or 0-10 rad) the solid cancer mortality risk per unit exposure is twice that predicted by the LNT model. Radiation appears to become more dangerous at low doses over prolonged periods, the opposite of the assertion of some nuclear energy advocates.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat would be a very good argument against the further deployment of coal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- csours 3y agoTo be clear, since some people don't know: https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/1997/fs163-97/FS-163-97.html https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/1997/fs163-97/FS-163-97.html
- pfdietz 3y agoAs I have pointed out, the radioactivity in uranium ore is higher than the radioactivity in coal, when comparing the amount of ore and the amount of coal that needs to be mined to produce a given amount of energy in today's power plants.
- hgomersall 3y agoNuclear plants don't tend to burn the fuel into tiny particulates and send them into the atmosphere.
- pfdietz 3y agoThey liberate decay products into the environment when the uranium ore is processed. Coal fired plants aren't putting ash into the atmosphere either these days, in the US. Bottom ash never went into the air, and fly ash is efficiently trapped in electrostatic precipitators and bag houses.
- sudosysgen 3y agoWhat is the p value for the hypothesis that the integral of the correct model from 0 10 rads is 2x larger than the integral for the LNT model?
- nielsbot 3y agoInteresting… My mother was a flight attendant for 35 years and she developed breast cancer later in life. She was told it was probably environmental not genetic based on testing. You do get additional radiation exposure while flying. Wonder if we should also study the effects of higher radiation exposure in the airline industry.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://srag.jsc.nasa.gov/spaceradiation/What/What.cfm https://srag.jsc.nasa.gov/spaceradiation/What/What.cfm https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/aircrew/cosmicionizingradiation.html https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/aircrew/cosmicionizingradia... Sounds like there is enough to evidence to perform a longitudinal cancer study across air transport workers to better understand the potentially increased cancer risk. EDIT: Is hazard pay warranted? Also, perhaps airlines should have to provide estimated cumulative exposure to employees based on their flight trip logs. Estimation should be straightforward based on flight track logs combined with cosmic radiation satellite data.
- klipt 3y agoCan't they just make all employees wear lead vests? I guess the added weight would cost a lot in fuel...
- samus 3y agoUnlike in medical facilities, the radiation comes from multiple directions. Also, the crew moves around the plane. The vests would have to cover an impractically large area. Also, when radiation is blocked by matter, secondary radiation is generated. Since the composition of cosmic radiation is for sure different than the one found in other occupational settings, lead vests might or might not have the same effect. Also, the aluminium skin of the aircraft already has a similar effect. There might not be that much to be done practically. It would be interesting though to let flight crew wear radiation badges.
- 3y ago
- rich_sasha 3y agoI understood LNT is already considered to be too pessimistic at low dose. Would this mean it is in fact optimistic? And low dose radiation is actually quite bad?
- pfdietz 3y ago[flagged]
- kortex 3y agoI think the main takeaway is we probably should not put too much stock in a linear-time-invariant-cumulative model of radiation mapping to cancer risk. Sure it's the easiest to calculate, but that's the streetlamp search fallacy. It's far more likely that the shape of the radiation dose curve matters quite a bit on how the body responds. E.g. the difference between 10 discrete 1 Gy events, vs one 10 Gy event, vs 10 Gy absorbed over a year.
- csours 3y agoThis is something I don't understand about sunburn - If I'm exposed to 15 minutes straight of sunlight, I will burn, but in 2-5 minute chunks spread out over several hours, I can tolerate much more. Is there an equation for this? Like a small coefficient with a high power? 0.1*Te^4 ? Or am I wrong about how sunburn works? This one just shows time as a straight factor, no exponent: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6345802/#:~:text=However%2C%20temperature%20is%20not%20the,3%20s)16%2C17 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6345802/#:~:tex....
- peteradio 3y agoSaturation. This impacts so many different systems. You can't really model it with simple polynomials, it requires step functions.
