9 ms·
Close to half of American adults favor TikTok ban, Reuters/Ipsos poll shows
- ddxv 3y agoIf there is sensitive data or tools at TikToks disposal, they should be dealt with by changing the laws. Rule by Law sets the US apart from China. We should not break our ideals in the name of politics and security theater.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thiagoharry 3y agoClose to half people agree with censorship. Of course, it's a product of propaganda. If people are afraid that foreign apps collect data about their citizens, they could do like in Europe and regulate with laws what is allowed to be collected and stored. Oh, if this is done, it also would prevent the American companies and their government to do the same...
- mvnuweucxqokii 3y agoThe concern is not data collection. The concern is demoralizing content.
- piskov 3y ago> China's government could use TikTok to control software on millions of devices and drive narratives to divide Americans Obviously other countries should ban US services as US government could (huh, “could”) use them to control software on millions of devices and drive narratives to divide %nation placeholder%? :-) Jeez the level of hypocrisy.
- throwaway2990 3y agoExcept tiktok is owned by the CCP while Facebook Twitter etc is not owned by the US government.
- piskov 3y agoIf only there were other means to achieve government goals besides the contractual “ownership” — see Twitter files as an example.
- thiagoharry 3y agoThe distinction is irrelevant if the government branches have power to use Facebook and Twitter data as they wish. Or if these companies are near monopolies, which gives them great powers comparable with a government.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> to use Facebook and Twitter data as they wish Data collection is the issue politicians are presenting, but I think the actual worry is in the other direction: the influence the Chinese govt can have over the US population through algorithmic and explicit feed changes.
- paxys 3y agoAre you under the impression that other countries don't ban US services for exactly this reason?
- piskov 3y agoAnd how are they labeled for that by US? :-) You don’t understand, it’s different (c).
- flappyeagle 3y agoAdversaries. Goes both ways.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoChina does ban US services for exactly this reason. Principles that work in a free society work within and between free societies. They don't work on an international scale between nations that are opposed to each other, geopolitically, the incentives are all wrong. Leaving morals and ideology aside, simply strategically, Russia, China and the US are all wise to distrust each other and put limits on how each other's corporations can act within their boundaries. It's not the same situation between allies. Like, sure the US can use facebook to mess with Germany or the UK politically, but their incentives aren't to destabilize their allies.
- piskov 3y ago> but their incentives aren't to destabilize their allies Why not? Take that “green” politics for example that lead Germany to close a lot of atomic plants and, now, basically, at mercy of US gas (which production surged 80%, if I’m not mistaken) And then US subsidies to move production to US so that some VW plant is cheaper in US than in Germany
- kelnos 3y agoI think it's fine for an otherwise-free society to decide that another country's government poses a threat to free societies elsewhere, and then do things like ban foreign investment and exports into the problematic country and its companies. But not allowing their own citizens to access content produced in that problematic country smacks of Soviet-style cold war isolation. Or, hell, the Chinese government's block on any outside news or media it doesn't agree with. Strategically, if the US (and others) want to remain free, democratic societies, doing things like banning TikTok is a step in the wrong direction.
- empath-nirvana 3y ago> But not allowing their own citizens to access content produced in that problematic country smacks of Soviet-style cold war isolation. Nobody is talking about that, though. Almost none of the content on Tik-Tok is produced in China. They're just talking about banning _the corporation_ from operating in the united states.
- acumenical 3y agoIt is not the same. The US government does not partially own Instagram or Twitter, and I've never seen pro-US narratives driven on either platform. I usually see the opposite if anything.
- piskov 3y agoTo be pro-US (meaning something that benefits US government) doesn’t mean it is plain “pro-US” content as in mentioning US at all.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoUS control over tech companies is a bit subtler than that and mostly manifests in certain people going through a revolving door between the executive suite in tech companies and some job in the military-industrial complex, as well as lucrative government contracts for the companies (look at how the deal was done for cloud services for the Pentagon). It's _extremely_ common for people with NSA or similar experience to have very senior positions at US tech companies, and there's a reason for that. It's nothing formal, it's more that having friendly people on both sides of the fence is mutually beneficial for the government and for those companies.
- nrb 3y agoDoes the US have a great firewall? Is it even in the same universe of information control as CCP? “This other government is provably controlling information flow and punishing thoughtcrime” is plenty of justification to be suspicious of China’s motives in a way that doesn’t feel blatantly hypocritical to me given that we are on the receiving end of similar suspicion by our allies and enemies.
- ForHackernews 3y agoIMHO it's worth banning all algorithmic social media in the name of public health. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/09/has-the-smartphone-destroyed-a-generation/534198/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/09/has-the...
- CountHackulus 3y agoMay as well ban video games, dungeons and dragons, and rock and roll while we're at it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 3y agoMaybe that devil's liquid ethanol too to boot. The war on drug is going great as it is kept going so why not extend it again.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI suspect the key word, here, is "adults."