- wnevets 3y agoIf you look at the history of what is considered a safe dosage of radiation you'll notice the amount only ever goes down, never up.
- pazimzadeh 3y agoLow-dose radiation from A-bombs elongated lifespan and reduced cancer mortality relative to un-irradiated individuals https://genesenvironment.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41021-018-0114-3 https://genesenvironment.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/...
- wnevets 3y agoDid this increase the safe dosage amount of radiation?
- pazimzadeh 3y agoThis shows that the idea that there is no safe level of radiation on principle is wrong.
- wnevets 3y agoI don't know if you're being serious or not.
- sixstringtheory 3y ago> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- wnevets 3y agoWhich of the two plausible interpretations is the strongest? Please enlighten me esteemed HN guideline expert. I am asking because I don't know the answer.
- pazimzadeh 3y agoHow do we reconcile this with the study which found that low dose radiation surrounding atomic bomb detonation was protective? Low-dose radiation from A-bombs elongated lifespan and reduced cancer mortality relative to un-irradiated individuals https://genesenvironment.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41021-018-0114-3 https://genesenvironment.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/...
- kortex 3y agoI'm guessing it might have something to do with the "impulse curve" of the radiation. Atom bomb would look like a spike with exponential decay. This study looks at constant low-grade exposure. It might be that a single main radiation event (if it doesn't acutely kill or sicken you too bad) causes an inflammatory response and increased mutation detection, while constant low-grade provides many more opportunities for errors to slip through the cracks.
- psychphysic 3y agoIt's in the article
- api 3y agoDifferent forms of radiation maybe?
- cududa 3y agoThis is one study. There have been endless studies showing the negative effects of people near the Trinity test site. In fact, the government still pays out money to victims. This is a nonsense study that was never reproduced. Moreover, Japan provided extraordinary health care to victims that survived the bombings. I'm as pro-nuclear energy as you can get, but trying to hand wave away the dangers of radiation exposure is actively detrimental to the cause. https://www.justice.gov/civil/common/reca https://www.justice.gov/civil/common/reca
- pazimzadeh 3y agoThose things are not in disagreement with each other. It could just be that the bomb was a selection event which selected people who have the best ability to repair DNA, which protects from cancer-causing mutations in general. Plus, the specific amount of radiation that is protective vs. cancer would probably only exist at a specific distance from the detonation site. So, even if the study is 100% accurate and reproducible, in no way is it an argument for dropping more bombs. You can't throw away data because you think someone could theoretically use it to support a bad idea.
- scythe 3y agoI drew a line on Figure 1. https://i.postimg.cc/3r6vgz5s/cancer-lntm.jpg https://i.postimg.cc/3r6vgz5s/cancer-lntm.jpg I was careful to ensure it was horizontal (y = 308 px, thanks GIMP). It is apparent that cancer rates at 60, 120, 180 mGy were higher than at 240 mGy. This may raise some questions about how to interpret the data.
- psychphysic 3y agoDo you know what a confidence interval is?
- Mathnerd314 3y agoI think that's the point, the paper is saying "a linear model was a good fit" when P=0.11. It's not at all a strong fit, compared to e.g. physics where p=1e-5 is desired. You'd think with 300k data points the results would at least be "statistically significant", p<0.05. The only data they present is averages over countries so I wouldn't be surprised if there was a huge effect of which site the worker was at, and their analysis deliberately ignores this effect by averaging, instead of including it as an explicit variable that explains most of the variation.
- psychphysic 3y agoR coefficient is how you assess fit to model. P is for significance you might use it to assess which model is better (typically using an interaction term). That 0.11 shows that the alternative model is not significantly better than the model presented. That might be confusing because typically everyone just thinks p<0.05 is good.
- scythe 3y agoI work in this field. I know lots of statistics. Do you?
- psychphysic 3y agoX DOUBT.