- raincom 3y ago'half of American adults' in the poll sample.
- 1270018080 3y agoYes that is how polls work
- beej71 3y agoOf course in the poll sample. Show me a poll that polled every single American.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoIf the rational for the ban is "too much influence over the public," the root problem is that apps shouldn't have that much influence over the public. Being that artificially engaging, algorithmic and addictive is a public health hazard... But no leader is going to say that because the US is fine with the influence such apps project to other countries (among other things). And that influence doesn't have to be directly from the U.S. govt.
- scarface_74 3y agoYes. Let’s start having the government banning everything that is a health hazard. Let’s have a “War on Algorithms”. That worked remarkably well for drugs. So what happens when we give the government the power to start banning websites that surface content algorithmically - like say Hacker News. I can see next we have to ban Reddit because r/cscareerquestions have a generation of computer grads thinking that if they spend months “grinding leetCode” and trying to working “for a FAANG” and failing, they feel like a failure.
- j_maffe 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope
- scarface_74 3y agoWho defines "too much influence over the public,"? Which has more influence TikTok or conservative news media that convinced people to try to overthrow the government?
- brucethemoose2 3y agoOverly engaging social media has weaponized conservative news media, among many other things. Blasting propaganda over cable, radio, magazines and such is as old as America itself. Thats fine. Its part of the deal. But a device that lives in your pocket, essentially required for participating in society, with many billions spent on stopping you from disengaging is an entirely different thing. There is no good historical precedent for how psycologically manipulative that is. Its unacceptable because China could quite probably start a civil war with such influence. Its not OK for Facebook, Google, or any government to have that unchecked power even if they just use it to sell ads or whatever. So... I dunno where the line should be. But wherever that is, we are well past it.
- pseudosavant 3y agoI suspect this view is held by American adults who aren't from a young enough generation to use TikTok. While Facebook and Instagram might be 'evil', they're considered 'our American evil'. This smacks of jingoism and ageism. It's simpler to ban what you don't personally use.
- karaterobot 3y agoGiven users of these sorts of apps have been demonstrated to have an addiction to them in many cases, are users of TikTok more or less reliable judges?
- babypuncher 3y agoIf this is our metric then we should ban Facebook and Instagram as well. But we won't, because they're American, and that is the only important distinction to those calling for a ban on TikTok.
- karaterobot 3y agoNo, you're comparing apples and oranges. In the poll, the reason they support banning TikTok is due to security concerns about China. The person I responded to was implying that the respondents' opinions are irrelevant because they do not (he assumes) use the platform themselves, and my point is that using the platform does not make your opinion on this issue more or less valid. Nobody is using addiction as a metric for banning anything in this case.
- pseudosavant 3y ago"Security concerns about China..." as more than half of the products you buy are from China. Your phone, router, bluetooth earbuds, chips in your car, the smart assistance that has an always on microphone, your smart TV that observes everything you watch and listens with a mic... But this free app that some people use definitely needs to be banned because "China". Selective jingoism.
- 3y ago
- paxys 3y agoPutting aside the privacy arguments, IMO there should be a simple case for quid pro quo import/export control. China bans American software companies from their market, thus giving an advantage to local alternatives. Those local alternatives on the other hand get unrestricted access to American markets. Why exactly should they be allowed to operate? Trade is always reciprocal, and software should not be an exception.
- CameronNemo 3y agoSo you think we should be copying Chinese policy decisions?
- paxys 3y agoGo read up on how the WTO works. We do this already for literally everything else, as does the rest of the world. The real issue is that when it comes to technology/software the policy makers have their heads in the sand.
- CameronNemo 3y agoYou're telling an international relations major to read about the WTO lol. I've been read. And just because the US is transactional with their other trade decisions doesn't make it good policy.
- flappyeagle 3y ago[flagged]
- cmdli 3y agoTrade should be reciprocal, that's how most trade decisions work. If you add a tariff to foreign goods, it's expected that the other party will add a tariff as well.
- CameronNemo 3y ago
- bdcravens 3y agoI wonder what the survey results would have been like for American adults if asked whether rock and roll should be banned circa 1956.
- scarface_74 3y agoOr NWA and “F%%% the police” and that evil rap music in the 80a and 90a.
- mrguyorama 3y ago[flagged]
- RiOuseR 3y ago[dead]
- perihelions 3y agoIf it were "60% of Americans favor HN ban", it'd be very easy for HN to recognize the morally abhorrent censorship for what it is. Extend to people you dislike, and who are very unlike you, the same dignity and autonomy you would yourself enjoy. (It's also clarifying to contemplate this argument: "we're *not* banning you from accessing HN: we're merely banning HN from making its website accessible by you).