- jvanderbot 3y agoI've been fascinated by the fact that electricians have a 2x greater risk of brain cancer than the general public. There are probably tons of environmental effects we're discounting / not modelling.
- newZWhoDis 3y agoI would suspect something like “the adhesive in electrical tape is carcinogenic” over “magnetic field cause cancer”. But who knows. If they do we are deeply, truly fucked.
- eternityforest 3y agoI mean until recently electrical tape did in fact use lead stabilizers. Pretty sure a lot still does.
- jjoonathan 3y agoElectrification happened 100 years ago in the US.
- regularfry 3y agoOne story we were told in high school physics was that at one point there was a worry about power lines being linked with leukaemia cases. And yes, there was a statistical correlation. Turned out to be the weedkiller they were using to keep down the plants at the base of the pylons.
- civilitty 3y agoLots of professions have significantly greater brain cancer risk than the general public like roofers, sheet metal workers, most people that deal with plastic manufacturing or cleaning solvents, and… waitresses [1]. [1] https://medicine.yale.edu/news-article/certain-occupations-put-people-at-higher-risk-for-developing-brain-cancer/ https://medicine.yale.edu/news-article/certain-occupations-p...
- api 3y agoLots of chemical exposure in that profession too.
- fortran77 3y agoSome US Airports had backscatter x-ray scanners used by the TSA with their shiny badges who certainly had no training on x-ray safety. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2220673/TSA-quietly-replaces-x-ray-scanners-major-airports-safer-devices--moves-old-machines-smaller-cities.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2220673/TSA-quietly... I now have cancer and am working with law firms on legal options.
- unsupp0rted 3y ago> ProPublic reports that researchers have estimated that widespread use of backscatter x-rays will cause between 6 and 100 cases of cancer each year among fliers. > The TSA maintains the devices are within federal safety limits. I've always "opted out" of backscatter machines. In about half the cases airport staff were exasperated with me. In Australia they interrogated me for "the specific reason" I requested a manual pat-down instead. I made one up. But my real reason was that I fly a lot and I don't need to be blasted with millimeter wave x-rays for no good reason.
- fortran77 3y ago"Millimeter Wave" machines are NOT "backscatter x-ray" machines. Millimeter Wave is a radio-wave device.
- ewoodrich 3y agoI've only ever seen mmWave full body scanners, TSA began phasing out backscatter X-rays in 2012 [1] and according to this [2] backscatter X-ray is no longer used in US airports. Maybe different in other countries, I don't know. mmWave is radio frequency not X-ray and similar frequencies are used in 5G. [1] https://www.propublica.org/article/tsa-removes-x-ray-body-scanners-from-major-airports https://www.propublica.org/article/tsa-removes-x-ray-body-sc... [2] https://www.lancsindustries.com/blog/what-you-need-to-know-about-backscatter-x-rays-and-safety/ https://www.lancsindustries.com/blog/what-you-need-to-know-a...
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoMakes you wonder how safe the hospital staff is using XR fluoroscopy day in day out? (Cath Labs, GI teams, etc.)
- athenot 3y agoThey wear 30lb lead aprons. On a practical note, it's back strain from having that thing on 10-12h a day.
- sarchertech 3y agoThey're supposed to, but they frequently don't according to my wife (ER doctor).
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoFrom my experience everyone uses it (perhaps the emergency setting is more intense). But my point on low radiation is that you are not behind a lead wall. Below knees, arms, head are exposed. Depending on the design the seams between sections of the protective gear will also leak. And the protective gear gets tested but only periodically not before every use. All in all everything seems to align with some probability of prolongued low radiation exposure much like nuclear power plant staff.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoI'm extremely suspicious of xray machines at the dentist and the doctors office. I refuse any xray that isnt absolutely vital. Medical professionals do them as a box checking exercise to prevent mal practice law suits, but they are largely useless. They do catch issues, but if you are young and healthy, the radiation risk is definitely there.
- eternityforest 3y agoAnother reason to be more injury avoidant than most young people usually are! I have lots of friends who sometimes have to go to the doctor for a sprain or hairline fracture or something, often from sports. It just doesn't seem worth it to do stuff like volleyball or any high impact sport.
- nradov 3y agoFractures are very rare in volleyball. High impact sports such as weightlifting are critical for bone health and building skeletal muscle. Lack of bone density and insufficient muscle are certainly more dangerous than an occasional x-ray. https://peterattiamd.com/ama37/ https://peterattiamd.com/ama37/ I do agree with avoiding sports that have a high risk of concussions due to head impacts.
- eternityforest 3y agoLots of people seem to make it to old age, still being almost as healthy and active as an average young person, sans any broken bones, without lifting much of anything heavy or playing any sports, they seem to just do causal swimming or hiking or tai chi or something. And there are gym rats who have a life of all kinds of random aches and pains despite being very strong, then have heart attacks, so I'm super confused on what you're actually supposed to do, but it definitely seems like there's a limit to how much people really need for close to optimal health. The science seems pretty clear that having muscle is better for your health, but it seems really hard to figure out how much is actually needed, and whether someone who's already reasonably in shape from walking and doing projects actually needs any lifting outside the "near zero injury chance and you probably won't be sore tomorrow" range for maximum health issues prevention.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paulmd 3y agoI really dislike the way various "skeptic" communities tend to rally around "X thing is safe/maybe actually good". Like global warming is another example. Science already tends to be very conservative and build a lot of bias towards the null hypothesis. And then amateur skeptics take that and add even further bias towards null/maybe-actually-good. Maybe global warming will make the plants grow better (no), maybe it won't do anything at all (no)! These very faint studies around things like radiation hormesis get blown into loud dissent that "maybe radiation actually good?". But god forbid you ask them to wear a mask to prevent the spread of a deadly disease, they want to see long-term studies in triplicate with massive p-factors.
- stefantalpalaru 3y ago[dead]
- talldatethrow 3y agoMy parents have owned homes and grown many food plants in many cold coastal climates near water (let's say Oregon) and in hot valley climates (ca central valley) where there is definitely less water. Things grow much better in the warmer area, but you have to water like crazy. I personally do wonder if we couldn't grow food where the water is, if only those areas weren't as cold as they currently are. Obviously makes you wonder if the rainfall in those areas would still stay.
- Retric 3y agoCold northern climates are cold because they get less sunlight which then translates into lower temperatures. Simply increasing temperature wouldn’t provide more sunlight in the spring and fall which means the growing seasons don’t actually expand nearly as much as you might think. Also, we can grow stuff as far north as Canada while the equator runs though South America. People used to Mercator projections get a wildly incorrect view of what earth’s surface looks like, but in reality the loss of farmland wildly outweighs any possible gains.
- 3y ago
- Solvency 3y agoI love how technologists/programmmers/enthusiasts will vehemently argue that EMFs, iPhones, Airpods, and all of the other countless devices constantly bombarding us with "non-ionizing radiation" is "completely and utterly harmless". Meanwhile even the most ancient patriarchal doctors with obsolete worldviews will suggest aspiring fathers may want to avoid having their phones in their pockets 24/7. No one knows jack shit, as we're finally discovering with PFAS, forever chemicals, etc. Stick with the earth.
- ch4s3 3y ago> will suggest aspiring fathers may want to avoid having their phones in their pockets That's because of the heat. We know for sure that higher temperatures temporarily lower sperm production. Those "ancient patriarchal doctors with obsolete worldviews" actually know a few things.
- bena 3y agoThis is about ionising radiation though.