- netsharc 3y agoIf 60% favor the ban because they view HN ass addicting, then maybe it's worth considering one's consumption of HN content. I guess it's mostly because it's owned by China, if it's the addiction they'd also want to ban the Zuckerverse.
- perihelions 3y ago- "favor the ban because" There's endless reasons you might want to stop other people from reading the things they want to read, and none of them matter, because, it is not your business what other people read.
- charliea0 3y agoSeems difficult to ban TikTok alone without violating the First Amendment. If you more generally banned exploitative data practices then you’d interfere with other social media companies as well.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoI think legally, all they can really do is force tiktok to cut all ties with the chinese government if they want to operate in the US.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoIs there any precedent for the US banning foreign press? If not, I think that speaks volumes.
- cheriot 3y agoThere's a lot of precedence for regulating commerce based on who owns the company and what country the owner is in.
- jrockway 3y agoI'm not really in favor of banning anything. As soon as you carve out something that should be banned, then things that shouldn't be banned are twisted by the detractors into being the class of material that should be banned. Today you get rid of Tiktok because it's Chinese Propaganda, and tomorrow you say that The New York Times reporting is propaganda that must also be banned. Then there are no information sources except from whoever is in charge, and that's basically the end of democracy. I think the cat is out of the bag with Tiktok. If we really think the Chinese government is going to influence ordinary Americans, I'd like to hear why they shouldn't be allowed to do that, and I'd like to hear why they won't just start using Instagram Stories or YouTube Shorts. I get the feeling that old people (like me now I guess) are annoyed that people use Tiktok to come up with absurd pranks that hurt a lot of people and that this platform gives them an audience. But I guarantee that if it's banned, we'll just see the "YouTube Kia Stealing Challenge" or whatever. The software issue is worrying. If video-sharing applications can be used as malware vectors, that is an iOS/Android bug that needs to be fixed with high urgency. Whatever Tiktok can do, your Verizon app or local newspaper can also do. Do you trust their IT teams to not let malware slip into production builds? I don't. So the OS needs to compartmentalize every app, and disallow wholesale information sharing (no device ID, no access to contacts, etc.; those features are totally unnecessary). All in all, preventing certain people from having a printing press is against everything our country stands for. Yeah, dumb people can do a lot of harm by publishing dumb things. We balance that risk with with happens when smart people can't publish smart things. Governments have always hated that, but it's always been good for ordinary citizens.
- UberFly 3y agoNot being in favor of banning anything sounds noble on the surface, but it isn't plausible. Society is built from the ground up on things people can and can't do.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd this is problem. Grown people should be able to do anything they want to do as long as it doesn’t affect anyone else.
- lukev 3y agoIs there even any mechanism for this in the US legal system? Companies and products can be regulated but the requirements need to be specific (and I'd welcome rules around personal data collection etc.) Or you can regulate an entire class of product, but then it would apply to all companies/manufacturers. I don't see how you can ban TikTok without either being super specific about which rules it's breaking, or also banning Instagram/Youtube/many others.
- kelnos 3y agoCongress can more or less do what it wants for things like this (under the guise of "interstate commerce"). They can write up a bill that says "TikTok is banned", and if it's passed and signed... that's that. Certainly the Biden administration can't ban it on their own unless they can figure out how to use existing regulatory power in a way that the courts will uphold.
- lukev 3y agoCongress can pass whatever they like, but there's a bunch of reasons a law like that would be unconstitutional and likely quickly struck down. Not only is it a violation of the First Amendment, it is almost a textbook case of a Bill of Attainder. (At least, to to my layman's understanding. IANAL.)
- schrectacular 3y agoFile with the WTO for trade fairness rules? After all, no Facebook allowed in China.
- yorwba 3y agoThe Facebook ban is kosher under WTO trade fairness rules because censorship laws apply to domestic and foreign companies equally, and Facebook decided to no longer follow them. A TikTok ban that doesn't violate trade fairness would have to be based on some criterion other than nationality, e.g. by banning vertical video or something.
- stcroixx 3y agoThey should also ask how many favor total ban on all trade with China. I suspect that sentiment is much more popular than they’d like to admit. TikTok would of course be banned along with everything else.
- Ekaros 3y agoMaybe they should and then ban any product with made in china text. And make holding them illegal. It would be fun to see what would happen.
- rayiner 3y agoWhat’s the beef with Tik Tok? Just because it’s Chinese? It seems less biased than Facebook or Twitter.
- hollerith 3y agoMy beef is that it is more addictive than FB or Twitter. Also, Facebook can be used to get back into contact with people from your past.
- ok123456 3y agoAnd the other half actually use TikTok.