- omgJustTest 3y agoNote: the title is misleading and contrary to the authors' conclusion. Where are the moderators? "The association between cumulative dose, lagged 10 years, and solid cancer mortality was reasonably well described by a linear model (fig 1); inclusion of a parameter describing the linear association between cumulative dose and solid cancer contributed substantially to model goodness of fit (supplementary table B). The addition of a parameter for the square of cumulative dose led to only a modest improvement in model goodness of fit compared with the linear model (likelihood ratio test =2.51, df=1; P=0.11), suggesting some downward curvature (that is, a negative estimated coefficient for the quadratic term). The addition of a parameter for an exponential term in the model led to a modest improvement in model goodness of fit for a linear-exponential model compared with the linear model (likelihood ratio test =3.17, df=1; P=0.08), again suggesting some downward curvature. To assess the trend over the lower cumulative dose range, we estimated associations between cumulative dose and solid cancer mortality over restricted ranges of 0-400 mGy cumulative dose (excess relative rate 0.63 (0.34 to 0.92) per Gy), 0-200 mGy cumulative dose (0.97 (0.55 to 1.39) per Gy), 0-100 mGy cumulative dose (1.12 (0.45 to 1.80) per Gy), 0-50 mGy cumulative dose (1.38 (0.20 to 2.60) per Gy), and 0-20 mGy cumulative dose (1.30 (−1.33 to 4.06) per Gy) (supplementary table C). Over the restricted range of 0-200 mGy cumulative dose, the association between cumulative dose and solid cancer mortality was well described by a linear model, and the addition of a parameter for the square of cumulative dose led to minimal improvement in model goodness of fit compared with the linear model (likelihood ratio test=0.54, df=1; P=0.46)." They say over and over that linear model (with relative risk = 1 at 0 dose) is a good fit! this is LNT. They say the improvements of adding the other fit are marginal. The error bounds here are large, and the deviation is small but apparently systematic or real below 200mGy. The authors, as far as I can tell, are just reporting the figures without claiming LNT is wrong.
- VikingCoder 3y agoUm, I don't think the HN title is contrary... Quoting: > What this study adds > The results of an updated study of nuclear workers in France, the UK, and the US suggest a linear increase in the relative rate of cancer with increasing exposure to radiation > Some evidence suggested a steeper slope for the dose-response association at lower doses than over the full dose range > The risk per unit of radiation dose for solid cancer was larger in analyses restricted to the low dose range (0-100 mGy) and to workers hired in the more recent years of operations
- zosima 3y agoIf you look at the relative risk curve (the very last page of the supplementary data), most of the exposure levels contain 1 in the relative risk estimate (also please notice that for some reason the confidence interval is 90%, if choosing the customary 95% all relative risk confidence intervals would probably overlap relative risk of 1.0): https://www.bmj.com/content/bmj/suppl/2023/08/16/bmj-2022-074520.DC1/ricd074520.ww1.pdf https://www.bmj.com/content/bmj/suppl/2023/08/16/bmj-2022-07... The fact that ~10mGy seems to not have 1.0 in the confidence interval is kind of bothering to me. Normal annual background radiation should be about ~3.5mGy (so 10mGy is about 3 years normal background radiation) and getting an increased solid tumor mortality risk from normal radiation levels, does suggest that something else has not quite been controlled for. Also the same group did the same paper on the same cohort before: https://www.bmj.com/content/351/bmj.h5359?ijkey=9f35e31bf918d31d82b100402db59f9835700e41&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha https://www.bmj.com/content/351/bmj.h5359?ijkey=9f35e31bf918... This just seems to be updated with a slightly older population.
- gwillen 3y agoThanks for linking the graph, that's kind of wild. I agree with you that the lowest datapoint seems crazy. I can think of a few explanations. - Random bad luck. - As you say, failing to control for something -- although, if you then treat the lowest datapoint as being effectively the default risk, this would suggest support for radiation hormesis (that people who got a bit more than background radiation actually did better.) - Some kind of data collection artifact. Perhaps the people with the absolute lowest dose, in a radiation-worker dataset, are selected for being ones who are not getting an accurate measurement (i.e. sloppy about wearing dose badges or something), and those people genuinely do have worse outcomes.