- NickC25 3y agoWe should insist that TikTok display the same content it is legally mandated to in China. The CCP got wise to crappy addictive content, and made sure that ByteDance (TikTok's owner) only displays legitimate educational content (languages, maths, physics, etc). If you're going to get people addicted to short-form content, at least teach them something useful. Also we should insist that quid-pro-quo policies be implemented - if China wants to ban our tech companies and control anything and everything on their shores, we need to treat them the same way they treat us. To those who think that would be unfair - get a grip. China does this shit all the time. China also freely admits they are in an economic competition with the US and wants to overtake the US in terms of economic power. A good analogy to this is steroids in an athletic competition. The US won't use them, but won't stop their competition from using them, but acts surprised when their competition (China) beats them. Either the playing field is level and everyone acts as such (quid-pro-quo in terms of banning tech products), or the playing field is not level (acknowledging that one side is playing by a different set of rules and gets to continue doing so) and one party is objectively playing a different game, one that it will win every time when its competition is stuck claiming moral superiority. China doesn't give a fuck about your morals, and China will stop at nothing to win.
- gizmo686 3y agoWe don't want to outsource our regulations to China. We should implement our own regulations for how media apps must behave, and apply those rules across the board (on both foreign and domestic companies).
- ssabev 3y agoAbsolutely agree here. We should be intolerant of intolerance in democratic societies and reciprocate with the more questionable counter parties from countries with .. shall we say different moral norms.
- AlexandrB 3y agoIt is unfair, but not to China or even TikTok. It's unfair to TikTok's users. Why are we advocating that China-style censorship should be applied to apps we use in the west just because the parent company is in China? And where does this stop? Do we restrict LGBTQ content in TikTok because China does it?
- mbgerring 3y agoThey’re right, and if only American adults could properly understand and contextualize what every other company in algorithm-driven media and behavioral advertising does, in terms of abusing personal data and manipulating attention, we would have the good sense to ban all of it.
- ok123456 3y agoTikTok panic is the new satanic panic. If you did this same poll back in the 80s, you would have seen similar support for banning MTV and heavy metal music. Except, now the government and their organs are actively trying to stoke this panic and it has undertones of Asian hate.
- localplume 3y ago[dead]
- mvnuweucxqokii 3y agoAmericans love kpop and anime. The hate is not for Asians.
- ok123456 3y agoAmericans "loving" kpop and anime is the modern form of orientalism. It won't stop them from a lobbying for a Chinese (Data) Exclusion Act.
- yeetawayhn 3y agoSo would that Chinese Data Exclusion Act cover Taiwan or not?
- mvnuweucxqokii 3y agoCan you please describe a kind of engagement with Asian culture or products that you will not dismiss as orientalism? I fear that everything will fit neatly into Asian hate or orientalism in your taxonomy. Americans love Asian cars. Tons of Hondas, Toyotas, Hyundais, Kias, etc. Also while some weeby anime fans may be orientalist, not all are, and love for Gangnam style was genuine. It was a great song and people loved it for that, not because traded on Asian stereotypes. The American geopolitical strategy in the Pacific rests heavily on a very deep trust of Japan, Korea, and Taiwan, among other partners.
- ok123456 3y ago
- wcarron 3y agoI'm in favor of anything that negatively impacts China. They are our greatest geopolitical enemy. Ban it. Ban Huawei products. Ban Chinese entities from any and all ownership of real estate or natural resources. Impose monetary limits on investments in pure financial instruments from their nationals. Make travel to the US more painful for their citizens. Punitively tax US companies who move their manufacturing to China.
- jmpman 3y agoI support the ban. It’s potentially a mouthpiece for China. I see Chinese propaganda in my feed today. Mostly benign cultural garbage - here learn Chinese from some lady with a beauty filter - here let’s see how great the workers in luxury furniture factory live in our communist paradise, and then see the bosses new mansion. Of course the tool can be gradually weaponized to push a Chinese agenda in their Taiwanese battle. Should be banned today. Alternate platforms will arise to fill the space, which aren’t CCP aligned.
- fasterik 3y agoThe fact that so many Americans are in favor of this is alarming. The government shouldn't be dictating what people can view on the internet, or what software they can install on their devices. This seems like common sense to me. What am I missing?
- smoldesu 3y ago> What am I missing? No one should dictate what people can view on the internet or what software they can install. Unfortunately it is a part of most modern operating systems, and the American government is fine with letting it happen. Our surveillance-agnostic attitude is the problem, government bans are merely a symptom of it going malignant.
- tb_technical 3y agoI also agree that TikTok should be banned. The cringe coming from that app is flipping tiresome.
- hmm37 3y agoDoes anyone know where I can find the poll questions, etc.? The poll is completely meaningless if we don't know what the questions are, and what e.g. "somewhat" supporting a ban means. E.g. does "somewhat" mean, bans on government phones but not on private phones? Because then of course many Americans are going to support that.