- lvlabguy 3y agoComparing background radiation to exposure from artificial radiation sources does not sound right to me. The background radiation is absorbed relatively evenly by the body surface. However, various artificial radiation exposure is local, such as dental x-rays or CT, which, for example, will increase the thyroid cancer risk at seemingly small exposure levels compared to cosmic radiation exposure.
- deleted 3y ago
- maratc 3y agoThese special studies are good for a scientific consumption, but they don't do much to make the results comprehensible to the general public. In this specific case, what's missing is the bigger perspective, like this: "If we look at the 100,000 average dead people, we'll find that 30,000 of them died from cancer. Now, we are looking at 100,000 dead low dose nuclear workers, and we have previously thought that 30,010 of these would have died from cancer, but now we've found that number to be closer to 30,020." This really puts "2x worse" into a proper context, which is: there are low-risk occupational hazards in nuclear industry.
- csours 3y agoOther numbers are more meaningful than "died of cancer" - Total time with cancer - including time without symptoms - Total time affected by cancer as a disease - time with symptoms - Total lifespan lost - how young did a person die of the disease There's probably no way to really know #1, #2 is hard to gather information on, #3 is more do-able.
- landemva 3y agoWhy are 1 and 2 more meaningful?
- maratc 3y agoThe relevant measurement is called QALY, or quality adjusted life years. It is meant to be a meaningful representation of a disease burden. As an example, thyroid cancer is hardly curable, but a common remedy is to remove the thyroid and to rely on medications going forward. Somebody in this condition can have a long quality life otherwise. Pancreatic cancer, on the other way, has very low survival rate, so it cuts a lot of QALYs out of a person’s life. It would be great if the authors would quantify their findings in QALY, as in e.g. “while we have previously believed that the low dose radiation results in a loss of x days (QALY wise), we now believe that number to be 2x days”.
- omgJustTest 3y agoThank you for making this point, I made it earlier in the day in a less convincing way... 2x is not even claimed in the article.
- m_dupont 3y agoYeah the title here really overstates the strength of the conclusions. Didn't read every table in the paper but they clearly state that a linear fit was parsimonious with the data, and adding quadratic and exponential terms only modestly improved the performance but neither even had a p-value of less than 0.05 (I am aware that overreliance on p-values is a bit of an issue, but nonetheless). Its also easy to see from the graph in the paper that the linear fit goes through all the error bars. * edit / Disclaimer: only skim-read the article, I should be working right now
- yongjik 3y agoLNT is a funny model: it's extremely simple yet people misunderstand it all the time. Like, it's basically how you would model loss of money would affect your finance. You lose ten cents, you're out of ten cents. You lose ten million dollars, you're out of ten million dollars. Totally proportional. Now the funny thing is, nobody sane would say "Losing a quarter that fell out of your pocket is losing money, gambling away a million dollars is also losing money! There's no threshold beyond which losing money becomes not losing money, therefore having a loose pocket is as bad as gambling addiction!" Yet change the subject from dollars to radiation, and so many people run around saying "No threshold! That means there's no safe dose! Living next to a working nuclear reactor is as bad as walking into the ruins of Chernobyl!"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ed_mercer 3y agoSee also: Radiation hormesis which is the hypothesis that low-level radiation is actually good for your body. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hormesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hormesis
- DoreenMichele 3y agoActual title: Cancer mortality after low dose exposure to ionising radiation in workers in France, the United Kingdom, and the United States (INWORKS): cohort study It's 150 characters, so had to be edited down somehow to fit the 80 character limit. This was not a good edit. I would likely have edited it down to this: International study: Cancer mortality after low dose work radiation exposure Beyond what others have said here, I found the current title -- Low dose radiation cancer 2x worse than predicted by LNT model -- extremely confusing because I thought it was talking about low dose radiation cancer treatments being ineffective.